Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under Neoliberalism

University of Massachusetts Amherst University of Massachusetts Amherst

ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst

Doctoral Dissertations Dissertations and Theses

November 2019

Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under

Neoliberalism Neoliberalism

Brian Myers

Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2

Part of the Critical and Cultural Studies Commons

Recommended Citation Recommended Citation

Myers, Brian, "Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under Neoliberalism" (2019).

Doctoral Dissertations

. 1801.

https://scholarworks.umass.edu/dissertations_2/1801

This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at

ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized

administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact

scholarworks@library.umass.edu.

Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under Neoliberalism

A Dissertation Presented

BRIAN H. MYERS

Submitted to the Graduate School of the

University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment

of the requirements for the degree of !

"#$%#&!#'!()*+#,#-).!

/0-%0120&!3456!

"0-7&%108%!#'!9#11:8*$7%*#8!!

Gaming For Life: Gaming Practices, Self-Care, and Thriving Under Neoliberalism!

;!"*,,0&%7%*#8!(&0,08%0<!

=.!

=>?;@!AB!CDE>/!

;--&#F0<!7,!%#!,%.+0!78<!$#8%08%!2.G!

HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

E1*+.!I0,%J!9)7*&!

HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

K*,7!A08<0&,#8J!C0120&!

HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

L&07;8<&07!>:,,M#&1J!C0120&!

! ! ! ! !!

HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!/:%!N)7++.J!"0-7&%108%!9)7*&!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !"0-7&%108%!#'!9#11:8*$7%*#8! !

;9O@PIKE"QECE@L/!

! ?'!%)*,!-&#R0$%!)7,!%7:S)%!10!#80!%)*8SJ!*%!*,!%)7%!%)0!$:+%:&7+!*17S0!M0!)7F0!#'!

%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!M&*%0&J!,*%%*8S!7+#80!7%!7!<0,TJ!,-*++*8S!#:%!M#&<,!'&#1!)*,!S08*:,!*,!7!

'*$%*#8B!!/#!1:$)!#'!%)0!M&*%*8S!-&#$0,,!*,!#2,$:&0<!*8!%)0!'*87+!M&*%%08!7$$#:8%!#'!

&0,07&$)J!0,-0$*7++.!%)0!,)00&!8:120&!#'!-0#-+0!800<0<!%#!2&*8S!78.!-&#R0$%!#'!%)*,!

+08S%)!%#!$#1-+0%*#8B!!/#!178.!-0#-+0!,:--#&%0<!%)*,!-&#R0$%B!!I*%)#:%!%)01J!?!

M#:+<!80F0&!)7F0!$#1-+0%0<!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!L)0.!M0&0!72,#+:%0+.!F*%7+!%#!%)*,!

-&#R0$%!78<!2&*8S*8S!%)*,!%#!1.!7:<*08$0U,!7%%08%*#8!*8!78!7$T8#M+0<S0108%!-7S0!

%)7%J!?!71!M*++*8S!%#!M7S0&J!%)0!F7,%!17R#&*%.!#'!-0#-+0!M*++!<0$+*80!%#!&07<!'00+,!+*T0!7!

M#0':++.!*87<0V:7%0!&0$*-&#$7%*#8B!!@#80%)0+0,,J!M0!#-0&7%0!M*%)*8!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!

M0!7&0!S*F08!7%!%*10,!78<!?!$788#%!%)*8T!#'!7!20%%0&!M7.!%#!0W-&0,,!1.!S&7%*%:<0!#&!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0*&!$#8%&*2:%*#8,!#:%,*<0!#'!78!X;$T8#M+0<S0108%,Y!,0$%*#8B!!

;-#+#S*0,!'#&!1.!+7$T!#'!*17S*87%*#8B!!?!T8#M!.#:!M*++!8#%!)#+<!*%!7S7*8,%!10B!

! Z*&,%J!%#!"&B!E1*+.!I0,%J!%)0!20,%!7<F*,#&!?!$#:+<!)7F0!)7<B!!L)0!&#7<!%#!%)*,!

$#1-+0%0<!<*,,0&%7%*#8!M7,!8#%!7!,1##%)!#80![7,!.#:!M0++!T8#M\B!!D0%!%)&#:S)#:%!

7++!#'!1.!,:&S0&*0,!78<!&0$#F0&*0,!78<!10%)#<#+#S.!$)78S0,!78<!M&*%*8S!+*1*%7%*#8,J!

.#:!%&07%0<!10!M*%)!-7%*08$0J!$#1-7,,*#8J!78<!S&7$0B!!?!M*++!20!'#&0F0&!S&7%0':+!'#&!

%)0!:8V:7+*'*0<!,:--#&%!.#:!S7F0!10!%)&#:S)#:%!%)*,!08%*&0!-&#$0,,B!!?!#8$0!%#+<!.#:!

%)7%!*'!.#:!)7<!0F08!0W-&0,,0<!%)0!,+*S)%0,%!)*8%!%)7%!?!M#:+<!8#%!'*8*,)!1.!<0S&00!

%)7%!?!M#:+<!)7F0!-&#272+.!V:*%B!!D#:!80F0&!<*<B!!;8<!*%!*,!%)78T,!%#!%)7%J!20.#8<!

0F08!.#:&!%)#:S)%':+!78<!*8,*S)%':+!'00<27$T!78<!17,%0&':+!72*+*%.!%#!,%00&!7!-&#$0,,!

7,!$#1-+*$7%0<!7,!7!<*,,0&%7%*#8J!%)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!M7,!'*8*,)0<B!!L)78T!.#:B!

F*!

! L#!1.!#%)0&!$#11*%%00!10120&,J!"&B!K*,7!A08<0&,#8!78<!"&B!L&07;8<&07!

>:,,M#&1B!!I)08!E1*+.!78<!?!M0&0!%)*8T*8S!72#:%!M)#!M#:+<!20!20,%!,:*%0<!%#!

,0&F0!#8!%)*,!$#11*%%00!78<!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)*,!-&#R0$%!*8!,*S8*'*$78%!M7.,J!E1*+.!

<0,$&*20<!.#:!2#%)!7,!X%)0!<&071!%071BY!!?!$#:+<!8#%!7S&00!1#&0B!!L)78T!.#:!2#%)!

'#&!.#:&!-7%*08$0!78<!*8,*S)%,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)*,!-&#R0$%J!M)*$)!17<0!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!

'7&!1#&0!*8%0&0,%*8S!%)78!?!*8*%*7++.!*17S*80<B!!L)78T!.#:!K*,7!'#&!*8%&#<:$*8S!10!%#!

%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!%)&*F*8S!78<!'#&!$)7++08S*8S!10!%#!%)*8T!20.#8<!,*1-+0!#--#,*%*#8,!%#!

%)0!1#&0!$#1-+*$7%0<!78<!10,,.!&07+*%.!#'!+*'0B!!L)78T!.#:!L&07;8<&07!'#&!20*8S!%)0!

$#11*%%00!10120&!M)#!$#:+<!,*1:+%780#:,+.!S00T!#:%!72#:%!F*<0#!S710,!M*%)!10!

*8!7!<0'08,0!78<!-:,)!10!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!1#,%!F:+80&72+0!78<!17&S*87+*]0<!-0#-+0,!

*8!1.!787+.,*,B!!?!M*,)!?!$#:+<!)7F0!%7T08!7!$+7,,!M*%)!.#:B!

! ;8<!8#M!%#!%)0!#%)0&!-0#-+0!#:%,*<0!#'!1.!$#11*%%00B!!/#10!$#8%&*2:%*#8,!

M0&0!,001*8S+.!,17++![78!*8%0&F*0M!)0&0J!7!&0'0&&7+!%)0&0\!2:%!M*%)#:%!%)01!%)*,!

-&#R0$%!M#:+<!)7F0!$&:12+0<B!!L#!"&B!@7<0])<7!/#%*&#F7J!M)#!M7,!-&#272+.!1#&0!

08%):,*7,%*$!72#:%!%)*,!-&#R0$%!%)78!0F08!?!M7,B!!L)78T!.#:!'#&!#''0&*8S!%#!<*,%&*2:%0!

1.!,:&F0.!%#!.#:&!,%:<08%,!,#!%)7%!?!$#:+<!&07$)!1.!-7&%*$*-7%*#8!S#7+,B!!L)78T!.#:!

'#&!,.1-7%)*]*8S!M*%)!1.!S&*-0,!78<!$0+02&7%*8S!1.!,:$$0,,0,B!!L)78T!.#:!'#&!

7$T8#M+0<S*8S!1.!-7*8!78<!%0++*8S!10!%)7%!*%!M7,!#T7.!M)08!?!$#:+<!8#%!M#&TB!!?!71!

)#8#&0<!%#!T8#M!.#:B!!L#!@:78$0!=&.78%J!#80!#'!1.!'*&,%!-7&%*$*-78%,J!2:%!1#&0!

*1-#&%78%+.!7!'&*08<B!!?%!M7,!,*%%*8S!7%!.#:&!T*%$)08!%72+0J!%7+T*8S!M*%)!.#:!72#:%!

.#:&!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,J!%)7%!%&78,'#&10<!%)*,!-&#R0$%!'&#1!R:,%!,#10!

*<07!?!)7<!*8%#!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!?!$#:+<!7$%:7++.!<#B!!D#:!17<0!%)*,!-&#R0$%!&07+!78<!

.#:!17<0!10!+7:S)J!2#%)!#'!M)*$)!?!71!F0&.!%)78T':+!'#&B!!L#!@*$#+0!O*,]T7!'#&!)0&!

F**!

S080&#,*%.!78<!-0&,-0$%*F0J!78<!'#&!S0%%*8S!10!#:%!#'!%)0!)#:,0!0F0&.!Z&*<7.!'#&!7!

S##<!<*880&B!!L#!"&B!97&+7!L)#17,J!'#&!17T*8S!%)0!0''#&%!%#!T00-!*8!%#:$)!M*%)!10!

M)08!?!&0%&07%0<!*8%#!1.,0+'B!!L#!1.!-7&08%,J!'#&!%)0*&!$#8%*8:0<!08%):,*7,1!78<!

,:--#&%J!0F08!M)08!%)0.!<*<8U%!T8#M!M)7%!%)0!)0++!?!M7,!,%:<.*8SB!!L#!Q087!9#++*8J!

M)#!)7,!$#8%*8:0<!%#!,:--#&%!:,!0F08!7'%0&!<07%)B!!?!M*,)!.#:!$#:+<!)7F0!,008!%)*,B!

! ;8<J!,7F*8S!%)0!20,%!'#&!+7,%J!%#!1.!-7&%80&J!9)&*,%#-)0&!9#++*8J!#&!7,!?!$7++!)*1!

XL#-)BY!!(7&%80&!*,!%##!,17++!7!M#&<!%#!<0,$&*20!M)7%!.#:!7&0!%#!10B!!?!<#8U%!T8#M!*'!

78.!,*8S+0!M#&<!$#:+<!08$#1-7,,!M)7%!.#:!1078!%#!10B!!D#:!7&0!%)0!#8+.!#%)0&!

-0&,#8!M)#!,7M!%)*,!08%*&0!-&#R0$%!%)&#:S)!'&#1!20S*88*8S!%#!08<B!!D#:!+*,%080<!

M)08!?!)7<!$#1-+*$7%0<!*<07,!%#!M#&T!#:%J!.#:!%7:S)%!10!)#M!%#!1787S0!7!-&#R0$%!

#'!%)*,!,*]0J!78<!.#:!,:--#&%0<!10!*8!0F0&.!,*8S+0!M7.!7!):178!20*8S!$78!,:--#&%!

78#%)0&!):178!20*8SB!!D#:!7&0!%)0!'##%!#'!1.!$#1-7,,B!!L)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!*,!7,!1:$)!

.#:&,!7,!1*80B!!!!!

F***!

;=/L>;9L!

GAMING FOR LIFE: GAMING PRACTICES, SELF-CARE, AND THRIVING

UNDER NEOLIBERALISM

/E(LEC=E>!3456!

=>?;@!AB!CDE>/J!=B;BJ!LAE!ZKP>?";!/L;LE!^@?_E>/?LD!

CB;BJ!LAE!ZKP>?";!/L;LE!^@?_E>/?LD!

()B"BJ!^@?_E>/?LD!PZ!C;//;9A^/ELL/`;CAE>/L!

"*&0$%0<!2.G!(&#'0,,#&!E1*+.!I0,%!

L)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!'&710,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!78!7&07!#'!

*8V:*&.!%)7%!)7,!&0$0*F0<!+*%%+0!7%%08%*#8!M*%)*8!%)0!'*0+<,!#'!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!78<!

$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,B!!?%!7&S:0,!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!2.!7:<*08$0,!7,!7!%##+!'#&!

%)&*F*8SJ!-&#F*<0<!M0!<0'*80!%)&*F*8S!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!'&710M#&T!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!

'7*+:&0!0,%72+*,)0<!2.!7!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.B!!^,*8S!,:&F0.!<7%7!'&#1!a4!

F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0!10120&,J!%0W%:7+!787+.,*,J!78<!0%)8#S&7-)*$!78<!7:%#`

0%)8#S&7-)*$!10%)#<#+#S*0,J!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!'*&,%!<0,$&*20,!)#M!F*<0#!S710!

7:<*08$0!10120&,!<0'*80!%)&*F*8S!2.!<*,%*8S:*,)*8S!*%!'&#1!7!&0+7%0<!%0&1J!,0+'`$7&0B!!

?%!%)08!1#F0,!%#!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!F*0M!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!

%)&*F*8SJ!,0+'`$7&0J!78<!S71*8SJ!7&S:*8S!%)7%!%)0*&!-0&,-0$%*F0,!7&0!*8'#&10<!2.!7!

80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!%)7%!$:+%*F7%0,!7!<*,-#,*%*#8!,%&:$%:&0<!2.!,0+'`

,:&F0*++78$0J!,0+'`S#F0&8108%J!78<!-&#<:$%*F*%.B!!Z&#1!%)0&0J!*%!1#F0,!%#!7!

<*,$:,,*#8!#'!7!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!0W71-+0!#'!7!F*<0#!S710!:,0<!'#&!%)0!-:&-#,0,!#'!

,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%#!0W71*80!%)0!7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!

%#!%)&*F*8S!7!F*<0#!S710!$78!-&#F*<0B!

*W!

L;=KE!PZ!9P@LE@L/!

;9O@PIKE"QECE@L/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBF!

;=/L>;9LbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBbbBF***!

K?/L!PZ!L;=KE/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBBBBW!

K?/L!PZ!Z?Q^>E/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbW*!

9A;(LE>!

5B ?@L>P"^9L?P@bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBB5!

3B 9P@9E(L^;K!Z>;CEIP>OG!;^"?E@9E!/L^"?E/J!(>;9L?9E!LAEP>DJ!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!;@"!A;=?L^/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbB5c!

dB CELAP"PKPQD!?G!;99P^@L?@Q!ZP>!9K;//!;@"!/Ee^;K?LD!?@!!

/^>_ED/!;@"!;99P^@L?@Q!ZP>!EC=P"?CE@L!?@!";L;!

9PKKE9L?P@bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBBbbca!

fB (K;D?@Q!LP!/^>_?_EJ!=^L!@PL!LP!LA>?_EG!Q;C?@Q!(>;9L?9E/!!

^@"E>!@EPK?=E>;K?/CbbbbbbbbbbBBbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBB54f!

cB CELAP"PKPQD!??G!P>J!API!9;@!IE!>E;"!;!LEeL!K?OE!Z?@;K!!

Z;@L;/D!e?_gBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB5fd!!

hB _?"EP!Q;CE/J!/EKZ`9;>EJ!;@"!LAE!K;=P>`KE?/^>E!9D9KEbbbbbBBb5hi!!

aB API!IE!9;@!^/E!_?"EP!Q;CE/!LP!LA>?_EbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBB345!

iB 9P@9K^/?P@J!P>!IAE>E!"P!IE!QP! Z>PC!AE>EBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB3c4!

;((E@"?9E/!

;B /^>_ED!j^E/L?P@/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBB3hh!

=B (;>L?9?(;@L!"E/9>?(L?P@/bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBBBB3a4!

=?=K?PQ>;(ADbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbBBd44!

K?/L!PZ!L;=KE/!

L72+0!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!(7S0!

5B!!(7&%*$*-78%!<01#S&7-)*$,!2.!S08<0&J!&7$0J!78<!,0W:7+*%.bbbbbbbbbbbbBBBBhc!

W*!

K?/L!PZ!Z?Q^>E/!

Z*S:&0!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!(7S0!

5B!!;!,$&008,)#%!'&#1!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*++:,%&7%*8S!%)0!<*,-+7.!:,0<!!

!!!!!M)08!S7%)0&*8S!17%0&*7+,BbbbbbbbbbbbbBBbbbbbBbbbbbbbbBBbbBBB5h6!

3B!!;!,$&008,)#%!'&#1!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*++:,%&7%*8S!%)0!F*,:7+!,-0$%7$+0!#8!!

!!!!!#8!<*,-+7.!M)08!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!7!<:8S0#8![M*%)!%)0!8710,!#'!#%)0&!

!!!!!-+7.0&,!#2,$:&0<\bbbbbBBBbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb5i3!

dB!!/$&008,)#%!'&#1!7!<*7+#S:0!,0V:08$0!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!bbbbbbbBBbbbB3fd!

9A;(LE>!5!

?@L>P"^9L?P@!

L)0&0!*,!7!,0$%*#8!*8!-%.#/&0.1/'2/3&[3455\J!7!2##T!2.!%)0!01*808%!<*S*%7+!

10<*7!&0,07&$)0&!/)0&&.!L:&T+0J!%)7%!?!M78%!%#!'#$:,!#8!7%!%)0!,%7&%!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!

?!<#!%)*,!'#&!7!1.&*7<!#'!&07,#8,J!%)0!1#,%!#2F*#:,!20*8S!%)7%!*%!0W01-+*'*0,!%)0!XS7-!

*8!%)0!+*%0&7%:&0Y!%)7%!1.!&0,07&$)!7%%01-%,!%#!'*++B!!A#M0F0&J!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!

*,!8#%!%)0!1#,%!$#1-0++*8S!&07,#8!%#!20S*8!M*%)!%)*,!-7,,7S0B!!@#J!?!71!<&7M8!%#!%)*,!

-7,,7S0!'#&!M)7%!*%!-&#F#T0,!*8!10B!!?!M78%!%#!20S*8!M*%)!%)*,!-7,,7S0!20$7:,0!*%!

)0+-,!10!:8<0&,%78<!1.,0+'J!1.!#M8!-0&,#87+!78<!-#+*%*$7+!$#11*%108%,!78<!

7%%7$)108%,J!1.!#M8!-0&,-0$%*F0!M*%)*8!%)0!<.871*$!'*0+<,!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,J!

F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,J!78<!10<*7!,%:<*0,J!78<!1.!-:&-#,0!'#&!-:%%*8S!%#S0%)0&!%)&00!

%0&1,!%)7%!#80!<#0,!8#%!'*8<!F0&.!#'%08!*8!%)0!+*%0&7%:&0!#'!%)0,0!'*0+<,G!XF*<0#!

S71*8SJY!X,0+'`$7&0JY!78<!X%)&*F*8SBY!!Z#&!%)7%!*,!%)0!-:&-#,0!#'!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!k!%#!

20S*8!17--*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S71*8SJ!,0+'`$7&0J!78<!%)&*F*8S!78<!

%)0!$#8%0W%,!#'!%)0*&!7&%*$:+7%*#8!*8!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!10<*7!7:<*08$0,B!!

?8!-%.#/&0.1/'2/3&[3455\4&L:&T+0!'#$:,0,!#8!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!

%0$)8#+#S.!78<!*8%*17$.!*8!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%B!!PF0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!5h!

$)7-%0&,J!L:&T+0!:,0,!F7&*#:,!$7,0!,%:<*0,!%#!17-!)#M!#:&!$:+%:&7+!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!

#'!%0$)8#+#S.!78<!*%,!7''#&<78$0,!)7F0!*8'+:08$0<!#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!*8%*17$.J!

,#$*7+*%.J!78<!$#1-78*#8,)*-B!!;%!7!)*,%#&*$7+!1#108%!M)08!%)0!+*80!20%M008!M)7%!*,!

&#2#%*$!78<!M)7%!*,!):178!*,!#'%08!F0&.!'*80!*8<00<J!L:&T+0!-&#F#$7%*F0+.!7,T,!)#M!

M0!S#%!%#!%)*,!1#108%!78<!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!M0J!7,!7!,#$*0%.J!,)#:+<!20!$#8%08%!M*%)!

*%B!!?8!-7&%*$:+7&J!L:&T+0!*,!M#&&*0<!72#:%!M)7%!,)0!,00,!7,!%)0!,:2,%*%:%*#8!#'!X &07 + Y !

*8%*17$.!20%M008!-0#-+0!M*%)!7!%0$)8#+#S*$7++.`10<*7%0<!*8%*17$.!%)7%!&07$)0,!*%,!

:+%*17%0!0W-&0,,*#8!*8!%)0!['#&!8#M\!*17S*80<!&#178%*$!08%78S+0108%!20%M008!

):178,!78<!&#2#%,B!!Z7$0<!M*%)!%)0!$#1-+0W*%.!78<!:8-&0<*$%72*+*%.!#'!*8%*17%0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!#%)0&!):178,J!L:&T+0!7&S:0,!%)7%!-0#-+0!7&0!*8$&07,*8S+.!%:&8*8S!

%#!%0$)8#+#S.!7,!7!-&0'0&72+0!78<!-0&17808%!7+%0&87%*F0!%#!):178!$#1-78*#8,)*-!

&7%)0&!%)78!7!+7,%`<*%$)!0''#&%!%#!,%7F0!#''!+#80+ *80,,B!!;,!L:&T+0!,:$$*8$%+.!-:%,!*%J!

,#$*72+0!&#2#%,!78<!%0$)8#+#S*$7++.!10<*7%0<!*8%*17$.!)7F0!S#80!'&#1!20*8S!X20%%0&!

%)78!8#%)*8SY!%#!X20%%0&!%)78!,#10%)*8SY![-B!a\B!!I)*+0!-%.#/&0.1/'2/3&*,!-&*17&*+.!

$#8$0&80<!M*%)!%)0!-&#,-0$%!#'!,#$*72+0!&#2#%,!78<!F*&%:7+!-0%,J!L:&T+0!7+,#!<07+,!

M*%)!%)0!*<07!#'!,*1:+7%*#8!1#&0!2&#7<+.!78<!)#M!M0!)7F0!$#8'*S:&0<!#:&,0+F0,!%#!

20!1#&0!,7%*,'*0<!M*%)!,*1:+7%*#8,!#'!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!%)78!%)0!&07+!%)*8SB!L)*,!0W%08<,J!

87%:&7++.J!%#!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!-0#-+0!78<!F*<0#!S710,B!?8!9)7-%0&!55!

[X>0<:$%*#8!78<!=0%&7.7+Y\J!L:&T+0!<0F#%0,!7!+#%!#'!,-7$0!%#!%)0!,%#&.!#'!X;<71JY!7!

fd`.07&`#+<!M)#!-&0'0&,!%)0!X0+0$%&#8*$!S+#MY!#'!S710,!+*T0!56$7/&78<!8"9"%":$'".#&

%#!)*,!X&07+!+*'0JY!M)*$)!L:&T+0!7,,0&%,!*,!'7++*8S!7-7&%![-B!33f\B!!

?!M78%!%#!+*8S0&!7!2*%!)0&0J!'#&!*8!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71J!M)*$)!1#F0,!

7$&#,,!7!F7&*0%.!#'!'00+*8S,!,:$)!7,!01-7%).!78<!$#1-7,,*#8!20'#&0!:+%*17%0+.!

&0,%*8S!#8!-*%.J!?!'*8<!-&#2+01,!M*%)!8#%!#8+.!)#M!-0#-+0,U!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!F*<0#!

S710,!7&0!'&710<!*8!$:&&08%!$:+%:&7+!<027%0,J!2:%!7+,#!)#M!-7&%*$:+7&!,:2R0$%*F*%*0,!

78<!M7.,!#'!20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<!7&0!+0S*%*1*]0<!M)*+0!#%)0&,!7&0!7$$#&<0<!+0,,!

$#1-+0W*%.J!78<!%):,!+0,,!,%7%:,B!!L:&T+0!20S*8,!2.!<0,$&*2*8S!;<71U,!7''0$%*#8!'#&!

S710,!,:$)!7,!56$7/&78<!8"9"%":$'".#B!;,!L:&T+0!M&*%0,J!X;<71!+*T0,!M)#!)0!*,!*8!

%)0,0!S710,!k!7!M7&&*#&!78<!7!M#&+<!&:+0&!k!1#&0!%)78!M)#!)0!*,!#:%,*<0!#'!%)01B!

A*,!)78<*$7-,!7&0!*8!%)0!&07+l!*8!%)0!S710,!)0!*,!7!,%7&Y![-B!356\B!!EF08!M*%)*8!%)*,!

'*&,%!-7&7S&7-)J!2*87&.!<*,%*8$%*#8,!78<!%)0*&!*1-+*$*%!)*0&7&$).!7&0!*8F#T0<!k!

20%M008!%)0!&07+!78<!%)0!F*&%:7+J!20%M008!%)#,0!M)#!7&0!)78<*$7--0<![M)#!7&0J!

-&0,:172+.J!8#%!X,%7&,Y\!78<!X,%7&,Y![M)#!7&0J!-&0,:172+.J!8#%!)78<*$7--0<\J!

20%M008!,0+'`0,%001!78<!<0-&0,,*#8B!!C#&0#F0&J!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!20%M008!%)0,0!

-7*&,!7&0!7+&07<.!0,%72+*,)0<B!!L)0!&07+!*,!-&0'0&&0<!%#!%)0!F*&%:7+B!!=0*8S!7!,%7&!*,!

20%%0&!%)78!20*8S!)78<*$7--0<B!/0+'`0,%001!%&:1-,!<0-&0,,*#8B!!L:&T+0!<0F0+#-,!

%)*,!-*$%:&0!':&%)0&!2.!<0,$&*2*8S!)#M!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<!*8!%)0!&07+!M#&+<!`!7!'7*+:&0!

%)7%!*,!-7&%+.!7%%&*2:%0<!%#!)*,!7%%7$)108%!%#!F*<0#!S710,B!!;<71U,!X&07+!R#2,Y![)0!

-&#F*<0,!%0$)8*$7+!,:--#&%!%#!78!*8,:&78$0!$#1-78.!#8!%)0!M00T<7.,!78<!

01#%*#87+!78<!-).,*$7+!,:--#&%!%#!78!0+<0&+.!178!#8!%)0!M00T08<,\!7&0!X,+*--*8S!

7M7.Y!20$7:,0!#'!)*,!F*<0#!S710!)72*%,J!M)*$)!$78!#$$:-.!'*'%008`)#:&!,%&0%$)0,!7%!7!

%*10B!!A*,!#''+*80!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!-0#-+0!)7F0!,:''0&0<B!!I)0&07,!*8!%)0!-7,%J!

;<71!:,0<!%#!-+7.!56$7/&M*%)!S&#:-,!#'!-0#-+0J!8#M!)0!*,!$#8%08%!%#!-+7.!M*%)!;.'(J!

#&!;?`!$#8%&#++0<!-+7.0&!,*1:+7$&:1,B!!EF08!)*,!.#%"#/&&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!-0#-+0!

)7F0!,:''0&0<B!!;<71!:,0<!%#!-+7.!78!#8+*80!F0&,*#8!#'!<=3$;;%/&M*%)!7!M#178!

8710<!E&*8J!2:%!%)7%!$#8%7$%!M7,!+#,%!#8$0!E&*8!1#F0<!#8!%#!78#%)0&!S710![-B!356\B!!

I)7%!L:&T+0!<0,$&*20,!*,!%)0!,+#M!7%%&*%*#8!#'!#80!178U,!+*'0!2.!)*,!7%%7$)108%!%#!7!

<*S*%7+!10<*:1![F*<0#!S710,\!%)7%!)7,!-&#1*,0<!*%,!:,0&,!1:$)!2:%!)7,!'7*+0<!%#!

,7%*,'.!%)#,0!-&#1*,0,B!L:&T+0!,-08<,!1:$)!%*10!<0,$&*2*8S!%)0!7--07+!#'!F*<0#!

S710,!'#&!;<71B!/)0!M&*%0,G!!

;<71!,7.,!%)7%!)0!,)#M,!1#&0!,T*++!7%!97-%:&0!%)0!Z+7S!%)78!)0!<#0,!7%!)*,!

%0$)8*$7+!R#2J!M)*$)!)0!$#8,*<0&,!&#%0!78<!20807%)!)*1B!=0.#8<!17,%0&.J!

S710,!#''0&!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!-0&'#&1!&#+0,!)0!'*8<,!088#2+*8SB!;<71!

M78%,!%#!20!7!S080&#:,!-0&,#8J!2:%!-#M0&!*,!7!-&0&0V:*,*%0!'#&!2080F#+08$0B!

?8!+*'0!;<71!'00+,!)0!)7,!8#80B!?8!S710,!)0!)7,!7!S&07%!<07+![-B!335\B!!

;%!78#%)0&!-#*8%J!L:&T+0!$#1108%,!#8!%)0!7--07+!#'!2#%,!7,!$#1-78*#8,!%#!;<71G!

XA0!0W-+7*8,!%)7%!%)0!2#%,!7&0!$#1-0%08%!$#8F0&,7%*#87+*,%,!20$7:,0!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!

#8!56$7/&%08<!%#!'#++#M!-&0<*$%72+0!-7%%0&8,Y![-B!335\B!!;8<!7S7*8J!7%!,0F0&7+!-#*8%,J!

L:&T+0!<*,$:,,0,!%)0!7--07+!#'!17,%0&.!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!#''0&G!X;<71!&01*8*,$0,!

72#:%!1#108%,!#'!17,%0&.!#8!56$7/l!'#&!)*1J!17,%0&.!#F0&!%)0!S710!M#&+<!*,!7!

,#:&$0!#'!R#.Y![-B!335\B!!?8!,)#&%J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!L:&T+0!F*<0#!S710,!#''0&!17,%0&.J!

$#1-78*#8,)*-J!-#M0&J!78<!'00+*8S,!#'!2080F#+08$0!%#!-0#-+0!M)#!&#:%*80+.!'00+!

%)7%!%)0.!)7F0!8#80!#'!%)#,0!%)*8S,!#''`+*80B!!

Z#&!L:&T+0J!%)#:S)J!%)0!-&#2+01!M*%)!%)0,0!F*&%:7+!-&#1*,0,!*,!%)7%!%)0.!<#!8#%!

%&78,+7%0!*8%#!,*1*+7&!7%%*%:<0,!78<!7''0$%,!*8!%)0!X&07+Y!M#&+<B!!;,!L:&T+0!8#%0,J!

F*&%:7+!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!#8+.!%)0&7-0:%*$7++.!2080'*$*7+!*'!%)0.!':8$%*#8!%#!':&%)0&!

X&07+Y!%)0&7-0:%*$!&0+7%*#8,)*-,![-B!33d\B!!Z#&!;<71J!)#M0F0&J!X%)0&0!*,!8#!0F*<08$0!

%)7%!#8+*80!7$$#1-+*,)108%!*,!17T*8S!)*1!'00+!20%%0&!72#:%!)*1,0+'!*8!%)0!&07+Y![-B!

33d\B!!L)*,!*,!0F*<08$0<!2.!%)0!7--7&08%!,+*--*8S!7M7.!#'!7++!%)7%!%0%)0&,!;<71!%#!

%)0!X&07+Y!M#&+<G!)*,!R#2,J!)*,!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!0F08!%)0!-&#1*,0!#'!7!&0-&#<:$%*F0!

':%:&0!M*%)!E&*8J!%)0!'71*+*7&!XS*&+!M)#!S#%!7M7.BY!!

@#M!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!$)7++08S0!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71!#&!%)0!'7*+:&0,!

%)7%!,)0!7&S:0,!7&0!7%%7$)0<!%#!)*,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!A#M!$#:+<!?g!?!)7F0!80F0&!10%!

X;<71JY!8#&!<#!?!)7F0!7$$0,,!%#!78.!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)!17%0&*7+!$#++0$%0<!<:&*8S!

L:&T+0U,!*8%0&F*0M,!M*%)!;<71B!!P8!7!1#&0!72,%&7$%!+0F0+J!?!7+,#!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!$+7*1!

%)7%!'7*+:&0J!7%%&*%*#8J!78<!80S7%*F0!7''0$%,!$78!#/9/3&20!7%%7$)0<!%#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!

/0+'`0,%001!$78!20!20%%0&!%)78!<0-&0,,*#8J!20*8S!)78<*$7--0<!$78!20!M#&,0!%)78!

20*8S!7!,%7&J!78<!%)0!&07+!$78!20!-&0'0&&0<!72#F0!%)0!F*&%:7+B!!?!M78%!%#!*8,*,%J!

)#M0F0&J!%)7%!%)0.!>.&#.'&2$9/&'.&;/B!!?!M78%!%#!*8,*,%!%)7%!;<71U,!,%#&.!*,!8#%!%)0!

#8+.!,%#&.!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S71*8S!78<!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!$78!20!

%#+<B!!

I)*+0!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71!78<!)*,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0!*,!&0+7%*F0+.!

208*S8!M)08!0W71*80<!*8!*,#+7%*#8J!7!1#&0!-&#2+017%*$!-*$%:&0!010&S0,!#8$0!M0!

-+7$0!%)7%!-*$%:&0!*8!%)0!$#8%0W%!#'!17*8,%&071!$:+%:&0!78<!*%,!<*,$#:&,0,!#'!F*<0#!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!I)08!0F7+:7%*8S!10<*7!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!#'!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,J!

M0!'*8<!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!'0M!7+%0&87%*F0,!*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&0!%#!%)0!,%#&.!%)7%!

L:&T+0!*,!%0++*8SB!!L)0!,%#&.!%#+<!2.!L:&T+0!*,!<00-+.!'71*+*7&!%#!2#%)!S710&,!78<!

10<*7!&0,07&$)0&,B!!?%!*,!%)0!,%#&.!#'!)#M!78!7%%7$)108%!%#!%)0!10<*7!20$#10,!

-7%)#+#S*$7+!#8$0!*%!$&#,,0,!7!$0&%7*8!+*80J!&0,:+%*8S!*8!%)0!$#++7-,0!#'!2#%)!%)0!,0+'!

78<J!*8!*%,!1#&0!0W%&010!F0&,*#8,J!%)0!2#<.!-#+*%*$!7,!7!M)#+0B!!

L)*,!-7%)#+#S*]7%*#8!#'!)07F.!10<*7!:,0&,!*,!8#%!80MB!!C0<*7!)*,%#&*78!>*$)7&<!

=:%,$)![344i\J!*8!)*,!,%:<.!#'!%)0!010&S08$0!#'!%)0!17,,!10<*7!7:<*08$0J!)7,!

7&S:0<!%)7%!178.!#'!%)0!$:+%:&7+!78W*0%*0,!,:&&#:8<*8S!78.!10<*7!7&0!012#<*0<!2.!

%)0!'*S:&0!#'!%)0!10<*7!7<<*$%B!!;,!=:%,$)!0W-+7*8,J!%)0!10<*7!7<<*$%!*,!7!-7%)#+#S*$7+!

17,,!10<*7!7:<*08$0!10120&J!X78!*8<*F*<:7+J!:,:7++.!17+0J!*,#+7%*8S!)*1,0+'!'&#1!

&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!'71*+.J!'&*08<,J!78<!$#11:8*%.J!8#%!':+'*++*8S!)*,!&0,-#8,*2*+*%*0,!

%#!%)0!'71*+.J!%)0!$#11:8*%.J!%)0!-#+*%.J!78<!'7*+*8S!%#!$:+%*F7%0!)*1,0+'Y![-B!536\B!!

I0!$78!,00!%)0!$#8%#:&,!#'!%)*,!'*S:&0!*8!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71B!!;,!L:&T+0!

&0-07%,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!-7,,7S0J!;<71U,!#''+*80!+*'0!*,!X'7++*8S!7-7&%Y![-B!33f\!78<!

X,+*--*8S!7M7.Y![-B356\B!!;8<!M)7%!$#8,%*%:%0,!%)*,!#''+*80!+*'0g!!>0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)!

'&*08<,!78<!'71*+.![-7&%*$:+7&+.!M#108\!78<!)*,!&0,-#8,*2*+*%*0,!%#!%)0!+7&S0&!

$#11:8*%.!012#<*0<!2.!)*,!+72#&B!!L)0,0!7&0!%)0!,%:''!#'!%)0!&07+!M#&+<J!L:&T+0!

$#8%08<,B!_*<0#!S710,J!M)08!72:,0<J!$7:,0!%)0,0!-&#<:$%*F0![78<!&0-&#<:$%*F0\!

7%%7$)108%,!%#!M*%)0&B!!

?%!*,!%)*,!-7%)#+#S*]7%*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710&,!78<!)07F.!10<*7!:,0&,J!%)0!7++`%##!

'71*+*7&!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!10<*7!:,7S0!M*%)!*++80,,J!*,#+7%*#8J!78<!'7*+:&0J!%)7%!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!M*++!*8%0&&:-%B!!/:,-08<*8S!%)*,!'71*+*7&!%&7R0$%#&.!%#M7&<,!

-7%)#+#S*]7%*#8!$78!7++#M!:,!%#!,00!7+%0&87%*F0,J!-#,,*2*+*%*0,J!78<!-0&,-0$%*F0,!%)7%!

$#:+<!-&#F*<0!:,!M*%)!7!+7&S0&!F#$72:+7&.!'#&!<*,$:,,*8S!S710&,J!10<*7!:,0&,J!78<!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$:+%:&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!

L#!,00!)#M!%)*,!1*S)%!M#&T!*8!-&7$%*$0J!M0!800<!#8+.!20S*8!M*%)!L:&T+0U,!

<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71B!!L)0!'*&,%!,%0-!*,!%#!V:0,%*#8!%)0!%0&1,!2.!M)*$)!L:&T+0!

0F7+:7%0,!;<71U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,B!!;,!8#%0<!-&0F*#:,+.J!%)0!'*&,%!

-7&7S&7-)!,*S87+,!%#!*%,!7:<*08$0J!%)&#:S)!*%,!$7&0':+!*8F#$7%*#8!#'!'71*+*7&!2*87&*0,!

78<!)*0&7&$)*0,J!%)7%!%)*,!*,!S#*8S!%#!20!7!87&&7%*F0!#'!'7*+:&0B!!Z&#1!%)0!20S*88*8SJ!

M0!T8#M!%)7%!;<71!*,!7!'7*+:&0B!!;++!%)7%!*,!+0'%!*,!%#!'*++!*8!%)0!<0%7*+,B!!;8<!'*++!*8!%)0!

<0%7*+,!L:&T+0!<#0,B!I0!+07&8!%)7%!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<!%#!7$$:1:+7%0!M07+%)B!!I0!+07&8!

%)7%!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<!%#!17&&.!78<!&0-&#<:$0B!!I0!+07&8!%)7%!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<!%#!

17*8%7*8!$#880$%*#8,!M*%)!'&*08<,!78<!'71*+.B!!?8!7+1#,%!0F0&.!$#8$0*F72+0!M7.J!

L:&T+0!M&*%0,J!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<B!!

=:%!M).!1:,%!%)*,!$#:8%!7,!'7*+:&0g!!I).!*,!&0':,*8S!%#!17&&.!7!'7*+:&0g!!I).!

*,!+0%%*8S!S#!#'!+72#&!7!'7*+:&0g!!

L)0,0!7&0!V:0,%*#8,!%)7%!L:&T+0J!*8!,#!178.!M7.,J!<0$+*80,!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&B!!

L)0!2*SS0,%!'7*+*8S!#'!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71U,!'7*+:&0,J!*8!1.!&07<*8SJ!*,!)0&!

&0':,7+!%#!*8%0&&#S7%0!%)0!27,*,!#'!)0&!0F7+:7%*#8!#'!;<71U,!+*'0!78<!S71*8S!)72*%,B!!

L)7%!*,J!,)0!+07F0,!:8V:0,%*#80<!)0&!7,,:1-%*#8,!72#:%!%)0!-&0,$&*20<!&#+0,!#'!%)0!

+*20&7+!,:2R0$%!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$7B!!;,!A7+20&,%71![3455\!7&S:0,!*8!02/&56//3&

-3'&.?&!$"%63/J!%)0!%0&1,!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0!:,0<!2.!&0,07&$)0&,!+*T0!L:&T+0!#'%08!

7,,:10!7!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0J!$7-*%7+*,%!,#$*0%.B!!A7+20&,%71!0W-+*$*%+.!,%7%0,!%)7%!

X,:$$0,,!*8!7!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0J!$7-*%7+*,%!,#$*0%.!0V:7%0,!%##!07,*+.!%#!,-0$*'*$!'#&1,!

#'!&0-&#<:$%*F0!17%:&*%.!$#12*80<!M*%)!M07+%)!7$$:1:+7%*#8Y![-B!3\B!!;:%)#&*]*8S!

)0S01#8*$!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0!*8!;10&*$78!,#$*0%.J!%)08J!*,!%)0!

7,,:1-%*#8!%)7%!)0%0&#,0W:7+*%.!78<!$7-*%7+*,1!7&0!87%:&7+!78<!8#&17+B!!I0!$78!,00!

%)*,!*8!L:&T+0U,!$#8$0&8!#F0&!%)0!+#,,!#'!;<71U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!E&*8J!M)0&0!?!

<0%0$%!%&7$0,!#'!%)0!'71*+*7&!78W*0%.!%)7%!;<71!XM*++!80F0&!'*8<!7!M#178BY!!I0!$78!

,00!%)*,!*8!L:&T+0U,!M#&&.!%)7%!;<71U,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!*8%0&'0&0!M*%)!2#%)!)*,!&07+!

R#2!78<!)*,!7,-*&7%*#8,!#'!20$#1*8S!7!,*8S0&!78<!,#8SM&*%0&![-B!35i\B!!A0%0&#,0W:7+!

&0-&#<:$%*#8!78<!M07+%)!7$$:1:+7%*#8!7&0!%)0!107,:&0,!#'!,:$$0,,!'#&!L:&T+0!78<!

2.!%)#,0!,%78<7&<,!;<71!)7,!'7*+0<B!!

=:%!A7+20&,%71!&01*8<,!:,!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!#%)0&!M7.,!#'!X20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<Y!

%)78!%)0,0!,%78<7&<,!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0!-&0,$&*20![-B!3\B!!Z7*+:&0J!7,!<0'*80<!2.!7!

)0%0&#8#&17%*F0J!$7-*%7+*,%!,#$*0%.J!$78!*8!'7$%!#''0&!&0M7&<,!%#!*%,!,:2R0$%,!%)7%!

,:$$0,,!$788#%B!!@#%!#8+.!<#0,!'7*+:&0!7++#M!*% ,! ,:2R0$%,!%#!0,$7-0!%)0!X-:8*,)*8S!

8#&1,!%)7%!<*,$*-+*80!20)7F*#&!78<!1787S0!):178!<0F0+#-108%Y![-B!d\J!2:%!*%!$78!

7+,#!01-#M0&!,:2R0$%,!%#!V:0,%*#8!78<!X-#T0!)#+0,Y!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!

-#M0&!78<!7<<&0,,!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<*,%&*2:%*#8!78<!&0$#S8*%*#8!%)7%!#&S78*]0!78<!

17*8%7*8!%)0,0!)*0&7&$)*0,B!!

Z#&!78!0W71-+0!#'!%)0!#--#&%:8*%*0,!7!<*''0&08%!7--&#7$)!%#!'7*+:&0!17.!-&#F*<0!:,J!?!

&0%:&8!%#!L:&T+0B!!;,!?!)7F0!7&S:0<J!L:&T+0!-7%)#+#S*]0,!;<71U,!10<*7!-&7$%*$0,!78<!

-#,*%*#8,!;<71!7,!7!'7*+:&0!20$7:,0!#'!)*,!*872*+*%.![#&!&0':,7+g\!%#!7%%7$)!)*1,0+'!%#!

X-&#<:$%*F0Y!'#&1,!#'!+72#&B!!=:%!#80!#'!%)0!*,,:0,!M*%)!%)*,!-7%)#+#S*]*8S!1#108%!*,!

%)7%!*%!$7,%,!;<71U,!X'7*+:&0,Y!7,!-0&,#87+!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.B!!;,!=7&27&7!E)&08&0*$)!

[3446\!)7,!8#%0<J!$7-*%7+*,1!#'%08!*8,*,%,!%)7%!,:$$0,,!*,!2#&8!#'!)7&<!M#&T!78<!

<0<*$7%*#8!M)*+0!'7*+:&0!*,!8#!#80U,!'7:+%!2: % !.#:&!#M8B!!L:&T+0J!*8!)0&!'#$:,!:-#8!

;<71U,!'7*+:&0,!7%!%)0!0W-08,0!#'!%)0!$#8%0W%!,:&&#:8<*8S!%)0,0!'7*+:&0,J!*1-+*$*%+.!

08<#&,0,!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0B!!D0%J!*'!M0!%7T0!7!,#'%!C7&W*,%!,%78$0!78<!-&#-#,0!%)7%!

1:$)!+72#&!:8<0&!$7-*%7+*,%!,.,%01,!*,!7+*087%*8S!%#!%)0!+72#&0&J!*,!*%!&07++.!,#!

,:&-&*,*8S!%)7%!;<71!$)##,0,!%#!+0%!%)7%!+72#&!X,+*-!7M7.gY!!?,!*%!&07++.!,#!-*%*72+0!

%)7%J!S*F08!%)0!$)#*$0!20%M008!7!M#&+<!M)0&0!;<71!$78!20!X7!M7&&*#&!78<!7!M#&+<!

&:+0&Y!78<!7!M#&+<!M)0&0!)0!*,!,*1-+.!X17T*8S!08<,!100%Y!2.!-&#F*<*8S!%0$)8*$7+!

,:--#&%!%#!78!*8,:&78$0!$#1-78.!78<!$7&0!%#!78!0+<0&+.!178J!%)7%!)0!M#:+<!$)##,0!

%#!20!7!M7&&*#&!78<!7!M#&+<!&:+0&g!!>7%)0&!%)78!:,0!%)0!,%#&.!#'!;<71!7,!7!M7.!%#!

$#1108%!:-#8!78<!$)7++08S0!7!$7-*%7+*,%!,.,%01!%)7%!&#:%*80+.!-&#F*<0,!+*1*%0<!

$)#*$0,!+*T0!%)0,0!%#!*%,!,:2R0$%,J!L:&T+0!*8,%07<!:,0,!%)*,!,%#&.!7,!78!0W71-+0!#'!)#M!

10<*7!7<<*$%*#8!$78!&:*8!7!-0&,#8U,!+*'0B!!

?%!*,!%)*,!S7-J!%)*,!'7*+:&0!%#!$#8,*<0&!7+%0&87%*F0,J!%)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!

,*%:7%0,!*%,0+'!M*%)*8B!!(7&%+.!%)*,!*,!<:0!%#!1.!#M8!-0&,#87+!&0$#S8*%*#8!#'!1.,0+'!*8!

;<71B!!?!+##T!7%!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71!78<!)*,!F*<0#!S710!:,7S0!78<!&07+*]0!

%)7%!;<71!78<!?!7&0!8#%!%)7%!<*''0&08%!*8!#:&!-+7.!)72*%,B!!K*T0!;<71J!?!&#:%*80+.!'*8<!

1.,0+'!$)##,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!#F0&!M#&TB!K##T*8S!%)&#:S)!%)0!-+7.!+#S,!#'!<*''0&08%!

F*<0#!S710!$#8,#+0,!%)7%!?!#M8J!*%!*,!8#%!:8:,:7+!%#!,00!:-M7&<,!#'!0*S)%!)#:&,!7!<7.!

,-08%!#8!#80!F*<0#!S710!#&!,-&07<!#:%!7$&#,,!1:+%*-+0!F*<0#!S710,B!!;8<!?!)7F0!

2008!<#*8S!%)*,!'#&!<0$7<0,J!,*8$0!%)0!<7.,!#'!%)0!i`2*%!@*8%08<#!@E/!,.,%01B!!?!M7,!

78!*8%&#F0&%0<!$)*+<!S&#M*8S!:-!*8!%)0!56i4,!78<!5664,!M)08!)#10!F*<0#!S710!

$#8,#+0,!'*&,%!20$710!7!F*72+0!$#11#<*%.!'#&!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,!'71*+*0,B!!Z7$0<!

M*%)!7!,:&-+:,!#'!+0*,:&0!%*10!*8!M)*$)!?!M7,!#8+.!0W-0$%0<!%#!-+7.J!?!M#:+<!$)##,0!

F*<0#!S710,!#F0&!%)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!78<!V:*%0!'&78T+.!%0&&*'.*8S!#-%*#8!#'!

7,,#$*7%*8S!M*%)!#%)0&!$)*+<&08!1.!7S0B!!EF08!%#!%)*,!<7.J!7,!?!0W-+7*8!1.!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,!%#!$#++07S:0,!#&!80M!7$V:7*8%78$0,J!?!S#!#:%!#'!1.!M7.!%#!,7.!%)7%!S71*8S!

)7,!7+M7.,!2008!7!M7.!'#&!10!%#!0,$7-0!'&#1!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!?!S710<!20$7:,0!?!<*<!

8#%!+*T0!20*8S!7&#:8<!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!L#!%)0*&!$&0<*%!?!)7<!7!1#%)0&!78<!'7%)0&![2#%)!

%07$)0&,\!M)#!M0&0!,08,*%*F0!%#!1.!800<,!78<!+0%!10!20!7+#80!M*%)!1.!S710,B!!=:%!?!

&07+*]0!%)7%!%)7%!,*%:7%*#8!M7,![7 8 <!$#8%*8:0,!%#!20\!&7&0!*8!7!,#$*0%.!%)7%!#'%08!

-&*F*+0S0,!%)0!,#$*7+J!0W%&#F0&%0<!$)*+<B!!C#F*8S!'#&M7&<!*8%#!7<:+%)##<!78<!S&7<!

+*'0J!?!&#:%*80+.!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!M7.!%#!<0,08,*%*]0!1.,0+'!%#!%)0!M#&+<!7&#:8<!

10B!!"*7S8#,0<!M*%)!78!78W*0%.!$#8<*%*#8!*8!1.!1*<!34U,J!?!%:&80<!%#!F*<0#!S710,!%#!

$7+1!<#M8!78<!<*,%&7$%!1.,0+'!'&#1!%)0!<*]].*8SJ!,-*&7+*8S!%)#:S)%,!%)7%!7&0!-7&%!

78<!-7&$0+!#'!1.!78W*#:,!1*8<B!!K7%0&J!*8!1.!07&+.!d4U,J!7!<02*+*%7%*8S!,-*87+!*8R:&.!

54!

+0'%!10!:872+0!%#!<#!1:$)!1#&0!20.#8<!,*%!F0&.J!F0&.!,%*++!*8!7!&0$+*80&!+0,%!?!,:''0&!

*8%08,0!-7*8!<#M8!%)0!+0'%!,*<0!#'!1.!2#<.B!!?8!%)#,0!%*10,J!F*<0#!S710,!M0&0!#80!#'!

%)0!'0M!%)*8S,!?!$#:+<!:,0!%#!<*,%&7$%!'&#1!%)0!-7*8B!!_*<0#!S710,J!*8!178.!M7.,J!

)7F0!2008!78<!$#8%*8:0!%#!20!80$0,,7&.!'#&!1.!,:&F*F7+B!

D0%J!M)*+0!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!7!F*%7+!-7&%!#'!1.!0F0&.<7.!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-).,*$7+!

78<!108%7+!17*8%0878$0J!?!7+,#!&0$#S8*]0!%)7%!%)0,0!,710!-&7$%*$0,!17.!8#%!)0+-!10!

1#F0!20.#8<!,:&F*F7+!%#!S&#M%)!78<!-&#,-0&*%.B!!L)0.!17.J!*8!'7$%J!*1-0<0!S&#M%)!

78<!-&#,-0&*%.B!!;'%0&!7++J!M)*+0!,-08<*8S!i!)#:&,!7!<7.!S&*8<*8S!7M7.!7%!7!F*<0#!

S710!17.!)0+-!$7+1!1.!78W*#:,!1*8<!78<!<*,%&7$%!10!'&#1!1.!$)&#8*$!-7*8J!*%!<#0,!

8#%!)0+-!10!<#!1:$)!20.#8<!%)7%B!!L)*,!$#8%&7<*$%*#8!20%M008!,:&F*F7+!78<!%)&*F*8S!

*,!%)0!$08%&7+!*<07!%)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!S&7--+0,!M*%)!78<!7%%01-%,!%#!17T0!,08,0!

#'B!!?!*8*%*7++.!20S78!$#8<:$%*8S!&0,07&$)!'#&!%)*,!-&#R0$%!M*%)!78!0.0!%#M7&<,!

&0$:-0&7%*8S!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!'&#1!)0S01#8*$!<*,$#:&,0,!%)7%!'&710!%)01!7,J!

7%!20,%J!*8#''08,*F0!#&!7,J!7%!M#&,%J!<0,%&:$%*F0!%#!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+,!78<!,#$*0%.!7,!7!

M)#+0B!!C.!-:&-#,0!M7,!%#!$#8,%&:$%!7!'&710M#&T!'#&!<*S*%7+!10<*7!,$)#+7&,!%#!

*8F0,%*S7%0!7!2&#7<0&!,-0$%&:1!#'!10<*7!-&7$%*$0,!78<!%#!,:SS0,%!%)7%!8#%!7++!#'!

%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!*8*1*$7+!%#!%)0!0178$*-7%#&.!S#7+,!#'!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,J!

%)7%!*8!'7$%!,#10!#'!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!80$0,,7&.!'#&!,#10!-0#-+0U,!,:&F*F7+B!!L)*,!

-:&-#,0!M7,!<&7M8!2#%)!'&#1!1.!#M8!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!<*S*%7+!10<*7J!,-0$*'*$7++.!

F*<0#!S710,J!78<!%)0!#2,0&F7%*#8,!78<!'*8<*8S,!#'!#%)0&!&0,07&$)0&,!%)7%!?!)7F0!

08$#:8%0&0<!#F0&!%)0!.07&,B!!;,!/7178%)7!;++08![345d\!-&#-#,0<!*8!)0&!7<<&0,,!7%!

%)0!345d!j:00&80,,!78<!Q710,!9#8'0&08$0!)0+<!7%!%)0!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!97+*'#&8*7`

=0&T0+0.J!178.!#'!%)0!V:7+*%*0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!S710&,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!,)710<!

55!

'#&!`!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!&0-0%*%*F0J!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!*,#+7%*8SJ!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!78#8.1#:,J!%)7%!

%)0.!7&0!0-)010&7+!`!7&0!-&0$*,0+.!%)0!V:7+*%*0,!%)7%!17T0!%)01!7--07+*8S!%#!V:00&,!

%&.*8S!%#!S0%!2.!*8!7!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0J!$7-*%7+*,%!,.,%01!%)7%!&#:%*80+.!<08*0,!%)01!

%)0!%##+,!'#&!,:&F*F7+B!

?8!S7%)0&*8S!78<!787+.]*8S!<7%7!'&#1!#%)0&!F*<0#!S71*8S!7:<*08$0!10120&,!

72#:%!%)0*&!0W-0&*08$0,!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0*&!%)#:S)%,!72#:%!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!)#M0F0&J!78!712*F7+08$0!010&S0<!

%)7%!M7,!*1-#,,*2+0!%#!<*,$#:8%B!!I)*+0!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!M*++*8S!%#!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-0<!%)01!&0<:$0!78W*0%.!78<!1787S0!%)0*&!

7''0$%*F0!,%7%0,!78<!1##<J!7!,*S8*'*$78%!71#:8%!&0':,0<!%)0!*<07!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!$#8%&*2:%0<!%#!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!%)&*F0B!!C78.!#'!%)01J!*8!'7$%J!0$)#0<!%)0!,710!

R:<S0108%,!78<!&0,0&F7%*#8,!%)7%!L:&T+0!0W-&0,,0<!*8!)0&!787+.,*,!#'!;<71J!

,:SS0,%*8S!%)7%!%)0!*<0#+#S*0,!0120<<0<!*8!L:&T+0U,!7$$#:8%!)7F0!7!$0&%7*8!<0S&00!

#'!-:&$)7,0!*8!1#&0!17*8,%&071!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8,!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!D0%!M)*+0!

L:&T+0!78<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!+7&S0+.!7%%&*2:%0<!%)0*&![78<!#%)0&U,\!20)7F*#&!%#!%)0!

*8<*F*<:7+U,!-,.$)#+#S*$7+!17T0`:-J!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!*8,%07<!<&7M,!#8!7!$&*%*$7+!

$:+%:&7+!-0&,-0$%*F0!%#!*8%0&&#S7%0!%)0!$:+%:&7+!:8<0&-*88*8S,!#'!%)*,!,%78$0!78<!

,:SS0,%!7+%0&87%*F0!&07<*8S,B!!!

Z#&!M)*+0!#%)0&,!17.!+##T!7%!;<71U,!78<!1.!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)!

$#8$0&8!#&!-*%.J!?!<#!8#%B!!?!&010120&!1.!$)*+<)##<!,-08%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!

%)*8TJ!XL)#,0!M0&0!':8!%*10,mY!!?!+##T!7%!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!#'!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!i!

)#:&,![#&!5c!)#:&,J!7,!;<71!<*<\!78<!%)*8TJ!XL)7%!M#:+<!20!7!S##<!<7.mY!!D0,J!%)0&0!

*,!S:*+%!7%%7$)0<!%#!%)#,0!<7.,J!2:%!%)7%!S:*+%!,%01,!+7&S0+.!'&#1!1.!7M7&080,,!%)7%!

53!

#%)0&,!M#:+<!+##T!7%!%)7%!<7.!78<!R:<S0!10!)7&,)+.!'#&!*%J!8#%!'&#1!78!*8%&*8,*$!

$)7&7$%0&*,%*$!#'!F*<0#!S710!#&!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,B!!

?8!,)#&%J!?!+##T!7%!L:&T+0U,!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!;<71!78<!,00!7!+#%!#'!1.,0+'!%)0&0J!7!

,0+'!%)7%!?!$#:+<!)7F0!20$#10!)7<!1.!$#8%0W%!2008!<*''0&08%B!!>7%)0&!%)78!+07<*8S!%#!

1.!7%%&*%*#8J!7,!*%!7&S:72+.!)7,!'#&!;<71J!F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8S!)7,!2008!$&:$*7+!%#!1.!

,:&F*F7+B!!;8<!?!T8#M!%)7%!?!71!8#%!%)0!#8+.!#80!M)#!'00+,!%)*,!M7.B!!L)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!20S78J!%)08J!2.!08%0&%7*8*8S!%)0!*<07!%)7 %!S71*8S!$78J!78<!#'%08!*,J!7!

80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!'#&!-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!S710,B!!L)*,!-#,*%*#8!<#0,!8#%!

&0V:*&0!10!%#!<08.!%)7%!S71*8S!78<!%)&*F*8S!$78!20!#--#,0<!%#!#80!78#%)0&J!7,!*%!

7&S:72+.!*,!*8!%)0!$7,0!#'!L:&T+0U,!;<71B!!=:%!?!<#!M78%!%#!,:,-08<!%)7%!07,.!

[20$7:,0!$#11#8\!$#8$+:,*#8!*8!,0&F*$0!#'!'*8<*8S!78<!$&07%*8S!,-7$0,!'#&!

7+%0&87%*F0!,%#&*0,!78<!7%%7$)108%,B!!/:$)!7!-&#R0$%!7++#M,!10!%#!0W-#,0!78<!

*8%0&&#S7%0!%)0!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!,:2R0$%*F*%.!%)7%!#&S78*]0!10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8!

-&7$%*$0,!78<J!2.!0W%08,*#8J!,#$*7+!+*'0!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$78!,#$*0%.B!!!Z#&!

0W71-+0J!M).!*,!-&#<:$%*F*%.J!<0'*80<!2.!%)0!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!M07+%)J!%)0!-&*F*+0S0<!

107,:&0!#'!,:$$0,,g!!I).!*,!20*8S!M*%)!-0#-+0!,#!1:$)!20%%0&!%)78!20*8S!7+#80g!!

EW71*8*8S!-0#-+0U,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-0#-+0!'&#1!8#8`<#1*878%!,#$*7+!

S&#:-,J!$78!)0+-!:,!<0,$&*20!<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!X20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<Y!78<!%7T0!

,0&*#:,+.!,#10!-0#-+0,U!<0,*&0,!%#!+*F0!*8!M7.,!%)7%!<*''0&!'&#1!%)0!M7.,!-&0,$&*20<!

2.!7!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0J!$7-*%7+*,%J!0W%&#F0&%0<!,#$*0%.B!!/:$)!7!-&#R0$%!7+,#!<00-08,!

#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!%)0!10<*7!$78!20!*8%0S&7%0<!*8%#!%)0!'72&*$!

#'!#:&!0F0&.<7.!+*F0,!78<!%)0!'#&$0!%)7%!*%!0W0&%,!#8!:,B!!>7%)0&!%)78!,00*8S!%)*,!7,!7!

,#+0+.!80S7%*F0!'#&$0J!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!0W-78<,!%)0!&78S0!#'!7''0$%,!%)7%!7&0!%.-*$7++.!

5d!

7%%7$)0<!%#!10<*7!:,0!2.!7$T8#M+0<S*8S!%)7%!%)0!10<*7!$78!-+7.!7!%)0&7-0:%*$!&#+0!

*8!%)0!+*F0,!#'!<*,08'&78$)*,0<!#&!#%)0&M*,0!X,0-7&7%0Y!-0#-+0B!!?8,%07<!#'!%)0!

-7&78#*<!7,,0&%*#8!%)7%!)07F.!10<*7!:,7S0!+07<,!%#!7%%&*%*#8J!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!

7<#-%,!%)0!-#,*%*#8!%)7%!M0!$788#%!S:7&78%00!*8!7<F78$0!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!0''0$%,!%)7%!7!

10<*7!#2R0$%!M*++!)7F0!20'#&0!*%!*,!%7T08!:-!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!7:<*08$0!10120&B!!?8!

#%)0&!M#&<,J!*%!#-08,!,-7$0!'#&!-#,,*2*+*%.!78<!,:&-&*,0J!8#%!#8+.!'#&!10<*7!

7:<*08$0,!2:%!7+,#!'#&!10<*7!&0,07&$)0&,B!

Preview!

! ?!)7F0!,%&:$%:&0<!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!7$$#&<*8S!%#!M)7%!?!,00!7,!%)0!%M#!17*8!

-)7,0,!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!L)0!'*&,%!-)7,0!*8F#+F0<!S7%)0&*8S!,:&F0.!<7%7!#8!

)#M!<*''0&08%!S&#:-,!:8<0&,%##<!%)&*F*8S!78<!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0*&!

%)&*F*8S!78<!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!:,*8S!7!,8#M27++!,71-+*8S!10%)#<!%#!&0$&:*%!7!

<*F0&,0!-##+!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!7$&#,,!,0W:7+!#&*08%7 % *#8!78<!,#$*7+!$+7,,B!!^,*8S!%)*,!

<7%7!7,!7!,%7&%*8S!-#*8%J!?!%)08!:,0<! % 0W%:7+J!0%)8#S&7-)*$!78<!7:%#`0%)8#S&7-)*$!

10%)#<#+#S*0,!*8!%)0!,0$#8<!-)7,0!%#!0W71*80!)#M!%)0!1#,%!-#-:+7&!S08&0!71#8S!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,n%)0!C7,,*F0+.!C:+%*-+7.0&!P8+*80!>#+0`(+7.*8S!Q710!`!$#:+<!

*8'#&1!%)0!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!%)&*F*8S!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!87&&7%0<B!!9)7-%0&,!3`f!<0,$&*20!

%)0!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!,:--#&%*8S!1.!*8F0,%*S7%*#8!78<!1.!,:&F0.!10%)#<#+#S.!

20'#&0!1#F*8S!*8%#!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!1.!,:&F0.!&0,:+%,B!!9)7-%0&,!c`aJ!1078M)*+0J!

<*,$:,,!1.!10%)#<#+#S.!'#&!787+.]*8S!78!#8S#*8SJ!+7&S0`,$7+0J!-7&%*$*-7%#&.!%0W%!+*T0!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7,!M0++!7,!#''0&!78!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!'&710M#&T!%)0!S710!-&#F*<0,!

'#&!,%&:$%:&*8S!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

5f!

L)0!87&&7%*F0!7&$!#'!%)0!<*,,0&%7%*#8J!1078M)*+0J!20S*8,!M*%)!78!7$$#:8%!#'!

)#M!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!#'!M)*$)!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!7!-7&%J!7&0!

,:2,:10<!78<!<0-+#.0<!2.!F7&*#:,!80#+*20&7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!'#&!%)0!-:&-#,0!#'!

&0-&#<:$*8S!%)0!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!!Z&#1!%)0&0J!*%!1#F0,!%#!7!

<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!%)0!F7&*#:,!-&7$%*$0,!-&#<:$0<!2.!%)0,0! '#&$0,!$78!$&07%0!$&7$T,!

*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!80#+*20&7+!$7-*%7+J!M)*$)!*8! %:&8!$78!$&07%0!

#--#&%:8*%*0,!'#&!0,$7-0!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8B!!!

5c!

9A;(LE>!3!

9P@9E(L^;K!Z>;CEIP>OG!;^"?E@9E!/L^"?E/J!(>;9L?9E!LAEP>D!

;@"!A;=?L^/!

L)0&0!7&0!%M#!17R#&!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710,!%)7%!7&0!$&*%*$7+!%#!)#M!?!7--&#7$)0<!

%)*,!-&#R0$%B!!!!PF0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!?!M*++!<*,$:,,!)#M!?!$#8$0-%:7+*]0<!

F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8S!7,!7!$#++0$%*#8!#'!7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!)#M!?!$#8,*<0&0<!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!2&#7<!$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8,!78<!,%&:$%:&0,!#8!%)0!#80!)78<!78<!

%)0!,17++0&`,$7+0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-0#-+0!#8!%)0!#%)0&B!!;!S:*<*8S!-&*8$*-+0!'#&!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!M7,!%#!7++#M!'#&!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!#'!<0,$&*2*8S!78<!787+.]*8S!F*<0#!S710!

-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!7&0!,:&-&*,*8S!78<!-0&)7-,!0F08!:8*V:0B!!A#M0F0&J!S*F08!1.!

$#11*%108%,!%#!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!*8V:*&.J!?!7+,#!<*<!8#%!M78%!%#!87*F0+.!7,,0&%!%)7%!

%)0,0!1#108%,!#'!,:&-&*,0!7&0!80$0,,7&*+.!%&78,'#&17%*F0!#'!2&#7<0&!,.,%01*$!

,%&:$%:&0,J!8#&!<*<!?!M78%!%#!7%#1*]0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!*S8#&0!%)0!+7&S0&!$#8%0W%,!

%)7%!%)0.!7&0!0120<<0<!*8B!!L#!7++#M!,-7$0!'#&!2#%)!#'!%)0,0!,#10%*10,!78%7S#8*,%*$!

*1-:+,0,J!?!7,,012+0<!7!'+0W*2+0!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!%)7%!*8,*,%,!%)7%!-0#-+0U,!

+*F0,!7&0!7+M7.,!+*F0<!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!,%&:$%:&7+!'#&$0,B!!L)0,0!,%&:$%:&7+!

'#&$0,J!*8!%:&8J!7&0!2#%)!&0-&#<:$0<!78<!&017<0!%)&#:S)!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-0#-+0B!

!!!

Media!as!a!Resource!For!Everyday!Life!

! Z*&,%!78<!'#&01#,%!?!M78%!%#!-#,*%*#8!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#R0$%!M*%)*8!10<*7!

,%:<*0,!78<!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!$78!2080'*%!'&#1!%)0!%)0#&*0,!78<!

10%)#<#+#S*0,!#'!10<*7!,%:<*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7:<*08$0!787+.,*,B!!?!&07+*]0!%)7%J!*8!

,#10!F*<0#!S710!$*&$+0,J!%)*,!$78!20!7!$#8%&#F0&,*7+!$)#*$0B!!C:$)!#'!%)0!M#&T!<#80!

5h!

#8!F*<0#!S710,!)7,!7%%01-%0<!%#!<*,%78$0!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!'&#1!#%)0&J!

1#&0!%&7<*%*#87+!10<*7!,:$)!7,!'*+1!78<!-&*8%![9&7M'#&<J!3453\B!!?8!1.!&0F*0M!#'!

F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)J!%)*,!#'%08!&0,:+%,!*8!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!2*87&*0,!%)7%!7&0!

:8%0872+0J!1#,%!8#%72+.!%)0!7$%*F0o-7,,*F0!2*87&.!%)7%!'&0V:08%+.!#&S78*]0,!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,![7$%*F0\!78<!1#&0!%&7<*%*#87+!10<*7![-7,,*F0\B!!

=0$7:,0!#'!%)*,J!*%!*,!#'%08!7,,:10<!M*%)*8!%)0,0!,%:<*0,!%)7%!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!

F*<0#!S710,!7&0!8#%!$6>"/#=/(4!#&!7%!+07,%!7&0!8#%!+*T0!'3$>"'".#$%&@/>"$&$6>"/#=/(B!!

L&7<*%*#87+!10<*7!7:<*08$0,!7&0!-7,,*F0!78<!&0$0-%*F0J!M)0&07,!F*<0#!S710&,!7&0!

1#&0!7$%*F0!78<!01-#M0&0<B!

! ?!<#!8#%!M78%!%)*,!%#!,#:8<!+*T0!?!<#!8#%!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0!,-0$*'*$*%*0,!#'!%)0!

F*<0#!S710!10<*:1B!!_*<0#!S710,!7&0!8#%!%0+0F*,*#8!#&!'*+1!#&!-&*8%J!78<!%):,!%)0!

0W-0&*08$0,!#'!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0,!7&0!+*T0+.!%#!20!<*''0&08%!'&#1!#%)0&!%.-0,!#'!

7:<*08$0!0W-0&*08$0,B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!Z&78,!Cp.&p![344i\!)7,!<*,%*8S:*,)0<!20%M008!

%M#!%.-0,!#'!1078*8S`17T*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710,G!(/@".("(J!&0'0&&*8S!%#!%)0!<0$#<*8S!#'!

10,,7S0,!78<!10<*7!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,J!78<!%6>.("(J!&0'0&&*8S!%#!%)0!1078*8S,!

$#8,%&:$%0<!%)&#:S)!-+7.':+!7$%*#8,B!!I)*+0!#80!$#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!%6>.("(!$#:+<!20!7!

-7&%!#'!78.!10<*7!*8%0&7$%*#8![%)0!-+7.':+80,,!#'!'78!'*$%*#8J!'#&!*8,%78$0\J!*8!F*<0#!

S710,!%6>.("(!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!'07%:&0!#'!%)0!10<*7!*8%0&7$%*#8B!!;,!,:$)J!*%!,0&F0,!7,!7!

:8*V:0!&0,#:&$0!'#&!S710!-+7.0&,!%)7%!$#:+<!<*,%*8S:*,)!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!-+7.*8S!7!

F*<0#!S710!'&#1!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!&07<*8S!7!2##T!#&!M7%$)*8S!7!1#F*0B!

A#M0F0&!?!<#!8#%!%)*8T!%)*,!&0V:*&0,!:,!%#!&7 <*$7++.!7+%0&!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!

M0!$#8$0-%:7+*]0!10<*7!7:<*08$0,B!!;,!Q7&&.!9&7M'#&<![3453\!7,,0&%,J!X*%!*,!V:*%0!

$+07&!%)7%!F*<0#!S710&,!7&0!<*''0&08%!'&#1!#%)0&!10<*7!7:<*08$0,J!2:%!,#!%##!7&0!

5a!

#%)0&!7:<*08$0,!,*S8*'*$78%+.!<*''0&08%!'&#1!07$)!#%)0&Y![-B!d3\B!!PF0&!%)0!.07&,J!

7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)0&,!)7F0!<0F0+#-0<!7!,08,*%*F*%.!%#!%)0!$#8%0W%,!*8!M)*$)!10<*7!

*8%0&7$%*#8,!#$$:&B!!L)*,!%)0#&0%*$7+!&#2:,%80,,!$#10,!'&#1!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)U,!

08S7S0108%!M*%)!%)0!%)0#&*0,!78<!10%)#<,!#'!78%)&#-#+#S.B!!;+7,::%7&*![5666\!)7,!

<0,$&*20<!%)*,!,)*'%!7,!7!%&78,*%*#8!'&#1!X'*&,%!M7F0!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)JY!M*%)!*%,!

-&*17&.!$#8$0&8!'#&!)#M!$#8%08%!M7,!:8<0&,%##<!2.!7:<*08$0!10120&,J!%#!X,0$#8<!

M7F0!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)JY!M)*$)!M7,!1#&0!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!)#M!10<*7!*8%0&7$%*#8,!

M0&0!*8%0S&7%0<!*8%#!%)0!0F0&.<7.!+*F0,!#'!*8<*F*<:7+,!78<!$#11:8*%*0,B!!L)*,!,)*'%!

&0,:+%0<!*8!%)0!&0$#S8*%*#8!%)7%!%)0!$7% 0S #&.!#'!X7:<*08$0Y!M7,!8#%!7,!,%72+0!7,!*%!

#&*S*87++.!7--07&0<!%#!&0$0-%*#8!&0,07&$)0&,B!!;,!N78*$0!>7<M7.![56ii\!

7$T8#M+0<S0<J!07&+.!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!#'%08!,%&:SS+0<!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!X<*,-0&,0<Y!

78<!X8#17<*$Y!'07%:&0,!#'!7:<*08$0,B!!>7%)0&!%)78!#$$:&&*8S!*8!7!,-0$*'*$J!2#:8<0<!

+#$7%*#8J!10<*7!*8%0&7$%*#8,!7&0!*8,%07<!<*,-0&,0<!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!,#$*7+!+*F0,!#'!

-0#-+0!+*F*8S!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!10<*7%0<!,#$*0%*0,!78<!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!

#%)0&!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!;,!>7<M7.![56ii\!':&%)0&!8#%0,J!1:$)!#'!%)0!M#&T!*8!

&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!:-!:8%*+!%)*,!-#*8%!M7,!S&#:8<0<!*8!%&78,1*,,*#8!1#<0+,!#'!

$#11:8*$7%*#8J!M)*$)!-&*F*+0S0<!%)0!-#,*%*#8!#'!%)0!X10<*7!%0W%BY!!L)*,!X%0W%JY!*8!

%:&8J!M7,!#'%08!%)#:S)%!#'!7,!#2R0$%*F0!78<!0W*,%*8S!-&*#&!%#!*%,!&0$0-%*#8!M*%)*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%0W%,B!!L)*,!X#8%#+#S*]*8S!#'!%)0!%0W%JY!%#!:,0!>7<M7.U,!-)&7,0J!

7,,:10<!%)7%!%)0!%0W%!<0%0&1*80<!*%,!1#<0!#'!&0$0-%*#8!78<!%):,!<*F#&$0<!%)0!%0W%!

'&#1!%)0!,#$*7+!$#8%0W%,!*8!M)*$)!*%!M7,!0120<<0<B!!C#&0#F0&J!*%!+#$T0<!7:<*08$0,!

*8%#!-7&%*$:+7&!M7.,!#'!$#8,:1*8S!%0W%,!78<!+*1*%0<!%)0!8:120&!#'!,*%0,!%)7%!

7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)0&,!$#:+<!X+##T!'#&Y!10<*7!*8%0&7$%*#8,B!!!

5i!

L)*,!%08<08$.!%#!X#8%#+#S*]0!%)0!%0W%Y!-0&,*,%,!*8!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,B!!;,!

9&7M'#&<![3453\!7,,0&%,!*8!)*,!#F0&F*0M!#'!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)J!%)0!

17R#&*%.!#'!M#&T!#8!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0,!)7,!'#$:,0<!7+1#,%!0W$+:,*F0+.!#8!

-7&%*$:+7&!*8,%78$0,!#'!-+7.J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)#,0!%)7%!#$$:&!M)08!7!S710!-+7.0&!*,!

,*%%*8S!*8!'&#8%!#'!7!,$&008B!!I)7%!*,!#'%08!+7$T*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,J!%)08J!*,!78!

7M7&080,,!#'!%)0!*8%0&$#880$%0<80,,!20%M008!%)0!10<*7!78<!0F0&.<7.!+*'0B!!L)*,!

+7$T!#'!7M7&080,,!178*'0,%,!8#%!#8+.!*8!M)0&0!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&,!)7F0!+##T0<!

'#&!F*<0#!S710!*8%0&7$%*#8,![*B0B!*8!'&#8%!#'!7!,$&008\J!2:%!*8!%)0!F0&.!

$#8$0-%:7+*]7%*#8!#'!S710,!78<!-+7.!7,!$&07%*8S!7!X17S*$!$*&$+0Y!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!

&07+*%.B!!L)0!$#8$0-%!#'!%)0!X17S*$!$*&$+0JY!27,0<!#8!%)0!M#&T!#'!N#)788!A:*]*8S7!

[56cc\!78<!-#-:+7&*]0<!*8!S710!,%:<*0,!2.!%)0!M#&T!#'!/7+08!78<!q*110&178!

[344f\J!-#,*%,!%)7%!S710,!$#8,%&:$%!78!7+%0&87%0!%*10!78<!,-7$0!%)7%!*,!-0&$0*F0<!7,!

<*,%*8$%!'&#1!X&07+*%.Y![*S8#&*8S!'#&!8#M!%)7%!M)7%!*,!#'%08!-0&$0*F0<!78<!<0'*80<!7,!

X&07+Y!*,!*8!*%,0+'!7!,#$*7+!$#8,%&:$%\B!!!

>0,07&$)0&,!)7F0!0W-78<0<!:-#8!%)0!X17S*$!$*&$+0Y!2.!,:--+0108%*8S!*%!M*%)!

-,.$)#+#S*,%!C*)7+.!9]*T,]08%1*)7+.*U,![5666\!$#8$0-%!#'!X'+#MY!%#!':&%)0&!<0,$&*20!

%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!XZ+#MY!&0'0&,!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,%7%0!*8!M)*$)!

78!*8<*F*<:7+U,!7%%08%*#8!*,!$#1-+0%0+.!#$$:-*0<!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!%7,TB!!L)*,!*,!#'%08!7!

-+07,:&72+0!0W-0&*08$0!7,!*8<*F*<:7+,!%08<!%#!'00+!01-#M0&0<!,*8$0!%7,T,!%)7%!

-&#<:$0!7!'+#M!,%7%0!7&0!7%!7!T*8<!#'!X,M00%!,-#%Y!#'!<*''*$:+%.!'#&!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+B!!@#%!

%##!07,.J!,*8$0!7!%##!07,.!%7,T!M#:+<!2#&0!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%!78<!2&07T!%)0!'+#M!,%7%0J!

78<!8#%!%##!$)7++08S*8SJ!,*8$0!7!%##!<*''*$:+%!%7,T!M#:+<!'&:,%&7%0!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%!78<!

56!

2&07T!%)0!'+#M!,%7%0B!!/7+08!78<!q*110&178![344f\!7<F#$7%0!7!F*<0#!S710!<0,*S8!

-)*+#,#-).!$08%0&0<!#8!-&#<:$*8S!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!'+#M!'#&!-+7.0&,B!!!

I)*+0!?!71!M*++*8S!%#!S&78%!%)7%!-&#<:$*8S!X'+#MY!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!08,:&*8S!

%)0!*8%0S&*%.!#'!%)0!17S*$!$*&$+0!*,!7!'&0V:08%!S#7+!'#&!S710!<0,*S80&,J!2#%)!$#8$0-%,!

7&0!*++`0V:*--0<!%#!<0,$&*20!%)0!$#1-+0W*%.!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!Z#&!#80J!*%!

-&*F*+0S0,!%)0!S710-+7.!0+0108%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7%!%)0!0W-08,0!#'!%)0*&!87&&7%*F0!

0+0108%,B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!0,%72+*,)0,!7!$:+%:&7+!,.,%01!M)0&0!F*<0#!S710!<0,*S80&,!

<#!8#%!'00+!7$$#:8%72+0!%#!%)0!&71*'*$7%*#8,!#'!%)0!$:+%:&7+!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!*8!%)0*&!

F*<0#!S710,J!M)*$)!$78!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)0!0&7,:&0!#'!,#10!7:<*08$0,!#&!,#$*7+!

S&#:-,B!!!L#!*++:,%&7%0!%)0!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)*,!*S8#&78$0J!?!M78%!%#!%:&8!%#!7!&0$08%!

0W$)78S0!20%M008!>#2!(7&<#J!'#&10&!9)*0'!9&07%*F0!P''*$0&!7%!=+*]]7&<!

E8%0&%7*8108%J!78<!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&!L#<<!A7&-0&![345f\B!!=+*]]7&<!

E8%0&%7*8108%!*,!$:&&08%+.!#80!#'!%)0!1#,%!,:$$0,,':+!F*<0#!S710!<0F0+#-0&,!78<!

-:2+*,)0&,!*8!%)0!M#&+<J!&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!%)&00!17R#&!'&78$)*,0,G!A$3=3$?'J!<'$3=3$?'J!

78<!B"$;%.B!!L#!S*F0!7!,08,0!#'!%)0!*1-7$%!%)7%!%)*,!$#1-78.!)7,J!*%,!<'$3=3$?'!

'&78$)*,0!)7,!-+7.0<!7!17R#&!&#+0!*8!%)0!2*&%)!#'!%)0!-&#'0,,*#87+!S71*8S!78<!S710`

2&#7<$7,%*8S!-)08#108#8![L7.+#&J!3453\J!M)*+0!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'!)7,!-&#F08!,#!

-#-:+7&!%)7%!*%!)7,!,-7&T0<!17,,*F0!10<*7!-78*$,!78<!$#8%&*2:%0<!%#!<*,$#:&,0,!

72#:%!%)0!X7<<*$%*F080,,Y!#'!F*<0#!S710,![9&7M'#&<J!3453).!!?8!,)#&%J!=+*]]7&<!*,!7!

17R#&!'#&$0!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!;%!78!C?L!Q710!K72!%7+TJ!(7&<#!01-)7,*]0<!

%)7%!=+*]]7&<!,00T,!%#!$&07%0!X0-*$!08%0&%7*8108%!0W-0&*08$0,YJ!M)*$)!)0!+7%0&!

<0'*80<!*8!%0&1,!#'!X':8Y!78<!XS710-+7.JY!&7%)0&!%)78!'#$:,,*8S!#8!87&&7%*F0!

0W-0&*08$0,B!!I)08!-&0,,0<!2.!A7&-0&!72#:%!)#M!%)*,!01-)7,*,!:-#8!X':8JY!

34!

XS710-+7.JY!78<!X0-*$!08%0&%7*8108%!0W-0&*08$0,Y!*1-7$%,!0''#&%,!%#!17T0!1#&0!

,#$*7++.!-&#S&0,,*F0!$#8%08%J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!1#&0!*8$+:,*F0!*17S0,!#'!M#108J!(7&<#!

&0,-#8<0<J!X?!M#:+<8U%!,7.!%)7%U,!&07++.!7!F7+:0!'#&!:,B!!?%U,!8#%!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!M0U&0!

7S7*8,%!0*%)0&J!2:%!*%U,!R:,%!8#%!,#10%)*8S!%)7%U,b,#10%)*8S!M0U&0!7$%*F0+.!%&.*8S!%#!

<#Y![7,!V%<B!*8!A7&-0&J!345f\B!!A7&-0&!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)*,!78<!#%)0&!&017&T,!'&#1!;;;`

<0F0+#-0&,!,:$)!7,!@*8%08<#!$&07%0!7!'7+,0!<*$)#%#1.!20%M008!X':8JY!X0-*$Y!

S710-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!X*8$+:,*F0!<0,*S8!#&!&0-&0,08%7%*#8Y!%)7%!*S8#&0,!%)0!':++!

&78S0!#'!%)0!7:<*08$0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!X?8$+:,*F0!<0,*S8!#&!&0-&0,08%7%*#8JY!'#&!

0W71-+0!%)0!*8$+:,*#8!#'!,710`,0W!-7*&*8S,!*8!@*8%08<#U,!+*'0`,*1:+7%#&!0.@.>$=2"&

C"?/&[345f\J!20$#10,!17&T0<!7,!*8)0&08%+.!-#+*%*$7+J!7,!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!%)&07%08,!%#!

<*,%&7$%!'&#1!78<!<*,&:-%!%)0!X17S*$!$*&$+0Y!#'!-+7.!2.!17T*8S!*%!X%##!&07+BY!!

C078M)*+0J!M)*%0!17+0!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.!&017*8,!:817&T0<!78<!:8-#+*%*$*]0<J!%)0!

%7T08`'#&`S&78%0<!$08%0&!%)7%!#&S78*]0,!)#M!M0!$#8$0-%:7+*]0!S710-+7.!

0W-0&*08$0,B!

;,!7!&0,:+%J!?!M78%!%#!2&#7<08!#:&!$&*%*$7+!F#$72:+7&.!'#&!<0,$&*2*8S!F*<0#!

S710!-&7$%*$0,!20.#8<!$#8$0-%,!,:$)!7,!X%)0!17S*$!$*&$+0Y!78<!X'+#MY!2.!%7T*8S!*8%#!

$#8,*<0&7%*#8!)#M!%)#,0!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!$#8,%&:$%0<!78<!,:,%7*80<!2.!*8<*F*<:7+!

7:<*08$0!10120&,B!!?%!*,!'#&!%)*,!&07,#8!%)7%!?!M78%!%#!7++.!1.,0+'!M*%)!&0,07&$)0&,!

,:$)!7,!LBKB!L7.+#&!78<!;<&*0880!/)7MJ!M)#!)7F0!<&7M8!:-#8!%)0!%)0#&*0,!78<!

10%)#<,!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,J!'01*8*,%!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)J!78<!V:7+*%7%*F0!

0%)8#S&7-)*$!M#&T!*8!#&<0&!%#!$#1-+*$7%0!#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!0F0&.<7.!+*'0B!!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!,M0&F0!%##!1:$)!*8%#!7!

)*,%#&.!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!)0&0![,:$)!7!%78S08%!$#:+<!20!*%,!#M8!2##TJ!7'%0&!7++ \J!2 :% !?!

35!

<#!M78%!%#!2&*0'+.!,*S87+!)#M!?!71!F*0M*8S!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!78<!M).!?!%)*8T!*%!*,!

F7+:72+0!%#!7<#-%!,#10!#'!*%,!%)0#&*0,!78<!10%)#<#+#S*0,!*8!%)*,!-&#R0$%B!!?8!

-7&%*$:+7&J!?!M78%!%#!,*S87+!1.!7++*78$0!M*%)!=3"'"=$%&=6%'63$%&('6>"/(J!M)#,0!+*807S0!*,!

#'%08!%&7$0<!27$T!%#!%)0!=*&1*8S)71!999/!*8!%)0!56c4,!78<!56h4,!78<!%)0!M#&T!#'!

,$)#+7&,!,:$)!7,!>*$)7&<!A#SS7&%J!/%:7&%!A7++J! (7 :+!I*++*,J!"*$T!A02<*S0J!9)7&+#%%0!

=&:8,<#8J!;8S0+7!C$>#22*0J!78<!178.!1#&0B!!L)*,!M#&T!%08<0<!%#!01-+#.!C7&W*,%!

78<!-#,%`C7&W*,%!10%)#<,!#'!787+.,*,!%#!*8%0&F080!*8!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!=&*%*,)!

M#&T*8S!$+7,,!$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8,!M*%)!$#8,0&F7%*F0!-#+*%*$7+!*<0#+#S*0,![7+%)#:S)!

$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!)7,!<*F0&S0<!'&#1!%)#,0!-7&%*$:+7&!7++0S*78$0,!*8!%)0!

*8%0&F08*8S!.07&,\B!!?!M78%!%#!,*S87+!%)*,!7++*78$0!M*%)!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!

20$7:,0!*%!&0,#87%0,!M*%)!1.!#M8!<&*F0!%#!$#++0$%J!<0,$&*20J!78<!787+.]0!7+%0&87%*F0!

F*<0#!S710!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,B!!;,!;<&*0880!/)7M![3454\!)7,!7&S:0<J!1:$)!#'!%)0!

M#&T!*8!2#%)!%)0!-#-:+7&!78<!7$7<01*$!-&0,,!)7,!<0,$&*20<!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!

M*%)#:%!$#8,*<0&*8S!%)0!2&#7<0&!V:0,%*#8,!#'!)#M!%)7%!$:+%:&0!*,!$#8,%&:$%0<B!!D0%!

#80!#'!%)0!+0,,#8,!#'!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!*,!%)7%!<0,$&*-%*#8,!#'!$:+%:&0!7+,#!

$#8,%*%:%0!%)0!2#:8<7&*0,!#'!%)7%!$:+%:&0B!!L)*,!*,J!2.!*%,!87%:&0J!7!-#+*%*$7+!7$%J!,*8$0!

%)0,0!2#:8<7&*0,!,)7-0!)#M!&0$#S8*%*#8!78<!F7&*#:,!'#&1,!#'!$7-*%7+!7&0!7%%7$)0<!

%#!,#10!-&7$%*$0,!78<!-0#-+0!78<!<08*0<!%#!#%)0&,B!

/)7M![3454\!-&#-#,0,!%)7%!*'!M0!7&0!%#!,%:<.!S710,!$:+%:&7++.![M)*$)!?!71\J!

M0!1:,%!*8!%:&8!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0!$#8'+*$%,!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,![-B!f5h\B!!L)*,!*8F#+F0,!

M&0,%+*8S!M*%)!)#M!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!*,!<0'*80<!78<!<0-+#.0<!2.!2#%)!*8,%*%:%*#87+!

'#&$0,!78<!2.!*8<*F*<:7+!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&,B!!LM#!&0,#:&$0,!%)7%!?!)7F0!'#:8<!

)0+-':+!*8!M#&T*8S!%)&#:S)!)#M!?!$#8$0-%:7+*]0!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!7&0!(*0&&0!

33!

=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!2$;"'6(!78<!/)0&&.!P&%80&U,!0+72#&7%*#8!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.J!

<*,$:,,0<!*8!%)0!80W%!,0$%*#8!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&B!!;8#%)0&!&0,#:&$0!%)7%!?!M*,)!%#!%#:$)!

:-#8!2&*0'+.!)0&0J!%)#:S)J!*,!K7:&08!=0&+78%U,![344i\!$#8$0-%!#'!%)0!D6E'$F.%"'"=$%!

7,-0$%,!#'!17,,!10<*7!$:+%:&0B!!?!<#!,#!7%!%)0!08<!#'!%)*,!,0$%*#8!20$7:,0!*%!,*%:7%0,!

M)7%!?!,00!7,!1.!-&#R0$%U,!F.%"'"=$%!S#7+,!7,!M0++!7,!)*S)+*S)%*8S!M)7%!?!1078!M)08!?!

,7.!%)7%!%)0!10<*7!$78!':8$%*#8!7,!7!&0,#:&$0!'#&!0F0&.<7.!+*'0B!!?8!)0&!M*<0`&78S*8S!

,%:<.!#'!17,,!10<*7%0<!M#108U,!$:+%:&0J!=0&+78%!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0!-&#R0$%!#'!M#108U,!

$:+%:&0!)7,!2008!%#!$#8,%&:$%!78!X*8%*17%0!-:2+*$Y!%)7%!7++#M,!*8<*F*<:7+!M#108!%#!

*17S*80!78<!&0$#S8*]0!%)01,0+F0,!M*%)*8!7!17,,!$#11:8*%.!#'!M#108B!!L)*,!

$#11:8*%.!*,!$08%0&0<!7&#:8<!%)0!20+*0'!%)7%!%)0&0!0W*,%,!X7!M#&+<!#'!,%&78S0&,!M)#!

M#:+<!20!01#%*#87++.!+*%0&7%0!*8!07$)!#%)0&U,!0W-0&*08$0!#'!-#M0&J!*8%*17$.J!<0,*&0J!

78<!<*,$#8%08%J!M*%)!7++!%)7%!08%7*+,Y![-B!c\B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!%)*,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!*,!

&##%0<!*8!%)0!20+*0'!*8!M#108U,!,)7&0<!7''0$%*F0!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!+#8S*8S!78<!<0,*&0J!

8#%!*8!78!72,%&7$%J!-#+*%*$*]0<!X*<08%*%.BY!!=0&+78%!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)*,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!*,!

8#%!-#+*%*$7+J!*8!%)0!%&7<*%*#87+!,08,0!#'!X1780:F0&*8S!'#&!&0,#:&$0!$#8%&#+!#&!$#8%0,%!

*8!%)0!0+0$%#&7+!7&087Y![A08<0&,#8!345dJ!-B!5d4\B!!?8,%07<J!%)*,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!*,!

D6E'$F.%"'"=$%J!0W*,%*8S!7+#8S,*<0!%)0!'*0+<!#'!-#+*%*$,B!!;,!=0&+78%![344i\!<0,$&*20,J!

M#108U,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!X%)&*F0,!*8!F3.E"@"')!%#!%)0!-#+*%*$7+J!#$$7,*#87++.!$&#,,*8S!

#F0&!*8!-#+*%*$7+!7++*78$0J!0F08!1#&0!#$$7,*#87++.!<#*8S!,#10!-#+*%*$,J!2:%!1#,%!#'%08!

8#%Y![X(&0'7$0JY!-7&7B!6\B!!?8!'7$%J!M#108U,!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!*,!1#&0!#'%08!

%)78!8#%!&0,*,%78%!%#!-#+*%*$,!78<!,%&:$%:&0<!7,!7!&0+*0'!?3.@!%)0!-#+*%*$7+J!M)*$)!)7,!

,#!#'%08!2008!%)0!,*%0!#'!M#108U,!<*,08'&78$)*,0108%!78<!<*,*++:,*#8108%B!!!

3d!

L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!%)*,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!<#0,!8#%!)7F0!-#+*%*$7+!0''0$%,B!!

=0&+78%![344i\!7+,#!01-)7,*]0,!%)7%!%)*,!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$!7+,#!,0&F0,!7,!

78!*1-#&%78%!,*%0!'#&!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!XM#108U,!'78%7,*0,J!*<08%*'*$7%*#8,J!78<!

7%%7$)108%,!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!*<08%*%*0,!78<!+*'0!87&&7%*F0,Y![X(&0'7$0JY!-7&7B!5d\J!M)*$)!

*8!%:&8!,)7-0!)#M!M#108!%)*8TJ!'00+J!78<!7$%!*8!%)0!M#&+<B!!L)*,!#''0&,!V:*%0!7!

<*''0&08%!F7+:7%*#8!%#!%)0!X&0+*0'!'&#1!-#+*%*$,Y!-&#F*<0<!2.!17,,!10<*7%0<!$:+%:&0,B!!

C:$)!#'!%)0!M#&T!*8!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!78<!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!)7,!8#%0<!%)0!

$#1-08,7%#&.!'07%:&0,!#'!-#-:+7&!$:+%:&0!78<!%)0!10<*7B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!N78*$0!

>7<M7.U,![5665\!S&#:8<2&07T*8S!G/$>"#1&'2/&G.@$#=/!:+%*17%0+.!$&*%*V:0,!)0&!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!$#1-08,7%#&.!:,7S0!#'!&#178$0!&07<*8SJ!7,!,008!*8!)0&!7,,0&%*#8,!%)7%!

%)0.!<*,%&7$%0<!)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!'&#1!X&07+Y!'01*8*,%!-#+*%*$7+!08S7S0108%B!!L)0&0!*,!

7!-7&%*$:+7&!+#S*$!#'!<*,%*8$%*#8!%)7%!:8<0&-*8,!%)7%!$&*%*V:0J!7!'&710M#&T!#'!%)*8T*8S!

%)7%J!7,!K*,7!A08<0&,#8![345d\!)7,!#:%+*80<J!<0178<,!X78!#--#,*%*#8!20%M008!M)7%!

$78!20!$#:8%0<!7,!-#+*%*$,!78<!M)7%!1:,%J!*8,%07<J!20!<0,$&*20<![78<!<01#%0<\!7,!

,#10%)*8S!0+,0Y![-B!5d5\B!!A08<0&,#8!$#8%*8:0,J!7&S:*8S!%)7%!XZ#&!178.!7:%)#&,!*8!

$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,J!%)0&0!*,!8#!,*S8*'*$78%!-#+*%*$,!*8!,:&F*F7+!78<!*%,!0F0&.<7.!S0,%:&0,l!

'#&!#%)0&,J!*8$+:<*8S!10J!%)0&0!*,!8#!-#+*%*$,!M*%)#:%!%)01Y![-B!5d5\B!!?!M78%!%#!7++.!

1.,0+'!M*%)!A08<0&,#8!*8!&0%)*8T*8S!M)7%!S0%,!%#!X$#:8%Y!7,!-#+*%*$7+!78<!M)7%!1:,%!

20!<*,1*,,0<!7,!7!<*,%&7$%*#8!'&#1!X&07+Y!-#+*%*$,B!!!

C#&0#F0&J!2.!*8,*,%*8S!#8!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!V:7+*%*0,!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!M0!

$78!20S*8!%#!<*,&:-%!%)0!7,,0&%*#8!*8!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,!%)7%!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!7!

-&*F*+0S0<!'0M!7:<*08$0!10120&,!7&0!7-#+*%*$7+!['#&!78!0W71-+0!#'!%)*,J!,00!

>#,0820&SJ!345f\B!!=.!*8,*,%*8S!%)7%!S710,!,)#:+<!20!X'&00!#'!-#+*%*$,JY!%)0,0!

3f!

&07$%*#87&.!7:<*08$0!10120&,!7&0!*8!'7$%!$71-7*S8*8S!'#&!%)0!17*8%0878$0!#'!%)0!

,%7%:,!V:#!*8!S71*8SJ!M)*$)!#F0&M)0+1*8S+.!-&*F*+0S0,!%)0!-0&,-0$%*F0,!78<!

'78%7,*0,!#'!M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!1*<<+0`$+7,,J!$*,`S08<0&0<!108B!!=0$7:,0!

#'!%)*,J!F*0M*8S!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,!#'!,:&F*F7+J!#&!0F08!%)&*F*8SJ!

7$$#1-+*,)0,!%M#!-:&-#,0,B!!?%!)0+-,!,$)#+7&,!$&*%*V:0!7!-#+*%*$,!#'!%)0!K0'%!%)7%!%&*0,!

%#!<&7M!7!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!X&07+Y!-#+*%*$,!78<!%)0!X0F0&.<7.!S0,%:&0,Y!%)7%!-0#-+0!

800<!%#!,:&F*F0J!78<!*%!$&*%*V:0,!$#8,0&F7%*F0!*<0#+#S*0,!%)7%!M#&T!%#!'&710!%)0!

-&7$%*$0,!78<!1078*8S,!#'!%)0!<#1*878%!S&#:-!7,!80:%&7+!78<!87%:&7+B!!!

=0&+78%U,!$#8$0-%!#'!%)0!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+J!%)08J!*,!:,0':+!'#&!7!F7&*0%.!#'!&07,#8,B!!

Z#&!#80J!*%!0,%72+*,)0,!%)0!,%7T0,!#'!17,,!10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8J!7,!17,,!10<*7!

$:+%:&0J!*8$+:<*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!-&#F*<0,!*8<*F*<:7+,!M*%)!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!%)0!

$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!'78%7,*0,J!*<08%*'*$7%*#8,J!78<!7%%7$)108%,B!!?%!7+,#!,0%,!:-!%M#!

%)010,!%)7%!7&0!$08%&7+!%#!1.!*8F0,%*S7%*#8!*8%#!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!k!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

F*<0#!S710,!$78!-&#F*<0!*8<*F*<:7+,!M*%)!'78%7,*0,!#'!20+#8S*8SJ!0F08!*'!%)7%!'78%7,.!

)7--08,!7%!%)0!0W-08,0!#'!#%)0&!7%%7$)108%,!78<!-0#-+0![7,!=0&+78%!'#:8<!*8!)0&!

787+.,*,\J!78<!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!#'%08!$#8,%&:$%0<!7,!7!&0+*0'!'&#1!%)0!

-#+*%*$7+B!!;,!M0!$78!,00!*8!%)0!0W$)78S0!20%M008!(7&<#!78<!A7&-0&!<*,$:,,0<!

-&0F*#:,+.J!#&!*8!%)0!#8S#*8S!XQ710&Q7%0Y!$#8%&#F0&,.

J!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!

&)0%#&*$7++.!-#,*%*#80<!7S7*8,%!X-#+*%*$,Y! 2 .!M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!$*,`

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!XQ710&Q7%0Y!$78!20,%!20!<0,$&*20<!7,!7!!+##,0+.`#&S78*]0<!&07$%*#8!#8!%)0!-7&%!#'!

X%&7<*%*#87+Y!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0,![*B0B!M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%J!17+0!S710&,\!%#!$)78S*8S!

<01#S&7-)*$,!M*%)*8!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,![-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!S&#M%)!#'!M#108!

7:<*08$0,\B!!I)*+0!,#10!XQ710&Q7%0&,Y!*8,*,%!%)7%!%)0*&!$71-7*S8!*,!&07++.!72#:%!

0W-#,*8S!$#&&:-%*#8!*8!F*<0#!S710!R#:&87+*,1J!%)0*&!%7&S0%,!78<!%7$%*$,J!*8$+:<*8S!

)7&7,,108%!78<!%)&07%,!#'!&7-0J!<07%)J!78<!<#WW*8S![%)0!:87:%)#&*]0<!-:2+*,)*8S!#'!

-&*F7%0!#&!*<08%*'.*8S!'07%:&0,!#'!7!-0&,#8!#8+*80\!)7F0!+0<!178.!%#!$#8$+:<0!%)7%!*%,!

$#8$0&8,!7&0!<00-+.!&##%0<!*8!1*,#S.8.B!!!

3c!

S08<0&0<!17+0!<0F0+#-0&,!78<!7:<*08$0,B!!=0&+78%U,!$#8$0-%!#'!%)0!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+!78<!

)0&!<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!M#108U,!*8%*17%0!-:2+*$,!)0+-,!:,!,00!%)7%!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!

-&#F*<0,!7!,*1*+7&!X&0+*0'!'&#1!-#+*%*$,Y!'#&!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0!17+0!S710&,B!!A0&0J!

%)#:S)J!X&0+*0'!'&#1!-#+*%*$,Y!1#&0!#'%08!%)78!8#%!1078,!X'&00<#1!'&#1!%)0!

-&0,,:&0,!78<!<0178<,!#'!*8$+:,*F*%.JY!0W-&0,,0<!7,!7!<*,<7*8!'#&!-#+*%*$7+!

$#&&0$%80,,!78<!7!<0,*&0!%#!X8#%!%7T0!%)*8S,!,#!,0&*#:,+.BY!!!

L)*,!#-08,!:-!7!-+0%)#&7!#'!V:0,%*#8,!'#&!&0,07&$)0&,!%#!*8F0,%*S7%0B!!?,!%)*,!

#80!#'!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!F*<0#!S710,!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)0!M0++`20*8S!#'!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0!

17+0!S710&,g!!;8<!*'!%)*,!*,!#80!#'!%)0!17R#&!-&#R0$%,!#'!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0J!%)08!

M)7%!*,!*%,!7--07+!'#&!8#8`M)*%0J!8#8`,%&7*S)%J!8#8`17+0!S710&,g!!I)7%!&0,#:&$0,!

<#0,!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!-&#F*<0!'#&!%)0!M0++`20*8S!#'!17&S*87+*]0<!$#11:8*%*0,J!

'#&!*8,%78$0!+0,2*78J!S7.J!2*,0W:7+J!%&78,S08<0&0<J!78<!#%)0&!V:00&`*<08%*'*0<!

*8<*F*<:7+,g!!I)7%!7&0!%)0!$#8%*8:*%*0,!78<!<*,$#8%*8:*%*0,!20%M008!%)0!S710-+7.!

0W-0&*08$0,!#'!%)0,0!<*,-7&7%0!S&#:-,g!!L)0,0!7&0!,#10!#'!%)0!-&#2+01,!%)7%!

=0&+78%U,!$#8$0-%!#'!%)0!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+!,08,*%*]0,!10!%#B!!?%!7+,#!,08,*%*]0,!10!%#!%)0!

#2,0&F7%*#8!%)7%!-0#-+0U,!10<*7!:,7S0!78<!-7&%*$*-7%*#8!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!10<*7!

$:+%:&0!*,!7,!1:$)!7''0$%*F0!7,!*%!*,!*<0#+#S*$7+B!!L)7%!*,!%#!,7.J!*%!*,!$&:$*7+!%)7%!

*8<*F*<:7+,!?//%!%)7%!%)0.!20+#8S!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$:+%:&0B!!?8!%)0!1078%*10J!%)#:S)J!?!

M*++!%:&8!%#!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%,!#'!2$;"'6(&78<!/)0&&.!P&%80&U,!M#&T!#8!-&7$%*$0!

%)0#&.!%#!':&%)0&!,-0$*'.!)#M!?!71!$#8$0-%:7+*]*8S!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

7,!*%!&0+7%0,!%#!#8S#*8S!<*,$:,,*#8,!72#:%!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.B!

3h!

Video!Game!Culture:!Habitus!and!Practice!

! ?8!78!*8%0&F*0M!M*%)!=&*78!K088#8![345c\!#'!%)0!"*S*%7+!9:+%:&0!78<!C 0<*7!

?8*%*7%*F0!7%!(088,.+F78*7!/%7%0!^8*F0&,*%.J!;<&*0880!/)7M!!17<0!78!*8$*,*F0!

$#1108%!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!*8!10<*7!,%:<*0,B!!

9#1108%*8S!#8!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%0W%:7+!787+.,*,!78<!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)!*8!

10<*7!,%:<*0,J!/)7M!8#%0<!%)7%!X;8!*<0#+#S*$7+!$&*%*V:0!,)#M,!:,!,#10%)*8S!72#:%!

)#M!,#$*0%.!*,!,%&:$%:&0<Y!78<!X7:<*08$0!787+.,*,!,)#M!:,!,#10%)*8S!72#:%!)#M!

-0#-+0!+*F0!M*%)*8!%)7%!,%&:$%:&0BY!!I)*+0!/)7M!M7,!7<<&0,,*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!%M#!2&#7<!2#<*0,!#'!10<*7!&0,07&$)J!%)*,!,%7%0108%!$78!7+,#!,0&F0!7,!7!

2&*<S0!20%M008!)#M!?!71!$#8$0-%:7+*]*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!<*S*%7+!10<*7!

7:<*08$0,!78<!%)0!10<*7!%)0.!$#8,:10!78<!)#M!?!71!1#&0!2&#7<+.!$#8$0-%:7+*]*8S!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8,!78<!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!&0-&#<:$0!78<!

&017T0!%)0,0!'#&17%*#8,!%)&#:S)!%)0*&!0F0&.<7.!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

/)7MU,!$)7&7$%0&*]7%*#8!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0,0!<*''0&08%!'*0+<,!#'!

10<*7!&0,07&$)!*,!7!&01*8<0&!%)7%!%)0,0!'*0+<,!7&0!8#%!1:%:7++.!0W$+:,*F0!78<!%)7%!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!10<*7!78<!7:<*08$0,!*,!8#%!,%&*$%+.!#--#,*%*#87+B!!

^8<0&-*88*8S!/)7MU,!2&*0'!$#1108%!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!8#%!#8+.!7&0!-0#-+0!7&0!,)7-0<!

2.!-7&%*$:+7&!,%&:$%:&0,J!2:%!%)7%!-0#-+0!7+,#!*8)72*%!%)0,0!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!

-#%08%*7++.!&017T0!%)01B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!/)7M!<#0,!8#%!,001!7,!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!%)0!

#--#,*%*#8!20%M008!10<*7!%0W%,!78<!7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,!7,!,)0!*,!*8!%)0*&!

7&%*$:+7%*#8,B!!?!M78%!%#!0+72#&7%0!#8!%)*,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,!78<!

7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!':&%)0&!,-0$*'.!)#M!?!71!F*0M*8S!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0!2.!

2&*8S*8S!*8!%M#!$#8$0-%:7+!%##+,!'&#1!,#$*#+#S.!78<!78%)&#-#+#S.!%)7%!7&0!F*%7+!%#!

3a!

1.!-&#R0$%!k!(*0&&0!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!X)72*%:,Y!78<!/)0&&.!=B!P&%80&U,!

'#&1:+7%*#8!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!!

L)0,0!%M#!$#8$0-%:7+!%##+,!7&0!F*%7+!'#&!,0F0&7+!&07,#8,B!!Z#&!#80J!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!)7,!2008!$08%&7+!%#!1:$)!#'!%)0!

%)0#&0%*$7+!+78<,$7-0!#'!10<*7!,%:<*0,!78<J!1#&0!,-0$*'*$7++.J!%)0!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!

7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)!%)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!$#8%&*2:%0,!%#B!!;,!,:$)J!?!M78%!%#!,-0$*'.!1.!

#M8!-#,*%*#8!*8!%)0,0!#8S#*8S!<027%0,!2.!7+*S8*8S!1.,0+'!M*%)!=#:&<*0:!78<!P&%80&B!!

Z:&%)0&1#&0J!?!20+*0F0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!M#:+<!2080'*%!'&#1!7!,0&*#:,!

08S7S0108%!M*%)!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!;,!<*,$:,,0<!*8!%)0!-&0F*#:,!,0$%*#8J!%)0!

<*,$#:&,0!7&#:8<!F*<0#!S710,!*8!2#%)!%)0!-#-:+7&!78<!%)0!7$7<01*$!-&0,,!%08<,!%#!

01-)7,*]0!%)0!*8%0&7$%*F*%.!#'!%)0!10<*:1!78<!%)0!'&00<#1,!F*<0#!S710,!-&#F*<0!%#!

7:<*08$0!10120&,B!!I)*+0!*%!*,!%&:0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!<*''0&08%!'&#1!#%)0&!10<*7!

*8!%)7%!%)0.!&0V:*&0!7:<*08$0!*8%0&7$%*#8!%#!-&#$00<J!%)*,!<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!F*<0#!

S710!7:<*08$0,!7&0!'&00!#'!$#8,%&7*8%B!!(&7$%*$0!%)0#&.J!M*%)!*%,!01-)7,*,!:-#8!%)0!

M7.,!*8!M)*$)!2&#7<!,%&:$%:&7+!'#&$0,!78<!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!*8<*F*<:7+!7$%#&,!7&0!

7&%*$:+7%0<!*8!,-0$*'*$!$#8%0W%,J!$78!)0+-!:,!7F#*<!%)*,!&#178%*$!F*0M!#'!7:<*08$0!

7S08$.!78<!<0F0+#-!7!1#&0!8:78$0<!-*$%:&0!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710!

%0W%,!78<!7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,B!!Z*87++.J!%)0,0!$#8$0-%:7+!%##+,!7&0!F*%7+!%#!%)*,!-&#R0$%!

20$7:,0!%)0.!'#&0S&#:8<!78!7,-0$%!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!%)7%!*,!#'%08!80S+0$%0<!*8!F*<0#!S710!

,%:<*0,!k!$+7,,B!!I)*+0!1:$)!F*<0#!S710!,$)#+7&,)*-!)7,!<&7M8!7%%08%*#8!%#!)#M!

S08<0&J!,0W:7+*%.J!&7$0J!78<!#%)0&!,#$*7+!<0%0&1*878%,![78<!%)0*&!*8%0&,0$%*#8,\!

*8'#&1!-+7.0&!-&7$%*$0,J!%)0&0!)7,!2008!&017&T72+.!+*%%+0!M#&T!#8!%)0!*8'+:08$0!#&!

$#8%0W%!#'!$+7,,J!<0,-*%0!%)0!<00-!*1-&*8%!#'!$+7,,!R:<S108%![0BSB!L:&T+0J!3455\B!!=.!

3i!

2&*8S*8S!*8!)72*%:,!78<!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.J!2#%)!#'!M)*$)!7&0!<00-+.!&##%0<!*8!-&#2+01,!

#'!,#$*7+!$+7,,J!?!*8%08<!%#!'*++!%)*,!S7-!78<!-&#F*<0!7!1#&0!8:78$0<!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!

M7.,!*8!M)*$)!,#$*7+!$+7,,!,)7-0,!78<!*,!,)7-0<!2.!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,B!!

Z*&,%J!?!M#:+<!+*T0!%#!%:&8!%#!X)72*%:,Y!78<!,-0$*'.!)#M!?!71!:,*8S!%)*,!%0&1B!!

L)*,!$#8$0-%!M7,!<0F0+#-0<!2.!(*0&&0!=#:&<*0:J!#80!#'!%)0!T0.!'*S:&0,!*8!%)0!

<0F0+#-108%!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!;,!/)0&&.!P&%80&![344h\!)7,!0W-+7*80<J!=#:&<*0:!

20S78!M#&T*8S!7%!7!%*10!M)08!178.!78%)&#-#+#S*,%,!78<!,#$*#+#S*,%,!M0&0!

7%%01-%*8S!%#!1#F0!20.#8<!$#8,%&7*8%`27,0<!%)0#&*0,!#'!,:2R0$%*F*%.!78<!%)0!

#--#,*%*#87+!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!%)7%!,:$)!%)0#&*0,!08%7*+0<B!!

?8!-7&%*$:+7&J!=#:&<*0:!S&7--+0<!M*%)!P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1!78<!*%,!7+1#,%!10$)78*,%*$!

%)0#&*]7%*#8!#'!%)0!<0%0&1*87%*#8!#'!,:2R0$%*F*%.!2.!0$#8#1*$!'#&$0,B!!=#:&<*0:!

&0R0$%0<!%)0!10$)78*,%*$!<0%0&1*87%*#8!#'!0$#8#1*$!'#&$0,!78<!*8!%)0!-&#$0,,!

,#:S)%!%#!&0*8%&#<:$0!7!8#%*#8!#'!%)0!7$%*8S!,:2R0$%!%.-*$7++.!0W$+:<0<!'&#1!%)0!

,#$*7+!787+.,*,!#'!%)7%!%*10![N#)8,#8J!566d\B!!A#M0F0&J!=#:&<*0:!7+,#!<*<!8#%!M78%!%#!

'7++!*8%#!%)0!#--#,*%0!%&7-!#'!$)7&7$%0&*]*8S!%)0!7$%*8S!,:2R0$%!7,!$#1-+0%0+.!'&00!#'!

$#8,%&7*8%J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!$+7,,!$#8,%&7*8%,B!!>7%)0&!%)78!-&0,08%*8S!,%&:$%:&0!78<!

7S08$.!7,!#--#,*%*#87+J!=#:&<*0:!*8,%07<!-&0,08%0<!7!%)0#&.!%)7%!'#$:,0<!#8!%)0!

<*7+0$%*$7+!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!7 8<! 7S08$.J!*8,*,%*8S!%)7%!,%&:$%:&0,!2#%)!

$#8,%&7*8!78<!-&#<:$0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-0#-+0B!!=#:&<*0:!<#0,!%)*,!2.!*8%&#<:$*8S!

%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!X)72*%:,Y!*8%#!#:&!$&*%*$7+!F#$72:+7&.B!

XA72*%:,JY!7,!?!71!:,*8S!*%J!&0'0&,!%#!%)0!<00-+.!0120<<0<!<*,-#,*%*#8,!

*8$:+$7%0<!*8!%)0!10120&,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!'#&17%*#8B!!?%!*,!)0&0!%)7%!?!M78%!%#!

7$T8#M+0<S0!1.!#M8!<0-7&%:&0!'&#1!)#M!%)0!%0&1!)7,!#'%08!2008!<0-+#.0<!*8!

36!

,#$*7+!&0,07&$)B!!L)0!%0&1!X)72*%:,Y!)7,!<&*'%0<!7!2*%!'&#1!=#:&<*0:U,!*8*%*7+!:,0!%#!

*8<*$7%0!X$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8,Y!1#&0!2&#7<+.B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!Q7&&.!9&7M'#&<![3453\!

,7.,!%)7%J!XA72*%:,!*,!,*1*+7&!%#!M)7%!#%)0&!7:%)#&,!)7F0!<0,$&*20<!7,!%)0!r$:+%:&0U!#'!

7!-7&%*$:+7&!S&#:-!#&!,#$*0%.Y![-B!554\B!!9&7M'#&<!%)08!S#0,!#8!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!M)7%!

<*,%*8S:*,)0,!X)72*%:,Y!'&#1!#%)0&!$#8$0-%,!#'!$:+%:&0!78<!17T0,!*%!:,0':+!'#&!F*<0#!

S710!7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)!*,!%)7%!)72*%:,!*,!X012#<*0<Y![-B!554\B!!?!<*,7S&00!M*%)!%)*,!

$)7&7$%0&*]7%*#8!#'!)72*%:,J!8#%!#:%!#'!7!M*,)!%#!'0%*,)*]0!=#:&<*0:U,!#&*S*87+!*8%08%J!

2:%!20$7:,0!?!'00+!%)7%!%)0!:%*+*%.!#'!)72*%:,!7,!7!$#8$0-%:7+!%##+!*,!<*+:%0<!*'!M0!+#,0!

,*S)%!#'!*%,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!$+7,,!'#&17%*#8,!78<!,%&:$%:&0,B!

L#!:8<0&,$#&0!%)*,!+7,%!-#*8%J!?!M78%!%#!,*%:7%0!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8%&*2:%*#8,!%#!

,#$*7+!%)0#&.J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!)*,!M#&T!#8!%7,% 0! 78<!<*,%*8$%*#8J!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!

<027%0,!#8!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!%)7%!M0&0!S#*8S!#8!7%!%)0!%*10!)*,!M#&T!'*&,%!7--07&0<!

[78<J!*8<00<J!7&0!,%*++!#8S#*8S\B!!;,!Q*2,#8`Q&7)71!0%B!7+B![3444\!)7F0!7&S:0<J!1:$)!

#'!%)0!$+7,,!%)0#&*0,!78<!-#+*%*$,!%)7%!=#:&<*0:!M7,!*8!$#8F0&,7%*#8!M*%)!<:&*8S!%)0!

56a4,!78<!56i4,!M0&0!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!7!87&&#M!&78S0!#'!7$%#&,! 7 8<!&0+7%*#8,)*-,B!!?!

8710<!%)*,!2#<.!#'!M#&T!XP&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1Y!07&+*0&!78<!M*++!$#8%*8:0!%#!<#!,#!'#&!

%)0!,7T0!#'!$+7&*%.B!!L)0!-&#2+01!M*%)!P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1J!7,!=#:&<*0:!78<!#%)0&,!

08S7S0<!*8!,#$*7+!%)0#&.!,7M!*%J!M7,!*%,!7%%7$)108%!%#!,%&:$%:&7+!78<!<0%0&1*87%*F0!

%)0#&*0,!#'!$+7,,B!!P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1!%.-*$7++.!$#8'*80<!*%,!'#$:,!%#!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

,:&-+:,!+72#&!78<!%)0!'+#M!#'!+72#&!F7+:0!'&#1!M#&T0&!%#!$7-*%7+*,%B!!L)*,!)7,!2008!

<0'*80<!7,!X%)0Y!$+7,,!-&#$0,,J!M)*+0!%)0!-#,*%*#8,!#'! - &#<:$0&oM#&T0&o+72#&0&!78<!

7--&#-&*7%#&o$7-*%7+*,%!7&0!%)0!#8+.![#&!#8+.!,*S8*'*$78%\!$+7,,!-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!7&0!

&0$#S8*]0<!M*%)*8!%)*,!'&710M#&T![Q*2,#8`Q&7)71!0%B!7+BJ!3444\B!!Z&#1!%)*,!

d4!

-0&,-0$%*F0J!-0#-+0U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!,:&-+:,!+72#&![M)*$)!*,!

':8<7108%7++.!7!&0+7%*#8,)*-!#'!0W-+#*%7%*#8\!$#1-+0%0+.!<0%0&1*80,!,#$*7+!+*'0!78<!

$#8,$*#:,80,,B!!L)*,!-#,*%*#8,!$+7,,!7,!%)0!$08%&7+!$#8%&7<*$%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!+*'0!78<!

$+7,,!*<08%*%*0,!7,!'*W0<!78<!:8*F#$7+J!,*8$0!0$#8#1*$!,.,%01,!-&0$0<0!78<!7&0!

0W%0&87+!%#!%)0!*<08%*%*0,!%)7%!%)0.!,%&:$%:&0B!

I)7%!=#:&<*0:!78<!178.!#%)0&!,#$*7+!%)0#&*,%,!)7F0!%&*0<!%#!<#!*,!%#!0W-78<!

#:&!F#$72:+7&.!'#&!%7+T*8S!72#:%!$+7,,!78<!$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,!78<!&0`7&%*$:+7%0!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$+7,,!78<!#%)0&!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,B!!;!T0.!7,-0$%!#'!%)*,!&0`

7&%*$:+7%*#8!)7,!2008!7!&0`%)*8T*8S!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$+7,,!78<!$:+%:&0B!!

P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1!%.-*$7++.!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!$:+%:&0!7,!7!,0$#8<7&.!0''0$%!#'!0$#8#1*$!

'#&$0,B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0J!$:+%:&0!M7,!,:2#&<*87%0!%#!78<!S:7&78%00<!2.!#80U,!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!1#<0!#'!0$#8#1*$!-&#<:$%*#8B!!/#$*7+!%)0#&*,%,!#'!%)0!56h4,![78<!

$#8%*8:*8S!*8%#!%#<7.\!&0R0$%0<!%)*,!F*0M!#8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!'&#8%,B!!Z#&!#80J!*%!*S8#&0<!

)#M!0$#8#1*$!'#&$0,!7&0!%)01,0+F0,!7%!+07,%!-7&%*7++.!<*,$:&,*F0!$#8,%&:$%*#8,J!78<!

%):,!$:+%:&0!$78!*8'#&1!0$#8#1*$!*<07,!78<!-&#$0,,0,!*8!M7.,!%)7%!$788#%!20!

7$$#:8%0<!'#&!'&#1!%)0!P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,%!-0&,-0$%*F0B!!/0$#8<J!*%!'7*+0<!%#!7$$#:8%!

'#&!%)0!,*S8*'*$78%!,$#-0!78<!-#M0&!#'!#%)0&!,#$*7+!,%&: $% :&0,J!,:$)!7,!&7$0J!S08<0&J!

78<!,0W:7+*%.B!!=.!$08%&7+*]*8S!$+7,,!7,!%)0!#&S78*]*8S!$#8%&7<*$%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!+*'0J!

P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1!M7,!8#%!72+0!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!0''0$%*F*%*0,!#'!%)0,0!

#%)0&!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,B!!!

L)0,0!$&*%*V:0,!#'!P&%)#<#W!C7&W*,1!&0,:+%0<!*8!M)7%!?!M*++!$7++!7!-#,%`

,%&:$%:&7+*,%!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!

-0&,-0$%*F0J!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!*,!2#%)!7!17%0&*7+!78<!<*,$:&,*F0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!

d5!

-&#<:$%*#8J!7--&#-&*7%*#8J!78<!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!M07+%)!78<!+72#&J!M)*$)!Q*2,#8`

Q&7)71!0%B!7+B![3444\!)7F0!*<08%*'*0<!7,!X$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,BY!!L)0,0!-&#$0,,0,!*8%0&7$%!

M*%)J!78<!7&0!%):,!,)7-0<!2.J!#%)0&!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,J!78<!7,!7!&0,:+%!

$78!20!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!#%)0&,!7,-0$%,!#'!,#$*7+!0W*,%08$0!%)7%!7&0!-#%08%*7+!,#:&$0,!

#'!*<08%*%.B!!L)*,!*,!%#!,7.!%)7%!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!*,!'#&10<!*8!*8%0&7$%*#8!M*%)J!78<!

#'%08!'*+%0&0<!%)&#:S)J!#%)0&!,#$*7+!0W-0&*08$0,!,:$)!7,!S08<0&J!&7$0J!78<!,0W:7+*%.B!!

L)0,0!78<!#%)0&!<*108,*#8,!#'!0W-0&*08$0!F7&.!M*%)*8!78<!7$&#,,!$+7,,!+#$7%*#8!*8!

%)0!+*'0!#'!*8<*F*<:7+,B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!*,!8#%!S:7&78%00<!2.!#80U,!,#$*7+!

-#,*%*#8!*8!7!)*0&7&$).![7,!%)#:S)!M0!<#!8#%!*8)72*%!<*''0&08%!-#,*%*#8,!7,!+72#&*8S!

2#<*0,!*8!<*''0&08%!$#8%0W%,\J!8#&!$78!M0!7,,:10!%)7%!*%!*,!%)0!#&S78*]*8S!$08%0&!#'!

*8<*F*<:7+!#&!$#++0$%*F0!*<08%*%.!,*8$0!,:2R0$%,!7&0!#F0&<0%0&1*80<!`!-&#<:$0<!

%)&#:S)!%)0!*8%0&,0$%*#8!#'!1:+%*-+0!,#$*7+!'#&$0,B!!"*,$:,,*#8,!#'!$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,J!

%)08J!$78!20!0W%08<0<!%#!7!F7&*0%.!#'!$:+%:&7+!,*%0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!0W-&0,,*#8!#'!

70,%)0%*$!%7,%0,J!$:+%:&7+!+0S*%*17%*#8,!#'!7:%)#&*%.J!78<!%)0!7''0$%*F0!*8F0,%108%,!*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!-#+*%*$,!78<!*<08%*%*0,B!!I)7%!07$)!#'!%)0,0!,*%0,!)7,!*8!$#11#8J!)#M0F0&J!

*,!7!$#8$0&8!M*%)!M)7%!=+0<,%0*8![56ah\!)7,!$7++0<!%)0!X$:+%:&7+!$#8%&#+!#F0&!% )0!

&0+07,0!#'!-0&,#87+!78<!,#$*7+!080&S*0,Y![-B ! i4\B!

L)*,!2&#7<!<0%#:&!*8%#!-#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!$#8$0-%*#8,!#'!$+7,,!)#-0': ++.!)0+-,!

0,%72+*,)!%)0!%)0#&0%*$7+!+78<,$7-0!'&#1!M)*$)!=#:&<*0:U,!-7&%*$:+7&!%)0#&0%*$7+!

$#8%&*2:%*#8,!,-&78SB!!?8!'7$%J!=#:&<*0:![56if\!-+7.0<!7!T0.!-7&%!*8!,)7-*8S!-#,%`

,%&:$%:&7+*,%!$#8$0-%*#8,!#'!$+7,,!%)&#:S)!)*,!M#&T ! #8!%7,%0!78<!<*,%*8$%*#8B!!L)*,!

M#&T!M7,!&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!7&%*$:+7%*8S!80M!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!20%M008!$:+%:&0!78<!$+7,,!

7,!M0++!7,!0W-78<*8S!,#$*7+!%)0#&.U,!72*+*%.!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!0''0$%*F*%.!#'!7!

d3!

1:+%*%:<0!#'!,#$*7+!78<!$:+%:&7+!'#&$0,J!7++!#'!M)*$)!7&0!%)0!)7++17&T,!#'!7!-#,%`

,%&:$%:&7+*,%!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!$+7,,B!!!

?8!)*,!M#&T!#8!%7,%0!78<!<*,%*8$%*#8J!=#:&<*0:![56if\!2&#7<+.!7&S:0,!%)7%!

,#$*0%.!*,!$#1-#,0<!#'!1:+%*-+0!'*0+<,!%)7%!#&S78*]0!78<!<*,%&*2:%0!&0,#:&$0,![2#%)!

17%0&*7+!78<!,.12#+*$\!7$$#&<*8S!%#!<*,%*8$%!+#S*$,B!!L)0,0!'*0+<,!':8$%*#8!,01*`

7:%#8#1#:,+.!,*8$0!%)0!&0,#:&$0,!07&80<!#&!7$$&:0<!*8!#80!'*0+<!<#!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!

%&78,+7%0!%#!#%)0&!'*0+<,J!7+%)#:S)!%)0&0! 7&0!#'%08!$#&&0,-#8<08$0,B!!=#:&<*0:!:,0,!

%)0!10%7-)#&!#'!X$7-*%7+Y!%#!<0,$&*20!)#M!%)0,0!'*0+<,!':8$%*#8!,01*`7:%#8#1#:,+.B!!

;$$#&<*8S!%#!=#:&<*0:U,!787+.,*,!#'!$7-*%7+J!-#M0&!78<!-&*F*+0S0!7&0!<*''0&08%*7++.!

<*,%&*2:%0<!7$$#&<*8S!%#!#80U,!-#,,0,,*#8!#'!%.-0,!#'!$7-*%7+J!,-0$*'*$7++.!0$#8#1*$!

$7-*%7+![M)7%!.#:!#M8!#&!07&8\J!$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+![M)7%!.#:!T8#M\J!,#$*7+!$7-*%7+!

[M)#1!.#:!T8#M\J!78<!,.12#+*$!$7-*%7+![-&0,%*S0!78<!,#$*7+!)#8#&\B!!^,*8S!%)*,!7,!

78!#&S78*]*8S!'&710M#&TJ!=#:&<*0:!7&S:0,!%)7%!<*''0&08%!<*,%&*2:%*#8,!#'!$7-*%7+!

F7&*72+.!-#,*%*#8!*8<*F*<:7+,!M*%)*8!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!%)7%!,)7-0!%)0*&!7$$0,,!%#!

-#M0&J!-&*F*+0S0J!78<!7:%)#&*%.!M*%)*8!,-0$*'*$!'*0+<,B!

P'!-7&%*$:+7&!*1-#&%78$0!%#!1.!,%:<.!*,!=#:&<*0:U,!01-)7,*,!:-#8!$:+%:&7+!

$7-*%7+!7,!7!M7.!%#!787+.]0!%)0!0W-&0,,*#8!#'!$+7,,!<*,%*8$%*#8!78<!0W$+:,*#8B!!;,!

/7&7)!L)#&8%#8!)7,!7&S:0<J!X$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+!*,!%)0!+*8$)-*8!#'!7!,.,%01!#'!<*,%*8$%*#8!

*8!M)*$)!$:+%:&7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!$#&&0,-#8<!M*%)!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,Y![7,!V%<B!*8!/08<0&J!

344dJ!-B!ddf\B!!P'!$&*%*$7+!*1-#&%78$0!%#!=#:&<*0:U,!%)0#&.!#'!$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+!*,!)*,!

&0F7+:7%*#8!#'!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!X%7,%0BY!!>7%)0&!%)78!,*1-+.!&0'0&&*8S!%#!*8<*F*<:7+!

-&0'0&08$0,!'#&!$:+%:&7+!#2R0$%,J!%7,%0!7+,#!&0'+0$%,!78<!&0-&#<:$0,!$:+%:&7+!

)*0&7&$)*0,B!!;,!=#:&<*0:!0W-+7*8,J!%7,%0!#'%08!':+'*++,!%)0!,#$*7+!':8$%*#8!#'!

dd!

+0S*%*1*]*8S!78<!87%:&7+*]*8S!,#$*7+!<*''0&08$0,B!!/*8$0!#80U,!%7,%0,!7&0!#'%08!%)#:S)%!

%#!20!X87%:&7+Y!78<!X:8%&7*80<JY!<*,%&*2:%*8S!7$$0,,!%#!-#M0&!78<!-&0,%*S0!#8!%)0!

27,*,!#'!#80U,!%7,%0,!7--07&,!1#&0!0S7+*%7&*78!%)78!<*,%&*2:%*8S!-#M0&!#8!%)0!27,*,!

#'!:807&80<!0$#8#1*$!$7-*%7+!#&!,#$*7+!-#,*%*#8B!!A#M0F0&J!7,!=#:&<*0:!7&S:0,J!%7,%0!

#'%08!$#&&0,-#8<,!M*%)!0<:$7%*#8!78<!,#$*7+!#&*S*8![78<!%):,!$+7,,\!20$7:,0!*%!*,!

+07&80<B!!L)*,!*8!%:&8!7&%*$:+7%0,!$:+%:&7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!M*%)!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,J!7,!

<*''0&08%!<*,-#,*%*#8,!$#&&0,-#8<!M*%)!<*''0&08%!,#$*7+!+#$7%*#8,!78<! 0W -0&*08$0,B!!

Z#&!0W71-+0J!=#:&<*0:!,-08<,!1:$)!%*10!787+.]*8S!)#M!%)0!X-:&0!S7]0JY!7!

-&*F*+0S0<!70,%)0%*$!<*,-#,*%*#8!%)7%!01-)7,*]0,!7!<*,$#880$%0<!78<!<*,%78$0<!

$#8,*<0&7%*#8!#'!$:+%:&7+!#2R0$%,!#8!%)0*&!#M8!%0&1,J!$#&&0,-#8<,!M*%)!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

$+7,,!-#,*%*#8!,*8$0!*%!*8F#+F0,!%)0!&01#F7+!#'!7&%!'&#1!*%,!&0+7%*#8!%#!7!,#$*7+!M#&+<J!

'&#1!80$0,,*%.J!78<!'&#1!%)0!2#<.B!!=#:&<*0:U,!1#F0!M7,!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!70,%)0%*$!

<*,-#,*%*#8![78<!*8<00<!7++!0W-&0,,*#8,!#'!%7,%0\!*,!,)7-0<!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!78<!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!M#&+<J!M)*$)! = #:&<*0:!$7++,!)72*%:,B!!

L)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!M#&+<J!*8!%:&8J!*,!-&#<:$0<!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!

'#&17%*#8B!!L)*,!0W%08<,!M)7%!7&0!%&7<*%*#87++.!,008!7,!X17&T0&,Y!#'!$+7,,J!,:$)!7,!

,-00$)!,%.+0J!%#!*8$+:<0!-&0'0&08$0,!'#&!$:+%:&7+!#2 R0$% ,!78<!0F08!%)0!,%.+0!*8!M)*$)!

%)0,0!#2R0$%,!7&0!$#8,:10<B!

?8!=#:&<*0:U,!,#$*7+!%)0#&.J!)72*%:,!*,!%)0!+*8T!20%M008!+7&S0!,%&:$%:&7+!

'#&17%*#8,!78<!%)0!7$%*#8,!#'!-0#-+0!X#8!%)0!S&#:8<BY!!A72*%:,!&0'0&,!%#!%)0!M7.,!*8!

M)*$)!$+7,,!'#&17%*#8,!7&0!*8%0&87+*]0<!7,!<*,-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!,)7-0!7!-0&,#8U,!

7%%*%:<0,!78<!20)7F*#&,B!!I)*+0!%)*,!+*T0+.!&0-&#<:$0,!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,J!,:$)!

&0-&#<:$%*#8!*,!8#%!S:7&78%00<B!!L)*,!*,!7 2 ,#+:%0+.!$&:$*7+!%#!8#%0!78<!*,!7!-+7$0!

df!

M)0&0!178.!-0#-+0![1.,0+'!*8$+:<0<\!)7F0!%08<0<!%#!1*,:8<0&,%78<!=#:&<*0:U,!

$#8$0-%!#'!)72*%:,B!!/#10!)7F0!$&*%*$*]0<!=#:&<*0:U,!'&710M#&T!'#&!0&&*8S!%##!1:$)!

#8!%)0!,*<0!#'!,%&:$%:&0J!17T*8S!*%!<*''*$:+%!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!$)78S0!78<!1#F0108%!

M*%)*8!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%:7+*]7%*#8!#'!)72*%:,![0BSB!Q7&8)71!s!I*++*71,J!56i4J!-B!

333l!;+0W78<0&[email protected]!5666J!-B!544\B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!>*$)7&<!N08T*8,!

[5663\!)7,!M&*%%08!0W%08,*F0+.!#8!M)7%!)0!-0&$0*F0,!7,!%)*,!2+*8<,-#%!M*%)*8!

=#:&<*0:U,!%)0#&.B!!I)*+0!=#:&<*0:!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0&0!*,!7!-&#$0,,!#'!7<R:,%108%!

20%M008!7!-7&%*$:+7&!'*0+<![#&!#2R0$%*F0J!0W%0&87+!,#$*7+!-#,*%*#8,!78<!$*&$:1,%78$0,\!

78<!%)0!,:2R0$%*F0!)72*%:,!#'!78!*8<*F*<:7+J!N08T*8,![5663\!8#%0,!%)7%!'*0+<,!%08<!%#!

-&#<:$0!78<!-&*F*+0S0!$0&%7*8!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!%)*,!0W%0&87+J!#2R0$%*F0!

08F*&#8108%B!!L)0!#2R0$%*F0!,#$*7+!-#,*%*#8,!78<!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!'*0+<J!

%)08J!%08<!%#!&0-&#<:$0!7!-7&%*$:+7&!)72*%:,!*8!*%,!,:2R0$%,B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!*%!$78!20!

<*''*$:+%!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!)#M!'*0+<,!78<!%)0!<*,-#,*% *#8,! 78<!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!

7,,#$*7%0<!M*%)!%)*,!'*0+<!,)*'%!78<!$)78S0B!!;,!N08T*8,![5663\!$#8%08<,J!*%!#'%08!

,001,!7,!*'!%)0!)72*%:,!#'!78!*8<*F*<:7+!78<!%)0!0W%0&87+!$*&$:1,%78$0,!#'!7!'*0+<!7&0!

2#:8<!*8!7!$+#,0<!'00<27$T!+##-J!M*%)!07$)!,*1-+.!$#8'*&1*8S!%)0!#%)0&![-B!ad\B!!

EF08!7!$#11*%%0<!=#:&<*0:!,$)#+7&!+*T0!/)0&&.!P&%80&![344h\!7<1*%,!%)7%!=#:&<*0:J!

*8!)*,!07&+.!M#&TJ!%08<,!%#!#F0&`01-)7,*]0!)#M!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!7!,:2R0$%U,!)72*%:,!

%08<,!%#!,)7-0!-0#-+0!%#!7$$0-%!%)0!<#1*878$0!#'!#%)0&,![-B!c\B!

?!M#:+<!7&S:0J!%)#:S)J!%)7%!%)*,!#F0&`01-)7,*,!#8!,%&:$%:&7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8!

*8!=#:&<*0:U,!07&+.!M#&T!*,!7!&0,:+%!#'!%)0!,%&:$%:&7+!%)0#&*0,!%)7% !)0!M7,!*8!

$#8F0&,7%*#8!M*%)!7%!%)0!%*10B!!?8!,)#&%J!%#!,-07T!%#!,%&:$%:&7+*,%,!=#:&<*0:!-)&7,0<!

)*,!$&*%*V:0,!#'!%)7%!,%&:$%:&7+*,1!*8!%0&1,!%)7%!M#:+<!20!+0S*2+0!%#!,%&:$%:&7+*,%,B!!

dc!

K7%0&!M#&T,!2.!=#:&<*0:!7&0!1:$)!1#&0!$+07&!*8!%)0*&!$&*%*V:0!#'!,%&:$%:&7+*,1!2.!

7&S:*8S!%)7%!7!,:2R0$%U,!)72*%:,!*,!,)7-0<!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!%)0.!*8)72*%!

2:%!7&0!8#%!S:7&78%00<!2.!%)#,0!,%&:$%:&0,B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!=#:&<*0:!78<!I7$V:78%!

[5663\!,%7%0!%)7%G!

A72*%:,!*,!8#%!%)0!'7%0!%)7%!,#10!-0#-+0!&07<!*8%#!*%B!!=0*8S!%)0!-&#<:$%!#'!

)*,%#&.J!*%!*,!78!#-08!,.,%01!#'!<*,-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!*,!$#8,%78%+.!,:2R0$%0<!%#!

0W-0&*08$0,J!78<!%)0&0'#&0!$#8,%78%+.!7''0$%0<!2.!%)01!*8!7!M7.!%)7%!0*%)0&!

&0*8'#&$0,!#&!1#<*'*0,!*%,!,%&:$%:&0![5dd\B!

! I)7%!*,!800<0<J!%)08J!*,!8#%!7!&0R0$%*#8!#&!0F08!7!,*S8*'*$78%!1#<*'*$7%*#8!#'!

=#:&<*0:U,!%)0#&.B!?8,%07<J!M)7%!*,!800<0<!*,!78!0+72#&7%*#8!#'!)#M!7!-0&,#8U,!

)72*%:,!*,!8#%!'*W0<!2.!*%,!#&*S*8,!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,%&:$%:&0!2:%!&7%)0&!0W*,%,!*8!7 !

<.871*$!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!*%B!!N:,%!,:$)!78!0+72#&7%*#8!*,!-&0,08%!*8!/)0&&.!P&%80&U,!

[344h\!M#&T!#8!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!(&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!*,!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!#F0&$#1*8S!%)0!

,%&:$%:&0o7S08$.!#--#,*%*#8!#'!07&+*0&!,#$*7+!%)0#&.!2 .! 7&S:*8S!'#&!%)0!<*7+0$%*$7+J!

&7%)0&!%)78!#--#,*%*#87+J!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!+7&S0`,$7+0!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!,.,%01,!

#8!%)0!#80!)78<!78<!%)0!,17++0&!,$7+0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!#8!%)0!#%)0&B!!;,!

,%7%0<!-&0F*#:,+.J!=#:&<*0:!M7,!*8,%&:108%7+!*8!0,%72+*,)*8S!%)0!,%&:$%:&0o7S08$.!

#--#,*%*#8!7,!7!-&#2+01!*8!,#$*7+!%)0#&.!78<!-&#F*<*8S!:,!M*%)!%)0#&0%*$7+!%##+,!%#!

#F0&$#10!%)*,!#--#,*%*#8B!!A#M0F0&J!7,!P&%80&![344h\!17*8%7*8,J!=#:&<*0:!78<!

#%)0&!E:&#-078!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&*,%,U!07&+.!01-)7,*,!#8!,#$*7+!&0-&#<:$%*#8!&7%)0&!

%)78!,#$*7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8!7,!M0++!7,!%)0*&!&0+*78$0!:-#8!,%&:$%:&7+*,%!+0W*$#8,!#'%08!

%)&07%080<!%#!&0*8%&#<:$0!7!T*8<!#'!':8$%*#87+*,1!*8%#!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!%)&#:S)!%)0!

27$T!<##&B!!?8!#&<0&!%#!S:7&<!7S7*8,%!,:$)!7!&0%:&8J!P&%80&!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0!07&+.!

dh!

-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!'&710M#&T!#'!%)0!56a4,!1:,%!20!,:--+0108%0<!M*%)!%)0!M#&T!'&#1!

#%)0&!17R#&!7&07,!#'!,#$*7+!%)0#&.J!8710+.!M#&T!#8!-#M0&J!)*,%#&.J!78<!$:+%:&0B!

! ?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!'#$:,!7%!+08S%)!#8!P&%80&U,!:,0!#'!%)0!2#<.!#'!$&*%*$7+!M#&T!

&0%)*8T*8S!-#M0&!,*8$0!?!)7F0!<0F#%0<!1:$)!,-7$0!*8!-&0F*#:,!,0$%*#8,!%#!

<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!-#M0&!78<!<#1*878$0B!!?!M*++!,*1-+.!8#%0!%)7%!P&%80&U,!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!

-#M0&!78<!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!'#$:,0,!+0,,!#8!<*&0$%!&0,*,%78$0!78<!1#&0!#8!%)0!M7.,!*8!

M)*$)!<#1*87%*#8!*,!7+M7.,!,)#%!%)&#:S)!M*%)!712*S:*%*0,!78<!$#8%&7<*$%*#8,B!!

9#8,0V:08%+.J!%)0!,#$*7+!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!,%&:$% :&0,!%)&#:S)!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!

7$%#&,!*,!7+M7.,!*1-0&'0$%!78<!%):,!F:+80&72+0!%#!%&78,'#&17%*#8!2.!%)0,0!F0&.!

-&7$%*$0,B!!!

?8,%07<J!?!M78%!%#!'#$:,!#8!P&%80&U,!M#&T!7&%*$:+7%*8S!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!M*%)!

%)0!X)*,%#&*$!%:&8Y!*8!,#$*7+!%)0#&.!78<!78%)&#-#+#S.!78<!M*%)!%)0!M#&T!#'!$:+%:&7+!

,%:<*0,B!!;,!=#:&<*0:!78<!I7$V:78%![5663\!*8,*,%J!)72*%:,!*,!%)0!-&#<:$%!#'!)*,%#&.B!!

>7%)0&!%)78!*8,*,%*8S!%)7%!7!-0&,#8U,!)72*%:,!*,!X'*W0<Y!2.!%)0!)*,%#&*0,!%)7%!-&0$0<0!

*%J!%)#:S)J!=#:&<*0:!78<!I7$V:78%!*8,%07<!<0$+7&0!%)7%!)72*%:,!*,!78!.F/#!,.,%01!#'!

<*,-#,*%*#8,!20$7:,0!#'!*%,!,%7%:,!7,!%)0!-&#<:$%!#'!)*,%#&.B!!P&%80&![344h\!-*$T,!:-!

%)*,!X)*,%#&*$Y!%)&07<!*8!)0&!#M8!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.J!7&S:*8S!%)7%!-&7$%*$0!

%)0#&.!M#&T,!20,%!M)08!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!)*,%#&*$*]0<B!!L)*,!*,!20$7:,0!,#$*7++.!

#&S78*]0<!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!-&#$0,,:7+J!:8'#+<*8S!7%!F7&*#:,!&).%)1,!78<!7&%*$:+7%*8S!

M*%)!<*''0&08%!0F08%,!#'!<*''0&08%!,$7+0,B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!%)0!1078*8S,!7,,*S80<!%#!

%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!17.!<*''0&!<&717%*$7++.!#F0&!%*10B!!A0&0!P&%80&!&0'0&08$0,!%)0!M#&T!

#'!C7&,)7++!/7)+*8,!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!<*''0&08$0,!17.!0W*,%!20%M008!)#M!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!

:8<0&,%##<!2.!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!78<!%)0!1078*8S,!7,,*S80<!%#!%)7%!-&7$%*$0!2.!%)0!+7&S0&!

da!

$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8!#&!,.12#+*$!#&<0&B!!/*1-+.!-:%J!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-&7$%*$0!17.!)7F0!

$#8,0V:08$0,!8#%!'#&0,008!#&!*8%08<0<!2.!*%,!-&7$%*%*#80&,B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!7,!-&7$%*$0,!

:8'#+<!#F0&!%*10!%)0.!&*,T!%&78,'#&1*8S!%)0!$:+%:&7+!$#8$0-%*#8,!%)7%!-&#<:$0<!

%)01!*8!%)0!'*&,%!*8,%78$0B!!I)*+0!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!7+M7.,!7$%!*8!&0'0&08$0!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!

$:+%:&7+!$#8$0-%*#8,J!*8!-&7$%*$0!%)#,0!,710!$#8$0-%*#8,!$78!20!,)*'%0<!#&!

%&78,'#&10<B!

/*1*+7&+.J!P&%80&!<&7M,!#8!%)0!M#&T!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!78<!10<*7!,%:<*0,!%#!

<0F0+#-!7!1#&0!-&0$*,0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!$:+%:&0!*8!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!;,!P&%80&!8#%0,J!

1:$)!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!&0+*0<!#8!7!1#,%+.!:8`&0M#&T0<!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!$:+%:&0!7,!7!

,.12#+*$!'&710M#&T!#&!,$)017!%)7%!-&#<:$0,!-7&%*$:+7&!,:2R0$%,!M)#!,00J!'00+J!78<!

*17S*80!-7&%*$:+7&!%)*8S,!M)*+0!$#8,%&7*8*8S!%)01!'&#1!,00*8SJ!'00+*8SJ!78<!

*17S*8*8S!#%)0&!%)*8S,B!!9:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,U!-&*17&.!$#8%&*2:%*#8!%#!%)0!%)*8T*8S!#'!

$:+%:&0J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!P&%80&J!M7,!%#!<0-+#.!%)*,!#+<!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!$:+%:&0!*8!80M!

87&&7%*F0,!k!87&&7%*F0,!#'!-#M0&!78<!*80V:7+*%.B!!P&%80&!$7++,!%)*,!%)0!X80M`#+<Y!

$#8$0-%!#'!$:+%:&0!78<!%&7$0,!*%,!&##%,!%#!%)0!=*&1*8S)71!/$)##+!#'!%)0!56a4,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!0%)8#S&7-)*$!M#&T!#'!(7:+!I*++*,!78<!%)0!10<*7!,%:<*0,!M#&T!#'!

/%:7&%!A7++B!!!

;8#%)0&!T0.!<0F0+#-108%!*8!%)0!&0`%)*8T*8S!#'!$:+%:&0!*8!,#$*7+!%)0#&.!$710!

'&#1!10<*7!,%:<*0,B!!;$$#&<*8S!%#!P&%80&J!10<*7!,%:<*0,!$#8$0-%:7+*]0,!$:+%:&0!7,!7!

$#++0$%*#8!#'!-:2+*$!%0W%,!%)7%!$78!20!787+.]0<!'#&!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!M#&T!%)0.!-0&'#&1B!!!

L)*,!%)0#&.!#'!-:2+*$!$:+%:&0!<0-*$%0<!$:+%:&0!7,!1#&0!1#2*+0!%)78!%)0!$+7,,*$!

'#&17+*,%!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!$:+%:&0!%)7%!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!-7&%*$:+7&!'#&1,!#'!$:+%:&0!7,!

X20+#8S*8SY!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!S&#:-,B!!I)*+0!$:+%:&7+!,.,%01,!$#:+<!,%*++!20!

di!

7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!$:+%:&7+!'#&17%*#8,!2.!)*,%#&*$7+!-&#$0,,0,J!$:+%:&0U,!

-7&%*7+!1#2*+*%.!7,,:&0<!%)7%!*%!$#:+<!20!<0-+#.0<!78<!7--&#-&*7%0<!*8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!

,#$*7+!$#8%0W%,B!!!

9#8,0V:08%+.!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!M#&T!#'!-:2+*$!$:+%:&0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*%,!&#+0!*8!

&0-&#<:$*8S!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*878$0J!)7<!%#!20!&0%)#:S)%B!!9+7,,*$!1#<0+,!#'!

$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$%*#8J!M)0&0*8!%0W%:7+!1078*8S,!7&0!'*W0<!2.!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$0&,!78<!

-7,,*F0+.!$#8,:10<!2.!7:<*08$0,J!M0&0!8#!+#8S0&!7<0V:7%0!%#!<07+!M*%)!%)0!M*<0&!

<*,%&*2:%*#8!78<!*8$&07,0<!1#2*+*%.!#'!17,,!10<*7!+*T0!&7<*#!78<!%0+0F*,*#8B!!

(0&)7-,!%)0!1#,%!'71#:,!$&*%*V:0!#'!%)*,!$+7,,*$!1#<0+!#'!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$%*#8!*,!

/%:7&%!A7++U,![3444\!XE8$#<*8So"0$#<*8SY!%)0#&.J!M)*$)!$#8$0*F0<!#'!$:+%:&7+!

-&#<:$%*#8!78<!&0$0-%*#8!7,!,0-7&7%0!2:%!&0+7%0<!1#108%,!*8!%)0!$*&$:+7%*#8!#'!

$:+%:&7+!%0W%,J!80*%)0&!#'!M)*$)!M0&0!S:7&78%00<!2.!%)0!#%)0&B!!;,!P&%80&!0W-+7*8,J!

%)0!%)0#&*0,!#'!$:+%:&0!<0F0+#-0<!2.!,$)#+7&,!,:$)!7,!/%:7&%!A7++!$78!)0+-!-&7$%*$0!

%)0#&.!0,$7-0!%)0!,-0$%0&!#'!':8$%*#87+*,1J!M*%)!*%,!01-)7,*,!#8!,#$*7+!,%72*+*%.!78<!

&0-&#<:$%*#8J!78<!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!<.871*$!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!+7&S0&!,#$*7+!

,%&:$%:&0,!78<!S&#:8<0<J!*8<*F*<:7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!!!! ! !!!!

I)7%!P&%80&U,!0+72#&7%*#8!78<!0W-78,*#8!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!<#0,!%#!7!$#8$0-%!

+*T0!)72*%:,J!%)08J!*,!%#!2&*8S!*%,!<.871*$!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#87+!0+0108%,!*8%#!'#$:,B!!

>7%)0&!%)78!&0'0&&*8S!%#!7!,%7%*$!<*,-#,*%*#8!+#$T0<!*8%#!-+7$0!2.!7!,:2R0$%U,!,#$*7+!

#&*S*8J!7!-0&,#8U,!)72*%:,!*,!*8,%07<!#-08!%#!$)78S0!7,!*%!*,!,:2R0$%0<!%#!80M!

0W-0&*08$0,B!!L)0,0!80M!0W-0&*08$0,J!*8!%:&8J!)7F0!%)0!-#%08%*7+!%#!1#<*'.!%)0!

,%&:$%:&0,!%)7%!#&*S*87++.!-&#<:$0<!7!-0&,#8U,! )7 2*%:,!78<!0872+0<!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!L)0!$#8$0-%!#'!)72*%:,J!$#8F0&,0+.J!$78!)0+-!:,!*<08%*'.!78<!17-!%)0!

d6!

$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,!%)7%!,%&:$%:&0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!L)0,0!$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,!

<#!8#%!'*W!$+7,,!<*,-#,*%*#8,!,#!1:$)!7,!-&#F*<0!%)0!'*0+<!:-#8!M)*$)!%)0,0!

<*,-#,*%*#8,!78<!%)0*&!%&7R0$%#&*0,!7&0!,)7-0<B!!;,!=#:&<*0:![566d\!)*1,0+'!8#%0,!*8!

02/&!"/%>&.?&86%'63$%&H3.>6='".#J!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!<*''0&08%!$+7,,!

<*,-#,*%*#8,!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!'*0+<!X&0$0*F0,!*%,!-7 &% *$:+7&!$#8%08%!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

,-7$0Y![-B!a3\B!!C#&0#F0&J!X%)0!,$#-0!7++#M0<!%#!<*,-#,*%*#8,!F7&*0,!7$$#&<*8S!%#!%)0!

,%7%0!#'!%)0!'*0+<![*8!-7&%*$:+7&J!*%,!7:%#8#1.\J!%)0!-#,*%*#8!*8!%)0!'*0+<!78<!%)0!

<0S&00!#'!*8,%*%:%*#87+*]7%*#8!#'!%)0!-#,*%*#8Y![-B!a3\B!!=#:&<*0:U,!1#<0+J!%)08J!*,!8#%!

%)0!,%7%*$!1#<0+!#'!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!<0,$&*20<!2.!,#10!,$)#+7&,J!2:%!7!<.871*$!

,.,%01!*8!M)*$)!,%&:$%:&0,!7&0!2#%)!&0-&#<:$0<!78<!,:2R0$%0<!%#!1#<*'*$7%*#8B!!

A72*%:,!*,J!72#F0!7++J!78!#-08!,.,%01!#'!<*,-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!*,!-&#<:$0<!2.!)*,%#&.![*B0B!

X&0$0*F0,!*%,!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%08%!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,-7$0Y\!78<!*,!,)7-0<!2.!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!

#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!

Summary!and!Synthesis!

! (:++*8S!27$T!%#!0W71*80!1.!7--&#7$)!%#!,%:<.*8S!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!1#&0!

2&#7<+.J!M0!$78!,00!%)7%!?!)7F0!7,,012+0<!7!'+0W*2+0!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!%)7%!

'#&0S&#:8<,!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!+7&S0`,$7+0!,%&:$%:&7+!78<!*8,%*%:%*#87 +!'#&$0,J!

#8!%)0!#80!)78<J!78<!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,J!#8!%)0!#%)0&B!!L)*,!

7--&#7$)!*,!:,0':+!8#%!#8+.!'#&!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&,J!2:%!7+,#!'#&!,$)#+7&,!

*8%0&0,%0<!*8!%)0!&0$0-%*#8!#'!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,!1#&0!S080&7++.B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!?!

%)#:S)%!*%!M#:+<!20!:,0':+!%#!-&#F*<0!7!2&*0'!,:117&.!78<!,.8%)0,*,!#'!1.!

f4!

$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0!*8`<0-%)!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!*%,!$#8,%*%:08%!

-7&%,!%)7%!?!)7F0!'#$:,0<!#8!*8!%)*,!$)7-%0&!,#!'7&B!

! L)*,!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!20S*8,!M*%)!%)0!%)0#&*0,!#'!10<*7!&0$0-%*#8!

,%:<*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*%,!$#8$0-%:7+*]7%*#8!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!10<*7!

-&7$%*$0,!78<!0F0&.<7.!+*'0B!!/*1-+.!-:%J!%)0!$#8,:1-%*#8!#'!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,!*,!8#%!

,#10)#M!,0-7&7%0!#&!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!%)0!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!$#1-#,0!7!-0&,#8U,!+*'0J!

2:%!7&0!<00-+.!*12&*$7%0<!*8!78<!$#8,%*%:08%!#'!%)0!+*F0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!L)7%!*,J!

10<*7!'#&1,!<#!8#%!,*1-+.!&0'+0$%!+*'0!7'%0&!%)0!'7$%J!2:%!7&0!:,0<!%#!)0+-!,)7-0!78<!

$#8,%*%:%0!%)7%!F0&.!+*'0B!!L)0&0'#&0J!10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,!,)#:+<!8#%!20!

0W71*80<!*8!*,#+7%*#8J!2:%!*8,%07<!1:,%!20!,*%:7%0<!*8!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!+*F0,!78<!

)*,%#&*0,!#'!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!08S7S0!M*%)!%)01J!*'!M0!7&0!%#!<0F0+#-!7!':++0&!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!&#+0!#'!10<*7!*8!0F0&.<7.!+*'0B!!L)0!M7.!%)7%!?!-&#-#,0!M0!<#!

%)*,!*,!%#!F*0M!10<*7!7,!7!&0,#:&$0!'#&!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!$#1-#,0!7!-0&,#8U,!+*'0J!

M)*$)!?!)7F0!&0'0&&0<!%#!7,!X0F0&.<7.!+*'0Y!'#&!%)0!,7T0!#'!,*1-+*$*%.B!!L)0,0!

&0,#:&$0,J!*8!%:&8J!7&0!8#%!+*1*%0<!%#!%)0!,.12+*$!78<!*<0#+#S*$7+!&0,#:&$0,!%)7%!)7F0!

%&7<*%*#87++.!$#8$0&80<!10<*7!78<!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!,$)#+7&,B!!;,!$#8%01-#&7&.!

10<*7!&0,07&$)J!1#,%!,*S8*'*$78%+.!K7:&08!=0&+78%U,![344iJ!3455\!M#&T!#8!10<*7!

78<!-:2+*$!7''0$%J!)7,!<01#8,%&7%0<J!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,!78<!$#8,:1-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,!7+,#!

)0+-!$#8,%&:$%!78<!1#2*+*]0!01#%*#8,!78<!7''0$%,!%)7%!$78!)7F0!7!<&717%*$!*1-7$%!

#8!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!;,!,:$)J!M0!1:,%!8#%!#8+.!7%%08<!%#!)#M!7:<*08$0,!

:8<0&,%78<!78<!*8%0&-&0%!%)0!10<*7!%)0.!$#8,:10B!!I0!1:,%!7+,#!0W-78<!#:&!

#2R0$%,!#'!,%:<.!%#!*8$+:<0!)#M!10<*7!17T0!-0#-+0!'00+!78<!%)0!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!

f5!

%)0,0!'00+*8S,!7,!-0#-+0!1#F0!%)&#:S)!%)0!#%)0&!,-7$0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!$#1-#,0!

%)0*&!+*F0,B!!!

! L)*,!$#8$0-%:7+!7--&#7$)!%#!%)0!&0$0-%*#8!#'!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,J!%)08J!$08%0&,!

7:<*08$0!10120&,!78<!'#$:,0,!#8!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!010&S0!'&#1!#&!7&0!#%)0&M*,0!

&0+7%0<!%#!%)0*&!$#8,:1-%*#8!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!10<*7!#2R0$%,B!!;,!,:$)J!7!$08%&7+!

%)0#&0%*$7+!*,,:0!%)7%!*%!7<<&0,,0,!*,!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!2&#7<!,#$*7+!

,%&:$%:&0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,J!#8!%)0!#80!)78<J!78<!%)0!7S08$.!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,J!#8!%)0!

#%)0&B!!?8!$#8%&7,%!%#!F*0M*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!7,!

#--#,*%*#87+J!%)#:S)J!?!7+*S8!1.,0+'!M*%)!,#$*7+!%)0#&*0,!%)7%!F*0M!%)01!<*7+0$%*$7++.J!

78<!%):,!7&0!1#&0!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!%)0*&!7&%*$:+7%*#8,!78<!*8%0&7$%*#8,B!!?!<#!%)*,!*8!

#&<0&!%#!20%%0&!,00!78<!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!*8<0%0&1*87%0!87%:&0!#'!-#M0&!78<!*%,!

0''0$%,B!!/#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,J!M)*+0!$0&%7*8+.!-#M0&':+J!7&0!80F0&!

%#%7+*]*8SJ!1078*8S!%)0.!$78!80F0&!S:7&78%00!7!-7&%*$:+7&!#:%$#10!7,!%)0.!7&0!

&0-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B! ! ?8,%07<J!%)0.!7&0!,)#%!%)&#:S)!

M*%)!712*S:*%*0,J!M)*$)!$78!*8!%:&8!+07<!%#!1#<*'*$7%*#8,!#&!%&78,'#&17%*#8,!7,!%)0.!

:8'#+<!#F0&!%*10B!!!

?8!#&<0&!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)*,!<*7+0$%*$7+!%08,*#8!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!

M*%)*8!1.!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&TJ!?!01-+#.0<!%M#!%)0#&0%*$7+!%##+,B!!L)0!'*&,%!M7,!

(*0&&0!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!2$;"'6(B!!A72*%:,J!7,!%)0!*8%0&87+*]7%*#8!78<!

012#<*108%!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!$+7,,!-#,*%*#8J!0872+0,!&0,07&$)0&,!%#!:8<0&,%78<!

)#M!7!-0&,#8U,!)*,%#&.!78<!0W-0&*08$0,!*8'#&1!%)0*&!7%%*%:<0,!78<!20)7F*#&,B!!

A#M0F0&J!$&:$*7++.J!)72*%:,!*,!#-08!%#!1#<*'*$7%*#8!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8!7,!7!-0&,#8!

1#F0,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!M#&+<!78<!08$#:8%0&,!80M!0W-0&*08$0,B!!I)*+0!#80!$#:+<!

f3!

7&S:0!%)7%!=#:&<*0:!<0$+*80,!%#!0+72#&7%0!#8!%)*,!<:0!%#!)*,!'#$:,!#8!%)0!

&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,J!)*,!,:$$0,,#&,!)7F0!<0F0+ #- 0<!%)*,!*<07B!!L)*,!

+07<,!10!%#!%)0!,0$#8<!%)0#&0%*$7+!%##+!?!108%*#80<!7%!%)0!#-08*8S!#'!%)*,!-7&7S&7-)!

k!/)0&&.!P&%80&U,![344h\!7$$#:8%!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.B!!!

K*T0!=#:&<*0:J!P&%80&!*,!+0,,!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!% )0! #--#,*%*#8!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!

78<!7S08$.!%)78!*8!%)0*&!7&%*$:+7%*#8J!*8!-7&%*$:+7&!)#M!%)0.!*8'#&1!78<!,)7-0!07$)!

#%)0&B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0J!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,!-&#<:$0!%)0!

-&7$%*$0,!#'!*8<*F*<:7+!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!2:%J!$&:$*7++.J!$788#%!S:7&78%00!)#M!%)0.!

:+%*17%0+.!:8'#+<B!!=0$7:,0!#'!%)*,J!%)0!-#M0&!0W0&%0<!2.!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!

*8,%*%:%*#8,!*,!7+M7.,!,)#%!%)&#:S)!M*%)!712*S:*%*0,!78<!$#8%&7<*$%*#8,J!-#%08%*7++.!

#-08*8S!%)0,0!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,!%#!1#<*'*$7%*#8!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8!2.!%)0!

-&7$%*$0,!#'!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!L)*,!&0,#87%0,!M*%)!%)0!'*0+<!#'!10<*7!,%:<*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

7:<*08$0!78<!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,J!M)*$)!01-)7,*]0,!%)0!*8<0%0&1*87$.!#'!$:+%:&7+!

'#&1,!78<!%)0*&!&0,-#8,*F080,,!%#!%)0!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,!*8!M)*$)!%)0.!7&0!&0$0*F0<B!!

=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!)72*%:,!78<!P&%80&U,!7$$#:8%!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!$78!)0+-!:,!

0+72#&7%0!#8!%)*,!2.!<&7M*8S!#:&!7%%08%*#8!%#!)#M!,-0$*'*$!$:+%:&7+!'#&$0,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!,#$*7+!$+7,,J!7&0!2&#:S)%!%#!207&!#8!78!*8<*F*<:7+U,!-&7$%*$0,!F*,`t`F*,!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!$:+%:&7+!'#&1!78<!)#M!%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,J!*8!%:&8J!$78!:8'#+<!:8-&0<*$%72+.J!

,#10%*10,!&0-&#<:$*8S!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!M)*+0!7%!#%)0&!%*10,!1#<*'.*8S!#&!0F08!

%&78,'#&1*8S!%)01B!!!

fd!

The!Field!of!Video!Gaming!Practices!

A7F*8S!0,%72+*,)0<!1.!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&TJ!?!8#M!%:&8!%#M7&<,!)#M!#%)0&!

,$)#+7&,!)7F0!<0,$&*20<!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!,#!7,!%#!-&#F*<0!7!,08,0!#'!%)0!

)*,%#&*0,!78<!)*0&7&$)*0,!%)7%!)7F0!,)7-0<!78<!$#8%*8:0!%#!,)7-0!F*<0#!S71*8S!78<!

)#M!*%!*,!*17S*80<!*8!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,B!!C.!-#*8%!#'!08%&.!*8%#!<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!%)0!

'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!*,!,%&:$%:&0<!78<!%)0!F7&*0%.!#'!*8,%*%:%*#87+J!,#$*7+J!78<!

-0&,#87+!-&#$0,,0,!%)7%!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)*,!,%&:$%:&*8S!*,!,*1-+0!`!?!M*++!20S*8!M*%)!1.!

$#8F0&,7%*#8,!M*%)!#%)0&!S710&,B!!?8!7!-&0+*1*87&.!*8%0&F*0M!'#&!%)*,!,%:<.!78<!

$#8F0&,7%*#8,!M*%)!#%)0&!,0+'`*<08%*'*0<!S710&,J!1.!*8%0&+#$:%#&,!<01#8,%&7%0<!7!

&017&T72+0!<0S&00!#'!&0'+0W*F*%.!72#:%!)#M!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!*,!,%&:$%:&0<!%#!

-&*F*+0S0!$0&%7*8!T*8<,!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!72#F0!#%)0&,B!!C.!*8%0&+#$:%#&,!8#%!#8+.!

<01#8,%&7%0<!78!7M7&080,,!#'!)#M!-#,*%*#8,!M*%)*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!7&0!

#&S78*]0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!10$)78*,1,!#'!%7,%0!78<!<*,%*8$%*#8J!2:%!7+,#!)#M!%)0*&!#M8!

-0&,#87+!)*,%#&*0,!*8'#&1!%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

Z#&!0W71-+0J!78!07&+.!*8%0&F*0M00J!>7F08J!<0,$&*20<!7!,*%:7%*#8!<:&*8S!02/&

I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@![=0%)0,<7!/#'%M#&T,J!3455\!M)0&0!,)0!&0R0$%0<!M)7%!,)0!'0+%!

,)0!M7,!X,:--#,0<!%#!<#Y!*8!%)0!S710B!!?8,%07<!#'!-&#S&0,,*8S!%)0!-+#%!#'!%)0!S710!

78<!-:&,:*8S!V:0,%,![M)*$)!%)0!S710!08$#:&7S0,\J!>7F08!$)#,0!%#!):8%!78<!S7%)0&!

F7&*#:,!*8S&0<*08%,!*8!#&<0&!%#!17T0!-#%*#8,B!!L)*,J!*8!'7$%J!$#1-&*,0<!%)0!17R#&*%.!

#'!)0&!7$%*F*%.!*8!<7)3"@B!!I)*+0!%)*,!*,!08%*&0+.!-#,,*2+0!S*F08!%)0!M7.!%)0!S710!*,!

<0,*S80<J!>7F08!0W-&0,,0<!78!7M7&080,,!%)7%!%)*,!M7,! 8#% !7!F3/?/33/>&$)#*$0!M*%)*8!

%)0!S710!%)&#:S)!)0&!#M8!7$T8#M+0<S108%!%)7%!%)*,!$)#*$0!M7,!7%!#<<,!M*%)!%)0!

*17S*80<J!<#1*878%!-+7.!,%.+0!08$#:&7S0<!2.!%)0!S710!78<J!-&0,:172+.J!-&0'0&&0<!

ff!

2.!1#,%!-+7.0&,B!!EF08!M*%)*8!7!S710!7,!&0-#&%0<+.!#-08`08<0<!78<!&0,-#8,*F0!%#!

-+7.0&!$)#*$0!7,!<7)3"@J!%)0&0!7&0!-&0'0&&0<!M7.,!#'!08S7S*8S!M*%)!78<!-&#S&0,,*8S!

%)&#:S)!%)0!S710!%)7%!,%&:$%:&0!$0&%7*8!T*8<,!#'!-+7.B!!L)*,!17.!8#%!#&*S*87%0!#8+.!

'&#1!%)0!S710!*%,0+'![7+%)#:S)!%)0!S710!$0&%7*8+.!0W0&%,!,#10!-&0,,:&0\J!2:%!7+,#!

'&#1!*%,!,*%:7%*#8!M*%)*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!'*0+<!#'!S71*8SJ!M)*$)!-&*F*+0S0,!$0&%7*8!%.-0,!

#'!-+7.!-&7$%*$0!72#F0!#%)0&,B!!C*7!9#8,7+F#U,![344a\!M#&T!#8!$)07%*8S!*,!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!&0+0F78%!)0&0J!7,!,)0!:,0,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!$)07%*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710,!%#!

#-08!:-!7!2&#7<0&!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!*,!,%&:$%:&0<B!!=:*+<*8S!78<!

0W-78<*8S!:-#8!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!X$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+JY!9#8,7+F#!-&#-#,0,!%)0!

$#8$0-%!#'!XS71*8S!$7-*%7+Y!%#!<0,$&*20!%)0!<.871*,1!#'!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,!71#8S!

-+7.0&,!7,!M0++!7,!%)0*&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!2#%)!%)0!S710!*8<:,%&.!78<!*%,!,:&&#:8<*8S!

-7&7%0W%:7+!*8<:,%&*0,J!8#%72+.!S71*8S!R#:&87+*,1!78<!M02,*%0,!,:$)!7,!K$@/!-5(!

[S710'7V,BS710,-#%B$#1\!<0<*$7%0<!%#!$#8,%&:$%*8S!M7+T%)&#:S),!78<!,%&7%0S*0,!

'#&!F7&*#:,!S710,B!!

?%!*,!*1-#&%78%!%#!8#%0!)0&0!%)7%!8#%!7++!S710-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!S*F08!0V:7+!

M0*S)%!M*%)*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8SB!!L)7%!*,J!S71*8S!$7-*%7+!%08<,!%#!7$$&:0!7$$#&<*8S!

%#!-7&%*$:+7&!+#S*$,J!+#S*$,!%)7%!7&0!,)7-0<!2.!+7&S0&!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!-&*F*+0S*8S!

87&&#M!0W-&0,,*#8,!#'!S08<0&J!,0W:7+*%.J!78<!$+7,,B!!C.!-&0F*#:,!M#&T!#8!

%0727SS*8S

!*8!%)0!L$%.!,0&*0,!#'!S710,![C.0&,J!345a\J!'#&!0W71-+0J!<01#8,%&7%0<!

%)7%!-7&%*$:+7&!S71*8S!,%.+0,!M0&0!-&*F*+0S0<!72#F0!#%)0&,!M*%)*8!%)0!L$%.!S71*8S!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!XL0727SS*8SY!)0&0!&0'0&,!%#!7!-+7.0&!-&7$%*$0!-#-:+7&*]0<!2.!%)0!F*<0#!S710!,0&*0,!

L$%.!*8!M)*$)!7!-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&!&0-07%0<+.!$&#:$)0,!#F0&!%)0!2#<.!#'!7!'7++08!

#--#808%U,!7F7%7&!%#!,*1:+7%0!&:22*8S!%)0*&!S08*%7+,!#8!%)0!-+7.0&U,!$#&-,0B!!

;+%)#:S)!*%!*,!S080&7++.!:,0<!7,!7!%##+!#'!,)71*8SJ!*%!$78!7+,#!20!$#8,*<0&0<!7!

,*S8*'*0&!#'!$+#,080,,!20%M008!-+7.0&,!7,!%0727SS*8S!+07 F0,! 7!-+7.0&!F:+80&72+0!%#!

$#:8%0&7%%7$T!78<!%):,!*,!%.-*$7++.!#8+.!<#80!71#8S!'&*08<,B!

fc!

$#11:8*%.B!!!?8!-7&%*$:+7&J!-7&%*$*-78%,!'7F#&0<!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!'#$:,0<!#8!<0F0+#-*8S!

,%&7%0S*0,!%#!0''*$*08%+.!7$)*0F0!%)0!M*8!$#8<*%*#8,!0,%72+*,)0<!2.!%)0!S710B!!L)0,0!

,%&7%0S*0,!M0&0!7+,#!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!<0,$&*20<!7,!X,0&*#:,Y!2.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!

/%&7%0S*0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!%0727SS*8S!%)7%!M0&0!,:-0&'+:#:,!%#J!#&!0F08!*8%0&'0&0<!

M*%)J!7$)*0F*8S!%)0,0!M*8!$#8<*%*#8,!M0&0!'&0V:08%+.!<08*S&7%0<!2.!-7&%*$*-78%,!#&!

#%)0&M*,0!17&T0<!7,!X'&*F#+#:,BY!!?!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)0,0!,%7%0108%,!M0&0!0F*<08$0!#'!

%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!7$$:+%:&7%*#8!%)7%!$)7&7$%0&*]0,!7!-+7.0&U,!08%&78$0!*8%#!%)0!L$%.&

S71*8S!$#11:8*%.B!!90&%7*8!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!%0727SS*8SJ!20$710!78!*8<0W!#'!7!

-+7.0&U,!<0S&00!#'!7$$:+%:&7%*#8B!!L)#,0!M)#!%0727S!M0&0!,008!7,!8#%!20*8S!':++.!

7M7&0!#'!%)0!8#&1,!78<!&:+0,!%)7%!S#F0&8!X7--&#-&*7%0Y!20)7F*#&!*8!%)0!L$%.!

$#11:8*%.B!!L)0,0!8#&1,!78<!&:+0,!#'!7--&#-&*7%0!S71*8S!20)7F*#&J!*8!%:&8J!

*8%0&,0$%0<!M*%)!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!S08<0&!78<!,0W:7+*%.![,*8$0!

%0727SS*8S!M7,!'&0V:08%+.!-&7$%*$0<!2.!17+0!-+7.0&,!#8!#%)0&!17+0!-+7.0&,\!78<!

$+7,,!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!2#<*+.!-&#-&*0%.!78<!&0,%&7*8%B!

L)*,!-&#$0,,!#'!7$$:+%:&7%*#8!*,!8#%!:8*V:0!%#!L$%.B!!LBKB!L7.+#&J!*8!H%$)&

M/'N//#&A.3%>(![344h\!78<!G$"("#1&'2/&<'$7/(![3453\J!-&#F*<0,!78!#F0&F*0M!#'!

-+7.0&!*8<:$%*#8!78<!,#$*7+!-&#S&0,,*#8!*8!2#%)!CCP>(Q,![C7,,*F0+.!C:+%*-+7.0&!

P8+*80!>#+0!(+7.*8S!Q710,\!78<!E`/-#&%,B!!/)0!<0,$&*20,!7!,.,%01!M)0&0!-+7.0&,!

X7&0!8#%!#8+.!%7:S)%!)#M!%#!-+7.J!2:%!)#M!%#!;/Y![L7.+#&J!344hJ!X=0$#1*8S!7!(+7.0&JY!

-7&7B!aJ!01-)7,*,!#&*S*87+\B!!?8!0,,08$0J!L7.+#&!7&S:0,!%)7%!)#M!-+7.0&,!08S7S0!M*%)!

F*<0#!S710,!*,!#'%08!1*,&0$#S8*]0<!7,!7!,%.+0J!M)08!*8!'7$%!)#M!-+7.0&,!7$%!*8!S710,!

$#&&0,-#8<,!M*%)!-+7.0&,U!M7.,!#'!20*8SJ!7$%*8SJ!78<!%)*8T*8SB!!?8!,)#&%J!%)0!-&#$0,,!

fh!

#'!7$$:+%:&7%*#8!2:*+%!*8%#!S710,!78<!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,!,)7-0,!78<!*,!,)7-0<!2.!7!

-+7.0&U,!)72*%:,B!

I)7%!*,!&0+0F78%!%#!1.!,%:<.J!%)08J!*,!%)0!%.-0!#'!)72*%:,!%)7%!%)0!'*0+<!#'!

S71*8S!-&*F*+0S0,!78<!)#M!<*''0&08%!-+7.0&,!&0,-#8<!%#!%)*,!M)08!%)0*&!&07,#8,!'#&!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!<#!8#%!$#8'#&1!%#!%)0!87&&#M!&78S0!#'!<*,-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!%)0!

'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!-&*F*+0S0,B!!C.!M#&T!#8!%0727SS*8S!)7,!)0+-0<!10!,00!%)7%!178.!#'!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!*8F0,%0<!*8!%)0!*<07!%)7%!S71*8S!M7,!X,0&*#:,BY!!L)*,!%.-0!#'!

S71*8S!M7,!%)08!#--#,0<!%#!1#&0!X'&*F#+#:,Y!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!,:$)!7,!%0727SS*8SB!!

L)0,0!M0&0!-+7.0&,!M)#J!2.!78<!+7&S0J!%##T!S71*8S!,0&*#:,+.!*8!7!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!

08F*&#8108%!%)7%!M7,J!78<!$#8%*8:0,!%#!20J!<*,1*,,*F0!#'!S71*8SB!!

! L)*,!-7&%*$:+7&!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!S710,!*,!8#%!:8*V:0!%#!S71*8S!7:<*08$0,B!!

?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!178.!S710!<0F0+#-0&,J!%)0!-7&7%0W%:7+!*8<:,%&*0,!%)7%!)7F0!

7&*,08!7&#:8<!S710,J!78<!0F08!1:$)!#'!%)0!7$7<01*$!M#&T!#8!S710,!7&0!7+,#!

*8F0,%0<!*8!$:+%*F7%*8S!%)0!*<07!%)7%!S710,!7&0!X,0&*#:,BY!!@#M!?!71!$+07&+.!8#%!

,7.*8S!%)7%!S71*8S!*,!8#%!X*1-#&%78%BY!!?!71!M&*%*8S!7!<*,,0&%7%*#8!#8!%)0!*1-7$%!#'!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!#8!%)0!+*F0,!#'!*%,!-&7$%*%*#80&,J!,#!$+07&+.!?!20+*0F0!S71*8S!*,!

*1-#&%78%m!!?!71!*8,%07<!-#*8%*8S!%#!)#M!%)0!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!X,0&*#:,Y!#&!X*1-#&%78%Y!

)7F0!2008!<0-+#.0<!*8!%)0!F7&*#:,!'*0+<,!%)7%!*8%0&,0$%!*8!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,J!,:$)!

7,!S710,!R#:&87+*,1!78<!7$7<01*$!&0,07&$)J!78<!)#M!%)7%!<0-+#.108%!'&0V:08%+.!

#$$+:<0,!#&!<0+0S*%*1*]0,!7!F7&*0%.!#'!<*''0&08%!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,B!!?!71!7+,#!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

%&#:2+0<!2.!%)0!'7*+:&0!#'!1:$)!M#&T!*8!S71*8S!,%:<*0,!%#!$&*%*$7++.!*8%0&&#S7%0!

%)0,0!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!X,0&*#:,JY!-7&%*$:+7&+.!)#M!X,0&*#:,Y!#'%08!$#&&0,-#8<,!%#!

<#1*878%!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!F7+:0B!

fa!

! @#MJ!,#10!1*S)%!'*8<!*%!#<<!%)7%!?!2&*8S!:-!<#1*878%!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!F7+:0!

78<!,%.+0!*8!7!$#8F0&,7%*#8!72#:%!S71*8SB!!;'%0&!7++J!7&08U%!F*<0#!S710,![78<!%)0!

-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!%)01\!<0F7+:0<!$:+%:&7+!#2R0$%,g!!?!M#:+<!7&S:0J!%)#:S)J!%)7%!*'!M0!

7&0!%#!)7F0!7!$&*%*$7+!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!S71*8S!$:+%:&0J!M0!1:,%!0W71*80!S71*8S!"#&

=.#'/E'B!!;8<!S71*8S!0W*,%,!*8!7!,:2#&<*87%0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!#%)0&!'*0+<,!#'!$:+%:&7+!

-&#<:$%*#8B!!;,!,:$)J!*%!*,!%#!20!0W-0$%0<!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!$0&%7*8!)#1#+#S*0,!20%M008!

%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!78<!%)0!'*0+<,!#'!#%)0&J!1#&0!F7+:0<!$:+%:&7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!N08T*8,!

[5663\!M&*%0,!%)7%!)#1#+#S*0,!0W*,%!20%M008!'*0+<,!'#&!%M#!17*8!&07,#8,B!!P8!%)0!

#80!)78<J!7,!-0#-+0!1#F0!7$&#,,!'*0+<,!%)0.!87%:&7++.!%&78,+7%0!%)0!+#S*$,!#'!#80!'*0+<!

*8%#!%)0!+#S*$!#'!78#%)0&J!+07<*8S!%#!,*1*+7&*%*0,!*8!-&7$%*$0,!78<!<*,-#,*%*#8,!

20%M008!%M#!'*0+<,B!!P8!%)0!#%)0&!)78<J!%)#:S)J!)#1#+#S*0,!20%M008!%M#!'*0+<,!$78!

20!-&#<:$0<!M)08!7!,%&#8S0&J!1#&0!<#1*878%!'*0+<!X*1-*8S0,Y!#8!7!M07T0&!'*0+<B!!

L)0!M07T0&!%)0!'*0+<J!%)0!,%&#8S0&!%)*,!X*1-*8S0108%Y!20$#10,![-B!ai\B!!L):,!*%!

17T0,!,08,0!%)7%!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8SJ!<:0!%#!*%,!,:2#&<*87%0!,%7%:,!*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!

$:+%:&0J!*,!*8'+:08$0<!78<!,)7-0<!2.!#%)0&J!X,%&#8S0&Y!'*0+<,!#'!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$%*#8B!!!

L)*,!X*1-*8S0108%Y!178*'0,%,!*8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,B!!?!,00!*%!*8!2#%)!7$7<01*$,U!

78<!S71*8S!R#:&87+*,%,U!01-)7,*,!#8!%)0!X)*S)+.!,#$*7+Y!7,-0$%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8!78!

0''#&%!%#!X<*,-&#F0Y!,%0&0#%.-0,!#'!%)0!,#+*%7&.!S710&!<*,$#880$%0<!'&#1!%)0!M#&+<!

7&#:8<!)*1B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!7!)07<+*80!'&#1!%)0!%0$)!M02,*%0!9@EL!-&#:<+.!,)#:%,!

%)7%!X/%:<.!'*8<,!#8+*80!S710&,!7&08U%!78%*,#$*7+!27,0108%!<M0++0&,Y![C##&0J!345f\B!!

C#&0!&0$08%+.J!7!I7,)*8S%#8!(#,%!7&%*$+0!&0-#&%0<!%)7%!X%)0!1.%)!#'!%)0!+#80+.!

S710&!-+7.*8S!*8!,#+*%:<0!*,!<07<Y![/0+T!s!Q:,T*8J!345i\B!!!!;,!;<&*0880!/)7M![3454\!

)7,!8#%0<J!,%:<*0,!%)7%!&0-#&%!%#!X<*,$#F0&Y!%)7%!S710&,!7&0!,#$*7+!7&0!#'%08!

fi!

R:W%7-#,0<!M*%)!%)0!,%0&0#%.-0!#'!%)0!X,*8S+0!-+7.0&Y!#&!,#+*%7&.!S710&![-B!f5d\B!!

>7%)0&!%)78!*8%0&&#S7%0!78<!-:,)!27$T!7S7*8,%!%)0!<08*S&7%*#8!#'!,#+*%7&.!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,J!%)#:S)J!%)0,0!7&%*$+0,!78<!,%:<*0,!*8,%07<!*8%0&,0$%!M*%)!78<!&0*8'#&$0!

8#&17%*F0!*<07,!#'!-&#-0&!7:<*08$0!<*,-#,*%*#8,!78<!%)0*&!7$$#1-78.*8S!$+7,,*,%!

78<!)0%0&#,0W*,%!'#:8<7%*#8,B!!

I0!7+,#!,00!78!08#&1#:,!71#:8%!#'!7%%08%*#8!S*F08!*8!S71*8S!,%:<*0,!%#!

S710,J!S08&0,J!78<!$#11:8*%*0,!%)7%!-&*F*+0S0!)*S)+.!,#$*7+!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,B!!I0++`

&0$0*F0<!,%:<*0,!,:$)!7,!LBKB!L7.+#&U,!H%$)&M/'N//#&A.3%>(&[344hOJ!C*7!9#8,7+F#U,!

82/$'"#1&[344a\J!78<!=#88*0!@7&<*U,!P)&C"?/&$(&$&Q"12'&I%?&H3"/('&[3454\!7++!'#$:,!#8!

CCP>(Q,![I9/3R6/('J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+J!78<!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'!&0,-0$%*F0+.\!%)7%!

&0V:*&0!-+7.0&,!%#!08%0&!F*&%:7+!08F*&#8108%,!-#-:+7%0<!2.!#%)0&!-+7.0&,.!!/*1*+7&+.J!

7!S&#M*8S!,:2,0%!#'!S71*8S!,%:<*0,!'#$:,0,!#8!%)0!2:&S0#8*8S!0`,-#&%,!,$080!

[L7.+#&J!3455l!L7.+#&J!3453l!I*%T#M,T*J!3453\B!!@#M!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!$&*%*$*]0!% )0,0!

*8<*F*<:7+!,%:<*0,!'#&!'#$:,*8S!#8!,#$*7+!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,B!!P8!%)0!$#8%&7&.J!?!)7F0!

'#:8<!%)01!7++!%#!20!-&#F#$7%*F0!78<!*8,-*&7%*#87+B!!C.!M#&&*0,!7&0!1#&0!<*&0$%0<!7%!

%)0!+*%0&7%:&0!#8!S71*8S!7,!7!M)#+0!78<!%)0!&0+7%*F0!+7$T!#'!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!-+7.!

0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!<*''0&!'&#1!%)0,0!)*S)+.!,#$*7+!#80,!#&!%)0!X,0&*#:,!-+7.Y!#'!

$#1-0%*%*F0!L$%.!S710&,B!!?!71!M#&&*0<!%)7%!1.!#M8!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!%)0!

0W-0&*08$0,!#'!1.!*8%0&+#$:%#&,!'&0V:08%+.!S#!:87$T8#M+0<S0<!2.!%)0!2&#7<0&!

S71*8S!$:+%:&0!7&#:8<!:,B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!,:&-&*,*8S!S*F08!S71*8SU,!,:2#&<*87%0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!#%)0&!10<*7!78<!$:+%:&7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!A#M0F0&J!%)0,0!,%&7%0S*0,!#'!

+0S*%*17%*#8!%)&07%08!%#!-#+*$0!78<!<*1*8*,)!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,!78<!%)0!,:2R0$%*F*%*0,!78<!

<*,-#,*%*#8,!%)0.!$78!-&#<:$0B!!!!!!!!

f6!

9*&$+*8S!27$T!%#!1.!&0,07&$)!#8!%0727SS*8SJ!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!%0727SS*8S!

0W01-+*'*0,!,#10!#'!%)0!%&78,S&0,,*F0!-#%08%*7+!#'!-+7.!78<!*%,!72*+*%.!%#!$*&$:1F08%J!

&0$#8%0W%:7+*]0J!78<!#%)0&M*,0!:-08<!%)0!&:+0,!#'!7!S710B!!;,!78!010&S08%!S710!

-+7.!10$)78*$!2#&8!'&#1!-+7.0&,U!$&07%*F0!:,0!#'!L$%.U,!$&#:$)!10$)78*$J!

%0727SS*8S!':8$%*#8,!7,!78!*8%0&&:-%*#8!*8!%)0!S710B!!I)*+0!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!<08.!*%,!

+#$7%*#8!M*%)*8!1*,#S.8*,%!78<!)#1#-)#2*$!<*,$#:&,0,!#'!%&7,)`%7+T*8SJ!,0F0&7+!

-7&%*$*-78%,!8#%0<!%)7%!*%!-&#F*<0<!%)01!M*%)!7!%.-0!#'!-0&F0&,0!-+07,:&0J!#&!$#:+<!

0F08!20!:,0<!7,!78!*8<0W!#'!%)0!$+#,080,,!20%M008!'&*08<,B!!=.!7&S:*8S!'#&!%)0!

,0&*#:,80,,!#'!'*&,%`-0&,#8!,)##%0&!S710,J!%)#:S)J!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!

<*,7--&#F0<!#'!%0727SS*8S!7%%01-%0<!%#!$#8,%&7*8!%)0,0!#%)0&!M7.,!#'!*8%0&7$%*8S!

M*%)!%)0!S710!78<!*%,!&:+0,J!%):,!+*1*%*8S!%)0!%.-0,!#'!-+07,:&0!78<!,#$*7+!

7%%7$)108%,!%)7%!#80!$78!<0&*F0!'&#1!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!!!

?8!%)*,!M7.J!M0!$78!,00!%)7%!,#10!#'!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!#'!1.!,%:<.!M#&T0<!%#!

7+*S8!7!XS710&Y!*<08%*%.!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!<*,$#:&,0,!&0S:+7%*8S!10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8!

%)7%!7&#,0!<:&*8S!%)0!8*80%008%)!$08%:&.!78<!$#8%*8:0!%#!)7F0!7!-0&,:7,*F0!'#&$0!#8!

$#8%01-#&7&.!*<07,!#'!-&#-0&!-&#`,#$*7+!7:<*08$0!20)7F*#&!78<!$#8,:1-%*#8!

[<0,-*%0!%0727SS*8SU,!178*'0,%+.!,#$*7+!$)7&7$%0&\B!!;,!>*$)7&<!=:%,$)![344i\!

<0,$&*20,J!%)0!010&S*8S!1*<<+0`$+7,,!#'!8*80%008%)`$08%:&.!;10&*$7J!*8!7!2*<!%#!

+0S*%*1*]0!%)0*&!$+7,,!,%7%:,!78<!$#8,#+*<7%0!%)0*&!-#M0&J!20S78!%#!$#8,%&:$%!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!*<07+!#'!&0,-0$%72*+*%.J!M)*$)!M7,!#'%08!0V:7%0<!M*%)!$#8%&#+!#'!%)0!2#<.B!!

L):,!1#&7+!&0'*80108%!78<!,:-0&*#&*%.!M0&0!#'%08!107,:&0<!2.!%)0!1*<<+0`$+7,,!

*<07+,!#'!&0,%&7*8%B!!L0727SS*8SJ!%)#:S)J!M*%)!*%,!&0'0&08$0,!%#!-0&F0&,0!78<!

c4!

:8<*,$*-+*80<!2#<*0,!78<!7!+7$T!#'!&0,%&7*8%J!%)&07%08,!%)0!&0,-0$%72*+*%.!%)7%!$0&%7*8!

S710&,!7%%01-%!%#!$:+%*F7%0B!

L)*,!*,!7++!%#!,7.!%)7%!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!7!,*%0!#'!,%&:SS+0!71#8S!<*''0&08%!

S&#:-,!M*%)!<*''0&08%!*8%0&0,%,!78<!&0,#:&$0,B!!L#!&0%:&8!%#!%)0!,:2R0$%!#'!S71*8S!

$7-*%7+J!9#8,7+F#U,![344a\!$#8$0-%!01-)7,*]0,!%)0!<.871*,1!*8)0&08%!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!

S71*8S!%)7%!*,!,#!'&0V:08%+.!+#,%!M)08!#%)0&!,$)#+7&,!:,0!=#:&<*0:B!!L)*,!<.871*,1!

*,J!#'!$#:&,0J!8#%!'&00!'&#1!,%&:$%:&0!#&!-#M0&B!!9#8,7+F#!7$T8#M+0<S0,!%)0!<*,-7&*%.!

#'!-#M0&!20%M008!S710!-+7.0&,J!%)0!+7&S0&!S710!78<!-7&7%0W%:7+!*8<:,%&*0,!

[*8$+:<*8S!S710!17S7]*80,J!,%&7%0S.!S:*<0,J!78<!S710!1#<,!%)7%!$78!&0$#8'*S:&0!#&!

7<<!%#!7!S710U,!0W*,%*8S!$#<0\J!78<!*8<00<!%)0!2&#7<0&!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$).!20.#8<!

S71*8SJ!*8!<0'*8*8S!78<!<*,%&*2:%*8S!S71*8S!$7-*%7+.!!A#M0F0&J!%)*,!,.,%01!#'!

<*,%*8$%*#8!*,J!$&:$*7++.J!#-08`08<0<B!!;,!9#8,7+F#![344a\!M&*%0,J!X-+7.0&,!

%)01,0+F0,!':&%)0&!,)7-0!S71*8S!$7-*%7+J!0,-0$*7++.!7,!80M!10<*7!'#&1,!#''0&!

*8<*F*<:7+,!1#&0!#--#&%:8*%*0,!%#!,)7&0!78<!%)0!S710!M#&+<!S&#M,!0F08!+7&S0&Y!

[XQ71*8S!97-*%7+JY!-7&7B!a\.!!9#8,7+F#!&01*8<,!:,!%)7%!=#:&<*0:U,!10%7-)#&!#'!

$7-*%7+J!M)*$)!$78!20!$*&$:+7%0<J!0W$)78S0<J!*8F0,%0<J!78<!&0<*,%&*2:%0<J!$78!7+,#!

)0+-!:,!%)*8T!72#:%!@.9/@/#'B!!/#!M)*+0!S71*8S!78<!-7&7%0W%:7+!*8<:,%&*0,!)7F0!

S&07%0&!7$$0,,!%#!78<!1#&0!-#M0&!%#!<*,%&*2:%0!S71*8S!$7-*%7+J!-+7.0&,!7&0!8#%!

<0F#*<!#'!7S08$.B!!C#,%!*1-#&%78%+.J!%)0!<*''0&08%!'#&1,!#'!-#M0&!78<!$7-*%7+!

7$$:1:+7%0<!2.!-7&%*$:+7&!*8,%*%:%*#8,!7&0!8#%!'*W0<!78<!,%72+0J!2:%!#-08!%#!

&0<*,%&*2:%*#8B!!I)*+0!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%)*,!%#!<0F#+F0!*8%#!7!&#178%*$!7,,0&%*#8!#'!

7:<*08$0!7S08$.J!?!<#!M78%!%#!7++#M!,-7$0!*8!1.!%)0#&0%*$7+!'&710M#&T!'#&!

c5!

*8<0%0&1*87$.!78<!%)0!72*+*%.!#'!-+7.0&,!%#!)7F0!,#10!&#+0!*8!,)7-*8S!%)0*&!

S710-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,B!!!

L)0!'#&1!%)*,!7S08$.!%7T0,!$#:+<!,*1-+.!20!$)##,*8S!'&#1!%)0!F7&*0%.!#'!

-#,*%*#8,!#''0&0<!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!'*0+<B!!;,!=#:&<*0:!)7,!-#,*%0<J!'*0+<,!,%&:$%:&0!%)0!

-#,*%*#8,!78<!,%78<-#*8%,!7F7*+72+0!%#!*8<*F*<:7+,!78<!#&S78*]0!%)0,0!-#,*%*#8,!

%)&#:S)!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!F7&*#:,!'#&1,!#'!$7-*%7+B!!?8!%)0!0W71-+0!%)7%!?!)7F0!2008!

<0F0+#-*8S!:,*8S!>7F08J!#80!$#:+<!F*0M!)0&!<0$*,*#8!%#!'#$:,!#8!$#++0$%*8S!2:%%0&'+.!

M*8S,!*8!<7)3"@&7,!7,,:1*8S!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-#,*%*#8!M*%)*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8SB!!I)*+0!

,#10!1*S)%!7&S:0!%)7%!>7F08U,!-&0'0&08$0!*,!,*1-+.!7!X17%%0&!#'!%7,%0JY!=#:&<*0:!

)0+-,!:,!,00!%)7%!X17%%0&,!#'!%7,%0Y!7&0!80*%)0&!87%:&7+![*B0B!%)0.!7&0!$:+%*F7%0<!78<!

%&7*80<\!8#&!7&0!%)0.!M*%)#:%!$#8,0V:08$0B!

=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%,!#'!'*0+<!78<!$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+!<#!8#%!#8+.!&0'0&!%#!M)7%!*,!

$#8,:10<J!%)#:S)B!!>#2!"&0M![344c\J!*8!)*,!,%:<.!#'!;10&*$78!T7&7#T0!

-0&'#&178$0!,%.+0,J!7+,#!8#%0,!%)7%!$:+%:&7+!$7-*%7+!*8'+:08$0,!)#M!#80!-0&'#&1,!

%)7%!$#8,:1-%*#8B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!$#:8%0&,!$0&%7*8!7,,0&%*#8,!2.!$:+%:&7+!%)0#&*,%,!

[8#%72+.!N#)8!/072&##T!78<!"7F*<!=&##T,\!%)7%!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!:&278!1*<<+0`

$+7,,!2+:&,!$:+%:&7+!78<!$+7,,!2#:8<7&*0,!%)&#:S)!%)0*&!7%%7$)108%!%#!$:+%:&7+!

-&7$%*$0,!78<!#2R0$%,!7,,#$*7%0<!M*%)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!$+7,,0,J!1#,%!8#%72+.!%)0!M#&T*8S!

$+7,,0,B!!"&0MJ!)#M0F0&J!7&S:0,!%)7%!2.!2&*8S*8S!0%)8#S&7-).!%#!207&!:-#8!#:&!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%7,%0!$:+%:&0,J!M0!$78!,00!%)7%!%)0!0W-&0,,*#8!#'!$+7,,!<*,%*8$%*#8!

78<!0W$+:,*#8!%)&#:S)!$:+%:&7+!'#&1,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!*,!1:$)!1#&0!08<:&*8S!%)78!

%)0,0!,$)#+7&,!%)*8TB!>7%)0&!%)78!F*0M*8S!-7&%*$*-7%*#8!*8!T7&7#T0!7,!7!,.12#+!#'!

c3!

2+:&&*8S!$+7,,!2#:8<7&*0,J!"&0M!7&S:0,!%)7%!<*''0&08%!,%.+0,!#'!T7&7#T0!78<!%)0*&!

$#&&0,-#8<08$0,!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!+#$7%*#8,!7$%:7++.!&07,,0&%!%)0,0!<*F*,*#8,B!

P80!$#:+<!<&7M!178.!$#1-7&*,#8,!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!T7&7#T0!

20$7:,0!%)0.!7&0!2#%)!)*S)+.!-0&'#&17%*F0!78<!<00-+.!012#<*0<!+0*,:&0!-&7$%*$0,!

78<!7&0!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!$+7,,!$:+%:&0B!!?8!'7$%J!9&7M'#&<![3453\!)7,!*8,*,%0<!%)7%!#80!#'!

%)0!&07,#8,!M).!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!)72*%:,!*,!:,0':+!*8!0W71*8*8S!F*<0#!S710!

0W-0&*08$0,!*,!20$7:,0!#'!%)0!012#<*0<!87%:&0!#'!F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8SB!!L):,!M)*+0!

"&0M!7&S:0,!%)7%!$+7,,!)*0&7&$)*0,!$78!20!&0-&#<:$0<!78<!1#<*'*0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!

-0&'#&178$0!#'!T7&7#T0J!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!,*1*+7&!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!$78!20!

&0-&#<:$0<!#&!1#<*'*0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!012#<*0<!-0&'#&178$0!#'!F*<0#!S710!-+7.B!!

9#8,0V:08%+.J!M0!1:,%!8#%!#8+.!-7.!7%%08%*#8!%#!M)7%!*,!20*8S!-+7.0<J!2:%!7+,#!%#!

)#MJ!*8!#&<0&!%#!20S*8!%#!<&7M!$#880$%*#8,!20%M008!7!-+7.0&U,!)72*%:,!78<!%)0*&!

-+7.!-&7$%*$0,B!!

L#!-&0F*0M!M)7%!%)*,!787+.,*,!+##T,!+*T0J!?!M78%!%#!&0%:&8!%#!>7F08!78<!)0&!

)72*%:,B!!;,!,)0!<0,$&*20,!*%J!>7F08!)7,!7!$#1-+*$7%0<!$+7,,!87&&7%*F0B!!;!2*&7$*7+!

$)*+<!S&#M*8S!:-!*8!-#F0&%.!*8!,:2:&278!9#880$%*$:%J!>7F08!<*<!8#%!)7F0!<*&0$%!

7$$0,,!%#!1:$)!#'!%)0!%0$)8#+#S*$7+!&0,#:&$0,!80$0,,7&.!%#!,:--#&%!7!S71*8S!)#22.B!!

?8!'7$%J!1:$)!#'!%)*,!%0$)8#+#S.!M7,!7$V:*&0<!,0$#8<)78<!'&#1!)0&!1#&0!7''+:08%!

20,%!'&*08<J!M)#!M#:+<!S*F0!)0&!)*,!#+<!S71*8S!$#8,#+0,!M)08!)0!:-S&7<0<!%#!80M0&!

#80,B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!>7F08!7+M7.,!'0+%!X#80!,%0-!20)*8<Y!#%)0&!S710&,B!!I)*+0!#%)0&!

S710&,!78<!%)0!S71*8S!*8<:,%&.!)7<!7+&07<.!1#F0<!#8!%#!80M0&!S080&7%*#8,!#'!

$#8,#+0,J!>7F08!M7,!#8+.!R:,%!<*,$#F0&*8S!%)0!-&0F*#:,!S080&7%*#8B!

cd!

! L)*,!'00+*8S!#'!20*8S!X#:%!#'!,%0-Y!M*%)!%)0!+7&S0&!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!

-0&,*,%,!0F08!%#!%)*,!<7.J!<0,-*%0!%)0!'7$%!%)7%!7%!%)0!%*10!#'!#:&!*8%0&F*0M!>7F08!)7<!

,*8$0!X$7:S)%!:-Y!M*%)!%)0!S710&,!7&#:8<!)0&B!!/)0!,%*++!'00+,!%)0&0!7&0!,*S8*'*$78% !

S7-,!*8!)0&!S710-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,J!)7F*8S!80F0&!-+7.0<!$0&%7*8!S710,!%)7%!7&0!

'&0V:08%!&0'0&08$0!-#*8%,!'#&!%)0!S710&,!7&#:8<!)0&B!!L)*,!*,!:8<#:2%0<+.!

$#1-#:8<0<!2.!)0&!,%7%:,!7,!7!2*&7$*7+!M#178!M)#!S&0M!:-!-##&B!

! D0%!<0,-*%0!%)0,0!'00+*8S,J!>7F08!7+,#!'*0&$0+.J!<0'*78%+.!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!S710&B!!

/)0!<*''0&0<!'&#1!,#10!#'!%)0!#%)0&!-0#-+0!%)7%!?!)7F0!,-#T08!%#J!%)#:S)J!*8!)0&!

<0'*8*%*#8!#'!M)7%!7!S710&!*,B!!/)0!*8,*,%0<!%)7%!#80U,!,%7%:,!7,!7!S710&!*,!+7&S0+.!

<0-08<08%!:-#8!%)0!*8%08,*%.!#'!%)0*&!7%%7$)108%!%#!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!

78<!8#%!%)0*&!7$$0,,!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!%0$)8#+#S*0,!#&!$#1-0%08$.!7%!-+7.*8S!S710,B!!

L)*,!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!S71*8S!*<08%*%.!M7,J!*8!-7&%J!*8'+:08$0<!2.!)0&!07&+.!

-7&%*$*-7%*#8!*8!#%)0&!'78<#1!$#11:8*%*0,!%)7%!M0&0!#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!78!*8%08,0!

7%%7$)108%!%#!%)0*&!10<*7!#2R0$%!#'!$)#*$0![<$"%.3&P..#&78<!K$31.)%/(J!*8!%)*,!$7,0\!k!

'78<#1!$#11:8*%*0,!%)7%!M0&0!7+,#!)*S)+.!S08<0&0<!'017+0B!!?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!)0&!

-7&%*$*-7%*#8!*8!F7&*#:,!'78<#1!$#11:8*%*0,J!>7F08!7+,#!)7<!7$$0,,!%#!)*S)0&!

0<:$7%*#8![7,!#'!#:&!*8%0&F*0MJ!,)0!)7<!7$)*0F0<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!E8S+*,)!

K*%0&7%:&0!78<!M7,!M#&T*8S!%#M7&<,!78!C;!*8!%)0!,710!'*0+<\B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!,)0!M7,!

<00-+.!'71*+*7&!M*%)!F7&*#:,!$&*%*$7+!,#$*7+!%)0#&*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-#,%`,%&:$% : &7+!

'01*8*,%!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!N:<*%)!=:%+0&!78<!$&*%*$7+!&7$0!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!20++!)##T,J!2#%)!#'!

M)#1!,)0!&0'0&08$0<!%)&#:S)#:%!#:&!*8%0&F*0MB!!!

?!,:SS0,%!%)7%!%)*,!)0+-,!0W-+7*8!M).!,)0!M7,!<&7M8!%#!S7%)0&*8S!)0&2,!78<!

$#++0$%*8S!2:%%0&'+*0,!*8!<7)3"@!78<!M).!,)0!M7,!,#!<0'08,*F0!#'!%)*,!-&7$%*$0B!!P%)0&!

cf!

0+0108%,!#'!<7)3"@U(!S710!<0,*S8J!+*T0!'*S)%*8SJ!$78!20!V:*%0!<0178<*8S!#'!-+7.0&,J!

&0V:*&*8S!2#%)!-&0$*,*#8!78<!V:*$T!&0'+0W0,B!! > 7F08!'&0V:08%+.!<0&*<0<!)0&,0+'!7,!78!

:8,T*++0<!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&![7+%)#:S)J!)7F*8S!M*%80,,0<!)0&!-+7.J!?!M#:+<!,7.!%)7%!

,)0!*,!V:*%0!,T*++0<\J!78<!7,!,:$)!-7&%*$*-7% *#8! *8!%)0,0!#%)0&!7,-0$%,!#'!<7)3"@!

%&*SS0&0<!)0&!78W*0%*0,!72#:%!)0&!#M8!,0+'!M#&%)B!!9#++0$%*8S!*8S&0<*08%,!78<!

2&0M*8S!-#%*#8,!*,!$#1-7&7%*F0+.!&0+7W*8SJ!)#M0F0&J!,*8$0!%)0,0!0+0108%,!&0V:*&0!

F0&.!+*%%+0!&0'+0W*F0!&07$%*#8!78<!,:''0&!8#!%*10!$#8,%&7*8%,B!!I)*+0!>7F08!M7,!M*++*8S!

%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!,:$)!-&7$%*$0,!17.!20!<*,-7&7S0<!2.!#%)0&,!<0,-*%0!%)0*&!

-#-:+7&*%.!71#8S!#%)0&!S710&,![,)0!8#%0<!%)0!-#-:+7&*%.!#'!$##T*8S!78<!+*'0!

,*1:+7%*#8!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!7,!0F*<08$0!#'!%)*,\J!>7F08!7%%&*2:%0<!%)*,!

<*,-7&7S0108%!8#%!%#!%)0!+7$T!#'!,T*++!%)7%!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!&0V:*&0J!2:%!%#!%)0*&!

7,,#$*7%*#8!M*%)!1*<<+0`$+7,,!M#108U,!+72#&!78<!<#1*878%!$#8,%&:$%*#8,!#'!

'01*8*8*%.B!!?8!>7F08U,!87&&7%*F0!#'!)0&!%7,%0!-&0'0&08$0,J!%)08J!M0!$78!,00!%)0!

$#1-+*$7%0<!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!S08<0&!78<!$+7,,J!7,!S08<0&0<!<*F*,*#8,!#'!

+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0!7,!M0++!7,!7$$0,,!%#!%0$)8#+#S.!,)7-0!#80U,!7$$0,,!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!

F*<0#!S710!$#11:8*%*0,!78<!%)0*&!-&0'0&&0<!,%.+0,!#'!-+7.B!!

! C.!*8%0&F*0M!M*%)!>7F08!)0+-,!:,!,00J!%)08J!%)7%!*'!&0,07&$)0&,!7&0!S#*8S!%#!

<*,$:,,!)#M!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!*8)72*%!-7&%*$:+7&! -#,*%*#8,!M*%)!7!'*0+<J!%)0.!1:,%!7+,#!

7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!%)7%!-#,*%*#8!*,!#F0&<0%0&1*80<B!!L)7%!*,!%#!,7.!%)7%!7!

-0&,#8U,!)72*%:,!*8%0&,0$%,!M*%)!%)0!&0,#:&$0,!78<!&0-0&%#*&0,!+07&80<!'&#1!#%)0&!

'*0+<,!78<!$#11:8*%*0,B!!;,!;8%)#8.!Q*<<08,!)7,!7&S:0<J!%)0!,0+'!*,!17<0!X71*<!7!

-:]]+*8S!<*F0&,*%.!#'!#-%*#8,!78<!-#,,*2*+*%*0,Y![7,!V%<B!*8!/08<0&J!3453J!-B!5a\B!!

I)*+0!Q*<<08,!M7,!,-0$*'*$7++.!&0'0&&*8S!%#!*<08%*%.J!?!<#!8#%!,00!M).!%)0!,710!$#:+<!

cc!

8#%!20!0W%08<0<!%#!)72*%:,B!!L)*,!,001,!7!+#S*$7+!1#F0!$#8,*<0&*8S!%)0!-#,%`

,%&:$%:&7+*,%!'&710M#&T!#'!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!%)7%!?!)7F0!$#8,%&:$%0<!*8!%)*,!$)7-%0&B!!

;,!,%7%0<!72#F0J!$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,!7&0!#'%08!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!#%)0&!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!

78<!<0%0&1*878%,J!78<!7,!,:$)!7!-0&,#8U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!$+7,,!-&#$0,,0,!*,!#'%08!

F7&*72+0!78<!'*+%0&0<!%)&#:S)!%)0*&!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!S08<0&J!&7$0J!,0W:7+*%.!#&!#%)0&!

,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,B!!?8!%)*,!M7.J!-#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!%)0#&*0,!#'!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.!,)7&0!

,#10!#'!%)0!,710!0+0108%,!7,!$&*%*$7+!%)0#&*0,!#'!*<08%*%.![0BSB!A7++J!566h$l!9#:+<&.J!

3444l!Q*+&#.J!344fl!;--*7)J!344c\J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!7,,0&%*#8!%)7%!*<08%*%*0,!7&0!

:8,%72+0J!1:+%*-+0J!78<!-0&'#&17%*F0J!7,!M0++!7,!M*%)!'01*8*,%!%)0#&*0,!#'!

*8%0&,0$%*#87+*%.![9&08,)7MJ!5665\!78<!-#,%`$#+#8*7+!%)0#&*0,!#'!).2&*<*%.![=)72)7J!

344d\B!!!!

A#M0F0&!%)0!*8,*S)%,!78<!F#$72:+7&*0,!-&#F*<0<!2.! -#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!

%)0#&*0,!#'!$+7,,!,:2R0$%*F*%.J!#'!M)*$)!)72*%:,!78<!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!7&0!7!-7&%J!7&0!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!,:*%0<!%#!%)0!V:0,%*#8,!78<!$#8$0&8,!%)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!7<<&0,,0,B!!

;,!M0!)7F0!,008!*8!1.!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!>7F08U,!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!*8!<7)3"@J!)0&!

0W-0&*08$0!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!*,!0120<<0<!*8!87&&7%*F0,!#'!,8#220&.!78<!

*8,0$:&*%.!`!M)7%!/0880%%!78<!9#22![56a3\!)7F0!$7++0<!%)0!X)*<<08!*8R:&*0,!#'!$+7,,Y!

`!7,!M0++!7,!87&&7%*F0,!#'!,:2F0&,*#8J!1#<*'*$7%*#8J!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8B!!?'!M0!7&0!

S#*8S!%#!':++.!7<<&0,,!%)0!$#1-+0W*%.!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!%)08J!M0!1:,%!S*F0!

$+7,,!*%,!<:0B!!A72*%:,!78<!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!#''0&!:,!7!M7.!%#!7<<&0,,!*,,:0,!#'!$+7,,!*8!

S71*8S!0W-0&*08$0,B!!L)*,!*,!0,-0$*7++.!$&:$*7+!%#!1.!$#8$0&8!M*%)!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!78<!%)&*F*8S!20$7:,0!%)&*F*8S![7%!+07,%!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!

S71*8S\!*,!'&0V:08%+.!0W-&0,,0<!*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!-&7$%*$0,!#'!+72#&!78<!

ch!

-&#<:$%*F*%.B!!Z#&!,#10J!7!,08,0!#'!%)&*F*8S!*,!7$)*0F0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!&0$#S8*%*#8!#'!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7,!F7+:72+0!78<!X,0&*#:,BY!!Z#&!#%)0&,J!+*T0!>7F08J!%)&*F*8S!*,!

7$)*0F0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!'&00<#1!%#!S7%)0&!F*&%:7+!2:%%0&'+*0,!*8!-07$0B!!?!20+*0F0!M0!

1:,%!)#+<!2#%)!#'!%)0,0!*<07,!#'!%)&*F*8S!*8!1*8<!*'!M0!7&0!%#!7<<&0,,!%)0!$#1-+0W*%.!

#'!%)&*F*8SU,!-+7$0!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8SB!

ca!

9A;(LE>!d!

CELAP"PKPQD!?!

;99P^@L?@Q!ZP>!9K;//!;@"!/Ee^;K?LD!?@!/^>_ED/!;@"!;99P^@L?@Q!ZP>!

EC=P"?CE@L!?@!";L;!9PKKE9L?P@!!

! C0%)#<,!7&0!':8<7108%7++.!72#:%!%)0!$)#*$0,!#80!17T0,!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!

&0,07&$)B!!I)7%!<*,%*8S:*,)0,!7$7<01*$!&0,07&$)!'&#1!#%)0&!'#&1,!#'!&0,07&$)!*,!8#%!

80$0,,7&*+.!%)0!,%0-,!M0!%7T0!%#!S7%)0&!78<!787+.]0!<7%7B!!>7%)0&J!*%!*,!%)0!&0'+0W*F0!

<*,-#,*%*#8!%)7%!#:&!%&7*8*8S!7,!,#$*7+!,$*08%*,%,!7%%01-%,!%#!$:+%*F7%0B!!I0!7&0!

%&7*80<!%#!8#%!#8+.!17T0!<0$*,*#8,!$#8$0&8*8S!)#M!M0!M*++!$#++0$%!<7%7J!2:%!%#!%)*8T!

72#:%!)#M!%)0,0!<0$*,*#8,!7&0!,)7-0<!2.!#:&!%)0#&0%*$7+!78<!17%0&*7+!$*&$:1,%78$0,!

78<!)#M!%)0,0!<0$*,*#8,J!*8!%:&8J!*8'#&1!%)0!T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!7!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!

$#8,%&:$%,B!!;!<*,,0&%7%*#8!$)7-%0&!<0F#%0<!%#!10%)#<,J!%)08J!,)#:+<!20!1#&0!%)78!7!

,%0-`2.`,%0-!S:*<0!%#!)#M!<7%7!M7,!$#++0$%0<B!!?%!,)#:+<!7+,#!<#$:108%!%)0!7:%)#&U,!

#8S#*8S!&0'+0$%*#8!#8!%)0!$)#*$0,!17<0!78<!%)0!+*80,!#'!*8V:*&.!-:&,:0<!7,!M0++!7,!

%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!:8<0&!M)*$)!%)#,0!$)#*$0,!M0&0!17<0B!!?%!,)#:+<!20!)#80,%!78<!

):12+0!72#:%!%)0!2#:8<7&*0,!*1-#,0<!:-#8!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!2.!%)0!7:%)#&U,!

<0$*,*#8,!72#:%!M)7%!T*8<,!#'!<7%7!%#!$#++ 0$%!78<!)#M!%#!$#++0$%!%)7%!<7%7B!!(0&)7-,!

1#,%!*1-#&%78%+.J!%)#:S)J!*%!,)#:+<!S*F0!%)0!,%:<.U,!7:<*08$0!,#10!<0S&00!#'!

$#1'#&%!%)7%!%)0!7:%)#&U,!10%)#<#+#S*$7+!<0$*,*#8,!M0&0!$7-72+0!#'!-&#<:$*8S!

1078*8S':+!<7%7B!!L)*,!,%:<.!<0-+#.0<!%M#!-&*17&.!10%)#<,!%#!$#++0$%!<7%7B!!L)0!

'*&,%!M7,!7!V:7+*%7%*F0!,:&F0.!%)7%!S7%)0&0<!*8'#&17%*#8!#8!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

27$TS&#:8<J!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!-0&,-0$%*F0,!#8!%)&*F*8S!78<!,0+'`$7&0B!!L)0!

,0$#8<!10%)#<!M7,!7!).2&*<!F*<0#!S710!#2,0&F7%*#8o%0W%:7+!787+.,*,!<0,*S80<!%#!

ci!

#2,0&F0!)#M!-7&%*$*-78%,!$#8,%&:$%0<!7!F*<0#!S710!%0W%!78<!%)0!1078*8S,!%)7%!

$#:+<!20!-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!%)7%!-&7$%*$0B!!L)*,!$)7-%0&!'#$:,0,!#8!1.!<0$*,*#8!%#!:,0!

7!V:7+*%7%*F0!,:&F0.J!M)*$)!M*++!*8F#+F0!<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!,:2R0$%,!M0&0!&0$&:*%0<J!%)0!

7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!%)*,!10%)#<J!78<!%)0!$#8%0W%!*8!M)*$)!%)*,!10%)#<!

M7,!$)#,08!78<!<0-+#.0<B!!

Participant!Recruitment!!

L)0!-&*17&.!<7%7!,0%!?!:,0<!%#!787+.]0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!78<!

)#M!%)0.!<0'*80<!%0&1,!+*T0!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!M7,!$&07%0<!:,*8S!7!V:7+*%7%*F0!

,:&F0.!?!<0,*S80<!78<!a4!-7&%*$*-78%,!$#1-+0%0<B!!=0'#&0!?!$78!<*,$:,,!%)0!

7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!,-0$*'*$!*8,%&:108%,!:,0<!%#!$#++0$%!<7%7!'&#1!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!M*++!'*&,%!$#8,*<0&!)#M!&0,07&$)!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!&0$&:*%0<!'#&!%)*,!

,%:<.B!!L)*,!80$0,,*%7%0,!0W71*8*8S!8#%!#8+.!%)0!,-0$*'*$!M7.,!%)7%!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!

$)#,08J!2:%!7+,#!)#M!?!$)#,0!%#!<0'*80!$0&%7*8!*8<*F*<:7+,!7,!&0+0F78%!%#!1.!,%:<.!

78<!)#M!?!,:2,0V:08%+.!*8F*%0<!%)0,0!*8<*F*<:7+,!%#!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!1.!,%:<.B!!

?!*8*%*7++.!<0,$&*20<!1.!*<07+!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!X-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,Y!

78<!8#%J!7,!17.!20!%&7<*%*#87++.!<#80J!XS710&,Y!#&!X%)0!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0BY!Z#&!

178.J!%)0!%0&1!XS710&Y!78<!%)0!-)&7,0!X-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,Y!7&0!

*8%0&$)78S072+0B!!?8!-&7$%*$0J!)#M0F0&J!XS710&Y!*,!%)0!,:2R0$%!#'!1:$)!<027%0!M*%)*8!

F*<0#!S710!$#11:8*%*0,J!7,!2#%)!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!,00T!%#!<0'*80!78<!

<0+*1*%!M)#!X$#:8%,Y!7,!7!S710&B!;,!/)7M![3453\!)7,!8#%0<J!%)#:S)J!1:$)!#'!%)*,!

<027%0!&0+*0,!:-#8!%)0!*8<:,%&.U,!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!%)0!X)7&<$#&0!S710&Y!7,!%)0!*<07+!

17&T0%![-B!d5\B!L)*,!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!%)0!X)7&<$#&0!S710&Y!#'%08!&0,012+0,!%)0!

,%0&0#%.-0,!#'!S710&,!'&0V:08%+.!'#:8<!*8!F7&*#:,![8#8`F*<0#`S710`&0+7%0<\!10<*7B!!

c6!

N::+![3454\!<0,$&*20,!%)0!)7&<$#&0!S710&!,%0&0#%.-0!7,!,#10#80!XM)#!)7,!7!

-&0'0&08$0!'#&!,$*08$0!'*$%*#8J!]#12*0,J!78<!'78%7,.!'*$%*#8,J!)7,!-+7.0<!7!+7&S0!

8:120&!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!M*++!*8F0,%!+7&S0!71#:8%,!#'!%*10!78<!&0,#:&$0,!%#M7&<!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!78<!08R#.,!<*''*$:+%!S710,Y![-B!i\B!!;<<*%*#87++.J!%)*,!)7&<$#&0!

S710&!*,!'&0V:08%+.!&0-&0,08%0<!7,!7!.#:8SJ!M)*%0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+!17+0!M)#!*,!

,#$*7++.!*,#+7%0<J!:80<:$7%0<J!78<!2.!78<!+7 &S0! :8,:$$0,,':+!*8!2#%)!)*,!-:2+*$!78<!

-&*F7%0!+*'0B!L)0!)7&<$#&0!S710&!*,!#'%08!'&0V:08%+.!$#8%&7,%0<!M*%)!%)0!X$7,:7+!

S710&Y!M)#J!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!)7F*8S!7!X-&0'0&08$0!'#&!-#,*%*F0!78<!-+07,78%!'*$%*#8,J!

u-+7.*8Sv!'0M!F*<0#!S710,J!u$#11*%%*8Sv!+*%%+0!%*10!78<!'0M!&0,#:&$0,!%#M7&<!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!78<!u<*,+*T*8Sv!F*<0#!S710,Y![N::+J!3454J!-B!i\J!*,!#'%08!

&0-&0,08%0<!7,!'017+0B!!

C.!S#7+!*8!&0'0&08$*8S!%)0,0!,%0&0#%.-0,!*,!8#%!%#!X<*,-&#F0Y!%)01B!/%:<.!

7'%0&!,%:<.J!*8!%)0!F*<0#!S710!*8<:,%&.!78<!*8!7$7<01*7J!)7,!'#:8<!%)7%!%)0!

,%0&0#%.-0,!#'!%)0!)7&<$#&0!S710&!78<!%)0!$7,:7+!S710&!'7*+!%#!+*F0!:-!%#!%)0*&!

$+7*1,!%#!&0-&0,08%!X-0#-+0!M)#!-+7.!S710,Y!7%!7+1#,%!0F0&.!+0F0+![0BSB!9&7M'#&<J!

3453l!K*'0$#:&,0!;,,#$*7%0,J!345f\B!!I)7%!?!M7,!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!M0&0!%)0!M7.,!*8!

M)*$)!)7*+*8S!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!XS710&,Y!M#:+<!87&&#M!%)0!&78S0!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!?!

$#:+<!&0$&:*%!'#&!1.!,%:<.J!,#!1:$)!,#!%)7%!?!M#:+<!20!:872+0!%#!7<<&0,,!1.!

&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,!,:''*$*08%+.B!!L)0!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!%)*,!-&#R0$%!*,!$#8$0&80<!

M*%)!<#!8#%!807%+.!$#&&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%.-*$7++.!7,,#$*7%0<!M*%)!

)7&<$#&0!#&!$7,:7+!XS710&,BY!!;+,#J!7,!/)7M![3453\!)7,!8#%0<J!%)0&0!17.!20!

$#&&0+7%*#8,!20%M008!7!XS710&Y!*<08%*%.!78<!#%)0&!*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&*0,!%)7%!$#:+<!

,)7-0!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!7!-0&,#8!$)##,0,!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&B!!?8!)0&!V:7+*%7%*F0!

h4!

,%:<.!#'!S710&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!108!M0&0!1:$)!1#&0!+*T0+.!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!

S710&,!%)78!M#108B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!/)7M!'#:8<!%)7%!%)0!80S7%*F0!$#88#%7%*#8,!

7,,#$*7%0<!M*%)!%)0!$7%0S#&.!#'!S710&!78<!M*%)!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!S71*8S!1#&0!

S080&7++.!M0&0!&0+0F78%!*8!,)7-*8S!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!-0#-+0!*<08%*'*0<!7,!S710&,B!!!

C.!'07&J!%)08J!M7,!%)7%!2.!*8*%*7++.!-&0,08%*8S!%)*,!7,!7!,%:<.!#'!XS710&,JY!?!

M#:+<!20!<08.*8S!1.,0+'!7$$0,,!%#!+7&S0!$#11:8*%*0,!#'!-0#-+0!M)#J!'#&!7!F7&*0%.!#'!

&07,#8,J!17.!8#%!*<08%*'.!7,!XS710&,BY!!>0$08%!0F08%,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!XQ710&Q7%0Y!

$#8%&#F0&,.J!)7F0!#8+.!)0*S)%080<!%)*,!'07&J!7,!108!$+7*1*8S!%#!&0-&0,08%!XS710&,Y!

)7F0!,.,%017%*$7++.!%7&S0%0<!78<!)7&7,,0<!M#108!78<!#%)0&!17&S*87+*]0<!S&#:-,!

20$7:,0!#'!%)0*&!<0178<,!'#&!*8$+:,*F*%.!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S71*8SB!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!*%!

M#:+<!)7F0!2008!-&#2+017%*$!%#!)7*+!,#10!$#11:8*%*0,!7,!XS710&,Y!M)08!%)0!%0&1!

XS710&Y!*,!7!%0&1!'&0V:08%+.!<0-+#.0<!2.!S&#:-,!78<!*8<*F*<:7+,!M)#!72:,0!78<!

)7&7,,!%)01B!

Z#&!%)*,!&07,#8J!?!M7,!$7&0':+!%#!&0'0&!%#!1.!-#%08%*7+!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!X-0#-+0!

M)#!-+7.!S710,Y!&7%)0&!%)78!XS710&,BY!!?!7+,#!*8%08%*#87++.!0W$+:<0<!78.!&0'0&08$0,!

%#!#%)0&!*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&*0,!*8!1.!&0$&:*%108%!17%0&*7+,!,#!7,!8#%!%#!&0*8%&#<:$0!

)0S01#8*$!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!S710&!*<08%*%.!%)&#:S)!%)0!27$T<##&B!!?8,%07<J!?!7,T0<!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*8!%)0!,:&F0.!*%,0+'!)#M!%)0.!*<08%*'*0<B!!I)*+0!?!<*<!7,T!-7&%*$*-78%,!

)#M!%)0.!*<08%*'*0<!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!0W-+*$*%!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!&7$0J!S08<0&J!78<!

,0W:7+*%.J!?!17<0!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#-08`08<0<!78<!08$#:&7S0<!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!:,0!%)0!

%0&1,!78<!$7%0S#&*0,!%)7%!%)0.!M0&0!1#,%!$#1'#&%72+0!M*%)B!

L)*,!,%&7%0S.!$#&&0,-#8<0<!20%%0&!M*%)!%)0!-#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!%)0#&*0,!#'!

*<08%*%.!%)7%!7&0!<0-+#.0<!M*%)*8!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!2.!<&7M*8S!7%%08% *#8!% #!% )0!

h5!

-&#$0,,!#'!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!78<!7$T8#M+0<S*8S!%)0!&#+0!%)7%!*8<*F*<:7+,!-+7.!*8!%)*,!

-&#$0,,B!!/%:7&%!A7++![566h\!7&S:0,!%)7%!7%%08%*#8!%#!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!

'#&$0,!:,!%#!%7T0!*8%#!7$$#:8%!8#%!#8+.!)#M!<*,$:&,*F0!'#&17%*#8,!$#8,%&:$%!,-0$*'*$!

,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,!'#&!*8<*F*<:7+,!%#!#$$:-.![%)&#:S)!M)7%!;+%):,,0&!)7,!<0,$&*20<!7,!

X*8%0&-0++7%*#8Y!#&!X)7*+*8SY\J!2:%!7+,#!)#M!,:2R0$%,!&0,-#8<!%#!%)*,!)7*+*8SJ!M)*$)!*,!

80F0&!,1##%)!2:%!#F0&<0%0&1*80<B!!A7++!*8,*,%,!%)7%!X%)0&0!*,!%)0!F3.>6='".#&#'!,0+'!

7,!78!#2R0$%!*8!%)0!M#&+<J!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,0+'`$#8,%*%:%*#8J!&0$#S8*%*#8!78<!

&0'+0$%*#8J!%)0!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!&:+0J!7+#8S,*<0!%)0!,$&:-:+#:,!7%%08%*#8!%#!8#&17%*F0!

&0S:+7%*#8J!78<!%)0!$#8,%&7*8%,!#'!% )0! &:+0,!M*%)#:%!M)*$)!8#!r,:2R0$%*'*$7%*#8U!*,!

-&#<:$0<Y![-B!5d\.!!Z#$:,*8S!#8!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!&7%)0&!%)78!7 !,-0$*'*$!

*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&.!,:$)!7,!XS710&Y!7$T8#M+0<S0,!%)0!&#+0!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!-+7.,!*8!%)0!

-&#$0,,!#'!,0+'`$#8,%*%:%*#8B!?%!7+,#J!7,!/)7M![3453\!7&S:0,J!7++#M,!&0,07&$)0&,!%#!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!X78!*8<*F*<:7+!17.!*<08%*'.!M*%)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!,#$*7+!$7%0S#&*0,![0BSB!

20*8S!7!M#178!78<!K7%*87!78<!2*,0W:7+!78<!7!S710&\J!M*%)#:%!%)0!$&F3".3"&

-&*F*+0S*8S!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$7%0S#&.!7%!%)0!#:%,0%![-B!d4\B!!

/#J!:+%*17%0+.J!)#M!<*<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!$)##,0!%#!*<08%*'.!%)01,0+F0,g!!

>0S7&<*8S!%)0*&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!*<08%*%.!XS710&JY!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

'0+%!$#1'#&%72+0!*<08%*'.*8S!7,!7!XS710&Y!M)08!0W-+*$*%+.!7,T0<!%)0*&!#-*8*#8!#8!%)0!

%0&1B!!A#M0F0&!3c!!#'!%)0!a4!-7&%*$*-78%,!*8!1.!,%:<.!<0$+*80<!%#B!!^8,:&-&*,*8S+.J!

%)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!17R#&*%.!#'!%)#,0!-7&%*$*-78%,![5h\!M0&0!M#108!M)*+0!i!M0&0!

108!78<!5!$)#,0!8#%!%#!*<08%*'.!%)0*&!S08<0&B!!I)7%!M7,!,:&-&*,*8SJ!%)#:S)J!M0&0!

%)0*&!&07,#8,!'#&!&0':,*8S!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!S710&,B!!?!)7<!78%*$*-7%0<!%)7%!M#108!

M#:+<!20!+0,,!+*T0+.!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!S710&,!%)78!108!20$7:,0!#'!%)0!0W$+:,*#87&.!78<!

h3!

1*,#S.8*,%*$!-&7$%*$0,!#'!S710&,J!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!)7F0!20$#10!1#&0!F*,*2+0!78<!

-:2+*$!<:0!%#!%)0!*8'71#:,!Q710&Q7%0!0F08%B!!A#M0F0&J!#8+.!5!M#178!17<0!78.!

&0'0&08$0!%#!%)0!1*,#S.8*,%*$!-&7$%*$0,!#'!S710&,!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!)0&!&0':,7+!%#!

*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&J!M)0&07,!3!108!&0'0&08$0<!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!M)08!R:,%*'.*8S!%)0*&!

&0':,7+!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!S710&,B!!L)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!&07,#8!-7&%*$*-78%,!$*%0<!M)08!

<*,$:,,*8S!%)0*&!&0':,7+!%#!*<08%*'.!7,!S710&,!M7,!1#&0!2787+!78<!+0,,!#F0&%+.!

-#+*%*$7+B!!L)0.!,*1-+.!'0+%!%)7%!%)0.!<*<!8#%!<0F#%0!08#:S)!%*10!#&!080&S.!%#!%)0!

-&7$%*$0!%#!R:,%*'.!$7++*8S!%)01,0+F0,!S710&,B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!#80!-7&%*$*-78%!M&#%0!

%)7%!,)0!<#0,!8#%!*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&!20$7:,0J!X?w1!8#%!M*++*8S!%#!-:%!*8!%)7%!1:$)!

%*10!#&!0''#&%!*8%#!S71*8S!20$7:,0!'#&!10!*%w,!8#%!72#:%!%)0!7$%:7+!S710!'#&!10B!!?w1!

1#&0!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!)7F*8S!':8!M*%)!#%)0&,!78<!$)7++08S*8S!1.,0+'!#8$0!*8!7!M)*+0!

M*%)!*8%0&0,%*8S!$#8$0-%,!78<!*<07,BY!!!

?!M78%!%#!:8-7$T!%)*,!&0,-#8,0!7!2*%!20$7:,0!*%!&0'0&08$0,!78#%)0&!*,,:0!7%!

-+7.!*8!S710&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!%)7%!1:,%!20!7$T8#M+0<S0<B!!;,!?!,%7%0<J!&0,-#8,0,!,:$)!

7,!%)*,!M0&0!1#&0!2787+!78<!+0,,!#F0&%+.!-#+*%*$7+!%)78!0W-0$%0<J!2:%!%)7%!<#0,!8#%!

1078!%)7%!%)0,0!&0,-#8,0,!M0&0!'&00!'&#1!%)0!-#+*%*$,!#'!S710&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!78<!

%)0!1*,#S.8*,%*$!7,,:1-%*#8,!0120<<0<!*8!*%,!*8,%*%:%*#87+!<0'*8*%*#8B!!L)*,!

&0,-#8<08%J!N78*$0J!*8F#T0,!78!*1-+*$*%+.!S08<0&0<!2*87&.!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!%)0!+#S*$!

#'!)#M!,-0$*'*$!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!0*%)0&!7&0!#&!7&0!8#%!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!7!S710&!

*<08%*%.B!!/)0!<0,$&*20,!)0&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7,!X)7F*8S!':8!M*%)!#%)0&,Y!78<!

X$)7++08S*8S!1.,0+'bM*%)!*8%0&0,%*8S!$#8$0-%,!78<!*<07,Y!%#!*++:,%&7%0!M).!,)0!<#0,!

8#%!*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&B!!/)0!$#8%&7,%,!%)*,!M*%)!)0&!*<07!#'!M)7%!7!XS710&Y!*,J!#80!

M)#!*,!0W-+*$*%+.!*8F0,%0<!*8!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,![-0&)7-,!%#!%)0!0W$+:,*#8!#'!

hd!

#%)0&,\B!!/)0!7+,#!*1-+*$*%+.!$#880$%,!XS710&,Y!M*%)!$#1-0%*%*F0!-&7$%*$0,J!7,!

0F*<08$0<!2.!)0&!#M8!,%7%0<!-&0'0&08$0!'#&!$##-0&7%*F0!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,![X)7F*8S!

':8!M*%)!#%)0&,Y\!78<!%)0!$#8$#1*%78%!20+*0'!%)7%!,:$)!7!-&0'0&08$0!<*,V:7+*'*0,!)0&!

'&#1!*<08%*'.*8S!7,!7!XS710&BY!!L)*,!+#S*$!&0'+0$%,!7!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!%&08<!M)0&02.!

M#108!7&0!<*,$#:&7S0<!'&#1!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!$#11:8*%*0,!$08%0&0<!7&#:8<!

%0$)8#+#S.!%)&#:S)!%)0!-0&,*,%08%!10,,7S0!%)7%!%)0,0!$#11:8*%*0,!7&0!8#%!'#&!%)01!

[97,,0++!s!N08T*8,J!5666l!<0!97,%0++!s!=&.,#8J !5666l!Z&#8!0%B!7+BJ!344a7l!Z&#8!0%B!7+BJ!

344a2l!9)0,,J!3455\B!!L)*,!*,!<#80!*8!8:10&#:,!,:2%+0!.0%!80F0&%)0+0,,!-0&F7,*F0!

M7.,B!!;,!%)0!&0,-#8<08%!:8<0&!<*,$:,,*#8!0W01-+*'*0,J!#80!#'!%)0,0!M7.,!*,!%)&#:S)!

%)0!20+*0'!%)7%!$0&%7*8!)*S)+.!S08<0&0<!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!'01*8*80`S08<0&0<!

$##-0&7%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!1.!&0,-#8<08%!108%*#8,J!7&0!8#%!M0+$#10!*8!%)0,0!,-7$0,B!!?%!

<#0,!8#%!17%%0&!%)7%!%)*,!*,!#2R0$%*F0+.!'7+,0!k!8:10&#:,!S710,!#8!0F0&.!-+7%'#&1!

0*%)0&!)07F*+.!'07%:&0!$##-0&7%*F0!1#<0,!#'!-+7.!#&!*8$+:<0!,*8S+0!-+7.0&!1#<0,!

M)0&0!.#:!#8+.!$#1-0%0!7S7*8,%!7!-&0`-&#S&7110<!7&%*'*$*7+!*8%0++*S08$0B!!

9#1-0%*%*#8!*,!#8+.!#80!1#<0!#'!*8%0&7$%*8S!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,!78<!M*%)!#%)0&!

-+7.0&,!%)&#:S)!F*<0#!S710,B!!D0%!80F0&%)0+0,,!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!20%M008!17,$:+*80`

S08<0&0<!$#1-0%*%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!F*<0#!S710,!&017*8,!-&#1*808%!*8!-#-:+7&!

$#8$0-%*#8,!#'!S710&!*<08%*%.!78<!*,!&0*8'#&$0<!%)&#:S)!,0F0&7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,J!

*8$+:<*8S!F*<0#!S710!7<F0&%*,*8S!78<!08%):,*7,%!R#:&87+*,1J!%)7%!$7%0&!%#!78<!

&0*8'#&$0!%)*,!87&&#M!<0'*8*%*#8B!!/:$)!1*,#S.8*,%*$!'#&$0,!*1-+*$*%+.!<*,$#:&7S0!

M#108!'&#1!*<08%*'.*8S!7,!S710&,!78<!1:,%!20!7$T8#M+0<S0<!0F08!M)08!M#108!

<#!8#%!0W-+*$*%+.!8710!%)01B!!!!!!

hf!

?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0!-0&$0-%*#8!#'!7!+7$T!#'!7$$#11#<7%*#8!'#&!%)0*&!-&0'0&&0<!

-+7.!,%.+0,J!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!$*%0<!%)7%!%)0.!-&0'0&!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,!%#!S71*8SJ!,:$)!

7,!&07<*8S!#&!M7%$)*8S!,-#&%,J!M)08!<0,$&*2*8S!M).!%)0.!<#!8#%!*<08%*'.!7,!S710&,B!!

/*1*+7&+.J!#%)0&,!M&#%0!%)7%!S710&,!7&0!-&*17&*+.!<0'*80<!2.!7!-7,,*#8!'#&!%)0!

10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!7!-7,,*#8!%)0.!<#!8#%!,)7&0B!!;++!#'!%)0,0!&07,#8,!&0*8'#&$0!7!

$#8$+:,*#8!%)7%!/)7M![3453\!<&0M!'&#1!)0&!,%:<.!#8!S710&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!-&#$0,,0,!

k!%)7%!S710&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!*,!8#%!R:,%!,)7-0<!2.!#80U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!

*8,%*%:%*#87+!*<08%*%.!#'!S710&!2:%!7+,#!78!*8<*F*<:7+U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!#%)0&!

*<08%*%*0,J!$#8%0W%,J!78<!%)0!10<*:1!#'!S710,!*%,0+'![-B!f4\B!!?%!7+,#!01-)7,*]0,!

78#%)0&!-#*8%!%)7%!/)7M![3453\!17T0,!*8!)0&!,%:<.!#8!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!S710&!

*<08%*'*$7%*#8!k!%)7%!)#M!-7&%*$*-78%,!X*<08%*'.!%)01,0+F0,b1:,%!20!:8<0&,%##<!7,!7!

-7&%*$:+7&J!1#108%7&.!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!)#M!%)0.!F*0M!%)01,0+F0,!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!M)7%!

%)0.!20+*0F0!*,!%)0!-:&-#,0!#'!%)0!,%:<.Y![-B!d3\B!!?%!*,!7+,#!#8+.!7!-7&%*$:+7&J!

1#108%7&.!7&%*$:+7%*#8!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!M)7%!%)0.!20+*0F0!7!XS710&Y!%#!20B!!;,!#80!#'!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!0W-+7*80<J!Xu"0'*8*8S!M)#!7!S710&!*,v!*,!7!2*%!%&*$T.!20$7:,0!%)0!

<0'*8*%*#8!,001,!%#!)7F0!$)78S0<!V:*%0!7!2*%!#F0&!%)0!.07&,B!!!P8$0!:-#8!7!%*10J!7!

S710&!M7,!,*1-+.!,#10#80!M)#!-+7.0<!78<!08R#.0<!F*<0#!S710,B!=:%!8#M!%)7%!

1#,%!#'!%)0!-#-:+7%*#8!08R#.,!-+7.*8S!,#10!'#&1!#'!F*<0#!S710J!%)0!%0&1!)7,!

$)78S0<!%#!&0'+0$%!7!,17++0&!,:2,0%!#'!-+7.0&,BY!!/*1*+7&+.J!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!,%7%0<!

%)7%!%)0.!17.!)7F0!$#8,*<0&0<!%)01,0+F0,!S710&,!7%!#80!-#*8%!*8!%)0*&!+*F0,J!2:%!

$:&&08%!$*&$:1,%78$0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!*8$&07,0<!<0178<,!#'!M#&T!78<!'71*+.J!

-&#)*2*%0<!%)01!'&#1!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!

hc!

L:&8*8S!7M7.!'&#1!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!7!S710&!*<08%*%.J!)#M!

0+,0!<*<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!$)##,0!%#!*<08%*'.!%)01,0+F0,g!!^8,:&-&*,*8S+.J!-7&%*$*-78%,!

'&0V:08%+.!*8F#T0<!<#1*878%!*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&*0,!,:$)!7,!S08<0&J!&7$0J!78<!,0W:7+*%.!

%#!,%&:$%:&0!%)0*&!&0,-#8,0,B!!!I*%)!&0S7&<,!%#!S08<0&!*<08%*%.J!3h!-7&%*$*-78%,!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!17+0!78<!di!-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!'017+0B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!d!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!%&78,S08<0&0<J!S08<0&'+:*<J!#&!S08<0&V:00&J!M)*+0!78#%)0&!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!8#8`2*87&.!M*%)!%)0!-&#F*,*#8!%)7%!%)*,!*<08%*%.!*,!$#8%*8S08%!:-#8!

%)0*&!-#+*%*$7+!S#7+,!7%!%)0!%*10B!!L:&8*8S!%#!&7$0J!fi!-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!I)*%0!

#&!97:$7,*78J!a!-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!=*&7$*7+!#&!C:+%*`&7$*7+J!a!-7&%*$*-78%,!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!;,*78J!d!-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!A*,-78*$!#&!K7%*8WJ!78<!5!-7&%*$*-78%!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!@7%*F0!;10&*$78B!!Z*87++.J!M*%)!&0S7&<,!%#!,0W:7+*%.J!di!-7&%*$*-78%,!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!/%&7*S)%!#&!A0%0&#,0W:7+J!5d!-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!=*,0W:7+J!i!

*<08%*'*0<!7,!j:00&!#&!(78,0W:7+J!78<!d!*<08%*'*0<!7,!Q7.!#&!K0,2*78B!!L)0,0!'*8<*8S,!

7&0!,:117&*]0<!*8!%)0!%72+0!%)7%!'#++#M,B!

L72+0!5G!(7&%*$*-78%!<01#S&7-)*$,!2.!S08<0&J!&7$0J!78<!,0W:7+*%.!

By!gender!

Z017+0!

di!

C7+0!

3h!

P%)0&![%&78,S08<0&0<J!8#8`

2*87&.J!0%$B\!

By!race!

I)*%0o97:$7,*78!

fi!

;,*78!

A*,-78*$oK7%*8W!

@7%*F0!;10&*$78!

=*`&7$*7+oC:+%*`&7$*7+!

By!sexuality!

/%&7*S)%oA0%0&#,0W:7+!

di!

=*,0W:7+!

5d!

j:00&o(78,0W:7+!

Q7.!#&!K0,2*78!

hh!

Class!Identification!and!Class!Culture!

!!!

9+7,,J!M)*$)!7,!?!<*,$:,,0<!*8!1.!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!*,!7!,*S8*'*$78%!

*8%0&-&0%*F0!'&710!'#&!1.!,%:<.J!M7,!7!1#&0!$#1-+*$7%0<!*<08%*%.!%#!<0%0&1*80!78<!

*,!M#&%).!#'!7!1#&0!*8`<0-%)!0W71*87%*#8B!!9&:$*7++.J!?!*8F*%0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!

<*,$:,,!%)0*&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!$+7,,!F0&.!<*''0&08%+.!%)78!%#!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!

<*''0&08$0B!!I)0&07,!?!:,0<!#80!V:0,%*#8!%#!<*&0$%+.!7,T!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!)#M!%)0.!

*<08%*'*0<!2&#7<+.J!M)0&0*8!%)0.!%.-*$7++.!*8F#T0<!%)0!<#1*878%!*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&*0,!

<*,$:,,0<!72#F0J!?!*8F*%0<!%)01!%#!<*,$:,,!%)0*&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!$+7,,!1#&0!#2+*V:0+.!

78<!7$&#,,!1:+%*-+0!V:0,%*#8,B!!?!$)#,0!%)*,!,%&7%0S.!'#&!,0F0&7+!&07,#8,J!7++!#'!M)*$)!

<0,0&F0!0+72#&7%*#8B!

! P80!'7$%#&!%)7%!*8'+:08$0<!%)*,!<0$*,*#8!M7,!1.!$#8$0&8!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

M#:+<!8#%!)7F0!%)0!,710!'+:08$.!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!$+7,,!%)7%!%)0.!M#:+<!)7F0!M)08!

<*,$:,,*8S!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!<*''0&08$0B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!?!%)#:S)%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!M#:+<!8#%!)7F0!78!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!$+7,,!k!%)0.!72,#+:%0+.!<#B!!>7%)0&J!

?!7,,:10<!%)7%J!,*8$0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M#:+<!20!-&0<#1*878%+.![%)#:S)!8#%!

0W$+:,*F0+.\!;10&*$78J!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!<*''0&08$0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!&7$0!78<!S08<0&J!

M#:+<!20!1#&0!,7+*08%!78<!,0+'`0F*<08%!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)78!$+7,,!M#:+<!20B!!;,!7!

&0,:+%J!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!M#:+<!#F0&-#M0&! $+ 7,,!78<!%)&07%08!%#!

<*,-+7$0!$+7,,!7,!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!-&*17&.!0W-+787%#&.!-&*8$*-+0!'#&!%)0*&!-&7$%*$0,B!!

L)*,!7,,:1-%*#8!M7,!2#&80!'&#1!-&0F*#:,!&0,07&$)!#8!$+7,,!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!

-&#$0,,0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!/)0&&.!=B!P&%80&U,![344d\!Q/N&S/3(/)&B3/$@"#1J!M)*$)!

M&0,%+0<!M*%)!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!&7$0J!0%)8*$*%.J!78<!$+7,,B!!?8!%)*,!,%:<.J!

M)*$)!20S78!7,!78!*8F0,%*S7%*#8!#'!$+7,,!*<08%*%.J!P&%80&!'#:8<!%)7%!)0&!&0,07&$)!

ha!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*8,*,%0<!#8!%)0!$08%&7+*%.!#'!%)0*&!0%)8*$*%.!<0,-*%0!P&%80&U,!7%%01-%,!%#!

,%00&!%)0!$#8F0&,7%*#8!%#M7&<,!$+7,,B!!!

L)*,!+07<!P&%80&!%#!$#8$+:<0!%)7%J!M)*+0!$+7,,!78<!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!

<*''0&08$0!7&0!787+.%*$7++.!<*,%*8$%J!%)0.!7&0!,#!1:%:7++.!*1-+*$7%0<!*8!%)0!;10&*$78!

$#8%0W%!%)7%!*%!*,!80*%)0&!-#,,*2+0!8#&!<0,*&72+0!%#!-:++!%)01!7-7&%![-B!ad\B!!;!

&07,#872+0!7:<*08$0!10120&!1*S)%!%)08!7,TJ!XI0++!%)08!M).!<*<!%)0!7:%)#&!#'!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!,0-7&7%0!$+7,,!'&#1!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!*8!)*,!,:&F0.g!!"#0,!

%)*,!8#%!&0*8'#&$0!%)0!*<07!%)7%!$+7,,!$78!20!,#10)#M!-:++0<!7-7&%!'&#1!%)0,0!#%)0&!

$7%0S#&*0,gY!!C.!78,M0&!%#!%)*,!+*0,!*8!%)0!-&0,,:&0,!#'!&0,07&$)!78<!%)0!'7$%!%)7%!7++!

&0,07&$)!*,!,*%:7%0<!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%0W%B!!":0!%#!%)0!$#8,%&7*8%,!*1-#,0<!:-#8!10!

2.!1.!)07+%)!78<!0$#8#1*$!&0,#:&$0,![M)*$)!?!M*++!<*,$:,,!*8!1#&0!<0%7*+!20+#M\J!?!

M7,!$#11*%%0<!%#!:,*8S!,:&F0.,!%#!S7%)0&!<7%7!&7%)0&!%)78!#%)0&!10%)#<#+#S*0,!

<0-+#.0<!2.!,%:<*0,!,*1*+7&!*8!,:2R0$%!78<!,$#-0J!,:$)!7,!*8%0&F*0M,!#&!-7&%*$*-78%!

#2,0&F7%*#8B!!/:&F0.,!<*''0&!'&#1!%)0,0!#%)0&!10%)#<,!-&*17&*+.!*8!%)0!71#:8%!#'!

*8%0&7$%*#8!%)0.!7++#M!20%M008!&0,07&$)0&!78<!&0,-#8<08%B!L)0!%01-#&7+*%.!#'!

*8%0&F*0M,!78<!-7&%*$*-78%!#2,0&F7%*#8!$&07%0!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!'#&!7!<*7+#S:0!%#!

010&S0!20%M008!&0,07&$)0&!78<!-7&%*$*-78%!7,!2#%)!1:,%!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!

*8!&07+!%*10B!!I)*+0!%)0!%#-*$,!<*,$:,,0<!$78!20J!78<!#'%08!7&0J!*8*%*7++.!<0%0&1*80<!

2.!%)0!&0,07&$)0&J!%)0!<*7+#S*$!87%:&0!#'!%)0,0!10%)#<#+#S*0,!$&07%0,!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!

'#&!%)0!010&S08$0!#'!%#-*$,!:878%*$*-7%0<!2.!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!%)7%!$78!%)08!20!

-:&,:0<!1#&0!<00-+.!,)#:+<!2#%)!*8%0&+#$:%#&,!$#8,08%B!!L)*,!*,!-&0$*,0+.!M)7%!

)7--080<!%#!P&%80&![344d\!M)*+0!$#8<:$%*8S!*8%0&F*0M,!'#&!)0&!Q/N&S/3(/)&

B3/$@"#1!-&#R0$%B!!;,!P&%80&!<0,$&*20,!*%J!,)0!*8*%*7++.!<0'*80<!%)0!-&#R0$%!*8!%0&1,!#'!

hi!

$+7,,!*,,:0,J!M)*$)!,)0!M78%0<!%#!2&*8S!1#&0!,%&#8S+.!%#!%)0!'#&0'&#8%!#'!

0%)8#S&7-)*$!78<!78%)&#-#+#S*$7+!&0,07&$)B!!A#M0F0&J!*%!M7,!)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

-0&,*,%08%!<0%0&1*87%*#8!%#!'#&0S&#:8<!%)0*&!0%)8*$!*<08%*%*0,!7,!%)0!0W-+787%#&.!

-&*8$*-+0!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!<*F*,*#8,!*8!%)0*&!$#11:8*%.!%)7%!$#8F*8$0<!P&%80&!#'!%)0!

*8%0&&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!&7$0J!0%)8*$*%.J!78<!$+7,,!7%!%)0!+0F0+!#'!<*,$#:&,0J!78<!%)7%!

%)0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!#80!*,!'&0V:08%+.!X)*<<08Y!M*%)*8!%)0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!78#%)0&![-B!h6\B!!

C.!<0$*,*#8!%#!:,0!,:&F0.,J!%)#:S)J!87%:&7++.!'#&0$+#,0<!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!?!$#:+<!

7++#M!$+7,,!*,,:0,!%#!010&S0!*8<*&0$%+.!%)&#:S)!%)0!:,0!#'!<*7+#S:0B!!;,!,:$)J!%#!

-&0F08%!*,,:0,!#'!$+7,,!'&#1!S0%%*8S!+#,%!*8!%)0!1*WJ!?!<0$*<0<!%#!,0-7&7%0!#:%!

V:0,%*#8,!#'!$+7,,!'&#1!%)0!#%)0&J!2&#7<0&!V:0,%*#8!#'!)#M!7!-7&%*$*-78%!*<08%*'*0,B!

L)*,!*,!#80!#'!%)0!2080'*%,!#'!7!,:&F0.!`!*%!7++#M,!&0,07&$)0&,!%#!1#&0!

0''*$*08%+.!S7%)0&!<7%7!&0+7%0<!%#!%)0*&!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,!%)&#:S)!%)0!:,0!#'!<*&0$%!

V:0,%*#8,B!!A#M0F0&J!7!$7,:7+!S+78$0!7%!1.!,:&F0.![-&#F*<0<!*8!;--08<*W!;\!M#:+<!

+07<!7!&07<0&!%#!8#%*$0!%)7%!?!<*<!8#%J!7$%:7++.J!7,T!7!<*&0$%!V:0,%*#8!72#:%!)#M!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'.!%)01,0+F0,!*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!$7%0S#&.!#'!$+7,,B!!A0&0!M0!

&:8!*8%#!7!'0M!#%)0&!$#1-+*$7%*#8,!%)7%!7!,:&F0.!<0,*S80<!%#!7,,0,,!7!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

$+7,,!*<08%*'*$7%*#8!1:,%!7$$#:8%!'#&B!!P80!#'!%)0,0!*,!%)7%J!7,!8#%0<!72#F0J!)#M!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*<08%*'.!%)01,0+F0,!<:&*8S!7!&0,07&$)!08$#:8%0&!*,!7!X-7&%*$:+7&J!

1#108%7&.!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!)#M!%)0.!F*0M!%)01,0+F0,!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!,%:<.Y!

[/)7MJ!3453,!-B!d3\B!!L)*,!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-&#2+017%*$!M)08!7,T*8S!72#:%!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!*<08%*'*$7%*#8,!*8!7!,:&F0.J!,*8$0!$+7,,!<*''0&,!'&#1!#%)0&!,*S8*'*0&,!

+*T0!&7$0!78<!S08<0&!*8!%)7%!*%!<#0,!8#%!#'%08!17&T!7!-0&,#8!*80,$7-72+.![Z0+,T*J!

3444J!-B!di\B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!#%)0&!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!7&0!,%72+0!78<!

h6!

$#)0&08%J!10&0+.!%)7%!$+7,,!*,!'&0V:08%+.!:8<0&,%##<!2.!-0#-+0!7,!'+:*<!78<!1#2*+0J!

M)0&07,!%)0&0!*,!,%*++!$#8%&#F0&,.!#F0&!%)0!*8<0%0&1*87$.!#'!#%)0&!*<08%*'*$7%*#8,B!!

;8.!7%%01-%!%#!$7-%:&0!7!-0&,#8U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!$+7,,!2.!<*&0$%+.!7,T*8S!%)01!M)7%!

%)0*&!$+7,,!*,!-#%08%*7++.!'*W0,!M)7%!*,!*8!7$%:7+*%.!7!1#F*8S!%7&S0%J!&08<0&*8S!*%!

<*''*$:+%!%#!:8<0&,%78<!%)0!<*''0&08%!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!7!-0&,#8!7+1#,%!*80F*%72+.!1#F0,!

%)&#:S)!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)0*&!+*'0B!!L)0,0!#%)0&!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!+07F0!7!<:&72+0!

*1-&0,,*#8!#8!7!-0&,#8U,!20+*0',!78<!20)7F*#&,J!7,!=#:&<*0:U,!$#8$0-%!#'!2$;"'6(!

#&*08%,!:,!%#M7&<,B!!!

?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0!-&#2+01!#'!X'*W*8SY!%)0!1#F*8S!%7&S0%!#'!$+7,,!78<!%)0&02.!

-&0F08%*8S!7!&0,07&$)0&!'&#1!%7T*8S!8#%0!#'!%)0!F7&*#:,!$+7,,`<0'*80<!,#$*7+!

+#$7%*#8,!%)7%!,)7-0!7!-0&,#8U,!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!M#&+<J!78#%)0&!'07%:&0!#'!$+7,,!

%)7%!-&0,08%,!7!):&<+0!M)08!7%%01-%*8S!%#!<*&0$%+.!*8V:*&0!72#:%!$+7,,!*,!%)0!

,%&:$%:&0!#'!'00+*8S!-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!$+7,,!1#2*+*%.B!!Z0+,T*![3444\!7&S:0,!%)7%!

,)710!*,!787+.%*$7++.!*1-#&%78%!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!$+7,,!1#2*+*%.!7,!*%!*,!#80!#'!%)0!

<#1*878%!'00+*8S,!-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!$+7,,!1#2*+*%.B!!C#F0108%!:-!#&!

<#M8!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!%08<,!%#!*8$:+$7%0!'00+*8S,!#'!,)710!*8!-0#-+0!7,!%)0.!7&0!

%7:S)%!%#!'00+!0127&&7,,0<!72#:%!0*%)0&!M)0&0!%)0.!)7F0!$#10!'&#1!#&!M)0&0!%)0.!

7&0!S#*8SB!!?8!%)0!$7,0!#'!$0&%7*8!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!+*T0!%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,![%#!M)*$)!

178.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!0*%)0&!20+#8S!#&!)7F0!20+#8S0<!7%!,#10!-#*8%!*8!%)0*&!+*F0,\J!

%)0,0!'00+*8S,!#'!,)710!7&0!*8%08,*'*0<!7,!%)0!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8!*%,0+'!)7,!)*,%#&*$7++.!

2008!78!#2R0$%!#'!,$#&8![Z0+,T*J!3444J!-B!da\B!!?8!7!&0,07&$)!,*%:7%*#8!M)0&0!'#++#M`:-!

V:0,%*#8,!7&0!-&0$+:<0<J!?!%)#:S)%!%)7%!<*&0$%+.!7,T*8S!'#&!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!

a4!

*<08%*'*$7%*#8,!M#:+<!&0,:+%!*8!807&`:878*1#:,!<0$+7&7%*#8,!#'!20+#8S*8S!%#!%)0!

1*<<+0`$+7,,B!!!

;,!7!&0,:+%!#'!%)0!,-0$*'*$!$)7++08S0,!#'!7,T*8S!72#:%!$+7,,!*<08%*'*$7%*#8,!*8!7!

,:&F0.!$#8%0W%J!?!*8,%07<!7,T0<!V:0,%*#8,!&0+7%0<!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!17&T0&,!#'!$+7,,B!!

L)0,0!V:0,%*#8,!,#+*$*%0<!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!%&7<*%*#87+J!X#2R0$%*F0Y!17&T0&,!#'!$+7,,J!

,:$)!7,!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%U,!0<:$7%*#8!78<!#$$: - 7%*#8!78<!%)0*&!-7&08%,Uo$7&0S*F0&,U!

0<:$7%*#8!78<!#$$:-7%*#8J!7,!M0++!7,!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!%)0!,)7-0!#'!%)0!<*,$:&,*F0!

'*0+<!'&#1!M)*$)!%)0.!<&7M!%)0*&!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!$+7,,B!!?8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!7!

-7&%*$*-78%U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!<*,$:&,*F0J!$:+%:&7+!+0F0+!#'!$+7,,!M7,!S+0780<!'&#1!

V:0,%*#8,!72#:%!%)0*&!%7,%0!*8!F*<0#!S710,!78<!#%)0&!-#-:+7&!10<*7J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0*&!

$7&0S*F0&,U!7%%*%:<0,!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,B!!!

Z:&%)0&1#&0J!M)08!787+.]*8S!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,J!?!&0,*,%0<!%)0!:&S0!%#!

,%&*$%+.!$7%0S#&*]0!%)0*&!$+7,,!*<08%*%.!78<!,#:S)%!*8,%07<!%#!:,0!%)0!17&T0&,!#'!$+7,,!

<*,$:,,0<!%#!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!I)7%!M7,!S7*80<!2.!%)*,!

,%&7%0S.g!!Z#&!#80J!%)*,!,%&7%0S.!&0,*,%,!%)0!*<07!% )7 %!$+7,,!*<08%*%.!78<!2$;"'6(!7&0!

$#)0&08%!78<!,%72+0B!!97%0S#&*]*8S!7!-0&,#8U,!$+7,,!%)&07%08,J!*8!1.!1*8<J!%#!

&0*8%&#<:$0!0,,08%*7+*,%!$#8$0-%,!#'!$+7,,!*<08%*% .! 78<!0W-0&*08$0!%)&#:S)!%)0!27$T!

<##&B!!^,*8S!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!17&T0&,!%#!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!7!-0&,#8U,!0W-0&*08$0,J!

)#M0F0&J!#''0&,!7!M7.!%#!*8F0,%*S7%0!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!7!-0&,#8U,!$+7,,!78<!

%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)#:%!&0-&#<:$*8S!%)0!*<07!%)7%!7!-0&,#8U,!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!

-#,*%*#8!80$0,,7&*+.!S:7&78%00,!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-&7$%*$0B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!

$#8%0W%:7+*]7%*#8!&7%)0&!%)78!$7%0S#&*]7%*#8!0872+0<!10!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!$+7,,!

1#2*+*%.!78<!%&7R0$%#&.!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!-#%08%*7+!<:&72*+*%.!#'!$+7,,!0W-0&*08$0,!7,!7!

a5!

-0&,#8!1#F0,!%)&#:S)!<*''0&08%!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,B!!I)*+0!10,,*0&J!,:$)!7!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!

$+7,,!*,!7+,#!1#&0!F7+*<B!!?!%)*8T!*%!20%%0&!0872+0<!10!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!7!-0&,#8U,!$+7,,!%&7R0$%#&.!78<!%)0*&!10<*7!:,7S0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0*&!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,B!!?%!7+,#!#-080<!,-7$0!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!<:&72+0!87%:&0!#'!7!-0&,#8U,!

2$;"'6(B!!>7%)0&!%)78!<&7M*8S!,%&*$%!$#&&0+7%*#8,!20%M008!7!-0&,#8U,!1#108%7&.!

$+7,,!,%7%:,!78<!%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!7,!7!$7%0S#&*]7%*#8!,%&7%0S.!M#:+<!

08$#:&7S0J!?!M7,!*8,%07<!72+0!%#!7--&#7$)!V:0,%*#8,!#'!$+7,,!78<!10<*7!:,7S0!1#&0!

)#+*,%*$7++.B!

L#!S*F0!.#:!78!*<07!72#:%!%)0!$+7,,!$:+%:&0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%)#:S)J!*%!*,!

80$0,,7&.!%#!<0,$&*20!,#10!#'!%)0!'7$%#&,!%)7%!*8'#&10<!%)0!,)7-0!#'!%)#,0!$:+%:&0,B!!

L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!%)0,0!7&0!%)0!#8+.!'7$%#&,!%)7%!,)7-0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!

0W-0&*08$0,B!!C.!-7&%*$*-78%,!)7F0!1#F0<!%)&#:S)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,B!!/#10!

)7F0!*<08%*'*0<!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!7%!$0&%7*8!%*10,!*8!%)0*&!+*F0,!#8+.!%#!

1#F0!7M7.!'&#1!%)01!*8!#%)0&,B!!K*T0!#80U,!S710&!*<08%*%.![78<J!?!M#:+<!$#8%08<J!

+*T0!7++!*<08%*%*0,\J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!*<08%*%*0,!78<!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!20,%!

:8<0&,%##<!7,!1#108%7&.!7&%*$:+7%*#8,!,*%:7%0<!M*%)*8!7!,-0$*'*$!$#8%0W%B!!>7%)0&!

%)78!:,*8S!%)0,0!'7$%#&,!7,!'*W0<!17&T0&,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!+#$7%*#8,J!%)08J!?!

:,0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$+7,,!87&&7%*F0,!7,!7!R:1-*8S!#''!-#*8%!'#&!%)0!1#&0!$7&0':+!

$#8,*<0&7%*#8,!#'!$+7,,!0W-0&*08$0,!'#:8<!*8!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!

L#!20S*8!M*%)J!?!M#:+<!,:117&*]0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!-&0<#1*878%+.!+#$7%0<!

M*%)*8!%)0!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8!$#11#8+.!T8#M8!7,!%)0!X+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,BY!!>*%7!Z0+,T*!

[3444\!)7,!<0,$&*20<!%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,J!#&!F/'"'/&;.631/."("/J!7,!&0,*<*8S!

#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!$+7,,*$7+!#--#,*%*#8!20%M008!%)0!:8&:+.!78<!-+07,:&0`,00T*8S!

a3!

M#&T*8S!$+7,,0,J!#8!%)0!#80!)78<J!78<!%)0!<#1*800&*8SJ!&0-&0,,0<!2#:&S0#*,*0!#8!

%)0!#%)0&!)78<B!!L)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,J!%)08J!)7,!80*%)0&!%)0!&0F#+:%*#87&.!

-#%08%*7+!#'!%)0!M#&T*8S!$+7,,!8#&!%)0!$:+%:&7+!78<!0$#8#1*$!,%7%:,!#'!%)0!

2#:&S0#*,*0B!!;,!Z0+,T*!M&*%0,J!%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,!X)7,!%.-*$7++.!2008!78!#2R0$%!#'!

,$#&8!71#8S!*8%0++0$%:7+,J!2+710<!'#&!0F0&.%)*8S!'&#1!0W$00<*8S+.!27<!%7,%0!%#!%)0!

&*,0!#'!A*%+0&Y![-B!df\B!!?%!*,!7!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8!-&0<#1*878%+.!17&T0<!2.!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!

'00+*8S!#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!,)710!78<!*8,0$:&*%.J!$7:S)%!20%M008!%)0!$:+%:&0,!#'!%)0!

1*<<+0!78<!:--0&!$+7,,0,J!M)*$)!+##T!<#M8!:-#8!%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0!$+7,,J!78<!

M#&T*8S!$+7,,!$:+%:&0,J!M)*$)!7&0!17&T0<!7,!F:+S7&!78<!%):,!<08*0<!%#!10120&,!#'!

%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0!$+7,,!*8!%)0*&!0''#&%,!%#!17*8%7*8!&0,-0$%72*+*%.B!

I).!<#!?!+#$7%0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!-&0<#1*878%+.!*8!%)7%!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8g!!/0F0&7+!

&07,#8,B!!P80!*,!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#8,!78<!

-&#'0,,*#8,B!!;,!7!&01*8<0&J!?!*8V:*&0<!72#:%!%)0!0<:$7%*#8!78<!-&#'0,,*#8,!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!$7&0S*F0&,!<:0!%#!1.!&0+*78$0!:-#8!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!)72*%:,!%#!'&710!

$+7,,!$:+%:&0B!!;!-0&,#8U,!)72*%:,!*,!'#&10<!'&#1!78!07&+.!7S0!78<J!7+%)#:S)!$7-72+0!

#'!%&78,'#&17%*#8J!*,!80F0&%)0+0,,!<:&72+0B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!7!-0&,#8U,!$)*+<)##<!

0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!$+7,,!78<!$+7,,!$:+%:&0,!&017*8,!7!':8<7108%7+!0+0108%!#'!%)0*&!

)72*%:,J!0F08!*'!%)0.!)7F0!1#F0<!%)&#:S)!#%)0&!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,B!

?8!%#%7+J!c4!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0,$&*20<!%)0*&!'7%)0&U,![#&!,%0-`'7%)0&U,\!0<:$7%*#8!

78<!ch!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0,$&*20<!%)0*&!1#%)0&U,![#&!,%0-`1#%)0&U,\!0<:$7%*#8B!!L)0!

&017*8*8S!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!%)0*&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#8!78<J!<0,-*%0!

%)0!*8F*%7%*#8!%#!<*,$:,,!#%)0&!$7&0S*F0&,!20,*<0,!-7&08%,J!8#!#80!108%*#80<!78.!

$7&0S*F0&,!#:%,*<0!#'!-7&08%,!78<!,%0-`-7&08%,B!!?!,:&1*,0!%)7%!%)0!&07,#8!'#&!%)0!

ad!

S&07%0&!8:120&!#'!1#%)0&,!<0,$&*20<!*,!20$7:,0!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!2*7,!%#M7&<,!M#108!

7,!$7&0S*F0&,!k!,0F0&7+!-7&%*$*-78%,!108%*#80<!72,08%00!'7%)0&,!78<J!*8!$7,0,!#'!

<*F#&$0J!1#%)0&,!M0&0!:8*F0&,7++.!8710<!7,!%)0!-&*17&.!$7&0S*F0&B!!P'!%)0!'7%)0&,!

<0,$&*20<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!%)0!)*S)0,%!0<:$7%*#87+!+0F0+!

7$)*0F0<!'0++!'7*&+.!0F08+.!7$&#,,!7!,-0$%&:1!20%M008!%0&1*87%*8S!%)0*&!0<:$7%*#8!7%!

)*S)!,$)##+!78<!$#1-+0%*8S!,#10!'#&1!#'!7!S&7<:7%0!<0S&00G!5a!'7%)0&,!$#1-+0%0<!

$#++0S0![<0'*80<!7,!7%%7*8*8S!7!%0&1*87+!f`.07&!<0S&00\J!53!$#1-+0%0<!)*S)!,$)##+J!53!

7%%08<0<!$#++0S0!2:%!<*<!8#%!'*8*,)J!78<!6!7%!+07,%!20S78!M#&T!#8!7!S&7<:7%0!<0S&00B!!

>0S7&<*8S!1#%)0&,J!%)0!,71-+0!M7,!1#&0!)07F*+.!M0*S)%0<!%#M7&<,!%)0!$#1-+0%*#8!

#'!7!$#++0S0!<0S&00G!3a!$#1-+0%0<!$#++0S0J!55!$#1-+0%0<!)*S)!,$)##+J!54!7%%08<0<!

$#++0S0!2:%!<*<!8#%!$#1-+0%0!7!<0S&00J!78<!i!7%!+07,%!20S78!M#&T!#8!7!S&7<:7%0!

<0S&00B!!!!

>0S7&<*8S!-7&08%7+!#$$:-7%*#8,J!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0,$&*20<!

-7&08%,!M)#!)7<!-&#'0,,*#87+!#&!,0&F*$0!*8<:,%&.!$7&00&,B!!P8+.!54!-7&%*$*-78%,!

<0,$&*20<!%)0*&!'7%)0&,!7,!)7F*8S!7!%&7<*%*#87++.!M#&T*8S!$+7,,!$7&00&!k!a!,*1-+.!

<0,$&*20<!%)0*&!'7%)0&U,!$7&00&!7,!X2+:0!$#++7&JY ! 5!,7*<!%)0*&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!*8!

$#8,%&:$%*#8J!78<!3!+720+0<!%)0*&!'7%)0&U,!M#&T!7,!X178:7+!+72#&BY!!C#%)0&,U!$7&00&,!

M0&0!+0,,!F7&*0<!78<!,T0M0<!%#M7&<,!%&7<*%*#87++.!X-*8T!$#++7&Y!R#2,!k!%)0!d!1#,%!

-#-:+7&!$7&00&,!$*%0<!M0&0!%07$)0&,![6\J!,%7.`7%`)#10!$7&0S*F0&,![i\J!78<!8:&,0,![i\B!!!

?8!78!7%%01-%!%#!S7%)0&!1#&0!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!*8$:+$7%0<!

<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,J!?!7+,#!*8V:*&0<!*8%#!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)0*&!-7&08%,!

&0S:+7%0<!%)0*&!F*<0#!S710!:,0J!,*8$0!%)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!17R#&*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

S&0M!:-!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,B!!L)*,!)0+-0<!10!%7-!*8%#!%)0*&!$:+%:&7+!7%%*%:<0,!%#M7&<,!

af!

F*<0#!S710,B!!;,!78!010&S*8S!80M!10<*7J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!<:&*8S!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

$)*+<)##<J!178.!78W*0%*0,!72#:%!10<*7!:,7S0!78<!-#-:+7&!$:+%:&0!)7F0!2008!

7%%7$)0<!%#!F*<0#!S710,!2.!F7&*#:,!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!,#$*7+!7$%#&,B!!;,,0,,*8S!

M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!-7&08%,!<0010<!F*<0#!S710,!80$0,,7&.!#'!&0S:+7%*#8!M#:+<!)0+-!10!

S7*8!*8,*S)%!*8%#!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!M0&0!-#,*%*#80<!07&+.!*8!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!+*F0,B!!

I0&0!%)0.!,008!7,!%)&07%08*8Sg!!"0,%&:$%*F0g!!(&#<:$%*F0g!!L)0!&0,-#8,0,!-&#F*<0<!

M0&0!7+1#,%!0F08+.!,-+*%B!!dd!-7&%*$*-78%,!,%7%0<!%)7%!%)0*&!-7&08%,!-+7$0<!,#10!,#&%!

#'!+*1*%!#8!%)0*&!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,J!%.-*$7++.!*8!%)0!'#&1!#'!+*1*%*8S!%)0!71#:8%!#'!

%*10!,-08%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!#&!1787S*8S!M)7%!%.-0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!M0&0!-+7.0<!

[0BSB!2788*8S!F*#+08%!F*<0#!S710,\B!!C078M)*+0J!d5!-7&%*$*-78%,!,%7%0<!%)7%!%)0*&!

-7&08%,!-+7$0<!8#!&0,%&*$%*#8!#8!%)0*&!F*<0#!S710!-+7.B!!I)08!,0-7&7%0<!2.!

0<:$7%*#8J!$#++0S0!0<:$7%0<!-7&08%,!M0&0!1#&0!+*T0+.!%#!&0S:+7%0!S710!:,7S0!%)78!%#!

8#%!&0S:+7%0!*%![3d!%#!5d\J!M)*+0!)*S)!,$)##+!0<:$7%0<!-7&08%,!0W)*2*%0<!%)0!#--#,*%0!

%08<08$.![5h!<*<!8#%!&0S:+7%0!F0&,:,!55!M)#!<*<\B!

Snowball!Sampling!and!Diversity!

!!!

;,!$78!20!,008J!%)08J!1.!&0$&:*%108%!,%&7%0S.!7++#M0<!10!%#!%7-!*8%#!S&#:-,!

%)7%!7&0!%&7<*%*#87++.!:8<0&&0-&0,08%0<!*8!S71*8S!,%:<*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M#108!78<!

2*,0W:7+!78<!V:00&!-0#-+0B!!>7$0J!1078M)*+0J!M7,!%)0!+07,%!*8%0&87++.!<*F0&,0!

$7%0S#&.J!7!<0F0+#-108%!%)7%!?!#8+.!20S&:<S*8S+.!7$$0-%0<!78<!,#!M78%!%#!<0F#%0!7!

+*%%+0!,-7$0!%#!0W-+#&*8SB!!L)0&0!7&0!7%!+07,%!%M#!'7$%#&,J!*8!1.!1*8<J!%)7%!+07<!%#!%)0!

-&*F*+0S*8S!#'!M)*%0!-7&%*$*-78%,!*8!1.!,%:<.B!!P80!M7,!1.!<0$*,*#8!%#!:,0!7!

,8#M27++!,71-+*8S!10%)#<!%#!&0$&:*%!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8!7!,8#M27++!,71-+0J!%)0!

&0,07&$)0&!%.-*$7++.!20S*8,!M*%)!#80!#&!1#&0!10120&,!#'!7!<0,*&0<!,#$*7+!S&#:-!78<!

ac!

7,T,!%)7%!-0&,#8!%#!&0$#1108<!#%)0&!'&*08<,J!&0+7%*F0,J!#&!7$V:7*8%78$0,!*8!#&<0&!%#!

$#8%*8:0!*8%0&F*0M*8S!*8!%)0!,710!,#$*7+!S&#:-![(&0,,J!5665J!-B!5a6\B!!;%!%)0!#:%,0%!

#'!1.!,%:<.J!?!*8*%*7++.!&0+*0<!#8!-0#-+0!M)#!M0&0!10120&,!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!*<08%*%.!

S&#:-,!7,!,%7&%*8S!-#*8%,!%#!20S*8!&0$&:*%*8S!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!L)#,0!S&#:-,J!)#M0F0&J!

M0&0!K0,2*78J!Q7.J!=*,0W:7+J!L&78,S08<0&J!78<!j:00&`*<08%*'*0<!-0#-+0!78<!-0#-+0!

'&#1!M#&T*8S!78<!-&#'0,,*#87+!$+7,,!27$TS&#:8<,J!8#%!10120&,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!&7$0!

#&!0%)8*$*%.B!

C.!<0$*,*#8!%#!27,0!1.!,8#M27++!,71-+0!#8!,0W:7+*%.!78<!$+7,,!*<08%*%*0,J!7,!

#--#,0<!%#!#%)0&!*<08%*%.!$7%0S#&*0,!+*T0!&7$0!78<!0%)8*$*%.J!M7,!*8!%:&8!*8'#&10<!2.!

,0F0&7+!'7$%#&,B!!I*%)!&0S7&<,!%#!,0W:7+*%.J!? ! M78%0<!%#!20S*8!%)0&0!20$7:,0J!7,!%)0!

(7&<#`A7&-0&!<027%0!78<!XQ710&Q7%0Y!$#8%&#F0&,.!&0F07+0<J!,0W:7+*%.!)7,!20$#10!

7!X'+7,)-#*8%Y!*8!&0$08%!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!72#:%!S71*8SB!!C#&0#F0&J!%)0,0!0F08%,!

,:SS0,%0<!%#!10!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!17.!1078!,#10%)*8S!V:*%0!<*''0&08%!'#&!

M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%!$*,`S08<0&0<!108!%)78!*%!<#0,!'#&!KQ=Lj!-0#-+0J!F*,`t`F*,!,0+'`$7&0!

78<!%)&*F*8SB!!?%!7+,#!&7*,0<!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!M).!KQ=Lj!-0#-+0!M#:+<!0F08!,00!

S71*8S!7,!7!&0,#:&$0!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!M)08!<#1*878%!S&#:-,!*8!%)0!S71*8S!

$#11:8*%.!7&0!#'%08!#--#,0<!%#!%)0*&!*8$+:,*#8B!!L)*,!$#8%&7<*$%*#8!,:SS0,%0<!%#!10!

%)7%!,0W:7+*%.!M7,!7!-&#<:$%*F0!+08,!2.!M)*$)!%#!'&710!%)0!$#8F0&,7%*#8!72#:%!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!S71*8SJ!%)&*F*8SJ!78<!,0+'`$7&0!78<!<0F0+#-!7!8:78$0<J!

$#1-+0W!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)7%!&0+7%*#8,)*-B!!9+7,,!M7,!7+,#!78!*1-#&%78%!<*108,*#8!

#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!S*F08!1.!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!78<!

%)0#&0%*$7+!7++*78$0,B!!?!'0+%!%)7%!*'!?!M7,!S#*8S!%#!%7-!*8%#!7!<*F0&,*%.!#'!%)&*F*8S!

ah!

-&7$%*$0,J!7,!<0178<0<!2.!1.!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,J!*%!M#:+<!20!80$0,,7&.!%#!&0$&:*%!

-7&%*$*-78%,!'&#1!7!F7&*0%.!#'!$+7,,!27$TS&#:8<,B!!

C.!*8*%*7+!,8#M27++!-7&%*$*-78%,J!>7F08!78<!O7%*7J!M0&0!-&#1*,*8S!,%7&%*8S!

-#*8%,!'#&!%)0!-&#R0$%!,*8$0!%)0.!2#%)!20+#8S0<!%#!8#8`<#1*878%!S&#:-,!M*%)!

&0S7&<,!%#!%)0*&!,0W:7+*%*0,!78<!$+7,,!-#,*%*#8,B!!>7F08!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!1:+%*`&7$*7+J!

2*,0W:7+!M#178B!!A0&!$+7,,!27$TS&#:8<J!1078M)*+0J!M7,!$#1-+*$7%0<!k!&7*,0<!*8!

-#F0&%.!2.!)0&!1#%)0&J!,)0!M7,!72+0!%#!7%%08<!$#++0S0!78<!0F08!20S*8!7!=7,%0&U,!

-&#S&71!%)7%!,)0!M7,!:8'#&%:87%0+.!'#&$0<!%#!+07F0!<:0!%#!$)&#8*$!*++80,,B!!/)0!

<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!,-+*%!20%M008!1:+%*-+0!$:+%:&0,J!2#%)!*8!&0S7&<,!%#!)0&!&7$0!78<!

*8!&0S7&<,!%#!)0&!$+7,,J!M)*$)!S7F0!)0&!7!$#1-+0W!78<!8:78$0<!-0&,-0$%*F0!#8!)#M!

%)0,0!$:+%:&0,!)7F0!*8'#&10<!)0&!+*'0!$)78$0,B!!C#&0#F0&J!7,!78!0W%&#F0&%0<!

-7&%*$*-78%!*8!7!K;>(*8S![K*F0!;$%*#8!>#+0!(+7.*8S\!$#11:8*%.J!,)0!$#:+<!-&#F*<0!

10!M*%)!7$$0,,!%#!7!<*F0&,0!$#11:8*%.!%)7%!M7,!<00-+.!*8F0,%0<!*8!S71*8SB!!O7%*7J!

#8!%)0!#%)0&!)78<J!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!M)*%0J!2*,0W:7+!M#178!M)#!M7,!&7*,0<!#8!7!'7&1!

*8!&:&7+!@0M!E8S+78<B!!A0&!'7%)0&!07&80<!)*,!QE"!'&#1!%)0!1*+*%7&.!78<!M#&T0<!*8!7!

-+7%0!,)#-!M)*+0!)0&!1#%)0&!7%%08<0<!$#++0S0![2:%!<*<!8#%!'*8*,)!)0&!<0S&00\!78<!

M#&T0<!*8!F7&*#:,!#''*$0!R#2,!%)&#:S)#:%!O7%*7U,!$)*+<)##<B!!O7%*7!7%%08<0<!$#++0S0!

2:%J!+*T0!)0&!1#%)0&J!80F0&!'*8*,)0<!)0&!<0S&00J!*8,%07<!+07F*8S!$#++0S0!%#!M#&T!':++!

%*10B!!/)0!$:&&08%+.!M#&T,!7,!7!-08,*#8!787+.,%J!7!-#,*%*#8!%)7%!%)78T':++.!S&78%,!)0&!

%)0!72*+*%.!%#!M#&T!'&#1!)#10!,*8$0J!+*T0!>7F08J!O7%*7!,:''0&,!'&#1!7!$)&#8*$!*++80,,!

[1:+%*-+0!,$+0&#,*,\B!!O7%*7!*,!7+,#!<00-+.!*8F0,%0<!*8!S71*8S!78<!*,!78!7$%*F0!

-7&%*$*-78%!*8!,0F0&7+!C7,,*F0+.!C:+%*-+7.0&!P8+*80!>#+0!(+7.*8S!Q710,!

[CCP>(Q,\J!0,-0$*7++.!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'![=+*]]7&<!E8%0&%7*8108%J!344f\B!!/)0!)7,!

aa!

*8F0,%0<!):8<&0<,J!-0&)7-,!0F08!%)#:,78<,J!#'!)#:&,!*8!%)0!S710!78<!)7,!

<0F0+#-0<!78!*8%*17%0!,#$*7+!$*&$+0!'&#1!%)0!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!%)7%!,)0!)7,!08$#:8%0&0<!

78<!-+7.0<!7+#8S,*<0J!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!%)7%!0W%08<!%#!#%)0&!S710,!78<!0F08!*8%#!%)0!

8#8`F*&%:7+!M#&+<B!!!!

=.!,%7&%*8S!1.!,8#M27++!,71-+0,!M*%)!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,J!M*%)!%)0*&!

0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!17&S*87+*]0<!$#11:8*%*0,!78<!$+7,,!1#2*+*%.J!?!)7<!)#-0<!%#!

08$#:8%0&!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!M*%)!,*1*+7&+.!<*F0&,0!0W-0&*08$0,B!!L)*,J!)#M0F0&J!

+07<,!10!%#!%)0!#%)0&!'7$%#&!%)7%!S&07%+.!*8'+:08$0<!%)0!&7$*7+!$#1-#,*%*#8!#'!1.!

,71-+0B!!?8!7,T*8S!>7F08!78<!O7%*7!%#!*8%&#<:$0!10!%#!#%)0&!-0#-+0!M)#!17.!20!

*8%0&0,%0<!*8!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!1.!,%:<.J!?!,-0$*'*$7++.!108%*#80<!,0W:7+*%.!78<!$+7,,!

7,!%M#!F7&*72+0,!%)7%!?!M78%0<!%#!08,:&0!M0&0!<*F0&,0!78<!<0$+*80<!%#!108%*#8!#%)0&!

F7&*72+0,!+*T0!&7$0B!!;%!%)0!%*10J!?!M78%0<!%#!08,:&0!%)7%!?!M#:+<!20!72+0!%#!&0$&:*%!7,!

178.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!-#,,*2+0!78<!,#!<*<!8#%!M78%!%#!-+7$0!%##!178.!+*1*%,!#8!1.!

&0$&:*%108%!$&*%0&*7B!!L)*,!%:&80<!#:%!%#!20!'#&%:*%#:,!,*8$0!>7F08!78<!O7%*7!M0&0!

#8+.!72+0!%#!)0+-!10!&0$&:*%!7--&#W*17%0+.!34!-7&%*$*-78%,J!#&!7!%)*&<!#'!%)0!8:120&!

%)7%!?!M7,!7*1*8S!'#&!%#!)0+-!08,:&0!F7+*<!78<!&0+*72+0!$#8$+:,*#8,B!!?!08<0<!:-!

%:&8*8S!%#!#%)0&!7$V:7*8%78$0,!M)#!M0&0!+0,,!)07F*+.!*8F0,%0<!*8!S71*8S!

$#11:8*%*0,!78<J!$&:$*7++.J!M0&0!,*%:7%0<!*8!&0S*#8,!#%)0&!%)78!@0M!E8S+78<B!!L)0,0!

*8$+:<0<!7!2*&7$*7+!M#178!M)#!$:&&08%+.!+*F0,!*8!%)0!/#:%)07,%!&0S*#8!#'!%)0!^B/B!

78<!78!E7,%0&8!E:&#-078!-&#'0,,#&!M)#!$:&&08%+.!M#&T,!7%!7!,17++!C*<M0,%!,%7%0!

$#++0S0B!!K*T0!M*%)!>7F08!78<!O7%*7J!?!,-0$*'*0<!%)7%!?!M7,!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!-0#-+0!M)#!

-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!2:%!M7,!-+788*8S!#8!-7.*8S!-7&%*$:+7&!7%%08%*#8!%#!,0W:7+*%.!78<!

$+7,,!*8!1.!787+.,*,B!!

ai!

L)0,0!<0$*,*#8,!&0,:+%0<!*8!%)0!,71-+0!'#&!%)0!,%:<.J!7!,71-+0!%)7%!*,!<*F0&,0!

*8!,#10!&0,-0$%,!2:%!8#%!*8!#%)0&,B!!=.!,-0$*'*$7++.!108%*#8*8S!,0W:7+*%.!78<!$+7,,!

<:&*8S!&0$&:*%108%J!?!M7,!72+0!%#!08,:&0!%)7%!%)0,0!$7%0S#&*0,!M0&0!,7%*,'7$%#&*+.!

F7&*0<B!!A#M0F0&J!2.!<0$+*8*8S!%#!,-0$*'*$7++.!$#8%&#+!1.!,71-+0!-#-:+7%*#8!'#&!&7$0J!

1.!,8#M27++!,71-+0!&0-&#<:$0<!2*7,0,!%#M7&<,!M)*%0!-0&,-0$%*F0,B!!L)0!$#8$+:,*#8!

%)7%!?!<&7M!'&#1!%)*,!*,!%)7%!<*F0&,*%.!7+#8S!78.!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!7W*,J!,:$)!7,!&7$0J!*,!

8#%!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!$78!20!S:7&78%00<!2.!%)0!10%)#<#+#S*$7+!%##+,!%)7%!M0!:,0!#&J!

M)08!:,*8S!7!,8#M27++!,71-+*8S!10%)#<J!%)0!*8*%*7+!-7&%*$*-78%,!&0$&:*%0<B!!"*F0&,*%.!

*,!7!S#7+!%)7%!&0V:*&0,!$#8,%78%!*8%0&F08%*#8!#8!%)0!-7&%!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)0&B!!?%!1:,%!20!

$:+%*F7%0<!%)&#:S)#:%!0F0&.!,%7S0!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#$0,,!7$$#&<*8S!%#!%)0!

-7&%*$:+7&!S#7+,!#'!7!S*F08!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!

A#M0F0&J!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!S*F0!%)0!*1-&0,,*#8!%)7%!0F0&.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!

*8F#+F*8S!):178!,:2R0$%,!1:,%!7$)*0F0!7!<*F0&,0!,71-+0!7$&#,,!0F0&.!$#8$0*F72+0!

7W*,!#'!,#$*7+!<*''0&08$0B!!/:$)!7!-#,,*2*+*%.!M#:+<!8#%!#8+.!20!*1-&7$%*$7+!*8!%0&1,!#'!

%)0!%*10!78<!'*878$*7+!&0,#:&$0,!80$0,,7&.!%#!S080&7%0!%)*,!<*F0&,*%.J!2:%!7+,#!M#:+<!

8#%!7<0V:7%0+.!,0&F*$0!0F0&.!-&#R0$%U,!S#7+,J!78<!$#:+<!*8!'7$%!)71-0&!,-0$*'*$!

&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%,B!!L)*,!*,!M).!?!,%7%0<!7%!%)0!#:%,0%!#'!1.!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!%)0!&7$*7+!

$#1-#,*%*#8!#'!1.!,71-+0!%)7%!*%!M7,!7!+*1*%7%*#8!#'!1.!,%:<.J!.0,J!2:%!8#%!7!

<*,V:7+*'.*8S!+*1*%7%*#8B!!!I)*+0!,#10!17.!7&S:0!%)7%!%)0!,71-+0!$#8,%&:$%0<!'#&!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#R0$%!*,!*8)0&08%+.!2*7,0<!78<!%):,!M#&% ).! #'!<*,1*,,7+J!?!7S&00!M*%)!

K*8<+#'!78<!L7.+#&![3455\J!M)#!7&S:0!%)7%!,:$)!$)7&S0,!%08<!%#!1*,:8<0&,%78<!%)0!

S#7+,!#'!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!1#&0!S080&7++.B!!P80!#'!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!V:7+*%7%*F0!

a6!

&0,07&$)!<*''0&,!'&#1!V:78%*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!*,!!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)U,!01-)7,*,!#8!

X$#1-7&72*+*%.Y!&7%)0&!%)78!XS080&7+*]72*+*%.BY!!!

L)*,!01-)7,*,!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!,:*%0<!%#!%)0!<0F0+#-108%!#'!XM07T!%)0#&.Y!

[/0<SM*$TJ!344d\B!!?8!)0&!2##T!0.6=2"#1&!//%"#1J&-??/='4&H/>$1.1)4&H/3?.3@$'"9"')!

[344d\J!EF0!O#,#',T.!/0<SM*$T!$#8%&7,%,!XM07T!%)0#&.Y!M*%)!X,%&#8S!%)0#&.JY!78<!

,:SS0,%!%)7%!M07T!%)0#&.!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!,:*%0<!%#!)0+-*8S!:,!,00!#-08*8S,!78<!

-#,,*2*+*%*0,!%)7%!,%&#8S!%)0#&.!'&0V:08%+.!'#&0$+#,0,!#&!*S8#&0,B!!Z#&!/0<SM*$TJ!%)0!

V:7+*'*0&,!XM07TY!78<!X,%&#8SY!<#!8#%!&0'0&!%#!%)0!&0+7%*F0!,%&08S%)!#&!M07T80,,!#'!

%)0!%)0#&.J!2:%!&7%)0&!%#!%)0!X,*]0!78<!%#-#+#S.!#'!%)0!<#17*8!%)7%!*%!#&S78*]0,Y![-B!

5df\B!!/%&#8S!%)0#&.!,00T,!7!M*<0!,-0$%&:1!#'!7--+*$72*+*%.J!M)*+0!M07T!%)0#&.!

&017*8,!$#1-7&7%*F0+.!+#$7+!78<!<0,$&*-%*F0B!!L)0!-&#2+01!M*%)!,%&#8S!%)0#&.J!'#&!

/0<SM*$TJ!*,!%)7%!*%!#'%08%*10,!#8+.!$#8'*&1,!M)7%!*,!7+&07<.!T8#M8J!78<!*,!8#%!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!7<0-%!7%!7<<&0,,*8S!-#,,*2*+*%*0,J!,:&-&*,0J!)#-0J!78<!$#8%*8S08$.B!!

Q*2,#8`Q&7)71![344h\!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!)7,!+0<!$&*%*$7+!%)0#&.!%#!&0-07%0<+.!

X<*,$#F0&Y!%)7%!X%)0!M#&+<!*,!':++!#'!$&:0+%.J!1*,0&.J!78<!+#,,J!7!-+7$0!#'!<#1*87%*#8!

78<!,.,%017%*$!#--&0,,*#8Y![-B!a\B!!Q*2,#8`Q&7)71J!<&7M*8S!#8!/0<SM*$TJ!,:SS0,%!

M07T!%)0#&.!7,!78!7+%0&87%*F0J!&0-7&7%*F0!-&#R0$%!%#!%)0!&0<:$%*F0!78<!-7&78#*<!

0W$0,,0,!#'!,%&#8S!%)0#&.B!!?%!*,!7!%)0#&.!%)7%!M#&T,!7%!7!+#$7+!+0F0+J!M*%)!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

,08,*%*F*%.!%#!$#8%0W%!78<!$#8%*8S08$.J!&7%)0&!%)78!7! % )0#&.!%)7%!,00T,!S080&7+!

7--+*$72*+*%.B!!/:$)!7!%)0#&0%*$7+!-&#R0$%!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!,:*%0<!%#!2#%)!%)0!S#7+,!#'!1.!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#R0$%!78<!*%,!-&7$%*$7+!$#8,%&7*8%,B!!L):,!M)*+0!%)0!7&S:108%,!%)7%!?!

71!17T*8S!78<!%)0!%)0#&*0,!%)7%!?!71!<0F0+#-*8S!7&0!80$0,,7&*+.!+*1*%0<!2.!1.!

-&#R0$%U,!,17++J!8#8`&78<#1!,71-+0J!?!M#:+<!-:%!'#&%)!%)7%!,:$)!7!,71-+0!,*]0!78<!

i4!

%)0!,-0$*'*$*%.!*%!7''#&<0<!)7,!S*F08!10!7!S&07%0&!72*+*%.!%#!,00!%)0!'&7$%:&0,!78<!

%&78,'#&17%*F0!-#,,*2*+*%*0,!%)7%!*8<*F*<:7+!-&7$%*$0,!7+M7.,!*8%&#<:$0!*8%#!2&#7<0&!

,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8B!!C#&0#F0&J!,*8$0!7++!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!-&0,08%0<!

M*%)!%)0!0W7$%!,710!V:0,%*#8,J!<:0!%#!1.!&0+*78$0!#8!,:&F0.,!%#!S7%)0&!<7%7J!*%!M7,!

07,*0&!%#!$#1-7&0!78<!$##&<*87%0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,!%)78!%)0.!M#:+<!)7F0!

2008!:,*8S!#%)0&!10%)#<#+#S*0,J!+*T0!*8%0&F*0M,J!M)*$)!%08<!%#!20!'7*&+.!,-0$*'*$!78<!

:8*V:0B!!/:$)!#:%$#10,!7&0!F0&.!1:$)!*8!+*80!M*%)!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8U,!S#7+!#'!

*8F0,%*S7%*8S!7+%0&87%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!1078*8S,!%)7%!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!*S8#&0<!#&!

<*,1*,,0<!*8!%)0!S71*8S!$#11:8*%.J!%)0!7$7<01.J!78<!%)0!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&0B!!!!!!!!!!!

We!Need!to!Talk!About!the!Body!in!Qualitative!Methods!

! P80!#'!%)0!1#,%!$&*%*$7+!$)#*$0,!17<0!<:&*8S!%)0!<7%7!S7%)0&*8S!-0&*#<!#'!1.!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!M7,!1.!<0$*,*#8!%#!:,0!,:&F0.,!%#!S7%)0&!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!&7%)0&!%)78!*8%0&F*0M,J!M)*$)!#%)0&!&0,07&$)0&,!*8!1.!'*0+<!)7F0!1#&0!

'&0V:08%+.!<0-+#.0<B!!L)0!-&*17&.!1#%*F7%*#8!'#&!%)*,!<0$*,*#8J!)#M0F0&J!M7,!8#%!

%)0#&0%*$7+!2:%!-&7$%*$7+!k!1.!-).,*$7+!)07+%)!<0178<0<!%)7%!?!:,0!7!+0,,!-).,*$7++.!

*8%08,*F0!10%)#<#+#S.!%)78!*8%0&F*0M,B!!;,!,:$)J!?!'00+!*%!*,!$&:$*7+!%#!<*,$:,,!1.!

2#<.!78<!%)0!M7.!*%!)7,!,)7-0<!2#%)!%)0!<7%7!?!$#++0$%0<!78<!%)0!&0,:+%*8S!M&*%%08!

7$$#:8%!#'!1.!&0,07&$)B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!78!:8)07&<!#'!1#F0!*8!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!,*8$0!%)0!&0'+0W*F0!%:&8!#'!%)0!56a4,!78<!56i4,!<0178<0<!,#$*7+!,$*08$0!

&0,07&$)0&,!7$$#:8%!'#&!)#M!%)0*&!-7&%*$:+7&!-#,*% *#8 ,!*8!%)0!'*0+<!7''0$%0<!%)0*&!

M#&TB!!C:$)!#'!%)*,!M#&T!)7,!$#10!'&#1!0%)8#S&7-)0&,!78<!78%)&#-#+#S*,%,!%)7%!

)7F0!%7T08!:-!%)0!-&#2+01!#'!S08<0&!78<!,0W:7+*%.!*8!'*0+<M#&T!78<!)#M!%)0*&!

7,,#$*7%0<!0W-0&*08$0,!2#%)!$)7++08S0!$#8F08%*#87+J!X#2R0$%*F0Y!7$$#:8%,!#'!

i5!

0%)8#S&7-)*$!M#&T!78<!#-08!:-!80M!,#:&$0,!#'!T8#M+0<S0![0BSB!Z*80J!566dl!@0M%#8J!

566dl!O:+*$T!78<!I*++,#8J!566cl!Q##<0J!5666l!!O08<7++J!3446\B!!?8!%:&8J!8:10&#:,!

,$)#+7&,!)7F0!0W%08<0<!%)0!*8,*S)%,!*8%#!012#<*108%!'#:8<!'&#1!1#&0!%&7<*%*#87+!

0%)8#S&7-)*0,!%#!%)0!,%:<.!#'!F*&%:7+!78<!#8+*80!$#11:8*%*0,![0BSB!=7.1J!3444l!

O08<7++J!3443l!C7&T)71J!344cl\B!

;,!;880%%0!C7&T)71J!#80!#'!%)0!-&01*0&!0%)8#S&7-)0&,!#'!#8+*80!$#11:8*%*0,J!)7,!

7&S:0<J!X-0&$0-%*#8!7+M7.,!*8F#+F0,!012#<*108%J!78<!%)*,!$788#%!20!,0%!7,*<0!*8!%)0!

$#8%0W%!#'!,%:<.*8S!+*'0!#8+*80Y![C7&T)71J!344cJ!-B!i46\B!!!

! >0,07&$)0&,!)7F0!-7*<!+0,,!7%%08%*#8J!)#M0F0&J!%#!%)0!7$%:7+!-).,*$7+*%.!#'!%)0!

2#<.!78<!*%,!$7-72*+*%*0,B!!9#8,*<0&7%*#8,!#'!%)0!2#<.!78<!*%,!+*1*%7%*#8,!78<!

7''#&<78$0,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!0W$+:<0<!'&#1!M&*%%08!7$$#:8%,!#'!<7%7!$#++0$%*#8J!

787+.,*,J!78<!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8B!!L)0!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)*,!0W$+:,*#8!7&0!,0F0&0J!7,!

K7:&7!E++*8S,#8![344h\!0W-+7*8,B!!"&*F08!2.!)0&!#M8!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!$)&#8*$!-7*8J!

*++80,,J!78<!<*,72*+*%.J!E++*8S,#8!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0!0&7,:&0!#'!%)0!2#<.!'&#1!%&7<*%*#87+!

V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%,!X#2,$:&0,!%)0!$#1-+0W*%*0,!#'!T8#M+0<S0!-&#<:$%*#8!

78<!.*0+<,!<0$0-%*F0+.!%*<.!7$$#:8%,!#'!&0,07&$)![-B!366\B!!E++*8S,#8!$#8%08<,!%)7%!

V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!M&*%*8S!*,!,%*++!)7:8%0<!2.!%)0!*<07!#'!%)0!X<*,012#<*0<!

&0,07&$)0&Y!78<!*%,!7,,:1-%*#8,!#'!7!2#<.![78<J!2.!0W%08,*#8J!7!,:2R0$%*F*%.\!%)7%!*,!

:8&0+7%0<!%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!T8#M+0<S0!-&#<:$%*#8B!!!

"0,-*%0!%)0!X87&&7%*F0!%:&8Y!*8!V:7+ *% 7%*F0!&0,07&$)!M&*%*8SJ!M)*$)!

7$T8#M+0<S0,!%)7%!&0,07&$)0&,!7&0!*1-0&'0$%!,#$*7+!7$%#&,!*8%0&-&0%*8S!%)0*&!

#2,0&F7%*#8,!'&#1!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-0&,-0$%*F0!["08]*8J!566a\J!E++*8S,#8![344h\!

$#8%08<,!%)7%!1:$)!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!M&*%*8S!,%*++!'#++#M,!7!,%&*$%!,#$*7+!,$*08$0!

i3!

7--&#7$)!%)7%!<0$+*80,!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!2#<.U,!-&0,08$0!*8!&0,07&$)B!!?%!<#0,!%)*,!*8!

%M#!M7.,B!!?%!$78!0&7,0!%)0!,:2R0$%!78<!2#<.!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!08%*&0+.!'&#1!%)0!

7$$#:8%!%)&#:S)!,:$)!$#8F08%*#8,!7,!:,*8S!%)0!-7,,*F0!F#*$0B!!!9#8F0&,0+.J!*%!$78!

7++#M!7!)07F*+.!$*&$:1,$&*20<!78<!$:&,#&.!7$T8#M+0<S0108%!#'!%)0!7:%)#&U,!2#<.!

78<!,:2R0$%*F*%.J!'#&!0W71-+0!2.!:,*8S!%)0!-0&,#87+!-&#8#:8!X?JY!M*%)#:%!$7&0':++.!

0W71*8*8S!%)0!2#<.!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&7$%*$0!M7,!-0&'#&10<B!!=#%)!

10%)#<,!<*1*8*,)!%)0!-&0,08$0!#'!%)0!2#<.!*8!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%,!78<!&0-&#<:$0!%)0!

'*$%*#8!#'!7!<*,012#<*0<J!80:%&7+!1*8<!%)7%!*,!$7-72+0!#'!<*,-7,,*#87%0+.!78<!

#2R0$%*F0+.!#2,0&F*8S!%)0!M#&+<!7&#:8<!*%![-B!d45\B!!L)0!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)0,0!

-&7$%*$0,J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!E++*8S,#8J!7&0!8#%)*8S!+0,,!%)78!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!%)0!

'*$%*#8!%)7%!&0,07&$)!$78!20!$#8<:$%0<!'&#1!7!80:%&7+J!:817&T0<!-#,*%*#8!78<!%)0!

$#8$#1*%78%!,*+08$*8S!#'!17&S*87+*]0<!F#*$0,!%)7%J!2.!80$0,,*%.J!$788#%!&017*8!

:817&T0<G!XI)08b&0,07&$)0&,U!2#<*0,!&017*8!:817&T0<!k!78<!)08$0!87%:&7+*]0<!

7,!8#&17%*F0!k!%)0.!&0*8,$&*20!%)0!-#M0&!#'!,$)#+7&,!%#!,-07T!M*%)#:%!&0'+0W*F0!

$#8,*<0&7%*#8!#'!%)0*&!-#,*%*#87+*%.J!M)0&07,!#%)0&,U!F#*$0,!&017*8!,*+08%!#&!

17&S*87+*]0<!2.!%)0*&!17&T0<!,%7%:,Y![-B!d45\B!

Z#&!%)0!'*87+!,0$%*#8!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)08J!?!M78%!%#!'#$:,!#8!1.!2#<.J!*%,!

7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,J!78<!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!1.!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!1.!2#<.!

,)7-0<!%)0!T8#M+0<S0!-&#<:$0<!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!<*,,0&% 7 %*#8!-&#R0$%B!!?!<#!

%)*,!'#&!,0F0&7+!&07,#8,B!!Z#&!#80J!%)0!S080,*,!#'!%)*,!-&#R0$%!+*0,!*8!1.!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

M*%)!1.!2#<.J!,-0$*'*$7++.!1.!#M8!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!*8R:&.J!<*,72*+*%.J!78<!108%7+!

*++80,,B!!L#!$#-0!M*%)!$)&#8*$!-7*8!#&!710+*#&7%0!%)0!2:&,%,!#'!-78*$!78<!-0&*#<,!#'!

<0-&0,,*#8!%&*SS0&0<!2.!F7&*#:,!08F*&#8108%7+!,%*1:+*!78<!*8%0&87+!$)01*$7+!

id!

&07$%*#8,J!?!M#:+<!%:&8!%#!F*<0#!S710,B!!(+7.*8S!7!S710!+*T0!B"$;%.&+++![=+*]]7&<!

3455\!7%!d!#U$+#$T!*8!%)0!1#&8*8S!M)08!?!$#:+<!8#%!,+00-!'&#1!-7*8!M7,!#80!#'!%)0!

'0M!$#1'#&%,!?!$#:+<!'*8<!M)08!?!)0&8*7%0<!7!,-*87+!<*,$!*8!1.!80$TB!!EF08!8#MJ!7'%0&!

&0$#F0&*8S!'&#1!%)7%!*8R:&.J!?!'*8<!1.,0+'!%)*8T*8S!27$T!%#!%)#,0!1#108%,!M*%)!

,#10%)*8S!7--&#7$)*8S!'#8<80,,B!!/*1*+7&+.J!M)080F0&!?!)7F0!%)0!+:W:&.!#'!

78%*$*-7%*8S!7!-78*$!7%%7$TJ!?!<&#-!0F0&.%)*8S!78<!%:&8!#8!7!F*<0#!S710!%#!'#$:,!1.!

7%%08%*#8!0+,0M)0&0!78<!+0,,08!%)0!*8%08,*%.!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!%&*SS0&B!!(+7.*8S!7!F*<0#!

S710!*,!7&&0,%*8S!08#:S)!%#!)#+<!7%!+07,%!,#10!#'!1.!7%%08%*#8!78<!$&07%0,!%*10!78<!

,-7$0!'#&!1.!2&7*8!%#!-&#$0,,!%)0!0F08%!%)7%!-&0$*-*%7%0<!%)0!-78*$J!#'%08%*10,!

*8%0&&:-%*8S!1.!2#<.U,!-78*$!&0,-#8,0B!!?%!M7,!0W-0&*08$0,!+*T0!%)0,0!%)7%!+0<!10!%#!

%)*8T!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!,:&F*F7+J!78<!2.!0W%08,*#8J!

,0+'!$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!L)0,0!0W-0&*08$0,!17<0!10!$:&*#:,!72#:%!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!

#%)0&!-0#-+0!:,0<!F*<0#!S710,!*8!7!,*1*+7&!M7.!78<!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!$#:+<!S*F0!

&*,0!%#!,:$)!7!-&7$%*$0B!!;8<!%)0.!+08%!%)*,!-&#R0$%!7!-7&%*$:+7&!:&S08$.!'#&!10J!7!<&*F0!

%#!7<<!%)0,0!0W-0&*08$0,!%#!$:&&08%!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!72#:%!10<*7!:,7S0!78<!$:+%:&0B!!!!

D0%!)#M!M0!%7+T!72#:%!%)0!2#<.U,!&#+0!*8!&0,07&$)!*,!R:,%!7,!*1-#&%78%!7,!

7$T8#M+0<S*8S!*%,!-&0,08$0B!!"&7M*8S!#8!-#,%`,%&:$%:&7+*,%!'01*8*,%!%)0#&*0,!#'!

012#<*108%!78<!-0&'#&17%*F*%.![0BSB!=:%+0&J!566dl!Q&#,]J!5666l!=7+,71#J!5666\!!

78<!&0,07&$)!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!7:%#0%)8#S&7-).![0BSB!"08]*8J!566al!E++*,J!566al!E++*,!78<!

=#$)80&J!3444\J!E++*8S,#8!08$#:&7S0,!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)0&,!%#!M&*%0!72#:%!%)0*&!

#M8!2#<*0,!*8!%)0*&!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%,B!!/:$)!7!-&7$%*$0!*,!*8%0S&7+!%#!&0'+0W*F*%.J!

M)*$)!E++*8S,#8![344h\!<0,$&*20,!7,!%)0!$#8%*8:7+!&01*8<0&!%)7%!&0,07&$)!*,!7+M7.,!

$#8<:$%0<!'&#1!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-0&,-0$%*F0!78<!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!%)*8T*8S!%)&#:S)!%)0!

if!

*1-+*$7%*#8,!#'!7!S*F08!&0,07&$)0&U,!,-0$*'*$*%.![-B!d4a\B!!L#!%)*,!08<J!E++*8S,#8!

&0$#1108<,!%)&00!&0,07&$)!M&*%*8S!10%)#<,!%)7%!&0,07&$)0&,!$78!:,0!%#!17T0!%)0*&!

2#<*0,!F*,*2+0B!!P80!*,!%#!M&*%0!7:%#0%)8#S&7-)*$7++.!72#:%!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#$0,,J!

:,*8S!7!+7.0&0<!#&S78*]7%*#8!%)7%!7+%0&87%0,!20%M008!%&7<*%*#87+!,#$*7+!,$*08$0!

M&*%*8S!78<!2&*0'!87&&7%*F0,!%)7%!<&717%*]0!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#$0,,J!%)0&02.!

-&#2+017%*]*8S!%)0!&0,07&$)0&`&0,07&$)0<!<*,%*8$%*#8!78<!,)#M*8S!)#M!&0,07&$)!*,!

$#8<:$%0<!:8<0&!78<!*1-+*$7%0<!*8!,-0$*'*$!$#8<*%*#8,B!!L)*,!*,!%)0!&#:%0!%)7%!?!)7F0!

$)#,08J!17*8+.!20$7:,0!,:$)!7!-&7$%*$0!'#&$0,!10!%#!$#8,*<0&!<0%7*+,!78<!

0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!7&0!%.-*$7++.!0&7,0<!'&#1!7!%&7<*%*#87+!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%!2:%!M0&0!

F*%7+!*8!<0%0&1*8*8S!%)0!,)7-0!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!=.!2&*8S*8S!%)0,0!

0W-0&*08$0,!%#!%)0!'#&0S&#:8<J!?!M78%!%#!8#%!#8+.!<0,$&*20!1.!#M8!&0,07&$)!

-&7$%*$0,!1#&0!':++.J!2:%!7+,#!$)7++08S0!M)7%!?!,00!7,!%)0!8#&17%*F0!2#<.J!M)*$)!

*8$+:<0,!%)0!2&7*8!78<!*%,!-&#$0,,0,J!%)7%!:8<0&+*0,!1#,%!V:7+*%7%*F0!X20,%!-&7$%*$0,BY!!

?8!,)#&%J!?!M78%!%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!20,%!-&7$%*$0,!7,,:10!7!-7&%*$:+7&!2#<.J!7!2#<.!

%)7%!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!17.!#&!17.!8#%!*8)72*%!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#$0,,B!!?!M78%!

%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!T8#M+0<S0!-&#<:$%*#8!7+M7.,!#$$:&,!:8<0&!-7&%*$:+7&!

$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!*80F*%72+.!*8'+:08$0!%)0!'#&1!78<!$#8%08%!#'!%)0!-&#<:$0<!

T8#M+0<S0B!!C.!,17++!$#8%&*2:%*#8!%#!%)*,!-#+*%*$7+!-&#R0$%!#'!<0`$08%0&*8S!7!

8#&17+*]0<J!:817&T0<!2#<.!'&#1!V:7+*%7%*F0!10%)#<,!&0,07&$)!*,!%#!17T0!F*,*2+0!

1.!#M8!2#<.!78<!*%,!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!-7*8J!*8R:&.J!*++80,,J!78<!<*,72*+*%.!78<!17-!

)#M!%)#,0!$#8<*%*#8,!*8'#&10<!%)0!M&*%%08!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%!.#:!7&0!$:&&08%+.!

&07<*8SB!!

ic!

Pain!and!Its!Uses!in!Qualitative!Research!

! ?!$78!8#M!%&7$0!%)0!+08S%)!#'!1.!9h`9a!80&F0!<#M8!1.!2#<.!M*%)!-&0$*,*#8B!!

?%!,%7&%,!7%!%)0!27,0!#'!1.!80$T!78<!1#F0,!<#M8!%)0!27$T!#'!1.!+0'%!,)#:+<0&!2+7<0B!

Z&#1!%)0&0!*%!%&7F0+,!<#M8!%)0!27$T!#'!1.!7&1!%)&#:S)!1.!+0'%!%&*$0-!20'#&0!

M&7--*8S!7&#:8<!%#!%)0!'&#8%!#'!1.!7&1!807&!%)0!0+2#MB!!?%!'*87++.!%&7F0+,!<#M8!%)0!

'&#8%!#'!1.!'#&07&1!20'#&0!%0&1*87%*8S!*8!1.!+0'%!*8<0W!78<!1*<<+0!'*8S0&,J!M)#,0!

1#F0108%!78<!,%&08S%)!%)0!80&F0!$#8%&#+,B!!?!T8#M!%)0!-7%)!%)*,!80&F0!%7T0,!

%)&#:S)!1.!2#<.!20$7:,0!0F0&.!1*++*10%0&!#'!1.!9h`9a!80&F0!M7,!#8!'*&0!'#&!%)0!

20%%0&!-7&%!#'!'#:&!.07&,B!!!

! L)0!9h`9a!80&F0!S0%,!*%,!8710!'&#1!M)0&0!*%!08%0&,!%)0!,-*80!78<!$#880$%,!%#!

%)0!$08%&7+!80&F#:,!,.,%01B!!?%!08%0&,!%)0!,-*80!20%M008!%)0!,*W%)!78<!,0F08%)!

$0&F*$7+!F0&%02&70J!%)0!,17++!2#80,!%)7%!'#&1!%)0!,-*87+!$#+:18B!!L)0!,*W%)!78<!

,0F08%)!$0&F*$7+!F0&%02&70!7&0!$#8,*<0&0<!%)0!+7,%!%M#! F0&% 02&70!#'!%)0!80$TB!!L)0.!

7&0!<0+*$7%0!2#80,!%)7%!7&0!+##,0+.!$#880$%0<!%#!7++#M!'#&!%)0!80$TU,!7&%*$:+7%*#8!78<!

&78S0!#'!1#%*#8B!!=0%M008!07$)!F0&%02&70!*,!7!&:220&.!<*,$!%)7%!7$%,!7,!7!$:,)*#8!'#&!

%)0,0!2#80,B!!L)0,0!<*,$,!7$%!7,!,)#$T!72,#&20&,J!$:,)*#8*8S!%)0!,-*80!'&#1!%)0!<7*+.!

,)#$T,!78<!,%&7*8,!%)7%!7$$#1-78.!%)0!1:8<780!7$%,!#'!1#F*8S!78<!%M*,%*8S!M0!7++!

<#!7,!M0!1#F0!%)&#:S)!%)0!M#&+<B!!;%!%)0!20S*88*8S!#'!345dJ!'#&!&07,#8,!?!,%*++!<#!

8#%!T8#MJ!1.!9h`9a!<*,$!,+*--0<!'&#1!*%,!-+7$0!78<!2:+S0<!*8%#!%)0!+0'%!,*<0!#'!1.!

80$TB!

! C.!2#<.!)7%0<!%)*,B!!?!T8#M!%)*,!20$7:,0!1.!2#<.!17<0!*%,!<*,-+07,:&0!

T8#M8!*8!7!<&717%*$!'7,)*#8J!2.!*8'+71*8S!%)0!%*,,:0!7&#:8<!M)0&0!%)0!<*,$!M7,!8#M!

*87--&#-&*7%0+.!-+7$0<B!!=.!*%,0+'!?!*17S*80!%)*,!M#:+<!)7F0!2008!%#+0&72+0J!*'!8#%!

ih!

$#1'#&%72+0B!!;8!*8$#8F08*08$0J!%#!20!,:&0J!2:%!7!1787S072+0!#80B!!L)0!-&#2+01J!7,!?!

-7*8':++.!<*,$#F0&0<J!M7,!%)0!9h`9a!80&F0B!!Z#&!M)08!1.!9h`9a!<*,$!2:+S0<!#:%!*8%#!

1.!2#<.!78<!1.!2#<.!&0,-#8<0<!2.!*8'+71*8S!%)0!%*,,:0!7&#:8<!1.!<*,$J!*%!

87&&#M0<!%)0!$)7880+!M)0&0!%)0!80&F0!08%0&0<!1.!,-*87+!$#+:18B!!L)0!10<*$7+!

%0&1!'#&!%)*,J!7,!?!+07&80<!'&#1!1.!'*&,%!C>?!&0-#&%J!*,!X,%08#,*,BY!!L)0!,%08#,*,!%)7%!

&0,:+%0<!'&#1!1.!)0&8*7%0<!<*,$!,0F0&0+.!$#1-&0,,0<!1.!9h`9a!80&F0B!!L)*,!

$#1-&0,,*#8!,08%!,07&*8S!-7*8!7++!7+#8S!%)0!+08S%)!#'!1.!+0'%!7&1B!

! @#M!?!M*,)!?!$#:+<!<0,$&*20!%)*,!-7*8!*8!7! <0% 7$)0<J!#2R0$%*F0!M7.B!!?!M*,)!?!

$#:+<!<0,$&*20!1.!-7*8!:,*8S!,#10!,#&%!#'!10%&*$!%)7%!)7,!2008!0,%72+*,)0<!78<!

&0'*80<!*8!%)0!10<*$7+!$#11:8*%.!'#&!<0$7<0,B!!?!$788#%B!!?!$788#%!20$7:,0J!7,!?!

+07&80<!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!,0F0&7+!.07&,!#'!<#$%#&U,!F*,*%,!78<!-).,*$7+!%)0&7-.!

,0,,*#8,J!-7*8!*,!<00-+.!78<!*80W%&*$72+.!,:2R0$%*F0B!!?%!!$788#%!20!72,%&7$%0<!'&#1!

%)0!2#<.!78<!$#1-7&0<!7$&#,,!<*''0&08%!2#<*0,B!!I0!7++!&0,-#8<!%#!$#8<*%*#8,!+*T0!7!

)0&8*7%0<!<*,$!*8!:8*V:0!78<!,-0$*'*$!M7.,B!!I)7%!17.!20!,*1-+.!:8$#1'#&%72+0!'#&!

#80!-0&,#8!$78!20!<02*+*%7%*8S!'#&!78#%)0&B!!L)0!20,%!M7.!%)7%!<#$%#&,!)7F0!

<0F0+#-0<!%#!<0,$&*20!78<!107,:&0!-7*8!*,!%#!7,T!-7%*08%,!%#!$#1-7&0!%)0!*8%08,*%.!

#'!%)0*&!-7*8!%#!%)0*&!-&0F*#:,!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!-7*8!78<!<0%0&1*80!M)0%)0&!*%!*,!

1#&0!#&!+0,,B!!;!54!-#*8%!,$7+0!*,!:,0<J!M*%)!5!1078*8S!X8#!-7*8Y!78<!54!1078*8S!

X%)0!M#&,%!-7*8!.#:!$78!*17S*80BY!!/#!?!M*++!:,0!%)*,!,$7+0J!M*%)!%)0!$7F07%!#'!$#:&,0!

20*8S!%)7%!*%!*,!*1-0&'0$%!78<!*1-&0$*,0B!!!!

! P8!7F0&7S0J!1.!-7*8!+0F0+!)#F0&0<!7&#:8<!7!hB!!L)*,!*,!7!-7*8!%)7%!$788#%!20!

*S8#&0<!#&!'#&S#%%08!M)08!%)0!1*8<!*,!'#$:,0<!#8!#%)0&!%7,T,B!!?%!*,!0F0&!-&0,08%J!

<0178<*8S!7%%08%*#8B!!"0-08<*8S!#8!%)0!0F08%,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!<7.J!%)0!-7*8!M#:+<!

ia!

$+*12!%#!78!i!#&!6B!!?!&010120&!#80!8*S)%!M7+T*8S!*8%#!1.!20<&##1!7%!5!71J!1.!7&1!

#8!'*&0J!M00-*8S!'&#1!-7*8!78<!7,T*8S!1.!-7&%80&!%#!%7T0!10!%#!%)0!<#$%#&!*8!%)0!

1#&8*8S!20$7:,0!?!M7,!7+1#,%!#:%!#'!-7*8!10<*$7%*#8B!!I)08!#8!87&$#%*$,!,:$)!7,!

).<&#$#<#80![1#&0!$#11#8+.!T8#M8!7,!X(0&$#$0%Y\J!%)0!<&:S!?!20,%!&0,-#8<0<!%#J!

1.!-7*8!+0F0+!M#:+<!<*-!%#!7!fB!!L)*,!*,!7!1:$)!1#&0!1787S072+0!+0F0+B!!;!+0F0+!f!-7*8!

$#:+<!20!,):8%0<!%#!%)0!27$T!#'!1.!1*8<!'#&!2&*0'!-0&*#<,!#'!%*10!,#!%)7%!?!$#:+<!

'#$:,!#8!%)0!#%)0&!%7,T,!%)7%!?!800<0<!%#!7 % %08<!%#J!,:$)!7,!M&*%*8S!#&!S&7<*8S!0,,7.,B!!

;%!1.!M#&,%J!?!800<0<!%#!%7T0!7!c1S!%72+0%!#'!).<&#$#<#80!0F0&.!f!)#:&,!%#!

':8$%*#8B!!!

L)*,!%&07%108%J!)#M0F0&J!M7,!8#%!,:,%7*872+0B!!;,!7!87&$#%*$J!).<&#$#<#80!

)7,!7!)*S)!&*,T!#'!7<<*$%*#8!78<!<0-08<08$0J!78<!,#!1.!-&*17&.!$7&0!-).,*$*78!

1#8*%#&0<!1.!*8%7T0!#'!%)0!<&:S!$+#,0+.!#F0&!%)0!<:&7%*#8!#'!1.!%&07%108%!78<!

&0$#F0&.B!!EF0&.!%M#!M00T,!?!M#:+<!800<!%#!,00!)*1!%#!&0$0*F0!78#%)0&!-&0,$&*-%*#8B!!

?8*%*7++.J!M)08!?!M7,!:872+0!%#!,00!)*1!<:0!%#!%)0!)07F.!M#&T+#7<,!#'!7!<#$%#&!

M#&T*8S!7%!7!:8*F0&,*%.!)07+%)!$+*8*$J!?!)7<!%#!S#!%#!M7+T!*8!$7&0!78<!M7*%!78.M)0&0!

'&#1!5!%#!f!)#:&,!%#!,00!78!:8'71*+*7&!<#$%#&!78<!&0V:0,%!7!&0'*++!#'!87&$#%*$,!%#!

,:,%7*8!10!:8%*+!1.!80W%!7--#*8%108%!M*%)!1.!-&*17&.!$7&0!-).,*$*78B!!L)*,J!#'!

$#:&,0J!%&*SS0&0<!$#8$0&8,!71#8S,%!%)0!#%)0&!<#$%#&,!*8!%)0!$+*8*$B!!!L)*,!+07<!%#!10!

)7F*8S!%#!,*S8!7!+0S7+!<#$:108%!,7.*8S!%)7%!?!M#:+<!#8+.!&0V:0,%!87&$#%*$,!'&#1!1.!

-&*17&.!$7&0!-).,*$*78B!!=&07T*8S!%)*,!7S&00108%!M#:+<!&0,:+%!*8!1.!*110<*7%0!

%0&1*87%*#8!7,!)*,!-7%*08%B!!!

L)0,0!0F08%,!M0&0!':&%)0&!$#1-+*$7%0<!2.!1.!108%7+!78<!01#%*#87+!

$#8<*%*#8B!!(&*#&!%#!1.!*8R:&.J!*8!3454J!?!M7,!#''*$*7++.!<*7S8#,0<!M*%)!1#<0&7%0!

ii!

78W*0%.!78<!20S78!%&07%108%B!!L)*,!%&07%108%!$#8,*,%0<!#'!2#%)!10<*$7%*#8!78<!

%)0&7-.B!!=.!%)0!%*10!#'!1.!*8R:&.J!%)0!10<*$7%*#8!M7,!#8S#*8S!2:%!%)0!%)0&7-.!M7,!

8#%B!!;8W*0%.!*,!+*T0!78.!#%)0&!$)&#8*$!*++80,,B!!/#10!<7.,!*%!*,!27&0+.!8#%*$072+0B!!

P%)0&!<7.,J!<:0!%#!F7&*#:,!%&*SS0&,J!*%!$78!20!0W7,-0&7%0<B!!C.!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!

87&$#%*$,J!7,!?!+07&80<J!M7,!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!$#:+<!07,*+.!%&*SS0&!1.!78W*0%.B!!/*%%*8S!*8!

1.!<#$%#&U,!#''*$0!0F0&.!%M#!M00T,!<*,$:,,*8S!1.!-7*8!+0F0+!78<!)#M!178.!-*++,!?!

M#:+<!800<J!?!M#:+<!'00+!<027,0<B!!?!'0+%!+*T0!78!7<<*$%J!20SS*8S!'#&!<&:S,J!7+M7.,!

7'&7*<!%)7%!,#10#80!0+,0!M#:+<!<0$*<0!%)7%!1.!-7*8!M7,!*8,:''*$*08%!%#!&0V:*&0!

%&07%108%B!!?!+07&80<!)#M!%#!-0&'#&1!1.!-7*8!'#&!#%)0&,J!%#!T00-!1.!80$T!,%*++!78<!

:8208%J!%#!)#+<!M)7%0F0&!<0F*$0!?!M7,!+##T*8S!7%!<*&0$%+.!*8!'&#8%!#'!1.!'7$0!&7%)0&!

%)78!*8!7!+7-J!%#!M*8$0!78<!2&07%)0!)07F*+.!M)08!1#F*8S!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!%)0!-7*8B!!?!

M7,!&0+*0F0<!M)08J!'#:&!1#8%),!*8%#!1.!*8R:&.J!1.!'*&,%!C>?!$#8'*&10<!%)7%!1.!9h`

9a!<*,$!M7,!)0&8*7%0<B!!?!8#M!)7<!F*,*2+0!0F*<08$0!%)7%!,#10%)*8S!M7,!M&#8SB!!?!M7,!

8#!+#8S0&!,#+0+.!<0-08<08%!:-#8!1.!'&7S*+0!%0,%*1#8.B!!

L)0,0!'00+*8S,!M#:+<!,:&'7$0!7S7*8!0F0&.!%*10!?!%##T!7!-&0,$&*-%*#8!'#&!

).<&#$#<#80!%#!20!'*++0<!7%!1.!-)7&17$.B!!EF0&.!F*,*%!%)0!'07&!M#:+<!010&S0!k!XL)0.!

M#8U%!S*F0!%)01!%#!10!%)*,!%*10B!!L)0.!M*++!<0$*<0!%)7%!?!)7F0!&07$)0<!1.!+*1*%B!!?!71!

%7T*8S!%##!1:$)BY!!L)0!%)#:S)%,!M#:+<!,-*&7+!78<!$#8%*8:0!%#!,M*&+!:8%*+!?!)7<!%)0!

-*++!2#%%+0!*8!1.!)78<B!!/7'0!'#&!78#%)0&!%M#!M00T,B!!L)08!%)0!-&#$0,,!M#:+<!&0-07%!

7S7*8B!!P8!78<!#''B!!Z#&!'#:&!.07&,B!

L)&#:S)#:%!%)*,!#&<07+J!?!800<0<!%#!M#&TB!!L#!17*8%7*8!1.!)07+%)!*8,:&78$0!

$#F0&7S0J!?!M#&T0<!7,!7!%07$)*8S!7,,#$*7%0!7%!1.!:8*F0&,*%.B!!":&*8S!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!

%)*,!-0&*#<!?!M#&T0<!*8!7!:8*F0&,*%.!'*&,%!.07&!M&*%*8S!-&#S&71J!%07$)*8S!,%:<08%,!%)0!

i6!

':8<7108%7+,!#'!$#++0S0!M&*%*8SB!!?!M7,!0W-0$%0<!%#!%07$)!5!#&!3!$+7,,0,![<0-08<*8S!

#8!%)0!,010,%0&\!#'!5c!,%:<08%,!07$)!7,!M0++!7,!7%%08<!%&7*8*8S!,0,,*#8,!0F0&.!M00TB!!

L)0!S&7<*8S!+#7<!M7,!)07F.!k!%)0!$#:&,0!$#8,*,%0<!#'!f!0,,7.,!20%M008!f!78<!h!

-7S0,!+#8SJ!07$)!M*%)!1:+%*-+0!<&7'%,!%)7%!?!800<0<!%#!$#1108%!#8B!!":0!%#!%)0!

87%:&0!#'!1.!*8R:&.J!%)#:S)J!)#+<*8S!1.!80$T!7%!78!78S+0!'#&!0W%08<0<!-0&*#<,!#'!

%*10!M7,!*87<F*,72+0B!!;8<!,#!M)7%!+*%%+0!080&S.!?!)7<!%#!M#&T!07$)!<7.!M7,!

$#8,:10<!2.!%)0!27&0!1*8*1:1!800<0<!%#!T00-!1.!$+7,,0,!&:88*8SB!!":&*8S!%)*,!

%*10!?!M7,!7+,#!,:--#,0<!%#!20!1#F*8S!'#&M7&<!#8!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#-#,7+J!2:%!

%)7%!M7,!*1-#,,*2+0!S*F08!1.!%07$)*8S!<0178<,B!!?!$#:+<!8#%!100%!%)0!-).,*$7+!78<!

$#S8*%*F0!<0178<,!#'!*8%08,*F0!&07<*8S!78<!M&*%*8SB!!C.!-&#-#,7+!M7,!-+7$0<!#8!

)*7%:,!:8#''*$*7++.J!M)*$)!'0+%!$+#,0!08#:S)!%#!7!'7*+:&0!%#!,%*8SB!!C.!1##<!,:''0&0<B!!

C.!78W*0%.!,-*T0<B!!?!20S78!%#!'00+!<0-&0,,0<B!

C0&$*':++.J!%)0&0!M0&0!0W%08<0<!-0&*#<,!#'!%*10!M)0&0!1.!,.1-%#1,!727%0<!

+#8S!08#:S)!%#!-&#<:$0!,#10!M#&T!#8!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!Z#:&!1#8%),!7'%0&!1.!

*8R:&.!'*&,%!178*'0,%0<!?!:8<0&M08%!7!10<*$7+!-&#$0<:&0!M)0&0!,%0&#*<,!M0&0!

*8R0$%0<!<*&0$%+.!*8%#!1.!,-*80B!!L)*,!<*<!8#%!$#&&0$%!%)0!)0&8*7%0<!<*,$!2:%!*%!<*<!

07,0!%)0!*8'+7117%*#8!7&#:8<!*%!08#:S)!,#!%)7%!%)0!%*,,:0!M7,!8#!+#8S0&!F*#+08%+.!

,V:00]*8S!1.!9h`9a!80&F0B!!;+%)#:S)!?!<*<!8#%!T8#M!*%!7%!%)0!%*10J!%)*,!M#:+<!#8+.!

S&78%!10!72#:%!7!'#:&!1#8%)!&0-&*0F0B!!":&*8S!%)7%!%*10J!?!M7,!72+0!%#!&0,%J!

&0$:-0&7%0J!78<!,+#M+.!2:*+<!:-!1.!%#+0&78$0!'#&!0W%08<0<!-0&*#<,!#'!*8%08,*F0!

&07<*8S!78<!M&*%*8SB!!=:%!R:,%!7,!?!M7,!20S*88*8S!%#!)*%!1.!,%&*<0J!1.!,.1-%#1,!

20S78!%#!&0%:&8B!!P8$0!7S7*8J!1.!+*'0!$#8%&7$%0<!%#!%)0!,*]0!#'!1.!*8R:&.B!!?!&0,:10<!

64!

%7T*8S!).<&#$#<#80J!%07$)*8S!1.!$#:&,0,J!78<!,*%%*8S!F0&.J!F0&.!,%*++!*8!7!&0$+*80&!

M)080F0&!?!$#:+<B!!!

L)*,!$.$+0!#'!-7*8`,%0&#*<,`&0,%!M#:+<!&0-07%!%)&00!%*10,J!M*%)!07$)!-0&*#<!#'!

&0,%!+7,%*8S!20%M008!f!78<!a!1#8%),B!!?!&0$0*F0<!1.!+7,%!,%0&#*<!*8R0$%*#8!*8!

@#F0120&J!345fB!!?%!M7,!1.!+7,%!20$7:,0J!'#&!%)0!'*&,%!%*10J!%)0!*8R0$%*#8!'7*+0<!%#!

)7F0!78.!8#%*$072+0!*1-7$%!#8!1.!-7*8B!!;'%0&!0W)7:,%*8S!0F0&.!#%)0&!-#,,*2*+*%.J!

,:&S0&.!M7,!8#M!1.!#8+.!#-%*#8B!!?!M7,!&0'0&&0<!%#!7!80:&#,:&S0#8J!M)#!7S&00<!

%)7%!78!78%0&*#&!$0&F*$7+!<*,$0$%#1.!78<!%*%78*:1!':,*#8!M7,!80$0,,7&.B!!?8!+7.178U,!

%0&1,J!%)*,!1078%!%)0!,:&S0#8!M#:+<!08%0&!1.!,-*80!%)&#:S)!%)0!'&#8%!#'!1.!80$T!

[+0,,!1:,$+0!%#!$:%!%)&#:S)!1078%!+0,,!-7*8!78<!%)0&0'#&0!7!V:*$T0&!&0$#F0&.\J!$:%!

#:%!%)0!#''08<*8S!<*,$J!<0$#1-&0,,!%)0!80&F0![*B0B!$:%!7M7.!%)0!*&&*%7%*8S!%*,,:0\J!78<!

7%%01-%!%#!,%72*+*]0!%)0!,-*87+!$#+:18!2.!':,*8S!%)0!2#80,!%#S0%)0&!<*&0$%+.!:,*8S!7!

-7,%0!17<0!'&#1!$7<7F0&!2#80!78<!7!,17++!%*%78*:1!-+7%0B!!!

?8!%)0!1*<<+0!#'!Z02&:7&.J!345cJ!?!)7<!1.!'*&,%!#-0&7%*#8B!!C.!-7&%80&!M#:+<!

+7%0&!*8'#&1!10!%)7%!%)0!,:&S0&.!%##T!1:$)!+#8S0&!%)78!M7,!-+7880<!<:0!%#!%)0!

,0F0&*%.!#'!1.!*8R:&.B!!I)08!?!M7,!*8!&0$#F0&.J!%)0!80:&#,:&S0#8!*8'#&10<!)*1!%)7%!

1.!<*,$!M7,!#80!#'!%)0!M#&,%!)0!)7<!0F0&!,008!k!*%!M7,!%M*,%0<!78<!,*80M.!M*%)!

2#80!,-:&,!%)7%!17<0!&01#F*8S!*%!$)7++08S*8SB!!?!71!#<<+.!-&#:<!#'!%)*,B!!;S7*8J!*%!

M7,!%78S*2+0!0F*<08$0!%)7%!%)*,!M7,!8#%!*8!1.!)07<!k!%)7%!?!M7,!8#%!,*1-+.!:,*8S!%)*,!

78!0W$:,0!%#!<#<S0!%)0!<*''*$:+%!M#&T!#'!-&0-7&*8S!7!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!I*%)*8!%)0!10<*$7+!

<*,$#:&,0,!#'!#:&!%*10J!1.!*8R:&.!M7,!T8#M72+0!78<!1.!-7*8!:8<0&,%78<72+0B!!L)0!

2080'*%,!#'!%)*,!$788#%!20!:8<0&0,%*17%0<B!!"0,-*%0!1.!'07&,!78<!78W*0%*0,J!?!M7,!

'#&%:87%0!08#:S)!%#!)7F0!<#$%#&,!M)#J!'#&!%)0!1#,%!-7&%J!20+*0F0<!M)7%!?!,7*<!78<!

65!

<*<!%)0*&!20,%!%#!)0+-!10!'00+!20%%0&B!!?!T8#M!#%)0&,!M)#!)7F0!!8#%!2008!,#!'#&%:87%0!

*8!%)0*&!<07+*8S,!M*%)!10<*$7+!-&#'0,,*#87+,B!

;'%0&!%)7%!'*&,%!,:&S0&.J!?!M7,!#-%*1*,%*$B!!;'%0&!7!1#8%)!#'!-7*<!10<*$7+!+07F0J!

?!&0,:10<!%07$)*8S!78<!M#&T*8S!#8!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#,-0$%:,B!!?!$&07%0<!%)0!

-&#,-0$%:,!:8<0&!%)0!7,,:1-%*#8!%)7%!?!M#:+<!)7F0!7!X8#&17+Y!2#<.!#8$0!?!20S78!

S7%)0&*8S!0F*<08$0B!!L)*,!,0010<!&07,#872+0!k!1.!,:&S0&.!M7,!$#1-+0%0<!78<!?!)7<!

0F0&.!&07,#8!%#!20+*0F0!%)7%!*%!M7,!7!,:$$0,,B!!C.!-7*8!M7,!8#!+#8S0&!#F0&M)0+1*8S!

78<!?!M7,!72+0!%#!M078!1.,0+'!#''!#'!).<&#$#<#80![7!-&#$0,,!%)7%!+7,%0<!%)&00!

1#8%),\B!!?8!1.!-&#,-0$%:,J!?!,%7%0<!%)7%!?!-+7880<!%#!S7%)0&!<7%7!'&#1!-7&%*$*-78%,!

:,*8S!*8%0&F*0M,!78<!#2,0&F7%*#8,!k!$+7,,*$!10%)#<,!'#&!%)0!V:7+*%7%*F0!7:<*08$0!

&0,07&$)!%)7%!?!M7,!-#,*%*#8*8S!1.!-&#R0$%!7,B!!":&*8S!1.!<0'08,0!*8!/0-%0120&!#'!

%)7%!.07&J!?!<#!8#%!&0$7++!78.!#'!1.!$#11*%%00!10120&,!$#1108%*8S!#8!%)#,0!

10%)#<,B!!C#,%!#'!%)0!<*,$:,,*#8!F*,`7`F*,!10%)#<#+#S.!&0F#+F0<!7&#:8<!1.!

&0$&:*%*8S!10%)#<,!78<!)#M!?!M#:+<!*8%0&-0++7%0!78<!<0'*80!%)0!<01#S&7-)*$,!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,![7!-&#$0,,!?!)7F0!<*,$:,,0<!72#F0\B!!C.!10%)#<,!'#&!S7%)0&*8S!<7%7J!#8!

%)0!#%)0&!)78<J!M0&0!,#!$#8F08%*#87+!7,!%#!20!:8&017&T72+0B!!P%)0&!,%:<*0,!+*T0!1.!

,%:<.!)7<!$#++0$%0<!<7%7!%)*,!M7.!78<!M 0&0! ,:$$0,,':+J!,#!*%!'#++#M0<!%)7%!%)0,0!

10%)#<,!M0&0!7--&#-&*7%0B!

P8$0!%)7%!M7,!'*8*,)0<J!?!20S78!%)0!$)7++08S*8S!%7,T,!#'!&0$&:*%*8S!

-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!*8%0&F*0M*8S!%)01B!!":&*8S!%)*,!-0&*#<J!%)#:S)J!?!M#:+<!7+,#!+07&8!

%)7%!1.!&0$#F0&.!'&#1!%)0!,:&S0&.!%)7%!?!%)#:S)%!M#:+<!<0'*8*%0+.!&0,#+F0!1.!2#<*+.!

-&#2+01,!M7,!8#%!S#*8S!M0++B!!C.!2#<.J!*%!,001,J!M7,!&0R0$%*8S!%)0!,-*87+!':,*#8B!!

L)0!,-*87+!':,*#8!M7,!80$0,,7&.!%#!,%72*+*]0!%)0!,-*87+!$#+:18B!!P%)0&M*,0!?!&*,T0<!

63!

)7F*8S!1.!,-*80!$#++7-,0!<#M8!#8%#!1.!27%%0&0<!9h`9a!80&F0J!,08<*8S!10!27$T!%#!

,V:7&0!#80B!!;,!?!,7*<!20'#&0J!%)0!':,*#8!M7,!7%%01-%0<!:,*8S!<#87%0<!$7<7F0&!2#80B!!

C.!2#<.!<*<!8#%!+*T0!%)*,J!7--7&08%+.J!78<!,*1-+.!72,#&20<!%)0!2#80!M*%)#:%!':,*8SJ!

+07F*8S!1.!,-*80!*8!7!-&0$7&*#:,!-#,*%*#8B!!EF08!:,*8S!7!10<*$7+!<0F*$0!$7++0<!7!2#80!

S&#M%)!,%*1:+7%#&!7$$#1-+*,)0<!8#%)*8SB!!;8#%)0&!,:&S0&.!M7,!800<0<B!!?!,$)0<:+0<!

*%!'#&!%)0!+7,%!<7.!#'!Z02&:7&.J!345hJ!7!+*%%+0!1#&0!%)78!7!.07&!7'%0&!1.!-&0F*#:,!

,:&S0&.B!

L)*,!,:&S0&.!M#:+<!20!1:$)!1#&0!%&7:17%*$J!2#%)!-).,*$7++.!78<!

01#%*#87++.B!!?8,%07<!#'!78!78%0&*#&!<*,$0$%#1.J!1.!,:&S0#8,!M#:+<!800<!%#!-0&'#&1!

7!-#,%0&*#&!,:&S0&.B!!L)*,!1078%!%)0.!M#:+<!)7F0!%#!$:%!*8%#!1.!,-*80!'&#1!%)0!27$TJ!

M*%)!7++!#'!*%,!7%%08<78%!1:,$+0,B!!;+,#J!&7%)0&!%)78!:,0!$7<7F0&!2#80!%#!-0&'#&1!%)0!

':,*#8J!%)0.!M#:+<!:,0!2#80!0W%&7$%0<!'&#1!1.!)*-J!M)*$)!1078%!78#%)0&!*8$*,*#8!*8!

1.!+#M0&!27$TJ!M*%)!7++!#'!"'(!7%%08<78%!1:,$+0,B!!L)*,!&0,:+%0<!*8!7!1:$)!1#&0!

*8%08,*F0!&0$#F0&.B!!>7%)0&!%)78!S#*8S!)#10!%)7%!<7.J!?!M#:+<!800<!%#!,%7.!*8!%)0!

)#,-*%7+!#F0&8*S)%!%#!17T0!,:&0!%)7%!1.!-7*8!+0F0+,!M0&0!1787S072+0B!!P8$0!?!M7,!

<*,$)7&S0<J!?!M#:+<!800<!%#!,-08<!7!,*S8*'*$78%!-0&*#<!#'!%*10![1#&0!%)78!%)0!1#8%)!

?!)7<!,-08%!-&0F*#:,+.\!&0,%*8SB!!@#!0W0&$*,0B!!@#!<&*F*8SB!!C.!<7.,!#8$0!7S7*8!

$#8,*,%0<!#'!20*8S!F0&.J!F0&.!,%*++B!!;2#:%!7++!?!$#:+<!1787S0!%#!<#!%)&#:S)!%)0!)7]0!

#'!87&$#%*$,!M7,!M7%$)!%0+0F*,*#8B!!EF08!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!M7,!%##!#F0&M)0+1*8S!

k!1.!1:,$+0,!M#:+<!%08,0!'&#1!%)0!0W$*%0108%!78<!0W7$0&27%0!1.!-7*8B!

;S7*8J!%)&#:S)#:%!7++!#'!%)*,J!-&#S&0,,!#8!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!

M7,!*1-#,,*2+0B!!?!$#:+<!27&0+.!+07F0!1.!20<J!+0%!7+#80!&0$&:*%!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!

$#8<:$%!*8%0&F*0M,B!!L)0!*11#2*+*%.!78<!<:++80,,!20S78!%#!,*S8*'*$78%+.!*1-7*&!1.!

6d!

1##<B!!;,!7!S##<!,%:<08%J!?!)7<!:8<0&0,%*17%0<!)#M!$08%&7+!1.!-&#<:$%*F*%.!)7<!

2008!%#!1.!,08,0!#'!,0+'`M#&%)B!!@#MJ!M*%)!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!,$&00$)*8S!%#!7!)7+%!

'#&!%)0!'#&0,0072+0!':%:&0J!?!'0+%!M#&%)+0,,B!!?!M7,!8#%!M#&T*8SB!!?!M7,!8#%!07&8*8S!

1#80.B!!?!M7,!,*%%*8S!7++!<7.J!'00+*8S!+*T0!7!2:&<08!7,!1.!-7&%80&!M08%!%#!M#&T!78<!

%##T!$7&0!#'!10B!!;+&07<.!-&#80!%#!78W*0%.J!?!8#M!,+*--0<!*8%#!7!<00-!<0-&0,,*#8B!!=.!

%)0!'#++#M*8S!N:80J!,*1-+.!+07F*8S!1.!20<!M7,!78!0''#&%B!!?!<*,%*8$%+.!&010120&!#80!

<7.J!7%!#&!807&!1.!+#M0,%J!M)08!?!,-08%!,*W!)#:&,!%&.*8S!%#!1#%*F7%0!1.,0+'!08#:S)!

%#!%7T0!7!,)#M0&B!!/*W!)#:&,!%0++*8S!1.,0+'!%#!S0%!:-J!)#-!*8!%)0!,)#M0&J!.#:!<#8U%!

0F08!)7F0!%#!M7,)!.#:&!)7*&J!R:,%!%:&8!#8!%)0!M7%0&B!!/*W!)#:&,!'*S)%*8S!%)0!<&07<!

%)7%!%)7%!%7,T!,:11#80<!M*%)*8!*8B!!I)7%!*,!:,:7++.!7!,#:&$0!#'!&0+*0'!78<!&080M7+!

'#&!178.!20$710!78!*1-#,,*2+0!%7,T!'#&!10B!!?!1*S)%!7,!M0++!)7F0!2008!%&.*8S!%#!

$+*12!7!,)00&!$+*''!*8!%)0!&7*8B!!;'%0&!,*W!)#:&,!#'!%&.*8S!%#!$#7$)!1.,0+'!*8%#!7!,)#M0&J!

?!S7F0!:-B!!?%!M7,!%)08!%)7%!%)0!M&#8S80,,!#'!%)*,!,*%:7%*#8!$&.,%7++*]0<B!!L)*,!M7,!8#%!

)#M!?!%.-*$7++.!&0,-#8<0<!%#!%)*8S,B!!L)*,!M7,!8#%!8#&17+B!!K7%0&!%)7%!M00TJ!7%!%)0!

,:SS0,%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%80&J!?!$#8%7$%0<!1.!'#&10&!%)0&7-*,%!78<!,$)0<:+0<!78!

7--#*8%108%!%#!100%!M*%)!)0&B!!;%!1.!%)0&7-*,%U,!,:SS0,%*#8J!?!7+,#!10%!M*%)!7!

-,.$)*7%&*$!10<*$*80!-&0,$&*20&!78<!&0F*,0<!1.!10<*$7%*#8!*8%7T0B!!=.!N78:7&.J!

345aJ!M0!)7<!'*87++.!)*%!:-#8!7!$#12*87%*#8!#'!%)0&7-.!78<!10<*$7%*#8!0''0$%*F0!

08#:S)!'#&!10!%#!1#F0!%)&#:S)#:%!1.!<7.!M*%)#:%!'00+*8S!7!$&:,)*8S!<&07<!7%!%)0!

%)#:S)%!#'!-0&'#&1*8S!%)0!,*1-+0,%!#'!%7,T,B!!?%!M7,!7+,#!7&#:8<!%)*,!%*10!%)7%!?!

&0$0*F0<!M#&<!'&#1!1.!80:&#,:&S0#8B!!L)0!,:&S0&.!M7,!7!,:$$0,,B!!C.!,-*80!)7<!

':,0<B!!?!M7,!#''*$*7++.!)07+0<B!!!

6f!

L)&#:S)#:%!1.!&0$#F0&.J!78!*17S0!T0-%!7--07&*8S!%#!10!%)7%!'0+%!+*T0!%)0!

20,%!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!#'!1.!,*%:7%*#8B!!?%!)0+-0<!10!%#!:8<0&,%78<!1.!,*%:7%*#8J!%#!

$#8%&#+!78<!<0+*1*%!*%B!!?!,7M!1.,0+'!,%78<*8S!*8!7!2+7$T!,-7$0B!!(0&)7-,!*%!M7,!%)0!

2#%%#1!#'!7!-*%B!!>0S7&<+0,,J!%)0!,-7$0!)7<!7!'+##&!78<!*%!'0+%!+*T0!%)0!2#%%#1!#'!

(.@/'2"#1B!!;++!7&#:8<!10J!,%&0%$)*8S!7,!'7&!7,!?!$#:+<!,00J!M7,!%)0!2&#T08!S+7,,!#'!

1.!+*'0B!!Z&#1!%)0!%*10!?!M7,!<*7S8#,0<!M*%)!1.!)0&8*7%0<!<*,$!78<J!,:2,0V:08%+.J!

<0-&0,,*#8J!1.!+*'0!M7,!*8!7!$#8,%78%!,%7%0!#'!,)7%%0&*8SB!!=:%J!*8!+7%0!345hJ!7+1#,%!f!

.07&,!7'%0&!1.!1#108%!#'!*8R:&.J!?!20S78!%#!'00+!+*T0!?!$#:+<!,%7&%!$+078*8S!:-!%)0!

,)7&<,B!!;8<!%)7%!*,!M)7%!?!71!,%*++!<#*8SB!

/#J!%#!,:117&*]0!%)0!%*10+*80!%)7%!?!)7F0!0,%72+*,)0<G!

• N78:7&.!345dG!?8R:&.!

• C7.!345dG!Z*&,%!,%0&#*<!*8R0$%*#8l!%01-#&7&.!&0$#F0&.!

• /0-%0120&!345dG!/.1-%#1,!&0%:&8!

• @#F0120&!345dG!/0$#8<!,%0&#*<!*8R0$%*#8l!%01-#&7&.!&0$#F0&.!

• /0-%0120&!345fG!/.1-%#1,!&0%:&8!

• @#F0120&!345fG!L)*&<!,%0&#*<!*8R0$%*#8l!8#!&0$#F0&.!

• Z02&:7&.!345cG!Z*&,%!/:&S0&.!

• /0-%0120&!345cG!/:$$0,,':+!(&#,-0$%:,!"0'08,0l!<7%7!$#++0$%*#8!

$#1108$0,!

• "0$0120&!345cG!Z*&,%!,:&S0&.!$+7,,*'*0<!7,!7!'7*+:&0l!<7%7!$#++0$%*#8!

*8%0&&:-%0<!*8<0'*8*%0+.!

• Z02&:7&.!345hG!/0$#8<!/:&S0&.!

• N:80!345hG!P''*$*7++.!<*7S8#,0<!M*%)!<0-&0,,*#8l!%&07%108%!

$#1108$0,!

• "0$0120&!345hG!>0$#F0&.!

I).!<#!?!<*,$:,,!%)*,g!!I)7%!*,!*%,!&0+0F78$0!%#!%)*,!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%g!!I)7%!*,!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0!T8#M+0<S0!$#8,%&:$%0<!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!

&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!78<!%)0!2#<.!%)7%!$#8,%&:$% 0<!*%g!!L#!-:%!*%!,*1-+.J!1.!2#<.!78<!*%,!

M#:8<,!78<!$)01*$7+!*127+78$0,!<0%0&1*80<!%)0!2#:8<7&*0,!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!

6c!

78<!%)0!10%)#<,!7F7*+72+0!%#!10B!!":0!%#!1.!2#<.U,!$#8<*%*#8J!?!$#:+<!8#%!#8+.!

$#8,*<0&!M)7%!V:7+*%7%*F0!%##+,!M0&0!20,%!,:*%0<!%#!78,M0&!1.!-&#-#,0<!&0,07&$)!

V:0,%*#8,B!!C.!-&#$0,,!)7<!%#!20!1#&0!*%0&7%*F0!78<!$#8,*<0&7%0!#'!1.!2#<.U,!

$#8<*%*#8B!!L#!*++:,%&7%0J!?!M*++!<0,$&*20!%)0!$#8%0W%!,:&&#:8<*8S!1.!<0$*,*#8!%#!:,0!

#8+*80!V:7+*%7%*F0!,:&F0.,!%#!S7%)0&!<7%7!#8!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!

78<!*8%0&*#&!-0&,-0$%*F0,B!!!

?8!1.!#&*S*87+!-&#,-0$%:,J!?!)7<!-&#-#,0<!%#!S7%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%!<7%7!:,*8S!

*8%0&F*0M,B!!L)*,!10%)#<!)7,!7!+#8S!78<!M0++!&0$0*F0<!)*,%#&.!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!10<*7!

7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)B!!;+,#J!S*F08!1.!*8%0&0,%,!*8!-0#-+0,U!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,!78<!

*8%0&*#&!%)#:S)%!-&#$0,,0,J!?!20+*0F0<!%)7%!*8%0&F*0M,!M0&0!%)0!20,%!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!

7<<&0,,!1.!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,!<:0!%#!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!$&07%0!7!<*7+#S:0!20%M008!

&0,07&$)0&!78<!-7&%*$*-78%!78<!-#%08%*7++.!$&07%0!7!1#&0!%0W%:&0<!78<!,:&-&*,*8S!

7$$#:8%!%)78!#%)0&!10%)#<,J!,:$)!7,!,:&F0.J!$#:+<!$#8,%&:$%B!!A#M0F0&J!?!80S+0$%0<!

%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!&#+0!#'!1.!2#<.!*8!$#8,%&:$%*8S!%)*,!<7%7J!,-0$*'*$7++.!%)0!<0178<,!

%)7%!,:$)!7!10%)#<!M#:+<!-+7$0!#8!1.!2#<.B!!?8%0&F*0M,J!M)*+0!8#%!%)0!1#,%!

-).,*$7++.!<0178<*8S!0W0&$*,0!*17S*872+0J!,%*++!)7F0!7!,*S8*'*$78%!-).,*$7+!

$#1-#808%J!7!-).,*$7+!$#1-#808%!%)7%!7!1#&0!8#&17%*F0!2#<.!$#:+<!07,*+.!)78<+0!

78<!%):,!*S8#&0B!!Z#&!#80J!*8%0&F*0M,!&0V:*&0!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!%#!20!-&0,08%!M*%)!%)0!

-7&%*$*-78%!*8!,#10!'7,)*#8B!!":0!%#!1.!-).,*$7+!+*1*%7%*#8,J!*8`-0&,#8!*8%0&F*0M,!

M0&0!7!%&0108<#:,!):&<+0!7,!%)0.!M#:+<!&0V:*&0!10!%#!<&*F0!%#!78!7S&00<!:-#8!

+#$7%*#8!78<!,*%!*8!78!:8T8#M8!08F*&#8108%!'#&!7%!+07,%!78!)#:&J!%)08!<&*F0!27$T!

)#10B!!L)0!#%)0&!#-%*#8J!%0+0`$#8'0&08$*8S!F*7!%0+0-)#80!#&!#8+*80!*8%0&'7$0,!!,:$)!

7,!;--+0U,!Z7$0%*10J!Q##S+0U,!S$)7%J!#&!/T.-0J!M#:+<!20!1#&0!1787S072+0!2:%!7+,#!

6h!

01#%*#87++.!<0178<*8SB!!Z#&!&07,#8,!?!<#!8#%!':++.!:8<0&,%78<J!%0+0`$#8'0&08$*8S!

7$%*F7%0,!1.!78W*0%.!'7&!1#&0!%)78!'7$0`%#`'7$0!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!<#B!!/*8$0!?!M7,!

7+&07<.!0W%&010+.!01#%*#87++.!'&7S*+0!M)08!?!'0+%!&07<.!%#!20S*8!$#++0$%*8S!<7%7J!%0+0`

$#8'0&08$*8S!78<!*%,!7$$#1-78.*8S!78W*0%.!,-*T0!M7,!<7:8%*8SB!

I)7%!'*87++.!0+*1*87%0<!*8%0&F*0M,!7,!78!#-%*#8J!%)#:S)J!M7,!%)0!0''#&%!

&0V:*&0<!%#!%&78,'#&1!%)0!*8%0&F*0M,!*8%#!7!'#&1!%)7%!$#:+<!20!07,*+.!787+.]0<B!!

/*8$0!*8%0&F*0M,J!M)0%)0&!$#8<:$%0<!*8!-0&,#8!#&!F*7!%0+0`$#8'0&08$*8SJ!#$$:&!

%)&#:S)!%)0!10<*:1!#'!,-00$)J!*%!*,!80$0,,7&.!%#!&0$#&<!%)01!,#!%)7%!%)0.!$78!20!

787+.]0<!7%!7!+7%0&!<7%0B!!?8!#&<0&!%#!'7$*+*%7%0!%)*,J!*8%0&F*0M,!7&0!%.-*$7++.!

%&78,$&*20<!*8%#!7!,$&*-%!,#!%)7%!%)0.!$78!20!$#<0<!78<!8#%7%0<B!!L&78,$&*2*8SJ!

)#M0F0&J!*,!7!%&0108<#:,!-).,*$7+!:8<0&%7T*8S!'#&!,#10#80!M)#,0!80$T!*,!

$#1-&#1*,0<B!!;!#80!%#!%M#!)#:&!*8%0&F*0M!$#:+<!%7T0!10!:-M7&<,!#'!'*F0!)#:&,!%#!

%&78,$&*20J!<0-08<*8S!#8!F7&*#:,!'7$%#&,B!!C:+%*-+.!%)7%!2.!d4![%)0!S080&7+!8:120&!

#'!*8%0&F*0M,!%)7%!?!M7,!7*1*8S!'#&\J!78<!.#:!)7F0!5c4!)#:&,!#'!+72#&!<0F#%0<!%#!

,*1-+.!%&78,'#&1*8S!1.!<7%7!*8%#!7!:,072+0!,%7%0B!!L)7%!*,!5c4!)#:&,!#'!,*%%*8S!*8!

'&#8%!#'!7!$#1-:%0&!78<!%.-*8SJ!<0+0%*8SJ!'7,%!'#&M7&<*8SJ!&0M*8<*8SJ!78<!,+#M*8S!

<#M8B!!EF08!M*%)!78!0&S#8#1*$!M#&T!,%7%*#8!0,%72+*,)0<J!?!T80M!%)7%!%)*,!71#:8%!#'!

+72#&!M7,!%##!2:&<08,#10!'#&!1.!2#<.B!!

?!+7*<!#:%!%)0,0!*,,:0,!M*%)!1.!7<F*,#&!78<!,)0!7S&00<!%)7%J!*8!1.!-&0,08%!

$#8<*%*#8J!*8%0&F*0M,!M#:+<!20!8*S)!*1-#,,*2+0B!!>7%)0&!%)78!7278<#8!%)0!&0,07&$)!

-&#R0$%J!%)#:S)J!?!<0$*<0<!%#!)#8#&!1.!+*1*%7%*#8,!78<!,00T!#:%!7+%0&87%*F0!10%)#<,!

'#&!S7%)0&*8S!%)0!%.-0!#'!<7%7!?!800<0<B!!L)0!10%)#<!%)7%!,0010<!%)0!1#,%!

-&#1*,*8S!M7,!#8+*80!V:7+*%7%*F0!,:&F0.,B!!L)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!%)0!,:&F0.!M7,!

6a!

&0+7%*F0+.!,*1-+0!k!?!,*1-+.!7<7-%0<!1.!*8%0&F*0M!,$)0<:+0J!M)*$)!#8+.!&0V:*&0<!

,#10!,17++!7<R:,%108%,!78<!1#<*'*$7%*#8,!%#!M#&<*8S![,00!;--08<*W!;!'#&!7!$#-.!#'!

1.!,:&F0.\B!!>0$&:*%108%!7+,#!M7,!'7$*+*%7%0<!2.!:,*8S!78!#8+*80!,:&F0.B!!?8,%07<!#'!

%&.*8S!%#!$##&<*87%0!7!%*10!78<!-+7$0!M)0&0!2#%)!?!78<!7!-7&%*$*-78%!$#:+<!20!

-&0,08%!,*1:+%780#:,+.J!?!M7,!72+0!%#!$&07%0!7!,:&F0.!:,*8S!/:&F0.C#8T0.!78<!

<*,%&*2:%0!7!+*8T!%#!%)0!,:&F0.!%)&#:S)!F7&*#:,!$)7880+,J!*8$+:<*8S!%)0!,#$*7+!10<*7!

7$$#:8%,!#'!1.,0+'!78<!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!L)*,!0872+0<!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!%7T0!:-!%)0!

,:&F0.!7%!%)0*&!+0*,:&0!7,!M0++!7,!*8%0&&:- %!78<!&0%:&8!%#!%)0!,:&F0.!,)#:+<!%)0.!800<!

%#B!!L)*,!M7,!7!$#8,*<0&72+0!7<F78%7S0!,*8$0!%)0!,:&F0.!M7,!V:*%0!+#8SB!!?%!$#8%7*80<!

3h!#-08`08<0<!V:0,%*#8,!78<!%##T!7&#:8<!78!)#:&!%#!$#1-+0%0![7$$#&<*8S!%#!7!

,71-+0!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,\B!!A7F*8S!1.!,:&F0.!0W*,%!#8!7!M02,*%0!%)7%!0872+0<!:,0&,!

%#!+#S!*8!78<!#:%!01-#M0&0<!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!1#&0!07,*+.!2&07T!<#M8!78<!,+#%!%)0!

,:&F0.!*8%#!%)0*&!#M8!,-0$*'*$!,$)0<:+0,J!M)*$)!)0+-0<!1*%*S7%0!%)0!)#:&!+#8S!

<0178<!#'!%)0!':++!,:&F0.!78<!%):,!)0+-0<!08,:&0!7!)*S)!$#1-+0%*#8!&7%0!#'!%)0!

,:&F0.B!

P'!$#:&,0J!7!,:&F0.!*,!8#%!M*%)#:%!*%,!+*1*%7%*#8,B!!":0!%#!%)0!7,.8$)&#8#:,!

87%:&0!#'!%)0!,:&F0.!78<!%)0!78#8.1*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!M7,!:872+0!%#!7,T!

'#++#M!:-!V:0,%*#8,!%#!$+7&*'.!78<!<00-08!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,B!!I)7%!?!,7M!

M7,!M)7%!?!S#%B!!/*1*+7&+.J!78.!$#8':,*#8!7!-7&%*$*-78%!17.!)7F0!)7<!72#:%!7!

V:0,%*#8!?!M7,!7,T*8S!$#:+<!8#%!20!07,*+.!&010<*0<B!!N:,%!7,!?!)7<!%#!&0+.!,#+0+.!#8!1.!

#M8!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!7!-7&%*$*-78%U,!78,M0&,J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!$#:+<!#8+.!&0+.!#8!

%)0*&!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8,!#'!1.!V:0,%*#8,B!!L)*,!'&7$%:&0<!#:&!72*+*%.!%#!$#`$#8,%&:$%!

1078*8S!78<!*8%&#<:$0<!7!$0&%7*8!71#:8%!#'!712*S:*%.!*8%#!1.!<7%7B!!!

6i!

;+,#J!%)0!7,.8$)&#8#:,!0+0108%!#'!%)0!,:&F0.!78<!%)0!78#8.1*%.!S:7&78%00<!

%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!1078%!%)7%!-#%08%*7+!%78S08%,!*8%&#<:$0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

$#:+<!8#%!20!':&%)0&!0W-+#&0<!#&!<0F0+#-0<B!!L)0!<*7+#S*$!87%:&0!#'!'7$0`%#`'7$0!

*8%0&7$%*#8,!$78!#'%08!S*F0!&*,0!%#!%#-*$,!78<!'00+*8S,!:878%*$*-7%0<!2.!%)0!

&0,07&$)0&B!!L)0!&0,07&$)0&!$78!%)08!<0$*<0!%#!0*%)0&!0W-+ #&0! %)0,0!%78S08%,!':&%)0&!

#&!+07F0!%)01!20!,)#:+<!%)0.!20!%##!'7&!7'*0+<!'&#1!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!S#7+,!#'!%)0!

&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!L)*,!&0<:$0,!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!#'!,:&-&*,0J!#'!08$#:8%0&*8S!% )0!

:878%*$*-7%0<!78<!:8'#&0,008!*8!7!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%J!M)*$)!$78!#'%08!20!7!S&07%!

#--#&%:8*%.!%#!':&%)0&!<0F0+#-!78<!$#1-+*$7%0!#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

-)08#108#8!78<!)#M!M0!%)0#&*]0!*%B!!L)7%!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!?!<*<!8#%!08$#:8%0&!

,:&-&*,0,!M)08!787+.]*8S!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,B!!?!72,#+:%0+.!<*<J!7,!?!M*++!

<*,$:,,!*8!+7%0&!$)7-%0&,B!!A#M0F0&J!%)#,0!,:&-&*,0,!$#:+<!8#%!20!:,0<!%#!':&%)0&!

<0F0+#-!78<!&0'*80!+7%0&!-7&%*$*-78%!08$#:8%0&,J!78<!,#!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!*1-7$%!%)0!

%&7R0$%#&.!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!M7,!,:2,0V:08%+.!+*1*%0<B!

D0%!M)7%!M7,!S7*80<!%)&#:S)!#8+*80!,:&F0.,g!!Z#&!#80J!?!M7,!72+0!%#!S7%)0&!

1#&0!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)78!?!)7<!*8*%*7++.!-&#R0$%0<J!%):,!*8$&07,*8S!1.!72*+*%.!%#!

&0$#S8*]0!,*S8*'*$78%!-7%%0&8,!2.!S*F*8S!10!1#&0!<7%7!%#!M#&T!M*%)B!!;8#%)0&!2080'*%!

M7,!7!S&07%0&!07,0!*8!$#1-7&*8S!%)0!&0,-#8,0,!#'!<*''0&08%!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8%0&F*0M,!

$78!#'%08!'00+!(6"&1/#/3"(J!7,!07$)!*8%0&F*0M!%7T0,!#8!*%,!#M8!,)7-0!78<!'#&1!7,!%)0!

$#8F0&,7%*#8!:8'#+<,B!!;,!,:$)J!*%!$78!20!<*''*$:+%!%#!$#1-7&0!%)0!&0,-#8,0,!#'!

<*''0&08%!-7&%*$*-78%,J!7,!%)0&0!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!<*''0&08$0,!2 0% M008!N2$'!%)0!

-7&%*$*-78%,!7&0!&0,-#8<*8S!%#B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!7!-&#2+01!'#&!#8+*80!,:&F0.,J!%)#:S)J!

M)*$)!S:7&78%00,!%)7%!7++!-7&%*$*-78%,!7&0!7%!+07,%!&0,-#8<*8S!%#!%)0!,710!V:0,%*#8,J!

66!

M#&<0<!*8!%)0!0W7$%!,710!M7.B!!L)*,!M7,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!2080'*$*7+!'#&!1.!-&#R0$%J!

M)*$)!*,!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!)#M!<*''0&08%!,#$*7+!$#8%0W%,!78<!*<08%*%*0,!,)7-0!-0#-+0U,!

F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

=:%!-0&)7-,!%)0!S&07%0,%!7''#&<78$0!#'!%)0!#8+*80!,:&F0.J!%)#:S)J!M7,!%)0!

72*+*%.!%#!$#8%*8:0!M*%)!1.!&0,07&$)B!":0!%#!%)0!-).,*$7+!<0178<,!#'!*8%0&F*0M*8SJ!?!

&*,T0<!20*8S!*8$7-72+0!#'!$#1-+0%*8S!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!*'!?!*8,*,%0<!#8!<#*8S!

*8%0&F*0M,B!!C.!2#<.!M7,![78<!,%*++!*,\!:8&:+.!78<!:8-&0<*$%72+0B!!I)*+0!?!M7,J!'#&!

%)0!1#,%!-7&%J!)07+%).!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!S7%)0&*8S!78<!787+.]*8S!<7%7J!?!)7<!

8#!M7.!#'!-&0<*$%*8S!%)7%!%)7%!M#:+<!20!%)0!$7,0B!!I)08!7$$#:8%*8S!'#&!%)0!&*,T!#'!

':&%)0&!<02*+*%7%*#8!78<!*8$7-7$*%7%*#8J!?!<0$*<0<!%)7%!,#10!T8#M+0<S0!M7,!20%%0&!

%)78!8#!T8#M+0<S0!7%!7++B!

L)*,!2&*8S,!10!%#!M)7%!?!'00+!7&0!%)0!,*S8*'*$78%!%7T07M7.,!#'!1.!0W-0&*08$0!

-0&'#&1*8S!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!M*%)!78!:8&:+.J!*8R:&0<!2#<.B!!I)7%!'#++#M,!7&0!1.!

7%%01-%,!%#!%)0#&*]0!1.!0W-0&*08$0!78<!0W%&7-#+7%0!%)0!$#&0!*<07,!%)7%!M*++!*8'#&1!

[)#-0':++.\!)#M!?!-0&'#&1!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!*8!,:2,0V:08%!-&#R0$%,B!!L)0,0!7&0!

8#%!X20,%!-&7$%*$0,JY!20$7:,0!7,!?!)7F0!,%7%0<!-&0F*#:,+.!?!20+*0F0!%)7%!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!

X20,%!-&7$%*$0,Y!-&0,:10,!7!-7&%*$:+7&J!8#&17+*]0<!2#<.B!!L)0.!7&0!*8,%07<!#8S#*8S!

*,,:0,!%)7%!?!'00+!1.!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)J!78<!-0&)7-,!7++!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)J!M#:+<!

2080'*%!'&#1!08S7S*8S!M*%)B!

L)0!'*&,%!*<07!*,!%)7%!2#<*0,!7&0!7+07%#&.!78<!:8,%72+0J!7,!#--#,0<!%#!'*W0<!

78<!,%72+0B!!;,!1.!,%#&.!,)#M,J!1.!2#<.!1#F0<!%)&#:S)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!,%7%0,!#F0&!%)0!

$#:&,0!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!k!'&#1!*8R:&.!%#!%&07%108%!%#!&0$#F0&.B!!L)*,!M7,!8#%!7!

+*807&!-&#$0,,J!2:%!78!*%0&7%*F0!#80B!!?!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!1#F0!27$T!78<!'#&%)!

544!

20%M008!%)0,0!F7&*#:,!,%7%0,J!7++!%)0!M)*+0!)7F*8S!%#!17T0!<0$*,*#8,!72#:%!%)0!,)7-0!

#'!1.!-&#R0$%!:8<0&!%)0,0!,)*'%*8S!$#8<*%*#8,B!!L)*,!*,!*8!+*80!M*%)!-#,%,%&:$%:&7+!

'01*8*,%!%)0#&*]*8S!#'!%)0!2#<.!78<!012#<*108%![0BSB!=7%%0&,2.J!5666l!=*&T0J!5666l!

=:%+0&J!5666\J!M)*$)!0W-+*$*%+.!&0,*,%,!&0-&0,08%*8S!%)0!2#<.!7,!7!'*W0<J!,#+*<!08%*%.B!!

Z#&!0W71-+0J!=*&T0![5666\!7&S:0,!'#&!78!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!2#<.!7,!7!,0+'`

#&S78*]*8S!08%*%.!%)7%!&0,-#8<,!%#!$)78S0,!*8!%)0!08F*&#8108%!*8!78!7$%*F0!M7.!

&7%)0&!%)78!,*1-+.!%)0!-7,,*F0!:8'#+<*8S!#'!7!S080%*$!2+:0-&*8%B!!/*1*+7&+.J!=7%%0&,2.!

[5666\!)7,!7&S:0<!%)7%!M0!,)#:+<!%)*8T!#'!%)0!2#<.!7,!7!X<*,,*-7%*F0!,.,%01Y!*8!

&0+7%*#8!%#!*%,!08F*&#8108%J!M)0&0!<*''0&08%*7+,!#'!080&S.!'+#M,!$7:,0!80M!,%7%0,!#&!

'#&1,!%#!*&&:-%!#:%!#'!-#%08%*7+*%*0,B!!L)0,0!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!#'!%)0!2#<.!$)7++08S0!

%&7<*%*#87+!$#8$0-%*#8,!#'!%)0!2#<.!7,!M0++!7,!*%,!2#:8<7&*0,!78<!%)0!$#8$#1*%78%!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,0+'!78<!#%)0&B!!@#! +#8S0&!78!#--#,*%*#8J!,0+'!7 8<!#% )0&!0W*,%!*8!

7!1:%:7++.!<0%0&1*8*8S!&0+7%*#8,)*-!7,!2#%)!*8'#&1!#80!78#%)0&B!!!

;8#%)0&!%7T07M7.!'&#1!1.!0W-0&*08$0!*,!%)7%!%)0!2#<.!)7,!78!7S08$.!#'!*%,!

#M8!78<!*,!8#%!,*1-+.!%)0!X-&#-0&%.!#'!%)0!1*8<`,0+'Y![E++*8S,#8J!344hJ!-B!d4h\B!!?8!

%&7<*%*#87+!&0,07&$)!7$$#:8%,J!&0,07&$)0&,!%08<!%#!01-)7,*]0!%)0!108%7+!-&#$0,,0,!

78<!<0$*,*#8,!%)7%!,)7-0<!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0J!%)0!

108%7+o*8%0++0$%:7+!7,-0$%,!#'!%)0#&*]*8SJ!<7%7!$#++0$%*#8J!78<!787+.,*,!7&0!-&*F*+0S0<!

7,!%)0!1#,%!*1-#&%78%!$)7++08S0,!%)7%!&0,07&$)0&,!M&0,%+0!M*%)!M)08!$#8,%&:$%*8S!7!

&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!L)0!2#<.!#'!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!*,!&7&0+.!&0- &0,08 %0<!*8!&0,07&$)!

7$$#:8%,!7,!78!7$%*F0!7S08%!%)7%!0W0&%,!*%,!#M8!'#&$0!#8!%)0!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!D0%!

%)*,!*,!-&0$*,0+.!M)7%!1.!2#<.!<*<!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!<7%7!$#++0$%*#8J!787+.,*,J!78<!

%)0#&*]*8S!*8!%)*,!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!?%!$#8,%78%+.!7,,0&%0<!*%,0+'!%)&#:S)!%)0!

545!

10$)78*,1,!#'!-7*8!78<!&0+*0'J!$#11:8*$7%*8S!M)7%!M7,!78<!M7,!8#%!,:,%7*872+0B!!

C.!10%)#<#+#S*$7+!<0$*,*#8,!M0&0!8#%!2#&8!,#+0+.!'&#1!*8%0++0$%:7+!$#8,*<0&7%*#8,!

#'!%)0!X'*%Y!20%M008!1.!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,J!%)0#&0%*$7+!'&710M#&TJ!78<!10%)#<,!#'!

<7%7!$#++0$%*#8B!!?!7+,#!)7<!%#!%7T0!*8%#!7$$#:8%!%)0!7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!1.!

2#<.!78<!$#8,%&:$%!7!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!%)7%!*%!$#:+<!7<0V:7%0+.!-0&'#&1B!!!

A#M0F0&J!?!&0$#S8*]0!%)7%!%)*,!*,!8#%!7!&0F#+:%*#87&.!7&S:108%B!!;,!?!)7F0!8#%0<J!

#%)0&!&0,07&$)0&,J!1#,%!8#%72+.!E++*8S,#8![344hl!345a\J!)7F0!M&*%%08!72#:%!%)0!

M7.,!*8!M)*$)!%)0*&!2#<*0,!78<!*%,!$7-72*+*%*0,!)7F0!*8'#&10<!%)0*&!&0,07&$)!

-&7$%*$0,B!!I)7%!?!M78%!%#!:,0!1.!0W-0&*08$0!%#!<#J!%)#:S)J!*,!%#!0W%08<!%)*,!

$#8F0&,7%*#8!%#!*8$+:<0!$#8,*<0&7%*#8,!#'!1##<!<*,#&<0&,!78<!#%)0&!80:&#+#S*$7+!

$)7++08S0,B!!C.!&0,07&$)!-&7$%*$0!M7,!*8'#&10<!8#%!,#+0+.!2.!1.!-).,*$7+!*8R:&.J!2:%!

7+,#!2.!*%,!*8%0&,0$%*#8!M*%)!1.!$)&#8*$!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!78W*0%.!78<!<0-&0,,*#8B!!

L)0!2&7*8!78<!*%,!80:&#$)01*,%&.J!7'%0&!7++J!7&0!':8<7108%7++.!-).,*#+#S*$7+!78<!%)7%!

-).,*#+#S.!$78!,)*'%!78<!0W0&%!*%,!#M8!0''0$%,J!7,!$78!78.!#%)0&!-7&%!#'!%)0!2#<.B!!;,!

M*%)!#%)0&!'01*8*,%!%)0#&*]7%*#8,!#'!*8%0&,0$%*#87+*%.![9&08,)7MJ!5665\J!%)#:S)J!?!

M78%!%#!,%&0,,!%)7%!%)*,!M7,!8#%!,*1-+.!78!7<<*%*F0!-&#$0,,B!!C.!-).,*$7+!*8R:&.!78<!

1.!1##<!<*,#&<0&,!*8%0&,0$%0<!%#!$&07%0!78!0W-0&*08$0!%)7%!M7,!V:7+*%7%*F0+.!

<*''0&08%!'&#1!%)0!-7&%,!#'!*%,!$#8,%&:$%*#8,!78<!?!<#!8#%J!*8<00<!$788#%J!%)*8T!72#:%!

%)01!,0-7&7%0+.B!!!

?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!08<!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)#:S)J!2.!#8+.!<*,$:,,*8S!%)0!+*1*%7%*#8,!

%)7%!1.!2#<.!-+7$0<!:-#8!1.!72*+*%*0,!%#!$#8,%&:$%!T8#M+0<S0B!!?!'00+!*%!M#:+<!20!7!

<*,,0&F*$0!%#!80S+0$%!%)0!7''#&<78$0,!#'!<#*8S!&0,07&$)!M*%)!78!*8R: &0<J! 78W*#:,J!

<0-&0,,0<!2#<.B!!L)0!,*8S+0!S&07%0,%!2080'*%!#'!$#8<:$%*8S!&0,07&$)! : 8<0&!%)0,0!

543!

$#8<*%*#8,!)7,!2008!78!*8$&07,0!*8!1.!$7-7$*%.!%#!01-7%)*]0!M*%)!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

78<!%)0!,:2,0V:08%!72*+*%.!%#!8#%*$0!-)08#1087!78<!0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!'&0V:08%+.!S#!

:8#2,0&F0<B!!N:,%!7,!E++*8S,#8![344h\!8#%0<!%)7%!)0&!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!$)&#8*$!-7*8!

78<!*++80,,!20$710!7!-#*8%!#'!$#880$%*#8!20%M008!)0&,0+'!78<!)0&!,:2R0$%,!%)7%!

0872+0<!%)01!%#!<0F0+#-!7!,%&#8S0&!&0+7%*#8,)*-J!,#!%##!)7,!1.!0W-0&*08$0!M*%)!

-7*8J!*8R:&.J!<0-&0,,*#8J!78<!78W*0%.!,08,*%*]0<!10!%#!%)#,0!0W-0&*08$0,!*8!1.!

,:2R0$%,B!!L)0!,*S8*'*$78$0!#'!%)*,J!?!'00+J!$788#%!20!#F0&,%7%0<B!!;,!>:SS*0&#![3444\!

)7,!8#%0<J!7!,*S8*'*$78%!%)010!%)7%!)7,!010&S0<!'&#1!<0$7<0,!#'!10<*7!7:<*08$0!

&0,07&$)J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!:,0,!78<!S&7% *'*$7 %*#8,!%&7<*%*#8J!)7,!2008!%)7%!*8<*F*<:7+,!

'&0V:08%+.!:,0!%)0!10<*7!%#!1787S0!%)0*&!1##<B!!?8<00<J!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!,%7%0<!

&07,#8!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M7,!%#!7++0F*7%0!,%&0,,J!78W*0%.J!

78<!<0-&0,,*#8B!!;,!7!-0&,#8!M)#!)7,!:,0<J!78<!$#8%*8:0,!%#!:,0J!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!

%)*,!-:&-#,0J!78<!7+,#!7,!7!&0,07&$)0&!%&7*80<!*8!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!10%)#<,!78<!

,#$*7+!78<!$:+%:&7+!%)0#&.J!?!71!*8!7!:8*V:0!-#,*%*#8!%#!#2,0&F0J!<0,$&*20J!78<!

%)0#&*]0!%)*,!-&7$%*$0B!!

L)*,!2&*8S,!10!%#!%)0!'*87+!%7T07M7.!#'!)#M!7!S&07%0&!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!#'!%)0!

2#<.!$78!2080'*%!V:7+*%7%*F0!10<*7!&0,07&$)B!!/*1-+.!-:%J!,:$)!7!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!$78!

#-08!:,!%#!80M!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!%):,!80M!7&07,!#'!,% : <.!78<!&0,07&$)B!!I*%)#:%!%)0!

0W-0&*08$0!#'!,*%%*8S!*8!'&#8%!#'!7!%0+0F*,*#8!7%!d!#U$+#$T!*8!%)0!1#&8*8SJ!<0,-0&7%0+.!

%&.*8S!%#!<*,%&7$%!1.,0+'!'&#1!%)0!,07&*8S!-7*8!*8!1.!+0'%!7&1!M*%)!7!S710!#'!B"$;%.&

+++J!?!<#!8#%!%)*8T!?!M#:+<!)7F0!*17S*80<!%)*,!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!C.!#M8!F*F*<!

0W-0&*08$0,!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#!,:&F*F0!78#%)0&!<7.!*8,-*&0<!10!%#!8#%*$0!)#M!

#%)0&!-0#-+0!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!%)0!,710!-:&-#,0J!*'!:8<0&!F7,%+.!<*''0&08%!

54d!

$#8<*%*#8,B!!?%!M7,!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!1.!012#<*108%J!%)08J!%)7%!-&#F*<0<!%)0!

*1-0%:,!'#&!%)*,!-&#R0$%B!!?!71!8#%!,7.*8S!%)7%!0F0&.!V:7+*%7%*F0!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%!)7,!

%#!'#$:,!#8!%)0!&0,07&$)0&U,!2#<.!%#!%)0!0W%08%!%)7%!?!)7F0!*8!%)*,!$)7-%0&B!!"*''0&08%!

-&#R0$%,!&0V:*&0!<*''0&08%!%##+,B!!=:%!?!<#!%)*8T!%)7%!1#,%J!*'!8#%!7++J!V:7+*%7%*F0!

&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%,!M#:+<!2080'*%!'&#1!7!S&07%0&!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!#'!%)0!&#+0!%)0!

&0,07&$)0&U,!2#<.!-+7.,!*8!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!T8#M+0<S0B!!;%!M#&,%J!7!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!

#'!%)0!2#<.!$78!S*F0!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!7!<00-0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0*&!#M8!-#,*%*#8!*8!

&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0*&!,:2R0$%,J!M*%)!,:2R0$%,!)0&0!1078*8S!2#%)!%)0!&0,07&$)0&U,!$)#,08!

%#-*$!#'!*8V:*&.!78<!-#%08%*7+!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!;%!20,%J!%)#:S)J!7!S&07%0&!7%%08%*#8!%#!%)0!

2#<.!$78!#-08!:,!%#!80M!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!M#:+<!S#!:8#2,0&F0<!

#%)0&M*,0J!78<!*8!%:&8!'#,%0&!7!S&07%0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!78<!01-7%).!%#M7&<,!%)0!

-0#-+0!M0!*8%0&7$%!78<!$#8,%&:$%!T8#M+0<S0!M*%)!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!#:&!-&#R0$%,B!

54f!

9A;(LE>!f!

(K;D?@Q!LP!/^>_?_EJ!=^L!@PL!LP!LA>?_E!

Q;C?@Q!(>;9L?9E/!^@"E>!@EPK?=E>;K?/C!!

=0'#&0!<0+F*8S!*8%#!%)0!<0%7*+,!#'!%)0!,:&F0.!<7%7!$#++0$%0<!'&#1!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!%)0!%)010,J!-7%%0&8,J!78<!<*,$#8%*8:*%*0,!%)7%!010&S0<!<:&*8S!1.!

787+.,*,!#'!%)0!<7%7J!?!M78%!%#!,)7&0!7!1#108%!%)7%!#$$:&&0<!<:&*8S!1.!-&#-#,7+!

<0'08,0!%)7%J!*8!)*8<,*S)%J!%:&80<!#:%!%#!20!-&0,$*08%B!!;,!M0!M0&0!M&7--*8S!:-!78<!

S7%)0&*8S!#:&!%)*8S,!%#!+07F0J!7!$#11*%%00!10120&!%:&80<!%#!10!78<J!*8!7!

$#8F0&,7%*#87+!%#80J!&0$#1108<0<!7!&0$08%!2+#S!-#,%!'&#1!7!$#++07S:0!%)7%!,)0!)7<!

$#10!7$&#,,![97+0J!345c\B!!?8!%)*,!2+#S!-#,%J!%)0!7:%)#&J!Q&7$0!97+0J!17<0!7!

<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!,0+'`$7&0!78<!,0+'`,##%)*8SJ!8#%*8S!%)7%!%)0.!M0&0!8#%!

80$0,,7&*+.!,.8#8.1#:,!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&B!!/0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!97+0!7&S:0<J!7&0!%)0!

-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!17T0!:,!<#!#:&!20,%J!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!17T0!:,!'00+!

20%%0&B!!;,!,:$)J!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!%*10!1787S0108%!#&!2:<S0%*8S!17.!7$%:7++.!

)7&1!7!-0&,#8U,!1##<!*8!%)0!-&0,08%![20$7:,0!%)0.!&0V:*&0!78!7$%*F0!08S7S0108%!

M*%)!%)*8S,!%)7%!17.!%&*SS0&!#80U,!78W*0%.!#&!<0-&0,,*#8\J!2:%!,0&F0!%#!)0+-!%)01!

'+#:&*,)!78<!-&#,-0&!*8!%)0!+#8S!&:8B!!?8!'7$%J!%)0!$7%0S#&*]7%*#8!#'!,#10!7$%*F*%*0,!

[+*T0!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,g\!7,!,0+'`$7&0!17.!20!7!1*,&0$#S8*%*#8J!,*8$0!#:&!

7%%7$)108%!%#!%)#,0!$7%0S#&*0,!17.!20!-&0F08%*8S!:,!'&#1!08S7S*8S!*8!#%)0&!

-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!*1-&#F0!#:&!+*F0,B!

! L)0&0!*,!7!+#%!%#!:8-7$T!*8!%)*,!$7,:7+!08$#:8%0&!%)7%!80F0&%)0+0,,!,%7.0<!

M*%)!10!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!-&#R0$%B!!@#MJ!7%!%)0!$#8$+:,*#8!#'!%)*,!

*%0&7%*#8!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%J!?!)7F0!7!$+07&0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!M)7%!1.!

54c!

$#11*%%00!10120&!M7,!%&.*8S!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!*8!%)7%!1#108%![?!%)*8TJ!?!)#-0\B!!

(0&)7-,!$#+#&0<!2.!K7:&08!=0&+78%U,![3455\!#2,0&F7%*#8,!78<!M7&8*8S,!*8!836/%&

TF'"@"(@J!1.!$#11*%%00!10120&!M7,!'#$:,*8S!1.!7%%08%*#8!#8!%)0!8#8`80$0,,7&.!

$#880$%*#8!20%M008!-+07,:&0!78<!&0+*0'J!#8!%)0!#80!)78<J!78<!%)&*F*8S!78<!

-&#,-0&*%.J!#8!%)0!#%)0&B!!;,!7![&0+7%*F0+.\!.#:8S!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!,$)#+7&!*8%0&0,%0<!

*8!10<*7!&0$0-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,!78<!$:+%:&7+!$)78S0J!?!)7F0!7!%08<08$.!%#!'7++!*8%#!%)0!

%&7-!#'!$#8,%&:$%*8S!7!2*87&.!#--#,*%*#8!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!78<!

:8$&*%*$7++.!$0+02&7%*8S!78.!&0$0-%*#8!-&7$%*$0!%)7%!,001,!%#!&0,:+%!'&#1!%)0!0W0&$*,0!

#'!78!*8<*F*<:7+U,!$)#*$0B!!P80!M7.!%#!*8%0&-&0%!1.!$#11*%%00!10120&U,!$#1108%J!

%)08J!*,!7,!7!&01*8<0&!%#!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!-&7$%*$0,!78<!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8,!

#'!%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,!*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!,.,%01*$!'#&$0,!%)7%!,)7-0!

%)01!M*%)#:%!0F0&!$#1-+0%0+.!<0%0&1*8*8S!%)01B!!C.!$#11*%%00!10120&!M7,!

-0&)7-,!08$#:&7S*8S!10!%#!+##T!7%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,%&:$%:&0!78<!7S08$.!*8!

7++!#'!*%,!$#1-+0W*%.!M*%)#:%!7,,:1*8S!*8!7<F78$0!M)7%!?!M#:+<!'*8<![,:$)!7,!

&0,*,%78$0\!78<!%#!8#%!7,,:10!%)7%!,0+'!$7&0!M7,!80$0,,7&*+.!XS##<Y![#&!80$0,,7&*+.!

X27<Y\B!!!

! ?!2&*8S!%)*,!08$#:8%0&!:-!7%!%)0!20S*88*8S!#'!1.!'*&,%!<7%7!787+.,*,!$)7-%0&!

20$7:,0!%)*,!0-*,#<0J!?!%)*8TJ!*,!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!%08,*#8!%)7%!*,!'#:8<7%*#87+!%#!1.!

*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!2#%)!X%)&*F*8SY!78<!X,0+'!$7&0BY!!?!

)7<!*8*%*7++.!7,,:10<!%)0,0!%M#!%0&1,!%#!20!&0+7%*F0+.!*,#1#&-)*$!#&!,.8#8.1#:,!

M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!M)08!?!<0F0+#-0<!1.!,:&F0.J!'#&!0W71-+0!M)08!?!7,T0<!

54h!

-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!<0'*80!X%)&*F*8SY!78<!X,0+'`$7&0Y!*8!%)0!,710!V:0,%*#8B

!!C.!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!)#M0F0&J!<&0M!,:2%+0!2:%!*1-#&%78%!<*,%*8$%*#8,!20%M008!%)01B!!

^8%78S+*8S!%)0,0!<*,%*8$%*#8,!+07<!%#!7!S&07%0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!,%&:$%:&0!#'!

'00+*8SJ!%#!:,0!>7.1#8<!I*++*71,U!%0&1![I*++*71,!s!P&&#1J!56cf\J!%)7%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!%)0*&!-&7$%*$0,!M0&0!0120<<0<!*8B!!?!M#:+<!$#10!%#!<0'*80!%)*,!

,%&:$%:&0!#'!'00+*8S!*8!%0&1,!#'!712*F7+08$0!78<!&0+:$%78$0J!M)*$)!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!

0W-&0,,!*%,0+'!*8!%)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!$#8,%&:$%0<!20%M008!%)&*F*8S!78<!

,0+'`$7&0B!!P8$0!%)*,!<*,%*8$%*#8!M7,!0,%72+*,)0<J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!

78<!08%):,*7,%*$7++.!$7%0S#&*]0!%)0*&!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7,!7!'#&1!#'!,0+'`$7&0!.0%!

)0,*%7%0!%#!7,,#$*7%0!%)0,0!,710!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)!%)&*F*8SB!!!

! L)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)08J!M*++!$#8$08%&7%0!#8!%)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

%)&*F*8S!$#8,%&:$%0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!%)0!$:+%:&7+!+#S*$!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!%)7%!?!

20+*0F0!:8<0&-*8,!%)*,!<*,%*8$%*#8B!!?8!,)#&%J!?!*8%0&-&0%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!7,!,0%!*8!1#%*#8!2.!7!80#+*20&7+!&7%*#87+*%.!

[=&#M8J!344h\!%)7%!<0178<,!78!*8<*F*<:7+!%7T0!-0&,#87+!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!%)0!

17*8%0878$0!78<!&0-7*&!#'!%)0!,0+'B!!(+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!+*T0!#%)0&!,0+'`$7&0!

-&7$%*$0,J!$78!20!F*0M0<!7,!7!'#&1!#'!X*117%0&*7+!+72#&Y!*8!%)7%!*%!X-&#<:$0,!#&!

178*-:+7%0,!7''0$%,!,:$)!7,!7!'00+*8S!#'!07,0J!M0++`20*8SJ!,7%*,'7$%*#8J!0W$*%0108%J!#&!

-7,,*#8Y![A7&<%!s!@0S&*!344fJ!-B!546\B!!L)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!X,0+'`&0-7*&Y!7&0!80$0,,7&.!

'#&!%)0!&080M7+!#'!M#&T0&,U!108%7+!78<!01#%*#87+!&0,#:&$0,!&0V:*&0<!2.!%)0!

*8%0++0$%:7+!78<!7''0$%*F0!<0178<,!#'!1:$)!+72#&!*8!%)0!,0&F*$0`'#$:,0<!0$#8#1.!#'!

%)0!-#,%`Z#&<*,%!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%B!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!Z#&!1#&0!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!)#M!?!,-0$*'*$7++.!*8F*%0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!<*,$:,,!

%)0,0!*,,:0,J!,00!V:0,%*#8,!35`3f!#'!1.!V:0,%*#887*&0![-&#F*<0<!*8!;--08<*W!;\B!

54a!

Z&#1!%)0&0J!%)*,!$)7-%0&!M*++!$#8%08<!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!<*,%*8$%*#8!

20%M008!X,0+'`$7&0Y!78<!X%)&*F*8SJY!7,!M0++!7,!%)0*&!08%):,*7,%*$!+720+*8S!#'!%)0*&!

F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7,!,0+'`$7&0!78<!&0+:$%78$0!%#!+720+!%)#,0!,710!-&7$%*$0,!7,!

0W71-+0,!#'!X%)&*F*8SJY!*,!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!)*0&7&$).!#'!F7+:0!0120<<0<!*8!%)*,!

80#+*20&7+!&7%*#87+*%.!78<J!%#!7!+0,,0&!2:%!,%*++!*1-#&%78%!0W%08%J!%#!$0&%7*8!

-&#S&0,,*F0!*<0#+#S*0,!#'!%)0!+0'%B!!I)*+0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!,:$)!7,!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!

80$0,,7&.!*8!#&<0&!'#&!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!1787S0!78<!&080M!%)0*&!7''0$%*F0!,%7%0,J!

78<!%):,!-0&'#&1!M7S0!+72#&J!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!M0&0!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!F7+:0<!7,!)*S)+.!

7,!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!%)0.!F*0M0<!7,!7$%*F0+.!$#8%&*2:%*8S!%#!%)0*&!S&#M%)!78<!

-&#,-0&*%.B!!?8!'7$%J!*8!,#10!$7,0,!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!F*0M0<!%)0*&!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!7,!

7$%*F0+.!*8)*2*%*8S!%)0*&!S&#M%)!78<!%):,!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!%)&*F0B!!Z*87++.J!?!M*++!

$#8$+:<0!%)*,!$)7-%0&!2.!$#8,*<0&*8S!%)7%!&7%)0&!%)78!7,T*8S!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!

<08*S&7%0!#&!0F08!'#&0S#!$#1-+0%0+.!%)0*&!7%%7$)108%!%#!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!M0!,)#:+<!20!1#&0!$&*%*$7+!#'!%)0!%0&1,!#'!%)&*F*8S!0,%72+*,)0<!

2.!2#%)!80#+*20&7+!78<!-&#S&0,,*F0!&7%*#87+*%*0,!2.!<&7M*8S!7%%08%*#8!%#!7!'7$0%!#'!

%)&*F*8S!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!108%*#80<!2:%!<*<!8#%!<0F0+#-!%)#&#:S)+.!k!%)0!72*+*%.!

%#!*17S*80!80M!-#,,*2*+*%*0,B!!"#*8S!,#!M*++!)0+-!:,!,00!%)7%J!M)*+0!%)0!-&0,:10<!S#7+!

#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!*,!17*8%0878$0!78<!%):,!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!%)0!,%7%:,!V:#J!

,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!7+,#!-&#<:$0!'*,,:&0,!*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!%)0!

,%7%:,!V:#B!!L)*,!+*80!#'!%)*8T*8S!M*++!20! ': &%)0&!<0F0+#-0<!*8!+7%0&!$)7-%0&,!M)0&0!?!

M*++!0W71*80!%)0!,-0$*'*$!10$)78*,1,!#'!%)0!-#-:+7&!C7,,*F0+.!C:+%*-+7.0&!P8+*80!

>#+0`(+7.*8S!Q710![CCP>(Q\!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!78<!,:SS0,%!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!%)0!

0W-0&*08$0!#'!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710!$78!<0,%72*+*]0!78<!*8%0&&:-%!80#+*20&7+!&7%*#87+*%*0,B!

54i!

Defining!Neoliberalism!

! /*8$0!80#+*20&7+*,1!*,!7!2&#7<!78<!712*S:#:,!%0&1J!?!M78%!%#!,-0$*'.!)#M!?!

71!:,*8S!%)0!%0&1B!!?!)7F0!'#:8<!I08<.!=&#M8U,![344h\!'*S:&*8S!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!7,!

7!X-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.Y!%#!20!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-&#<:$%*F0B!!?8!$#8%&7,%!%#!78!*<0#+#S.J!

M)*$)!=&#M8!$#8%08<,!,%01,!'&#1!#&!17,T,!7!,-0$*'*$!0$#8#1*$!&07+*%.J!=&#M8!

7&S:0,!%)7%!$#8%01-#&7&.!80#+*20&7+*,1!*,!20,%!:8<0&,%##<!7,!7!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!

*8!%)0!Z#:$7:+<*78!,08,0!*8!%)7%!*%!*,!X7!8#&17%*F0!-#+*%*$7+!&07,#8!#&S78*]*8S!%)0!

-#+*%*$7+!,-)0&0J!S#F0&878$0!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!$*%*]08,)*-Y![-B!h6d\B!!Z#&!=&#M8J!%)*,!

#$$:&,!M)08!7!,-0$*'*$!'#&1!#'!17&T0%!&7%*#87+*%.!*,!*1-#,0<!:-#8!-#+*%*$7+!78<!

,#$*7+!,-)0&0,J!&0,:+%*8S!*8!%)0!#&S78*]7%*#8!#'!%)0,0!<*,%*8$% ! .0%!*8%0&&0+7%0<!'*0+<,!

7$$#&<*8S!%#!7!17&T0%!&7%*#87+*%.B!!!

I)*+0!%)*,!$78!20!,008!*8!7!M*<0!F7&*0%.!#'!,%7%0!-#+*$*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!

#:%,#:&$*8S!78<!-&*F7%*]7%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!M0+'7&0J!0<:$7%*#8J!78<!%)0!

-&*,#8!,.,%01,J!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+0F78$0!%#!1.!<*,$:,,*#8!*,!=&#M8U,!#2,0&F7%*#8!#'!

%)0!%.-0!#'!,:2R0$%*F*%.!-&*F*+0S0<!2.!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1B!!

=&#M8!7&S:0,!%)7%!80#+*20&7+*,1!&0-&0,08%,!%)0!*<07+!,:2R0$%!78<!$*%*]08!7,!78!

*8<*F*<:7+!7:%#8#1#:,!08%&0-&080:&!78<!$#8,:10&!XM)#,0!1#&7+!7:%#8#1.!*,!

107,:&0<!2.!%)0*&!$7-7$*%.!'#&!r,0+'`$7&0U!k!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!-&#F*<0!'#&!%)0*&!#M8!

800<,!78<!,0&F*$0!%)0*&!#M8!712*%*#8,J!M)0%)0&!7,!M0+'7&0!&0$*-*08%,J!10<*$7+!

-7%*08%,J!$#8,:10&,!#'!-)7&17$0:%*$7+,J!:8*F0&,*%.!,%:<08%,J!#&!M#&T0&,!*8!

0-)010&7+!#$$:-7%*#8,Y![-B!h6f\B!!/0+'`$7&0J!%)08J!*,!$08%&7+!%#!)#M!7!80#+*20&7+!

-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!107,:&0,!78<!<*,%&*2:%0,!F7+:0!78<!-&0,%*S0!7$&#,,!F7&*#:,!

,:2R0$%,!78<!-&7$%*$0,B!!I*%)*8!%)*,!'&710M#&TJ!7!-0&,#8U,!M#&%)!*,!*8'#&10<!2.!

546!

%)0*&!$7-7$*%.!%#!%7T0!$7&0!#'!%)01,0+F0,!78<!%#!8#%!&0+.!:-#8!%)0!*8%0&F08%*#8,!#'!

#%)0&,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!,%7%0J!%#!-&#F*<0!'#&!%)01,0+F0,B!!9#8F0&,0+.J!78.!+7$T!#&!

'7*+:&0!*,!&08<0&0<!%)0!'7:+%!#'!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!&7%)0&!%)78!%)0!&0,:+%!#'!,.,%01*$J!

*8,%*%:%*#87+!*80V:7+*%*0,!%)7%!<*,%&*2:%0!1#&0!&0,#:&$0,![M)0%)0&!*%!20!0$#8#1*$J!

,.12#+*$J!#&!$:+%:&7+\!%#!,#10!S&#:-,!78<!+0,,!%#!#%)0&,B!!I)*+0!%)*,!*,!-0&)7-,!7!

2&#7<0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!X,0+'`$7&0Y!%)78!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!-:%!

'#&M7&<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!=&#M8U,!7,,0&%*#8!#'!%)0!80$0,,*%.!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!:8<0&!

80#+*20&7+!&0S*10,!#'!%)#:S)%!7&0!*1-#&%78%!%#!T00-!*8!1*8<!7,!M0!1#F0!*8%#!7!

<*,$:,,*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,B!!L)0!800<!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!M7,!

$#8,*<0&0<!,0+'`0F*<08%!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!7!1:8<780!'07%:&0!#'!$#8%01-#&7&.!+*'0!

%)7%!17.!S#!:817&T0<B!

Participant!Definitions!of!Self-Care!

! /#!)#M!<*<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!78<!M).!<#!?!7&S:0!

%)7%!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,!7&0!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.g!!;,!

<*,$:,,0<!*8!%)0!-&0F*#:,!$)7-%0&J!?!$#8,%&:$%0<!7!,: &F0.! %#!0+*$*%!&0,-#8,0,!'&#1!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,B!!=0$7:,0!#'!%)*,J!?!'00+!*%!80$0,,7&.!%#!<*,$:,,!)#M!?!'&710<!%)0,0!*,,:0,!

78<!)#M!%)*,!17.!)7F0!,)7-0<!%)0!&0,-#8,0,!%)7%!M0&0!S7%)0&0<B!!L)0!%0&1!

X%)&*F*8SY!*,!8#%!7!%0&1!%)7%!*,!'71*+*7&!%#!%)0!S&#:-,!#'!-0#-+0!%)7%!?!,#+*$*%0<B!!L#!:,0!

O0880%)!(*T0U,![56ha\!%&7<*%*#87+!,#$*#+*8S:*,%*$!F#$72:+7&.J!?!M7,!$#S8*]78%!#'!%)0!

'7$%!%)7%!%)0!M#&<!X%)&*F*8SY!M7,!78!X0%*$Y!%0&1!%#!<0,$&*20!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!#&!7!%0&1!20+#8S*8S!%#!78!X#:%,*<0&Y!7$$#:8%!#'!7!$#11:8*%.U,!

20)7F*#&,!78<!-&7$%*$0,B!!L)*,!M7,!7!$#8,$*#:,!<0$*,*#8!#8!1.!-7&%!,*8$0J!*8!%)0!

554!

,-*&*%!#'!0W-0&*108%7%*#8!78<!<*,$#F0&.J!?!M78%0<!%#!0W-+#&0!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)*,!

%0&1!$#:+<!20!7--+*0<!%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&,!78<!%)0&02.!,)*'%!)#M!

&0,07&$)0&,!%)*8T!72#:%!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

A#M0F0&J!,*8$0!%)&*F*8S!M7,!78!X0%*$Y!%0&1J!?!M7,!7+,#!7M7&0!%)7%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!1*S)%!8#%!20!7,!'+:08%!*8!<0'*8*8S!%)0!%0&1!78<!7--+.*8S!*%!%#!%)0*&!

-&7$%*$0,!7,!%)0.!M#:+<!#%)0&J!1#&0!'71*+*7&!%0&1,B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!*8!1.!,:&F0.!?!7+,#!

7,T0<!V:0,%*#8,!72#:%!%)0,0!1#&0!'71*+*7&!%0&1,!%)7%!?!%)#:S)%!17.!20!&0+7%0<!%#!

%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!P80!#'!%)0,0!%0&1,!M7,!X,0+'`$7&0BY!!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!<0+F0!

%##!'7&!*8%#!%)0!)*,%#&.!#'!%)*,!%0&1J!,*8$0!,:$)!78!08<07F#&!$#:+<!20!*%,!#M8!

<*,,0&%7%*#8J!?!*17S*80B!!?!M*++!,*1-+.!8#%0!%)7%!%)*,!%0&1!#&*S*87%0<!*8!7$%*F*,%!

$:+%:&0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!'01*8*,%!$#8,$*#:,80,,!&7*,*8S!-&7$%*$0,!#'!%)0!56h4,J!7,!7!

M7.!%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0!108%7+!78<!01#%*#87+!%#++!%)7%!-&#S&0,,*F0!,%&:SS+0,!$#:+<!

)7F0!#8!%)0*&!-&7$%*%*#80&,!78<!%#!08$#:&7S0!7$%*F*,%,!%#!<*,08S7S0!'&#1!%)0,0!

-&7$%*$0,!7,!800<0<!78<!M*%)#:%!S:*+%![A7&&*,J!345a\B!!?%!)7,!&0$08%+.!1#F0<!*8%#!

17*8,%&071!$:+%:&0J!%)#:S)J!-&*17&*+.!<:0!%#!$#8%01-#&7&.!$#&-#&7%0!1*8<':+80,,!

1#F0108%,!%)7%!-&#1#%0!,0+'`$7&0!7,!7!%0$)8*V:0!%#!&080M!M#&T0&,![O*8871#8J!

345h\B!!

L)*,!*,!,*1-+.!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!%)0!%0&1!X,0+'`$7&0Y!)7,!7!S&07%0&!-:&$)7,0!

71#8S!%)0!S&#:-,!%)7%!?!08S7S0<!M*%)J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0!

-&7$%*$0,B!!;,!,:$)J!?!:,0<!X,0+'`$7&0Y!7,!M0++!7,!#%)0&!'71*+*7&!%0&1,!+*T0!X,%&0,,!

&0+*0'Y!*8!$#8R:8$%*#8!M*%)!%)0!+0,,!'71*+*7&!%0&1!X%)&*F*8SY!,#!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

$#:+<!20%%0&!-*8!<#M8!%)0*&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!%0&1!X%)&*F*8SY!%)&#:S)!%)0!7$%,!#'!

<*''0&08%*7%*#8!78<!787+#S.B!!L)0!<0$*,*#8!%#!-7*&!X,0+'`$7&0Y!78<!X%)&*F*8SY!*8!1.!

555!

,:&F0.!M7,!'#&%:*%#:,J!*8!)*8<,*S)%J!20$7:,0!*%!+0<! % #!7!,:&-&*,*8S!<*,$#F0&.!k!%)7%!

%)0,0!%M#!%0&1,!M0&0!8#%J!*8!'7$%J!*,#1#&-)*$!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!#&!0F08!<*''0&08%!

-7&%,!#'!,#10!S&07%0&!M)#+0B!!;$$#&<*8S!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%)0.!&0'0&08$0<!08%*&0+.!

<*''0&08%!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)7%J!M)*+0!&0+7%0<J!M0&0!80F0&%)0+0,,!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!

#80!78#%)0&B!!?%!M7,!%)0!V:7+*%.!#'!%)*,!<*,%*8$%*#8J!*8!%:&8J!%)7%!+0<!10!%#!20+*0F0!%)7%!

%)0,0!%0&1,!M0&0!-&*17&*+.!:8<0&,%##<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1B!!!

L#!,00!%)*,J!?!M*++!8#M!['*87++.\!%:&8!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,!78<!$+#,0+.!

<*,$:,,!%)0!%)010,!78<!-7%%0&8,!%)7%!010&S0<!2#%)!20%M008!78<!7$&#,,!%)0!7W0,!#'!

<*''0&08$0J!$+7,,!78<!,0W:7+*%.J!%)7%!?!:,0<!%#!$#8,%&:$%!1.!,71-+0B!!C.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

<0'*80<!,0+'`$7&0!-&*17&*+.!7,!7!,0%!#'!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!%)0.!'0+%!M0&0!80$0,,7&.!%#!

,:,%7*8!%)0*&!-).,*$7+J!108%7+J!78<!01#%*#87+!M0++`20*8SB!!I)08!7,T0<!%#!<0'*80!,0+'`

$7&0J!f6!#:%!#'!a4!-7&%*$*-78%,J!#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!%M#`%)*&<,!#'!1.!,71-+0J!<0,$&*20<!

,0+'`$7&0![2&#7<+.\!7,!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!#80!<#0,!%#!%7T0!$7&0!#'!.#:&,0+'B!!L#!7F#*<!%)0!

$*&$:+7&*%.!#'!%)*,!<0'*8*%*#8J!%)#:S)J!78<!%#!S*F0!7!1#&0!7$$:&7%0!,08,0!#'!M)7%!M7,!

%.-*$7++.!1078%!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)08!%)0.!:,0<!%)*,!-)&7,0![7,!<0%0&1*80<!2.!

%)0*&!7$$#1-78.*8S!0W-+787%*#8,\J!?!*8,%07<!&0*8%0&-&0%0<!%)*,!<0'*8*%*#8!7,!

X17*8%7*8*8S!78<!,:--#&%*8S!#80U,!)07+%)BY!!L)*,!M7,!2.!'7&!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!

,%7%0<!<0'*8*%*#8B!!L)0!807&0,%!7+%0&87%*F0!<0'*8*%*#8,!M0&0!X17T*8S!%*10!'#&!

.#:&,0+'Y![i!-7&%*$*-78%,\!78<!%)0!$#1-78*#8!%#!,:--#&%*8S!#80U,!)07+%)J!

X-&0F08%*8S!)7&1Y![h!-7&%*$*-78%,\J!78<!0F08!%)0,0!M0&0!108%*#80<!*8!$#8R:8$%*#8!

M*%)!X,:--#&%*8S!#80U,!)07+%)Y!7--&#W*17%0+.!c4x!#'!%)0!%*10B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!M)*+0!7!

,17++!,:2,0%!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!,0+'`$7&0!0W$+:,*F0+.!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!108%7+!

553!

)07+%)J!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!,0+'`$7&0!1#&0!)#+*,%*$7++.!7,!17*8%7*8*8S!

#80U,!108%7+J!01#%*#87+J!78<!-).,*$7+!)07+%)B!!/:&-&*,*8S+.J!%)*,!<0'*8*%*#8!M7,!'7*&+.!

:8*'#&1!7$&#,,!<*''0&08$0,!*8!2#%)!,0W:7+*%.!78<!$+7,,!0W-0&*08$0,J!7!'7$%!?!7%%&*2:%0!

%#!%)0!-0&F7,*F080,,!#'!%)0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%B!!!

;,!?UF0!,%7%0<J!%)0!8:120&!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!,%7%0<!,#10!F7&*7%*#8!#'!%)0!

<0'*8*%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!7,!,:--#&%*8S!#80U,!)07+%)!M7,!$#8,*<0&72+0B!!I)*+0!?!<#!8#%!

%)*8T!*%!:,0':+!%#!0W71*80!07$)!78<!0F0&.!*8,%78$0!*8!<0-%)J!?!<#!M78%!%#!-&#F*<0!7!

,08,0!#'!)#M!%)*,!*<07!M7,!0W-&0,,0<!*8!%)0!+78S:7S0!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!I)7%!

'#++#M,J!%)08J!*,!7!,71-+0!#'!-7&%*$*-78%!&0,-#8,0,B!!!

Z#&!0W71-+0J!?,77$!,7*<G!!

;,!'#&!,0+'`$7&0J!?!M#:+<!,7.!%)7%!*%!*,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!8#%!#8+.!%7T*8S!7$%*#8,!%#!

-&#%0$%!78<!-&0,0&F0!#80,0+'!-).,*$7++.J!2:%!%#!-&0F08%!

-,.$)#+#S*$7+o108%7+o01#%*#87+!<717S0!$7:,0<!2.!#F0&0W0&%*#8!#&!

#F0&,%*1:+7%*#8B!

K0,+*0G!

?!<0'*80!y,0+'`$7&0y!7,!<#*8S!78.%)*8S![#&!8#%!<#*8S!,#10%)*8S\!*8!#&<0&!%#!

-&#<:$0!#-%*17+!-0&,#87+!2080'*%,J!M)0%)0&!%)7%!*,!&0+7W7%*#8J!*1-&#F*8S!,T*8!

$7&0J!2#8<*8S!M*%)!7!+#F0<!#80J!T00-*8S!#80,0+'!7%!7!<*,%78$0!'&#1!%#W*$!

-0#-+0J!17*8%7*8*8S!#80w,!,78*%.J!*1-&#F*8S!#&!17*8%7*8*8S!S##<!)07+%)J!78<!

,#!#8B!

@*$#+0G!!

/0+'!$7&0!*8F#+F0,!%&07%*8S!.#:&,0+'!M0++!-).,*$7++.J!01#%*#87++.J!108%7++.J!78<!

,-*&*%:7++.B!L)*,!$78!1078!<*''0&08%!%)*8S,!'#&!<*''0&08%!-0#-+0B!=:%!*8!S080&7+J!

,0+'!$7&0!*8F#+F0,!+*F*8S!#:%!.#:&!+*'0w,!-:&-#,0B!D#:!,%7.!7M7.!'&#1!-+7$0,J!

-0#-+0J!#&!,*%:7%*#8,!78<!%)*8S,!%)7%!17T0!.#:!'00+!y,)*%%.y!#&!'00+!,%&0,,0<!

#:%B!

97,0.G!

/0+'`$7&0!*,!<#*8S!M)7%!?!800<!%#!)7F0!08#:S)!080&S.!78<!01#%*#87+!$7-7$*%.!

%#!<#!%)0,0!%)*8S,!u-&0F*#:,+.!,%7%0<!7$%*F*%*0,!+*T0!-&#<:$*8S!7&%!78<!

,-08<*8S!%*10!M*%)!'&*08<,vB!().,*$7+!).S*080!78<!+*F*8S!,-7$0!:-T00-J!

0W0&$*,0J!S710,!78<!#%)0&!&0+7W*8S!7$%*F*%*0,J!$)7++08S0,!+*T0!-&#2+01!,#+F*8SB!

55d!

Z#&!78!0W71-+0!#'!)#M!,:--#&%*8S!#80U,!)07+%)!78<!-&0F08%*8S!)7&1!M0&0!

'&0V:08%+.!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&J!78#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%J!@#&178<J!,%7%0<G!

?!M#:+<!<0'*80!y,0+'`$7&0y!7,!%)0!7$%!#'!08,:&*8S!%)7%!.#:&!#M8!800<,!7&0!10%J!

M)0%)0&!%)7%!*,!S0%%*8S!08#:S)!,+00-J!S0%%*8S!%&07%108%!'#&!78W*0%.!#&!108%7+!

*++80,,J!#&!$:%%*8S!27$T!#8!7$%*F*%*0,!M)08!.#:!7&0!8#%!'00+*8S!:-!%#!%)01B!

E,,08%*7++.J!*%!*,!08,:&*8S!%)7%!.#:!7&0!-&*#&*%*]*8S!.#:&!)07+%)![-).,*$7+J!

108%7+J!78<!01#%*#87+\B!

!;8<!'*87++.J!9*8<.!,7*<G!

%7T*8S!$7&0!#'!.#:&!,0+'!,#!.#:!7&0!7,!108%7++.!78<!-).,*$7++.!)07+%).!7,!.#:!

7&0!72+0!%#!20B!!!

?!M78%!%#!%7T0!,#10!,-7$0!78<!0W-78<!:-#8!%)0!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!,0+'`$7&0!7,!

%)0!17*8%0878$0!#'!7!-0&,#8U,!-).,*$7+J!108%7+J!78<!01#%*#87+!,0+'!2.!+*8T*8S!*%!M*%)!

78!*<07!%)7%!*,!-0&F7,*F0!*8!-).,*#+#S.!k!%)0!*<07!#'!)#10#,%7,*,B!!;,!0F*<08$0<!2.!

%)0!0W71-+0,!?!-&#F*<0<!72#F0J!%)0!%0&1!X,0+'`$7&0Y!M7,!'&0V:08%+.!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!

2#%)!,%72*+*%.!78<!&080M*8S!78<!17*8%7*8*8S!#80U,!2#<.!,#!%)7%!%)0.!$78!-0&'#&1!

%7,T,!%)0.!0*%)0&!800<0<!#&!M78%0<!%#!<#B!!?,77$!-0&)7-,!20,%!0W- &0,,0<! %)*,!%)&#:S)!

)*,!:,0!#'!%)0!M#&<,!X-&#%0$%JY!X-&0,0&F0JY!78<!X-&0F08%BY!!L)0!*17S0!%)*,!$#8R:&0,!*,!

#'!7!2#<.!7%!&*,TJ!F:+80&72+0!%#!$)78S0!78<!<0-+0%*#8!'&#1!2#%)!M*%)*8!78<!M*%)#:%B!!

L)*,!*,!8#%!7!<0,*&72+0!,%7%0B!!>7%)0&J!*%!*,!7!,%7%0!%)7%!7!-0&,#8!1:,%!$#&&0$%!#&J!7%!%)0!

F0&.!+07,%J!$#1-08,7%0!'#&B!!!;%!%)0!$08%0&!#'!%)0!*<07!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!%)08J!*,!%)0!

7$)*0F0108%!#'!7!'*W0<J!,%72+0!2#<.B!!L)*,!*<07+*]0<!2#<.!*,!72+0!%#!17*8%7*8!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!,%7%0!#'!-).,*$7+J!108%7+J!78<!01#%*#87+!20*8S!7S7*8,%!%)0!F7&*#:,!

'+:$%:7%*8S!$#8%0W%,!%)7%!%)0!2#<.!08$#:8%0&,!%)&#:S)!%)0!1:8<780!-&#$0,,!#'!

+*F*8S!78<!1#F*8S!%)&#:S)!%)0!M#&+<B!!/0+'`$7&0J!%)08J!20$#10,!7!%0$)8#+#S.!#'!

)#10#,%7,*,B!

?%!*,!*1-#&%78%!%#!8#%0J!)#M0F0&J!%)7%!)#10#,%7,*,!*,!8#%!7!,%&*$%+.!87%:&7+!

-&#$0,,J!2:%!*,!7+,#!7!<*,$:&,*F0!$#8,%&:$%B!!;,!K.8<7!=*&T0![5666\!<0,$&*20,!*%J!

55f!

)#10#,%7,*,!*,!<00-+.!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!%)0!*<07!#'!7!'*W0<!78<!,%72+0!2#<.B!!L)*,!'*W0<!

78<!,%72+0!2#<.J!*8!%:&8J!)7,!2008!78!#&S78*]*8S!-&*8$*-+0!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!

-).,*#+#S*$7+!<*,$#:&,0,!#'!%)0!2#<.B!!A#10#,%7,*,J!*8!%)*,!F*0MJ!M#&T,!%#!,:--#&%!

%)0!*<07!#'!7!'*W0<!78<!,%72+0!2#<.J!7+#8S!M*%)!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!S080%*$,J!,*8$0!%)0!

+7%%0&!-:&-#&%,!%#!%0++!:,!)#M!%)0!2#<.!,)#:+<!20!M)*+0!%)0!'#&10&!%0++,!:,!)#M!%)0!

2#<.!M#&T,!%#!,%7.!M)0&0!*%!,)#:+<!20B!

D0%!M)*+0!)#10#,%7,*,!*,!$#8,*<0&0<!2.!178.!%#!20!7!X87%:&7+Y!-&#$0,,J!%)0!

-&#$0,,!#'!)#10#,%7,*,J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!)#10#,%7%*$7++.`*8$+*80<!-&7$%*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!

20+*0,!%)0!71#:8%!#'!*8%08,0!78<!#8S#*8S!M#&T!%)7%!1:,%!20!-0&'#&10<!*8!#&<0&!%#!

,:,%7*8!78.!<0S&00!#'!,%72*+*%.!*8!%)0!2#<.B!!? % !*,!)0&0!%)7%!=*&T0!-&#<:$%*F0+.!+*8T,!

-).,*#+#S.!M*%)!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!N:<*%)!=:%+0&U,!'#:8<7%*#87+!M#&T!#8!

S08<0&!78<!-0&'#&17%*F*%.!*8!K/#>/3&03.6;%/&[5664\&78<!M.>"/(&02$'&P$''/3![566d\B!!

/-0$*'*$7++.J!=*&T0!'#$:,0,!#8!=:%+0&U,!01-)7,*,!#8!*%0&7%0<!-&7$%*$0,!*8!#&<0&!%#!

-&#<:$0!78<!17*8%7*8!%)0!'*$%*#8!%)7%!7!-7&%*$:+7&!2#<*+.!-0&'#&178$0![,:$)!7,!

S08<0&\!*,!7$%:7++.!7!87%:&7+J!2*#+#S*$7++.`<0%0&1*80<!,%7%0B!!;,!=*&T0!8#%0,J!1:$)!#'!

%)0!2#<.U,!*8%0&*#&*%.![*%,!1:,$+0!17,,!78<!$#1-#,*%*#8J!'#&!0W71-+0\!7&0!+*T0M*,0!

-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!*%0&7%*F0!-&7$%*$0,B!

?!*8$+:<0!%)*,!2&*0'!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!#'!)#10#,%7,*,!78<!*%,!<*,$:&,*F0!

$#1-#808%,!*8!#&<0&!%#!<01#8,%&7%0!)#M!$#1-7%*2+0!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*,!M*%)!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!-&#R0$%,!#'!S#F0&8108%7+*%.!78<!

80#+*20&7+*,1!<0,$&*20<!2.!Z#:$7:+%B!!=.!-:%%*8S!'#&M7&<!%)0!*<07!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!*,!7!

%0$)8#+#S.!#'!)#10#,%7,*,J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!*1-+*$*%+.!*8F#T0!78!*17S0!#'!%)0!2#<.!

7,!-0&-0%:7++.!F:+80&72+0!78<!7%!&*,TB!!L)*,!F:+80&72*+*%.!78<!:8$0&%7*8%.!*8!%:&8J!*,!

55c!

-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!F7&*#:,!$*&$:+7%#&.!-&7$%*$0,!#'!08S7S0108%!78<!*8%0&7$%*#8J!

1#,%!8#%72+.!+72#&!-&7$%*$0,J!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!08S7S0!*8J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!*8%0&*#&!

-&#$0,,0,!#'!%)0!2#<.J!M)*$)!)7,!*%,!#M8!M*++!78<!0''0$%*F*%.B!!?8!,)#&%J!%)0!<*,$#:&,0!

#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&#2+017%*]0,!%)0!1787S0108%!#'!-0&,#87+!F:+80&72*+*%.!78<!&*,T!

-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!0F0&.<7.!+*'0J!1#,%!8#%72+.!+72#&!-&7$%*$0,B!!L)*,J!

*8!%:&8J!&0,012+0,![*8!1*$&#$#,1\!%)0!2&#7<0&!$#8$0&8,!#'!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!-&#R0$%!#'!

S#F0&8108%7+*%.J!M)*$)!72#F0!7++!0+,0!*,!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!%)0!1787S0108%!#'!&*,T!78<!

:8$0&%7*8%.J!8#%!#8!7!-0&,#87+!,$7+0J!2:%!#8!7!-#-:+7%*#8!,$7+0B!

Z#:$7:+%![344a\!%&7$0,!%)0!*<07!#'!S#F0&8108%7+*%.![*'!8#%!*%,!7$%:7+!

010&S08$0!*8!-#+*$.\!%#!%)0!0$#8#1*$!78<!,-7%*7+!-&7$%*$0,!#'!%)0!5i

!$08%:&.!

E:&#-078!%#M8J!M)*$)!<*1*8*,)0<!%)0!-&0,08$0!#'!M7++,!*8!#&<0&!%#!7++#M!'#&!S&07%0&!

%&7<0!78<!$*&$:+7%*#8B!!L)*,!S&07%0&!0$#8#1*$!'&00<#1!$710!7%!%)0!$#,%!#'!S&07%0&!

*8,0$:&*%.!7,!%)0!27&&*0&,!20%M008!%)0!%#M8!78<!*%,!08F*&#8108%J!20%M008!*8,*<0!

78<!#:%,*<0J!M0&0!,:--&0,,0<J!7++#M*8S!'#&!-&0F*#:,+.!:8'#&0,008!0F08%,!%#!7&*,0J!

2#%)!-#,*%*F0!78<!80S7%*F0B!!?%!*,!)0&0!M0!,00!%)0!010&S08$0!#'!S#F0&8108%7+!

10$)78*,1,!#'!,0$:&*%.!%)7%!7*1!%#!17W*1*]0!%)0!2080'*%,!#'!%)*,!*8$&07,0<!

$*&$:+7%*#8!M)*+0!1*8*1*]*8S!*%,!$#,%,B!!A08$0!M0!20S*8!%#!,00!7!S&07%0&!01-)7,*,!#8!

*8'&7,%&:$%:&0,!,:$)!7,!&#7<,!%)7%!7*1!%#!&0S:+7%0!78<!$#8%&#+!%)0!1#F0108%!#'!

*8<*F*<:7+,!7,!M0++!7,!7!S&07%0&!$#8$0&8!M*%)!-:2+*$!).S*080J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7,!*%!&0+7%0,!

%#!7!S&07%0&!<08,*%.!#'!80M!2#<*0,!*8)72*%*8S!%)0!%#M8![L0&&78#F7J!3446\B!

C7W*1*]*8S!%)0!2080'*%,!#'!$*&$:+7%*#8!78<!0W$)78S0!M)*+0!1*8*1*]*8S!#&!

$#1-08,7%*8S!*%,!$#,%,!`!%)0,0!7&0!%)0!F0&.!%0&1,!2.!M)*$)!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%.-*$7++.!

<0'*80<!,0+'`$7&0B!!D0%!M)*+0!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!S#F0&8108%7+*%.!*,!7*10<!7%!1787S*8S!

55h!

78<!$#8%&#++*8S!08%*&0!-#-:+7%*#8,J!%)0!<#17*8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*,!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+B!!?!

$#8%08<!%)7%!%)*,!+#S*$!*,!0F*<08$0!%)7%!%)0!#F0&7&$)*8S!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1J!M)*$)!%)0!%0$)8*V:0,!#'!S#F0&8108%7+*%.!<0,$&*20<!2.!Z#:$7:+%!

*1-+*$*%+.!,:--#&%![=70&S!3446l!L0&&78#F7J!3446\J!*8'#&1,!78<!,)7-0,!)#M!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!,0+'`$7&0B!!P'!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+0F78$0!*,!)#M!%)0!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1!08$#:&7S0,!-0#-+0!%#!<*,-+7$0!%)0!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!%)0!$7&0!#'!%)0!

,0+'!'&#1!%)0!,%7%0!#8%#!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!*8!7!S&07%0&!0''#&%!%#!-&*F7%*]0!-&0F*#:,+.!

-:2+*$!,0&F*$0,!78<!,:2,:10!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!%#!%)0!0$#8#1*$![=&#M8!344h\B!!97&*8S!'#&!

%)0!,0+'!%):,!20$#10,!7!1#&7+!78<!0%)*$7+!*1-0&7%*F0!'#&!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+J!78<!'7*+*8S!

%#!<#!,#!17T0,!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!F:+80&72+0!%#!$08,:&0J!,)710J!78<!%)0!&01#F7+!#'!

$*%*]08,)*-!,%7%:,!78<!*%,!7%%08<78%!-&*F*+0S0,B!

?!,00!,:SS0,%*#8,!#'!%)*,!78W*0%.!*8!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!'&0V:08%!&0'0&08$0,!%#!%)0!

X800<Y!%#!$7&0!'#&!%)0!,0+'B!!L)0!M#&<!X800<Y!M7,!#80!#'!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!

M#&<,!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)08!<0'*8*8S!,0+'`$7&0B!!D0%!<0,-*%0!*%,!'&0V:08$.J!%)0&0!

M7,!F0&.!+*%%+0!<*,$:,,*#8!7,!%#!M)7%!%)0,0!800<,!M0&0!#&!M)0&0!%)0,0!800<,!$710!

'&#1B!!/#10%*10,J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M#:+<!+*8T!%)0,0!800<,!%#!%)0!-).,*$7+!800<,!#'!

%)0!2#<.J!,:$)!7,!M)08!=0&.+!,%7%0<!%)7%!,0+'!$7&0!$78!20!X,+00-*8S!M)08!.#:!800<!

,+00-BY!!A#M0F0&J!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!R:,%!7,! + *T0+.!%#!+07F0!%)0!<0%7*+,!#'!%)0,0!800<,!

:8,-#T08J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!#&*S*8,!#'!%)0,0!800<,J!+07F*8S!10!%#!'+0,)!#:%!%)0!$:+%:&7+!

7,,:1-%*#8,!:8<0&-*88*8S!%)0,0!7,,0&%*#8,B!!!;,!?!)7F0!7+&07<.!,:SS0,%0<J!?!%)*8T!

%)0!'&0V:08%!.0%!712*S:#:,!*8F#$7%*#8!#'!X800<Y!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!,:SS0,%,!)#M!

<00-+.!0120<<0<!%)0*&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*,!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!80#+*20&7+!

<*,$#:&,0,!#'!*8<*F*<:7+!7$$#:8%72*+*%.B!!

55a!

L7T0!%)0!'#++#M*8S!-)&7,0,J!M&*%%08!2.!%)&00!<*''0&08%!-7&%*$*-78%,G!

9)&*,G!!

/0+'`$7&0!`!17T*8S!,:&0!.#:!S0%!%)*8S,!<#80!%)7%!800<!<#80!!

97,0.G!!

/0+'`$7&0!*,!<#*8S!M)7%!?!800<!%#!%#!)7F0!08#:S)!080&S.!78<!01#%*#87+!

$7-7$*%.!%#!<#!u#%)0&v!%)*8S,!

;<7G!!

/0+'!$7&0!*,!%)0!7$%!#'!&0$#S8*]*8S!%)7%!.#:!800<!%#!%7T0!%*10!%#!:8M*8<!78<!

%7T0!$7&0!#'!.#:&!108%7+!)07+%)B!

;++!%)&00!#'!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!0W-&0,,!,0+'`$7&0!7,!80$0,,7&.!*8!#&<0&!'#&!#%)0&!

80$0,,7&.!-&7$%*$0,!%#!#$$:&B!!D0%!7++!#'!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!7+,#!<0$+*80!%#!0W71*80!

M).!%)0,0!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!,#!80$0,,7&.J!#&!0F08!M)7%!%)0.!7&0!80$0,,7&.!'#&B!!;%!

%*10,J!7,!*8!;<7U,!<0,$&*-%*#8J!*%!,#:8<,!+*T0!,0+'`$7&0!*,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!

17*8%0878$0!#'!,78*%.J!M)*$)!':&%)0&!20S,!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!M)7%!*,!<0-+0%*8S!)0&!

,78*%.J!8#%!%#!108%*#8!M).!*%!*,!80$0,,7&.!%#!17*8%7*8!)0&!,78*%.J!#&!0F08!M)7%!,%7%0!

#'!1*8<!S0%,!%#!X$#:8%Y!7,!,78*%.B!!;%!#%)0&!%*10,J!7,!*8!97,0.U,!78<!9)&*,U,!

<0,$&*-%*#8J!*%!,001,!7,!*'!,0+'`$7&0!*,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!$#8%*8:0<!-0&'#&178$0!#'!

+72#&!78<!%)0!M#&T!#'!&0+7%*#8,)*-,B!!(&*#&!%#!%)0!V:#%0!-&#F*<0<J!97,0.!,-0$*'*$7++.!

108%*#8,!X'00+*8S!,7%*,'*0<!78<!1#%*F7%0<!%#!-&#<:$0!7&%!78<!0W-&0,,!$&07%*F*%.J!

)7F0!S#7+,!78<!M#&T!%#M7&<!%)01J!08R#.!,-08<*8S!%*10!M*%)!'&*08<,!'&0V:08%+.!b!

%7$T+0!*8%0++0$%:7+!-&#2+01,!78<!08S*800&*8S!-&#R0$%,J!u78<v!)7F0!S##<!)07&%`%#`

)07&%,Y!7,!0W71-+0,!#'!%)*8S,!%)7%!&0V:*&0!%)0!080&S.!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!&0-+08*,)0,B!!!

D0%!M).!7&0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$%*#8J!+72#&J!78<!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

17*8%0878$0!,#!*1-#&%78%g!!Z#&!0F*<08$0!#'!%)0*&!*1-#&%78$0J!+0%!:,!,*1-+.!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!'00+!%)0,0!<0178<,!,#!,%&#8S+.!%)7%!%)0.!'00+!

$#1-0++0<!%#!$:+%*F7%0!7!&78S0!#'!,:--#&%!-&7$%*$0,!R:,%!,#!%)0.!17.!,7%*,'.!%)0,0!

55i!

<0178<,B!!;,!?!)7F0!2008!7&S:*8SJ!?!20+*0F0!%)7%!7%!+07,%!,#10!#&!-7&%!#'!%)0,0!

<0178<,!,%01!'&#1!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1J!,-0$*'*$7++.!*%,!

0V:7%*#8!#'!-&#<:$%*F*%.!78<!,0+'`,:''*$*08$.!M*%)!1#&7+!M#&%)B!!@#MJ!?!<#!8#%!M78%!

%#!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!*,!%)0!#8+.!'#&$0!7%!M#&T!*8!%)0,0!,*%:7%*#8,B!!L)0!800<,!<0,$&*20<!

2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7&0!$#1-+0W!78<!#F0&<0%0&1*80<J!010&S*8S!'&#1!78!*8%0&,0$%*#8!

#'!,%&:$%:&7+!-&0,,:&0,!78<!-0&,#87+!-&0'0&08$0,B!!A#M0F0&J!?!<#!$#8%08<!%)7%!*%!*,!

*1-#&%78%!%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!80#+*20&7+*,1U,!'#&$0!*'!M0!7&0!%#!$#1-&0)08<!%)0!

1078*8S!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!#:&!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%B!!L)*,!7&S:108%!M*++!20$#10!

$+07&0&!:-#8!0W71*8*8S!%)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!$#8,%&:$%0<!

2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%#!M)*$)!?!8#M!%:&8B!

Participant!Definitions!of!Thriving!!!!!

! I)0&07,!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!,0+'`$7&0!M7,!07,*+.!&0$#S8*]72+0!%#!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!7,!0F*<08$0<!2.!%)0!07,0!M*%)!M)*$)!%)0.!<0,$&*20<!*%!78<!%)0!

$#&&0,-#8<08$0,!20%M008!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,J!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!%)&*F*8S!M7,J!#8!%)0!

M)#+0J!1#&0!:8'71*+*7&B!!?%!*,!*8!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8S!78<!%)0*&!#-*8*#8,!#8!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)&*F*8S!-&7$%*$0,!78<!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!M0!$78!

7+,#!,00!%)0!1#,%!,*S8*'*$78%!<*F0&S08$0,!7+#8S!%)0!-&*17&.!7W0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!*8F0,%*S7%0<!k!$+7,,!78<!,0W:7+*%.B!!?8!%)*,!,0$%*#8J!%)08J!?!M*++!<0,$&*20!

%)0!<*''0&08%!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!%)&*F*8S!7,!M0++!7,!%)0*&!S080&7+!

712*F7+08$0!%#M7&<,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!%#!%)&*F0B!!^+%*17%0+.!?!

M*++!$#8%08<!%)7%!7!-0&,#8U,!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!*8,0$:&*%.!78<!F:+80&72*+*%.J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!7,!%)0.!&0+7%0!%#!17&S*87+*]7%*#8J!M0&0!7!,*S8*'*$78%!*8'+:08$0!#8!

556!

M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)0.!F*0M0<!F*<0#!S710,!7,!-7&%!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!?8!,)#&%J!%)0!$+#,0&!7!

-7&%*$*-78%!M7,!%#!%)0!*<07+*]0<!<#1*878%!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8![*B0B!,%&7*S)%!78<!1*<<+0`

$+7,,\J!%)0!+0,,!+*T0+.!%)0.!M0&0!%#!,:--#&%!%)0!20+*0'!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$#:+<!

$#8%&*2:%0!%#!7!-0&,#8U,!%)&*F*8SB!

! L:&8*8S!%#!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8S!

S*F08!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M7,!X-&#,-0&*8SJY!78!:12&0++7!%0&1!:8<0&!M)*$)!?!

7SS&0S7%0<!#%)0&!,*1*+7&!%0&1,!:,0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!+*T0!XS&#M%)Y!#&!

X*1-&#F*8SJY!78<!X)7--*80,,BY!!;++!%#+<J!&#:S)+.!78!0V:7+!71#:8%!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!

17<0!,#10!&0'0&08$0!%#!X-&#,-0&*8SY!*8!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8S!7,!17<0!,#10!

&0'0&08$0!%#!X)7--*80,,JY!M*%)!3d!-7&%*$*-7 8 %,!&0'0&08$*8S!-&#,-0&*8S!78<!33!

-7&%*$*-78%,!&0'0&08$*8S!)7--*80,,B!!L)0,0!%M#!<0'*8*%*#8,!7+#80!$#1-&*,0<!7+1#,%!

%M#`%)*&<,!#'!7++!-7&%*$*-78%!&0,-#8,0,!%#!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!)#M!%#!<0'*80!%)&*F*8SB!!L)0!

&017*8*8S!<0'*8*%*#8,!M0&0!1#&0!,-0$*'*$!78<!$78!20!20,%!<0,$&*20<!7,!$#1-#808%,!

#'!%)0,0!%M#!2&#7<!,%7%0,J!*8$+:<*8S!%)*8S,!+*T0!X20*8S!*8!$#8%&#+JY!X20*8S!'*878$*7 + + .!

,0$:&0JY!78<!X20*8S!)07+%).BY!!I)*+0!%)0,0!%M#!%0&1,J!X-&#,-0&*8SY!78<!X)7--*80,,JY!

,)7&0!178.!,*1*+7&*%*0,J!?!M*++!%&07%!%)01!,0-7&7%0+.!20$7:,0!?!M78%!%#!)*S)+*S)%!

M)7%!?!%)*8T!*,!7!,*S8*'*$78%!'07%:&0!%#!T00-!*8!1*8<!M)08!%)*8T*8S!72#:%!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)&*F*8S!78<!80#+*20&7+*,1J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7,!*%!&0+7%0,!%#!F*<0#!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!k!%)0!V:7+*%.!#'!1#F0108%B!!/*1-+.!-:%J!X-&#,-0&*8SY!78<!*%,!

&0+7%0<!%0&1,!*1-+.!7!,08,0!#'!1#F0108%!%#M7&<,!78<!$)78S0!'#&!%)0!20%%0&J!M)*+0!

X)7--*80,,Y!+7&S0+.!*1-+*0,!7!,%7%*$!,%7%0B!!A7--*80,,!<0,$&*20,!7!,%7%0!#'!':+'*++108%!

78<!,7%*,'7$%*#8!M*%)!M)7%!)7,!7+&07<.!2008!7$)*0F0<J!M)*+0!-&#,-0&*8S!<0,$&*20,!7!

-0&,-0$%*F0!%)7%!*,!1#&0!#&*08%0<!%#M7&<,!%)0!':%:&0!78<!M)7%!)7,!.0%!%#!20!

534!

7$)*0F0<B!!L)0,0!%M#!,%7%0,!7&0J!#'!$#:&,0J!8#%!1:%:7++.!0W$+:,*F0B!!?8!'7$%J!%)0&0!M7,!

,*S8*'*$78%!#F0&+7-!20%M008!%)0!%M#!<0'*8*%*#8,!71#8S!&0,-#8<08%,B!!D0%!2.!

<*,08%78S+*8S!%)0!%M#!$#8$0-%,!M0!$78!20%%0&!: 8<0&,% 78<!M).!%)0&0!M7,!7!$0&%7*8!

<0S&00!#'!712*F7+08$0!72#:%!$7%0S#&*]*8S!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7,!X%)&*F*8SY!M)08!

F0&.!+*%%+0!712*F7+08$0!0W*,%0<!M)08!$7%0S#&*]*8S!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7,!,0+'`

$7&0B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

L#!20S*8J!+0%!:,!0W71*80!X)7--*80,,Y!1#&0!$+#,0+.!78<!<*,$:,,!)#M!%)*,!

$#8$0-%!M7,!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!%)&*F*8S!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8%0&0,%*8S+.!08#:S)J!

X)7--.Y![7+#8S!M*%)!*%,!F7&*78%,\!M7,!%)0!%)*&<!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!M#&<!2.!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!*8!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!%)0!'*&,%!78<!,0$#8<!20*8S!X%)&*F*8SY!78<!

X+*'0Y!&0,-0$%*F0+.B!!L)*,!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!)7--*80,,!78<!)#M!*%!*,!:8<0&,%##<!7&0!

*1-#&%78%!,:2R0$%,!%#!$#8,*<0&!M)08!%&.*8S!%#!S&7,-!)#M!%)&*F*8S!*,!:8<0&,%##<B!!

I)*+0!,0F0&7+!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0$+*80<!%#!S#!*8%#!<0%7*+!72#:%!M)7%!$#8,%*%:%0,!

X)7--*80,,Y!%#!%)01J!%)0!!#80,!%)7%!<*<!$78!-&#F*<0!:,!M*%)!7!S+*1-,0!*8%#!%)0!

$:+%:&7+!'&710M#&T!%)7%!,#10!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7&0!M#&T*8S!M*%)*8!M)08!%)0.!

<0'*80<!%)&*F*8SB!!L7T0!C7&8*0J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!M)#!<0'*80<!%)&*F*8S!*8!%)0!'#++#M*8S!

M7.G!

?!M#:+<!<0'*80!%)&*F*8S!7,!0W$0++*8S!*8!7++!7&07,!#'!.#:&!+*'0J!,:$)!7,!108%7+!

78<!-).,*$7+!)07+%)J!.#:&!,#$*7+!+*'0J!#$$:-7%*#8J!78<!1#,%!*1-#&%78%+.!)7--.!

M*%)!.#:&,0+'!78<!.#:&!+*'0B!

P&!"7F*<G!

L)&*F*8S!*,!#80!*,!7%!%)0*&!-07T!*8!%)0*&!+*'0!78<!7&0!S080&7++.!)7--.J!7%!07,0J!

$)7++08S0!%)01,0+F0,J!78<!%7T0!+*'0!*8!,%&*<0B!L)0.!)7F0!178.!%)*8S,!%#!+##T!

'#&M7&<!%#!+*T0!':8!0F08%,J!'&*08<,)*-,J!-0&,#87+!-&#R0$%,J!-&#2+01!,#+F*8SJ!

<&071*8SJ!78<!+#F*8S!%)01,0+F0,!78<!#%)0&,!7&#:8<!%)01!:8$#8<*%*#87++.!

535!

;8<!'*87++.J!(7%%.G!

L)&*F*8SG!;!S080&7+!08R#.108%!'#&!+*'0J!800<,!7&0!20*8S!10%B!Z*878$0,!7&0!

,%72+0!78<!T0-%!*8!%)0!2+7$T!&0S:+ 7 &+.J!08#:S)!'##<!*8!%)0!'&*<S0J!+#80+*80,,!*,!

1*8*17+!

Z&#1!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,U!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!M)7%!$#8,%*%:%0,!)7--*80,,J!7!'0M!%)010,!

20S*8!%#!010&S0B!!E7$)!-7&%*$*-78%J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!17<0!&0'0&08$0!%#!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!

M)0%)0&!%)0.!20!&#178%*$!#&!-+7%#8*$![X,#$*7+!+*'0lY!X'&*08<,)*-,JY!X+#80+*80,,!*,!

1*8*17+Y\B!!K72#&!78<!-&#<:$%*F*%.!7&0!7+,#!*1-#&%78%!%#!%)&*F*8S!'#&!%)0,0!

-7&%*$*-78%,B!!L)*,!$#:+<!,-0$*'*$7++.!20!M7S0!+72#&J!7,!C7&8*0!78<!(7%%.!&0'0&08$0J!#&!

*%!$#:+<!20!%)0!1#&0!802:+#:,!'00+*8S!#'!20*8S!-&#<:$%*F0!78<!$)7++08S0<J!7,!"7F*<!

$+7*1,B!!?!M#:+<!-:%!'#&M7&<!%)7%!%)0,0!7&0!$#8F08%*#87+!1#<0+,!#'!,:$$0,,B!!;,!

A7+20&,%71![3455\!8#%0,J!,:$$0,,!*8!7!$7-*%7+*,%J!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!*,!

#'%08!0V:7%0<!M*%)!M07+%)!7$$:1:+7%*#8!78<!7!-7&%*$:+7&!+0F0+!#'!01#%*#87+!

17%:&*%.J!#'%08!107,:&0<!2.!#80U,!72*+*%.!%#!$&07%0!78<!17*8%7*8!7!8:$+07&!'71*+.B!!

"0,-*%0!%)0!&0$08%!$&*%*V:0,!#'!%)0,0!1#<0+,!#'!,:$$0,,!%)7%!)7F0!7&*,08!*8!%)0!M7T0!

#'!%)0!'*878$*7+!$&*,*,!#'!%)0!+7%0!3444,!78<!%)0!S&#M*8S!&0$#S8*%*#8!#'!V:00&!

,:2R0$%*F*%*0,J!%)0,0!1#<0+,!#'!,:$$0,,!,%*++!)7F0!7!S&07%!<07+!#'!-:&$)7,0!*8!%)0!

'78%7,*0,!#'!-0#-+0B!!!

L)*,!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!M7,!'7*&+.!M0++!&0-&0,08%0<!71#8S!%)0!<*''0&08%!

*<08%*%.!-#,*%*#8,!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!*8)72*%0<B!!C#&0#F0&J!%)*,!<0'*8*%*#8!M7,!7+,#!

1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!0W-&0,,0<!2.!%)#,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!$#:+<!20!&07<!7,!20+#8S*8S!%#!

%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0`$+7,,!78<!1*<<+0`$+7,,J!7,!M0++!7,!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!)7F0!1#F0<!

20%M008!%)0,0!%M#!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,B!!I)*+0!?!)0,*%7%0!%#!17T0!78.!S080&7+!$+7*1,!

27,0<!#8!%)*,!<7%7J!,*8$0!1.!,71-+0!,*]0!<#0,!8#%!,:--#&%!*%J!%)*,!<7%7!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!

533!

,%&:$%:&0,!#'!'00+*8S!%)7%!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!%)0!1*<<+0!$+7,,J!1#,%!

8#%72+.!,0$:&*%.J!$#:+<!#&*08%!,:2R0$%,!%#M7&<,!7!1#&0!,%7%*$!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!

L)*,!*,!':&%)0&!,:--#&%0<!2.!7!$:&*#:,!0+0108%!%)7%!?!8#%0<!71#8S!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!

%)7%!?!M#:+<!<0,$&*20!7,!X$#1'#&%72+.Y!1*<<+0`$+7,,J!*B0B!%)#,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#,0!

-7&08%,J!$)*+<)##<!0W-0&*08$0,J!78<!+*'0!%&7R0$%#&*0,!$+#,0+.!7+*S8!M*%)!%)0!*17S*80<!

*<07+!#'!7!-&#'0,,*#87+!$+7,,!k!)*S)+.!0<:$7%0<J!M*%)!,%72+0!01-+#.108%J!78<!M*%)!8#!

8#%72+0!'71*+*7+!*8,0$:&*%*0,!<0,$&*20<B!!L)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!,-0$*'*$7++.!108%*#80<!

X$#8%&#+Y!M)08!<0,$&*2*8S!)7--*80,,J!*8!$#8%&7,%!%#!%)0!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!M0&0!

8#%!,#!$+#,0+.!7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!1*<<+0`$+7,,!*<07+J!M)#!80F0&!108%*#80<!%)0!%0&1B!!?!

8#%0!%)*,!%#!,)#M!)#M!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!*<07!#'!)7--*80,,!0W-&0,,0<!2.!,#10!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!M*%)!*%,!'#:8<7%*#8!*8!$7-*%7+*,%J!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!107,:&0,!#'!,:$$0,,J!

*,!$+#,0+.!&0+7%0<!%#!'00+*8S,!#'!,0$:&*%.J!,#!1:$)!,#!%)7%!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!#80!

M#:+<!-&0<*$%!M#:+<!)7F0!%)0!+07,%!71#:8%!#'!0W-0&*08$0!M*%)!*8,0$:&*%.J!27,0<!#8!

%)0*&!$+7,,!2*#S&7-)*0,J!7+,#!<0,$&*20!20*8S!*8!$#8%&#+!7,!7!T0.!0+0108%!#'!%)&*F*8S!

M)08!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!<#!8#%B!

;++!#'!%)*,!*,!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!7!-7&%*$*-78%U,!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)&*F*8S!*,!<00-+.!

*8'#&10<!2.!%)0*&!$+7,,!0W-0&*08$0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7,!%)0.!&0+7%0!%#!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!

$#8%&#+J!:8$0&%7*8%.J!78<!F:+80&72*+*%.B!!L)0!+0,,!0W-0&*08$0!7!-7&%*$*-78%!)7<!M*%)!

*8,0$:&*%.!78<!F:+80&72*+*%.J!M)0%)0&!&0,:+%*8S!'&#1!0$#8#1*$!%&#:2+0,J!'71*+*7+!

<*,%:&278$0,J!#&!)07+%)!-&#2+01,J!%)0!,%&#8S0&!%)0!%08<08$.!%#!<0,$&*20!%)&*F*8S!*8!

,%7%*$!%0&1,!,:$)!7,!)7--*80,,B!!C#&0#F0&J!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!7+,#!1#&0!+*T0+.!

%#!$7%0S#&*]0!X20*8S!*8!$#8%&#+Y!7,!7!,*S8*'*$78%!$#1-#808%!#'!%)7%!)7--*80,,B!!;S7*8J!

%)#:S)J!?!M78%!%#!$7&0':++.!V:7+*'.!%)*,!7&S:108%B!!L)0!<*''0&08$0,!%)7%!?!71!

53d!

<0,$&*2*8S!7&0!,:2%+0!F7&*7%*#8,!*8!*8%08,*%.J!8#%!,%7&T!$#8%&7,%,B!!;++!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!8#!17%%0&!%)0!7W*,!#'!<*''0&08$0!:,0<!%#!<*''0&08%*7%0!20%M008!%)01J!

M0&0!+*T0+.!%#!<0,$&*20!X%)&*F*8SY!7,!X)7--*80,,BY!!?%!*,!R:,%!%)7%!%)0!%0&1,!:,0<!%#!

<0,$&*20!%)*,!)7--*80,,!M0&0!,+*S)%+.!<*''0&08%!'#&!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!7+*S80<!1#,%!

$+#,0+.!M*%)!%)0!*<07+*]0<!1*<<+0`$+7,,!,:2R0$%B!!L)7%!*,J!%)0&0!M7,!7!,%&#8S0&!

%08<08$.!%#!$)7&7$%0&*]0!)7--*80,,!*8!%0&1,!#'!X$#8%&#+JY!M)*$)!*,!$#8,*,%08%!M*%)!7!

1*<<+0`$+7,,!0W-0&*08$0!%)7%!&017*8,!&0+7%*F0+.!:817&T0<!2.!%)0!<00-!'00+*8S,!#'!

*8,0$:&*%.!78<!F:+80&72*+*%.!<0,$&*20<!2.!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,B!

=:%!M)7%!72#:%!%)0!#%)0&!<#1*878%!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!X%)&*F*8SY!-:%!'#&M7&<!2.!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!k!X-&#,-0&*8SgY!!;,!,%7%0<!72#F0J!M)*+0!,*1*+7&!%#!X)7--*80,,Y!78<!

'&0V:08%+.!7--07&*8S!7+#8S,*<0!*%J!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!X-&#,-0&*8SY !$#88#%0,!7!,08,0!#'!

1#2*+*%.!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8!%)7%!X)7--*80,,Y!<#0,!8#%B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!%7T0!%)0!

'#++#M*8S!0W71-+0,!#'!%)*,!<0'*8*%*#8G!

=0&.+G!!

;%!%)0!,710!%*10J!?!$#8,*<0&!%)&*F*8S!%#!*8<*$7%0!20*8S!*8!7!,%7%0!#'!1*8<!

M)0&0!.#:w&0!S&#M*8S!78<!$)78S*8SJ!<0F0+#-*8S!%)#:S)%!-7%%0&8,!78<!,T*++,!

?,77$G!!

?wF0!80F0&!S*F08!1:$)!%)#:S)%!%#!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!2:%!?w<!,7.!%)7%!*%!

&0'0&,!%#!7!+*F*8S!20*8S!8#%!#8+.!+*F*8 S !78<!,:&F*F*8SJ!2:%!S&#M*8S!78<!

<0F0+#-*8S!20.#8<!*%,!-&0F*#:,!+0F0+!#&!$7-7$*%.B!

K0,+*0G!!

/00*8S!7,!y%)&*F0y!$#10,!'&#1!%)0!P+<!@#&,0!U3V?$J!M)*$)!1078,!y%#!S&7,-Jy!

78<!0F08%:7++.!%##T!#8!%)0!1078*8S!#'!'+#:&*,)*8S!#&!-&#,-0&*8SJ!?w<!,7.!%)7%!?!

<0'*80!%)&*F*8S!7,!7%%7*8*8SJ!#&!17T*8S!-#,*%*F0!-&#S&0,,!*8!7%%7*8*8SJ!%)7%!'#&!

M)*$)!?!71!S&7,-*8S!%#M7&<B!

?8!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!X%)&*F*8SY!7,!X-&#,-0&*8SJY!M0!$78!,00!7!S&07%0&!

<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!X%)&*F*8SY!78<!X,0+'`$7&0Y!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0!7<<0<!01-)7,*,!#8!

53f!

1#2*+*%.B!!;,!<0,$&*20<!7%!%)0!20S*88*8S!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!

'7F#&0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M7,!$+#,0+.!&0+7%0<!%#!%)0!*<07!#'!)#10#,%7,*,J!M)0&02.!

%)0!,:2R0$%!7$)*0F0,!7!,%7%0!#'!,%72*+*%.!*8!%)0!1*<,%!#'!'+:$%:7%*8S!*8%0&87+!78<!

0W%0&87+!'#&$0,B!!L)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!X%)&*F*8SY!7,!X)7--*80,,Y!#8+.!<*''0&,!'&#1!%)*,!

<0'*8*%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!%)0!<0S&00!%#!M)*$)!%)0!,:2R0$%!*,!01#%*#87++.!,7%*,'*0<!M*%)!

%)*,!,%7%0!#'!,%72*+*%.B!!L)0!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!X%)&*F*8SY!7,!X-&#,-0&*8SJY!)#M0F0&J!

*8%&#<:$0,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!7!<0,*&0!'#&!S&#M%)!78<!*1-&#F0108%J!78<!)08$0!7!<0S&00!

#'!:8$0&%7*8%.J!*,!*1-#&%78%!%#!,#10!-7&%*$*-78%,U!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!A#M0F0&J!!

M)*+0!%)*,!<0S&00!#'!:8$0&%7*8%.!1078,!%)7%!-#,*%*F0!#:%$#10,!7&0!8#%!S:7&78%00<J!

78<!%):,!*1-+*0,!%)0&0!*,!,#10!&*,T!*8F#+F0<J!-7&%*$*-78%,!<*<!8#%!108%*#8!%)*,!&*,T!

*8!%)0!X-&#,-0&*8SY!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!L)*,!+07<,!10!%#!$#8$+:<0!%)7%!%)0!<0S&00!

#'!&*,T!*8)0&08%!%#!%)0!$#8$0-%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!20*8S!$#8,%&:$%0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!*,!

,#!,17++!7,!%#!20!80S+*S*2+0B!!!

A0&0!?!'*8<!*%!-&#<:$%*F0!%#!&01*8<!%)0!&07<0&!#'!9]*T,]08%1*)7+.*U,![5666\!

$#8$0-%!#'!X'+#MBY!!;,!<*,$:,,0<!*8!%)0!$#8$0-%:7+!'&710M#&T!$)7-%0&!#'!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8J!X'+#MY!&0'0&,!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&! ,% 7%0!*8!M)*$)!78!*8<*F*<:7+U,!7%%08%*#8!*,!

$#1-+0%0+.!#$$:-*0<!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!%7,TB!!I)7%!?!M78%!%#!<&7M!7%%08%*#8!%#!*,!%)0!

&#+0!%)7%!<*''*$:+%.!-+7.,!*8!%)0!$&07%*#8!#'!7!,%7%0!#'!'+#MB!!;,!<0,$&*20<!2.!

9]*T,]08%1*)7+.*J!%)0!-+07,:&72+0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!'+#M!*,!S080&7++.!-&#<:$0<!2.!7!%7,T!

%)7%!*,!7%!7!T*8<!#'!X,M00%!,-#%Y!#'!<*''*$:+%.!'#&!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!k!8#%!%##!07,.!78<!8#%!

%##!)7&<B!!?8!,)#&%J!*%!*,!7!%7,T!%)7%!7!,:2R0$%!1:,%!M#&T!%#!7$)*0F0J!2:%!%)7%!%)0!

,:2R0$%!*,!&07,#872+.!$#8'*<08%!%)7%!%)0.!$78!7 $)*0F0! M*%)!%)0!,T*++,!%)7%!%)0.!

$:&&08%+.!-#,,0,,B!!L)*,!*,!%)0!T*8<!#'!$)7++08S0!%)7%!M#:+<!20,%!<0,$&*20!%)0!

53c!

:8$0&%7*8%.!*1-+*0<!2.!%)0!X-&#,-0&*8SY!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!k!7!$)7++08S0!%)7%!

-:,)0,!%)0!,:2R0$%!78<!08$#:&7S0,!,#10!S&#M%)!78<!<0F0+#-108%!M*%)#:%!%&:+.!

%)&07%08*8S!#&!<*,178%+*8S!%)0!0,%72+*,)0<!M#&+<!#&<0&!#'!%)0!,:2R0$%B!!?%!*,!-#,*%*F0!

S&#M%)!M*%)*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%0W%!#&!,%&:$%:&0!%)7%!<#0,!8#%!&7<*$7++.!7+%0&!%)7%!

$#8%0W%!#&!,%&:$%:&0!k!7!$7&0':++.!$#8%&#++0<!78<!1787S0<!:8$0&%7*8%.B!!

The!Bigger!Picture!of!Thriving!

! =0'#&0!-&#S&0,,*8S!%#!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!-7&%*$*-78%,!F*0M0<!F*<0#!S710!

-&7$%*$0,!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)&*F*8S!78<!,0+'`$7&0J!?!M78%!%#!%7T0!7!,%0-!27$T!78<!-&#F*<0!

78!#F0&F*0Mo,.8%)0,*,!#'!%)0!-&0<#1*878%!M7.,!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!

%)&*F*8S!78<!)#M!%)7%!&0+7%0,!%#!%)0!2&#7<0&!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!

%)7%!?!7&S:0!*,!$08%&7+!%#!%)*,!:8<0&,%78<*8SB!!;,!,%7%0<!72#F0J!%)0!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!

%)&*F*8S!7,!X)7--*80,,Y!78<!7,!X-&#,-0&*%.JY!M)*+0!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!#80!78#%)0&J!

'&0V:08%+.!010&S0<!%#S0%)0&!*8!7!<0'*8*%*#8!-&#F*<0<!2.!7!,*8S+0!-7&%*$*-78%B!!L):,!

<0,-*%0!%)0*&!<*''0&08$0,!*%!*,!*1-#&%78%!%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!%)0,0!<0'*8*%*#8,!7&0!

'&0V:08%+.!%78S+0<!%#S0%)0&!78<!-&0,08%0<!7,!$#)0&08%!*8! % )0!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!

%)&*F*8S!0W-&0,,0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!L)*,!+07<,!10!%#!M)7%!?!)7F0!<0$*<0<!%#!$7++!

%)0!X)7+'`&07+Y!$#1-#808%!#'!%)&*F*8S![78!)#17S0!%#!N0,-0&!N::+U,![344c\!'71#:,!

<0,$&*-%*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7,!X)7+'`&07+Y\B!!?!,7.!X)7+'`&07+Y!%#!,*S87+!%)0!*<07!%)7%!% )0!

0W-0&*08$0!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!<0'*80<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!*,!2#%)!78!*17S*80<J!

-&#,-0&#:,!':%:&0!,%7%0!78<!7!-&0,08%J!%)#:S)!,%*++!*<07+*]0<J!,%7%0B!!?8!%)0!*17S*87&.!

#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%)08J!%)&*F*8S!0W*,%,!7,!7!,%7%0!M)0&0!%)0!%M#!$#8%&7<*$%#&.!

53h!

0W-0&*08$0,!8710<!72#F0![X)7--*80,,Y!78<!X-&#,-0&*%.Y\!$78!20J!7%!%*10,J!

&0$#8$*+0<!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&B!!!

! L)*,!&0,#+:%*#8J!*8!1.!%)*8T*8SJ!*,!$&:$*7+!%#!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!M#&T!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1B!!;,!,%7%0<!72#F0J!%)0!X)7--*80,,Y!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!<0,$&*20<!2.!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!7+*S8,!M*%)!M)7%!A7+20&,%71![3455\!)7,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!,:$$0,,!*8!7!

$7-*%7+*,%J!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!k!%)0!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!M07+%)J!%)0!

0,%72+*,)108%!#'!,%72+0!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!2#%)!&#178%*$!78<!-+7%#8*$J!78<!-7&%*$*-7%*#8!

*8!-&#<:$%*F0!+72#&B!!L)0!X-&#,-0&*%.Y!7,-0$%!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!1078M)*+0J!#&*08%,!

-7&%*$*-78%,!%#M7&<,!80#+*20&7+*,1U,!<0,*&0!'#&!$#8%*8:0<!S&#M%)!78<!7$V:*,*%*#8B!!

L)0!X)7+'`&07+Y!87%:&0!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!%)08J!M*%)!*%,!-&#1*,0!#'!2#%)!-&0,08%!78<!':%:&0!

)7--*80,,!78<!S&#M%)J!$78!20!7!-#M0&':+!*<0#+#S*$7+!%##+!%#!&0$#8$*+0!-7&%*$*-78%,!

M*%)!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!*%,!-&#1*,0,!78<!'78%7,*0,B!!

! I)7%!*,!+0'%!#:%!#'!%)*,!'78%7,.!*,J!#'!$#:&,0J!%)0!0W-+#*%7%*F0!78<!7+*087%*8S!

0+0108%,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1J!M)*$)!0W%&7$%,!-).,*$7+J!*8%0++0$%:7+J!78<!01#%*#87+!+72#&!

'&#1!%)0!2#<*0,!#'!*%,!,:2R0$%,J!%&78,'#&1,!*%!*8%#!$7-*%7+J!78<!%)08!<*,%&*2:%0,!%)*,!

$7-*%7+!:80F08+.!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!-#-:+7%*#8!7$$#&<*8S!%#!+#S*$,!%)7%!7&0!*8':,0<!M*%)!

&7$*,1J!)0%0&#,0W*,1J!1*,#S.8.J!78<!#%)0&!<*F*,*F0!*<0#+#S*0,B!!A08$0!%)0!800<!'#&!

,0+'`$7&0B!!/0+'`$7&0!20$#10,!%)0!10$)78*,1!M)0&02.!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!,:2R0$%!&0-7*&,!

*%,0+'!'&#1!%)0!*8R:&*0,!%)7%!7&0!$#8%*8:#:,+.!*8'+*$%0<!*8!7!$7-*%7+*,%J!

)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!%)7%!#8+.!<001,!$0&%7*8!$+7,,!+#$7%*#8,!78<!

0W-&0,,*#8,!#'!,0W:7+*%.!7,!F7+:72+0!78<!M#&%).B!!/)#:+<!%)0!,:2R0$%!'*8<!)0&,0+'!

#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!87&&#M!&78S0!#'!$+7,,!+#$7%*#8,!78<!,0W:7+*%*0,!-&*F*+0S0<!M*%)*8!%)*,!

$7-*%7+*,%J!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0J!%)0!*8R:&*0,!*8'+*$%0<!7&0!<00-0&!78<!%)0!

53a!

M#:8<,!,:,%7*80<!1#&0!$)&#8*$B!!L)0!-&#R0$%!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!:8<0&!%)0,0!$#8<*%*#8,J!

20$#10,!1#&0!78<!1#&0!$#8,:1*8SB!!D0%!*%!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!=.!

X80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8JY!?!1078!%)7%!7+%)#:S)!,0+'`$7&0!<#0,!8#%!S:7&78%00!%)7%!#80!

M*++!%)&*F0J!#80!$788#%!%)&*F0!M*%)#:%!*%B!!;8<!7%!+07,%!,#10!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!

7M7&0!#'!%)*,!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!P80!

-7&%*$*-78%J!?+080J!0W-&0,,0<!%)*,!*<07!7%!*%,!,*1-+0,%!M)08!,)0!,%7%0<!%)7%J!X/0+'!$7&0!

*,!20*8S!72+0!%#!%7T0!$7&0!#'!.#:&,0+'!108%7++.!78<!-).,*$7++.B!L)&*F*8S!*,!%)0!72#F0!

;@"!0W$00<*8S!*%BY!!?8!'7$%J!%)0!,%7%0108%!%)7%!%)&*F*8S!*,!X1#&0!%)78!R:,%!,:&F*F*8SY!

7--07&0<!*8!i!-7&%*$*-78%,U!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!+08<*8S!M0*S)%!%#!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

,0+'`$7&0!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!0+0108%!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!!

! L#!,:117&*]0J!-7&%*$*-78%,!2&#7<+.!<0'*80<!%)&*F*8S!*8!%M#J!8#8`1:%:7++.!

0W$+:,*F0!M7.,!k!)7--*80,,!78<!-&#,-0&*%.B!!L)*,!+07<!10!%#!$#8$+:<0!%)7%!%)&*F*8SJ!

7,!*%!M7,!:8<0&,%##<!2.!%)0!10120&,!#'!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!?!08S7S0<!

M*%)J!*,!X)7+'`&07+JY!$#1-#,0<!%#!F7&.*8S!<0S&00,!#'!,7%*,'7$%*#8!M*%)!7!-&0,08%!,%7%0!

#'!7''7*&,!78<!78!#&*08%7%*#8!%#M7&<,!78!*17S*80<!':%:&0!#'!0F08!S&07%0&!-&#,-0&*%.B!!

L):,J!%)0!20,%!M#&T*8S!<0'*8*%*#8!%)7%!?!$78!-&#F*<0!*,!%)7%!%)&*F*8S!*,!%)0!-&#$0,,!2.!

M)*$)!-0#-+0!,:--#&%!78<!,:,%7*8!%)0*&!+*'0!M#&+<,!M)*+0!*17S*8*8S!7!20%%0&!':%:&0B!!!

=0'#&0!%)&*F*8S!$78!20!7$)*0F0<J!%)08J!7!-7&%*$*-78%!1:,%!'*&,%!20!72+0!%#!

,:&F*F0J!*B0B!17*8%7*8!%)0*&!-).,*$7+J!108%7+J!78<!01#%*#87+!)07+%)B!!L):,!,0+'`$7&0!*,!7!

80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!A#M0F0&J!%)0!<0178<,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)0!

&0,#:&$0,!800<0<!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!7&0!8#%!<*,%&*2:%0<!0V:7++.J!+7&S0+.!7,!7!&0,:+%!#'!

0$#8#1*$!78<!*<0#+#S*$7+!,%&:$%:&0,!%)7%!-&*F*+0S0!$0&%7*8!,#$*7+!+#$7%*#8,!72#F0!

#%)0&,B!!P80!#'!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!-&#R0$%,!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1J!%)#:S)J!*,!%#!#2':,$7%0!%)0!

53i!

,%&:$%:&7+!#&*S*8,!#'!%)0,0!*80V:7+*%*0,!78<!<*,-+7$0!%)#,0!#&*S*8,!#8%#!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!

,:2R0$%J!<0178<*8S!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!,:2R0$%!20!&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!%)0*&!,0+'`$7&0!M)*+0!7%!

%*10,!<0-&*F*8S!%)01!#'!%)0!F0&.!&0,#:&$0,!800<0<!%#!%7T0!$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'B!!L)*,!*,!

%)0!2&#7<!,%&:$%:&0!*8!M)*$)!%)0!-&0<#1*878%+.!+#M0&`1*<<+0!$+7,,!78<!1*<<+0`

$+7,,!-7&%*$*-78%,!#'!1.!,%:<.!,*%:7%0<!%)0*&!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!2#%)!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

%)&*F*8SB!

How!Gaming!Practices!Relate!to!Self-Care!and!Thriving!

! @#M!%)7%!?!)7F0!0,%72+*,)0<!%)0!2&#7<!*<0#+ #S*$7 +!,%&:$%:&0!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!7&0!17<0!+0S*2+0J!?!M*++!

%:&8!%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!<*,$:,,!)#M!%)*,!-&7$%*$0!*,!,*%:7%0<!

*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!%)0!1#&0!S080&7+!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!-&7$%*$0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8!

,)#&%J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!S080&7++.!&0,-#8,*F0!%#!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,!$#:+<!20!7!F*%7+!-7&%!#'!#80U,!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,B!!A#M0F0&J!M)08!*%!$#10,!

%#!%)&*F*8SJ!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!1#&0!712*F7+08%!72#:%!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,!$#:+<!)0+-!,#10#80!%)&*F0J!M*%)!,0F0&7+!#:%&*S)%!V:0,%*#8*8S!#&!<08.*8S!

%)7%!%)*,!$#:+<!#$$:&B!!K7:&08!=0&+78%![3455\!)7,!8#%0<!7!,*1*+7&!7''0$%*F0!,%78$0!*8!

M#108U,!+*%0&7&.!$:+%:&0J!7!,%78$0!%)7%!,)0!)7,!%0&10<!X$&:0+!#-%*1*,1BY!!Z#&!%)0!

,7T0!#'!,-0$*'*$*%.J!)#M0F0&J!?!M*++!&0'0&!%#!%)*,!#2,0&F7%*#8!7,!%)0!X-7&7<#W!#'!,0+'`

$7&0Y!k!%)0!20+*0'!%)7%!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!*,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!#80U,!&0-7*&!78<!&080M7+!7+,#!

-&0F08%,!%)7%!-0&,#8!'&#1!1#F*8S!20.#8<!XR:,%!,:&F*F*8SBY!!/0+'`$7&0J!'&#1!%)*,!

-0&,-0$%*F0J!$78!20!,008!7,!$#8%&7<*$%#&.!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!<0,-*%0!*%,!,%7%:,!7,!7!

80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!*%!*,!-#,,*2+0J!#&!7%!+07,%!-+7:,*2+0!%#!

536!

20+*0F0J!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!2#%)!)0+-!78<!)7&1!7!-0&,#8J!#'%08!,*1:+%780#:,+.B!!

Z#&!%)0!&017*8<0&!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!?!M*++!7%%01-%!%#!:8-7$T!78<!<0F0+#-!%)*,!'*8<*8S!

M)*+0!787+.]*8S!)#M!%)*,!*<07!M7,!<*,%&*2:%0<!7$&#,,!%)0!F7&*#:,!7W0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!

%)7%!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!*,!$#8$0&80<!M*%)B!

! L:&8*8S!%#!%)0!#2,0&F7%*#8!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7<F#$7%0<!'#&!%)0!

*1-#&%78$0!#'!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%#!,0+'!$7&0J!%)0!,%&#8S0,%!0F*<08$0!*8!'7F#&!#'!

%)*,!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!M7,!8#%!,#!1:$)!*8!M)7%!M7,!,7*<!7,!*8!M)7%!M7,!8#%!,7*<!*8!%)0*&!

,:&F0.!&0,-#8,0,B!!=.!%)*,!?!1078!%)7%!%)0&0!M7,!8#!#F0&%!<*,7S&00108%!M*%)!%)0!

*<07J!0W-&0,,0<!*8!%)0!,:&F0.J!%)7%!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!$#:+<!20!7!-7&%!#'!7!

-0&,#8U,!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,B!!?8!'7$%J!,0+'`$7&0!$#:+<!20!&07<!7,!#80!#'!%)0!1#,%J!*'!8#%!

%)0!1#,%J!*1-#&%78%!&07,#8,!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!

L)*,!$78!20!*8'0&&0<!'&#1!%)0*&!1#%*F7%*#8,!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!>0+7W7%*#8!M7,!

%)0!1#,%!-#-:+7&!&07,#8!$*%0<!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!M*%)!df!-7&%*$*-78%,J!#&!

&#:S)+.!)7+'!#'!%)0!-#-:+7%*#8J!$+7*1*8S!%)7%!%)0.!-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!7%!+07,%!-7&%+.!

'#&!&0+7W7%*#8!#&!&0+*0'!'&#1!,%&0,,B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!%)*,!1#%*F7%*#8!M7,!%)0!1#,%!

'&0V:08%+.!$*%0<!7$&#,,!%)0!F7&*#:,!7W0,!#'!<*''0&08$0!7,$0&%7*80<!2.!1.!,:&F0.B!!

C078M)*+0J!#%)0&!1#%*F7%*#8,!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!M0&0!'&0V:08%+.!$*%0<J!

,:$)!7,!XZ:8Y![5h!-7&%*$*-78%,\J!X"*,%&7$%*#8Y ! [5d!-7&%*$*-78%,\J!78<!XE,$7-0Y![6!

-7&%*$*-78%,\J!7&0!7++!$+#,0+.!7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!-&*17&.!S#7+!#'!,0+'`$7&0!k!%)0!

17*8%0878$0!#'!)07+%)J!*8$+:<*8S!*%,!&0-7*&!78<!&080M7+B!!I)*+0!?!M#:+<!)0,*%7%0!%#!

$+7*1!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!-7&%!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!,0+'`$7&0!

-&7$%*$0,J!,*8$0!#8+.!7!)78<':+!$+7*10<!7,!,:$)J!%)0!0F*<08$0!M7&&78%,!%)0!,#'%0&!

$+7*1!%)7%!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!$#1-7%*2+0!M*%)!%)0!+7&S0&!-&#R0$%!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!

5d4!

7,!0W-&0,,0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8<00<J!7,!?!M*++!7&S:0!*8!%)0!'#++#M*8S!$)7-%0&,J!

%)0&0!7&0!$0&%7*8!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!,:$)!7,!%)0*&!01-)7,*,!#8!&0-0%*%*#8!78<!

7$)*0F0108%J!%)7%!17T0!%)01!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M0++`,:*%0<!%#!%)0!-&#R0$%!#'!,0+'`$7&0!

:8<0&!80#+*20&7+*,1B!

! I)08!*%!$#10,!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!)#M0F0&J!%)0!-*$%:&0!*,!1#&0!712*S:#:,B!!I)*+0!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!07,*+.J!0F08!,#10%*10,!08%):,*7,%*$7++.J!+*8T0<!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!

M*%)!,0+'`$7&0J!%)0.!M0&0!#8!%)0!M)#+0!1#&0!712*F7+08%!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!I)08!<*&0$%+.!7,T0<!72#:%!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!F*<0#!

S710,!$#8%&*2:%0<!%#!%)0*&!0W-0&*08$0!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!78<!)#M!%)0.!<*<!,#J!%)0!1#,%!

'&0V:08%+.!,%7%0<!*<07!M7,!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!<*<!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8S!20$7:,0!#'!

%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!)0+-!-0#-+0!&0+7W![34!-7&%*$*-78%,\B!!A#M0F0&J!78!7+1#,%!0V:7+!

8:120&!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,![5a!-7&%*$*-78%,\!#:%&*S)%!,%7%0<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!<#!8#%!

$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!78<!*8!'7$%!$#:+<!7$%*F0+.!<0%&7$%!'&#1!%)&*F*8SB!!L7T0!%)0!

'#++#M*8S!,%7%0108%,J!M)*$)!7&0!'7*&+.!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!#'!%)0!&07,#8,!S*F08!'#&!M).!

F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!<#!8#%!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SG!

(7%%.G!!

/*8$0!S710,!7&0!7!'#&1!#'!0,$7-*,1!'#&!10![78<!+*'0!)7,!2008!,%&0,,':+!+7%0+.\!

?!<#!8#%!%)*8T!%)0.!)0+-!10!%)&*F0J!2:%!%)0.!<#!)0+-!10!'00+!7!2*%!1#&0!,%72+0!

78<!$7+1J!,#!%)0.wF0!2008!7!):S0!&0+*0'!'#&!,0+'!$7&0B!

@*$#+0G!!

@#%!&07++.J!?!M*,)!?!<*<!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,B!L)0.!7&0!7!<*,%&7$%*#8!'&#1!<7*+.!

,%&0,,#&,J!2:%!%7T0!%*10!7M7.!'&#1!%)0!20%%0&!1#&0!y&07+y!%)*8S,!*8!+*'0J!,:$)!

7,!,-08<*8S!%*10!M*%)!'&*08<,J!#&!08R#.*8S!%)0!#:%<##&,B!L#!10!%)&*F*8S!

M#:+<!20!%#!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!78<!0W-0&*08$0!+*'0!*8!7!1#&0!0W-78,*F0!

M7.!

5d5!

(7:+*80G!!

(0&,#87++.J!?!<#8w%!%)*8T!S71*8S!*,!)0+-':+!R:,%!20$7:,0!*%w,!8#%!&07+B!!D#:!7&0!

8#%!<#*8S!78.%)*8S!-&#<:$%*F0!7%!7++B!!().,*$7++.!.#:!7&08w%!20*8S!)07+%).!78<!

108%7++.!.#:w&0!R:,%!1:%*8S!.#:&!01#%*#8,!78<!'00+*8S,!M)*$)!*,8w%!)07+%).B!

/0F0&7+!%)010,!010&S0<!'&#1!%)0,0!,%7%0108%,B!!P80!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!

S710,!$78!<0%&7$%!'&#1!%)&*F*8S!0F08!*'!%)0.!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!7!-0&,#8U,!,0+'`$7&0B!!L)0!

,0$#8<!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!<*,%&7$%!7!-0&,#8!'&#1!%)0!X&07+Y!-&7$%*$0,!*8!

+*'0!%)7%!7$%:7++.!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!,:$)!7,!$#1-78*#8,)*-!78<!-&#<:$%*F*%.B!!

=#%)!#'!%)0,0!*<07,!7&0!$#8,*,%08%!M*%)!7!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!,:,-*$*#8!#'!10<*7J!*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!F*<0#!S710,B!!"*,$:,,*#8,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8!%)0!17*8,%&071!%08<!%#!'#$:,!

<*,-&#-#&%*#87%0+.!#8!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!F*#+08%!20)7F*#&J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!*8!%*10,!#'!$&*,*,!78<!%&7:17!['#&!0W71-+0J!%)0!'&0V:08%!#$$:&&08$0!#'!

17,,!,$)##+!,)##%*8S,\B!!?!71!+0,,!*8%0&0,%0<J!%)#:S)J!*8!M)0%)0&!7!$7:,7+!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!0W*,%,!20%M008!%)0,0!%M#!F7&*7 2 +0,!k!*'!#80!<#0,!*%!*,!,:2%+0!78<!1:,%!20!

$#8%0W%:7+*]0<!M*%)*8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!#%)0&!'7$%#&,J!,:$)!7,!'71*+.!+*'0J!7F7*+72*+*%.!#'!

'*&07&1,J!78<!%&07%108%!2.!#%)0&,![;8<0&,#8!0%B!7+BJ!3454\B!!I)7%!?!71!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!

*,!%)0!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!,:,-*$*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!*8!-7&%*$:+7&J!78<!17,,!10<*7J!

1#&0!2&#7<+.B!!L)*,!<*,%&:,%!)7,!2008!7!'07%:&0!#'!%)0!;10&*$78!$:+%:&7+!+78<,$7-0!

,*8$0!7%!+07,%!%)0!%:&8!#'!%)0!%M08%*0%)! $08% :&.!78<!*,!<00-+.!%*0<!%#!*<07,!#'!

$*%*]08,)*-!78<!-7&%*$*-7%*#8!*8!-:2+*$!+*'0J!7,!=:%,$)![344i\!)7,!7&S:0<B!!L)7%!*,J!%)0!

17,,!10<*7!78<!%)0!7:<*08$0,!%)7%!17,,!10<*7!$:+%*F7%0,!7&0!$#8%*8:7++.!0F7+:7%0<!

#8!%)0!27,*,!#'!%)0*&!-&#W*1*%.!%#!X%)0!$#8,$*08%*#:,J!$:+%*F7%0<!78<!*8'#&10<!

$*%*]08Y![=:%,$)J!344iJ!-B!3\B!!P'!$#:&,0!M)7%!$#8,%*%:%0,!7!X$#8,$*08%*#:,J!$:+%*F7%0<!

78<!*8'#&10<!$*%*]08Y!'#&!$&*%*$,!#'!%)0!17,,!10<*7!*,!#'%08!S&#:8<0<!*8!$#8,0&F7%*F0!

5d3!

*<07+,!#'!7!&7%*#87+!*8<*F*<:7+!$7-72+0!#'!&07,#80<J!X#2R0$%*F0Y!787+ .,*,![*B0B!7!

,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!1*<<+0`$+7,,!17+0\B!!/*8$0!%)0!%0&1,!#'!$*%*]08,)*-!

#'%08!S#!:80W71*80<!2.!10<*7!$&*%*$,J!%)0,0!$&*%*$*,1,!'&0V:08%+.!&0-&#<:$0!78<!

&0*8'#&$0!$+7,,!78<!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,B!!;+,#J!7,!A08&.!N08T*8,![344h7J!344h2\!)7,!

8#%0<!*8!)*,!M*<0`&78S*8S!,%:<*0,!#8!-7&%*$*-7%#&.!10<*7!$:+%:&0,!78<!'78<#1,J!

%)0,0!$&*%*$*,1,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!&0F*F0<!78<!&0<0-+#.0<!7,!80M!10<*7J!,:$)!7,!F*<0#!

S710,J!010&S0B!

! I)7%!?!M78%!%#!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)*,!#8S#*8S!$#8F0&,7%*#8!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!7!

-0&,#8U,!-0&$0-%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!78<!*%,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!80M!10<*7!*,!#'%08!,008!

%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,0,!#'!%)0,0!-#-:+7&!<*,$#:&,0,J!M)*$)!01-)7,*]0!%)0!%)&07%!#'!10<*7!

%#!<01#$&7$.!78<!&07,#8B!!L)*,!$78!20!,008!2.!%)0!&0,-#8,0,!#'!7!,:2,0$%*#8!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!,%7%0108%,!-&#F*<0<!72#F0J!2:%!7+,#!*8!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!,:,-*$*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!%.-0,!#'!0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!%)0.!7,,:10!F*<0#!

S710,!-&#F*<0B!!O0.!71#8S!%)0,0!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!<*,%&7$%*#8!78<!0,$7-0B!!

"*,%&7$%*#8!78<!0,$7-0J!M)*+0!8#%!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%!1#%*F7%*#8,!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!8710<!2.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!M0&0!&0'0&08$0<!08#:S)!%*10,!2.!08#:S)!

-7&%*$*-78%,![&#:S)+.!34!-7&%*$*-78%,J!#&!7!+*%%+0!#F0&!7!V:7&%0&!#'!1.!-#-:+7%*#8\!

%)7%!*%!*,!M#&%).!#'!':&%)0&!*8F0,%*S7%*#8B!!P'!-7&%*$:+7&!*8%0&0,%!M7,!%)0!<*F*,*#8!

20%M008!-7&%*$*-78%,!7,!%#!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)0!<*,%&7$%*#8!78<!0,$7-0!-&#F*<0<!2.!

F*<0#!S710,!7&0!2080'*$*7+!#&!)7&1':+B!!LM#`%)*&<,!#'!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)7%!

&0'0&08$0<!<*,%&7$%*#8!M0&0!0*%)0&!#:%&*S)%!<*,1*,,*F0!#'!*%!#&!7%!+07,%!,T0-%*$7+!#'!*%,!

2080'*%,B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!;+20&%!$+7*10<!%)7%J!XP8!%)0!#%)0&!,*<0!#'!%)7%!$#*8!)#M0F0&J!?!

)7F0!2008!T8#M8!%#!-+7.!%##!1:$)B!/#10%*10,J!?!<#!*%!#:%!#'!)72*%!78<!7,!7!M7.!%#!

5dd!

<*,%&7$%!'&#1!%)*8S,!?!,)#:+<!<07+!M*%)BY!!/*1*+7&+.J!!Q#&<#8!<08*0<!%)7%!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,!)0+-0<!)*1!%)&*F0!2.!8#%*8S!%)7%!%)0!%*10!)0!,-08%!#8!F*<0#!S710,!

$#:+<!)7F0!2008!20%%0&!,-08%!#8!#%)0&!7$%*F*%*0,G!X@#J!%)0.!<#8w%!)0+-!10!%)&*F0B!

L)0&0!7&0!,#10!S710,!?!M#:+<8w%!%&7<0!'#&!78.!#%)0&!0W-0&*08$0J!+*T0!(#&%7+!#&!

/PC;B!=:%!1#,%!#'!%)0!%*10!?wF0!,-08%!-+7.*8S!S710,!M#:+<wF0!17<0!10!%)&*F0!1#&0!

*'!?w<!,-08%!*%!<#*8S!,#10%)*8S!1#&0!:,0':+BY!

! (7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!,-#T0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7,!78!0,$7-0J!)#M0F0&J!M0&0!1:$)!

1#&0!-#,*%*F0!*8!%)0*&!7,,0,,108%!#'!F*<0#!S710,U!72*+*%.!%#!-&#1#%0!%)&*F*8SB!!P'!%)0!

8*80!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!0W-+*$*%+.!108%*#80<!0,$7-0![%)0!,710!8:120&J!2.!%)0!M7.J!

M)#!0W-+*$*%+.!108%*#80<!X<*,%&7$%*#8Y\J!#8+.!5!-7&%*$*-78%!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!*%!7,!

-#%08%*7++.!)7&1':+B!!L)0!#%)0&,!$+7*10<!%)7%!%)0!0,$7-0!-&#F*<0<!2.!F*<0#!S710,!

M7,!M0+$#10!78<!2080'*$*7+B!!L7T0!;&+080J!'#&!*8,%78$0B!!;&+080!$+7*10<!%)7%J!X=0*8S!

%7T08!r#:%!#'!%)*,!M#&+<U!78<!08S&#,,0<!*8!78#%)0&!M#&+<!*,!72,#+:%0+.!M)7%!?!800<!

M)08!%)0!,%&0,,0,!#'!%)0!M#&+<!,%7&%!%#!20$#10!%##!1:$)BY!!/*1*+7&+.J!>#&.!$+7*10<!

%)7%J!XL)0.!)0+-!10!%)&*F0!2.!*8$&07,*8S!%)0!71#:8%!#'!)7--*80,,!?!'00+!-0&!<7.J!?!

7+,#!:,0!%)01!%#!%7T0!$7&0!#'!1.!01#%*#87+!M0++!20*8S!M)08!?!800<!%#!0,$7-0!'#&!7!

+*%%+0!M)*+0BY!!(0&)7-,!%)0!1#,%!,-0$*'*$!*8,%78$0!#'!%)0!F7+:0!#'!S710,!7,!7!'#&1!#'!

0,$7-0J!)#M0F0&J!$710!'&#1!?+080J!M)#!<0,$&*20<!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-0<!)0&!%#!

0,$7-0!'&#1!)0&!$)&#8*$!-7*8!78<!*++80,,![78!0W-0&*08$0!?!,)7&0\G!

D:-!`!?!M#:+<8w%!20!72+0!%#!08<:&0!1.!+*'0!M*%)#:%!S710,B!L)78T,!%#!7!F0&.!

-7*8':+!%&07%108%![c4z!*8R0$%*#8,!#'!*&&*%78%,!*8%#!E_E>D!R#*8%!%#!$7:,0!,$7&!

%*,,:0\!?wF0!S&7<:7++.!2008!2:*+<*8S!:-!1.!,%&08S%)!78<!72*+*%.!%#!':8$%*#8B!?!

M#:+<!)7F0!S*F08!:-!+#8S!78<!0F0&!7S#!M*%)#:%!S710,B!=0*8S!$)&#8*$7++.!*++!

7+,#!%7T0,!7!%#++!#8!1.!108%7+!)07+%)B!?%!S*F0,!10!78!0,$7-0!'&#1!%)#,0!

<01#8,!7,!M0++B!

5df!

L)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!X<*,%&7$%*#8Y!78<!X0,$7-0Y!*,!7!S##<!&01*8<0&!%)7%!

F7&.*8S!.#:&!M#&<*8S!%)&#:S)#:%!7!,:&F0.!$78!)0+-!<&7M!#:%!,*S8*'*$78%!<*''0&08$0,!

*8!-7&%*$*-78%,U!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!7!-)08#108#8B!!P,%08,*2+.J!%)0!%0&1,!X<*,%&7$%*#8Y!

78<!X0,$7-0Y!<0,$&*20!%)0!,710!-)08#108#8!k!%)0!72*+*%.!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%#!

*8%0&&:-%!7!-+7.0&U,!7%%08%*#8!78<!'#$:,!*%!0+,0M)0&0B!!D0%!%)*,!':8$%*#8!#'!F*<0#!

S710,!1:,%!20!$#8%0W%:7+*]0<!*8!%)0!7$%:7+!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-+7.0&,J!,-0$*'*$7++.!*8!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!M)7%!%)0*&!7%%08%*#8!*,!20*8S!%7T08!7M7.!'&#1!78<!)#M!%)*,!

<*,-+7$0108%!#'!7%%08%*#8!7''0$%,!%)0!#%)0&!7&07,!#'!7!-+7.0&U,!+*'0B!!;8W*0%.J!

<0-&0,,*#8J!+72#&J!'71*+.!78<!&0+7%*#8,)*-!-&#2+01,J!0F08!2#&0<#1!k!%)0,0!M0&0!%)0!

0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!1#,%!+*T0+.!%#!,7.!%)0.!*8%0&&:-%0<!M*%)!F*<0#!

S710,B!!(&#2*8S!':&%)0&J!M0!$78!20S*8!%#!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!%)0,0!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!

0,$7-0!78<!<*,%&7$%*#8!*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!'72&*$!#'!%)0,0!-7&%*$*-78%,U!+*F0,B!!I0!$78!:,0!

%)0!0W71-+0,!M0!)7F0!7+&07<.!,008!7,!7!,%7&%*8S!-#*8%!'#&!M)7%!%)*,!

$#8%0W%:7+*]7%*#8!+##T,!+*T0!*8!-&7$%*$0B!!;&+080J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!,-#T0!#'!X20*8S!#:%!#'!

%)*,!M#&+<Y!7,!7!2080'*$*7+!0W-0&*08$0!,*8$0!*%!&0+*0F0,!F7&*#:,!-&0,,:&0,!%)7%!)7F0!

2:*+%!:-!#F0&!%*10!78<!-&0F08%,!%)01!'&#1!#F0&M)0+1*8S!)0&B!!/-07T*8S!1#&0!

2&#7<+.J!%)#:S)J!M).!M#:+<!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!X20*8S!#:%!#'!%)*,!M#&+<Y!20!-0&$0*F0<!

7,!7!M7.!%#!&0+*0F0!%)0,0!-&0,,:&0,g!!I)7%!*8!;&+080U,!+*'0!17.!)7F0!-&0<*,-#,0<!)0&!

%#!,00T!&0':S0!*8!'78%7,*0,!&7%)0&!%)78!$#8'&#8%!)0&!-&#2+01,!1#&0!<*&0$%+.g!

! =0'#&0!?!$#8%*8:0!*8!1.!787+.,*,!#'!;&+080U,!$#1108%J!?!<#!M78%!%#!$+7&*'.!#80!

%)*8S!%)#:S)B!!?8!:,*8S!7!-)&7,0!+*T0!X,00T!&0':S0!*8!'78%7,*0,Y!?!M78%!%#!0,%72+*,)!

%)7%!?!71!8#%!%&.*8S!%#!0F7+:7%0!%)*,!-&7$%*$0B!!L)*,!*,!<*''*$:+%J!#'!$#:&,0J!,*8$0!?!71!

:,*8S!7!+78S:7S0!78<!,-07T*8S!%#!78!7:<*08$0!%)7%!7&0!2#%)!7+&07<.!,%00-0<!*8!

5dc!

$:+%:&7+!,T0-%*$*,1,!72#:%!%)0!F7+:0!#'!'78%7,.!78<!0,$7-0!F*,`t`F*,!%&78,'#&17%*#8!

78<!$)78S0!k!8710+.!%)7%!'78%7,.!78<!0,$7-0!$78!-#%08%*7++.!<*,%&7$%!'&#1!&07+J!

+7,%*8S!%&78,'#&17%*#8!78<!$)78S0B!!?!M78%!%#!,:,-08<!%)7%!+*8T7S0!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!7,T!%)7%!1.!7:<*08$0!<#0,!7,!M0++J!'#&!2.!,:,-08<*8S!%)7%!

'71*+*7&!<*,1*,,7+!#'!'78%7,.!?!$#8%08<!M0!$78!,00!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!'78%7,.!78<!

0,$7-0!'&#1!7!80M0&J!,+*S)%+.!1#&0!S08%+0!-0&,-0$%*F0B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!M*++!7++#M!:,!%#!

,00!7!1#&0!-&#<:$%*F0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!'78%7,.!78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8B!!!

! >0%:&8*8S!%#!;&+080J!%)#:S)J!M0!$78!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!)0&!7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!

0,$7-0!M*%)*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!,#$*7+!&0+7%*#8,!#'!)0&!+*'0B!!;&+080!S&0M!:-!*8!7!

$#11:8*%.!%)7%!,)0!<0,$&*20<!7,!X,:-0&!M)*%0Y!78<!XF0&.!>0-:2+*$78BY!!A0&!-7&08%,!

)7<!&0+7%*F0+.!,%72+0!$7&00&,!k!)0&!1#%)0&J!78!0+0108%7&.!,$)##+!%07$)0&l!)0&!'7%)0&J!

7!$#1-:%0&!-&#S&7110&!'#&!7!+7&S0!$#&-#&7%*#8B!!Z&#1!M)7%!?!)7F0!S7%)0&0<!#'!)0&!

$)*+<)##<J!)0&!+*'0!M7,!&0+7%*F0+.!,%72+0!*'!8#%!':++.!$#1'#&%72+0B!!;&+080U,!'7%)0&!M7,!

&7&0+.!)#10!M)08!,)0!M7,!7M7T0J!<:0!%#!)*,!R#2J!2:%!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!72+0!%#!,%7.!7%!

)#10!78<!$7&0!'#&!)0&!78<!)0&!,*2+*8S,!'#&!%)0!'*&,%!'#:&%008!.07&,!#'!)0&!+*'0B!!K:W:&.!

M7,!20.#8<!%)0*&!S&7,-!2:%!%)0*&!)7&<!M#&T!M7,!&0M7&<0<!M*%)!&0+7%*F0!,0$:&*%.B!!

=.!%&7<*%*#87+!,#$*7+!10%&*$,J!%)08J!;&+080!$#:+<!20!$#8,*<0&0<!1*<<+0`$+7,,!k!)0&!

-7&08%,!M0&0!-&#'0,,*#87+,!M*%)!7%!+07,%!,#10!)*S)0&!0<:$7%*#8!78<!;&+080!)0&,0+'!

[7%!%)0!%*10!#'!1.!,:&F0.\!M7,!*8!%)0!-&#$0,,!#'!$#1-+0%*8S!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!

1:,*$7+!%)07%0&B!!!

! L)*,!-*$%:&0!#'!1*<<+0`$+7,,!*<08%*%.J!)#M0F0&J!*,!$#1-+*$7%0<!2.!#%)0&!

'07%:&0,!#'!;&+080U,!+*'0B!!"0,-*%0!S&#M*8S!:-!*8!7!X,:-0&!M)*%0Y!78<!XF0&.!

>0-:2+*$78Y!$#11:8*%.J!;&+080!)0&,0+'!<*<!8#%!*<08%*'.!7,!,:$)J!*8,%07<!-&0'0&&*8S!

5dh!

%#!$7%0S#&*]0!)0&,0+'!7,!7!X2+7$T!,)00-BY!!L)*,!<*''0&08$0!M7,!2&#:S)%!':&%)0&!*8%#!

&0+*0'!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!)0&!,0W:7+*%.J!M)*$)!,)0!<0,$&*2 0<! 7,! X -78,0W:7+BY!!?8!

7<<*%*#8J!;&+080U,!1*<<+0`$+7,,!-#,*%*#8!M7,!,#10M)7%!-&0$7&*#:,!7%!%)0!%*10!#'!#:&!

$#&&0,-#8<08$0B!!"0,-*%0!$:&&08%+.!20*8S!08&#++0<!*8!$#++0S0!78<!)7F*8S!-7&08%,!

M)#!M0&0!$#1'#&%72+.!-&#'0,,*#87+J!,)0!,%*++!'0+%!%)0!,%*8S!#'!<0-&*F7%*#8J!7%!+07,%!

M)08!*%!$710!%#!'*%%*8S!)0&!S71*8S!)72*%,!*8%#!7!2:<S0%!%)7%!M7,!,%&0%$)0<!%)*8B!!L)*,!

<*<!8#%!-&0F08%!)0&!'&#1!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!%)#:S)B!!?%!,*1-+.!1078%!%)7%!,)0!)7<!

%#!&0,#&%!%#!$&07%*F0!107,:&0,!%)7%!-0#-+0!M*%)!+*1*%0<![*'!78.\!<*,-#,72+0!*8$#10!

'&0V:08%+.!&0,#&%!%#B!!?8!;&+080U,!$7,0J!%)*,!1078%!&0-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,![X*'!,)0!)7,!

%#Y\!78<!,)7&*8S!F*<0#!S710,!M*%)!)0&!S*&+'&*08<J!M)#!*,!7+,#!7!S710&B!

! D0%!M)7%!$:+%*F7%0<!%)*,!-7,,*#8!'#&!F*<0#!S710,!*8!;&+080g!!9#8%&7&.!%#!%)0!

$#8F08%*#87+!M*,<#1!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!%)0!-&#F*8$0!#'!7<#+0,$08%!17+0,J!;&+080!

M7,!*8%&#<:$0<!%#!F*<0#!S710,!2.!)0&!1#%)0&B!!;&+080U,!1#%)0&!)7<!-+7.0<!F*<0#!

S710,!'&0V:08%+.!*8!)0&!.#:%)!78<J!*8!%:&8J!:,0<!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!M7.!%#!2#8<!M*%)!

)0&!<7:S)%0&B!!;,!;&+080!<0,$&*20,!*%J!,00*8S!;&+080!20$#10!7%%7$)0<!%#!F*<0#!S710,!

M7,!XF0&.!,7%*,'.*8SY!'#&!)0&!1#%)0&B!!;8<!,#!M0!$78!20S*8!%#!20%%0&!:8<0&,%78<!%)0!

$*&$:1,%78$0,!#'!;&+080U,!+*'0!%)7%!-&0<*,-#,0<!)0&!%#!F*0M*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7,!

2080'*$*7+!0,$7-0!78<!,#:&$0!#'!&080M7+B!L)0,0!$0&%7*8+.!*8$+:<0!07&+.!7$$0,,!%#!

F*<0#!S710,!78<!7!'71*+*7+!08F*&#8108%!%)7%!$:+%*F7%0<!%)0!80$0,,7&.!%0$)8#+#S*$7+!

$#1-0%08$*0,!%#!08R#.!%)01B!!C#&0!2&#7<+.J!%)0,0!$*&$:1,%78$0,!7+,#!*8$+:<0!78!

08F*&#8108%!%)7%!F7+:0<!F*<0#!S710,!7,!M0++!7,!7!S080&7+!'00+*8S!#'!<*,$#880$%!'&#1!

)0&!+#$7+!$#11:8*%.B!!!

5da!

! ;8<!M)7%!#'!-+7.0&,!M)#!M0&0!1#&0!-0,,*1*,%*$!72#:%!%)0!F7+:0!#'!F*<0#!

S710,J!M)#!'0+%!%)0.!M0&0!7!<*,%&7$%*#8!'&#1!#%)0&J!1#&0!M#&%).!08<07F#&,g!!

E7&+*0&!?!V:#%0<!@*$#+0J!M)#!,%7%0<!%)7%!,)0!M*,)0<!,)0!<*<!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,B!!

@*$#+0!0F08!M08%!,#!'7&!7,!%#!$+7*1!%)7%!%)&*F*8S!78<!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!

*8$#1-7%*2+0!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&G!XL#!10!%)&*F*8S!M#:+<!20!%#!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!

78<!0W-0&*08$0!+*'0!*8!7!1#&0!0W-78,*F0!M7.BY!!A#M!$78!M0!17T0!,08,0!#'!%)*,!$+7*1g!!

;S7*8J!#80!,%&7%0S.!*,!%#!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!@*$#+0U,!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)*8!%)0!

2&#7<0&!,#$*7+!78<!-0&,#87+!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!)0&!+*'0B!!K*T0!;&+080J!@*$#+0!,-0$*'*$7++.!

17&T0<!)0&,0+'!7,!<*''0&08%!'&#1!XM)*%0!E:&#-078!,%78<7&<,BY!!D0%!M)*+0!;&+080U,!

<*''0&08$0,!M0&0!%)0!&0,:+%!#'!)0&!-#+*%*$7+!78<!,0W: 7 +!#&*08%7%*#8,J!@*$#+0U,!M0&0!%)0!

&0,:+%!#'!&7$*7+!78<!0%)8*$!<*''0&08$0,B!!@*$#+0!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!78!;10&*$78!

?8<*78!M#178J!,-0$*'*$7++.!7!"7T#%7!M#178!'&#1!%)0!D78T%#8!/*#:W!@7%*#8B!!;,!7!

&0,:+%!#'!)0&!0%)8*$!*<08%*%.J!@*$#+0U,!$+7,,!7''*+*7%*#8,!7&0!1#&0!$#1-+*$7%0<!%#!

,*%:7%0!%)78!;&+080U,B!!I)*+0!)*,%#&*$7++.!*8<*S08#:,!-0#-+0!*8!%)0!^8*%0<!/%7%0,!)7F0!

2008!,:2R0$%,!#'!&7$*7+!<*,$&*1*87%*#8!78<!)#&&*'*$!0W-+#*%7%*#8!2.!%)0!,%7%0J!@*$#+0!

17<0!+*%%+0!&0'0&08$0!%#!%)#,0!+7&S0&!'#&$0,B!!?8,%07<J!@*$#+0!'#$:,0<!#8!)0&!-7&08%,U!

-&#'0,,*#8,!k!)0&!'7%)0&!*,!%)0!EW0$:%*F0!"*&0$%#&!'#&!%)0!%&*27+!$#++0S0!#'!%)0*&!

&0,0&F7%*#8!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!*,!%)0!,$)##+!-,.$)#+#S*,%!78<!"*&0$%#&!#'!/-0$*7+!

E<:$7%*#8!'#&!%)0*&!%&*27++.!&:8!,$)##+,B!!;,!'#&!@*$#+0!)0&,0+'J!+*T0!;&+080!,)0!*,!

$:&&08%+.!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%B!!!

! ;,!M0!$78!,00!%)08J!2#%)!@*$#+0!78<!;&+080!2#%)!<0,$&*20<!%)01,0+F0,!7,!

<*,%*8$%!'&#1!%)0!-&0,:10<!<#1*878%!S&#:-!#'!M)*%0J!$#8,0&F7%*F0!;10&*$78!108B!!

L)*,!7+,#J!2.!0W%08,*#8J!-#,*%*#8,!%)01!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!*17S*80<!-&*17&.!7:<*08$0!#'!

5di!

F*<0#!S710,B!!?8!,)#&%J!%)0,0!7&0!%M#!,:2R0$%,!M)#J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!$#8F08%*#87+!

M*,<#1J!M#:+<!8#%!'00+!$#1'#&%72+0!*<08%*'.*8S!7,!S710&,B!!!A#M0F0&J!;&+080!

20$710!7!F*<0#!S710!08%):,*7,%!M)#!:,0,!F*<0#!S710,!%#!2#%)!,:,%7*8!)0&,0+'!78<!

-&#,-0&J!M)*+0!@*$#+0!20$710!7!$7,:7+!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&!M)#,0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0!

10<*:1!*,!1#&0!'&7:S)%B!!L)0!+7&S0,%!,*8S+0!'7$%#&!%)7%!?!$78!-#*8%!%#!%#!0W-+7*8!%)*,!

<*F0&S08$0!*,!%)0*&!$)*+<)##<!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0*&!&0,:+%78%!

$:+%:&7+!7%%*%:<0,!%#M7&<,!%)0!10<*:1B!!;,!<0,$&*20<J!;&+080!S&0M!:-!*8!78!

08F*&#8108%!%)7%!F7+:0<!F*<0#!S710,!78<!08$#:&7S0<!%)0*&!$#8,:1-%*#8!k!)0&!

'7%)0&!M7,!*8F#+F0<!*8!%)0!%0$)8#+#S.!,0$%#&!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!F*<0#!S710!

08%):,*7,%!)0&,0+'!M)#!:,0<!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!M7.!%#!2#8<!M*%)!)0&!$)*+<&08B!!

@*$#+0U,!08F*&#8108%J!#8!%)0!#%)0&!)78<J!M7,!,*S8*'*$78%+.!+0,,!7$$#11#<7%*8S!%#!

%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!F*<0#!S71*8SB!!I)*+0!@*$#+0!$788#%!&010120&!)0&!-7&08%,!0F0&!

<*&0$%+.!&0S:+7%*8S!)0&!:,7S0!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!7$$#&<*8S!%#!@*$#+0!%)0.!<*<!8#%!)7F0!

%#!,*8$0!,)0!XM7,!8#%!%)7%!7<<*$%0<Y!%#!%)0!S710,!,)0!#$$7,*#87++.!-+7.0<B!!A0&!:,0!#'!

%)0!%0&1!X7<<*$%*#8Y!)0&0!*,!T0.J!,*8$0!*%!,*S87+,!7!'&0V:08%!M#&&.!71#8S!F*<0#!S710!

$&*%*$,!%)7%!%)0!10<*:1!*,!)7&1':+!%#!*%,!7:<*08$0B!!L)0!&)0%#&*$!<0-+#.0<!2.!@*$#+0!

%#!<0,$&*20!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!*8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!7+*S8,!)0&!V:*%0!$+#,0+.!M*%)!%)0!

-&0F7*+*8S!<*,$#:&,0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7,!)7&1':+J!7!<*,$#:&,0!%)7%!)7,!2008!M0++`

<#$:108%0<!2.!-&0F*#:,!,$)#+7&,)*-![L7.+#&J!3453l!/)7MJ!345fl!C.0&,J!345a\B!!?8!

%)0!72,08$0!7!,*S8*'*$78%!'#&$0!%#!$#:8%0&7$%!*%J!%)0!<#1*878%!80S7%*F0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!

F*<0#!S710,!,001,!%#!)7F0!0W0&%0<!7!S&7F*%7%*#87+!'#&$0!%)7%!-:++0<!@*$#+0U,!

-0&$0-%*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8%#!*%,!#&2*%B!

5d6!

! I)7%!?!M78%!%#!01-)7,*]0J!%)&#:S)!%)0,0!0W71-+0,J!*,!%)7%!%)0!-0&$0-%*#8!#'!

F*<0#!S710,!7,!0*%)0&!78!X0,$7-0Y!#&!7!X<*,%&7$%*#8Y!*,!#F0&<0%0&1*80<J!#&!

$#8,%*%:%0<!%)&#:S)!7!1:+%*%:<0!#'!'#&$0,!%)7%!0W*,%!*8!F7&.*8S!*8%08,*%*0,!<0-08<*8S!

#8!%)0!F7&*#:,!,#$*7+!-#,*%*#8,!78<!%&7R0$%#&*0,!#'!7!,:2R0$%B!!?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!+7&S0&!

,%&:$%:&7+!<0%0&1*878%,!,:$)!7,!&7$0J!S08<0&J!78<!,0W:7+*%.J!%)#:S)J!7!,*S8*'*$78%!

'7$%#&!*8!)#M!-0#-+0!*8$#&-#&7%0!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!*8%#!%)0*&!+*F0,!*,!%)0*&!

7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*%,0+'B!!?8!,)#&%J!*,,:0,!#'!%7,%0!7&0!

$&*%*$7+J!78<!2.!0W%08,*#8!*,,:0,!#'!,#$*7+!$+7,,B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0J!M)0%)0&!#&!

8#%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!<*,1*,,0<!7,!7!<*,%&7$%*#8J!:,0<!7,!7!'#&1!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!#&!,008!7,!

$#8%&*2:%*8S!%#!7!-0&,#8U,!,08,0!#'!%)&*F*8S!*,!,*S8*'*$78%+.!,)7-0<!2.!7!-0&,#8U,!

2$;"'6(B!!;!-0&,#8U,!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*%,0+'!20$#10,!7!

T*8<!#'!,0+'`':+'*++*8S!-&#-)0$.!F*,`t`F*,!%)0!*,,:0!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!7&0!

<*,1*,,*F0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8!S080&7+!7&0!7+,#!+0,,!+*T0+.!%#!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!%##+!

'#&!%)&*F*8S!M)*+0!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!7&0!1#&0!7$$0-%*8S!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!7+,#!1#&0!

+*T0+.!%#!,00!%)01!7,!7!-#%08%*7+!%##+!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!!

! L)0!1#&0!+#$7+*]0<!<7%7!$#8$0&8*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!0,$7-0J!

<*,%&7$%*#8J!78<!)72*%:,!1*&&#&!7!2&#7<0&!-7%%0&8!%)7%!010&S0<!'&#1!1.!<7%7B!!P'!

%)0!5h!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!$+7*10<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!0*%)0&!<#!8#%!$#8%&*2:%0!

%#!%)&*F*8S!#&!7$%*F0+.!*1-0<0!%)&*F*8SJ!55!M0&0!$+#,0+.!7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!1*<<+0!78<!

+#M0&`1*<<+0!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,J!1078*8S!%)0*&!-7&08%,!M#&T0<!*8!,%72+0J!-&#'0,,*#87+!

$7&00&,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0*&!$)*+<)##<J!%)0.!)7<!7!,*S8*'*$78%!71#:8%!#'!'#&17+!

0<:$7%*#8J!78<!%)0.!M0&0!0*%)0&!$:&&08%+.!01-+#.0<!*8!#&!-#,*%*#8*8S!%)01,0+F0,!%#!

20!01-+#.0<!*8!-&#'0,,*#87+!$7&00&,!%)01,0+F0,B!!C078M)*+0J!#8+.!h4x!

5f4!

[7--&#W*17%0+.\!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M)#!0*%)0&!$:&&08%+.!7&0!#&!)7F0!2008!$+#,0+.!

7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!1*<<+0!78<!+#M0&`1*<<+0!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8,!7S&00<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,J!

:8<0&!$0&%7*8!$#8<*%*#8,J!$#:+<!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SB!!(7&%*$*-78%,!7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!

M#&T*8S!$+7,,!'&7$%*#8![0*%)0&!*8!%)0!-7,%!#&!*8!%)0!-&0,08%\!M0&0!1#&0!+*T0+.!%#!

$+7*1!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$#:+<!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!M*%)!i4x!17T*8S!,:$)!$+7*1,B!!!

! L)*,!<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!%)0&0!*,!7!,%&*$%!$#&&0+7%*#8!20%M008!#80U,!$+7,,!

-#,*%*#8!78<!%)0*&!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,B!!C.!,71-+0!,*]0!*,!%##!,17++!78<!

%##!2*7,0<!%#!,:--#&%!,:$)!7!$+7*1B!!?8,%07<J!?!M78%!%#!17T0!%)0!1#&0!1#<0,%!$+7*1!

%)7%!7!-0&,#8U,!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!,0$:&*%.!78<!F:+80&72*+ *% .J!M)*$)!*,!

,*S8*'*$78%+.!*8'#&10<!2.!%)0*&!&0+7%*F0!-#,*%*#8!%#!%)0!<#1*878%!1#<0,!#'!20*8S!*8!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0J!0W0&%,!,#10!*8'+:08$0!#8!%)0*&!7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!

S710,!78<!)#M!%)0.!:,0!F*<0#!S710,B!!L#!-:%!*%!1#&0!,*1-+.J!7!-0&,#8U,!2$;"'6(!

,)7-0,J!2:%!<#0,!8#%!S:7&78%00J!%)0*&!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!L)0!1#&0!$+#,0+.!7!

-0&,#8!*<08%*'*0,!M*%)!%)0!<#1*878%!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!78<!*%,!-&0'0&&0<!M7.,!#'!20*8SJ!

*8!%)*,!$7,0!M*%)!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1J!80#+*20&7+*,1J!78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.J!

%)0!,%&#8S0&!%)0!%08<08$.!%#!<*,1*,,!%)0!-#%08%*7+!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%#!-&#1#%0!

%)&*F*8SB!!L)#,0!M)#!*8)72*%!-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!7&0!$+#,0&!%#!%)0!0<S0,!#'!%)0,0!,#$*7+!

,%&:$%:&0,J!)#M0F0&J!%08<!%#!)7F0!7!1#&0!#-08!78<!S080&#:,!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!

:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!%0$)8#+#S.!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!L)*,!17T0,!,08,0!,*8$0!%)0!0<S0,!#'!7!

,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!7&0!%)0!1#,%!F:+80&72+0!-#,*%*#8,!%#!*8)72*%J!78<!%)0&0'#&0!%)0!1#,%!

-#&#:,B!!/:2R0$%,!7%!%)0!17&S*8!#'!,#$*0%.J!%)08J!7&0!*8!7!20%%0&!-#,*%*#8!%#!V:0,%*#8!

#&!&0R0$%!%)0!+#S*$!78<!-0&,-0$%*F0!#'!<#1*878%!S&#:-,!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!1#,%!+*T0+.!%#!

20!0W-#,0<!%#!7+%0&87%*F0!*<07,!78<!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

5f5!

?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!&#178%*$*]0!%)*,!17&S*87+*]7%*#8J!#'!$#:&,0B!!?!M#:+<!,:SS0,%!

%)7%!-7&%!#'!%)0!&07,#8!M).!17&S*87+*]0<!-0#-+0!7&0!1#&0!+*T0+.!%#!012&7$0!F*<0#!

S710,!7,!7!-#%08%*7+!&0,#:&$0!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!*,!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!&#:%*80+.!

<08*0<!7$$0,,!%#!#%)0&J!1#&0!$#8F08%*#87+!78<!1#&0!7$$0-%0<!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!,0+'`

$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!+*T0!10<*$7+!$7&0J!7!,0$:&0!78<!7<0V:7%0!,#:&$0!#'!*8$#10J!78<!7!

)07+%).!27+78$0!20%M008!+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0B!!;,!%)0.!,#!'&0V:08%+.!<#J!-0#-+0!#8!%)0!

17&S*8,!17T0!<#!M*%)!M)7%!*,!7F7*+72+0B!!L)*,!'&0V:08%+.!+07<,!%#!%)0!$&07%*F0!

&0-:&-#,*8S!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!%##+,J!,:$)!7 ,!10<*7B!!L)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#!

$7&0!'#&!%)0!,0+'!#&J!+0,,!'&0V:08%+.J!-&#,-0&!78<!%)&*F0!*,!&0+7%0<!%#!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!

<0-&*F7%*#8![M)0%)0&!7$:%0!#&!%01-0&7%0\!78<!F:+80&72*+*%.!M*%)*8!7!$7-*%7+*,%J!

80#+*20&7+J!78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0B!!!

?'!%)*,!*,!%)0!$7,0J!7,!?!)7F0!2008!7&S:*8SJ!M)0&0!$78!M0!S#!'&#1!)0&0g!!I)7%!

%&7R0$%#&*0,!78<!-7%),!7&0!#-080<!%#!:,!%)&#:S)!+07&8*8S!%)*,g!!P80!-7%)!M#:+<!20!%#!

$:+%*F7%0!7!S08%+0&!78<!1#&0!$#1-7,,*#87%0!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!71#8S!17&S*87+*]0<!S&#:-,B!!L)*,!*,!7!-7%)!?!M)#+0`

)07&%0<+.!7<F#$7%0!'#&B!!"*,1*,,*8S!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!7,,#$*7%*8S!%)01!M*%)!,#$*7+!

-&#2+01,!<#0,!+*%%+0!%#!&010<.!%)0!17&S*87+*]7%*#8!%)7%!-0#-+0!M*%)!+*1*%0<!$:+%:&7+!

78<!0$#8#1*$!&0,#:&$0,!0W-0&*08$0!#8!<7.`%#`<7.!27,*,B!!;8#%)0&!-7%)J!#80!%)7%!?!

M*++!20!'#++#M*8S!*8!%)0!$#1*8S!$)7-%0&,J!*,!%#!%7T0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

%)&*F*8S!,0&*#:,+.!78<!20S*8!*8F0,%*S7%*8S!%)0!-#%08%*7+!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!

%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!#''0&!%#!*%,!7:<*08$0,B!!;S7*8J!%)*,!<#0,!8#%!08%7*+!

,#10)#M!'#&S*F*8S!#&!'#&S0%%*8S!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!S*F0!&*,0!%#!%)*,!$&07%*F0!:,0!#'!

F*<0#!S710,B!!?%!<#0,J!)#M0F0&J!08%7*+!%7T*8S!7!1#&0!-&#%0$%*F0!,%78$0!%#M7&<,!%)0,0!

5f3!

-&7$%*$0,!78<!17T*8S!,-7$0!'#&!%)0!*<07!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!)7F0!7!

%&78,'#&17%*F0!0''0$%!#8!*8<*F*<:7+,!78<!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,B!!!

5fd!

9A;(LE>!c!

CELAP"PKPQD!??!

P>J!API!9;@!IE!>E;"!;!LEeL!K?OE!Z?@;K!Z;@L;/D!e?_g!

! A7F*8S!0,%72+*,)0<!%)0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!,*%:7%0<!%)01,0+F0,!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!

%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0,0!<*,$#:&,0,J!?!M*++!%:&8!%#!%)0!10<*:1!*%,0+'!!*8!

%)0,0!80W%!%)&00!$)7-%0&,!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!'*87+!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8!#'!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8!

k!M)7%!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!7!-0&,#8U,!0W-0&*08$0!#'!%)&*F*8Sg!!L)*,!

M*++!*8F#+F0!'#$:,*8S!#8!%)0!10$)78*$7+!78<!87&&7%*F0!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!8710<!7,!$#8%&*2:%*8S!%#!%)0*&!,0+'`$7&0!78<o#&!%)&*F*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!!

Z#&!%)0!,7T0!#'!#&S78*]7%*#87+!$+7&*%.!? ! )7F0!<*F*<0<!%)*,!<*,$:,,*#8!*8%#!%)&00!

$)7-%0&,B!!L)*,!'*&,%!#80!M*++!<*,$:,,!%)0!10%)#<#+#S.!?!01-+#.0<!%#!$)##,0!78<!

787+.]0!7!,-0$*'*$!F*<0#!S710!%0W%J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!L)0!'#++#M*8S!$)7-%0&!

<*,$:,,0,!M).!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!-7&%*$:+7&+.!,:*%0<!%#!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!7,!M0++!7,!

)#M!%)#,0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20J!78<!)7F0!2008J!:,0<!2.!F7&*#:,!,%7T0)#+<0&,J!

*8$+:<*8S!F*<0#!S710!-&#<:$0&,!78<!*117%0&*7+!+72#&!*8<:,%&*0,J!%#!&080M!$0&%7*8!

&0,#:&$0,!80$0,,7&.!%#!,:--#&%!*117%0&*7+!+72#&!&0S*10,B!!L)*,!M*++!*8F#+F0!

<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!$0&%7*8!0W-0&*08$0,!7,,#$*7%0<!M*%)!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!

&0+7W7%*#8!78<!<*,%&7$%*#8J!7&0!-&#<:$0<J !78<!)#M!7:<*08$0!10120&,!7&0!&0`&#:%0<!

'&#1!+0*,:&0!27$T!*8%#!+72#&B!!L)0!'*87+!$)7-%0&!M*++!'#$:,!-&*17&*+.!#8!M)7%!F*<0#!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!$78!#''0&!%#!$:+%:&7+!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0*&!

72*+*%.!%#!)0+-!-+7.0&,!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!':%:&0,!78<!S&#:8<!'00+*8S,!'#&!%)#,0!

':%:&0,!*8!%)0!-&0,08%B!!L)0!7&S:108%!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&!M*++!<*F0&S0!'&#1!-&0F*#:,!

5ff!

<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,![0BSB!L0&&78#F7J!3446l!=70&SJ!3446J!345f\!%)7%!

+#$7%0!S71*8SU,!<*,&:-%*F0!-#%08%*7+!%#!80#+*20&7+!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!*8!%)0*&!

,#$*7+J!80%M#&T0<!$#1-#808%,B!!?8,%07<J!?!M*++!7&S:0!%)7%J!*8!$0&%7*8!$#8%0W%,J!,#+*%7&.!

F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!)7F0!1#&0!%#!#''0&!%&78,'#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!-&#R0$%,!%)78!#%)0&!

,#$*7+!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!!!!

L#!20S*8J!?!M78%!%#!$+7&*'.!78!787+.%*$!*,,:0!%)7%!17.!7&*,0!71#8S!1.!

7:<*08$0!#'!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&,B!!I*%)*8!2#%)!#'!%)0!787+.%*$!$)7-%0&,J!?!M*++!20!

<*,$:,,*8S!%)0!+:<*$!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,![%)0!XS710Y!-7&%\!78<!%)0!87&&7%*F0!

'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,![%)0!XF*<0#Y!-7&%\!%#S0%)0&!78<!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!#80!78#%)0&B!!

I)*+0!,#10!&0,07&$)0&,!$)##,0!%#!<*,08%78S+0!78<!,0-7&7%0!%)0,0!0+0108%,!*8!%)0*&!

787+.,0,J!#'%08!'#&!S##<!&07,#8,J!,:$)!78!*8%0++0$%:7+!,$)017!M#:+<!M#&T!7%!$&#,,!

-:&-#,0,!%#!%)0!S#7+,!#'!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!C.!-7&%*$*-78%,!<*,$:,,0<!2#%)!%)0!+:<*$!

78<!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8!&0+7%*#8!%#!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!78<!,#!

,0-7&7%*8S!%)01!'&#1!#80!78#%)0&!M#:+<!1*,&0-&0,08%!%)0*&!,%7%0108%,B!!P8!7!1#&0!

%)0#&0%*$7+!+0F0+J!)#M0F0&J!?!M#:+<!7+,#!7&S:0!%)7%!,0-7&7%*8S!%)0,0!0+0108%,!'&#1!

#80!78#%)0&!#&J!%#!-:,)!*%!0F08!':&%)0&J!'&#1!%)0!,:&&#:8<*8S!$#8%0W%!*8!M)*$)!%)0,0!

0+0108%,!7&0!$#8,:10<J!-#%08%*7++.!1*,:8<0&,%78<,!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!

0W-0&*08$0<!2.!7$%:7+!-+7.0&,B!

I)*+0!787+.,0,!#'!,-0$*'*$!F*<0#!S710!%0W%,!$78!2080'*%!'&#1!,:$)!

<*,%*8$%*#8,J!,*8$0!%)0.!7++#M!'#&!'*80&J!1#&0!<0%7*+0<!<0,$&*-%*#8,J!787+.,0,!#'!F*<0#!

S710!-&7$%*$0,!-#%08%*7++.!<#!8#%!,*8$0!-+7.0&,!<#!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!0W-0&*08$0!%)0!

+:<*$!78<!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!7!F*<0#!S710!,0-7&7%0+.B!!I)*+0!,#10!S71*8S!

S08&0,J!,:$)!7,!1#2*+0!-:]]+0!S710,J!17.!01-)7,*]0!+:<*$!0+0108%,!1#&0!)07F*+.!

5fc!

M)*+0!#%)0&!S08&0,J!,:$)!7,!F*,:7+!8#F0+,J!'#$:,!1#&0!#8!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,J!%)0!

17R#&*%.!#'!F*<0#!S710,!$#8%7*8!,#10!$#12*87%*#8!#'!2#%)B!!;,!N0,-0&!N::+![344c\!

7&S:0<!*8!)*,!*8'+:08%*7+!,%:<.!L$%?WG/$%J!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!X)7+'`&07+Y!*8!%)0!,08,0!%)7%!

%)0.!7&0!$#12*80<!'&#1!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!X&07+Y!+:<*$!0+0108%,J!,:$)!7,!&:+0!

,.,%01,!%)7%!,%&:$%:&0!)#M!-+7.0&,!08S7S0!M*%)!%)0!F*<0#!S710J!78<!X'78%7,.Y!

87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!*17S*87&.!M#&+<!78<!$)7&7$%0&,!%)7%!-+7.0&,!7&0!

08$#:&7S0<!%#!2#%)!#2,0&F0!78<!*8)72*%B!!L)0!80$0,,7&.!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!7!S710U,!

87&&7%*F0!78<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!78<!7!S710U,!$#<0!78<!17$)*80!7$%*#8,J!*8!%:&8J!)7,!

20$#10!#80!#'!%)0!S:*<*8S!7,,:1-%*#8,!#'!&0$08%!F*<0#!S710!787+.,0,J!7,!$78!20!

,008!*8!C7+T#M,T*!78<!>:,,M#&1U,![345a\!*8%&#<:$%*#8!%#!%)0!0<*%0<!$#++0$%*#8!

K$@"#1&G/F3/(/#'$'".#B!

C#&0#F0&J!7%%01-%*8S!%#!<*,%*8S:*,)!20%M008!%)0!+:<*$!78<!87&&7%*F0!

0+0108%,!*8!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!-&#<:$0!,-0$*'*$!0W-0&*08$0,!&:8,!%)0!

&*,T!#'!1*,&0$#S8*]*8S!0*%)0&!#&!2#%)B!!L)*,!*,!20$7:,0!87&&7%*F0!<*,$#:&,0,!78<!

7,,:1-%*#8,!7&0!#'%08!0120<<0<!M*%)*8!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!7!S710U,!10$)78*$,J!78<!

F*$0`F0&,7B!!Z#&!78!0W71-+0!#'!%)*,J!+0%!:,!+##T!7%!%)0!'#++#M*8S!*8,%78$0!'&#1!1.!

<7%7G!

;+20&%G!!

K7.*8S!M7,%0!%#!0801*0,!M*%)!7!,%7&,)*-!$78!20!7!S##<!M7.!%#!+0%!#:%!

-08%!:-!'&:,%&7%*#8B!

A0&0!;+20&%!&0'0&08$0,!%)0!10$)78*$7+!'07%:&0,!#'!7!S710J!8710+.!%)0!S710U,!M*8!

$#8<*%*#8![<0'07%!78!0801.\!78<!%)0!-&0,:10<!&0+7%*#8,)*-![$#1-0%*%*#8\!%)7%!%)0!

S710!7%%01-%,!%#!,%&:$%:&0!20%M008!%)0!-+7.0&!78<!%)0!S710!08F*&#8108%!2.!%)*,!

M*8!$#8<*%*#8B!!L)*,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!*,!7+,#!-&0,:172+.!1787S0<!2.!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,0%!#'!

5fh!

&:+0,!%)7%!':&%)0&!,%&:$%:&0,!)#M!7!-+7.0&!*8%0&7$%,!M*%)!%)0!S710!78<J!,)#:+<!%)0!

S710!)7F0!,#$*7+!$#1-#808%,J!M*%)!)#M!-+7.0&,!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!%)&#:S)!

%)0!S710B!!A#M0F0&J!)*,!&0'0&08$0!%#!7!X,%7&,)*-Y!7+,#!S0,%:&0,!%#M7&<,!%)0!

'78%7,%*$7+!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710B!!A0!*,!8#%!R:,%!08S7S*8S!*8!78!72,%&7$%!#&!

%)0#&0%*$7+!$#1-0%*%*#8J!7,!#80!M#:+<!'*8<!*8J!,7.J!7!S710!#'!$)0$T0&,!#&!L0%&*,B!!@#J!

)0!*,!%)0!-*+#%!#'!7!,%7&,)*-B!!A0!*,!08S7S0<!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!'78%7,.B!!L)*,!87&&7%*F0J!*8!

%:&8J!2&*8S,!M*%)!*%!,-0$*'*$!%&#-0,J!0W-0$%7%*#8,J!78<!7,,:10<!0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!

-+7.0&,!)7F0!1#&0!#&!+0,,!'+:08$.!M*%)!78<!%):,!':&%)0&!,)7-0,!7!-+7.0&U,!0W-0&*08$0!

-+7.*8S!7!F*<0#!S710B!!L)0!S08&0!#'!,$*08$0!'*$%*#8!%)7%!;+20&%!&0'0&08$0,J!'#&!

*8,%78$0J!)7,!%&7<*%*#87++.!2008!*17S*80<!2.!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$0&,J!17&T0%*8S!0W-0&%,J!

78<!0F08!17*8,%&071!7:<*08$0,J!7,!7!17+0`<&*F08!S08&0J!M*%)!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!*%,!

$#8,:10&,!'*S:&0<!%#!20!17+0B!!L):,!%)0,0!%&#-0,!17.!20!1#&0!'71*+*7&!%#!17+0!

-+7.0&,!+*T0!;+20&%!%)78!%)0.!M#:+<!20!%#!'017+0!-+7.0&,B!!L)*,!'71*+*7&*%.J!*8!%:&8J!

17.!,)7-0!7!-+7.0&U,!$#1'#&%!M*%)!%)0!S710!*8!V:0,%*#8J!78<!,:2,0V:08%+.!)#M!*%!*,!

:,0<!7,!7!,#:&$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!&080M7+B!!L):,!2#%)!%)0!10$)78*$7+!78<!87&&7%*F0!

'07%:&0,!#'!%)0!F*<0#!S710J!78<!%)0*&!7&%*$:+7%*#8J!17.!20!$&:$*7+!%#!$:+%*F7%*8S!

;+20&%U,!<0,*&0<!0W-0&*08$0!k!X%#!+0%!#:%!-08%!:-!'&:,%&7%*#8BY!!I0!$78!*17S*80!%)7%!7!

<*''0&08%!$#12*87%*#8!#'!+:<*$!78<!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!M#:+<!)7F0!-&#<:$0<!7!

<*''0&08%!0W-0&*08$0B!!!

But!Which!Game!to!Choose?!

! /*8$0!M0!7&0!1#F*8S!'&#1!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!-+7.0&,!:8<0&,%78<!78<!'&710!

%)0*&!0W-0&*08$0,!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#M7&<,!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!

5fa!

M#&T!%#!-&#<:$0!,-0$*'*$!T*8<,!#'!0W-0&*08$0J!7!$)78S0!#'!10%)#<#+#S.!*,!80$0,,7&.B!!

=&#7<+.!,-07T*8SJ!1.!787+.%*$!'#$:,!*,!%&78,*%*#8*8S!'&#1!%)0!7:<*08$0!#'!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!10<*:1!%#M7&<,!%)0!10<*:1!*%,0+'B!!A#M0F0&J!?!:,0<!%)0!,:&F0.,!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!$#1-+0%0<!%#!<0%0&1*80!M)7%!%0W%,!?!7--&#7$)0<!78<!)#M!?!7--&#7$)0<!

%)01B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!?!'#&0S&#:8<0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!0W-0&*08$0,!78<!:,0<!%)#,0!

0W-0&*08$0,!%#!S:*<0!1.!787+.,0,!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!F*<0#!S710!%0W%,B!!L)*,!7--&#7$)!%#!

%0W%:7+!787+.,*,!)7,!7!&*$)!)*,%#&.!*8!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,B!!L)0!1#,%!'71#:,!*8,%78$0!#'!

%)*,!10%)#<#+#S.!*,!*8!N78*$0!>7<M7.U,![5665\!&0,07&$)!*8%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

&#178$0!8#F0+!&07<0&,J!<0%7*+0<!*8!G/$>"#1&'2/&G.@$#=/B!!?8!)0&!,%:<.J!#,%08,*2+.!7!

&0$0-%*#8!,%:<.J!>7<M7.!<0F#%0<!7!,*S8*'*$78%!71#:8%!#'!,-7$0!%#!787+.]*8S!%)0!

%0W%,!#'!,0F0&7+!&#178$0!8#F0+,!%#!$#8,%&:$%!78!*<07!#'!%)0!,%&:$%:&0!%)0,0!8#F0+,!

2:*+%J!M)*$)!)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!,:2,0V:08%+.!'#:8<!,#!7--07+*8SB!!A0&!$)#*$0!#'!%0W%,!%#!

787+.]0!78<!)0&!&07<*8So787+.%*$!,%&7%0S*0,J!%)#:S)J!M0&0!*8'#&10<!2.!%)0!,:&F0.,!

78<!*8%0&F*0M,!,)0!$#8<:$%0<!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!&#178$0!8#F0+!&07<0&,J!,-0$*'*$7++.!

M)7%!8#F0+,!)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!108%*#80<!7,!20*8S!%)0*&!'7F#&*%0,B!!C#&0#F0&J!>7<M7.!

<0<:$0<!'&#1!)0&!,:&F0.,!78<!*8%0&7$%*#8,!M*%)!&#178$0!8#F0+!&07<0&,!%)7%!#80!#'!

%)0!-&*17&.!&07,#8,!%)7%!%)0.!&07<!&#178$0!8#F0+,!M7,!%#!F*$7&*#:,+.!0W-0&*08$0!

%)0!+#F0!78<!$7&0!%)7%!%)0!8#F0+,U!)0&#*80,!M0&0!S*F08!2.!%)0!17+0!+#F0!*8%0&0,%,B!!

I#&T*8S!27$TM7&<,!'&#1!%)*,!*8,*S)%J!>7<M7.!M7,!72+0!%#!:,0!-,.$)#787+.%*$!

%)0#&*0,!%#!787+.]0!)#M!%)0!8#F0+,!,%&:$%:&0<!%)*,!0W-0&*08$0J!S*F*8S!:,!':&%)0&!

*8,*S)%!*8%#!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!,%&:$%:&0,!$&07%0<!2.!7!%0W%!78<!)#M!7:<*08$0,!*8)72*%0<!

%)#,0!,%&:$%:&0,B!

5fi!

! /*1*+7&+.J!?!'*&,%!S7%)0&0<!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!F*<0#!S710!

-&0'0&08$0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!78<!:,0<!%)7%!*8'#&17%*#8!%#!<0%0&1*80!M)7%!F*<0#!S710!

%0W%,!?!M#:+<!787+.]0!78<J!,:2,0V:08%+.J!M)7%!'07%:&0,!#'!%)#,0!%0W%,!?!M#:+<!$)##,0!

%#!'#$:,!#8B!!;,!M0!8#%0<!*8!%)0!-&0F*#:,!$)7-%0&J!F*<0#!S710,!M0&0!'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!

'#&!%)0!-:&-#,0,!#'!&0+7W7%*#8!78<!&0+*0'J!M)*$)!M0&0!*8!%:&8!F*%7+!0+0108%,!#'!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!,0+'`$7&0!&#:%*80,B!!?8!'7$%J!*%!M7,!F*<0#!S710,U!72*+*%.!%#!)0+-!-+7.0&,!

&0+7W!%)7%!&0-#&%0<+.!17<0!%)01!,#!F7+:72+0!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,B!!

;!$+#,0&!0W71*87%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,!7+,#!S7F0!10!,#10!*8,*S)%!*8%#!

%)0!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!-&#<:$0<!%)0,0!0W-0&*08$0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0*&!:,0!#'!

&0-0%*%*F0!%7,T,!%)7%!&0V:*&0!7!+0,,0&!<0S&00!#'!7%%08%*#8!78<!%)0*&!:,0!#'!%&#-0,!'&#1!

'71*+*7&!S08&0,!#'!'*$%*#8J!+*T0!,$*08$0`'*$%*#8!78<!'78%7,.B!!L):,J!20'#&0!*8F0,%*S7%*8S!

78.!-7&%*$:+7&!F*<0#!S710J!?!)7<!7+&07<.!87&&#M0<!1.!787+.,*,!%#!'#$:,!#8!%)#,0!

'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!1#,%!$#11#8+.!$*%0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!)0+-!M*%)!

&0+7W7%*#8!78<!&0+07,0B!

! L)*,!,%*++!+0'%!:878,M0&0<!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!M)7%!%0W%,!%#!787+.]0B!!?8!1.!,:&F0.!

?!7,T0<!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!8710!%)0!S710,!#&!%.-0,!#'!S710,!%)0.!'&0V:08%+.!-+7.0<!

7,!M0++!7,!%#!<0,$&*20!-7&%*$:+7&!*8,%78$0,!M)0&0!7!S710!)0+-0<!%)01!'00+!&0+7W0<B!!

Z&#1!%)0,0!V:0,%*#8,!?!$#1-*+0<!7!+*,%!#'!5h4!<*''0&08%!F*<0#!S710,!78<!F*<0#!S710!

,0&*0,J!%7T*8S!$7&0!%#!8#%0!)#M!'&0V:08%+.!07$)!#80!M7,!108%*#80<!78<!M)0%)0&!#&!

8#%!*%!M7,!108%*#80<!*8!$#8R:8$%*#8!M*%)!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!*%,!&0+7%0<!

0W-0&*08$0,J!,:$)!7,!,%&0,,!&0+*0'!78<!&0+7W7%*#8B!!Z&#1!%)*,!+*,%J!?!<0%0&1*80<!%)7%!

%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!$*%0<!S08&0J!*8!2#%)!8:120&!78<!*8!<*,$:,,*#8,!&0+7%0<!%#!,0+'`

$7&0J!M7,!%)0!%)0!C7,,*F0+.!C:+%*-+7.0&!P8+*80!>#+0`(+7.*8S!Q710![)0&07'%0&!

5f6!

&0'0&&0<!%#!2.!*%,!$#11#8!7$&#8.1J!CCP\B!!(#-:+7&!CCP,!,:$)!7,!A.3%>&.?&

A$3=3$?'![=+*]]7&<J!344f\J!<'$3&A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=![E+0$%&#8*$!;&%,J!3455\!78<!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,![/V:7&0`E8*WJ!345d\!M0&0!7+,#!71#8S!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!$*%0<!

*8<*F*<:7+!S710,B!!!

! L)0!-#-:+7&*%.!#'!%)*,!S08&0!71#8S!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!-&0,08%0<!,#10!:8*V:0!

$)7++08S0,!%#!1.!0''#&%,!%#!787+.]0!F*<0#!S710!%0W%,B!!Z#&!#80J!%)0,0!S710,J!%&:0!%#!

%)0*&!S080&*$!$7%0S#&*]7%*#8J!7&0!17,,*F0B!!I)*+0!$#11*%108%,!%#!#%)0&!S710,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!,*8S+0!-+7.0&!F*<0#!S710,J!7&0!107,:&0<!*8!)#:&,![#'%08!M*%)!%)0!*8`

S710!$+#$T,!%)7%!7&0!7!$#11#8!'07%:&0!*8!178.!S710,\J!$#11*%108%,!%#!CCP>(Q,!

7&0!%.-*$7++.!107,:&0<!*8!@.#'2(B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!&0M7&<,!-+7.0&,!

M*%)!*8`S710!$#++0$%*2+0,!78<!$#,%:10,!'#&!%)0*&!7F7%7&!%#!M07&!#8$0!%)0.!)7F0!

,:2,$&*20<!%#!%)0!S710!'#&!7!$0&%7*8!8:120&!#'!1#8%),B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!CCP,!7+,#!

%08<!%#!*8$+:<0!1#&0!$#8%08%!%)78!S710,!'&#1!#%)0&!S08&0,J!2#%)!*8!%)0!,)00&!

71#:8%!#'!$#8%08%!78<!*8!%)0!%.-0,!#'!$#8%08%!7F7*+72+0!%#!-+7.0&,B!!;,!*'!%)7%!M7,!8#%!

08#:S)J!%)0,0!S710,!7&0!7+,#!&0S:+7&+.!:-<7%0<!M*%)!80M!$#8%08%B!!/#10!#'!%)0,0!

:-<7%0,!71#:8%!%#!+*%%+0!1#&0!%)78!,*1-+0!7<<*%*#8,J!,:$)!7,!,17++!7&07,!#&!V:0,%,B!!

P%)0&!:-<7%0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!#80,!17&T0<!2.!%)0!-&#<:$0&,!7,!X0W-78,*#8,JY!$78!

&7<*$7++.!0W-78<!78<!7+%0&!)#M!%)0!S710!*,!-+7.0<B!!L)0,0!0W-78,*#8,!7&0!7T*8!%#!':++!

S710,!%)01,0+F0,!78<!7&0!#'%08!%&07%0<!7,!,:$)J!M*%)!17&T0%*8S!78<!<*,%&*2:%*#8!%#!

&*F7+!78.!80M!S710B!

L#!S*F0!1.!7:<*08$0!78!*<07!#'!%)0!08#&1#:,!,$7+0!#'!%)0,0!S710,J!?!M*++!:,0!

%)0!S710!?!:+%*17%0+.!<0$*<0<!%#!'#$:,!#8J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J&7,!78!0W71-+0B!!L#!<7%0J!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$#8,*,%,!#'!%)0!27,0!S710J!'*&,%!&0+07,0<!*8!3454!78<!,*S8*'*$78%+.!

5c4!

&0F*,0<!*8!345dJ!7,!M0++!7,!%M#!0W-78,*#8 ,G!L/$9/#(N$3>&[345c\!78<!<'.3@;%..>!

[345a\B!!L)0!2:+T!#'!%)0!S710-+7.!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&$#8,*,%,!#'!V:0,%,J!#&!%7,T,!

7,,*S80<!2.!7!$)7&7$%0&!$#8%&#++0<!2.!%)0!S710![$#++#V:*7++.!&0'0&&0<!%#!7,!78!X@(9JY!

#&!X8#8`-+7.72+0!$)7&7$%0&Y\B!!L)0,0!%7,T,!$#8,*,%!#'!7!&0+7%*F0+.!,17++!8:120&!#'!

7$%*F*%*0,J!,:$)!7,!<0'07%*8S!$0&%7*8!1#8,%0&,!#&!S7%)0&*8S!$0&%7*8!*%01,J!%)7%!7&0!

+*1*%0<!2.!%)0!S710U,!01-)7,*,!#8!$#127%!78<!0W-+#&7%*#8B!!!A#M0F0&J!%)0,0!V:0,%,!

7&0!'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!%#!<0F0+#-!%)0!-+7.0&U,!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!S710U,!87&&7%*F0J!

*8$+:<*8S!%)0!1.%)#+#S.!#'!%)0!M#&+<J!%)0!-0&,#87+*%.!78<!)*,%#&*0,!#'!%)0!87&&7%*F0U,!

,:2,%78%*7+!$7,%!#'!$)7&7$%0&,J!78<!%)0!$: + %:&0,!#'!%)0!F7&*#:,!&7$0,!78<!87%*#8,!%)7%!

-#-:+7%0!%)0!M#&+<B!!C78.!#'!%)0,0!V:0,%,J!*8!%:&8J!7&0!S&#:-0<!%#S0%)0&!*8%#!XV:0,%!

+*80,JY!#&!7!,0&*0,!#'!V:0,%,!%)7%!<0F0+#-!7!,-0$*'*$!-+#%!%)&#:S)!7!S7%0<!-&#S&0,,*#8!

10$)78*,1!M)0&0!%)0!$#1-+0%*#8!#'!#80!V:0,%!:8+#$T,!%)0!80W%!V:0,%!*8!%)0!$)7*8B!!

L)0,0!V:0,%!+*80,!$78!$#8,*,%!#'!78.M)0&0!20%M008!h!V:0,%,J!*8!%)0!$7,0!#'!7!S*F08!

$+7,,U,!*8*%*7+!V:0,%!+*80J!%#!7--&#W*17%0+.!ff4J!*8!%)0!$7,0!#'!%)0!17*8!,$087&*#!V:0,%!

+*80B!

I)7%!*,!1#&0J!%)0&0!7&0!7+,#!,-0$*'*$!$)7++08S0,!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!7%%01-%J!,:$)!

7,!<0'07%*8S!1#&0!<*''*$:+%!F0&,*#8,!#'!%)0!17*8!,$087&*#U,!0801*0,J!,%&:$%:&0<!

$#1-0%*%*#8,!20%M008!<*''0&08%!S&#:-,!#'!-+7.0&,![T8#M8!7,!(F(J!#&!X-+7.0&!F0&,:,!

-+7.0&JY!27%%+0,\J!78<!%)0!Q#+<!/7:$0&!$7,*8#!$#1-+0%0!M*%)!F7&*#:,!,17++0&`,$7+0!

S712+*8S!S710,B!!P8!%#-!#'!%)0!87&&7%*F0!78<!S710-+7.!$#8%08%J!%)0&0!*,!7+,#!7!

$#8,*<0&72+0!,#$*7+!$#1-#808%!%)7%!-+7.0&,!17.!0*%)0&!$)##,0!#&!<0$+*80!%#!

-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!%#!F7&.*8S!<0S&00,B!!L)0,0!*8$+:<0!:,*8S!X<:%.!'*8<0&,JY!M)*$)!-+7.0&,!

:8'71*+*7&!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!$78!:,0!%#!S&#:-!%#S0%)0&!%#!$#1-+0%0!,-0$*'*$!%7,T,J!

5c5!

*8%08%*#87++.!'#&1*8S!S&#:-,!M*%)!7$V:7*8%78$0,J!#&!0F08!'#&1*8S!+7&S0!

#&S78*]7%*#8,J!#&!X'&00!$#1-78*0,JY!07$)!M*%)!%)0*&!#M8!-+7.0&!<0'*80<!-:&-#,0,J!

#&S78*]7%*#87+!,%&:$%:&0J!78<J!%#!%)0!0W%08%!7''#&<0<!2.!%)0!S710J!$:+%:&0!78<!

*<0#+#S.B!!!!!!!

;,!M0!$78!,00J!%)08J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*,!7!17,,*F0!78<!$#1-+0W!S710!M*%)!7!

F7&*0%.!#'!$#1-#808%,!%)7%!-+7.0&,!17.!$)##,0!#&!<0$+*80!%#!08S7S0!M*%)!<0-08<*8S!

#8!%)0*&!,-0$*'*$!$#8%0W%,!78<!-0&,#87+!800<,J!<0,*&0,J!78<!)*,%#&*0,B!!;8<!&010120&J!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&*,!#8+.!#80!S710!*8!%)0!CCP!S08&0B!!P%)0&!&0-&0,08%7%*F0,!#'!%)0!

S08&0J!*8$+:<*8S!%)0!'71#:,!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'J!<'$3&A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=J!#&!0F08!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!CCP!-&0<0$0,,#&J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+J!7&0!#'!7!$#1-7&72+0!,$7+0J!

)7F*8S!)7<!.07&,!%#!7$$:1:+7%0!80M!$#8%08%!78<!&0F*,0!%)0*&!0W*,%*8S!$#8%08%B!!

;%%01-%*8S!%#!787+.]0!0F08!7!,17++!8:120&!#'!%)0,0!S710,!M#:+<!20J!%#!-:%!*%!

1*+<+.J!712*%*#:,B!!Q*F08!%)0!*8,%*%:%*#87+!-&0,,:&0,!%#!-&#<:$0!7!M&*%%08!7$$#:8%!#'!

#80U,!&0,07&$)!*8!7!&07,#872+0!71#:8%!#'!%*10J!8#%!%#!108%*#8!%)0!+*1*%0<!&0,#:&$0,!

#'!080&S.!78<!7%%08%*#8!80$0,,7&.!%#!-&#<:$0!T8#M+0<S0!M)*+0!#$$:-.*8S!7!,-0$*'*$!

2#<.J!?!<0$*<0<!%)7%!787+.]*8S!1:+%*-+0!CCP>(Q,!M7,!:8'07,*2+0B!!!!!!

Z#&!%)*,!&07,#8J!?!$)#,0!%#!'#$:,!1.!080&S*0,!#8!787+.]*8S!#80!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!

S710!#'!%)0!CCP>(Q!S08&0B!!/0F0&7+!*,,:0,!M0&0!M0*S)0<!78<!$#8,*<0&0<J!*8$+:<*8S!

%)0!S#7+,!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%J!1.!7$$0,,!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!S710!78<!%)0!-+7%'#&1[,\!

%)0!S710!$#:+<!-+7.0<!#8J!78<!1.!#M8!S71*8S!,T*++,!78<!$#1-0%08$*0,B!!=0'#&0!

20S*88*8S!%)*,!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%J!?!)7<!#8+.!<722+0<!M*%)!%)0!CCP>(Q!S08&0B!!?!)7<!

-+7.0<!,0F0&7+!S710,!*8!%)0!S08&0!-&0F*#:,+.!2:%!80F0&!%#!X$#1-+0%*#8JY!7!)7].!%0&1!

*8!7!S08&0!%)7%!01-)7,*]0,!08<S710!$#8%08%!78<!%)0!S080&7%*#8!#'!-+7.0&`<0'*80<!

5c3!

S#7+,!2:%!%)7%!?!71!:,*8S!%#!1078!%)0!$#1-+0%*#8!#'!7!S710U,!17*8!,$087&*#!V:0,%!

+*80B!!A#M0F0&J!1.!+7$T!#'!0W-0&*08$0!-+7.*8S!S710,!*8!%)0!CCP>(Q!S08&0!M7,!8#%!7!

,*S8*'*$78%!<&7M27$T!<:0!%#!%)0!M07+%)!#'!0W-0&*08$0!?!)7<!-+7.*8S!#%)0&!,*1*+7&!

S08&0,J!0,-0$*7++.!%)0!,*8S+0!-+7.0&!&#+0`-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710![X>(Q,Y\!%)7%!CCP,!

M0&0!<0&*F0<!'&#1B!!L)0,0!S08&0,!7&0!$+#,0+.!&0+7%0<!%#!#80!78#%)0&!78<!*8!'7$%!%)0!

%&#-0,J!10$)78*$,J!78<!%&08<,!#'!#80!S08&0!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!7<#-%0<!78<!&0F*,0<!2.!

%)0!#%)0&B!!?!)7F0!2008!-+7.*8S!&#+0`-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!?!M7,!78!7<#+0,$08%!

78<!$#:8%!%)0!S08&0!71#8S!1.!'7F#&*%0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!+#8S!&:88*8S!,0&*0,!!"#$%&

!$#'$()J!78<!,#!1.!72*+*%.!%#!S&7,-!%)0!10$)78*$,!#'!%)0!CCP!S08&0!78<!-7&%*$*-7%0!

':++.!M7,!80F0&!7!,*S8*'*$78%!-&#2+01B!!!

I*%)!10$)78*$7+!-&#M0,,!78!*8,*S8*'*$78%!'7$%#&J!78<!,00*8S!%)7%!%)0!1#,%!

-#-:+7&!S710,!*8!%)0!CCP!S08&0!)7<!,*1*+7&!10$)78*$,J!1.!$)#*$0!M7,!,*S8*'*$78%+.!

*8'+:08$0<!2.!1.!-0&,#87+!%7,%0!78<!'71*+*7&*%.!M*%)!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!'&78$)*,0!%)7%!

%)0!CCP!M7,!7!-7&%!#'B!!;,!?!2&*0'+.!108%*#80<!72#F0J!?!M7,![78<!,%*++!71\!7!'78!#'!%)0!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,B!!L)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()!'&78$)*,0!*,!7!+#8S!&:88*8S!78<!M0++`&0$0*F0<!

&#+0`-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710!,0&*0,J!M*%)!5c!08%&*0,!*8!%)0!17*8!,0&*0,![7,!#'!%)*,!M&*%*8S\!

78<!8:10&#:,!,-*8`#''!78<!,*<0!S710,J!7,!M0++!7,!F7&*#:,!$&#,,`10<*7!%*0`*8,!,:$)!

7,!%)0!2*S`2:<S0%!A#++.M##<!'*+1J!!"#$%&!$#'$()J&02/&<F"3"'(&A"'2"#![3445\J!78<!!

F7&*#:,!2##T,J!%0+0F*,*#8!-&#R0$%,J!7&%!*8,%7++7%*#8,J!78<!$#8$0&%!,0&*0,!%)7%!7&0!%##!

8:10&#:,!%#!+*,%!)0&0B!!I)*+0!%)0!F7,%!17R#&*%.!#'!%)0!S710,!*8!%)0!,0&*0,!7&0!,*8S+0`

-+7.0&!S710,J!*%!)7,!)7<!%M#!,*S8*'*$78%!CCP,!k!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+![344d\J!M)*$)!

7+%)#:S)!<7%0<!*,!,%*++!$:&&08%+.!&:88*8SJ!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,![3454\B!!?!<0$*<0<!%#!

'#$:,!#8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!+7&S0+.!<:0!%#!1.!'71*+*7&*%.!M*%)!78<!'#8<80,,!'#&!%)0!

5cd!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,B!!PF0&!*%,!%)&00!<0$7<0,!#'!0W*,%08$0J!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,!)7,!

<0F0+#-0<!7!F7,%!$#++0$%*#8!#'!%&#-0,J!*$#8#S&7-)*0,J!78<!&0'0&08$0,!%)7%!7&0!

'&0V:08%+.!&0`:,0<!78<!&0<0-+#.0<!7$&#,,!*%,!F7&*#:,!S710,![07$)!#'!M)*$)!'07%:&0,!

78!08%*&0+.!80M!$7,%J!80M!1.%)#+#S.J!78<!'&0V:08%+.!80M!S710!10$)78*$,\B!!?!

&07,#80<!%)7%!1.!'71*+*7&*%.!M*%)!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()!,0&*0,!M#:+<!07,0!10!*8%#!%)0!7%`

%*10,!#F0&M)0+1*8S!%0&&*%#&.!#'!%)0!CCP!S08&0J!7,!178.!#'!%)0!%&#-0,!78<!

10$)78*$,!#'!%)7%!S08&0!M0&0!&0$#8'*S:&0<!78<!7<7-%0<!'#&!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

7:<*08$0B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!M7,!7+,#!7!S##<!$)#*$0!<:0!%#!%)0!-#-:+7&*%.!#'!%)0!

S710B!!?%!$:&&08%+.!)7,!7--&#W*17%0+.!5f!1*++*#8!,:2,$&*20&,![/7%#J!345i\B!!L)*,!*,!7!

8:120&!%)7%!*,!0V:7+0<!#8+.!2.!%)0!M0++`T8#M8!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'!78<!<M7&',!%)0!

8:120&,!#'!#%)0&!&0$08%!CCP,J!,:$)!7,!<'$3&A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=&[3455\&78<!G"?'!

[3455\B!!!!!

D0%!%)0&0!M7,!78#%)0&!,*S8*'*$78%!'7$%#&!20)*8<!1.!$)#*$0!%#!'#$:,!#8!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,&%)7%!?!M#:+<!20!&01*,,!8#%!%#!108%*#8B!!?!&07,#80<!%)7%!1.!'71*+*7&*%.!

M*%)!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()!'&78$)*,0!M#:+<!7+,#!)0+-!1*%*S7%0!,#10!#'!%)0!78W*0%.!?!

<0F0+#-!M)08!-+7.*8S!CCP,B!!L)*,!M7,!8#%!78!*8,*S8*'*$78%!2080'*%!k!#80!#'!%)0!

+7&S0,%!*,,:0,!%)7%!800<,!%#!20!1787S0<!M)08!?!-+7.!CCP,!*,!1.!78W*0%.B!!P80!#'!1.!

,-0$*'*$!78W*0%.!%&*SS0&,J!*8!'7$%J!*,!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!?!71!

7+1#,%!0W$+:,*F0+.!7!,#+*%7&.!-+7.0&B!!?8!'7$%J!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!1.!<*,$:,,*#8,!M*%)!

'&*08<,!78<!$#++07S:0,!M)#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!1#&0!'#&17+!*8%0&7$%*#8,!

?!)7F0!)7<!M*%)!&0,07&$)!-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!M7,!,%&:$T!2.!)#M!,#+*%7&.!?!-&0'0&!1.!F*<0#!

S710!-&7$%*$0,!%#!20B!!I)08!#2,0&F*8S!#%)0&!-0#-+0!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,J!0*%)0&!

'#&17++.!#&!*8'#&17++.J!?!:,:7++.!8#%0!,#10!'#&1!#'!,#$*7+!*8%0&7$%*#8B!!/#10%*10,!

5cf!

%)0,0!*8%0&7$%*#8,!7&0!'#&17++.!,%&:$%:&0<!2.!%)0!F*<0#!S710J!7,!M)08!-0#-+0!-+7.!7!

$##-0&7%*F0!1#<0!*8!7!F*<0#!S710!%#S0%)0&!0*%)0&!*8!-0&,#8!#&!#8+*80B!!P%)0&!%*10,!

,#$*7+!*8%0&7$%*#8,!#$$:&!1#&0!,-#8%780#:,+.J!,:$)!7,!M)08!7!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&!

20S*8,!%7+T*8S!%#!#%)0&!-0#-+0!M)#!7&0!-&0,08%!*8!%)0!&##1!M*%)!%)01!2:%!M)#!17.!

#&!17.!8#%!20!8#%!-+7.*8S!%)0!F*<0#!S710B!!!

?8!1.!#M8!-0&,#87+!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0J!)#M0F0&J!?!%&.!%#!+*1*%!%)*,!,#$*7+!

*8%0&7$%*#8!7,!1:$)!7,!-#,,*2+0!2.!-+7.*8S!,*8S+0`-+7.0&!S710,!7+1#,%!0W$+:,*F0+.J!

#&!*S8#&*8S!%)0!1:+%*-+7.0&!$#1-#808%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!M)08!80$0,,7&.J!78<!

-+7.*8S!7+#80!7,!1:$)!7,!-#,,*2+0B!!(7&%!#'!%)*,!-&0'0&08$0!$78!20!7%%&*2:%0<!%#!1.!

-0&,#87+*%.!k!?!71!78!*8%&#F0&%!M)#!*,!07,*+.!#F0&M)0+10<!2.!%##!178.!<0178<,!#8!

1.!7%%08%*#8B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!)7F*8S!%#!&7-*<+.!,)*'%!20%M008!%)0!-).,*$7+!78<!108%7+!

<0178<,!#'!7!F*<0#!S710!78<!%)0!01#%*#87+!<0178<,!#'!1787S*8S!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!

M*%)!#%)0&,J!M)0%)0&!%)0.!7&0!*8!-0&,#8!#&!#8+*80J!,%&78S0&,!#&!'71*+.J!*,!7!

$#8,*<0&72+0!<&7*8!#8!1.!&0,#:&$0,B!!;8#%)0&!&07,#8!'#&!1.!,#+*%7&.!-+7.!,%.+0!*,!

%)7%J!S&#M*8S!:-J!?!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!&0%&07%!'&#1!,#$*7+!

*8%0&7$%*#8,B!!L)0&0'#&0!%)0!7,,#$*7%*#8!20%M008!XF*<0#!S710,Y!78<!X,#+*%:<0Y!M7,!7!

-7&%!#'!1.!2$;"'6(!'&#1!78!07&+.!7S0J!M0++!20'#&0!?!0F0&!$#8,$*#:,+.!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!

XS710&JY!78<!1.!7<#-%0<!*,#+7%*#8!'&#1!#%)0&!-0#-+0!1078%!%)7%!%)*,!7,,#$*7%*#8!

M7,!&7&0+.!$)7++08S0<!78<!?!80F0&!+07&80<!)#M!%#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!M*%)!#%)0&,B!

>7%)0&!%)78!F*0M!%)*,!*,,:0!7,!,#10%)*8S!%#!20!V:7&78%*80<!#''!'&#1!1.!

787+.,*,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%)#:S)J!?!<0$*<0<!%#!%&07%!*%!7,!78!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!'#$:,!

#8!7!%.-0!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0!%)7%!'&0V:08%+.!0,$7-0,!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)!k!%)0!

,*8S+0!-+7.0&!0W-0&*08$0B!!L)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0!7++#M0<!10!%#!%7T0!'#&!S&78%0<!%)7%!

5cc!

S710,!7&0!*8)0&08%+.!,#$*7+!78<!1#F0!%)0!$#8F0&,7%*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!2&#7<0&!

V:0,%*#8!#'!)#M!S710,!7&0!,#$*7+!2.!$#8,*<0&*8S!M)7%!%.-0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!7&0!7''#&<0<!

2.!-7&%*$:+7&!S710,!78<!)#M!%)#,0!%.-0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!7&0!%)08!%7T08!:-!78<!7<#-%0<!

%)&#:S)!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!S710&,B!!P80!#'!%)0!+7&S0,%!,)*'%,!*8!%)0!-0&$0-%*#8!#'!%)0!

F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0!*8!%)0!-7,%!<0$7<0!)7,!2008!%)0!010&S*8S!7$T8#M+0<S0108%!

%)7%!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!<00-+.!,#$*7+J!78<!8#%!#8+.!*8!1:+%*-+7.0&!F*<0#!

S710,B!!_*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,J!+*T0!7++!10<*7!&0$0-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,J!7&0!0120<<0<!*8!

-).,*$7+!08F*&#8108%,!78<!7&0!-0&'#&10<!7,!7!-7&%!#'!-0#-+0U,!0F0&.<7.!+*F0,J!78<!

7,!,:$)!20$#10!7!-7&%!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!+*F0,!#'!-0#-+0,B!!_*<0#!S710,!7&0!%)0!,:2R0$%!#'!

$#8F0&,7%*#8,!20%M008!'&*08<,!#&!%)0!#2R0$%!7&#:8<!M)*$)!7!S7%)0&*8S!*,!#&S78*]0<B!!

L)0.!7&0!%##+,!'#&!$&07%*8S!78<!,:,%7*8*8S!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!20%M008!'71*+.!10120&,J!7,!

M0!,7M!*8!%)0!-&0F*#:,!$)7-%0&U,!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!;&+080U,!S71*8S!)*,%#&.B!!P&!%)0.!7&0!

-+7.0<!M)*+0!#%)0&!-0#-+0!S#!72#:%!%)0*&!+*F0,!7&#:8<!%)0!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&B!!!

L)*,!*,!7++!%#!,7.!%)7%!%)0&0!,)#:+<!8#!+#8S0&!20!78.!V:0,%*#8!72#:%!M)0%)0&!

#&!8#%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!,#$*7+B!!L)0.!7&0B!!I)7%!*8,%07<!&017*8,!%#!20!*8F0,%*S7%0<!

7&0!%)0!T*8<,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!%)7%!-0#-+0!08S7S0!*8!M)*+0!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!

%)&#:S)!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!<*''0&08%!,%7T0,!#'!%)0,0!F7&*#:,!

,#$*7+*%*0,!78<!%)0!,%7%:,!0W%08<0<!%#!%)01!2.!%)0!F7&*#:,!7$%#&,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,!

%)7%!*8'#&1!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,J!'&#1!2&#7<!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!%)0!;10&*$78!

0<:$7%*#87+!,.,%01!%)0!80M,!10<*7!%#!%)0!1#&0!+#$7+!78<!,-0$*'*$!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

$#11:8*%*0,!#'!S710&,!78<!*8<*F*<:7+!S710&,!%)01,0+F0,B!!?8F0,%*S7%*8S!%)0,0!

V:0,%*#8,!8#%!#8+.!-&#1*,0,!%#!0W-78<!#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!,#$*7+*%.!20.#8<!7!

&0<:$%*F0!2*87&.!#'!7+#80o%#S0%)0&J!2:%! M *++!7+,#!)0+-!&0,07&$)0&,!,00!)#M!F*<0#!

5ch!

S710,!7&0!:,0<!2.!-0#-+0!%#!,%&7%0S*$7++.!1787S0!78<!$#8%&#+!%)0!F7&*#:,!7,-0$%,!#'!

,#$*7+*%.J!,:$)!7,!*%,!<:&7%*#8!78<!*%,!*8%08,*%.B!

(#,*%*#8*8S!1.,0+'!7,!7!,#+*%7&.!S710&!M)*+0!-+7.*8S!7!':8<7108%7++.!,#$*7+!

S08&0!+*T0!%)0!CCPJ!%)08J!7++#M0<!10!%#!,:,-08<!%)0!7,,:1-%*#8,!#'!1:+%*-+7.0&!

,#$*7+*%.!%)7%!7&0!S080&7++.!7%%&*2:%0<! % #!%)0!S08&0!78<!*8,%07<!$#8,*<0&!%)0!<*''0&08%!

%.-0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!%)7%!7&0!17<0!7F7*+72+0!%#!%)0!-+7.0&!2.!%)0!S710J!M)7%!%.-0,!7&0!

<*,$#:&7S0<J!78<!M)7%!%.-0,!7&0!#:%&*S)%!<08*0<B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!0872+0<!10!%#!20%%0&!

#2,0&F0!78<!7,,0,,!%)0!<*''0&*8S!F7+:0,!%)7%!%)7%!%)0!S710!*1-+*$*%+.!7,,*S80<!%#!

<*''0&08%!%.-0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!78<!%):,!20%%0&!:8<0&,%78<!)#M!,:2R0$%,!7&0!)7*+0<!7,!

X,#$*7+Y!78<!)#M!7!,:2R0$%!17.J!*8!%:&8J!&0,-#8<!%#!%)*,!*8%0&-0++7%*#8B!!!

L)*,!M7,!7!%&0108<#:,!2080'*%J!78<!8#%!#8+.!20$7:,0J!7,!K*8<+#'!78<!L7.+#&!

[3455\!&01*8<!:,J!%)0!-#,*%*#8!#'!$:+%:&7+!#:%,*<0&!$78!7++#M!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!7!20% %0&!

F78%7S0!-#*8%!%#!*8%0&&#S7%0!,#10!#'!%)0!7,,:1-%*#8,!78<!X%7T08`'#&`S&78%0<Y!

0+0108%,!#'!%)0!$:+%:&0![-B!5fd\B!!?%!M7,!7+,#!,-0$*'*$7++.!2080'*$*7+!%#!1.!-&#R0$%!

20$7:,0!7!,*S8*'*$78%!-#&%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!8#%0<!%)7%!#80!#'!%)0!17*8!

7%%&7$%*#8,!#'!%)0!CCP!S08&0!M7,!%)7%!*%!0872+0<!%)01!%#!1787S0!,#$*7+!*8%0&7$%*#8,!

<0-08<*8S!#8!%)0*&!'+:$%:7%*8S!800<,!78<!<0,*&0,B!!L)*,!*8$+:<0<! % )0!72*+*%.!%#!

M*%)<&7M!'&#1!,#$*7+!*8%0&7$%*#8,!08%*&0+.!,)#:+<!%)0.!-&#F0!%)&07%08*8SJ!

#F0&M)0+1*8SJ!#&!#%)0&M*,0!:8<0,*&72+0B!!I)*+0!#%)0&!787+.,0,J!%)08J!)7F0!

01-)7,*]0<!%)0!1:+%*-+7.0&!78<!$#11:87+!0+0108%,!#'!CCP,J!1.!787+.,*,!$#10,!7%!

V:0,%*#8,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!'&#1!7!<*''0&08%!78S+0!2.!%7T*8S!%)0!,#+*%7&.!-+7.0&!7,!%)0!

,%7&%*8S!-#*8%!78<!V:0,%*#8*8S!%)0!$08%&7+*%.!#'!7!1:+%*-+7.0&J!$#11:87+!,#$*7+*%.!%#!

%)0!CCP!S08&0B!!/:$)!7!-0&,-0$%*F0!0872+0<!10!%#!20%%0&!#2,0&F0!)#M!7!,-0$*'*$!

5ca!

CCPJ!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!M#&T,!%#!0872+0!78<!08$#:&7S0!,#10!%.-0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!

M)*+0!<*,08$#:&7S*8S!#&!<08.*8S!#%)0&,B!!;,!M0!M*++!,00!*8!1.!787+.,*,J!%)*,!

-&*F*+0S0,!$0&%7*8!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,!72#F0!#%)0&,J!-#%08%*7++.!&0-&#<:$*8S!$:+%:&7+!

8#&1,!$#8$0&8*8S!,#$*7+*%.!%)7%!$78!&0*8'#&$0!%)0!17&S*87+*]7%*#8!#'!F:+80&72+0!

,:2R0$%,B!

Blending!Textual!Analysis,!Participant!Observation,!and!Auto-Ethnography!

! C.!787+.,*,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!)7,!7,!1:$)!*8!$#11#8!M*%)!%)0!,#$*7+!

,$*08$0!10%)#<!#'!-7&%*$*-78%!#2,0&F7%*#8!7,!*%!<#0,!M*%)!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!%0W%:7+!

787+.,*,B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!78!7+%#S0%)0&!:8*V:0!7--&#7$)!%#!F*<0#!S710!787+.,*,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!#'!S08&0,!%)7%!01-)7,*]0!,#$*7+*%.J!+*T0!CCP,B!!EW%08,*F0!&0,07&$)!#8!

%)0!S08&0J!*8$+:<*8S!C*7!9#8,7+F#U,![344a\!M#&T!#8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+J!LBKB!L7.+#&U,!

[344h\!M#&T!#8!I9/3R6/('J!78<!=#88*!@7&<*U,![3454\!M#&T!#8!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'J!

)7F0!0W-+*$*%+.!-#,*%*#80<!%)0*&!&0,-0$%*F0!787+.,0,!7,!0%)8#S&7-)*0,B!!Q*F08!%)0!

:8*V:0!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!#'!%)0!CCP!S08&0J!%)*,!7--&#7$)!17T0,!,08,0B!!L)0!-0&,*,%08%!

M#&+<,!#'!CCP,!,%&#8S+.!&0,012+0,!%)0!%&7<*%*#87+!0%)8#S&7-)*$!X,*%0Y!78<!%)0!

7'#&0108%*#80<!,%:<*0,!%&07%0<!%)01!7,!,:$)J!M*%)!%)0!&0,07&$)0&,!F*,*%*8S!%)0!,*%0!

#'!%)0!CCP!<7*+.J!#2,0&F*8S!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!F7&*#:,!7$%#&,J!*8%0&7$%*8S!M*%)!#%)0&!

-+7.0&,J!78<!<0F0+#-*8S!7!<00-!78<!)#+*,%*$!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!S71*8S!

$#11:8*%.U,!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,!78<!,.,%01,!#'!1078*8SB!

! C.!7--&#7$)!%#!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<*''0&,!'&#1!%)0!1#&0!0%)8#S&7-)*$7++.`

#&*08%0<!7$$#:8%,!#'!9#8,7+F#J!L7.+#&J!78<!@7&<*!*8!*1-#&%78%!M7.,J!)#M0F0&B!!L)0!

1#,%!*1-#&%78%!<*,%*8$%*#8!*,!%)7%!?!M7,!8#%!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!<0F0+#-*8S!7!)#+*,%*$!

5ci!

7$$#:8%!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,!#'!%)0!CCPB!!?8,%07<J!?!M7,!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!7!,-0$*'*$!

%.-0!#'!-&7$%*$0!k!S71*8S!7,!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!I)*+0!*8!7!$+7,,*$!0%)8#S&7-)*$!

7$$#:8%!%)0!&0,07&$)0&!%&*0,!%#!08%0&!%)0!'*0+<!M*%)!7,!#-08!7!1*8<!7,!-#,,*2+0!78<J!

%)&#:S)!*110&,*#8J!S&7<:7++.!<0F0+#-!78!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!M)7%!*,!,*S8*'*$78%!#&!8#%!

*8!%)0!,*%0U,!$:+%:&7+!M#&+<J!?!)7<!7!,-0$*'*$!*8%0&0,%!*8!7!87&&#M!&78S0!#'!-&7$%*$0,!

<0&*F0<!'&#1!1.!,:&F0.!<7%7B!!!

C#&0#F0&J!<:0!%#!%)0!<7%7!#2%7*80<!'&#1!1.!,:&F0.J!?!)7<!7+&07<.!<0F0+#-0<!

78!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!)#M!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!:8<0&,%##<!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!M0++!

7,!)#M!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!2&#7<+.!:,0<!F*<0#!S710,!%#!'7$*+*%7%0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!I)7%!

&017*80<!%#!20!*8F0,%*S7%0<!M0&0!%)0!,-0$*'*$!7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!F*<0#!

S710!%0W%,!%#!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!K##T*8S!7%!)#M!7!,-0$*'*$!F*<0#!

S710!M#&T,!%#!,%&:$%:&0!7!-0&,#8U,!-+7.!$#:+<!)0+-!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!%)0!F*<0#!S710!

-&7$%*$0,!<0,$&*20<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!%):,!*1-&#F0!#:&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!

$#1-+0W!&0+7%*#8,)*-!#'!<0%0&1*87%*#8!%)7%!0W*,%,!20%M008!F*<0#!S710!%0W%,!78<!

%)0*&!7:<*08$0,B!!;,!/#8*7!K*F*8S,%#80![344f\!&01*8<,!:,J!&0$0-%*#8!&0,07&$)!0W*,%,!

7%!%)0!*8%0&,0$%*#8!20%M008!'/E'6$%!78<!(.="$%!<0%0&1*87%*#8,B!!I)*+0!%)0!-&0F*#:,!

$)7-%0&,!'#$:,0<!-&*17&*+.!#8!%)0!,#$*7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!%)7%!,)7-0<!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,U!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!,#$*7+!$+7,,J!%)0!&017*8*8S!$)7-%0&,!M*++!

'#$:,!#8!%)0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!

/:$)!7!-:&-#,0!M*++!7+,#!)0+-!'*++!7!S7-!%)7%!#%)0&!F*<0#!S710!78<!&0$0-%*#8!

,$)#+7&,!)7F0!8#%0<B!!Q7&&.!9&7M'#&<![3453\!*8!-7&%*$:+7 &! )7,!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)0!'*0+<!

#'!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!)7,!7!%08<08$.!%#!#F0&01-)7,*]0!%)0!*8%0&7$%*F0!V:7+*%*0,!#'!

F*<0#!S710,J!78<!2.!0W%08,*#8!-+7.0&!7S08$.!78<!$)#*$0B!!A#M0F0&J!%)*,!%08<08$.!

5c6!

%)&07%08,!%#!#2,$:&0!%)0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!*8$+:<*8S!)#M!

F*<0#!S710,!&0-&#<:$0!78<!$:+%*F7%0!7!&78S0!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!*<0#+#S*0,!78<!<*,$#:&,0,!

%)7%!-+7.0&,!1:,%J!*8!%:&8J!80S#%*7%0!7,!%)0.!-+7.B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!%)0&0!0W*,%!

8#!S##<!787+.,0,!#'!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!7,-0$%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!L)0&0!7&0!8:10&#:,!

0W$0-%*#87+!787+.,0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!M#&T!#'!;8<&0M!=70&S![3446J!345f\J!Q0&7+<!

_##&)00,![3446\J!78<!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7![345a\B!!!!?%!*,!10&0+.!%#!,%7%0!%)7%!

%)0&0!*,!,%*++!1:$)!M#&T!%#!20!<#80!#8!%)*,!'&#8%J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!&0S7&<*8S!%)0!CCP!

S08&0B!!!

L)*,!,%78$0!7+,#!':&%)0&!,*%:7%0,!1.!-7&%*$:+7&!&0,07&$)!M*%)*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!

$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!7,!#--#,0<!%#!#%)0&!%)0#&0%*$7+!7--&#7$)0,!%#!&0$0-%*#8J!,:$)!7,!%)0!

:,0,!78<!S&7%*'*$7%*#8!%&7<*%*#8B!!>0%:&8*8S!%#!K*F*8S,%#80![344f\J!,)0!7&S:0,!%)7%!

10<*7!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!%08<!%#!20!:827+78$0<!%#M7&<,!%&07%*8S!%)0!10<*7!7,!7!

%0$)8#+#S*$7+!#2R0$%J!+#$7%0<!M*%)*8!7!,-0$*'*$!,-7%*#`%01-#&7+!$#8%0W%J!&7%)0&!%)78!

7,!7!%0W%J!+#$7%0<!M*%)*8!7!,-0$*'*$!<*,$:&,*F0!$#8%0W%B!!L):,J!10<*7!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!

)7F0!%08<0<!%#!'#$:,!1#&0!0W%08,*F0+.!#8!)#M!F7&*#:,!10<*7!7&0!%7T08!:-!78<!:,0<!

2.!-7&%*$:+7&!7$%#&,!M)*+0!<0$+*8*8S!%#!*8F0,%*S7%0!%)0!<*,$:&,*F0!$#8%0W%!#'!7!10<*7!

#2R0$%U,!&0$0-%*#8J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!)#M!10<*7!-&#<:$%,!-&#<:$0!1:+%*-+0!78<!$)78S*8S!

,.12#+*$!10,,7S0,!%)7%!7:<*08$0,!1:,%!80S#%*7%0!7,!%)0.!$#8,:10!%)0!-&#<:$%B!!?'!

78.%)*8SJ!%)*,!%08<08$.!)7,!2008!*8%08,*'*0<!*8!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!<:0!%#!%)0!#F0&%!

%0$)8*$7+!87%:&0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)01,0+F0,B!!?%!*,!%01-%*8S!%#!'&710!F*<0#!S710,!7,!

7!%0$)8#+#S*$7+!#2R0$%!%)7%!*,!%7T08!:-!78<!:,0<!2.!S710&,J!1:$)!+*T0!7!&0'&*S0&7%#&!

#&!F7$::1!$+0780&J!78<!178.!,0+'`*<08%*'*0<!S710&,!%&07%!F*<0#!S710,!7,!,:$)B!!

A#M0F0&J!<#*8S!,#!/E=%6("9/%)!#2,$:&0,!%)0!$:+%:&7+!,*<0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!78<!&*,T,!

5h4!

1*,,*8S!%)0!<*,$:&,*F0!$#8%0W%!#'!7!S*F08!F*<0#!S710!78<!*%,!7%%08<78%!*<0#+#S*0,!

78<!F7+:0,B!!Z&71*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!%0W%J!)#M0F0&J!2&*8S,!%)0,0!7,-0$%,!#'!7!S710!

%#!%)0!'#&0'&#8%!78<!$78!)0+-!$#&&0$%!%)0!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!%08<08$.!%#!%&07%!F*<0#!

S710,!,#+0+.!7,!7!%0$)8#+#S.!78<!8#%!7,!7!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$%!%)7%!$78!$:+%*F7%0!

-7&%*$:+7&!M7.,!#'!,00*8S!78<!:8<0&,%78<*8S!%)0!M#&+<B!

D0%!*'!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!7!%0W%J!M)7%!T*8<!#'!%0W%!7&0!%)0.g!!"0$7<0,!#'!

&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!&0,07&$)!)7,!<01#8,%&7%0<!%)7%!<*''0&08%!10<*7!&0V:*&0!<*''0&08%!

787+.%*$!%##+,!*'!M0!7&0!%#!0''0$%*F0+.!,%:<.!%)01![9&7M'#&<J!3453\B!!_*<0#!S710,!7&0!

8#%!2##T,J!7'%0&!7++J!M)*$)!*8!%:&8!7&0!8#%!'*+1,!M)*$)!*8!%:&8!7&0!8#%!%0+0F*,*#8!

,0&*0,B!!A#M0F0&J!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!<*''0&!'&#1!#%)0&!10<*7!*,!7!-#*8%!#'!$#8%08%*#8!

71#8S!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&,B!!(0&,#87++.J!?!<#!8#%!)#+<!%)0!F*0M!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!

7&0!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!#%)0&!10<*7!20$7:,0!%)0.!7&0!"#'/3$='"9/B!!>0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!A08&.!N08T*8,U![344h7\!&0,07&$)!#8!$#8F0&S08$0!$:+%:&0!78<!%)0!

&0,:+%78%!2+:&&*8S!#'!%)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!-&#<:$0&,!78<!7:<*08$0,J!)7,!

<01#8,%&7%0<!-0&,:7,*F0+.!%)7%!7++!10<*7!$78!20J!78<!*8<00<!7&0J!*8%0&7$%*F0J!*'!#8+.!

20$7:,0!%)0.!&0V:*&0!7:<*08$0,!%#!*8%0&-&0%!%)01B!!I)7%!17%%0&,J!%)08J!*,!8#%!%)0!

*8%0&7$%*F*%.!#'!10<*7!2:%!2.N!78<!'.&N2$'&>/13//!%)0.!7&0!*8%0&7$%*F0B!!;!:,0':+!

-+7$0!%#!,%7&%!*8!%)*,!<*,$:,,*#8!*,!%)0!M#&T!#'!F*<0#!S710!,$)#+7&!E,-08!;7&,0%)!

[566a\J!M)#!)7,!$7++0<!F*<0#!S710,!X0&S#<*$!%0W%,JY!1078*8S!%)0.!&0V:*&0!7!8#8`

%&*F*7+!71#:8%!#'!M#&T!#8!%)0!-7&%!#'!%)0!-+7.0&!*8!#&<0&!%#!S0%!%)&#:S)!%)01B!!N710,!

@0M178![3443\!0W-78<,!#8!%)*,!$#8$0-%:7+*]7%*#8J!$7:%*#8*8S!:,!%#!8#%!7,,:10!%)7%!

7++!F*<0#!S710,!78<!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!X:8*'#&1+.!0&S#<*$JY!#&!&0V:*&0!%)0!

,710!71#:8%!#'!M#&TB!!"*''0&08%!S08&0,!78<!<*''0&08%!S710,!M*%)*8!7!S08&0!&0V:*&0!

5h5!

<*''0&08%!%.-0,!78<!*8%08,*%*0,!#'!+72#&!%#!S0%!%)&#:S)!%)01B!!EF08!%)0!,710!S710!

17.!<0178<!<*''0&08%!%)*8S,!'&#1!*%,!7:<*08$0!7%!<*''0&08%!-7&%,!#'!%)0!S710J!,:$)!

7,!M)08!*%!,)*'%,!'&#1!78!7$%*#8`*8%08,*F0!,0$%*#8!%)7%!&0V:*&0,!-&0$*,0!$#8%&#+!78<!

'#$:,0<!7%%08%*#8!%#!7!$*8017%*$!$:%,$080!%)7%!&0V:*&0,!7!-+7.0&!%#!,*1-+.!,-0$%7%0!

#&J!7%!1#,%J!-&0,,!7!2:%%#8!%#!-&#S&0,,!%)0!$:%,$080B!!I0!1:,%!7+,#!&010120&!%)7%!

<*''0&08%!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7+,#!<*F0&,*'.!%)0!0&S#<*$!<0178<,!#'!7!S*F08!S710J!

7,!%)0!S&#M*8S!2#<.!#'!+*%0&7%:&0!#8!F*<0#!S710!X,-0$%7%*8SJY!,-07&)07<0<!2.!LBKB!

L7.+#&![345i\J!)7,!<01#8,%&7%0<B!

L)*,!-&0,08%,!7!$)7++08S0!%#!78.!%0W%:7+!787+.,*,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!*,!V:*%0!

:8*V:0!'&#1!%)0!$)7++08S0,!#'!#%)0&!10<*7B!!I)*+0J!%#!20!,:&0J!M0!$78!80F0&!20!

$0&%7*8!%)7%!M0!,)7&0!%)0!,710!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!7!'*+1!#&!2##T!M*%)!#%)0&,!<:0!%#!

%)0!-#+.,01*$!87%:&0!#'!+78S:7S0!78<!$#11:8*$7%*#8J!M*%)!F*<0#!S710,!M0!$78!

80F0&!20!$0&%7*8!%)7%!M0!0F08!,)7&0!%)0!,710!'/E'J!7,!%)0!7$%*#8,!#'!7!-+7.0&!$78!

#'%08!-&#<:$0!<&717%*$7++.!<*''0&08%!87&&7%*F0,B!!L)*,!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%&:0!*8!7!S08&0!

+*T0!%)0!&#+0`-+7.*8S!S710J!M)*$)!%08<!%#!01-)7,*]0!-+7.0&!$)#*$0!78<!7S08$.J!78<!

*%,!#'',)##%!%)0!CCPJ!M)*$)!*8$+:<0,!2#%)!7!+7&S0!71#:8%!#'!$#8%08%!78<!<*''0&08%!

%.-0,!#'!$#8%08%!%)7%!-+7.0&,!$78!0*%)0&!-+7.!%)&#:S)!#&J!7%!%*10,J!*S8#&0B!

/#!)#M!<#0,!#80!787+.]0!7!%0W%!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!M*%)!*%,!M*<0!F7&*0%.!#'!

7$%*F*%*0,!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!08S7S0!*8!78<!$#1-+0W!87&&7%*F0!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!&07<J!M7%$)J!

78<!*8%0&7$%!M*%)g!!C.!*8*%*7+!-+78!M7,!%#!#2,0&F0!-0#-+0!-+7.*8S!%)0!F*<0#!S710!78<!

S7%)0&!<7%7!%#!20!787+.]0<!'&#1!%)0,0!#2,0&F7%*#8,B!!C.!%)*8T*8S!M7,!%)7%J!*8!#&<0&!

%#!S0%!7!,08,0!#'!%)0!F*<0#!S710!%0W%J!?!)7<!%#!'*&,%!S*F0!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!

%#!$#8,%&:$%!%)0!%0W%!%)&#:S)!%)0*&!$)#*$0,B!!I)*+0!%)*,!8#!<#:2%!M#:+<!)7F0!

5h3!

-&#<:$0<!*8%0&0,%*8S!78<!-&#<:$%*F0!&0,:+%,J!7!8:120&!#'!&07,#8,!$#1-0++0<!10!%#!

,00T!#%)0&!M7.,!%#!S7%)0&!%)0!<7%7!?!800<0<!%#!78,M0&!1.!&0,07&$)!V:0,%*#8,B!!P80!

#'!%)0,0!M7,!,*1-+.!%)0!17%0&*7+!$*&$:1,%78$0,!#'!-&#<:$*8S!T8#M+0<S0!M)*+0!

*8)72*%*8S!7!2#<.B!!/*8$0!1.!1#2*+*%.!M7,!+*1*%0<J!%#!#2,0&F0!-0#-+0!-+7.*8S!*8!

-0&,#8!?!M#:+<!)7F0!)7<!%#!'*8<!-0#-+0!F0&.!$+#,0!%#!10!M)#!-+7.!%)0!S710B!!"0,-*%0!

%)0!CCP!20*8S!%)0!1#,%!-#-:+7&!S08&0!$*%0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,!20*8S!#80!#'!%)0!1#,%!-#-:+7&!S710,!*8!%)7%!S08&0J!8#80!#'!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!

M*%)*8!$+#,0!-&#W*1*%.!%#!10!-+7.0<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!I)*+0!?!$#:+<!)7F0!-&#F*<0<!

$#-*0,!#'!%)0!S710!1.,0+'J!,:$)!78!#-%*#8!M7,!8#%!'07,*2+0!<:0!%#!%)0!0W%08,*F0!

'*878$*7+!2:&<08!*%!M#:+<!08%7*+J!'&#1!-:&$)7,*8S!%)0!S710!%#!,:2,*<*]*8S!

,:2,$&*-%*#8!'00,B!

A#M0F0&J!%)0!<#1*878%!'7$%#&!*8'+:08$*8S!1.!10%)#<#+#S*$7+!<0$*,*#8,!M7,!

8#%!%)0!17%0&*7+!$*&$:1,%78$0,!#'!1.!&0,07&$)J!*1-#&%78%!%)#:S)!%)0.!M0&0B!!

?8,%07<J!%)0!,%&#8S0,%!*8'+:08$0!M0&0!%)0!,-0$*'*$!S#7+,!#'!1.!&0,07&$)!-&#R0$%B!!Z#&!

&07,#8,!%)7%!?!,%7%0<!72#F0J!?!M7 ,! *8%0&0,%0<!*8!787+.]*8S!7!F*<0#!S710!%0W%!%#!+07&8!

1#&0!72#:%!)#M!7!S710!M#&T,!%#!,%&:$%:&0!78<!*8'+:08$0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!-+7.0&,J!

&7%)0&!%)78!)#M!-+7.0&,!&0,-#8<0<!%#!%)7% ! ,%&:$%:&0![,*8$0!?!)7<!7+&07<.!S7*80<!

*8,*S)%!*8%#!%)*,!'&#1!1.!,:&F0.,\B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!?!<0$*<0<!*%!M7,!8#%!80$0,,7&.!'#&!

10!%#!#2,0&F0!-+7.0&,!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*8!#&<0&!%#!<&7M!1078*8S':+!

$#8$+:,*#8,!72#:%!%)0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!#'!%)0!S710B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%)#:S)!

7$$#11#<7%*8S!%#!7!M*<0!F7&*0%.!#'!-+7.!,%.+0,!78<!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8,J!<#0,!8#%!

$#1-+0%0+.!,7$&*'*$0!,%&:$%:&0![8#!S710!<#0,\B!!(+7.0&,!7&0!*8%&#<:$0<!%#!%)0*&!

F7&*#:,!#-%*#8,!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)0!S710U,!+*807&!*8%&#<:$%*#8J!M)*$)!'07%:&0,!

5hd!

0W%08,*F0!%:%#&*7+,!#8!F7&*#:,!7,-0$%,!#'!%)0!S710B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!$0&%7*8!'07%:&0,!#'!

%)0!S710!7&0!S7%0<!20)*8<!$0&%7*8!87&&7%*F0!1*+0,%#80,J!78<!,#!7!-+7.0&!1:,%!-+7.!

%)&#:S)!%)0!S710U,!-&*17&.!,%#&.+*80B!!L):,!M)*+0!?!$#:+<!8#%!S:7&78%00!%)7%!?!M#:+<!

17T0!%)0!,710!<0$*,*#8,!7,!#%)0&!-+7.0&,J!?!$#:+<!20!,:''*$*08%+.!$#8'*<08%!%)7%!M0!

M#:+<!20!&0,-#8<*8S!%#!%)0!,710!,0%!#'!7F7*+72+0!#-%*#8,B!!^+%*17%0+.J!?!M7,!1#&0!

*8%0&0,%0<!*8!%)0!#-%*#8,!%)01,0+F0,J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!%)0,0!

#-%*#8,!*8%&#<:$0<!78<!%)0!*<0#+#S*0,!%)0.!7<F#$7%0<J!%)78!%)0!$)#*$0,!-+7.0&,!

17<0B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!-+7.0&!#2,0&F7%*#8,!M#:+<!)7F0!2008!S&7%:*%#:,B!

L)*,!<#0,!8#%!1078J!)#M0F0&J!%)7%!?!<*<!8#%!7%%01-%!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)0!

#-%*#8,!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!$)#,0B!!?8!1.!-+7.*8S!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!$#8,$*#:,+.!$)#,0!

#-%*#8,!%)7%!?!M#:+<!8#%!$)##,0!M0&0!?!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710!,#+0+.!'#&!':8B!!P'%08%*10,J!

)#M0F0&J!%)0!<*''0&08%!#-%*#8,!<*<!8#%!-&#<:$0!&7<*$7++.!<*''0&08%!&0,:+%,B!!;,!?!)7F0!

,7*<!20'#&0J!?!%)*8T!M0!7,!F*<0#!S710!&0,07&$)0&,!%08<!%#!#F0&01-)7,*]0!%)0!

*8%0&7$%*F*%.!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!%)0&02.!<*1*8*,)*8S!%)0!,%&:$%:&*8S!0''0$%,!#'!F*<0#!

S710!%0W%,B!!I)*+0!-0#-+0!$78!17T0!$)#*$0,!*8!7!S710!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%)#,0!

$)#*$0,!7&0!,%*++!+*1*%0<B!!P'%08%*10,J!%)0,0!+*1*%7%*#8,!78<!%)0*&!*<0#+#S*$7+!

,*S8*'*$78$0!7&0!#F0&+##T0<!#&!<*1*8*,)0<!*8!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!S71*8S!7:<*08$0,!%)7%!

'#$:,!-&*17&*+.!#8!)#M!-+7.0&,!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!78<!8#%!#8!%)0!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%!#'!

%)*,!:,7S0B!!L):,!1.!'#$:,!#8!%)0!%0W%:7+!0+0108%,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$78!20!,008!

7,!7!$#8%&*2:%*#8!%#!%)0!#8S#*8S!0''#&%,!%#!$#&&0$%!'#&!%)*,!*127+78$0!%#M7&<!)#M!

-+7.0&,!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!78<!7M7.!'&#1!%)0!1:+%*-+0J!<*F0&,0J!78<!$)78S*8S!

,.12#+*$!10,,7S0,!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!*8F7&*72+.!-&#<:$0!78<!-+7.0&,!1:,%!80S#%*7%0B!!

L)*,!*127+78$0!<#0,!8#%!0W*,%!#8+.!*8!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,J!7,!K*F*8S,%#80![344f\!

5hf!

8#%0,!*8!)0&!,:&F0.!#'!&0$0-%*#8!,%:<*0,!1#&0!2&#7<+.J!2:%!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7--7&08%!

78<!*8!800<!#'!,:--+0108%7%*#8B!

;8<!,#J!'*87++.J!%)*,!2&*8S,!:,!%#!78!0W-+787%*#8!#'!M)7%!?!7$%:7++.!<*<!%#!

S7%)0&!78<!787+.]0!<7%7B!!Z#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!d!1#8%),J!20S*88*8S!*8!N78:7&.!345iJ!?!

M#:+<!+#S!*8!<7*+.!%#!1.!<0,*S87%0<!,0&F0&!#8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!78<!-+7.!%)0!S710!

'#&!7!1*8*1:1!#'!fc!1*8:%0,B!!PF0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!#2,0&F7%*#8!-0&*#<J!?!'#$:,0<!

-&*17&*+.!#8!$#1-+0%*8S!%)0!17*8!,%#&.!V:0,%!+*80!#'!%)0!*8*%*7+!S710J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,J&-&G/$%@&G/;.3#B!!?!7+,#!-7&%*$*-7%0<!*8!#%)0&!V:0,%!+*80,J!1#,%!8#%72+.!F7&*#:,!

$)7&7$%0&!$+7,,!V:0,%!+*80,!78<!$&7'%*8S!$+7,,!V:0,%!+*80,B!!?!7+,#!-7&%*$*-7%0<!*8!#%)0&!

S710!1#<0,J!,-0$*'*$7++.!(+7.0&!F,B!(+7.0&![#&!(F(\!$#8%0,%,J!2:%!&0'&7*80<!'&#1!

08S7S*8S!)07F*+.!*8!%)#,0!1#<0,!,*8$0!%)0.!$#8'+*$%0<!1#,%!)07F*+.!M*%)!1.!#M8!

-0&,#87+!-+7.!,%.+0,B!!I)*+0!?!'#$:,0<!-&*17&*+.!#8!<0F0+#-*8S!#80!$)7&7$%0&!M)#,0!

-&*17&.!&#+0!M7,!)07+*8S!78<!,:--#&%*8S!#%)0&!$)7&7$%0&,J!?!0W-0&*108%0<!M*%)!

#%)0&!$+7,,0,!%#!S7*8!7!,08,0!#'!%)0!-+7.!#-%*#8,!17<0!7F7*+72+0!2.!%)01!7,!M0++!7,!

%)0!87&&7%*F0,!%)7%!%)0.!M0&0!,*%:7%0<!M*%)*8B!!":&*8S!%)*,!%*10!-0&*#<J!?!M#:+<!17T0!

<7*+.!R#:&87+!08%&*0,!<0,$&*2*8S!%)0!0F08%,!%)7%!?! )7 <!-7&%*$*-7%0<!*8J!F7&*#:,!,%#&.!

<0F0+#-108%,J!78<!1.!'00+*8S,!M)*+0!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!)#M!F7&*#:,!

S710!0+0108%,!7''0$%0<!1.!1##<!78<!S080&7+!01#%*#87+!<*,-#,*%*#8B!!L)0,0!8#%0,!

20$710!%)0!27,*,!'#&!1.!787+.,*,J!M)*$)!2&#7<+.!#&S78*]0<!1.!8#%0,!7$$#&<*8S!%#!

%)0!F7&*#:,!S710!1#<0,!78<!%)0*&!&0,-0$%*F0!<0178<,J!%)0!-#,*%*#8!%)7%!-+7.0&,!

M0&0!08$#:&7S0<!%#!7<#-%!*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0,0!<0178<,J!%)0!87&&7%*F0!78<!)#M!

*%!,*%:7%0<!1.!7F7%7&J!78<!1.!#M8!-0&,#87+!&07$%*#8,!%#!%)0,0!%0W%:7+!

<0%0&1*87%*#8,B!!?!M7,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!%)0!&0+7%*F0!*8%08,*%.!#'!%)0!F7&*#:,!

5hc!

S710!&0V:*&0108%,J!,*8$0!#80!#'!%)0!-&*17&.!S#7+,!#'!F*<0#!S710!-+7.!'#&!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!M7,!&0+7W7%*#8!78<!,%&0,,!&0+07,0J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8!#'!%)0!

-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&!M*%)*8!%)0!#F0&7++!,%#&.!#'!%)0!S710!78<!%)0!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!#'!

$)7&7$%0&,!78<!0F08%,!$#8,%&:$%0<!2.!%)0!S710B!!L)*,!7++#M0<!10!%#!*<08%*'.!%)0!

<#1*878%!7%%*%:<0,!78<!*<0#+#S*$7+!7,,:1-%*#8,!#'!%)0!S710!&0S7&<*8S!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!

#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!

?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710J!)#M0F0&J!?!7+,#!M78%0<!%#!,#10)#M!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0!$#1-+0W*%.!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!78<!S7*8!7!,08,0!#'!)#M!#%)0&,!

20.#8<!10!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,B!!;,!#%)0&!F*<0#!S710!&0$0-%*#8!,$)#+7&,!)7F0!8#%0<!

[0BSB!L7.+#&J!344hl!9#8,7+F#J!344al!9&7M'#&<J!3453l!/)7MJ!345f\J!S71*8S!*,!7!

$#1-+0W!-&7$%*$0!%)7%!<#0,!8#%!R:,%!$#8,*,%!#'!7!-0&,#8!*8!'&#8%!#'!7!,$&008!%)7%!0W*,%,!

*8!7!F7$::1B!!P%)0&!-0#-+0!17.!#&!17.!8#%!20!-&0,08%B!!P%)0&!10<*7!78<!

%0$)8#+#S*0,!17.!#&!17.!8#%!20!-&0,08%B!!;!-0&,#8U,!7%%08%*#8!$78!,)*'%J!F#+:8%7&*+.!

78<!*8F#+:8%7&*+.J!20%M008!F7&*#:,!#2R0$%,!#'!'#$:,B!!?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0!*8'#&17+!

#2,0&F7%*#8,!#'!#%)0&!-0#-+0U,!S71*8S!%)7%!?!2#%)!<*<!<:&*8S!%)*,!-&#R0$%!78<!)7F0!

<#80!7%!F7&*#:,!%*10,!%)&#:S)#:%!1.!+*'0J!?!7+,#!#2,0&F0<!78<!&0$#&<0<!%)&00!F*<0#!

S710!-+7.!,0,,*#8,!M*%)!%)&00!<*''0&08%!,0%,!#'!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!<0F0+#-!78!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!)#M!#%)0&!-0#-+0!20.#8<!1.,0+'!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!78<!)#M!%)*,!

$#:+<!*8'+:08$0!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!:,0<!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!P80!

#2,0&F7%*#8!#$$:&&0<!M*%)!7!'017+0!-7&%*$*-78%!*8!)0&!)#10!M)#!+*F0`%M00%0<!)0&!

F*<0#!S710!,0,,*#8!%#!7!S&#:-!#'!'&*08<,!78<!'#++#M0&,!,)0!)7<!7$V:*&0<!#8`78<`

#''+*80J!#80!#2,0&F7%*#8!#$$:&&0<!M*%)!7!'017+0!78<!17+0!$#:-+0!-+7.*8S!7!-#-:+7&!

5hh!

#8+*80!S710!%#S0%)0&!*8!%)0*&!)#10J!78<!%)0!'*87+!#2,0&F7%*#8!M7,!#'!7!,#+*%7&.!

M#178!-+7.*8S!7!,*8S+0!-+7.0&!S710!*8!)0&!)#10B!!!

I)7%!%)0,0!#2,0&F7%*#8,!<01#8,%&7%0<J!78<!M)*$)!1.!787+.,*,!M*++!7%%01-%!

%#!7$$#:8%!'#&J!*,!%)7%!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!<*F0&,0J!$#1-+0W!*8%0&7$%*#8,!20%M008!

F7&*#:,!,#$*7+!7$%#&,J!10<*7!%0$)8#+#S*0,J!78<!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,J!07$)!M*%)!%)0*&!#M8!

<0%0&1*87%*#8,B!!EF08!%)#:S)!*8!%)0!$#1*8S!$)7-%0&,!?!M*++!20!'#$:,*8S!-&*17&*+.!#8!

%)0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!,*8$0!?!20+*0F0!%)*,!*,!78!0+0108%!%)7%!*,!

1#,%!*8!800<!#'!0+72#&7%*#8!*8!%)0!+*%0&7%:&0!#8!F*<0#!S710,!78<!F*<0#!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,J!?!7+,#!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!+#,0!,*S)%!#'!%)0!'7$%!%)7%!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!7&0!

#8+.!#80!-7&%!#'!7!S&07%0&!7,,012+7S0!#'!'#&$0,B!!L):,!M)*+0!?!<#!M78%!%#!S*F0!%)0,0!

%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!%)0*&!<:0J!,*8$0!%)0.!<#!,%&:$%:&0!78<!,)7-0!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,J!?!7+,#!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!7,,0&%!%)7%!%)0!0''0$%,!#'!%)0,0!%0W%:7+!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!

7&0!*8!78.!M7.!S:7&78%00<B!!;,!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.![P&%80&J!344h\!)7,!7$T8#M+0<S0<!

&0-07%0<+.!#F0&!%)0!-7,%!%)*&%.!.07&,J!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!*8<*F*<:7+!-&7$% *$0,!

78<!2&#7<0&!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,!*,!$#1-+*$7%0<B!!?%!*,!%01-%*8S!%#!&0-&0,08%!%)0,0!

F7&*72+0,!7,!,*1-+.!#--#,*%*#87+J!2:%!%)0!%)0#&0%*$7+!-0&,-0$%*F0!%)7%!?!)7F0!2008!

7<F#$7%*8S!'#&!#F0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!-&#R0$%!<0178<,!7!1#&0!$#1-+*$7%0<!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)*,!&0+7%*#8,)*-B!!L):,J!20'#&0!?!<*,$:,,!1.!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!%0W%:7+!

<0%0&1*87%*#8,!#'!#80!%0W%J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!M78%!%#!0,%72+*,)!%)7%!%)0,0!7&0!8#%!

1078%!%#!20!:8<0&,%##<!7,!S:7&78%00,!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!1078*8S,!%)7%!7&0!-7,,*F0+.!

%7T08!:-!2.!78!7:<*08$0B!!?8,%07<J!?!M78%!%#!F*0M!%)01!'&#1!%)0!8#M`$+7,,*$!

-0&,-0$%*F0!#'!/%:7&%!A7++![566h7\!7,!<0%0&1*87%*#8,!*8!%)0!?"3('&"#('$#=/B!!I)*+0!

/%:7&%!A7++U,!1#<0+!#'!$:+%:&7+!$#8,:1-%*#8!)7,!2008!$)7++08S0<!'#&!*%,!&0<:$%*F*%.J!?!

5ha!

,%*++!'*8<!)*,!$#8$0-%!#'!<0%0&1*87%*#8!*8!%)0!'*&,%!*8,%78$0!7!:,0':+!%##+!'#&!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!7:<*08$0,!%)7%!?!)7F0!2#%)!

#2,0&F0<!78<!0W-0&*08$0<B!!A7++U,!$#8$0-%!S&78%,!-#M0&!%#!7!%0W%J!.0,J!2:%!8#%!

72,#+:%0!-#M0&B!!L)0!F*<0#!S710!-&#F*<0,!%)0!17%0&*7+!'#&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#:&!

$*&$:1,%78$0,!78<!*17S*8*8S!#:&!':%:&0,J!2:%!*%!<#0,!8#%!S:7&78%00!)#M!%)#,0!

17%0&*7+,!M*++!20!:,0<B!!?8!%)0!$)7-%0&,!%#!$#10J!?!M78%!%#!<0,$&*20!78<!#''0&!:-!78!

*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!%)0!&0,#:&$0,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!-&#F*<0,!'#&!%)0!-0&,#87+!-&#R0$%,!

#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!

5hi!

9A;(LE>!h!

_?"EP!Q;CE/J!/EKZ`9;>EJ!;@"!LAE!K;=P>`KE?/^>E!9D9KE!

?%!*,!;-&*+!6J!345i!k!1.!a4

!<7.!*8!E#&]07B!!;,!%)0!C*V#U%0

!)07+0&!C7,)7U%#!

=*&M78*J!?!)7F0!$#8V:0&0<!F*$*#:,!207,%,J!,#$*7+*]0<!M*%)!)07<,!#'!,%7%0J!&#:%0<!7!

$#+#8*]*8S!'#&$0J!78<!0F08!'0++0<!7!S#<!#&!%M#B!!L#<7.!20S*8,!78#%)0&!T*8<!#'!

7<F08%:&0J!%)#:S)B!!?!71!27$T!7%!+0F0+!#80J!)7F*8S!<0$*<0<!%#!<0F0+#-!1.!,T*++,!7,!7!

2#%78*,%B!!?!)7F0!,-#T08!M*%)!%)0!S:*+<17,%0&!*8!Q&*<78*7J!#80!#'!%)0!17*8!$*%.`,%7%0,!

*8!%)0!&0S*#8J!78<!&0$0*F0<!%)0!%##+!80$0,,7&.!%#!20S*8!-+.*8S!%)0!2#%78*,%U,!%&7<0!k!7!

$)07-!7W0B!!I*%)!%)0!1#80.!07&80<!'&#1!1.!-&0F*#:,!7<F08%:&0!?!71!72+0!%#!2:.!7!

,)722.!,0%!#'!M#&T!$+#%)0,!k!%)0!#8+.!$+#%)0,!1.!M07T!2#%78*,%!)7,!%)0!,T*++!%#!M07&J!

7--7&08%+.![$+#%)*8S!*8!E#&]07!#'%08!)7F0!+0F0+!&0,%&*$%*#8,!7%%7$)0<!%#!%)01\B!!;W0!

*8!)78<J!?!,0%!#:%!*8%#!%)0!'#&0,%!,:&&#:8<*8S!%)0!$*%.`,%7%0!#'!Q&*<78*7J!*8%08%!#8!

'*8<*8S!07,.!%&00,!%#!+#SB!!>*S)%!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!$*%.!S7 % 0,J!7!-7%$)!#'!'#&0,%!,%78<,J!

M*%)!,0F0&7+!%&00,!S+#M*8SB!!?!+##T!7%!1.!17-!*8!%)0!$#&80&!#'!%)0!,$&008!%#!$#8'*&1B!!

L)0,0!7&0!%)0!%&00,!?!71!+##T*8S!'#&!k!7!,%78<!#'!+0F0+!c!17%:&0!%&00,J!%)0!#8+.!%&00,!

1.!2#%78*,%!$:&&08%+.!)7,!%)0!,T*++!%#!+#SB!!?!7--&#7$)!7!%&00!78<!20S*8!S7%)0&*8S!

&0,#:&$0,B!!;!108:!#-08,!+*,%*8S!M)7%!&0,#:&$0,!?!$78!S7%)0&!'&#1!%)*,!%&00!78<!%)0!

$)78$0,!#'!1.!S7%)0&*8S!7%%01-%!,:$$00<*8S![Z*S:&0!5\B!!/*8$0!*%!*,!1.!'*&,%!%*10!

S7%)0&*8S!%)0,0!-7&%*$:+7&!&0,#:&$0,J!7++!?!,00!7&0!V:0,%*#8!17&T,!M*%)!7!3cx!$)78$0!

#'!20*8S!S7%)0&0<B!!?!,0+0$%!78!*%01!%#!S7%)0&!M*%)!%)0!-&0,,!#'!7!2:%%#8!78<!M7%$)!7,!

1.!$)7&7$%0&!,M*8S,!)*,!7W0B!!?%!+78<,!M*%)!7!M07T!%):8TB!!@#%)*8SB!!?!,0+0$%!%)0!*%01!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!?8!%)0!87&&7%*F0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%)0!C*V#U%0!7&0!7!&7$0!#'!-0#-+0!M*%)!$7%`+*T0!

-).,*$7+!'07%:&0,J!,:$)!7,!-#*8%0<!07&,!78<!%7*+,B!

5h6!

Z*S:&0!5B!!;!,$&008,)#%!'&#1!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*++:,%&7%*8S!%)0!<*,-+7.!:,0<!M)08!

S7%)0&*8S!17%0&*7+,B!

7S7*8J!)#-*8S!%)7%!%)*,!%*10!M*++!,:$$00<B!!;8#%)0&!M07T!%):8TB!!L)0!%)*&<!%*10!?!%&.J!

%)#:S)J!7!,7%*,'.*8S+.!&0,#878%!$)#-!&*8S,!#:%B!!/:$$0,,B!!!

;!'+:&&.!#'!*8'#&17%*#8!2&*0'+.!7--07&,!#8!,$&008!7,!%)0!*%01![7!-*0$0!#'!+7%0W\!

*,!-+7$0<!*8!1.!*8F08%#&.!78<!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!-#*8%,!7&0!7<<0<!%#!1.!$:&&08%!,:--+.B!!

EW-0&*08$0!-#*8%,J!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!7&0!7!V:78%*'*0<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!#'!1.!

<0F0+#-108%!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,![*B0B!#$$:-7%*#8\B!!;'%0&!7!-&0`<0%0&1*80<!71#:8%!

#'!0W-0&*08$0!*,!7$$&:0<J!1.!+0F0+!M*++!*8$&07,0!2.!#80J!&7*,*8S!1.!,%7%*,%*$7+!

7%%&*2:%0,J!#&!V:78%*'*0<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!#'!$0&%7*8!%&7*%,![+*T0!1.!,%&08S%)!78<!

-0&$0-%*#8\!%)7%!&#:S)+.!<0%0&1*80!%)0!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!,T*++,B!!K0F0+!

S7*8,!17.!7+,#!S&78%!.#:&!$)7&7$%0&!7$$0,,!%#!80M!7$%*#8,J!M)*$)!7&0!-7&%*$:+7&!

,T*++,!,-0$*'*$!%#!7!$+7,,!%)7%!7++#M ! 7!$)7&7$%0&!%#!-0&'#&1!$0&%7*8!':8$%*#8,B!!;'%0&!

'#:&!1#&0!,:$$0,,':+!M)7$T,!7%!F7&*#:,!%&00,J!1.!$)7&7$%0&!S7*8,!08#:S)!-#*8%,!%#!

5a4!

+0F0+!:-B!!;!'+:&&.!#'!7$%*F*%.!#$$:&,!7S7*8!7,!1.!$)7&7$%0&!'+7,)0,!M*%)!+*S)%J!%)0!

%&7<*%*#87+!!"#$%&!$#'$()!'78'7&0!-+7.,J!78<!7!+7&S0!S#+<!$7-%*#8!-&#$+7*1*8S!XK0F0+!

^-Y!7--07&,!#8!%)0!,$&008!M*%)!7!,17++0&!8#%*'*$7%*#8!%0++*8S!10!M)7%!,T*++!?UF0!

+07&80<![X;:%#`L&*78S:+7%0Y\B!!L)0!$0+02&7%*#8!<*0,!<#M8!7'%0&!72#:%!%08!,0$#8<,!

78<!?!&0%:&8!%#!$)#--*8S!<#M8!%&00,J!S7%)0&*8S!&0,#:&$0,J!78<!07&8*8S!0W-0&*08$0!

-#*8%,B!!;'%0&!1.!$)7&7$%0&!)7,!S7*80<!%)&00!1#&0!+0F0+,J!7!8#%*'*$7%*#8!7--07&,!

%0++*8S!10!%)7%!%)0!80W%!V:0,%!*8!%)0!2#%78*,%!$+7,,U,!,%#&.!*,!8#M!7F7*+72+0B!!?!&0%:&8!

%#!%)0!)07<!#'!%)0!2#%78*,%U,!S:*+<!78<!71!%7,T0<!M*%)!S7%)0&*8S!7!,0%!8:120&!#'!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!*%01B!!?!&0%:&8!%#!%)0!'#&0,%!78<!&0,:10!$)#--*8SB!

?!#''0&!%)*,!F*S80%%0!7,!78!*8%&#<:$%*#8!%#!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!'#&!

,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!17<0!7F7*+72+0!%#!-+7.0&,!2.!F*<0#!

S710!%0W%,B!!;'%0&!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!'#&!7!$#8,*<0&72+0!+08S%)!#'!%*10J!?!

<0$*<0<!%#!'#$:,!#8!<0F0+#-*8S!1.!$&7'%*8S!$+7,,0,J!#,%08,*2+.!*8!%)0!)#-0!#'!20*8S!

72+0!%#!7$V:*&0!%)0!20,%![#&!7%!+07,%!20%%0&\!0V:*-108%!78<!%):,!-7&%*$*-7%0!1#&0!

0''0$%*F0+.!*8!+7%0&!,%#&.!$#8%08%B!!?!7--&#7$)0<!%)0!$&7'%*8S!$+7,,0,!M*%)!7!<0S&00!#'!

712*F7+08$0!,*8$0!%)0.!&0V:*&0!78!0W%08,*F0!71#:8%!#'!M)7%!*,!T8#M8!F0&87$:+7&+.!

7,!XS&*8<*8SJY!#&!08S7S*8S!*8!7!&0-0%*%*F0!,0&*0,!#'!%7,T,!*8!#&<0&!%#!7$)*0F0!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!*8`S710!S#7+J!:,:7++.!S7*8*8S!+0F0+,!#&!7$V:*&*8S!+##%B!!Q&*8<*8S!*,!807&+.!

:2*V:*%#:,!*8!CCP,!78<!*,!#'%08!%&07%0<!7,!7!$)#&0J!M*%)!178.!*8!%)0!S71*8S!

$#11:8*%.!201#78*8S!*%,!80$0,,*%.!#&!-&#$+7*1*8S!*%!%#!20!27<!S710!<0,*S8B!!;!

<*$%*#87&.`,%.+0!08%&.!#8!S&*8<*8S!'#&!0/=2.F/>"$J!'#&!0W71-+0J!,%7%0,!%)7%!M)*+0!

S&*8<*8S!17.!7--07&!%#!&:8!$#:8%0&!%#!S##<!S710!<0,*S8J!*%!*,!7$%:7++.!80$0,,7&.!'#&!

-&#F*<*8S!-+7.0&,!M*%)!7!,08,0!#'!7$)*0F0108%!78<!%#!$&07%0!7!1#&0!0F08!-+7.*8S!

5a5!

'*0+<!'#&!-+7.0&,!2.!-&#F*<*8S!+0,,!,T*++0<!-+7.0&,!78!07,*0&!M7.!%#!-&#S&0,,!%)&#:S)!

%)0!S710!78<!$7%$)!:-!M*%)!1#&0!,T*++0<!-+7.0&,B!!C078M)*+0J!#F0&!#8!%)0!08%):,*7,%!

80M,!,*%0!GHK!$#J!M&*%0&!L*87!P+7)![345i\!$&*%*$*]0,!%)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!71#:8%!#'!

,*<0!V:0,%,!78<!1*8#&!#2R0$%*F0,!S710!-&#<:$0&,!01-+#.!7,!-7<<*8S!M)#,0!#8+.!

-:&-#,0!*,!%#!7&%*'*$*7++.!0W%08<!%)0!71#:8%!#'!%*10!7!-+7.0&!1:,%!*8F0,%!*8!7!S710!%#!

$#1-+0%0!*%B!

;,!?!,7*<J!%)#:S)J!?!7--&#7$)0<!%)0!$&7'%*8S!$+7,,0,!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!78<!

%)0*&!$#8$#1*%78%!S&*8<*8S!M*%)!712*F7+08$0J!8#%!<&07<!#&!'&:,%&7%*#8B!!D0,J!

S&*8<*8S!$78!20!2#&*8SB!!=:%!*%!$78!7+,#!20!&0+7W*8SB!!;,!?!$)#--0<!<#M8!%&00!7'%0&!

%&00!7'%0&!%&00J!?!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!08%0&!*8%#!78!7+1#,%!10<*%7%*F0!,%7%0!%)7%!<*<!8#%!

&0V:*&0!7!S&07%!71#:8%!#'!7%%08%*#8!#&!$#S8*%*F0!M#&TB!!L)0!07,0!78<!&0-0%*%*F080,,!

#'!%)0!<0178<,!#'!%)0!$&7'%*8S!$+7,,0,!M0&0!-&0$*,0+.!%)0!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710!%)7%!?!

7$%*F0+.!,#:S)%!#:%!7%!%*10,B!!;8<!?!71!8#%!7+#80!*8!'00+*8S!%)*,!M7.B!!C.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

&#:%*80+.!8#%0<!%)*,!0W-0&*08$0!7,!#80!#'!%)0! &07 ,#8,!M).!%)0.!,00T!#:%!F*<0#!

S710,J!7,!#--#,0<!%#!#%)0&!10<*7B!!9*8<.J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!,7*<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!X17T0!

10!)7--.!78<!%)0.!)0+-!M*%)!1.!,%&0,,!+0F0+,!20$7:,0!*%!S*F0,!10!,#10%)*8S!%#!

'#$:,!#8!'#&!7!M)*+0B!?!)7F0!F0&.!27<!78W*0%.!2:%!%)*,!)0+-,!10!S0%!7M7.!'&#1!7++!%)0!

&07+!78<!17<0!:-!-&#2+01,!1.!2&7*8!%&*0,!%#!'#$:,!#8!$#8,%78%+.BY!!"7F*<J!7,!M0++J!

8#%0<!%)7%!7!&0$08%!S710!#'!8$%%&.?&B6')!X*8F#+F0<!+*%%+0!%)*8T*8S![?!$#:+<!0,$7-0!'&#1!

%)0!%)*8T*8S!%)7%!)#10M#&T!7+M7.,!-&0,08%0<\B!?8!$#8$+:,*#8J!*%!+0%!10!20!7!

F0S0%72+0!M)#!-+7.0<!#''!#'!1:,$+0!&0'+0W0,!'#&!7!M)*+0BY!

?!M78%!%#!:,0!%)*,!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!0+0108%,!#'!S710!<0,*S8!7,!7!

R:1-*8S!#''!-#*8%!'#&!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!'#&!,0+'`$7&0J!)#M!

5a3!

S710,!7%%01-%!%#!,%&:$%:&0!78<!$#8%&#+!%)0,0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!%)0!

-#,,*2*+*%*0,!%)7%!7&0!#-080<!:-!7,!-+7.0&,!$#8'&#8%J!,:21*%!%#J!&0`M#&TJ!78<!

&0$#8%0W%:7+*]0!%)0,0!S710!0+0108%,B!!C.!<*,$:,,*#8!*,!%):,!-#,*%*#80<!,#10M)7%!

-&0$7&*#:,+.!20%M008!%)0!/$.++7!78<!9)7&.2<*,!#'!%M#!$#1-0%*8S!<*,$#:&,0,!#'!,0+'`

$7&0!78<!*%,!F7+:0!M*%)*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$78!,#$*0%.B!!Z#&!%)0!,7T0!#'!,*1-+*$*%.!

78<!$+7&*%.J!?!M*++!+720+!#80!-#,*%*#8!X$#8,0&F7%*F0JY!<:0!%#!*%,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!%)0!

;10&*$78!-#+*%*$7+!&*S)%J!78<!%)0!#%)0&!X-&#S&0,,*F0JY!M)*$)!*,!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!%)0!

;10&*$78!-#+*%*$7+!+0'%B!!;,!?!<01#8,%&7%0<!07&+*0&J!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

$)7&7$%0&*]0<!78<!,-#T0!72#:%!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!M0&0!<00-+.!*8'#&10<!2.!M)7%!

I08<.!=&#M8![344h\!)7,!$7++0<!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1B!!I*%)!%)0!

S&#M*8S!$08%&7+*]7%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&![A7&<%!s!@0S&*J!344f\!*8!-#,%`Z#&<*,%!

0$#8#1*$!,%&:$%:&0,J!%)*8S,!+*T0!7%%08%*#8J!&7%*#87+*%.J!78<!01#%*#87+!$7&0!)7F0!

20$#10!%)0!&7M!17%0&*7+,!800<0<!'#&!$7-*%7+*,%!7$$:1:+7%*#8B!!;,!,:$)J!10%)#<,!78<!

-&7$%*$0,!7&0!800<0<!'#&!%)0!&080M7+!#'!%)0,0!&0,#:&$0,J!78<!,#!$7- *% 7+![7,!

178*'0,%0<!*8!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!-#+*$*0,!#'!$#&-#&7%*#8,\!)7,!20S:8!%#!7:%)#&*]0!78<!

-&#1#%0!7!F7&*0%.!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!1*8<':+80,,J!'#&!%)*,!-:&-#,0!

[O*8871#8J!345h\B!!_*<0#!S710,!)7F0!20$#10!*8$&07,*8S+.!*1-#&%78%!%#!%)0!

$7-*%7+*,%!,:2,:1-%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!7,!$&*%*$,!*8!2#%)!%)0!7$7<01*$!78<!

17*8,%&071!&07+1,!)7F0!%#:%0<!%)0!72*+*%.!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%#!<0F0+#-!,T*++,!F7+:72+0!

%#!78!*117%0&*7+!0$#8#1.J!+*T0!-7%%0&8!&0$#S8*%*#8J!-&#2+01!,#+F*8SJ!78<!<0$*,*#8!

17T*8S![=0$T!s!I7<0J!344fl!I7&TJ!344al!97++0R7J!3454l!Q00J!345f\B!!D00![344h\!

17T0,!%)*,!0+*,*#8!20%M008!+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0!0W-+*$*%J!8#%*8S!%)7%!X0F0&.!<7.J!178.!

#'!%)01!u*B0B!CCP!-+7.0&,v!S#!%#!M#&T!78<!-0&'#&1!78!7,,#&%108%!#'!$+0&*$7+!%7,T,J!

5ad!

+#S*,%*$7+!-+788*8S!78<!1787S0108%!*8!%)0*&!#''*$0,J!%)08!%)0.!$#10!)#10!78<!<#!

%)#,0!F0&.!,710!%)*8S,!*8!CCP>(Q,Y![-B!h6\B!

A#M0F0&J!<0,-*%0!%)0*&!7--7&08%!:%*+*%.J! F*<0#!S710,!7&0!7+ ,#!'&0V:08 %+.!

-#,*%*#80<!7,!7!%)&07%!%#!%)0!,1##%)!#-0&7%*#8!#'!$7-*%7+!7$$:1:+7%*#8B!!;,!".0&`

I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&![3446\!)7F0!7&S:0<J!M)*+0!$7-*%7+*,1!*,!F0&.!S##<!7%!

,:2,:1*8S!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!*<0#+#S*0,!%)7%!*8*%*7++.!7--07&!%#!%)&07%08!*%J!%)*,!

,:2,:1-%*#8!*,!80F0&!%#%7+B!!/-0$*'*$7++.!S&#:8<*8S!%)*,!#2,0&F7%*#8!*8!%)0!,%&:$%:&0!

#'!%)0!S71*8S!*8<:,%&.J!".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&!*8,*,%!%)7%!M)*+0!%)0!

-#,,*2*+*%*0,!78<!-#%08%*7+*%*0,!#'!<*S*%7+!M#&+<,!78<!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!'&0V:08%+.!

'00<!27$T!*8%#!78<!&0*8'#&$0!%)0!M#&T*8S,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!*1-0&*7+*,1J!%)*,!

'00<27$T!+##-!*,!8#%!S:7&78%00<B!!L)7%!*,J!S710-+7.!$78!78<J!7,!".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!

<0!(0:%0&!<01#8,%&7%0J!<#0,!+*8T!%#!&7<*$7+!,#$*7+!7$%*#8![-B!WWW***\B!!L)0!,710!$#:+<!

20!,7*<!#'!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!,0+'`$7&0B!!!!

L)0!$#8,0&F7%*F0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!7%%01-%,!%#!1787S0!%)*,!-&0$7&*#:,!

-#,*%*#8J!,*1:+%780#:,+.!08$#:&7S*8S!%)0!7,-0$%,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!7&0!

$#8<:$*F0!%#!%)0!,1##%)!':8$%*#8*8S!#'!$7-*%7+!7$$:1:+7%*#8!78<!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

-&#-0&!80#+*20&7+!,:2R0$%,!M)*+0!7%%01-%*8S!%#!1*%*S7%0!%)0!0W$0,,0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!%)7%!

%)&07%08!%#!:8<0&1*80!*%B!!Z#&!F*<0#!S710,J!#80!M7.!%)*,!*,!7$$#1-+*,)0<!*,!%)&#:S)!

%)0!-7%)#+#S*]7%*#8!#'!0W$0,,*F0!F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8SJ!M)*$)!$78!20!,008!1#,%!

#2F*#:,+.!*8!%)0!-#-:+7&*]7%*#8!#'!%)0!*<07!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!7<<*$%*8S!

#&J!0F08!M#&,0J!$78!-&#<:$0!F*#+08%J!<0,%&:$%*F0!,:2R0$%,![,00!L:&T+0J!3455l!;+%0&J!

345a\B!!I)*+0!%)*,!%7$%*$!*,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!#&*S*87+J!,*8$0! 7 ,!=:%,$)![344i\!)7,!

<01#8,%&7%0<!010&S*8S!10<*7!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!7--&#7$)0<!M*%)!,:,-*$*#8J!%)0!

5af!

'&71*8S!#'!F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8S!7,!7!-:2+*$!)07+%)!78<!,7'0%.!$#8$0&8!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

*8%08,0J!-&#1-%0<!2.!%)0![&0+7%*F0+.\!&0$08%!-)08#108#8!#'!17,,!,$)##+!,)##%*8S,!

78<!%)0!,:2,0V:08%!0''#&%,!2.!$#8,0&F7%*F0!-#+*$.!17T0&,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!%)0!

@>;!%#!,$7-0S#7%!%)0!F*<0#!S710!*8<:,%&.B!!L)*,!712*F7+08$0!%#M7&<,!:,*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!'#&!%)0!-:&-#,0,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!*8!%:&8J!'&0V:08%+.!010&S0<!71#8S!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!%)0.!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!,0+'`$7&0B!!!

L)*,!$78!20!,008!*8!,%7%0108%,!+*T0!#80!17<0!2.!@*$#+0J!M)#!V:*$T+.!1#F0<!

20%M008!7--&0$*7%*F0!78<!$&*%*$7+!1##<,!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-!)0&!

0,$7-0G!!!!

E,$7-*8S!78<!&0+*0F*8S!,%&0,,!7&0!*8%0&&0+7%0<!'#&!10B!?!<*<!%)*,!.0,%0&<7.!

M)*+0!-+7.*8S!C7&*#!>:8!'#&!%)0!,710!&07,#8,B!?%w,!7!':8!S710B!?!M7,!,%&0,,0<!

#:%!72#:%!,$)##+M#&T!78<!,#10!+710!<:<0B!L)0!S710!)0+-0<!#8+.!'#&!%)0!

%*10!?!-+7.0<!*%B!=:%!7'%0&M7&<,J!?!&07+*]0<!?!M7,%0<!%*10!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710!

M)08!?!$#:+<!)7F0!<#80!M#&T!#&!S#80!%#!20<B!

?'!%)0!$#8,0&F7%*F0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!&0+:$%78%+.!012&7$0,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!

,0+'`$7&0J!%)0!10&0!'7$%!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!$78!20!:,0<!7,!7!%##+!'#&!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

$7-*%7+!78<!<#1*87%*#8!*,!08#:S)!'#&!%)#,0!#8!%)0!+0'%!%#!F*0M!,0+'`$7&0!M*%)!

,:,-*$*#8B!!L)*,!*,!M)7%!?!$7++!%)0!-&#S&0,,*F0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!M)*$)!

7--&#7$)0,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!%)&#:S)!7!+08,0!,)7-0<!2.!-7&78#*7B!!;,!

O*8871#8![345h\!8#%0,J!$&*%*$,!#8!%)0!+0'%!'&0V:08%+.!<*,1*,,!,0+'`$7&0!7,!.0%!

78#%)0&!%##+!#'!80#+*20&7+!*<0#+#S.!#&!2*#-#+*%*$7+!$#8%&#+!,*8$0!%)0!+#S*$!#'!-&7$%*$0,!

'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!*8!%)0!,0&F*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%J!X+*T0!

'+0W*2*+*%.J!,0+'`1787S0108%J!78<!,%&0%$)*8S!$#:+<!8#%!20!1#&0!-0&'0$%!'#&!78!0&7!#'!

$7-*%7+*,1!T8#M8!'#&!-&0$7&*%.!78<!08%&0-&080:&*7+*,1Y![-B!565`563\B!!L)*,!$78!20!

0W%08<0<!%#!787+.,0,!#'!%)0!&#+0!#'!%)0!10<*7!*8!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!1#108%J!7,!

5ac!

$0&%7*8!10<*7!S08&0,!)7F0!2008!)7&,)+.!$&*%*V:0<!'#&!<#*8S!%)0!*<0#+#S*$7+!M#&T!#'!

%)0!F7&*#:,!<#1*878%!+7$:870!#'!-#M0&!*8!7!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!%)0!

-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1J!,:$)!7,!%)0!,%7%0!78<!%)0!+72#&!0$#8#1.!

[P:0++0%%0J!344f\B!!/08<0&![3453\J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0!&07+*%.!%0+0F*,*#8!

S08&0!7+*S8,!M0++!M*%)!80#+*20&7+*,1!20$7:,0!*%!X<0178<,!%)7%!,:2R0$%,!%7T0!

&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!%)0!,0+'J!%#+0&7%0!&*,TJ!78<!+##T!%#!10<*7%0<!0W-0&%,!'#&!S:*<78$0!

#8!87F*S7%*8S!1#<0&8!+*'0Y![/08<0&J!3453l!-B!i\B!!_*<0#!S710,J!+*T0M*,0J!7&0!

F:+80&72+0!%#!%)*,!$&*%*V:0B!!/$)#+7&,!,:$)!7,!C*++*8S%#8![3446J!345f\J!9)0,,![3455\J!

=70&S![3446J!345f\J!78<!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7![345a\!)7F0!8#%0<!)#M!F*<0#!

S710,!78<!%)0!-7&7%0W%:7+!*8<:,%&*0,!%)7%!,:--#&%!%)01J!8#%72+.!%)0!7<F0&%*,*8S!

*8<:,%&.J!:,0!2#%)!%)0*&!87&&7%*F0!78<!+:<*$!0+0108%,!%#!-&#1#%0!7!F0&,*#8!#'!

,:2R0$%*F*%.!%)7%!*,!710872+0!%#!80#+*20&7+*,1B!!

A#M0F0&J!7!S&#M*8S!2#<.!#'!+*%0&7%:&0!#8! 2#%)!,0+'`$7&0!78<!F*<0#!S710,!

)7F0!7%%01-%0<!%#!$)7&%!7!<*''0&08%!-7%)!%)&#:S)!%)0,0!$#1-0%*8S!<*,$#:&,0,!#'!,0+'`

$7&0J!#80!%)7%!,*1:+%780#:,+.!7$T8#M+0<S0,!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!&0$&:*%0<!2.!

#--&0,,*F0!-#M0&!,%&:$%:&0,J!+*T0!%)0!,%7%0!78<!+72#&!0$#8#1.J!%#!-0&'#&1!F7&*#:,!

%7,T,!M)*+0!7+,#!&0':,*8S!%#!,:&&08<0&!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!%#!%)0,0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!

<#1*87%*#8B!!O*8871#8![345h\!0W01-+*'*0,!%)*,!-#,*%*#8J!-0&,:7,*F0+.!7&S:*8S!

7S7*8,%!%)0!<*,1*,,7+!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!*%,!7,,#$*7%0<!-&7$%*$0,!,*1-+.!20$7:,0!%)0.!

$78!20!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!$7-*%7+B!!Z#++#M*8S!/0<SM*$TU,![344d\!$7++!%#!<*,08%78S+0!%)0!

7M7&080,,!#'!+7&S0J!,.,%01*$!'#&1,!#'!#--&0,,*#8!'&#1!7!$&*%*$7+!<0178<!%#!F*0M!%)0!

$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)0,0!,.,%01,!*8!7!,-0$*'*$J!:,:7++.!-0,,*1*,%*$!M7.J!O*8871#8!

*8,*,%,!%)7%!,*1-+.!20$7:,0!,0+'`$7&0!78<!*%,!&0+7%0<!-&7$%*$0,!=$#!20!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!

5ah!

$7-*%7+*,1J!*%!<#0,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!'#++#M!%)7%!%)0.!N"%%!20B!!/:$)!7!%)0#&0%*$7+!1#F0!

7++#M,!%)0!$&*%*$!%#J!7,!/0<SM*$T![344d\!M&*%0,J!X:8-7$T!%)0!+#$7+J!$#8%*8S08%!

&0+7%*#8,!20%M008!78.!S*F08!-*0$0!#'!T8#M+0<S0!78<!*%,!87&&7%*F0o0-*,%01#+#S*$7+!

08%7*+108%,!'#&!%)0!,00T0&J!T8#M0&J!#&!%0++0&Y![-B!53f\B!!/-0$*'*$7++.!&0'0&&*8S!%#!,0+'`

$7&0J!O*8871#8!%:&8,!%#!%)0!M#&T!#'!C*$)0+!Z#:$7:+%J!,-0$*'*$7++.!)*,!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!

X$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'JY!%#!'*8<!78!7+%0&87%*F0!0-*,%01#+#S*$7+!,%78$0!%#M7&<,!,0+'`$7&0!%)7%!

7++#M,!'#&!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!7%%08%*#8!%#!78<!&0-7*&!#'!%)0!,0+'!17.!20!X7!-#&%7+!*8%#!

%)0!-+07,:&0J!$#++0$%*F0!08R#.108%J!78<!-#+*%*$7+!$)78S0!,#!<0,*&0<!2.!$&*%*$,Y![-B!

56f\B!!!

?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!%)0!'00<27$T!+##-!20%M008!+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0!,#!<0,*&0<!2.!

$7-*%7+!*,!8#%!S:7&78%00<!*8!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!2:%!*,!<0-08<08%!#8!%)0!+#$7+!

78<!$#8%*8S08%!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!20%M008!7!-0&,#8!78<!%)0!F7&*#:,!-&7$%*$0,!:,0<!2.!

%)7%!-0&,#8!%#!:8<0&,%78<!78<!$7&0!'#&!%)01,0+F0,B!!L)*,!%)0#&0%*$7+!-#,*%*#8!'#&1,!

%)0!'#:8<7%*#8!#'!1.!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!%0W%!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!O8#M*8S!%)7%!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!'&0V:08%+.!:,0<!CCP,J!&0-&0,08%0<!)0&0!2.!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,4&%#!$7&0!

'#&!%)01,0+F0,J!&080M!%)01,0+F0,J!78<!&0-7*&!%)0!<717S0,!M&#:S)%!2.!

&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!+72#&J!78<!F7&*#:,!1##<,!78<!*++80,,0,![*B0B!%"9"#1\J!?!-#,0<!%)0!

'#++#M*8S!V:0,%*#8,!%#!%)0!%0W%G!

5B A#M!<#0,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&M#&T!%#!&0-7*&!%)0!-,.$)*$!<717S0!#'!

+*F*8S!*8'+*$%0<!:-#8!-7&%*$*-78%,g!

3B A#M!<#0,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!M#&T!%#!&0`&#:%0!-+7.0&,!27$T!*8%#!+72#&!

#8$0!%)0.!7&0!&0-7*&0<g!

dB I)7%!7F08:0,!#'!0,$7-0!7&0!7''#&<0<!%#!-+7.0&,!78<!)#M!$78!%)0.!20!

7$%*F7%0<g!

5aa!

Escaping!into!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

! L#!20S*8J!+0%!:,!$#8,*<0&!%)0!&#+0!#'!0,$7-*,1!*8!-+7.*8S!CCP,B!!E,$7-*,1!

M7,!7!-#M0&':+!0W-+787%#&.!<0F*$0!'#&!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!78<!M7,!#'%08!<0-+#.0<!

M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!%)0*&!1#%*F7%*#8,!'#&!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!9#8%&7&.!%#!-#-:+7&!

#-*8*#8J!78<!0F08!%)0!#-*8*#8,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!<#!8#%!F*0M!F*<0#!S710,!7,!

*8)0&08%+.!0,$7-*,%!8#&!<#!?!F*0M!0,$7-*,1!7,!78!7F#*<78$0!#'!%)0!&07+J!78<!%):,!

M#&%).!#'!$#8<0187%*#8B!!;,!97++0R7![3454\!)7,!<01#8,%&7%0<J!%)0,0!-0&,-0$%*F0,!

7&0!:8<0&-*880<!2.!%M#!-&#2+017%*$!2*87&*0,!k!%)0!F*&%:7+!M#&+<o-).,*$7+!M#&+<!

2*87&.!78<!%)0!7&%*'*$*7+o&07+!2*87&.J!1#,%!$#11#8+.!0W-&0,,0<!*8!S710!,%:<*0,!7,!

%)0!X17S*$!$*&$+0Y!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!97++0R7J!27,0<!#8!<0$7<0,!#'!0%)8#S&7-)*$!78<!

%)0#&0%*$7+!M#&T!#8!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!8#%0,!%)7%!%)0!07,.!,0-7&7%*#8!20%M008!S710!

78<!8#8S710!%)7%!%)0,0!2*87&*0,!,:SS0,%!<#0,!8#%!)#+<!:-!:8<0&!,$&:%*8.B!!Q710,J!*8!

#%)0&!M#&<,J!7&0!<00-+.!*12&*$7%0<!*8!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!78<!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,!*8!

M)*$)!%)0.!7&0!-+7.0<!78<!*8!%:&8!,)7-0!78<!7&0!,)7-0<!2.!'00<27$T!+##-,!20%M008!

%)0,0!F7&*#:,!'#&$0,B!!L)*,!V:7+*%.!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,J!*8!'7$%J!*,!M)7%!%)0!

$#8,0&F7%*F0!<*,$#:&,0!#'!,0+'`$7&0!&0$#S8*]0,!78<!,00T,!%#!0W-+#*%B!!^+%*17%0+.J!

97++0R7!$#8%08<,!%)7%!0,$7-*,1!*,!8#%!78!*8)0&08%!-7&%!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0J!2:%!

%)0!&0,:+%!#'!X%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!V:7+*%*0,!#'!%)0!,-0$*'*$7++.!,*%:7%0<!08S7S0108%Y![-B!

ddi\B!

! ?'!0,$7-*,1!*,!-&#<:$0<!2.!7!X,-0$*'*$7++.!,*%:7%0<!08S7S0108%JY!%)08!M)7%!

7&0!%)0!F7&*#:,!'#&$0,!%)7%!$78!-&#<:$0!%)*,!0W-0&*08$0g!!I0!)7F0!7+&07<.!+##T0<!7%!

%)*,!V:0,%*#8!'&#1!%)0!-+7.0&!,*<0!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!78<!)7F0!8#%0<!,0F0&7+!

'7$%#&,!%)7%!:&S0!-0#-+0!%#!,00T!&0+*0'!78<!&080M7+!*8!F*<0#!S710,J!1#,%!

5ai!

-&0<#1*878%+.!%)0!0W)7:,%*8S!0''0$%,!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!!@#M!M0!M*++!%:&8!%#!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!%#!)0+-!<0F0+#-!78!7$$#:8%!#'!%)0!'#&1,!#'!0,$7-0J!&0+*0'J!78<!&080M7+!

%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!-&#F*<0!%#!-+7.0&,B!!A0&0!7S7*8!97++0R7U,![3454\!M#&T!#8!

0,$7-*,1!78<!F*<0#!S710,!-&#F*<0,!:,0':+!*8,*S)%,!*8%#!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-!

-&#<:$0!0,$7-*,%!0W-0&*08$0,B!!Z:8<7108%7+!%#!%)0*&!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!0,$7-*,1!78<!

F*<0#!S710,!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!S710,!$78!08S7S0!78<!$7-%:&0!%)0!7%%08%*#8!#'!-+7.0&,!

*8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,B!!L)0,0!*8$+:<0!,%*1:+7%*8S!$#S8*%*F0!7$%*F*%*0,!+*T0!-7%%0&8!

,00T*8SJ!-&#2+01!,#+F*8SJ!78<!<0$*,*#8!17T*8S!7,!M0++!7,!-&#F*<*8S!7--07+*8S!

,08,#&.!78<!70,%)0%*$!0W-0&*08$0,B!

! ?%!*,!%)*,!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,!%#!20!08S7S0<!%)7%!*,!-0&)7-,!$08%&7+!%#!M).!F*<0#!

S710,!7&0!,#!F7+:72+0!7,!%##+,!#'!,0+'`$7&0B!!;,!L7.+#&![344h\!#2,0&F0<!*8!)0&!

0%)8#S&7-).!#'!%)0!CCP!I9/3R6/('![5666\J!CCP,!7''#&<!-+7.0&,!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!

<.871*$7++.!,0%!78<!-:&,:0!-7&%*$:+7&!S#7+,!2.!-&#F*<*8S!7!M*<0!F7&*0%.!#'!$#1-+0W!

,.,%01,!78<!%7,T,!%#!08S7S0!M*%)B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*,!8#!<*''0&08%J!7++#M*8S!-+7.0&,!

%#!'#&1!+#$7+!#&S78*]7%*#8,!'#&!,-0$*'*$!-:&-#,0,J!0W-+#&0!<*''0&08%!08F*&#8108%,J!

$7,:7++.!,#$*7+*]0!M*%)!'&*08<,J!<0F0+#-!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&U,!0V:*-108%!78<!,T*++,J!

-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!F7&*#:,!$#1-0%*%*#8,!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!#&!%)0!$#1-:%0&!*%,0+'J!78<!

-0&'0$%!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&U,!7--07&78$0J!M7&<&#20J!78<!-0&,#87+!+*F*8S!,-7$0![%#!8710!

7!'0M!-#%08%*7+!S#7+,\B!!L)0!F7&*0%.!#'!$#1-+0W!0W-0&*08$0,!%)7%!CCP,!+*T0!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!7''#&<!%#!%)0*&!-+7.0&,!17T0,!%)0!S08&0!-7&%*$:+7&+.!7--07+*8S!%#!-+7.0&,!

8#%!#8+.!20$7:,0!-+7.0&,!)7F0!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!%7*+#&!%)0*&!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!

800<,!78<!1##<,J!2:%!7+,#!20$7:,0!%)0!-+7.0&!$78!,00T!<*''0&08%!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)*8!

%)0!,710!S710!7,!%)0*&!800<,!78<!<0,*&0,!,)*'%B!!E1*+.!<0,$&*20,!)#M!#80!CCPJ!<'$3&

5a6!

A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=![E+0$%&#8*$!;&%,J!3454l!722&0F*7%0<!7,!<A0TG\J!7''#&<,!)0&!

%)*,!#--#&%:8*%.G!

L)0!0,$7-*,1!'7$%#&!78<!%)0!,#$*7+!'7$%#&!<0'*8*%0+.!)0+-J!78<!*8!S710,!+*T0!

/ILP>J!.#:!$78!07,*+.!,0%!.#:&!#M8!-7$0!#'!-+7.J!#-%*8S!%#!R:,%!)78S!27$T!

78<!$&7'%!*'!.#:!<#8w%!'00+!+*T0!%)&#M*8S!.#:&,0+'!*8%#!0-*$!V:0,%,B!P8!1#&0!

%)78!#80!#$$7,*#8!?wF0!,%0--0<!*8%#!/ILP>!,-0$*'*$7++.!,#!%)7%!?!$78!,0%!1.!

$)7&7$%0&!<#M8!*8!7!&##1!,:&&#:8<0<!2.!,%:''!?wF0!$#++0$%0<!*8`S710J!#&!%#!

+*,%08!%#!7!,#8S!?!+*T0!7%!7!$78%*87!?!'&0V:08%B!?%w,!8:<S0<!10!27$T!'&#1!%)0!

0<S0!#'!78W*0%.!7%%7$T,!#8!1#&0!%)78!#80!#$$7,*#8B!

! I)*+0!,%:<*0,!#8!CCP,!%08<!%#!01-)7,*]0!%)0!$#11:87+!-&7$%*$0,!7''#&<0<!

2.!%)0,0!S710,J!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,!+*T0!%)0!#80!<0,$&*20<!2.!E1*+.!&0F07+!%)7%!%)0!

72*+*%.!%#!M*%)<&7M!'&#1!,#$*7+!7$%*F*%*0,!78<!-+7.!7+#80!*,!7+,#!7!F7+:72+0!

7''#&<78$0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*'!M0!7&0!0W71*8*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,!#'!,0+'`

$7&0B!!?!M#:+<!,:SS0,%!%)7%!%)0!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!-+7.0&,!+*T0!E1*+.!#''0&!7!<*''0&08%!

-0&,-0$%*F0!#8!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!$#8%&#+!78<!-+7.!0W-0&*08$0,B!!C:$)!

&0,07&$)!#8!$#8%&#+!*8!F*<0#!S710,!)7F0!7--&#7$)0<!%)0!%#-*$!'&#1!%)0!-0&,-0$%*F0!

#'!X'+#MY![9,*T,]08%1*)7+.*J!5664\J!#&!)#M!-+7.0&,!:,0!7!S710!%#!7$)*0F0!78!

0W-0&*08$0!#'!20*8S!1078*8S':++.!*8!$#8%&#+!#'!78!0W-0&*08$0B!!O0&&!0%B!7+B![344h\!

)7F0!<0,$&*20<!%)0!'+#M!0W-0&*08$0!7,!X)*%%*8S!%)0!r,M00%!,-#%U!20%M008!%)0!

788#.78$0!#'!7!%7,T!%)7%!*,!-0&$0*F0<!7,!%&*F*7+!78<!%)0!'&:,%&7%*#8!#'!7!%7,T!%)7%!*,!

-0&$0*F0<!7,!%##!<*''*$:+%Y![-B!a5\B!!>0,07&$)!#8!S710!<0,*S8![0BSB!/7+08!s!

q*110&178J!344f\!)7F0!01-)7,*]0<!X'+#MY!7,!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!-+7.0&,!<0,*&0!%)0!

1#,%!M)08!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!I)*+0!?!<#!8#%!<*,-:%0!%)7%!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!

X'+#MY!$78!*8<00<!20!-+07,:&72+0J!-+7.!7$$#:8%,!2.!-0#-+0!+*T0!E1*+.!&01*8<!:,!%)7%!

#%)0&!,*S8*'*$78%!0W-0&*08$0,!7&0!17<0!-#,,*2+0B!

5i4!

! L)0!1#%*F7%*#8,!'#&!-+7.!<0,$&*20<!2.!E1*+.!78<!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!*,!8#%!

#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!%)0!7$)*0F0108%!78<!17*8%0878$0!#'!7!'+#M!,%7%0J!2:%!&7%)0&!%)0!

7$)*0F0108%!#'!M)7%!10<*7!-,.$)#+#S*,%,!)7F0!%0&10<!X0W$*%7%#&.!)#10#,%7,*,JY!#&!

%)0!$)##,*8S!#'!10<*7!%#!X7$)*0F0!78!#-%*17+!+0F0+!#'!7&#:,7+Y![=&.78%!s!"7F*0,J!

344hJ!-B!3h\B!!L)*,!$78!20!7$)*0F0<!%)&#:S)!78!*8$&07,0!*8!*8%08,*%.J!,:$)!7,!M)08!

-+7.0&,!-+7.!%#!7++0F*7%0!2#&0<#1J!2:%!$&:$*7++.!*%!$78!7+,#!20!7$)*0F0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!

<0`0,$7+7%*#8!#'!*8%08,*%.B!!C0<*7!7&0!M0++!,:*%0<!%#!1#<*'.*8S!#80U,!1##<J!+0F0+!#'!

7&#:,7+J!78<!7%%08%*#8J!78<!F*<0#!S710,!*8!-7&%*$:+7&!7''#&<!-+7.0&,!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!

%#!-&0$*,0+.!7<R:,%!78<!%M07T!%)0*&!7''0$%*F0!&0,#:&$0,![97++0R7J!3454J!-B!dfh\B!!L)*,!

-&0$*,*#8!*,!7''#&<0<!2.!7!F7&*0%.!#'!S710!<0,*S8!%0$)8*V:0,!78<!10$)78*,1,B!!Z#&!

*8,%78$0J!1#,%!F*<0#!S710,!8#M7<7.,!7++#M!-+7.0&,!%#!1#<*'.!7!S710U,!<*''*$:+%.!

+0F0+J!,$7+*8S!*%!:-!#&!<#M8!<0-08<*8S!#8!%)0*&!<0,*&0<!+0F0+!#'!$)7++08S0B!!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!#8!%)0!#%)0&!)78<J!0W01-+*'*0,!78#%)0&!10$)78*,1!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!7!

S710U,!<0,*S8!7++#M,!'#&!7!M*<0!&78S0!#'!0W-0&*08$0,!k!%)0!7F7*+72*+*%.!#'!7!M*<0!

F7&*0%.!#'!#2R0$%*F0,B!!L#!*++:,%&7%0!%)*,J!?!M*++!:,0!%M#!0W71-+0,!'&#1!1.!#M8!

0W-0&*08$0,!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710B!!;,!<*,$:,,0<!72#F0J!?!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.!08S7S0!*8!

$&7'%*8S!78<!S7%)0&*8S!7$%*F*%*0,!M)08!?!M78%0<!%#!<0`0,$7+7%0!1.!1##<!#&!

#%)0&M*,0!M*%)<&7M!'&#1!,%*1:+7%*#8B!!L)0,0!7$%*F*%*0,!M0&0!M0++`,:*%0<!%#!%)*,!%7,T!

,*8$0!%)0.!7&0!&0+7%*F0+.!,*1-+0!k!%)0.!&0V:*&0!'0M!2:%%#8!-&0,,0,J!7&0!8#%!

<0-08<08%!#8!7!-+7.0&U,!&0'+0W0,J!78<!7&0!0W%&010+.!&0-0%*%*F0B!

! A#M0F0&J!#8!%)0!#%)0&!08<!#'!%)0!,-0$%&:1J!<:&*8S!1#108%,!#'!)*S)!,%&0,,!

[,:$)!7,!M)08!1.!78W*0%.!M7,!7$%*F7%0<\J!?!M#:+<!,00T!#:%!1#&0!*8%08,*F0!7$%*F*%*0,!

*8!#&<0&!%#!<*,&:-%!1.!%)#:S)%!-7%%0&8,!78<!<*,08S7S0!'&#1!,-*&7+*8S!%)#:S)%,!78<!

5i5!

01#%*#8,B!!?!&010120&!#80!*8,%78$0J!7--&#W*17%0+.!%M#!1#8%),!*8%#!1.!%*10!M*%)!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!M)0&0!?!*8%08%*#87++.!,#:S)%!#:%!M)7%!?!<0010<!%)0!1#,%!

<0178<*8S!7$%*F*%*0,!%)0!S710!)7<!%#!#''0&!k!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!7!1:+%*`-+7.0&!<:8S0#8!

k!*8!#&<0&!%#!<*,%&7$%!1.,0+'!'&#1!7!-*0$0!#'!27<!80M,!?!)7<!&0$0*F0<B!!":8S0#8,J!*8!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!7&0!$#1-+0W!17]0,!'07%:&*8S!,%&#8S0&!0801*0,!M*%)!1#&0!

$#1-+*$7%0<!;B?B!-7%%0&8,!%)78!%)#,0!08$#:8%0&0<!<:&*8S!&0S:+7&!-+7.B!!;,!7!&0,:+%J!

<:8S0#8,!&0V:*&0!-+7.0&,!%#!%071!:-!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&J!:,:7++.!*8!S&#:-,!#'!'#:&J!%#!

$#1-+0%0!%)01B!!^8+*T0!$&7'%*8S!78<!S7%)0&*8SJ!<:8S0#8,!7&0!78.%)*8S!2:%!$7+1B!!L)0!

7<<0<!<*''*$:+%.!#'!%)0!<:8S0#8,!&0V:*&0,!-+7.0&,!%#!20!$#8,%78%+.!7+0&%!%#!M)7%!*,!

#$$:&&*8S!#8!%)0!,$&008J!'#&$*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!&0,-#8<!V:*$T+.!%#!$#8,%78%+.!$)78S*8S!

$*&$:1,%78$0,B!!L)0!80$0,,*%.!#'!-+7.*8S!M*%)!#%)0&!):178,!7+,#!2&*8S,!M*%)!*%!%)0!

7<<0<!$#1-+*$7%*#8!#'!$##&<*87%*#8!78<!$#11:8*$7%*#8!20%M008!-+7.0&,J!7,!07$)!

-+7.0&!*,!7,,*S80<!7!<0,*S87%0<!&#+0!M*%)*8!%)0!<:8S0#8!27,0<!#8!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&U,!

$+7,,!#&!-&#'0,,*#8B!!!

?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!7++!#'!%)*,J!%)0&0!*,!%)0!F*,:7+!<0,*S8!#'!%)0!S710B!!Q&7.!0%B!7+B!

[344c\!)7F0!:,0<!%)0!%0&1!XR:*$*80,,Y!%#!<0,$&*20!7!%.-0!#'!*8%0&'7$0!%)7%!-&#F*<0,!

-#,*%*F0!'00<27$T!%)&#:S)!0W$0,,*F0!F*,:7+!,-0$%7$+0B!!>0'0&&*8S!27$T!%#!1.!#-08*8S!

F*S80%%0J!?!<*<!8#%!R:,%!&0$0*F0!7!8#%*'*$7%*#8!%0++*8S!10!%)7%!?!)7<!+0F0+0<!:-B!!C.!

$)7&7$%0&!0&:-%0<!*8!,-7&T,!7,!7!'78'7&0!-+7.0<!78<!S*78%!S#+<!+0%%0&,!&07<*8S!XK0F0+!

^-mY!7--07&0<!#8!%)0!,$&008B!!/:$)!0W$0,,*F0!<*,-+7.,!0W01-+*'.!XR:*$*80,,Y!,*8$0!

%)0.!<#!8#%!R:,%!$#11:8*$7%0!*8'#&17%*#8!%#!%)0!-+7.0&J!2:%!7+,#!-&#F*<0!78!

*110<*7%0J!-+07,:&72+0!0W-0&*08$0!*8!78<!#'!%)01,0+F0,B!!;,!N::+![3454\!8#%0,J!

R:*$*80,,!7+,#!08)78$0,!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!'00+*8S!$#1-0%08%J!#&!$+0F0&J!#&!#%)0&M*,0!!

5i3!

Z*S:&0!3B!!;!,$&008,)#%!'&#1!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*++:,%&7%*8S!%)0!F*,:7+!,-0$%7$+0!#8!

<*,-+7.!M)08!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!7!<:8S0#8![M*%)!%)0!8710,!#'!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!

#2,$:&0<\B!!

-#M0&':+!M)08!-+7.*8S!7!S710![-B!fc`f6\B!!I)*+0!R:*$*80,,!*,!78!0+0108%!#'!7++!F*<0#!

S710,J!%#!#80!<0S&00!#&!78#%)0&J!*%!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-&#8#:8$0<!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!

L)*,!*,!1#,%!0F*<08%!<:&*8S!1:+%*-+7.0&!<:8S0#8,J!M)08!0F0&.!$)7&7$%0&U,!7$%*#8,!

-&#<:$0!,-0$%7$:+7&!0''0$%,!%)7%!'*++!%)0!,$&008![Z*S:&0!3\B!!!

I)*+0!%)*,!$78!20!<*,#&*08%*8SJ!0,-0$*7++.!20$7:,0!*%!17T0,!*%!<*''*$:+%!%#!

<0%0&1*80!M)7%!0W7$%+.!*,!#$$:&&*8S!#8!,$&008J!*%!7+,#!71-+*'*0,!%)0!S710U,!72*+*%.!%#!

7%%&7$%!78<!)#+<!7!-+7.0&U,!7%%08%*#8!78<!,7%*,'.!7!<0,*&0!'#&!*8$&07,0<!*8%08,*%.B!!Z#&!

%)#,0!-+7.*8S!%#!<0`0,$7+7%0!%)0*&!1##<J!1078M)*+0J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&7+,#!#''0&,!7!

F7&*0%.!#'!70,%)0%*$7++.!-+07,*8S!+78<,$7-0,!%#!M78<0&!78<!0W-+#&0!7%!%)0*&!+0*,:&0J!

&78S*8S!'&#1!'#&0,%,!%#!<0,0&%,!%#!,8#M'*0+<,B!!;,!97++0R7![3454\!8#%0,J!*8)72*%*8S!

207:%*':+!+78<,$7-0,!+*T0!%)0!#80,!'#:8<!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$78!$&07%0!7!,%&#8S0&!

5id!

7''0$%*F0!&07$%*#8!*8!-+7.0&,!%)78!F*0M*8S!207:%*':+!+78<,$7-0,!*8!8#80&S#<*$!10<*7!

,*8$0!%)0!-+7.0&!*,!7''#&<0<!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!0W-+#&0!%)0,0!+78<,$7-0,!'#&!

%)01,0+F0,![-B!dfh\B!

I)7%!*,!,*S8*'*$78%!72#:%!%)0,0!7''#&<78$0,J!)#M0F0&J!*,!8#%!#8+.!M)7%!%)0.!

7++#M!-0#-+0!%#!<#J!2:%!7+,#!M)7%!%)0.!7++#M!-0#-+0!%#!3/?6(/B!!P'%08%*10,J!$)##,*8S!

8#%!%#!<#!,#10%)*8S!$78!20!1#&0!*1-#&%78%!%)78!$)##,*8S!%#!<#!,#10%)*8SB!!?1-+*$*%!

*8!%)0!V:#%0!'&#1!E1*+.!72#F0!*,!%)0!$#8,$*#:,!&0':,7+!%#!08S7S0!*8!%)0!#%)0&!

0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710!%)7%!M#:+<!20!%##!<0178<*8S!7%!%)0!%*10B!!L)*,!,08%*108%!M7,!

0$)#0<!2.!,0F0&7+!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,J!,-0$*'*$7++.!M)08!%)0.!M0&0!7,T0<!M)0%)0&!#&!

8#%!%)0.!-&0'0&!%#!-+7.!S710,!7+#80!#&!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!L)0!17R#&*%.!#'!

-7&%*$*-78%,!&0,-#8<0<!M*%)!,#10!F7&*7%*#8!#'!X*%!<0-08<,BY!!I)7%!X*%Y!<0-08<0<!#8!

F7&*0<!'&#1!-7&%*$*-78%!%#!-7&%*$*-78%J!,:$)!7,!%)0!7F7*+72*+*%.!#'!#%)0&!-0#-+0!%#!-+7.!

M*%)!78<!%)0!S08&0!#'!%)0!S710B!!/*S8*'*$78%!'#&!1.!<*,$:,,*#8J!)#M0F0&J!M7,!%)0!

*1-#&%78$0!-+7$0<!:-#8!%)0!-+7.0&U,!1##<!M)08!<0$*<*8S!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%#!-+7.!

M*%)!#%)0&,B!!L)*,!$78!20!,008!*8!%)0!'#++#M*8S!V:#%0!'&#1!9*8<.G!

?%!<0-08<,!#8!1.!1##<B!?!S#!%)&#:S)!-)7,0,!M)0&0!?!7+M7.,!M78%!%#!20!M*%)!

-0#-+0!78<!,#10%*10,!?!R:,%!M7887!-+7.!%)0!S710!2.!1.,0+'B!CCP,!*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!7&0!%)*,!M7.!'#&!10B!?!+#F0!S&#:-!7$%*F*%*0,!2:%!,#10!<7.,!?!-7,,!

R:,%!,#!?!$78!S0%!1.!#M8!,%:''!<#80!*8!%)0!S710B!b!>07++.!*%!7++!$#10,!<#M8!%#!

%)*,G!A#M!*,!1.!<0-&0,,*#8!%#<7.g!?'!*%!*,8w%!S&07%!?!M7887!-+7.!7+#80!,#!?!$78!

S#!7%!1.!#M8!-7$0!78<!%7T0!+#%,!#'!2&07T,B!?'!*%!*,!S##<J!?w1!S#*8S!%#!M78%!%#!

-+7.!M*%)!'&*08<,!78<!$)7%B!

I)08!*8%0&-&0%*8S!%)*,!&0,-#8,0J!78<!%)0!8:10&#:,!#%)0&,!+*T0!*%J!*%!M7,!

*1-#&%78%!%)7%!?!$#8%0W%:7+*]0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!<0,$&*20<!M*%)*8!%)0!2&#7<0&!$#8%0W%!#'!

%)0!-7&%*$*-78%U,!+*'0B!!?8!9*8<.U,!$7,0J!*%!*,!&0+0F78%!%#!8#%0!%)7%!,)0!M7,J!7%!%)0!%*10J!

01-+#.0<!7,!78!0W0$:%*F0!7,,*,%78%!%#!%)0!9EPo#M80&!#'!)0&!$#1-78.B!!/:$)!78!

5if!

#$$:-7%*#8!M#:+<!80$0,,7&*+.!*8F#+F0!7!)*S)!71#:8%!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!,*8$0!*%!

*8F#+F0,!01#%*#87++.!,:--#&%*8S!,#10#80!0+,0B!!;,!7!-0&,#8!M)#!,:''0&,!'&#1!

<0-&0,,*#8J!%)0,0!<0178<,!:-#8!9*8<.U,!108%7+!78<!01#%*#87+!&0,0&F0,!7&0!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!7$:%0B!!":&*8S!)0&!+0*,:&0!%*10J!%)08J!*%!*,!8#%!,:&-&*,*8S!%)7%!9*8<.!

M#:+<!$)##,0!78!7$%*F*%.!%)7%!7++#M,!)0&!%#!$#8%&#+!-0#-+0U,!7$$0,,!%#!)0&B!!!

I)7%!?!M78%!%#!,:SS0,%J!%)08J!*,!%)7%!*8!%)0!$#8%0W%!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!M)0&0!

M#&T0&,!7&0!0W-0$%0<!%#!&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!<0178<,!'#&!%)0*&!7%%08%*#8!78<!01#%*#87+!

&0,0&F0,!'&#1!7!F7&*0%.!#'!-0#-+0!#&!&*,T!+#,*8S!%)0*&!R#2,J!%)0&0!$78!20!,#10%)*8S!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!7++:&*8S!72#:%!7!+0*,:&0!7$%*F*%.!%)7%!7''#&<,!7!-0&,#8!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!

&0':,0!,:$)!<0178<,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7''#&<,!%)*,J!%#!7!$0&%7*8!0W%08%B!!I)*+0!%)0!

17*8!,%#&.+*80!#'!%)0!S710!<#0,!&0V:*&0!-+7.0&,!%#!S&#:-!:-!M*%)!#%)0&,!

-0&*#<*$7++.J!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710!$78!20!&0':,0<B!!L)0!

$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)*,!&0':,7+J!*8!%:&8J!7&0!1*8*17+B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!M)08!-+7.*8S!

%)&#:S)!%)0!S710!?!M#:+<!'&0V:08%+.![:,:7++.!#8$0!#&!%M*$0!7!,0,,*#8\!&0$0*F0!78!

*8F*%7%*#8!%#!R#*8!7!XZ&00!9#1-78.JY!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!8710!'#&!7!S:*+<!#&!78!*8`

S710J!-+7.0&`#&S78*]0<!$#11:8*%.!#'!-0#-+0B!!P8$0!%)0!8#%*'*$7%*#8!7--07&0<J!%)0!

S710!M#:+<!S*F0!10!d44!,0$#8<,!%#!&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!*8F*%7%*#8!20'#&0!<0+0%*8S!*%B!!?'!?!

$)#,0!%#!&0,-#8<![M)*$)!?!7+1#,%!7+M7.,!<*<\J!?!M#:+<!,*1-+.!)7F0!%#!7$$0-%!#&!

<0$+*80!%)0!*8F*%7%*#8!M*%)!0*%)0&!7!X.0,Y!#&!7! X 8#JY!7,!M0++!7,!&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!

'#++#M*8S!8#%*'*$7%*#8!$#8'*&1*8S!1.!<0$*,*#8J!7S7*8!M*%)!7!X.0,Y!#&!7!X8#BY!!L)0!

)7&,)0,%!-087+%.!M#:+<!20!1.!#M8!'00+*8S,!#'!S:*+%!'#&!<0$+*8*8S!78!*8F*%7%*#8J!2:%!

%)7%!S&7<:7++.!1#&-)0<!*8%#!788#.78$0!<:0!%#!%)0!'&0V:08%!#$$:&&08$0!#'!%)0,0!

*8F*%7%*#8,B!!;,*<0!'&#1!%)0!,17++!7''0$%*F0!$#,%,!#'!<0$+*8*8S!78!*8F*%7%*#8J!%)08J!?!

5ic!

&0$0*F0<!8#!#2F*#:,!-087+%*0,!'&#1!&0':,*8S!%#!08S7S0!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!%)08J!7''#&<,!-+7.0&,!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!*117%0&*7+!M7S0!+72#&!'&0V:08%+.!

M*%))#+<,!'&#1!M#&T0&,!k!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!&0':,0!<0178<,!#8!%)0*&!7%%08%*#8!

M*%)!1*8*17+!$#8,0V:08$0B!!/*8$0!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!08S7S0<!*8!

F7&*#:,!'#&1,!#'!*117%0&*7+!M7S0!+72#&!M)08!%)0.!'*++0<!#:%!1.!V:0,%*#887*&0J!%)*,!

7''#&<78$0!M#:+<!20!7--07+*8SJ!-0&)7-,!0F08!80$0,,7&.J!'#&!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!20!72+0!

%#!:,0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7,!7!%##+!#'!,0+'`$7&0B!!!!!!!!!!

?!108%*#8!7++!#'!%)0,0!0+0108%,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!%#!&0*8'#&$0!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

F*<0#!S710,!7&0!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M0++!,:*%0<!%#!1#<*'.*8S!78<!&0S:+7%*8S!7!-0&,#8U,!

7''0$%*F0!,%7%0B!!CCP,!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!1078M)*+0J!-0&)7-,!20,%!0W01-+*'.!%)*,!

,*8$0!%)0.!7''#&<!-+7.0&,!7!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,!%#!-+7.J!'&#1!$7+1J!7+1#,%!10<*%7%*F0!

-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!$&7'%*8S!78<!S7%)0&*8S!%#!*8%08,0!27%%+0,!M*%)!#--#808%,!&0V:*&*8S!7!

)*S)!<0S&00!#'!7%%08%*#8!78<!$##&<*87%*#8!M*%)!#%)0&,B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!#%)0&!

10<*7!'#&1,!7&0!8#%!$7-72+0!#'!7''#&<*8S!7!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,!#'!08S7S0108%J!0*%)0&!

*8%&*8,*$7++.!#&!%)&#:S)!%)0!$&07%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!7:<*08$0,B!!L)0!:,0,!78<!

S&7%*'*$7%*#8,!7''#&<0<!2.!%0+0F*,*#8!F*0M*8S!F7&.!<&717%*$7++.J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!

<0-08<*8S!#8!M)0%)0&!#80!*,!M7%$)*8S!7+#80J!#&!M*%)!#%)0&,J! #&! 08S7S*8S!*8!$0&%7*8!

-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!+*F0!%M00%*8SB!!=:%!'0M!10<*7!,#!#2F*#:,+.!7''#&<!7:<*08$0,!%)0,0!

<*''0&*8S!1#<0,!#'!08S7S0108%!78<!7&0!0W-+*$*%+.!<0,*S80<!%#!<#!,#!7,!F*<0#!S710,B!!

?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!#%)0&!10<*7!'#&1,J!'#&!0W71-+0!%0+0F*,*#8!78<!'*+1J!&0+.!#8!%)0!+72#&!

#'!%)0*&!7:<*08$0,!%#!#-08!:-!178.!#'!%)0*&!-#%08%*7+*%*0,J!M)*+0!F*<0#!S710,!<#!

,#10!#'!%)7%!M#&T!'#&!%)0!7:<*08$0!%)&#:S)!'+0W*2+0!<0,*S8!-&7$%*$0,B!!L)*,!$78!20!

,#10%)*8S!7,!,*1-+0!7,!#''0&*8S!<*''0&08%!<*''*$:+%.!,0%%*8S,!#&!7,!$#1-+*$7%0<!7,!

5ih!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!-&0,08%7%*#8!#'!1:+%*-+0!S710!1#<0,J!07$)!M*%)!%)0*&!#M8!

*8%08,*%.J!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!$)##,0!78<!1#F0!20%M008B!!?%!*,!8#%!,:&-&*,*8SJ!%)08J!%)7%!

*117%0&*7+!M#&T0&,!,#!'&0V:08%+.!%:&8!%#!F*<0#!S710,!*8!%)0*&!<#M8%*10J!,*8$0!

F*<0#!S710,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!CCP,J!7&0!<0,*S80<!%#!20!'+0W*2+0!78<!&0,-#8,*F0!%#!7!

-+7.0&U,!7''0$%*F0!,%7%0J!78<!%):,!7&0!M0++!,:*%0<!%#!)0+-*8S!-+7.0&,!7$)*0F0!

X0W$*%7%#&.!)#10#,%7,*,BY!

!Returning!From!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

! L#!,:117&*]0J!M0!)7F0!<*,$:,,0<!M).!-0#-+0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*117%0&*7+!

M#&T0&,J!*8$#&-#&7%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8%#!%)0*&!,0+'!$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!)#M!F*<0#!

S710,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!CCP,J!7&0!M0++`,:*%0<!%#!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!20$7:,0!%)0*&!'+0W*2+0!

<0,*S8,!7++#M!7:<*08$0,!%#!1#<*'.!78<!&0S:+7%0!%)0*&!7''0$%*F0!,%7%0,B!!@#M!M0!M*++!

%:&8!%#!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!)#M!CCP,!$78!20!:,0<!%#!&0`&#:%0!7:<*08$0,!27$T!*8%#!

$7-*%7+*,%!1#<0,!#'!M7S0!+72#&B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%! CCP,J!78<!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!

1#&0!S080&7++.J!7&0!80$0,,7&*+.!7!-7&%!#'!7!'00<27$T!+##-!20%M008!+72#&!78<!+0*,:&0B!!

;,!O*8871#8![345h\!)7,!8#%0<J!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-&0$7&*#:,!*8!

)#M!%)0.!17.!20!:%*+*]0<J!78<!%):,!$78!20!17<0!%#!M#&T!*8!1:+%*-+0!M7.,![-B!5ih\B!!?!

<#!8#%!M78%!%#!'7++!*8%#!%)0!%&7-! #'! %)*8T*8S!%)7%!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,%&7%0S.!#&!-&7$%*$0!

1:,%!7+M7.,!20!-&0,:10<!%#!&0*8'#&$0!<#1*878%!-#M0&!,%&:$%:&0,!20$7:,0!%)0.!

+7$T!78!7!-&*#&*!*11:8*%.!%#!%)*,![/0<SM*$TJ!344dJ!-B!5d3`5dd\B!!/*1-+.!20$7:,0!7!

S*F08!-&7$%*$0!$78!20!:,0<!'#&!7!-7&%*$:+7&!-:&-#,0!<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!*%!M*++!7+M7.,!

20!:,0<!'#&!%)7%!-:&-#,0B!!9#8F0&,0+.J!$)##,*8S!%#!:8-7$T!%)0!10$)78*,1,!M)0&02.!

7!S*F08!-&7$%*$0!$78!20!#&!)7,!2008!:,0<!%#!&0*8'#&$0!<#1*878%!-#M0&!,%&:$%:&0,!

<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!?!%)*8T!%)7%!%)*,!*,!%)0!#8+.!0''0$%!#'!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!P80!#'!%)0!

5ia!

,%&08S%),!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.!*,!%)0!'+0W*2*+*%.!<0&*F0<!'&#1!*%,!01-)7,*,!#8!+#$7+J!

$#8%*8S08%!&0+7%*#8,)*-,B!!/:$)!'+0W*2*+*%.!7++#M,!10!%#!7<#-%!7!80$0,,7&*+.!

-&0$7&*#:,!-#,*%*#8!M)0&02.!?!$78!1#&0!$+07&+.!*8F0,%*S7%0!%)0!'+:$%:7%*8S!#-08*8S,!

78<!'#&0$+#,:&0,!%)7%!010&S0!M)08!-0#-+0!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

%)&*F*8SB!

! Z#&!*%!*,!'&0V:08%+.!%)0!$7,0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!78<!<#!M#&T!%#!&0-&#<:$0!

%)0!':8$%*#8,!78<!*<0#+#S*0,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!$#8%01-#&7&.!-#,%`Z#&<*,%!

$7-*%7+*,1!78<!*%,!01-)7,*,!#8!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!7,!".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&!

[3446\!)7F0!-0&,:7,*F0+.!7&S:0<!*8!%)0*&!-#+*%*$7+`0$#8#1*$!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!F*<0#!

S710!*8<:,%&.B!!CCP,!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7&0!-0&)7-,!1#&0!*8F0,%0<!%)78!#%)0&!

S710!S08&0,!*8!-0&-0%:7%*8S!%)0!+72#&`+0*,:&0!$.$+0!M)0&02.!-0#-+0!:,0!+0*,:&0!%#!

&0,%!78<!&080M!%)0*&!<0-+0%0<!080&S*0,!20'#&0!&0%:&8*8S!%#!M#&T!,*8$0!7!,*S8*'*$78%!

71#:8%!#'!%)0*&!&0F08:0!*,!S080&7%0<!%)&#:S)!1#8%)+.!,:2,$&*-%*#8,B!!I)*+0!%)0!

'&#8%*0&!&)0%#&*$!#'!%)0!S710U,!-&#1#%*#87+!17%0&*7+,!#''0&,!%)0!-+7.0&!%)0!'78%7,.!#'!

0,$7-*8S!%)0!-&0,,:&0,!#'!%)0!X&07+Y![1078*8S!8#8`F*&%:7+\!M#&+<J!7,!0F*<08$0<!2.!*%,!

&0$08%!%7S+*80!X;<F08%:&0!;M7*%,!D#:!=0.#8<!%)0!A#&*]#8Y![/V:7&0`E8*WJ!345i\J!%)0!

&07+*%.!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!:+%*17%0+.!:8<0&$:%,!%)*,!-#,,*2*+*%.!7,!%)0!-+7.0&!1:,%!

:,0!%)0!M7S0,!07&80<!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!S710!*8!#&<0&!%#!,:,%7*8!%)0*&!X7<F08%:&0,!

20.#8<!%)0!)#&*]#8JY!78<!%):,!1:,%!+#S!#''!78<!&0%:&8!%#!M#&T!0F08%:7++.B!

! /#!*'!-+7.!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!1:,%!20!,:,%7*80<!%)&#:S)!%)0!17*8%0878$0!#'!

%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0J!M)7%!,-0$*'*$!10$)78*,1,!<#0,!%)0!S710!<0-+#.!%#!

08$#:&7S0!%)*,!-+7.!-&7$%*$0g!!I)*+0!%)0&0!7&0!1:+%*-+0!10$)78*,1,!<0-+#.0<J!'#&!

%)0!&017*8<0&!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&!?!M78%!%#!'#$:,!#8!7!,0+0$%!'0M!-&7$%*$0,!:%*+*]0<!2.!

5ii!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!%#!*++:,%&7%0!)#M!%)0!S710!M#&T,!%#!&0`&#:%0!%)0!-+7.0&!27$T!*8%#!

%)0!&07+!M#&+<J!%)0!-#,,*2+0!M7.,!%)7%!-+7.0&,!17.!0,$7-0!%)*,!7%%01-%!%#!$7-%:&0!

78<!1787S0!%)0*&!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!<*,$#:&,0,!%)7%!&08<0&!%)0,0!7F08:0,!

#'!0,$7-0!-&#2+017%*$B!!(+7.!-&7$%*$0,J!7'%0&!7++J!$78!#-08!-+7.0&,!%#!-&0$7&*#:,!78<!

7+07%#&.!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!-+07,:&0!78<!0,$7-0!%)7%!)7F0!%)0!-#%08%*7+!%#!<*,&:-%!78<!

%&78,'#&1!7!-+7.0&U,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!)*0&7&$)*0,!78<!<*,%&*2:%*#8,!#'!

F7+:0B!!Z&#1!%)*,!-0&,-0$%*F0J!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#!&0-7*&!%)0!

,0+'!'&#1!%)0!7%%&*'.*8S!0''0$%,!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!7&0!7!,*%0!#'!,%&:SS+0!20%M008!

$7-*%7+*,1!78<!*%,!,:2R0$%,B!!=.!0W71*8*8S!%)0!7&07,!M)0&0!$#8%&#+!*,!0W0&%0<J!M0!$78!

20S*8!%#!:8<0&,%78<!)#M!%)*,!$#8%&#+!17.!20!&0':,0<J!:8<0&1*80<J!%&78,'#&10<J!#&!

#%)0&M*,0!0+:<0<B!

Interrupting!Gameplay!

! !!!L:&8*8S!%#!%)0!,-0$*'*$!10$)78*,1,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&:,0,!%#!$7-%:&0!78<!

1787S0!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!*%,!-+7.0&,J!#80!*8!-7&%*$:+7&!,%78<,!#:%!k!%)0!S710U,!

X*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.BY!!N0,-0&!N::+![3454\J!*8!)*,!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!<0,*S8!'07%:&0,!#'!

$#8%01-#&7&.!$7,:7+!S710,J!$#8%08<,!%)7%!%)0!72*+*%.!#'!7!S710!%#!20!*8%0&&:-%0<!*,!

$&:$*7+!%#!*%,!72*+*%.!%#!20!'+0W*2+.!*8%0S&7%0<!*8%#!%)0!<7*+.!&).%)1,!#'!7!<*F0&,0!

7:<*08$0!M*%)!:8-&0<*$%72+0!,$)0<:+0,![-B!dh`d6\B!!;,!N::+!8#%0,J!*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.!)7,!

,0F0&7+!$#1-#808%,J!'&#1!%)0!':8$%*#87+!%#!%)0!-,.$)#+#S*$7+J!%)7%!,)7-0!M)0%)0&!7!

-+7.0&!'00+,!*%!*,!7--&#-&*7%0!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!S71*8S!,0,,*#8B!!P8!7!-:&0+.!

':8$%*#87+!+0F0+J!7!S710!1:,%!7''#&<!-+7.0&,!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!,7F0!%)0*&!S710!,%7%0!78<!

&0%:&8!%#!*%!7%!7!+7%0&!1#108%!*8!%*10B!!L)0!'+0W*2*+*%.!#'!7!S710U,!,7F0!<0,*S8!)7,!7!

5i6!

+7&S0!*8'+:08$0!#8!)#M!*8%0&&:-%*2+0!%)0!S710!17.!20B!!E7&+.!S710,![0BSB!%)#,0!

&0+07,0<!#8!%)0!#&*S*87+!@E/!$#8,#+0\!M0&0!+*1*%0<!*8!%)0*&!,%#&7S0!$7-7$*%.!78<!,#!

#8+.!7++#M0<!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!,7F0!%)0!S710!,%7%0!7%!-&0`<0,*S87%0<!7&07,!#&!1#108%,J!

*'!%)0.!7++#M0<!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!,7F0!7%!7++B!!9#8%01-#&7&.!S710,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

<#M8+#7<72+0!1#2*+0!S710,J!#'%08!*8$+:<0!'&0V:08%!#--#&%:8*%*0,!%#!,7F0!%)0!S710!

7,!M0++!7,!7:%#`,7F0,J!M)0&0!%)0!S710!*%,0+'!$&07%0,!7!,7F0!,%7%0!7'%0&!7!$0&%7*8!

-0&*#<!#'!%*10!#&!:-#8!08$#:8%0&*8S!7!-7&%*$:+7&!%&*SS0&B!!C78.!S71*8S!-+7%'#&1,J!

+*T0!1#2*+0!<0F*$0,!78<!$:&&08%!$#8,#+0,J!7+,#!'07%:&0!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!,:,-08<!%)0!

S710!7%!78.!-#*8%!78<!&0%:&8!%#!%)0!S710!7%!7!+7%0&!<7%0!,)#:+<!%)0!800<!7&*,0B!!L)*,!

7++#M,!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!%)0#&0%*$7++.!)7+%!78<!&0,:10!S710!-+7.!7%!78.!%*10J!7++#M*8S!

%)0!-+7.0&!%#!*8%0S&7%0!78.!S710!*8%#!78.!,$)0<:+0B!!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<0-+#.,!7!8:120&!#'!%)0,0!':8$%*#8,B!!(+7.0&,!$78!+#S!*8!78<!

+#S!#:%!7%!%)0*&!+0*,:&0!*8!-&7$%*$7++.!78.!7&07B!!?!,7.!X-&7$%*$7++.Y!#8+.!20$7:,0!?!

$788#%!$#8'*&1!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)*,!72*+*%.!*,!7F7*+72+0!*8!0F0&.!7&07!,*8$0!?!<*<!8#%!

08$#:8%0&!0F0&.!7&07!<:&*8S!1.!'*0+<!M#&TB!!A#M0F0&J!?!08%0&0<!08#:S)!7&07,!78<!

08S7S0<!M*%)!08#:S)!S710!1#<0,!%)7%!?!71!$#1'#&%72+0!,%7%*8S!%)7%!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,!$78!20!*8%0&&:-%0<!*8!1#,%!7&07,!M*%)!07,0!78<J!$&:$*7++.J!+*%%+0!%#!8#!80S7%*F0!

$#8,0V:08$0,!%#!%)0!-+7.0&B!!L)0!#8+.!%*10!?!0F0&!#2,0&F0<!7!-+7.0&!20!-:8*,)0<!'#&!

*8%0&&:-%*8S!%)0*&!S710!M7,!M)08!?!)7<!%#!+07F0!*8!%)0!1*<,%!#'!0W-+#&*8S!7!<:8S0#8!

M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!L)*,!*,!:8<0&,%78<72+0J!,*8$0!+07F*8S!7!<:8S0#8!8#%!#8+.!

*8$#8F08*08$0,!%)0!-+7.0&!M)#!*,!+07F*8SJ!2:%!7+,#!*8$#8F08*08$0,!7++!#'!%)0!#%)0&!

-+7.0&,!0W-+#&*8S!%)7%!<:8S0#8!M*%)!%)01B!!A#M0F0&J!1.!-:8*,)108%!'#&!<#*8S!,#!

#8+.!*8$+:<0<!20*8S!+#$T0<!#:%!#'!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!#%)0&!S&#:-!7$%*F*%*0,!'#&!7!,0%!

564!

71#:8%!#'!%*10![*8!%)*,!$7,0J!#80!)#:&\B!!P:%,*<0!#'!%)*,!#80!0W-0&*08$0J!8#!#%)0&!

F#+:8%7&.!*8%0&&:-%*#8,!%#!1.!-+7.!M0&0!-087+*]0<J!%):,!,:--#&%*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,U,!$#11*%108%!%#!*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.B!

A#M0F0&J!':8$%*#87+!$#1-#808%,!7&0!8#%!%)0!#8+.!0+0108%,!#'!

*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.B!!N::+![3454\!7+,#!8#%0,!%)7%!%)0!-,.$)#+#S*$7+!$#1-#808%,!#'!

*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.!7&0!R:,%!7,J!*'!8#%!1#&0J!*1-#&%78%!7,!%)0!':8$%*#87+!$#1-#808%,B!!L)0!

-,.$)#+#S*$7+!$#1-#808%,!#'!*8%0&&:-%*2*+*%.!&0'0&!%#!%)0!S710!17T*8S!-+7.0&,!'00+!

+*T0!*%!*,!7$$0-%72+0!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!-+7.B!!L)7%!*,!%#!,7.J!*%!*,!8#%!,:''*$*08%!'#&!7!

S710!%#!20!':8$%*#87++.!*8%0&&:-%*2+0B!!;'%0&!7++J!7++!S710,!7&0!':8$%*#87++.!

*8%0&&:-%*2+0!7%!78.!1#108%!,*8$0!%)0!-+7%'#&1,!78<!<0F*$0,!%)0.!7&0!-+7.0<!#8!$78!

20!%:&80<!#''J!0*%)0&!2.!$)#*$0!#&!2.!$)78$0B!!A#M0F0&J!R:,%!20$7:,0!7!S710!=$#!20!

%:&80<!#''!<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!7!-+7.0&!M*++!N$#'!%#!%:&8!*%!#''B!!L#!7$$#:8%!'#&!%)*,J!

S710,!$#11:8*$7%0!%)0!7$$0-%72*+*%.!#'!*8%0&&:-%*8S!%)0!S710!*8!7!F7&*0%.!#'!M7.,B!!

Z#&!#80J!$0&%7*8!S710,!8#%*'.!-+7.0&,!*8!7<F78$0!)#M!+#8S!7!-7&%*$:+7&!7$%*F*%.!$78!

%7T0!#&!*,!0W-0$%0<!%#!%7T0B!!?8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!'#&!0W71-+0J!-+7.0&,!7&0!S*F08!7!h4!

1*8:%0!%*10!+*1*%!%#!$#1-+0%0!<:8S0#8,J!%):,!7++#M*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!-+78!7$$#&<*8S+.B!!

A#M0F0&J!%)0!1#&0!$#11#8!10%)#<!'#&!7!S710!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!%)0!7$$0-%72*+*%.!#'!

*8%0&&:-%*8S!%)0!S710!*,!%#!-&#F*<0!M)7%!N::+![3454\!)7,!$7++0<!X2&07T`'7$*+*%7%*8S!

1#108%,JY!#&!%)0!1#108%,!M)08!7++!-&0,,*8S!%7,T,!)7F0!2008!7$)*0F0<B!!?8!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!%)0!*8%0&'7$0!:-<7%0,!7++!%7,T,!*8!%)0!S710![T8#M8!7,!X<:%*0,Y\!7,!.#:!

&07$)!$0&%7*8!1*+0,%#80,!M*%)*8!%)0!%7,TB!!P8$0!$#1-+0%0J!7!+7&S0!$).&#8!7--07&,!78<!

7!1:,*$7+!'78'7&0!-+7.,!8#%*'.*8S!.#:!%)7%!%)0!<:%.!)7,!2008!$#1-+0%0<B!!(+7.0&,!$78!

%&7$T!1:+%*-+0!<:%*0,!,*1:+%780#:,+.B!!A#M0F0&J!%)0!S710!*,!<0,*S80<!,#!%)7%!%7,T,!

565!

7&0!$+:,%0&0<!%#S0%)0&!*8!,-0$*'*$!7&07,!M)*$)!%)0!S710!S:*<0,!-+7.0&,!%)&#:S)B!!Z#&!

0W71-+0J!#8$0!%)0!-+7.0&!$#1-+0%0,!#80!<:%.!*8!%)0!17*8!,%#&.+*80J!78#%)0&!20$#10,!

7F7*+72+0B!!;%!-&0<0%0&1*80<!-#*8%,!*8!%)0!17*8!,%#&.+*80!<:%.!$)7*8J!%)0!80W%!%7,T!

M*++!<*&0$%!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!78#%)0&!7&07!*8!%)0!S710J!M)0&0!1#&0!<:%*0,!7&0!7F7*+72+0B!!

L)*,!$.$+0!$#8%*8:0,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!08%*&0%.!#'!%)0!S710U,!,%#&.+*80B!!L)0,0!<:%*0,J!

S080&7++.J!$78!20!7$$#1-+*,)0<!V:*$T+.![M*%)*8!7!'0M!1*8:%0,\J!7''#&<*8S!%)0!-+7.0&!

7!S&07%!71#:8%!#'!'+0W*2*+*%.!%#!<0%0&1*80!)#M!+#8S!%)0.!M*++!-+7.!%)0!S710B!!?'!%*10!

*,!+*1*%0<J!7!-+7.0&!$78!V:*$T+.!+#S!*8%#!%)0!S710J!$#1-+0%0!7!'0M!V:0,%,J!78<!+#S!#:%!

V:*$T+.B!!?'!%)0!-+7.0&!)7,!1#&0!+0*,:&0!%*10!%#!,-08<J!%)0.!$78!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!178.!

V:0,%,!#&!*8!#%)0&!7&07,!#'!%)0!S710![,:$)!7,!<:8S0#8,\!%)7%!7&0!1#&0!%*10!

*8%08,*F0B!!!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!':&%)0&!*8$08%*F*]0,!-+7.0&,!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!-+7.!%*10!2.!

-&#F*<*8S!7!X&0,%*8S!2#8:,BY!!/)#:+<!7!-+7.0&!+#S!#:%!*8!7!,7'0!]#80![,:$)!7,!7!%#M8\J!

:-#8!&0%:&8*8S!%#!%)0!S710!%)0.!M*++!20!S&78%0<!7!2#8:,!%#!%)0!71#:8%!#'!

0W-0&*08$0!%)0.!07&8!M)08!-0&'#&1*8S!&#:%*80!7$%*#8,!+*T0!T*++*8S!1#8,%0&,!#&!

$&7'%*8S!*%01,B!!L)0!<:&7%*#8!#'!%)0!2#8:,!$#&&0,-#8<,!%#!%)0!+08S%)!#'!%*10!%)0!

-+7.0&!M7,!+#SS0<!#:%J!M*%)!+#8S0&!&0,%*8S!-0&*#<,!&0,:+%*8S!*8!+#8S0&!2#8:,0,B!!

EW-0&*08$0!-#*8%,!7&0!:,0<!%#!S7*8!+0F0+,J!-&#S&0,,!%)&#:S)!%)0!S710J!78<!:8+#$T!

,-0$*'*$!$#8%08%!+*T0!1#:8%,!78<!<:8S0#8,B!!L)0&0'#&0J!%)0!'7,%0&!#80!$78!-&#S&0,,!

%)&#:S)!+0F0+,J!%)0!'7,%0&!%)0.!S7*8!7$$0,,!%#!,-0$*'*$!$#8%08%B!!L)0!&0,%*8S!2#8:,!$78!

)0+-!<*1*8*,)!%)0!-,.$)#+#S*$7+!-:++!%#!,-08<!1#&0!%*10!*8!%)0!S710!2.!17T*8S!

S7*8*8S!+0F0+,!1#&0!0''*$*08%!'#&!-+7.0&,!M)#!$78J!#&!1:,%J!%7T0!2&07T,B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!

17T0,!%)0!S710!1#&0!7<7-%72+0!%#!%)0!F7&.*8S!&).%)1,!#'!<*''0&08%!-+7.0&,B!!

563!

Awareness!of!Time!and!Self-Governance!

;8#%)0&!%)*8S!%)7%!*,!*1-#&%78%!%#!8#%0!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!)#M!%)0!S710!

'7$*+*%7%0,!%)0!'00<27$T!+##-!20%M008!+7 2 #&!78<!+0*,:&0!*,!*%,!#F0&%!$:+%*F7%*#8!#'!78!

7M7&080,,!#'!%*10B!!;,!?!)7F0!108%*#80<J!07&+.!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!S710!<0,*S8![0BSB!/7+08!

s!q*110&178J!344f)!01-)7,*]0<!9,*T,]08%1*)7+.*U,![5664\!'+#M!0W-0&*08$0!7,!

*<07+B!!P80!#'!%)0!<0'*8*8S!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!#'!%)0!'+#M!0W-0&*08$0!*,!%)0!+#,,!#'!78!

7M7&080,,!#'!%*10B!!;,!9,*T,]08%1*)7+.*!#2,0&F0<J!-0#-+0!*8F#+F0<!*8!7$%*F*%*0,!%)0.!

'#:8<!0,-0$*7++.!08S7S*8S!&0-#&%0<!+#,*8S!%&7$T!#'!%*10!#&!'00+*8S!7,!*'!%)0!7$%*F*%.!

M7,!,#10)#M!X#:%,*<0!#'!%*10BY!!A#M0F0&J!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!*,!&0*8'#&$0<!

%)&#:S)!78!7M7&080,,!#'!%*10J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!)#M!1:$)!%*10!*,!,-08%!#8!+0*,:&0!

-&7$%*$0,B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!*%!,%78<,!%#!&07,#8!%)7%!7!S710!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!

M)*$)!*,!<00-+.!*12&*$7%0<!*8!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!<:0!%#!*%,!&0+*78$0!:-#8!7!

,:2,$&*-%*#8!1#<0+!%#!S080&7%0!-&#'*%,J!M#:+<!800<!%#!01-+#.!$0&%7*8!,%&7%0S*0,!%#!

-0&,*,%08%+.!&01*8<!-0#-+0!#'!%)0!-7,,7S0!#'!%*10B!!?!)7F0!7+&07<.!<*,$:,,0<!,#10!#'!

%)0,0!,%&7%0S*0,J!,:$)!7,!%)0!0,%72+*,)108%!#'!%*10!+*1*%,!'#&!$#1-+0%*8S!$0&%7*8!

0+0108%,B!!A#M0F0&J!?!$#8%08<!%)7%!%)0!1#,%!-0&,*,%08%!78<!0''0$%*F0!10%)#<!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,U,!:,0,!%#!$:+%*F7%0!%)*,!7M7&080,,!#'!%*10!*,!%)0!<*,-+7.*8S!#'!%)0!&07+!

M#&+<!%*10J!M)*$)!2.!<0'7:+%!*,!+#$7%0<!*8!%)0!:--0&!&*S)%!)78<!$#&80&!#'!%)0!,$&008B!!

I)*+0!%)*,!<*,-+7.!$78!20!7+%0&0<!#&!0F08!)*<<08!2.!-+7.0&,J!<#*8S!,#!&0V:*&0,!%)0!

7$%*F0!0''#&%!#'!%)0!-+7.0&J!M)#!1:,%!S#!%)&#:S)!%)&00!+7.0&,!#'!108:,!%#!$)78S0!%)0!

<*,-+7.B!!;,!,:$)J!*%!*,!+*T0+.!%)7%!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!-+7.0&,!M#:+<!$)##,0!%#!+07F0!*%!7,!

*,B!!L):,J!M)*+0!*%!*,!72,#+:%0+.!%&:0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!M#&T!%#!$#8,%&:$%!<*''0&08%!

56d!

%01-#&7+*%*0,![,00!A78,#8J!345i!'#&!7!%)#&#:S)!787+.,*,!#'!S710!%01-#&7+*%*0,\J!*%!*,!

*1-#&%78%!%#!8#%0!)#M!%)0,0!%01-#&7+*%*0,!*8%0&,0$%!M*%)!#%)0&!%01-#&7+*%*0,!78<!

%)0!F7&*#:,!'#&$0,!%)7%!,)7-0!%)0,0!*8%0&,0$%*#8,B!!

L)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!1#8*%#&*8S!78<!107,:&*8S!#80U,!%*10!*,!':&%)0&!

&0*8'#&$0<!2.!%)0!#%)0&!10%)#<,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<0-+#.,!%#!$:+%*F7%0!7!<*,-#,*%*#8!

%#M7&<,!1#8*%#&*8S!78<!S#F0&8*8S!%)0!,0+'J!,-0$*'*$7++.!*%,!:,0!#'!,%7%*,%*$,!%#!

V:78%*'.!78<!107,:&0!%)0!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!#'!%)0!-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&B!!"&7M*8S!#8!=#S#,%U,!

[344a\!$#8$0-%!#'!X-&#$0<:&7+!&)0%#&*$JY!=70&S![3446J!345f\!)7,!7&S:0<!%)7%!F*<0#!

S710,!$:+%*F7%0!78!X08%&0-&080:&*7+!,0+'Y!%)7%!*,!710872+0!%#!%)0!<0178<,!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!$7-*%7+*,1!2.!-#,*%*#8*8S!-+7.0&,!7,!&*,T!1787S0&,!M)#!1:,%!

1#8*%#&!$#8<*%*#8,J!:,0!%)0!*8'#&17%*#8!7%!)78<!%#!17T0!<0$*,*#8,J!78<!%7T0!

-0&,#87+!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!%)0,0!<0$*,*#8,B!!(+7.0&,J!%)08J!1:,%!$:+%*F7%0!7!<00-!

7M7&080,,!#'!$#8,%78%+.!$)78S*8S!$#8<*%*#8,!*8!#&<0&!%#!7$)*0F0!F*$%#&.!*8!7!F*<0#!

S710B!!I)*+0!=70&SU,![3446J!345f\!787+.,0,!M0&0!,-0$*'*$!%#!%)0!,-#&%,!S08&0J!)0!

7$T8#M+0<S0,!%)7%!%)*,!787+.,*,!$78!20!0W%08<0<!%#!78.!S08&0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!

'#&$0,!-+7.0&,!%#!7<7-%!%#!$)78S*8S!,*%:7%*#8,!78<!10<*7%0!%)0!*8'#&17%*#8!-+7.0&,!

&0$0*F0!%#!1787S0!%)0,0!,*%:7%*#8,J!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!;,!8#%0<!72#F0J!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!-&#F*<0,!-+7.0&,!M*%)!7!807&`$#8,%78%!,%&071!#'!*8'#&17%*#8!&0+7%0<!%#!

M)7%0F0&!%7,T!%)0.!)7F0!$)#,08!%#!-:&,:0!7%!7!S*F08!1#108%J!*8$+:<*8SJ!2:%!8#%!

+*1*%0<!%#J!%)0!$:&&08%!#2R0$%*F0,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!%7,TJ!)#M!1:$)!#'!78!#2R0$%*F0!%)0.!

)7F0!7$$#1-+*,)0<J!78<!%)0!,:$$0,,!#&!'7*+:&0!#'!78!*8<*F*<:7+!7$%*#8B!!

(+7.0&,!7&0!7+,#!08$#:&7S0<!%#!1#8*%#&!78<!1787S0!%)0*&!7F7%7&U,!S&#M%)!

78<!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!%)#:S)%':++.B!!K*T0!#%)0&!CCP,J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!-&#F*<0,!

56f!

-+7.0&,!M*%)!,0F0&7+!108:,U!M#&%)!#'!*8'#&17%*#8!72#:%!%)0*&!7F7%7&U,!$#8<*%*#8!%)7%!

$78!20!7$$0,,0<!7%!78.!%*10B!!L)*,!*8'#&17%*#8!*,!%.-*$7++.!&0-&0,08%0<!7,!7!+*,%!#'!

V:78%*%7%*F0!107,:&0108%,!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!%)7%!%)0!S710!<0%0&1*80,!

7&0!&0+0F78%!%#!%)0!7F7%7&U,!-0&'#&178$0J!,:$)!7,!%)0!$)7&7$%0&U,!-).,*$7+!,%&08S%)!#&!

*8%0++*S08$0B!!(+7.0&,!1:,%!:,0!%)*,!*8'#&17%*#8!%#!<0F0+#-!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&!78<!#:%'*%!

%)01!M*%)!0V:*-108%!,:*%0<!%#!%)0*&!-7&%*$:+7&!&#+0!M*%)*8!%)0!S710B!!;,!=70&S!

[345f\!$#8%08<,J!%)*,!-&#$0<:&7+!&)0%#&*$!-#,*%*#8,!-+7.0&,!7,!X08%&0-&080:&*7+!

,0+F0,!M)#!1:,%!1787S0!&*,T!2.!17T*8S!$#8,%78%!7,,0,,108%,!#'!%)0!<7%7!20*8S!

-&0,08%0<!%#!%)01Y![-B!566\B!!L)*,!-#,*%*#8*8SJ!*8!%:&8J!7+*S8,!-+7.0&,!M0++!M*%)!7!

80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!%)7%!7--&#7$)0,!+*'0!'&#1!78!0$#8#1*$!,%78<-#*8%!

M)0&0!,:2R0$%,!7&0!&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!1#8*%#&*8S!78<!1787S*8S!%)01,0+F0,J!,0+F0,!%)7%!

7&0!*8!%:&8!17<0!*8%0++*S*2+0!78<!$#8%&#++72+0!%)&#:S)!%)0!V:78%*'*$7%*#8!#'!%)0!2#<.B!!

?!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!7,-0$%!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!&0*8'#&$0,!#%)0&!7%%01-%,!2.!%)0!S710!%#!

08$#:&7S0!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!7<#-%!7!1*8<':+!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!,0+'!78<!$7&0':++.!

1#8*%#&!78<!$#8%&#+!%)01,0+F0,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M)08!*%!$#10,!%#!)#M!%)0*&!%*10!*,!

<*,%&*2:%0<!20%M008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!#%)0&J!1#&0!7:%)#&*]0<J!+72#&!

-&7$%*$0,B!!?8!,)#&%J!%)0!<0,*S8!*8%0&'7$0,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&08$#:&7S0!-+7.0&,!%#!

,-08<!%*10!*8!%)0!S710J!2:%!8#%!%##!+#8SB!!;,!M0!M*++!,00!*8!%)0!'#++#M*8S!,0$%*#8J!

)#M0F0&J!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!#8+.!10$)78*,1!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!*,!

,:,%7*80<B!!L)0!1#&0!S080&7+*]0<!,:,-*$*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!

;10&*$78!$:+%:&0!7+,#!M#&T,!%#!-&0F08%!-+7.0&,!'&#1!,-08<*8S!%##!1:$)!%*10!#8!

S71*8SJ!78!#:%$#10!%)7%!'&0V:08%+.!M#&T,!%#!&0`&#:%0!%)0!-+7.0&!27$T!*8%#!+72#&B!

56c!

The!Value!of!the!Suspicion!of!Gaming!to!Neoliberalism!

! ;,!?!<*,$:,,0<!*8!%)0!20S*88*8S!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!,0+'`$7&0!*,!,#10%)*8S!#'!7!

<#:2+0`0<S0<!,M#&<!'#&!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!!?%!$78!&080M!

&0,#:&$0,!+*T0!7%%08%*#8!%)7%!7&0!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!

2:%!*%!$78!7+,#!,0&F0!7,!X7!-#&%7+!*8%#!-+07,:&0!78<!-#+*%*$7+!$)78S0Y![O*8871#8J!

345hJ!-B!5if\J!-#%08%*7++.!<*,&:-%*8S!$7-*%7+*,1B!!;,!,:$)J!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20!

,008!7!,*%0!#'!,%&:SS+0!20%M008!,:2R0$%,J!M)#!M78%!%#!0,$7-0!'&#1!%)0!0W-+#*%7%*F0!

<0178<,!#'!$7-*%7+J!78<!%)0!'#&$0,!#'!$7-*%7+J!M)*$)!,00T!%#!$7-%:&0!78<!,:2,:10!

%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,!'#&!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!!_*<0#!S710,J!7,!7!%##+!'#&!

,0+'`$7&0J!7&0!<00-+.!*1-+*$7%0<!*8!%)*,!,%&:SS+0B!!K*T0!#%)0&!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!7--&0$*7%0<!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!%)0!&0+7W7%*#8!78<!&0+07,0!%)0.!-&#F*<0<B!!

A#M0F0&J!'#&!178.!%)*,!7--&0$*7%*#8!0W*,%0<!7+#8S,*<0!7!,:,-*$*#8!#'!%)0!0F08%:7+!

$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)*,!&0+7W7%*#8B!!?8!%)*,!,0$%*#8J!?!M*++!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!,:,-*$*#8!*,!

&0-&0,08%7%*F0!#'!7!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!-#,*%*#8,!

%)01!7,!%)&07%08*8S!%#!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!#&<0&B!!L)*,!M*<0,-&07<!

,:,-*$*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!1078M)*+0J!*8%0&,0$%,!M*%)!80#+*20&7+!*1-0&7%*F0,!%#!

1#8*%#&!78<!&0S:+7%0!%)0!,0+'!7,!-+7.0&,!7&0!08$#:&7S0<!%#!$7&0':++.!#2,0&F0!)#M!

+#8S!%)0.!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)7%!-+7.!*'!*%!)7,!S#80!#8!%##!+#8SB!!!

! >0,07&$)0&,!78<!$&*%*$,!)7F0!<#$:108%0<!%)0!0W*,%08$0!#'!%)*,!M*<0,-&07<!

,:,-*$*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0*&!0''0$%,!0W%08,*F0+.B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!/)7M![3453\!

)7,!8#%0<!%)7%!%)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,!M7,!7!$&*%*$7+!'7$%#&!*8!M)0%)0&!

#&!8#%!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&,!*<08%*'*0<!7,!XS710&,BY!!?8!1.!,%:<.!#8!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!

%0727SS*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710,![C.0&,J!345a\J!?!,*1*+7&+.!8#%0<!7!<0'08,*F080,,!71#8S,%!

56h!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#M7&<,!%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!M)*$)!?!7&S:0<!M7,!&##%0<!*8!%)0!

<0F7+:7%*#8!#'!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!2.!1#&0!17*8,%&071!$:+%:&7+!'#&$0,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,B!!

C078M)*+0J!%)0&0!*,!7!+#8S!%&7<*%*#8J!*8!2#%)!%)0!7$7<01*$!78<!%)0!-#-:+7&!-&0,,J!#'!

$&*%*$*]*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!%)0*&!+*8T,!%#!7SS&0,,*#8![0BSB!;8<0&,#8!0%B!7+BJ!3454\J!

*,#+7%*#8![0BSB!L:&T+0J!3455\J!78<!7<<*$%*#8![0BSB!;+%0&J!345a\B!!EF08!1#&0!$0+02&7%#&.!

7$$#:8%,!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!Q00U,![345f\!787+.,*,!#'!)#M!S71*8S!$78!

$#8%&*2:%0!%#!+*%0&7$.!78<!+07&8*8S!78<!=0$T!s!I7<0U,![344f\!87&&7%*F0!#'!)#M!

S710&,!7&0!,)7-*8S!2:,*80,,!-&7$%*$0,J!7&0!1#%*F7%0<!2.!7%%01-%,!%#!&0$:-0&7%0!

F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!'#&!%)0!M*<0&!-:2+*$B!

! L)*,!,:,-*$*#8!,:&'7$0<!&0-07%0<+.!*8!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!F*<0#!

S710,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M)08!7,T0<!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)0.!'0+%!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-0<!%)01!

%7T0!$7&0!#'!%)01,0+F0,!78<o#&!%)&*F0J!7,!$78!20!,008!*8!%)0!'#++#M*8S!0W71-+0,G!

;-)#8,0G!!

?!'00+!+*T0!%)0.!<#!%)0!#--#,*%0!'#&!2#%)B!I)*+0!%)0.!#80!<7.!17.!)0+-!10!

%)&*F0J!7,!?!M#:+<!+*T0!%#!M#&T!*8!#&!M*%)!F*<0#S710,!'#&!7!$7&00&J!%)0.!

$:&&08%+.!7&0!#8+.!7!%*10!<&7M!7M7.!'&#1!,$)##+J!78<!#'%08!+07<!10!%#!

80S+0$%!7,-0$%,!#'!,0+'!$7&0B!

@*$#+0G!!

@#%!&07++.J!?!M*,)!?!<*<!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,B!L)0.!7&0!7!<*,%&7$%*#8!'&#1!<7*+.!

,%&0,,#&,J!2:%!%7T0!%*10!7M7.!'&#1!%)0!20%%0&!1#&0!y&07+y!%)*8S,!*8!+*'0J!,:$)!

7,!,-08<*8S!%*10!M*%)!'&*08<,J!#&!08R#.*8S!%)0!#:%<##&,B!L#!10!%)&*F*8S!

M#:+<!20!%#!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!78<!0W-0&*08$0!+*'0!*8!7!1#&0!0W-78,*F0!

M7.B!

(7:+*80G!!

(0&,#87++.J!?!<#8w%!%)*8T!S71*8S!*,!)0+-':+!R:,%!20$7:,0!*%w,!8#%!&07+B!.#:!7&0!

8#%!<#*8S!78.%)*8S!-&#<:$%*F0!7%!7++B!().,*$7++.!.#:!7&08w%!20*8S!)07+%).!78<!

108%7++.!.#:w&0!R:,%!1:%*8S!.#:&!01#%*#8,!78<!'00+*8S,!M)*$)!*,8w%!)07+%).B!

56a!

EF08!M)08!8#%*8S!%)0!F7+:0!#'!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!,0+'!$7&0J!,0F0&7+!-7&%*$*-78%,!'0+%!*%!

80$0,,7&.!%#!V:7+*'.!%)0*&!,%7%0108%,!2.!7$T8#M+0<S*8SJ!78<!%)0&02.!$#8'*&1*8SJ!%)0!

%)&07%!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%#!-&#<:$%*F*%.B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!_0+F7!,%7%0<G!

L)0.!<#!)0+-!10!%7T0!1.,0+'!#:%!#'!1.!)07<B!;,!+#8S!7,!%)0.w&0!7!27+78$0<!

-7&%!#'!1.!+*'0J!?!<#8w%!%)*8T!*%w,!7!80S7%*F0!0''0$%B!L)0!-&#2+01!$#10,!*'!?!-+7.!

F*<0#!S710,!*8,%07<!#'!,00*8S!-0#-+0J!#&!,+00-*8S!08#:S)J!#&!78.%)*8S!7+#8S!

%)#,0!+*80,B!?!<#8w%!%)*8T!?!<#!%)7%J!78<!%)7%!?!<#!7!S##<!R#2!#'!-&*#&*%*]*8S!%)0!

7--&#-&*7%0!%)*8S,!

;--&#W*17%0+.!#80`%)*&<!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!0W-&0,,0<!,#10!,#&%!#'!:807,0!72#:%!

%)0*&!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!78<!$#8$0&8!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$#:+<!#&!<*<!*8%0&'0&0!M*%)!

#%)0&!7,-0$%,!#'!%)0*&!+*F0,B!!@#MJ!?!M*++!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!*%!*,!<027%72+0!M)0%)0&!#&!

8#%!%)0,0!0W-&0,,*#8,!M0&0!&0'+0$%*F0!#'!%)0!*8%0&87+*]0<!20+*0',!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!

#&!M0&0!,:-0&'*$*7+!-0&'#&178$0,!*8'#&10<!2.!%)0!V:0,%*#887*&0!$#8%0W%B!!L)0!

&0,07&$)!,0%%*8S!*,!7!$#8%0W%!<*,%*8$%!'&#1!#%)0&!$#8%0W%,J!M*%)!*%,!#M8!+#S*$!78<!

7F7*+72+0!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!7&0!$#8,%&:$%0<!78<!1#2*+*]0<!2.!2#%)!%)0!

&0,07&$)0&!78<!-7&%*$*-78%,!<:&*8S!%)0!&0,07&$)!08$#:8%0&B!!Q*F08!%)0!'#&17+*%.!#'!

%)0!V:0,%*#887*&0!$#8%0W%J!7,!M0++!7,!%)0!-0&$0-%*#8!#'!7$7<01*$!M#&T!7,!X,0&*#:,JY!*%!

*,!M*%)*8!%)0!&07+1!#'!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!%)0,0!&0,-#8,0,!<*<!8#%!7$%:7++.!0W-&0,,!%)0*&!

*8%0&87+!20+*0',J!2:%!M0&0!*8,%07<!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!M)7%!%)0.!*17S*80<!%)0.!,)#:+<!,7.!

*8!78!X#''*$*7+Y!,0%%*8SJ!%):,!S7*8*8S!7!$0&%7*8!<0S&00!#'!$:+%:&7+!,%7%:,B!!EF08!*'!%)*,!

M0&0!%)0!$7,0J!)#M0F0&J!%)*,!M#:+<!17T0!1.!7&S:108%!,%&#8S0&J!8#%!M07T0&J!,*8$0!

*%!M#:+<!20!':&%)0&!0F*<08$0!#'!%)0!-&*F*+0S0<!,%7%:,!#'!%)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8B!

! ;8<!M)7%!*,!%)0!$#8%08%!#'!%)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8g!!;,!M0!$78!,00!*8!%)0!72#F0!

0W71-+0,J!*%!*,!-&*17&*+.!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!2.!%)0!'00+*8S!%)7%!#80!,)#:+<!20!<#*8S!

,#10%)*8S!20%%0&B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!%)*,!<*,-#,*%*#8!*,!,%&:$%:&0<!2.!7!)*0&7&$).!#'!

56i!

F7+:0!*8!M)*$)!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!&78T,!20+#M!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,B!!;8<!

M)7%!7&0!%)0,0!#%)0&!-&7$%*$0,g!!E<:$7%*#8J!,#$*7+*]7%*#8J!0W0&$*,0J!%)0&7-.J!78<!

#F0&7++!-&#<:$%*F*%.!M0&0!%)0!1#,%!'&0V:08%+.!$*%0<!$7%0S#&*0,!#'!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!

F*<0#!S710,!<*,%&7$%0<!'&#1B!!L)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!7+*S8!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M0++!M*%)!%)0!

$#8F08%*#87+!F7+:0!,.,%01,!#'!;10&*$78!,#$*0%.J!M)*$)J!7,!A7+20&,%71![3455\!)7,!

7&S:0<J!7&0!':8<7108%7++.!,%&:$%:&0<!2.!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!%)0!)0%0&#,0W:7+!

&0-&#<:$%*F0!17%&*W!M)0&0!M#&%)!*,!<0%0&1*80<!2.!M07+%)!7$$:1:+7%*#8!78<!

&0-&#<:$%*F0!17%:&*%.![-B!3\B!!I)*+0!%)0&0!)7,!2008!7!-:,)!M*%)*8!%)0!F*<0#!S710!

*8<:,%&.!%#!7+*S8!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)!%)0,0!1#&0!$#8F08%*#87+!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!

7,!2.!01-)7,*]*8S!%)0!-&#<:$%*F0!7,-0$%,!#'!-+7.![9)0,,J!3455\!#&!%)0!*,#1#&-)*$!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710!-+7.!78<!*117%0&*7+!+72#&![D00J!344hl!".0&`

I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&J!3446\J!%)0!&0,-#8,0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!,:SS0,%!%)7%!%)*,!

0''#&%!%#!&07+*S8!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!M*%)!$#8F08%*#87+!-&#<:$%*F*%.!)7,!8#%!.0%!

%)#&#:S)+.!$#8F*8$0<!%)0!-:2+*$B!!/)710!78<!712*F7+08$0!,%*++!<00-+.!,%&:$%:&0!

178.!#'!%)0!<*,-#,*%*#8,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%#M7&<,!F*<0#!S710,B!!L)*,!,)710J!

%)#:S)J!,*%,!7+#8S,*<0!7!,%&#8S!<0,*&0!%#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,B!!?8!$#8R:8$%*#8!M*%)!07$)!

#%)0&J!%)0!<0,*&0!%#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0!,#$*7+!,%*S17!7%%7$)0<!%#!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!$78!)0+-!,:,%7*8!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!2.!08$#:&7S*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!-+7.J!

%)0&02.!&080M*8S!%)0!&0,#:&$0,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!$#8%*8:0<!#-0&7%*#8!#'!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!78<!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)7%!-+7.!%#!&0%:&8!%#!#%)0&J!1#&0!7$$0-%72+0!

-&7$%*$0,B&

566!

Conclusion!

! L#!,:117&*]0J!%)*,!$)7-%0&!)7,!2&#7<+.!7&S:0<J!:,*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7,!78!

0W71-+0J!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!&0-7*&!78<!&080M!%)0!7%%08%*F0!78<!01#%*F0!

&0,#:&$0,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!$#8%*8:0<!#-0&7%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&!2.!7''#&<*8S!

-+7.0&,!7!F7&*0%.!#'!%##+,!%#!7$)*0F0!7!,%7%0!#'!X0W$*%7%#&.!)#10#,%7,*,Y![=&.78%!s!

"7F*,J!344h\B!!?8!7<<*%*#8!%#!%)0,0!%##+,!'#&!,0+'`$7&0J!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!S710,!+*T0!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!7+,#!7''#&<,!-+7.0&,!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!1#8*%#&!78<!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!-+7.!

,0,,*#8,J!M)*$)!M)08!$#12*80<!M*%)!80#+*20&7+!*1-0&7%*F0,!%#!&0S:+7%0!%)0!,0+'!78<!

08S7S0!*8!1#&0!-&#<:$%*F0!7$%*F*%*0,!$78!&0`&#:%0!-+7.0&,!27$T!*8%#!%)0!'#&1,!#'!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&!%)7%!$7-*%7+!$78!0W%&7$%!F7+:0!78<!-&#'*%,!'&#1B!!?8!%)*,!87&&7%*F0!?!

)7F0!<0,$&*20<J!,0+'`$7&0!20$#10,!7!,*%0!#'!,%&:SS+0!20%M008!-0#-+0!78<!%)0!

*8,%*%:%*#8,!#'!$7-*%7+J!7,!-0#-+0!,00T!%#!0,$7-0!'&#1!%)0!080&F7%*8S!<0178<,!#'!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&!78<!&0$:-0&7%0!%)0*&!<0-+0%0<!-,.$)*$!78<!01#%*#87+!&0,#:&$0,!

M)*+0!$7-*%7+!7%%01-%,!%#!08,:&0!%)7%!%)*,!0,$7-0!*,!#8+.!%01-#&7&.B!!=0'#&0!1#F*8S!

#8!%#!%)0!80W%!-)7,0!#'!1.!7&S:108%J!)#M0F0&J!?!M78%!%#!-&#F*<0!7!'0M!

V:7+*'*$7%*#8,!'#&!%)*,!7&S:108%B!!L)0!'*&,%!*,!%)7%!%)*,!,%&:SS+0!20%M008!-0#-+0!78<!

$7-*%7+!*,!8#%!7!80$0,,7&.!'07%:&0!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!2:%!*,!*8,%07<!%)0!)*,%#&*$7+!-&#<:$%!#'!

*8%0&,0$%*8S!'#&$0,!78<!S#7+,!%)7%!,*1:+%780#:,+.!-&#<:$0J!+*1*%J!78<!0,$7-0!#80!

78#%)0&B!!L)7%!*,!%#!,7.J!M)*+0!%)*,!$)7-%0&!)7,!'#$:,0<!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!*%,!,-7$0!#8!

17--*8S!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!%#!,:,%7*8!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!%)7%!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&!*,!<0-08<08%!:-#8J!%)*,!#:%$#10!*,!2.!8#!1078,!7,,:&0<B!!

P%)0&M*,0J!F7&*#:,!7$%#&,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,!M#:+<!8#%!)7F0!%#!M#&T!,#!)7&<!%#!

344!

17*8%7*8!*%m!!L)0&0!7&0!$&7$T,!*8!%)0!,1##%)!#-0&7%*#8!#'!%)*,!-&#$0,,J!M)*$)!?!M*++!

0W71*80!*8!1#&0!<0-%)!*8!%)0!80W%!$)7-%0&B!!!

L)0!'*87+!V:7+*'*$7%*#8!*,!,*1-+.!%)7%J!2.!8#%*8S!)#M!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20!

,:2,:10<!2.!$7-*%7+J!?!<#!8#%!M*,)!%#!*S8#&0!%)0!F0&.!&07+!2080'*%,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!

,0+'`$7&0!$78!)7F0!'#&!*8<*F*<:7+,B!!?8!8#%*8S!)#M!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!)0+-!&0-&#<:$0!

0W-+#*%7%*F0!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!?!M#&&.!%)7%!#%)0&,!17.!*8%0&-&0%!%)0!%7&S0%!#'!1.!

$&*%*$*,1!%#!20!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!08S7S0!*8!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!&7%)0&!%)78!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!

78<!*8,%*%:%*#87+!7--7&7%:,0,!%)7%!17T0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!80$0,,7&.B!!?8!,)#&%J!?!M78%!

%#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!-&7$%*$0,!$78!)7F0!<*''0&08%!0''0$%,!<0-08<*8S!:-#8!%)0!+0F0+!#'!

72,%&7$%*#8!M0!7&0!+##T*8S!7&0!7%B!!Z#&!%)0!-0#-+0!M)#!:,0!F*<0#!S710,!%#!&0+7W!78<!

0,$7-0J!%)*,!-&7$%*$0!*,!80$0,,7&.!78<!F*%7+!'#&!%)0*&!$#8%*8:0<!0W*,%08$0B!!?%!*,!M)08!

M0!0W71*80!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-!%#!%)0*&!2&#7<0&!)*,%#&*$7+J!,#$*7+J!78<!

$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,!%)7%!%)0!1#&0!-&#2+017%*$!0+0108%,!7--07&B!!;,!P&%80&![344h\!)7,!

*8,*,%0<J!)#M0F0&J!+#$7+!-&7$%*$0,!$78!78<!'&0V:08%+.!<#!)7F0!:878%*$*-7%0<!78<!

%&78,'#&17%*#87+!0''0$%,!#8!%)0,0!1#&0!72,%&7$%!+0F0+,B!!?8!&0S7&<,!%#!,0+'`$7&0J!

O*8871#8![345h\!%##!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!$&07%0!X-#&%7+,!%#!-+07,:&0Y!

%)7%!&0,*,%!%)0!,:2,:1-%*#8!#'!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!%#!%)0!M#&T*8S,!#'!80#+*20&7+!

$7-*%7+*,1B!!?8!%)0!80W%!$)7-%0&J!M0!M*++!0W-+#&0!%)0,0!-#%08%*7+,!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!

78<!:,0!%)01!7,!7!M7.!%#!%)*8T!72#:%!)#M!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20$#10!7!-7&%!

#'!7!<*''0&08%!87&&7%*F0!%)78!%)0!#80!787+.]0<!*8!%)*,!$)7-%0&B!

345!

9A;(LE>!a!

API!IE!9;@!^/E!_?"EP!Q;CE/!LP!LA>?_E!

L)*,!$)7-%0&!0W%08<,!#8S#*8S!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!72#:%!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!

78<!%)&*F*8S!2.!0W71*8*8S!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!'#&!%)&*F*8SB!!L)*,!M*++!

&0V:*&0!8#%!#8+.!$#8%*8:*8S!1.!787+.,*,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!2:%!7+,#!$#8,%&:$%*8S!7!

<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!<*''0&,!,+*S)%+.!'&#1!%)0!#80!-&0,08%0<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!

?8!,)#&%J!%)*,!$)7-%0&!7&S:0,!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78J!78<!'&0V:08%+.!7&0J!:,0<!%#!

%)&*F0J!*'!M0!M#&T!%#!<*,08%78S+0!%)0!$#8$0-%!#'!%)&*F*8S!'&#1!%)0!F0&,*#8!#''0&0<!2.!

80#+*20&7+*,1B!!!

L#!20S*8J!?!M*++!&0%:&8!%#!O*8871#8U,![345h\!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

1*8<':+80,,!%#!-&#F*<0!0W71-+0,!#'!)#M!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20!7+*S80<!M*%)!#%)0&!

+*20&7%*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!/)0!<#0,!%)*,!2.!&01*8<*8S!&07<0&,!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!<#!

8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!':8$%*#8!7,!7!%##+!'#&!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!$7-*%7+!78<!%)0!0W-+#*%7%*#8!

#'!M#&T0&,B!!97-*%7+*,1J!7'%0&!7++J!<#0,!8#%!-&#<:$0!%)0!:&S0!'#&!,0+'`&0-7*&!#&!,0+'`

':+'*++108%J!2:%!*8,%07<!,:2,:10,!78<!0W-+#*%,!%)0,0!7+&07<.!0W*,%*8S!<0,*&0,!*8!*%,!

,:2R0$%,![-B!563\B!!Z#&!O*8871#8J!%)0!)*,%#&*$7+!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!M*%)!

$7-*%7+*,1J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!$7-*%7+U,!$#8%01-#&7&.!80#+*20&7+!0W-&0,,*#8J!)7,!$&07%0<!7!

-7&78#*<!%08<08$.!71#8S!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!%#!&0R0$%!7++!'#&1,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!'7F#&!#'!

$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!,#$*7+*]7%*#8B!!=.!<0$#:-+*8S!1*8<':+80,,!78<!#%)0&!'#&1,!#'!,0+'`

$7&0!'&#1!$7-*%7+*,%!&0-&#<:$%*#8J!O*8871#8!,:,-08<,!%)*,!-7&78#*<!&0R0$%*#8!#'!

,0+'`$7&0!78<!08$#:&7S0,!%)0!7<#-%*#8!#'!7!&0-7&7%*F0!,%78$0!%)7%!#-08,!,0+'`$7&0!

-&7$%*$0,!:-!%#!80M!-#%08%*7+,B!!!

343!

L#!,)#M!%)0!#%)0&!'#&1,!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!17.!%7T0J!O*8871#8!%:&8,!%#!

C*$)0+!Z#:$7:+%U,![56ii\!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!%)0!X$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'Y!*8!%)0!%)*&<!F#+:10!#'!

)*,!L"('.3)&.?&</E6$%"')!%&*+#S.B!!?8!%)*,!M#&TJ!Z#:$7:+%!7&S:0,!%)7%!Q&0$#`>#178!

7,$0%*$*,1!08$#:&7S0<!*%,!,:2R0$%,!%#!%:&8!%)0!,0+'!*8%#!78!#2R0$%!#'!$#8%01-+7%*#8!

78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8!2.!08S7S*8S!*8!7%%08%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!&0'+0$%*#8J!*8%&#,-0$%*#8J!

78<!$#8%01-+7%*#8B!!Z#:$7:+%!:+%*17%0+.!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!%)0,0!7,$0%*$!-&7$%*$0,!$#:+<!

20$#10!-7&%!#'!M)7%!)0!%0&1,!X-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.JY!M)*$)!$78!)0+-!-0#-+0!87F*S7%0!

-#M0&!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!%)#:S)%':++.!78<!M*%)!7!1*8*1:1!#'!<#1*87%*#8B!!L):,J!

$#8%&7&.!%#!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!-7&78#*<!7,,0&%*#8!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!$78J!78<!

%)0&0'#&0!M*++J!08$#:&7S0!%)0!7%#1*]7%*#8!#'!-0#-+0J!Z#:$7:+%U,!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!,0+'`

$7&0!&0F07+,!7!<*''0&08%!$#8'*S:&7%*#8!#'!'#&$0,!%)7%!0872+0<!%)0!7,$0%*$!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

,0+'`$7&0!%#!20!&0`&#:%0<!27$T!*8%#!%)0!,#$*7+!*8!,:$)! 7!M7.!%)7%!%)0!,:2R0$%!$#8<:$%,!

%)0*&!7''7*&,!M*%)!78!0.0!%#M7&<,!1*8*1*]*8SJ!8#%!&0-&#<:$*8SJ!0W-+#*%7%*#8!78<!

<#1*87%*#8B!!!

=.!$#1-7&*8S!%)0!7,$0%*$*,1!#'!%)0!Q&0$#`>#178,!78<!%)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!

1*8<':+80,,!1#F0108%J!O*8871#8!$#8%08<,!%)7%!#80!#'!%)0!1#,%!,*S8*'*$78%!'7$%#&,!

%)7%!+*1*%,!%)0!0%)*$7+!78<!%&78,'#&17%*F0!-#%08%*7+!#'!,0+'`$7&0!*8!$7-*%7+*,%!,#$*0%*0,!

*,!%)0!+7$T!#'!7!,#$*7+!*8'&7,%&:$%:&0!%#!,:--#&%!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!;,!Z#:$7:+%!8#%0<J!

%)0!$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'!M7,!2:*+%!*8%#!%)0!*8,%*%:%*#87+!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!Q&0$#`>#178!

,#$*0%.J!8710+.!*%,!,$)##+,J!108%#&*8S!78<!%07$)*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!%)0!,-*&*%:7+!

,0&F*$0,!#''0&0<!2.!-)*+#,#-)0&,B!!/0+'`$7&0!:8<0&!80#+*20&7+*,1J!)#M0F0&J!*,!,008!7,!

7!-0&,#87+!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.J!78<!%):,!<*,-+7$0<!#8%#!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+B!!O*8871#8!

$#8$+:<0,!)0&!7&%*$+0!2.!-#,*8S!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!)#M!,0+'`$7&0!$78!20!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!

34d!

-+07,:&0J!$#++0$%*F0!08R#.108%J!78<!-#+*%*$7+!$)78S0!M*%)*8!7!,#$*#0$#8#1*$!$#8%0W%!

%)7%!*,!#&S78*]0<!7S7*8,%!%)*,!-#,,*2*+*%.B!

L)*,!$#8$+:<*8S!$)7-%0&!M*++!:,0!%)*,!V:0,%*#8!7,!7!R:1-*8S!#''!-#*8%!%#!

<*,$:,,!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!:,0<!'#&!%)&*F*8SB!!;,!?!)7F0!<#80!*8!-&0F*#:,!

$)7-%0&,J!1.!,%7&%*8S!-#*8%!M*++!20!)#M!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!<0'*80<!%)&*F*8SB!!^8+*T0!

-&0F*#:,!787+.,0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!&0,-#8,0,J!%)#:S)J!?!M*++!<0-7&%!'&#1!%)0*&!

<0'*8*%*#8,!V:*$T+.B!!L)*,!*,!20$7:,0J!*'!M0!7&0!%#!%)*8T!72#:%!)#M!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!

$78!20!-#&%7+,!*8%#!-+07,:&0J!$#++0$%*F0!7$%*#8J!78<!-#+*%*$7+!$)78S0!k!*8!,)#&%J!*'!M0!

7&0!%#!:,0!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%#!&0%)*8T!%)0!M#&+<!78<!#:&!-#,*%*#8!M*%)*8!*%!k!?!

20+*0F0!*%!*,!*1-0&7%*F0!%)7%!M0!&0%)*8T!)#M!M0!$#8$0-%:7+*]0!%)&*F*8SB!!;,!8#%0<!*8!

9)7-%0&!fJ!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!712*F7+08%!72#:%!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!

$#8%&*2:%0<!%#!%)&*F*8SB!!?!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)*,!M7,!20$7:,0!%)0*&!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!

%)&*F*8S!M0&0!&##%0<!*8!$#8F08%*#87+!1#<0+,!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0J!M)0&0!,:$$0,,!*,!

107,:&0<!2.!%)0!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!M07+%)!78<!%)0!7$)*0F0108%!#'!01#%*#87+!17%:&*%.!

[A7+20&,%71J!3455\B!!L)&*F*8SJ!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!M7,!+7&S0+.!:8<0&,%##<!7,!%)0!

7$$#1-+*,)108%!#'!%)0,0!1*+0,%#80,B!

?!M78%!%#!%&07<!$7&0':++.!)0&0!20$7:,0!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!<*,1*,,!%)0!<0,*&0,!#'!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!L)0!-&#2+01!*,!%)7%!%)0,0!<0,*&0,!)7F0!2008!,:2,:10<!2.!

80#+*20&7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!:,0<!%#!&0-&#<:$0!0W-+#*%7%*F0J!0W$+:,*#87&.!$#8<*%*#8,B!!

L)*,!*,!%#!,7.!%)7%!?!<#!8#%!%)*8T!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7&0!M&#8S!%#!M78%!%)0,0!%)*8S,B!!

I78%*8S!,0$:&*%.J!-0&,#87+!':+'*++108%J!)07+%).!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!78<!08%0&%7*8108%!7&0!

:8<0&,%78<72+0!78<!F7+:72+0B!!A#M0F0&!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.!M#&T!%#!

$*&$:1,$&*20!%)0,0!<0,*&0,!%)&#:S)!0W$+:,*#87&.!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!F7+:0B!!I)7%!?!M78%!

34f!

%#!7&S:0!M*%)!%)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)08J!*,!%)7%!*%!*,!-#,,*2+0!%#!%)*8T!72#:%!%)&*F*8S!*8!7!M7.!

%)7%!<#0,!8#%!&0*8'#&$0!%)*,!,%7%:,!V:#J!78<!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!)0+-!:,!<#!,#B!!

L)*,!*,!20$7:,0J!M)*+0!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.!7%%01-%!%#!

$7-%:&0!78<!&0S:+7%0!-0#-+0U,!<0,*&0,J!%)7%!$7-%:&0!*,!80F0&!%#%7+B!!(0#-+0U,!<0,*&0,!

7&0!F7&*0<!78<!0W$0,,*F0B!!E,$7-0!*,!-#,,*2+0J!78<!*'!8#%)*8S!0+,0!S71*8S!*,!F0&.!

:,0':+!'#&!0,$7-*8SB!

L)*,!$)7-%0&J!%)08J!M*++!%)*8T!%)&#:S)!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!-&#F*<0!#-08*8S,!'#&!

0,$7-0J!%&78,'#&17%*#8J!78<!%)0!0%)*$7+!80S#%*7%*#8,!#'!-#M0&!&0+7%*#8,)*-,B!!?8!

-7&%*$:+7&J!%)*,!$)7-%0&!M*++!+##T!7%!%M#!10$)78*,1,!'#&!0,$7-0J!,#$*7+*%.!78<!

87&&7%*F0J!78<!<*,$:,,!%)0!#-08*8S,!%)0.!17.!$&07%0!*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&!M)08!:,0<!'#&!%)0!-:&-#,0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0B!!L)0,0!#-08*8S,!17.!8#%!

$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!:8<0&,%##<!M*%)*8!%)0!$#8F08%*#8,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!

80#+*20&7+*,1J!2:%!?!$#8%08<!%)7%!%)0.!17.!-&#F*<0!#--#&%:8*%*0,!'#&!7!<*''0&08%!T*8<!

#'!%)&*F*8S!2.!-&#F*<*8S!-+7.0&,!M*%)!%)0!%##+,!%#!*17S*80J!,:--#&%J!78<!087$%!

<*''0&08%!T*8<,!#'!M#&+<,B!!

L)*,!*,!8#%!1078%!%#!20!78!0W)7:,%*F0!7$$#:8%!#'!7++!#'!%)0!M7.,!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!$78!$&07%0!#&!0W-+#*%!'*,,:&0,!*8!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8B!!

C.!7*1!*,!1#&0!+#$7+!78<!,-0$*'*$J!*8!T00-*8S!M*%)!/0<SM*$TU,![344d\!0W)#&%7%*#8!%#!

X:8-7$T!%)0!+#$7+J!$#8%*8S08%!&0+7%*#8,!20%M008!78.!S*F08!-*0$0!#'!T8#M+0<S0!78<!

*%,!87&&7%*F0o0-*,%01#+#S*$7+!08%7*+108%,!'#&!%)0!,00T0&J!T8#M0&J!#&!%0++0&Y![-B!53f\B!!

C.!787+.%*$!,%&7%0S.J!%)08J!M7,!8#%!%#!+##T!'#&!M)7%!$#:+<!20!S080&7+*]0<!%#!+7&S0&!

-#-:+7%*#8,!'&#1!1.!0W-0&*08$0!78<!%)0!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!?8,%07<J!?!

%&*0<!%#!7--&#7$)!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*8!78!#-08!78<!$:&*#:,!7''0$%*F0!&0S*,%0&J!%#!+##T!

34c!

+0,,!7%!M)7%!N$(!)7--08*8S!78<!*17S*80!1#&0!M)7%!=.6%>&;/!)7--08*8SB!!/:$)!78!

7--&#7$)!<#0,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!-&0$+:<0!%)0!7<1*%%0<+.!+*T0+.!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!%)0!

%&78,'#&17%*F0!-#%08%*7+!#'!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$#:+<!20!,:2,:10<!78<!&0`

&#:%0<!27$T!*8%#!$7-*%7+*,1B!!?%!10&0+.!8#%0,!%)7%!,:$)!78!#:%$#10!*,!8#%!S:7&78%00<!

2.!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8'*S:&7%*#8!#'!'#&$0,!78<!&0+7%*#8,!20%M008!10<*7!7:<*08$0,J!

$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$0&,J!78<!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!%)7%!?!)7F0!<0,$&*20<B!!=.!

,#'%08*8S!1.!$#8$+:,*#8,!78<!+*1*%*8S!%)0*&!,$#-0!#'!7--+*$72*+*%.J!?!7*1!%#!&0-+7$0!

%)0!-7&78#*7!#'!$&*%*$7+!%)*8T*8S!'*&,%!8710<!2.!/0<SM*$T![344d\!*8!'7F#&!#'!78!

*8%0&-&0%*F0!-&7$%*$0!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!2.!#-0880,,!78<!)#-0B!!L)*,!7--&#7$)!*,!7+*S80<!

M*%)!,*1*+7&!*8%0&-&0%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!%)0#&0%*$7+!,%78$0,J!,:$)!7,!X-+7:,*2+0!

#-%*1*,1Y![A08<0&,#8J!345d\J!XM07T!%)0#&.Y![/0<SM*$TJ!344dl!Q*2,#8`Q&7)71J!

344h\!78<!X&0-7&7%*F0!&07<*8SY![/0<SM*$TJ!344dl!O*8871#8J!345h\B!!;+%)#:S)!

#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!<*''0&08%!#2R0$%,!78<!S#7+,J!%)0,0!*8%0&-&0%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!

%)0#&0%*$7+!,%78$0,!,)7&0!78!#-%*1*,%*$J!.0%!<*,$0&8*8S!7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!-0#-+0U,!+#$7+!- &7 $%*$0,!78<!%)0!+7&S0&!*8,%*%:%*#87+!,%&:$%:&0,!

%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!,*%:7%0<!*8B!!L)0,0!%)0#&0%*$7+!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!<00-+.!$#11*%%0<!%#!

%)0!*<07!%)7%!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8J!#8!#80!+0F0+J!$78!80F0&!$#1-+0%0+.!

S:7&78%00!%)0!V:7+*%.!#&!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!+#$7+!-&7$%*$0,J!#8!78#%)0&!+0F0+B!!!

The!Privileging!of!Togetherness!in!Cultural!Criticism!

! ?!M78%!%#!20S*8!1.!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!'*,,:&0,!*8!80#+*20&7+!$7-*%7+*,%!

&0-&#<:$%*#8!M*%)!7!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!%)0!-7&%*$:+ 7 &!T*8<,!#'!%#S0%)0&80,,!78<!

$#++0$%*F*%.!%)7%!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$#8,%&:$%,!78<!,:--#&%,B!!9#++0$%*F*%.!78<!

34h!

%#S0%)0&80,,!)7F0!7!-7&%*$:+7&+.!-#M0&':+!)#+<!#8!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!*17S*87&.!#'!%)0!+0'%J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!7,!7!10$)78*,1!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!,#$*7+!$)78S0!*,!7$)*0F0<B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!

*8!%)0*&!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!S+#27+!7,$08<78$0!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!E1-*&0J!%)0!M0++`

&0S7&<0<!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!78<!7$%*F*,%,!A7&<%!78<!@0S&*![344f\!7&S:0<!%)7%!)#-0!

78<!%&78,'#&17%*#8!&0,%0<!M*%)*8!M)7%!%)0.!$7++0<!%)0!X1:+%*%:<0JY!#&!%)0!&020++*#8!

#'!178.!7$%#&,J!7%!178.!-#*8%,J!7S7*8,%!%)0!<*''0&08%!*8,%78%*7%*#8,!#'!E1-*&0B!!!;,!

O*8871#8![345h\!)7,!8#%0<J!%)0!,:,-*$*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!71#8S!+0'%*,%!$&*%*$,!

*,!<00-+.!&##%0<!*8!7!1#&0!S080&7+!&0':,7+!%#!-+7$0!#80,0+'!7%!%)0!$08%0&!#'!#80U,!

7%%08%*#8![-B!563\B!!9#++0$%*F*%.!78<!#%)0&!'#&1,!#'!%#S0%)0&80,,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!

'*S:&0<!7,!7!80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!$)78S0B!

! L)*,!-&*F*+0S*8S!#'!$#++0$%*F*%.!0W%08<,J!?!M#:+<!7&S:0J!%#!F*<0#!S710!

$&*%*$*,1B!!L)0!-&0,:10<!*,#+7%*#8!#'!S710&,!*,!7!'&0V:08%!,#:&$0!#'!%08,*#8!M*%)*8!

17*8,%&071!10<*7!$#F0&7S0!#'!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0B!!E7&+.!$#F0&7S0!#'!F*<0#!S710!

$:+%:&0!'&0V:08%+.!*8F#T0<!%)0!*17S0!#'!%)0!,#+*%7&.!S710&!*8!#&<0&!%#!$#8'*&1!78<!

F7+*<7%0!,:,-*$*#8,!72#:%!%)0!80S7%*F0!0''0$%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!C#&0!&0$08%+.J!

)#M0F0&J!$#F0&7S0!2.!&0,07&$)0&,J!R#:&87+*,%,J!78<!S71*8S!08%):,*7,%,!)7,!%:&80<!%#!

<*,-&#F*8S!%)*,!,%0&0#%.-0!2.!$*%*8S!01-*&*$7+!0F*<08$0!$#8%&7<*$%*8S!%)0!*17S0!#'!

%)0!,#+*%7&.!S710&![/)7MJ!3454\B!!_7&*#:,!$#1-78*0,!7+,#!&0S:+7&+.!&0+07,0!*8<:,%&.!

&0-#&%,!#8!<01#S&7-)*$,!78<!-+7.!-&7$%*$0,!%#!<01#8,%&7%0!)#M!S710&,!7&0!,#$*7+!

[0BSB!K*'0$#:&,0!;,,#$*7%0,J!345f\B!!C078M)*+0J!7,!<*,$:,,0<!*8!1.!*8%&#<:$%*#8J!

&0$08%!F*<0#!S710,!,$)#+7&,)*-!)7,!%08<0<!%#!S&7F*%7%0!%#M7&<,!80$0,,7&*+.!,#$*7+!

S710,J!+*T0!CCP,J!S710,!M*%)!)07F.!$#1-0%*%*#8!$#1-#808%,J!78<!#%)0&!,#$*7+!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!,:$)!7,!,-0$%7%*8SB!!!

34a!

I)08!M0!1#F0!%#!<*,$:,,*#8,!#'!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!0''0$%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!

$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!*,!,%*++!%)0!-&*F*+0S0<!10$)78*,1!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!

%&78,'#&17%*#8!*,!%)#:S)%!%#!#$$:&B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!*8!)*,!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!80#+*20&7+!

*<0#+#S*0,!0120<<0<!*8!%)0!,-#&%,!S710!S08&0J!;8<&0M!=70&S![345f\!*8%&#<:$0,!%)0!

M#&T!#'!80%M#&T!,$)#+7&!L*]*787!L0&&78#F7!%#!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S710,!,%:<*0,!*8!

#&<0&!%#!%)*8T!%)&#:S)!)#M!-+7.0&,!17.!0,$7-0!20*8S![&0\72,#&20<!*8%#!$7-*%7+*,%!

-&7$%*$0,!78<!80#+*20&7+!&7%*#87+*%*0,B!!L0&&78#F7![3446\!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!-#+*%*$7+!

%)0#&*,%!C7:&*]*#!K7]]7&7%#U,![344f\!$#8$0-%!#'!X,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8Y!$78!)0+-!

:,!*17S*80!7+%0&87%*F0,!%#!7!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!27,0<!#8!17&T0%`27,0<!

$#1-0%*%*#8B!!;$$#&<*8S!%#!L0&&78#F7J!%)*,!%)0#&.!-#,*%*#8,!$##-0&7%*#8!7,!%)0!XT0.!

10$)78*,1!*8!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!7!F7+:0!%)7%!$78!8#!+#8S0&!20!72,%&7$%+.!0$#8#1*$!k!

2:%!*,!*8,0-7&72+0!'&#1!,:2R0$%*F0J!,#$*7+!F7+:0,!,:$)!7,!%&:%)`F7+:0,J!70,%)0%*$!

F7+:0,J!:%*+*%.!F7+:0,J!0W*,%08%*7+`F7+:0,Y![-B!3ch\B!!L)&#:S)#:%!)0&!7&%*$+0J!L0&&78#F7!

7%%01-%,!%#!$)7&%!%)0!S0807+#S.!#'!%)0!,:2,:1-%*#8!#'!%)0!&07+1!#'!+*'0!%#!0$#8#1*$!

-&7$%*$0,!M)*$)!:8<0&+*0,!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1B!!I*%)*8!%)*,!

&7%*#87+*%.J!%)0!*<0#+#S.!#'!%)0!17&T0%J!,-0$*'*$7++.!7!17&T0%!<&*F08!2.!$#1-0%*%*#8J!

*,!'*S:&0<!7,!%)0!-&*17&.!08S*80!#'!+*'0!78<!<0%0&1*80&!#'!F7+:0B!!?'!M0!7&0!%#!&0%)*8T!

78<!%&78,'#&1!%)*,!,%&:$%:&0!#'!<#1*87%*#8J!L0&&78#F7!,:SS0,%,J!M0!1:,%!%:&8!

%#M7&<,!M#&T!%)7%!7%%01-%,!%#!%)0#&*]0!,#$*7+!+*'0!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!%0&1,!78<!,:2R0$%!

-#,*%*#8,!-&#F*<0<!2.!7!17&T0%`<&*F08!-#+*%*$7+!0$#8#1.B!!K7]]7&7%#U,!$#8$0-%!#'!

,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8J!'#&!L0&&78#F7J!*,!78!0W71-+0!#'!,:$)!M#&T!20$7:,0!*%!

*8%&#<:$0,!78!X*117808%!0%)*$,Y!*8%#!,#$*7+`0$#8#1*$!+*'0!M)#,0!F7+:0!*,!-&#<:$0<!

%)&#:S)!1078,!#%)0&!%)78!0W$)78S0!F7+:0![-B!3ch\B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!L0&&78#F7!

34i!

7&S:0,!%)7%!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!7++#M,!'#&!-&#<:$%*#8!%)7%!0W*,%,!#:%,*<0!#'!

-:&0!17&T0%!10$)78*,1,B!!?8,%07<!#'!%&07%*8S!07$)!#%)0&!7,!7$%#&,!M*%)*8!7!17&T0%!

,.,%01J!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!08$#:&7S0,!-0#-+0!%#!08S7S0!#80!78#%)0&!7,!

):178!20*8S,B!!9##-0&7%*#8J!%)08J!#''0&,!78!7+%0&87%*F0!1#<0+!#'!-&#<:$%*#8J!78<!2.!

<#*8S!,#!-&#F*<0,!7!1:$)!800<0<!$)0$T!#8!%)0!-&0,:10<!*117808$0!78<!

X87%:&7+80,,Y!#'!%)0!17&T0%B!!L)*,!'#&1,!%)0!'#:8<7%*#8!#'!L0&&78#F7U,!7&S:108%,!

72#:%!80%M#&T!$:+%:&0J!M)0&0!M0!$78!,00!0W71-+0,!#'!%)*,!T*8<!#'!-&#<:$%*#8!*8!

7$%*#8B!!!

>0%:&8*8S!%#!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,J!=70&S![345f\!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!L0&&78#F7U,!

M#&T!#8!80%M#&T!$:+%:&0!$#:+<!20!0W%08<0<!%#!F*<0#!S710,J!%):,!-&#F*<*8S!S710!

,$)#+7&,!M*%)!M7.,!%#!%)*8T!%)&#:S)!)#M!%)0!80#+*20&7+!S#F0&8108%7+*%.!0120<<0<!

*8!S710,!%)7%!=70&S!)7,!<#$:108%0<!$#:+<!-#%08%*7++.!20!%&78,'#&10<!#&!

,:-0&,0<0<!2.!#%)0&!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0,B!!L)0!$##-0&7%*#8!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!7''#&<0<!

2.!,#$*7+!80%M#&T*8S!%0$)8#+#S*0,J!#'!M)*$)!$#8%01-#&7&.!F*<0#!S710,!17T0!

0W%08,*F0!:,0J!7&0!7%!%)0!$08%0&!#'!)#M!S710,!,$)#+7&,!)7F0!%)0#&*]0<!

%&78,'#&17%*F0!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!;,!,:$)J!*%!*,!M#&%)!$#8,*<0&*8S!)#M!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!

7&0!<0-+#.0<!M*%)*8!S710,J!:,*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7,!78!0W71-+0B!!!

Constructing!the!Need!for!Togetherness!in!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

;'%0&!7++J!$##-0&7%*#8!20%M008!-+7.0&,!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!'07%:&0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,B!!?%!*,!&08<0&0<!80$0,,7&.!%)&#:S)!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!*%,!$+7,,!,.,%01!78<!%)0!

S7%*8S!#'!$#8%08%!20)*8<!178<7%#&.!$##-0&7%*F0!$)7++08S0,J!8710+.!<:8S0#8,B!!I0!

M*++!20S*8!M*%)!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!$+7,,!78<!$)7&7$%0&!$&07%*#8!10$)78*$,B!!X9+7,,JY!

346!

*8!%)0!F0&87$:+7&!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!<#0,!8#%!&0'0&!%#!%)0!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8!#&S78*]0<!

7&#:8<!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!$7-*%7+J!+72#&J!78<!&0$#S8*%*#8J!7,!*%!)7,!*8!07&+*0&!-7&%,!#'!

%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!?8,%07<J!X$+7,,Y!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!78<!1#,%!#%)0&!&#+0`-+7.*8S!

S710,!&0'0&,!%#!%)0!$+7,,*'*$7%*#8!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!7$$#&<*8S!% #!%)0*&!72*+*%*0,J!78<!*,!78!

0W%&010+.!$#11#8!M7.!'#&!2#%)!787+#S:0!78<!<*S*%7+!S710,!%#!#&S78*]0!$)7&7$%0&!

72*+*%*0,!78<!,)7-0!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!10$)78*$7+!<0F0+#-108%B!!/#10%*10,J!7,!*8!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!%)*,!$+7,,*'*$7%*#8!*,!'#&17+*]0<!78<!%&78,-7&08%J!7,!-+7.0&,!7&0!7,T0<!%#!

,0+0$%!7!$+7,,!'#&!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&!'&#1!71#8S,%!7!-&0`<0%0&1*80<!-##+!#'!7F7*+72+0!

$+7,,0,B!!?8!#%)0&!&#+0`-+7.*8S!S710,J!)#M0F0&J!%)0!$+7,,!,.,%01,!7&0!+0,,!&*S*<!78<!

<0'*80<J!7++#M*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!1*W!78<!17%$)!72*+*%*0,!'&#1!7!F7&*0%.!#'!$+7,,0,B!!Z#&!

%)0!,7T0!#'!$+7&*%.J!?!M*++!&0'0&!%#!%)0!,#$*7+!,$*08$0`27,0<!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!$+7,,!7,!X,#$*7+!

$+7,,Y!78<!%)0!F*<0#!S710`27,0<!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!$+7,,!7,!X10$)78*$7+!$+7,,Y![,*8$0!$+7,,!

*,!#'%08!7!-7&%!#'!7!S710U,!10$)78*$7+!,.,%01,!78<!<0,*S8\B!!!;,!Q0&7+<!_##&)00,!

[3446\!0W-+7*8,!*8!)*,!#F0&F*0M!#'!%)0!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!,.,%01,!*8!%)0!,*8S+0`-+7.0&!

S710,!#'!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,J!)#M!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,0,!7&0!<0,*S80<!78<!&0+7%0!%#!

07$)!#%)0&!$78!&0F07+!)#M!-+7.0&,!7&0!08$#:&7S0<!2.!%)0!S710!%#!%)*8T!72#:%!78<!

1787S0!,#$*7+!<*''0&08$0,B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!,)7-0,!M)7%!'#&1,!#'!$##-0&7%*#8!78<!

$#++0$%*F*%.!71#8S,%!-+7.0&,!7&0!-#,,*2+0!M*%)*8!%)0!S710J!M)*$)!$78!S&78%!:,!

*8,*S)%!*8%#!%)0!7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!7+*S8*8S!CCP,!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!

M*%)!%)0!%&78,'#&17%*#87+!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,!<0,$&*20<!2.!L0&&78#F7![3446\!78<!=70&S!

[345f\B!!!!!!!

_##&)00,![3446\!2&#7<+.!7&S:0,!%)7%!!"#$%&!$#'$()&$78!20!:8<0&,%##<!7,!7!

%#.!'#&!+07&8*8S!)#M!%#!7--&#7$)!78<!1787S0!%)0!<*''0&08$0,!-+7.0&,!&#:%*80+.!

354!

08$#:8%0&!7,!%)0.!1#F0!%)&#:S)!%)0!*8$&07,*8S+.!<*F0&,0J!1:+%*$:+%:&7+!M#&+<!

2&#:S)%!72#:%!2.!,#$*7+!1#F0108%,!78<!%)0!*8$&07,*8S+.!$08%&7+*]0<!&#+0!#'!

S+#27+*]0<J!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!!A0!17T0,!%)*,!7&S:108%!2.!<0,$&*2*8S!%)0!,0&*0,U!

%&07%108%!#'!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,0,!78<!<*''0&08$0!7$&#,,!%)0!'*&,%!%M0+F0!08%&*0,!*8!%)0!

,0&*0,B!!A0!#&S78*]0,!%)0!,0&*0,U!F7&*0<!7--&#7$)0,!%#!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!78<!$)7&7$%0&!

<*''0&08$0,!*8%#!%)&00!X1#108%,Y!%)7%!&#:S)+.!$#&&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!$)&#8#+#S*$7+!

:8'#+<*8S!#'!%)0!,0&*0,B!!L)0!'*&,%!1#108%J!&#:S)+.!,-788*8S!%)0!S710U,!'*&,%!,*W!

08%&*0,J!*8$08%*F*]0,!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!$:+%*F7%0!7!)0%0&#S08#:,!-7&%.J!M*%)!07$)!

$)7&7$%0&!)7F*8S!<*,%*8$%!72*+*%*0,!%)7%!$#1-+0108%!#80!78#%)0&B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!%)0!

*8,%&:$%*#8!178:7+!#'!%)0!'*&,%!!"#$%&!$#'$()!0W-+*$*%+.!08$#:&7S0,!-+7.0&,!%#!$&07%0!7!

-7&%.!$#1-#,0<!#'!<*''0&08%!$+7,,0,!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!*'!%)0.!M78%!%#!20!-&0-7&0<!'#&!%)0!

S710U,!$)7++08S0,B!!Z#++#M*8S!%)*,J!%)0!<0'7:+%!-7&%.!#'!'#:&!$)7&7$%0&,!*8!%)0!'*&,%!

S710!*,!7!I7&&*#&J!M)#!'#$:,0,!#8!<0'08<*8S!#%)0&!$)7&7$%0&,J!7!I)*%0!C7S0J!

$7-72+0!#'!)07+*8S!78<!20,%#M*8S!F7&*#:,!-#,*%*F0!0''0$%,!#8!$)7&7$%0&,![$#11#8+.!

&0'0&&0<!%#!7,!X2:''*8SY!*8!$#8%01-#&7&.!F*<0#!S710!F0&87$:+7&\J!78<!7!=+7$T!=0+%!

78<!=+7$T!C7S0J!$7-72+0!#'!*8'+*$%*8S!-).,*$7+!78<!17S*$7+!<717S0!#8!0801*0,!

&0,-0$%*F0+.B!!!

;,!_##&)00,!<0,$&*20,J!%)0,0!$+7,,0,!7&0!*8*%*7++.!8#%!%*0<!%#!78.!-7&%*$:+7&!

&7$*7+J!0%)8*$J!#&!#%)0&!$:+%:&7+!,*S8 *'*0&,B !!?8!%)0!'*&,%!!"#$%&!$#'$()J!%)0!$)7&7$%0&,!

7&0!$#1-+0%0!2+78T!,+7%0,J!<0F#*<!#'!78.!)*,%#&*0,!#&!-0&,#87+*%*0,!,7F*8S!%)0!#80,!

%)7%!7!-+7.0&!*17S*87%*F0+.!*1-#,0,!#8!%)01B!!;,!%)0!,0&*0,!<0F0+#-,J!)#M0F0&J!

-+7.72+0!$)7&7$%0&,!7&0!S*F08!-&0`,$&*-%0<!-0&,#87+*%*0,!78<!)*,%#&*0,J!&0,:+%*8S!*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,0,!20$#1*8S!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!,-0$*'*$!&7$0,J!0%)8*$*%*0,J!78<!$:+%:&0,B!!

355!

Z#&!0W71-+0J!%)0!$)7&7$%0&!#'!>.<*7!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&+,!*,!%)0!+7,%!,:&F*F*8S!10120&!

#'!7!$+78!#'!,:11#80&,!$7-72+0!#'!*8F#T*8S!%)0!-#M0&,!#'!S&07%!,-*&*%:7+!20*8S,B!!

9#8,0V:08%+.J!,)0!*,!%)0!#8+.!$)7&7$%0&!$7-72+0!#'!:,*8S!%)0!X,:11#8Y!72*+*%.!*8!%)0!

S710B!!A#M0F0&J!<0,-*%0!%)0!S&7<:7+!<0F0+#-108%!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!M*%)!<*,%*8$%!

-0&,#87+*%*0,!78<!%&7*%,J!%)0!S710!,%*++!*8$08%*F*]0,!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!$:+%*F7%0!7!<*F0&,0!

-7&%.!%)&#:S)!%)0!&*S*<!78<!<*''0&08%*7+!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!72*+*%*0,!7$&#,,!$)7&7$%0&,B!

L)0!&*S*<!$+7,,!78<!$)7&7$%0&!,%&:$%:&0!#'!%)0!'*&,%!1#108%!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()!

$)78S0,!*8!%)0!,0$#8<!1#108%!*<08%*'*0<!2.!_##&)00,![3446\J!M)*$)!$#8,*,%,!#'!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&,++![566a\!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,+++&[5666\B!!I)0&07,!20'#&0!-+7.0&,!)7<!

F0&.!+*%%+0!$)#*$0!M)08!*%!$710!%#!<*,%&*2:%*8S!72*+*%*0,!%#!$)7&7$%0&,J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

,++!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,+++!'07%:&0<!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!,.,%01,!%)7%!7++#M0<!'#&!-+7.0&,!

%#!<0%0&1*80!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!72*+*%*0,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,++J!'#&!0W71-+0J!*8%&#<:$0<!

%)0!X17%0&*7Y!,.,%01J!M)0&02.!72*+*%*0,!M0&0!+*8T0<!%#!,-0$*7+*]0<!*%01,!$7++0<!

X17%0&*7Y!%)7%!$#:+<J!*8!%:&8J!20!7,,*S80<!%#!78.!$)7&7$%0&B!!;!17%0&*7!7++#M*8S!7!

$)7&7$%0&!%#!$7,%!7!+*S)%8*8S!,-0++J!%)08J!$#:+<!20!7%%7$)0<!%#!78.!$)7&7$%0&J!M)0&07,!

20'#&0!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!$7,%!7!+*S)%8*8S!,-0++!M7,!+*1*%0<!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$)7&7$%0&B!!

A#M0F0&J!7,!_##&)00,!8#%0,!%)0&0!M0&0!,%*++!+*1*%,!%#!%)*,!$)7&7$%0&!$:,%#1*]7%*#8!

*1-#,0<!2.!%)0!S710!-&#<:$0&,J!7+%)#:S)!+0,,!#2F*#:,!%)78!*8!-&0F*#:,!S710,B!!L)*,!

$710!*8!%)0!'#&1!#'!&:+0,!&0,%&*$%*8S!$0&%7*8!$+7,,0,!#'!M07-#8,!%#!$0&%7*8!$)7&7$%0&,!

78<!%)0!,%7%*,%*$7+!S&#M%)!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!7,!%)0.!S7*80<!+0F0+,B!!

Z#&!_##&)00,J!%)0,0!1#<*'*$7%*#8,!7&0!,*S8*'*$78%!'&#1!7!$:+%:&7+!-0&,-0$%*F0!

20$7:,0!%)0.!0W-&0,,!7!1#&0!'+0W*2+0!#&*08%7%*#8!%#M7&<,!*<08%*%.!$#8,%&:$%*#8B!!?8!

-&0F*#:,!*%0&7%*#8,!#'!%)0!S710J!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!,%7%*,%*$,!78<!72*+*%*0,J!78<!

353!

,:2,0V:08%+.!%)0*&!08%*&0!<0F0+#-108%J!M0&0!-&0`<0%0&1*80<B!!L)*,!M7,!0W-&0,,*F0!

#'!7!T*8<!#'!X2*#+#S*$7+!<0%0&1*8*,1JY!*'!.#:!M*++J!M)0&0!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!$+7,,!78<J!+7%0&J!

&7$0J!0%)8*$*%.J!78<!$:+%:&0!<0%0&1*80<!%)0*&!$7-7$*%*0,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,++!78<!,+++!

2&#T0!M*%)!%)*,!&*S*<!<0%0&1*8*,1!2.!7++#M*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!<*&0$%!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!7!

$)7&7$%0&U,!72*+*%*0,J!%)0&02.!&01#F*8S!%)0!&*S*<!$+7,,!,.,%01!#'!-&0F*#:,!!"#$%&

!$#'$("/(!78<!<*,08%78S+*8S!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!+:<*$!<0F0+#-108%&'&#1!%)0*&!-0&,#87+*%.J!

$:+%:&0J!78<!)*,%#&.B!!A#M0F0&J!%)0!+*1*%,!-+7$0<!#8!%)*,!<*,%&*2:%*#8!M0&0!7+,#!

,*S8*'*$78%J!7,!_##&)00,!7&S:0,J!20$7:,0!*%!7++#M0<!%)0!S710!%#!$#8%*8:0!%#!

*8$08%*F*]0!$&07%*8S!<*F0&,0!-7&%*0,B!!I)*+0!0F0&.!$)7&7$%0&!$#:+<!<#!78.%)*8SJ!8#%!

0F0&.!$)7&7$%0&!$#:+<!<#!0F0&.%)*8S!0V:7++.!M0++B!!I)*+0!%)*,!17.!&0*8%&#<:$0!

$0&%7*8!0,,08%*7+*,1,!%)&#:S)!%)0!27$T!<##&!#'!S710!10$)78*$,J!_##&)00,!*,!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!#-%*1*,%*$!72#:%!%)*,!1#108%!*8!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()!,0&*0,!20$7:,0!*%!,%*++!

'#&$0,!%)0!-+7.0&!%#!M&0,%+0!M*%)!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!#'! #- 0&7%*8S!*8!7!M#&+<!%)7%!*,!

,:'':,0<!M*%)!,#$*7+!<*''0&08$0!M)*+0!&0,*,%*8S!0,,08%*7+*]*8S !#&!0&7,*8S!%)#,0!

<*''0&08$0,B!!!

L)*,!'7$0%!#'!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,!*,!S&07%+.!<*1*8*,)0<!*8!%)0!%)*&<!

1#108%!*<08%*'*0<!2.!_##&)00,J!$#1-&*,*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*&78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*++B!!

A0&0!%)0!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!,%&:$%:&0!*,!&0+7W0<!%#!%)0!-#*8%!#'!*&&0+0F78$0!7,!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*++U,!$)7&7$%0&!<0F0+#-108%!,.,%01,![$7++0<!%)0!X/-)0&0!

Q&*<Y!78<!XK*$08,0!=#7&<Y!&0,-0$%*F0+.\!:+%*17%0+.!7++#M!'#&!0F0&.!$)7&7$%0&!%#!<#!

0F0&.%)*8S!0V:7++.!M0++B!!I)*+0!%)*,!<#0,!)7F0!%)0!0''0$%!#'!$#1-+0%0+.!<*,08%78S+*8S!

7!$)7&7$%0&U,!)*,%#&.!78<!-0&,#87+*%.!'&#1!%)0*&!$7-7$*%*0,J!*%!<#0,!,#!2.!:+%*17%0+.!

0&7,*8S!78.!<*''0&08$0,!*8!$7-7$*%*0,B!!;,!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*!78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*++!

35d!

-&#S&0,,J!-+7.0&,!7&0!*8$08%*F*]0<!%#!<0F0+#-!$)7&7$%0&,!7+#8S!$#8F0&S*8S!-7%),!

:8%*+!7++!#'!%)0!$)7&7$%0&,!7&0!:8*'#&1B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!M)*+0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*!<#0,!+*1*%!

M07-#8!%.-0,!%#!,-0$*'*$!$)7&7$%0&,J!%)0!<*''0&08$0,!20%M008!%)0,0!M07-#8!%.-0,!

7&0!1*8*17+!7,!%)0!M07-#8,!7&0!72+0!%#!20!$:,%#1*]0<!2.!%)0!-+7.0&B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*++&0&7,0,!0F08!%)0,0!1*8*17+!<*''0&08$0,!2.!7++#M*8S!0F0&.!$)7&7$%0&!%#!0V:*-!

0F0&.!%.-0!#'!M07-#8B!!L)0!$#8,0V:08$0,!#'!%)*,J!7,!_##&)00,!0W-+7*8,J!*,!%)0!

1*8*1*]7%*#8!#&!#:%&*S)%!0&7,:&0!#'!<*''0&08$0,!20%M008!$)7&7$%0&,!7,!-+7.0&,!7&0!

*8$08%*F*]0<!%#!$&07%0!7!)#1#S08#:,!-7&%.!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!M)#!*8<*F*<:7++.!7&0!

$7-72+0!#'!78.%)*8S!78<!0F0&.%)*8SB!!L)0,0!,.,%01,J!*8!%:&8J!7&0!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!*<0#+#S*$7+!&0,-#8,0!%#!1:+%*$:+%:&7+*,1J!M)*$)!*,!%#!&0-&0,08%!<*''0&08$0!

7,!,#10%)*8S!%#!$#8V:0&!78<!1#F0!20.#8<B!!!

L)*,!)*,%#&.!'#&1,!%)0!'#:8<7%*#8!#'!%)0!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!,.,%01!%)7%!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!<0-+#.,B!!^8+*T0!*8!,*8S+0`-+7.0&!!"#$%&!$#'$("/(J!)#M0F0&J!-+7.0&,!7&0!

8#%!S*F08!7!-&0<0%0&1*80<!$7,%!#'!$)7&7$%0&,!2:%!1:,%!*8,%07<!$&07%0!%)0*&!#M8!

7F7%7&J!M)#!':8$%*#8,!7,!%)0*&!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!*8!%)0!S710!M#&+<B!!(+7.0&,!<#!%)*,!7%!

%)0!$#1108$0108%!#'!%)0!S710J!M)0&0!%)0.!1:,%!7,,*S8!%)0*&!7F7%7&!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

&7$0J!S08<0&J!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,J!78<!7--07&78$0B!!A#M0F0&J!M)*+0!S08<0&!78<!&7$0!

&017*8!*11:%72+0J!%):,!20%&7.*8S!78!*8F0,%108%!*8!$0&%7*8!'#&1,!#'!2*#+#S*$7+!

<0%0&1*8*,1J!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,J!78<!%):,!%)0*&!$7-7$*%*0,J!7&0!:8'*W0<!

78<!$)78S072+0B!!P8$0!%)0.!)7F0!&07$)0<!7!$0&%7*8!+0F0+!*8!%)0*&!$+7,,U,!<0F0+#-108%J!

-+7.0&,!7&0!'&00!%#!,M*%$)!%)0*&!$)7&7$%0&U,!$+7,,!%#!78.!#%)0&!7F7*+72+0!$+7,,!78<!

<0F0+#-!%)7%!$+7,,!7,!M0++B!!A#M0F0&J!:8+ *T 0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*&78<!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*++J!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*,!78!CCP!%)7%!)07F*+.!01-)7,*]0,!$##-0&7%*8S!78<!$##&<*87%*8S!

35f!

.#:&!7$%*#8,!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!(&#F*<*8S!7!,0&F*$0!'#&!,#$*7+*]7%*#8!*,!7!-#M0&':+!

7%%&7$%*#8!'#&!-+7.0&,J!,*8$0!%)0!S710!$78!20$#10!7!M7.!%#!$&07%0!78<!17*8%7*8!

&0+7%*#8,)*-,!20%M008!-0#-+0B!!".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&![3446\!)7F0!S#80!,#!

'7&!7,!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!%)0!1:+%*-+7.0&!$7-72*+*%*0,!#'!,:2,$&*-%*#8`27,0<!CCP,!+*T0!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7&0!$&*%*$7+!%#!S080&7%*8S!-&#'*%!'#&!%)0!S710U,!-&#<:$0&,J!,*8$0!

-+7.0&,!'&0V:08%+.!&0+.!#8!CCP,!%#!$&07%0!78<!,:,%7*8!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!M)*$)!

08$#:&7S0,!-+7.0&,!%#!$#8%*8:0!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710J!M)*$)!*8!%:&8!&0V:*&0,!

17*8%7*8*8S!7!-7*<!,:2,$&*-%*#8!%#!%)0!S710![7,!#'!%)*,!M&*%*8SJ!7!,:2,$&*-%*#8!%#!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&$#,%,!|5fB66!7!1#8%)\B!

L)*,!1078,!%)7%!%)0&0!*,!7!,*S8*'*$78%!*8$08%*F0!'#&!%)0!<0F0+#-0&,!#'!%)0!S710!

%#!08$#:&7S0!-+7.0&,!%#!-+7.!M*%)!#%)0&,B!!P80!M7.!%)*,!*,!7$$#1-+*,)0<!*,!%)&#:S)!7!

10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!,.,%01!%)7%!08,:&0,!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!<*''0&08$0,!20%M008!07$)!

-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&!%)7%!,*S8*'*$78%+.!)*8<0&J!*'!8#%!#:%&*S)%!-&0F08%J!7!,#+*%7&.!-+7.0&!

'&#1!7$$#1-+*,)*8S!7++!#'!%)0!S710U,!%7,T,B!!L)0!<0F0+#-0&,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!

$#8,%&:$%!%)0!80$0,,*%.!#'!*8%0&<0-08<08$0!20%M008!$)7&7$%0&,!2.!-&0F08%*8S!

-+7.0&,!'&#1!<*,%&*2:%*8S!72*+*%*0,!20%M008!%)0!F7&*#:,!$+7,,0,B!!L):,J!+*T0!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*!78<!*++J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7++#M,!7!$)7&7$%0&U,!7F7%7&!%#!17,%0&!0F0&.!

,*8S+0!72*+*%.!*8!%)0!S710B!!A#M0F0&J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!-&0F08%,!7!-+7.0&U,!$)7&7$%0&!

'&#1!7$$0,,*8S!7++!#'!%)#,0!72*+*%*0,!,*1:+%780#:,+.B!!I)08!7!$)7&7$%0&!,M*%$)0,!

$+7,,0,J!%)0.!+#,0!7$$0,,!%#!7++!#'!%)0!72*+*%*0,!#'!%)0*&!-&0F*#:,!$+7,,B!!I)*+0!%)0,0!

72*+*%*0,!$78!20!&0S7*80<!2.!&0F0&%*8S!27$T!%#!%)7%!$+7,,J!$+7,,!$)78S*8S!*,!-&0F08%0<!

<:&*8S!$0&%7*8!,0S108%,J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)#,0!,0S108%,![+*T0!X<:8S0#8,Y\!%)7%!

35c!

0W-+*$*%+.!&0V:*&0!7!-7&%.!$#1-#,0<!#'!1:+%*-+0!-+7.0&,B!!D#:!$78!<#!*%!7++J!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!,001,!%#!20!,7.*8SJ!R:,%!8#%!7%!%)0!,710!%*10B!

?!-&#-#,0!%)7%!%)0,0!$)78S0,!%#!%)0!$+7,,!,.,%01!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&

&0-&0,08%J!%#!:,0!_##&)00,U!%0&1*8#+#S.J!7!X'#:&%)!1#108%Y!*8!%)0!'&78$)*,0!%)7%!

,.8%)0,*]0,!%)0!'*&,%!78<!,0$#8<!1#108%U,!01-)7,*,!#8!80S#%*7%*8S!<*''0&08$0!M*%)!

%)0!%)*&<!1#108%U,!01-)7,*,!#8!-+7.0&!$:,%#1*]7%*#8B!!=.!17T*8S!07$)!$+7,,!7!

<*,$&0%0!-&#'0,,*#8!78<!+#$T*8S!72*+*%*0,!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$+7,,J!%)0!S710!7++#M,!'#&!

-+7.0&,!%#!0W-0&*108%!78<!-+7.!M*%)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!&#+0,!M)*+0!,%*++!17*8%7*8*8S!7!800<!

'#&!*8%0&<0-08<08$0!78<!$##-0&7%*#8B!!L)0!80$0,,*%.!#'!80S#%*7%*8S!<*''0&08$0!*,!

1#,%!$+07&+.!<01#8,%&7%0<!*8!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!<:8S0#8,B!!X":8S0#8,Y!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,!7&0!$#1-+0W!17]0,!%)7%!'07%:&0!,%&#8S0&!0801*0,!78<!20%%0&!&0M7&<,!%)78!7!

-+7.0&!M#:+<!'*8<!0+,0M)0&0B!!I)*+0!-+7.0&,!$#:+<!%0$)8*$7++.!-+7.!%)&#:S)!

<:8S0#8,!7+#80J!%)0!S710!<0,*S8!,%&#8S+.!<*,$#:&7S0,!%)*,!7--&#7$)B!!/*8$0!0801*0,!

*8!<:8S0#8,!7&0!,%&#8S0&J!1#&0!8:10&#:,J!78<!)7F0!1#&0!$#1-+0W!;B?B!&#:%*80,!

%)78!$#8F08%*#87+!0801*0,J!7!,#+#!-+7.0&!*,!+*T0+.!%#!20!#F0&M)0+10<!78<!T*++0<!

:8+0,,!%)0.!-#,,0,,!0W%&010+.!-#M0&':+!0V:*-108%!%)7%!*,!:,:7++.!#8+.![+0S7++.\!

#2%7*872+0!2.!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!<:8S0#8,B!!!Z:&%)0&1#&0J!M)*+0!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!

<:8S0#8,!17.!20!#-%*#87+!<*F0&,*#8,!*8!#%)0&!CCP,!,:$)!7,!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'!78<!

G"?'J!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&7!-+7.0&!1:,%!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!<:8S0#8,!%#!-&#S&0,,!%)&#:S)!

%)0!17*8!,%#&.+*80!78<!:8+#$T!-7&%*$:+7&!2080'*%,J!,:$)!7,!X1#:8%,JY!#&!F0)*$+0,J!

%.-*$7++.!78*17+,J!%)7%!7!-+7.0&!$78!&*<0!%#!%&7F0+!%#!#2R0$%*F0,!'7,%0&B!!!!!

A#M0F0&J!*8!1.!0W-0&*08$0!%)0!,%&#8S0,%!*8$08%*F0!%#!XS&#:-!:-Y!%#!-+7.!*8!

<:8S0#8,!*,!'#:8<!*8!%)0!S710U,!X<:8S0#8!'*8<0&Y!%##+B!!Z*&,%!*8%&#<:$0<!*8!A.3%>&.?&

35h!

A$3=3$?'J!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&!%##+,!)7F0!,*8$0!20$#10!7!807&!:8*F0&,7+!'07%:&0!*8!CCP,!

20$7:,0!%)0.!7&0!7!$#8F08*08%!M7.!%#!7,,012+0!7!'7,%!78<J!,*S8*'*$78%+.J!%01-#&7&.!

S&#:-!%#!:8<0&%7T0!7!,-0$*'*$!$)7++08S0B!!I)*+0!%)0!S710!-&#F*<0,!-+7.0&,!M*%)!%)0!

72*+*%.!%#!$&07%0!#%)0&J!1#&0!,%72+0!S&#:-,!78<!$#11:8*%*0,J!%)0!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&!%##+!

0872+0,!-+7.0&,!M)#!0*%)0&!7&0!8#%!-7&%!#'!,:$)!#&S78*]7%*#8,J!+*T0!,#+#!-+7.0&,J!#&!

M)#,0!&0S:+7&!-7&%.!10120&,!7&0!:87F7*+72+0!%#!V:*$T+.!-7*&!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!78<!

:8<0&%7T0!7!S*F08!$)7++08S0B!!L)*,!S&07%+.!*8$&07,0,!7!-+7.0&U,!$#8%&#+!#F0&!%)0*&!

-&#S&0,,*#8!%)&#:S)!%)0!S710U,!,%#&.!7,!%)0.!7&0!8#%!,#!<0-08<08%!#8!%)0!,$)0<:+0,!

78<!<0178<,!#'!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!#-08+.!08$#:&7S0,!-+7.0&,!%#!:,0!

%)0!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&J!0F08!S#*8S!,#!'7&!7,!%#!*8$+:<0!*%!*8!%)0!V:0,%!<0,$&*-%*#8,!#'!

<:8S0#8,![0BSB!X:,0!%)0!<:8S0#8!%)0!'*8<0&!%##+!%#!08%0&!/7,%7,)7Y\B!!!

L#!:,0!%)0!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&J!7!-+7.0&!1:,%!,*1-+.!,0+0$%!%)0!%##+!'&#1!%)0!

,.,%01!108:J!,0+0$%!M)*$)!$)7++08S0!.#:!M78%!%#!:8<0&%7T0J!,:$)!7,!7!,-0$*'*$!

<:8S0#8!#&!2#,,!'*S)%J!78<!M7*%!'#&!%)0!,.,%01!%#!-7*&!.#:!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!I)7%!

*,!,*S8*'*$78%!'#&!1.!<*,$:,,*#8J!)#M0F0&J!*,!%)0!+#S*$!%)0!%##+!:,0,!%#!7,,012+0!

S&#:-,B!!I)08!:,*8S!%)0!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&J!%)0!%##+!7:%#17%*$7++.!&0S*,%0&,!.#:!7,!#80!

#'!%)&00!X&#+0,Y![X%78TJY!X<717S0JY!#&!X)07+0&Y\!27,0<!#8!%)0!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!.#:!

)7F0!$:&&08%+.!7,,*S80<!%#!.#:&!$)7&7$%0&B!!L)0,0!&#+0,!$#&&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!

10$)78*$7+!$+7,,U,!%&7<*%*#87+!':8$%*#8!M*%)*8!78!CCP!S&#:-J!M*%)!%7,T,!,:$)!7,!

7%%7$T*8S!0801*0,J!<0'08<*8S!%)0!-7&%.J!78<!)07+*8S!#&!,:--#&%*8S!#%)0&!-7&%.!

10120&,!<*,%&*2:%0<!20%M008!%)0!<*''0&08%!&#+0,B!!Z#&!%)0!<:8S0#8!%#!$#1108$0J!

%)0,0!%)&00!&#+0,!800<0<!%#!20!'*++0<!7$$#&<*8S!%#!%)0!$#1-#,*%*#8!<0%0&1*80<!2.!%)0!

S710![%.-*$7++.!#80!%78TJ!#80!)07+0&J!78<!%M#!<717S0!<07+0&,\B!!;,!'0M0&!$+7,,0,!

35a!

M0&0!<0,*S87%0<!7,!X%78TY!78<!X)07+0&Y!%)78!X<717S0JY!%)0,0!&#+0,!:,:7++.!%##T!

+#8S0&!%#!'*++![7+%)#:S)J!,*8$0!?!-+7.0<!-&*17&*+.!7,!7!)07+0&J!1.!M7*%!%*10,!M0&0!

-&#272+.!,)#&%0&!%)78!%)0!17R#&*%.!#'!-+7.0&,\B!!?8!<:8S0#8,J!M)*+0!#F0&%!

$#11:8*$7%*#8J!0*%)0&!2.!F#*$0!#&!2.!%0W%J!*,!8#%!&0V:*&0<J!$##&<*87%*#8!78<!

$##-0&7%*#8!*,B!!/:$$0,,':+!$#1-+0%*#8!#'!7!<:8S0#8!&0V:*&0,!07$)!-+7.0&!%#!

:8<0&,%78<!)#M!%)0*&!$+7,,!':8$%*#8,!*8!7!S&#:-!78<!M)7%!%7,T,!%)0.!7&0!0W-0$%0<!%#!

-0&'#&1J!M)*$)!<*''0&,!,*S8*'*$78%+.!'&#1!,#+#!-+7.!M)0&0!7!-+7.0&!*,!&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!

0F0&.%)*8SB!!L)0!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!,#+#!78<!S&#:-!-+7.!*,!,#!,)7&-!%)7%!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!01-+#.,!78!08%*&0!%:%#&*7+!,0$%*#8!-&*#&!%#!%)0!'*&,%!<:8S0#8!

08$#:8%0&0<!<:&*8S!%)0!17*8!,%#&.!%)7%!0W-+*$*%+.!%07$)0,!-+7.0&,!M)7%!%)0,0!

0W-0$%7%*#8,!7&0!78<!)#M!%#!20,%!':+'*++!%)01B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!7,!7!)07+0&!1.!%&7*8*8S!

,0$%*#8!'#$:,0<!#8!)#M!%#!:,0!72*+*%*0,!%#!)07+! M #:8<0<!-+7.0&,J!)#M!%#!)07+!

1:+%*-+0!$)7&7$%0&,J!78<!)#M!%#!<#<S0!0801.!7%%7$T,!M)*+0!)07+*8SB!!":&*8S!7!

<:8S0#8J!?!M#:+<!'#$:,!#8!%)0,0!7$%*F*%*0,![M)*$)!$#1-&*,0<!7!F0&.!87&&#M!

,-0$%&:1!#'!%)0!72*+*%*0,!7F7*+72+0!%#!1.!$)7&7$%0&\!M)*+0!+07F*8S!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!%#!

$7&&.!#:%!%)0*&!#M8!7$%*F*%*0,B!

;,!,:$)J!%)0!$+7,,!,.,%01!01-+#.0<!2.!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!20,%!0W-&0,,0<!

%)&#:S)!*%,!<:8S0#8!<0,*S8!78<!%)0!7$$#1-78.*8S!<:8S0#8!'*8<0&!%##+J!$&07%0,!78<!

&0*8'#&$0,!%)0!<*''0&08$0,!20%M008!*8<*F*<:7+!$)7&7$%0&,!78<!17T0,!%)0,0!

<*''0&08$0,!,*S8*'*$78%!78<J!$&:$*7++.J!:87F#*<72+0B!!L)*,!M#&T,!%#!:8<0&1*80!%)0!

-&#$0<:&7+!&)0%#&*$!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*&78<!*++J!M)*$)!_##&)00,![3446\!7&S:0,!

*8$08%*F*]0!)#1#S080*%.!78<!%):,!0W-&0,,0,!78!X0%)8#$08%&*$J!7,,*1*+7%*#8*,%!

7--&#7$)!%#!$#-*8S!M*%)!$:+%:&7+!<*''0&08$0JY!M)0&0!<*''0&08$0!*,!:+%*17%0+.!0&7,0<!

35i!

7,!$)7&7$%0&,!-&#S&0,,B!!L)*,!X7,,*1*+7%*#8*,%Y!&)0%#&*$!*,!+7&S0+.!*8$#1-7%*2+0!M*%)!

%)0!$+7,,!,.,%01!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!M)*$)!08$#:&7S0,!%)0!$&07%*#8!#'!

)0%0&#S08#:,!-7&%*0,B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!*,!+7&S0+.!*8'+:08$0<!2.!%)0!,#$*7+!$#8F08%*#8,!#'!

%)0!CCP!S08&0!78<!%)0!0$#8#1*$!*8$08%*F0!%#!0W%08<!7!-+7.0&U,!08S7S0108%!M*%)!

%)0!S710J!78<!%):,!%)0*&!,:2,$&*-%*#8J!%)&#:S)!%)0,0!,#$*7+!10$)78*$,B!

The!Limitations!of!Togetherness!in!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

A#M0F0&J!R:,%!20$7:,0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!08$#:&7S0,!,#10!'#&1!#'!

$##-0&7%*#8!20%M008!-+7.0&,!<#0,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!1078!%)7%!*%!M*++!S080&7%0!%)0!

,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!*17S*80<!2.!K7]]7&7%#![344f\J!L0&&78#F7![3446\J!78<!

=70&S![345f\!%)7%!$#:+<!-#%08%*7++.!$#:8%0&7$%!7!17&T0%`$08%0&0<!80#+*20&7+!

-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.B!!?8!1.!0W-0&*08$0,!M*%)!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!)7F0!08$#:8%0&0<!

,0F0&7+!+*1*%*8S!'7$%#&,!0120<<0<!*8!2#%)!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!%)0!S710!78<!%)0!

$#11:8*%*0,!#'!-&7$%*$0!%)7%!)7F0!010&S0<!7&#:8<!%)0!S710!%)7%!M#&T!7S7*8,%!

-&7$%*$0,!#'!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8B!!L)0!'*&,%!+*1*%*8S!'7$%#&!%)7%!?!M78%!%#!<*,$:,,!

7&0!%)0!17%0&*7+!+*1*%,!%#!$##-0&7%*#8B!!;,!?!,%7%0<!-&0F*#:,+.J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<#0,!

7''#&<!-+7.0&,!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!F*7!*8`S710!%0W%`27,0<!

$)7%!78<!F#*$0!$)7%B!!A#M0F0&J!%)7%!72*+*%.!$78J!78<!#'%08!*,J!+*1*%0<!2.!%)0!)7&<M7&0!

800<0<!%#!0''*$*08%+.!$#11:8*$7%0!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M)08!-+7.*8S!#8!7!

<0<*$7%0<!S71*8S!$#8,#+0!+*T0!%)0!(+7.,%7%*#8!f![7,!?!<*<\B!!_#*$0!$)7%J!%)0!1#,%!

0''*$*08%!1078,!#'!$#11:8*$7%*#8J!&0V:*&0,!7!,-0$*7+*]0<!0W%0&87+!1*$&#-)#80J!,:$)!

7,!%)0!#80,!'#:8<!*8!,-0$*7+*]0<!S71*8S!)07<,0%,J!%)7%!7!-+7.0&!1:,%!7$V:*&0!

*8<0-08<08%+.!#'!2#%)!%)0!$#8,#+0!)7&<M7&0!78<!%)0!S71*8S!,#'%M7&0B!!!

356!

/)#:+<!7!-+7.0&!<0$*<0!%#!'#&0S#!F#*$0!$)7%J!%)0.!1:,%!$#11:8*$7%0!M*%)!

#%)0&!-+7.0&,!F*7!%)0!*8`S710!$)7%B!!A0&0!7S7*8!-+7.0&,!7&0!'7$0<!M*%)!17%0&*7+!

+*1*%7%*#8,B!!(+7.0&,!17.!%.-0!10,,7S0,!%#!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!:,*8S!0*%)0&!78!0W%0&87+!

=+:0%##%)!T0.2#7&<!#&!78!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<B!!;8!0W%0&87+!T0.2#7&<!*,!1#&0!0''*$*08%!

%)78!%)0!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<B!!Z#&!#80J!-+7.0&,!<#!8#%!)7F0!%#!-&0,,!1:+%*-+0!2:%%#8,!

%#!7$$0,,!%)0!0W%0&87+!T0.2#7&<!k!%)0!S710!&0$#S8*]0,!M)08!78!0W%0&87+!T0.2#7&<!*,!

20*8S!:,0<!78<!,#!-&0,,*8S!78.!T0.!#8!%)0!T0.2#7&<!7:%#17%*$7++.!08%0&,!%)0!

-+7.0&,!*8%#!$)7%B!!!

;8#%)0&J!1#&0!,*S8*'*$78%!27&&*0&!%#!$#11:8*$7%*#8J!78<!)08$0!%#!

,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8J!*,!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!%)0!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<!%)7%!-+7.0&,!1:,%!

:,0!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!M*%)!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!*'!%)0.!<#!8#%!)7F0!7$$0,,!%#!0W%0&87+!

1*$&#-)#80,!#&!M*&0+0,,!T0.2#7&<,B!!I)*+0!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!%)0!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<!

&0,012+0,!7!%&7<*%*#87+!jIE>LD!T0.2#7&<J!1#F*8S!20%M008!T0.,!&0V:*&0,!-&0,,*8S!

2:%%#8,!*8,%07<!#'!1#F*8S!.#:&!)78<!%)&#:S)!,-7$0B!!9#1-7&0<!%#!%)0!#%)0&!

$#11:8*$7%*#8!%0$)8#+#S*0,!<*,$:,,0<J!:,*8S!%)0!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<!*,!,+#MJ!

&0V:*&*8S!1*8:%0,!%#!*8-:%!10,,7S0,!%)7%!M#:+<!&0V:*&0!#8+.!,0$#8<,!*8!#%)0&!

10%)#<,B!!L)*,!+*1*%7%*#8!$78!20!<0F7,%7%*8S!*8!7!S710!%)7%!&0V:*&0,!V:*$T!&07$%*#8,!

%#!$)78S*8S!27%%+0'*0+<!$*&$:1,%78$0,B!!K7$T*8S!7$$0,,!%#!0*%)0&!78!7--&#-&*7%0!

1*$&#-)#80!#&!7!M*&0+0,,!T0.2#7&<J!78<!%):,!&0+*78%!:-#8!%)0!*8`S710!T0.2#7&<J!?!

M#:+<!S080&7++.!R:,%!<0$+*80!%#!$#11:8*$7%0!7%!7++!M)08!?!-+7.0<!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!

/:$)!7!-&7$%*$0J!M)*+0!8#%!*<07+J!M7,!7+,#!8#%!%&07%0<!7,!:8:,:7+!#&!720&&78%!2.!%)0!

&78<#1!-+7.0&,!?!M7,!-7*&0<!M*%)B!!?8!1.!0W-0&*08$0J!'0M!-+7.0&,!17<0!:,0!#'!78.!#'!

%)0!$)7%!'07%:&0,!M)*+0!-+7.*8S!%)&#:S)!<:8S0#8,B!!L)0!17R#&*%.!#'!$)7%!10,,7S0,!

334!

#$$:&&0<!7%!%)0!$#1108$0108%!78<!$#8$+:,*#8!#'!<:8S0#8,![*B0B!20'#&0!78<!7'%0&!

78.!$)7++08S0,!#$$:&\J!78<!M0&0!+*1*%0<!%#!-#+*%0J!S080&*$!S&00%*8S,!78<!0W-&0,,*#8,!

#'!S&7%*%:<0B!!?!M7,!7+,#!80F0&!#F0&%+.!$)7,%*,0<!'#&!<0$+*8*8S!%#!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!%)0,0!

&*%:7+!0W$)78S0,J!7,!?!)7F0!2008!'#&!'7*+*8S!%#!'#++#M!$#11:8*$7%*#8!0W-0$%7%*#8,!*8!

#%)0&J!#''+*80!$#8%0W%,B!!!

L)*,!+07<!10!%#!20+*0F0!%)7%!*%!M7,!7!S080&7++.!7$$0-%0<!8#&1!M*%)*8!%)0!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!%)7%!$)7%%*8S!M*%)!,%&78S0&,!<:&*8S!1:+%*-+7.0&!0F08%,!M7,!8#%!

0W-0$%0<B!!I)*+0!%)*,!%.-0!#'!#F0&%!$#11:8*$7%*#8!M7,!8#%!80$0,,7&.!'#&!%)0!

$#1-+0%*#8!#'!%)0!S710U,!$)7++08S0,!`!<:&*8S!%)&00!1#8%),!#'!<7*+.!-+7.!1.!S&#:-,!

80F0&!'7*+0<!%#!$#1-+0%0!7!%7,T!k!?!M#:+<!$#8%08<!%)7%!*%!*,!7!,*S8*'*$78%!+*1*%7%*#8!'#&!

%)0!7$)*0F0108%!#'!%)0!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!%)7%!L0&&78#F7![3446\!78<!=70&S!

[345f\!#-%*1*,%*$7++.!-:%!'#&M7&<!7,!78!7+%0&87%*F0!%#!%)0!$#1-0%*%*F0!0%)#,!#'!

17&T0%`<&*F08!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.B!!;,!L0&&78#F7!<0,$&*20,J!,.1-7%)0%*$!

$##-0&7%*#8!$78!':8$%*#8!7,!7!$)0$T!#8!80#+*20&7+*,1U,!17&T0%`27,0<!*<0#+#S.!2.!

08$#:&7S*8S!-0#-+0!%#!%&07%!#80!78#%)0&!7,!':++!):178!20*8S,J!&7%)0&!%)78!7,!7$%#&,!

*8!7!17&T0%!,.,%01B!!I)*+0!%)0!$#11:8*$7%*#8!-&7$%*$0,!7''#&<0<!2.!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,!<*<!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!-#,*%*#8!-+7.0&,!7,!7$%#&,!*8!7!17&T0%!,.,%01J!%)0.!7+,#!<*<!

8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!08$#:&7S0!-+7.0&,!%#!%)*8T!#'!#80!78#%)0&!7,!':++!):178!20*8S,B!!

A0&0!?!M*++!7S7*8!:,0!1.,0+'!78<!1.!0W-0&*08$0,!7,!78!0W71-+0B!!;,!78!*8%&#F0&%!M)#!

7+,#!,:''0&,!'&#1!78W*0%.!78<!<0-&0,,*#8J!*8%0&7$%*#8,!M*%)!-0#-+0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!

,%&78S0&,J!*8!7!$#1-0%*%*F0!$#8%0W%!M*%)!$+07&!M*8!78<!+#,0!$#8<*%*#8,!$78!20!7!

'&7:S)%!0W-0&*08$0B!!?8!#&<0&!%#!87F*S7%0!%)0,0!$*&$:1,%78$0,J!?!M#:+<!#'%08!%&.!%#!

%)*8T!#'!%)0!#%)0&!$)7&7$%0&,!#8!,$&008!M*%)!10!8#%!7,!7F7%7&,!$#8%&#++0<!2.!#%)0&!

335!

):178,J!2:%!7,!$#1-:%0&`$#8%&#++0<!$)7&7$%0&,!,*1*+7&!%#!%)0!8:10&#:,!#%)0&!

$#1-:%0&`$#8%&#++0<!7$%#&,!?!)7<!08$#:8%0&0<!<:&*8S!,#+#!-+7.B!!?!M*++!8#%!,7.!%)7%!?!

M7,!0F0&!72+0!%#!':++.!20+*0F0!%)*,J!2:%!7--&#7$)*8S!1:+%*-+7.0&!7$%*F*%*0,!'&#1!%)*,!

-0&,-0$%*F0!)0+-0<!10!%#!,00!)#M!+*%%+0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<#0,!%#!08$#:&7S0!-+7.0&,!

%#!%&07%!#80!78#%)0&!7,!':++J!08%*%+0<!):178!20*8S,!&7%)0&!%)78!#2R0$%,!0W*,%*8S!*8!7!

&0-&0,08%7%*#87+!,-7$0B!!L#!20!'7*&J!*%!<#0,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!-&0F08%!%)*,J!0*%)0&B!!=:%!

2.!17T*8S!%)0!0%)*$7+!%&07%108%!#'!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!%)0!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!#'!%)0!-+7.0&,J!

78<!8#%!7!,%78<7&<!'07%:&0!#'!%)0!S710U,!<0,*S8J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<#0,!+*%%+0!%#!

08,:&0!%)7%!-+7.0&,!7&0!%&07%0<!M*%)!<*S8*%.!78<!&0,-0$%B!!?8!7!$#1-0%*%*F0!S71*8S!

$#8%0W%!M*%)!01#%*#87+!,%7T0,J!*%!*,!7++!%##!07,.!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!,+*<0!*8%#!20)7F*#&,!

%)7%!17.!17&S*87+*]0!#&!%&7:17%*]0!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!I)*+0!%)0&0!7&0!10$)78*,1,!'#&!

-+7.0&,!%#!&0-#&%!72:,0!%#!%)0!S710U,!1#<0&7%#&,J!%)*,!*,!7!&07$%*#87&.!10$)78*$!

%)7%!7S7*8!<*,-+7$0,!%)0!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!-#+*$*8S!72:,0!#8!%#!%)0!F*$%*1,!#'!72:,0B!

L)*,!+07<,!%#!78#%)0&!$)7++08S0!-+7.0&,!'7$0!*8!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!#'!

,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!k!%)0!<*,R:8$%:&0!20%M008!%)0!0W-0$%7%*#8,!0,%72+*,)0<!2.!

%)0!S710!78<!%)0!,#$*7+!78<!$:+%:&7+!0W-0$%7%*#8,!%)7%!-+7.0&,!2&*8S!%#!78<!$#8,%&:$%!

%)&#:S)!%)0!S710B!!;,!?!108%*#80<!20'#&0J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!-&#F*<0,!78!0W%08,*F0!

%:%#&*7+!-&#S&71!-&*#&!%#!%)0!$#1108$0108%!#'!%)0!'*&,%!1:+%*-+7.0&!7$%*F*%.!

178<7%0<!2.!%)0!17*8!,%#&.+*80B!!L)*,!%:%#&*7+!-&#S&71!*8%&#<:$0,!-+7.0&,!%#!%)0*&!

<0,*S87%0<!&#+0!M*%)*8!1:+%*-+7.0&!7$%*F*%*0,!78<J!%):,J!0,%72+*,)0,!,-0$*'*$!

10$)78*$7+!0W-0$%7%*#8,!'#&!M)7%!-+7.0&,!7&0!,:--#,0<!%#!<#!M*%)*8!%)7%!$#8%0W%B!!

A#M0F0&J!?!M7,!8#%!&0V:*&0<![#&!0F08!08$#:&7S0<\! %#!+07&8!72#:%!)#M!%)0!#%)0&!

<0,*S87%0<!&#+0,![X%78TY!78<!X<717S0Y\!M0&0!0W-0$%0<!%#!-0&'#&1!*8!1:+%*-+7.0&!

333!

7$%*F*%*0,B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!<#0,!8#%!-&#F*<0!7!'&710M#&T!'#&!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!)#M!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!-+7.J!0*%)0&!10$)78*$7++.!#&!*8!7!2&#7<0&J!$:+%:&7+!

,08,0B!!!

L)*,!$78!+07<!%#!1*,:8<0&,%78<*8S,!78<!$#8'+*$%,!20%M008!-+7.0&,J!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!M)08!%)0!10$)78*$7+!0W-0$%7%*#8,!-:%!'#&M7&<!2.!%)0!S710!78<!%)0!

0W-0$%7%*#8,!#'!%)0!-+7.0&,!7&0!#:%!#'!7+*S8108%B!!L)*,!M7,!*++:,%&7%0<!%#!10!<:&*8S!

#80!<:8S0#8!0W-0&*08$0B!!?!M7,!$#8'#&1*8S!%#!%)0!0W-0$%7%*#8,!%)0!S710!)7<!

0,%72+*,)0<!'#&!)#M!7!)07+0&!-0&'#&1,!*8!<:8S0#8,!k!?!M7,!)07+*8S!%7&S0%,!78<!

,%7.*8S!#:%!#'!%)0!M7.!#'!0801*0,B!!A#M0F0&J!%)*,!<*<!8#%!100%!%)0!0W-0$%7%*#8,!#'!7%!

+07,%!#80!#%)0&!-+7.0&J!M)#!,08%!10!7!10,,7S0!%)&#:S)!$)7%G!XA07+0&!.#:!T8#M!.#:!

$78!<#!<717S0!7,!M0++gY!!C.!'*0+<!8#%0,!7%!%)0!%*10!17<0!8#%0!#'!%)0!'00+*8S,!#'!

0127&&7,,108%!78<!78S0&!%)7%!%)*,!$#1108%!-&#F#T0<!*8!10!k!0127&&7,,108%!7%!

'7*+*8S!%#!100%!%)0!0W-0$%7%*#8,!#'!#%)0&!-+7.0&,!78<!78S0&!7%!M)7%!?!%)#:S)%!M7,!78!

:8&07,#872+0!<0178<B!!^8,:&0!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!-&#%#$#+,!*8!%)*,!$*&$:1,%78$0J!?!

7$V:*0,$0<!%#!%)0!-+7.0&U,!&0V:0,%!78<!20S78!<717S*8S!0801*0,!*8!20%M008!)07+*8S!

7++*0,B!!K7%0&!?!7,T0<!,0F0&7+!'&*08<,!#'!1*80!1#&0!'71*+*7&!M*%)!%)0!$:+%:&0!#'!CCP,!

M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)*,!M7,!7!$#11#8!0W-0$%7%*#8!#'!)07+0&,B!!L)0.!&0-+*0<!%)7%!

<717S*8S!0801*0,J!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!)07+*8SJ!M7,!8#%!7!&0V:*&0108%!#'!)07+0&,J!2:%!%)7%!

*%!M7,!X8*$0!M)08!*%!)7--080<BY!!!

?!-#*8%!%#!%)*,!0W71-+0J!)#M0F0&J!8#%!#8+.!%#!*++:,%&7%0!)#M!%)0!0W-0$%7%*#8,!

0,%72+*,)0<!2.!7!S710!78<!%)0!,#$*7+!$#8F08%*#8,!%)7%!010&S0!7&#:8<!%)0!-+7.*8S!#'!

7!S710!$78!<*F0&S0!'&#1!#80!78#%)0&J!2:%!7+,#!%#!8#%0!)#M!%)0!<0178<,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!

*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$78!'7++!:80F08+.!#8!<*''0&08%!-+7.0&,J!%):,!,)7-*8S!M)#!)7,!

33d!

7$$0,,!%#!%)0!80%M#&T0<!,-7$0,!78<!%)0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!-&#F*<0<!2.!%)0!S710B!!

C:$)!)7,!2008!M&*%%08!72#:%!)#M!#8+*80!S71*8S!,-7$0,!7&0!#'%08!'&7:S)%!M*%)!

%08,*#8!78<!72:,0J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!'#&!F:+80&72+0!78<!17&S*87+*]0<!-#-:+7%*#8,!M)#!

'7++!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!*17S*80<!7:<*08$0!#'!F*<0#!S710,![0BSB!Q&7.J!345fl!9)0,,!s!/)7MJ!

345c\B!!I)7%!?!M78%!%#!8#%0!*,!%)7%!0F08![&0+7%*F0+.\!S08%+0!&0$#1108<7%*#8,!+*T0!

%)0!#80!-&#F*<0<!%#!10!*8!%)0!08$#:8%0&!<0,$&*20<!72#F0!$78!'7++!)7&,)+.!#8!-+7.0&,!

M)#J!'#&!F7&*#:,!&07,#8,J!7+&07<.!-0&$0*F0!#8+*80!,-7$0,!7,!%)&07%08*8SB!!I)*+0!?!<#!

8#%!M78%!%#!S080&7+*]0!1.!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!,)710!78<!0127&&7,,108%!%#!#%)0&!

-+7.0&,J!#&!0F08!$+7*1!%)7%!,:$)!7!&07$%*#8!*,!$#11#8J!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!<*,1*,,!*%!

#:%&*S)%!0*%)0&B!!I)7%!?!*8,%07<!M78%!%#!<#!M*%)!%)*,!0W-0&*08$0!*,!,:SS0,%!%)7%!% )0&0!

*,!7!&78S0!#'!$#11:8*$7%*F0!0W-&0,,*#8,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!*8!#8+*80!,-7$0,!#:%,*<0!#'!

#F0&%!)7%0!,-00$)J!#''08,*F0!+78S:7S0J!#&!#%)0&!#F0&%!'#&1,!#'!72:,0!%)7%!$78!

80F0&%)0+0,,!7+*087%0!-0#-+0!'&#1!%)0,0!,-7$0,B!!I*%)#:%!,:''*$*08%!,%&:$%:&0,!*8!

-+7$0!%#!0<:$7%0!-+7.0&,!#8!)#M!%#!$&07%0!*8$+:,*F0!,-7$0,!78<!0,%72+*,)!

$#11:8*$7%*F0!8#&1,!%)7%!-&*F*+0S0!<*F0&,*%.J!%)0!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!%)7%!

L0&&78#F7![3446\!7&S:0,!$78!-&#F*<0!7+%0&87%*F0,!%#!%)0!80#+*20&7+!-&*F*+0S*8S!#'!

17&T0%!$#1-0%*%*#8!M*++!&017*8!0+:,*F0!*8!#8+*80!,-7$0,B!

Thriving!and!Togetherness!in!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

I)7%!<#0,!%)*,!)7F0!%#!<#!M*%)!%)&*F*8Sg!!;,!?!)7F0!<*,$:,,0<!20'#&0J!1.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!'&0V:08%+.!$#880$%0<!%)&*F*8S!M*%)!,:$$0,,!78<!':+'*++108%B!!A#M0F0&J!

%)0!,:$$0,,!78<!':+'*++108%!*17S*80<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M0&0!+7&S0+.!$#8,%&:$%0<!

M*%)*8!78!*<0#+#S*$7+!'&710M#&T!%)7%!#8+.!&0$#S8*]0,!,:$$0,,!78<!':+'*++108%!:,*8S!

33f!

%&7<*%*#87+![&0G!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!$7-*%7+*,%*$\!17&T0&,G!*8<*F*<:7+!-&#<:$%*F*%.!78<!

7$)*0F0108%J!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!M07+%)J!78<!01#%*#87+!17%:&*%.!17&T0<!2.!%)0!

0,%72+*,)108%!#'!7!<#10,%*$!'71*+.B!!;S7*8J!?!M78%!%#!&0*%0&7%0!%)7%!%)0&0!*,!8#%)*8S!

80$0,,7&*+.!M&#8S!M*%)!:,*8S!%)0,0!7,!17&T0&,!'#&!%)&*F*8SB!!I)7%!*,!-&#2+017%*$!*,!

M)08!%)0.!20$#10!%)0!.#%)!17&T0&,!'#&!%)&*F*8SJ!78<!7,!,:$)!20$#10!-7&%!#'!7!

8#&17%*F0!,.,%01!%)7%!17*8%7*8,!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!%)&#:S)!%)0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!

#'!2#%)!17%0&*7+!&0,#:&$0,!78<!,.12#+*$!&0$#S8*%*#8B!!!!!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!2.!78<!+7&S0J!<#0,!+*%%+0!%#!$)7++08S0!#&!0W-78<!%)*,!

$#8$0-%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!%)&#:S)!*%,!,#$*7+!10$)78*$,B!!;,!?!7&S:0<!*8!%)0!-&0F*#:,!

$)7-%0&J!*%,!<0,*S8!*,!7%!+07,%!-7&%*7++.!*8F0,%0<!*8!7!80#+*20&7+!,#$*7+`0$#8#1*$!

'#&17%*#8!%)7%!*,!<0-08<08%!#8!&0`&#:%*8S!-0#-+0!'&#1!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

&0$:-0&7%*#8!78<!&080M7+!27$T!*8%#! - &#<:$%*F0!+72#&!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!$78!20!

1#80%*]0<!78<!0W-+#*%0<B!!L)*,!,#$*7+`0$#8#1*$!'#&17%*#8J!*8!%:&8J!*,!<*,$:&,*F0+.!

,:--#&%0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!,:$$0,,!M*%)!M07+%)!7$$:1:+7%*#8!78<!%)0!

0,%72+*,)108%!#'!,%72+0!,#$*7+!&0+7%*#8,)*-,B!!I)*+0!#80!#'!%)0!0+0108%,!01-)7,*]0<!

*8!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!17&T0%*8S!*,!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!0,%72+*,)!,#$*7+!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!

78<!2:*+<!7!$#11:8*%.!k!*%,!M02,*%0!-&#1*808%+.!7<F0&%*,0,!%)7%!-+7.0&,!$78!X'#&1!

+7,%*8S!'&*08<,)*-,!78<!101#&*0,Y!k!*8!-&7$%*$0!%)0&0!7&0!,0F0&7+!27&&*0&,!*8!-+7$0!

%)7%!-&#)*2*%!%)*,J!'&#1!%)0!10$)78*$7+!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!%)0!S710U,!*8%0&'7$0!%#!%)0!

$:+%:&7+!8#&1,!78<!0W-0$%7%*#8,!#'!-+7.0&,!<0F0+#-0<!*8!&0,-#8,0!%#!%)0!S710U,!

7''#&<78$0,!78<!+*1*%7%*#8,B!!;,!80%M#&T!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!=7.1![3444\!78<!C7&T)71!

[566i\!&01*8<!:,J!-+7.0&,!<#!8#%!08%0&!*8%#!#8+*80!,-7$0,!7,!2+78T!,+7%0,B!!L)0.!

*8,%07<!2&*8S!M*%)!%)01!%)0!$:+%:&7+!8#&1,!78<!7%%*%:<0,!$:+%*F7%0<!*8!#%)0&!,-7$0,J!

33c!

M)*$)!*8!%:&8!*8'#&1!%)0*&!20)7F*#&!78<!-&7$%*$0,!*8!#8+*80!,-7$0,B!!=.!<0$+*8*8S!%#!

0W-+*$*%+.!$#<*'.!7!,0%!#'!*8$+:,*F0!8#&1,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!78<!%:%#&!-+7.0&,!*8!%)01!*8!7!

M7.!,*1*+7&!%#!)#M!%)0!S710!%:%#&,!-+7.0&,!*8!*%,!10$)78*$,J!*%!*,!7++!%#!07,.!%#!

&0-&#<:$0!%)0!,#$*7+!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!17T0!#%)0&!-:2+*$!,-7$0,!,#!%)&07%08*8S!%#!

10120&,!#'!17&S*87+*]0<!$#11:8*%*0,B!!L)*,J!*8!%:&8J!17T0,!*%!$)7++08S*8S!%#!

0,%72+*,)!%)0!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!<*,$:,,0<!2.!K7]]7&7%#![344f\J!L0&&78#F7!

[3446\J!78<!=0&S![3446J!345f\B!!?8!1.!#M8!*8'#&17+!<*,$:,,*#8,!M*%)!'&*08<,!M)#!

-+7.!CCP,J!%)0.!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)0!20,%!M7.!%#!08,:&0!7!M0+$#1*8S!,#$*7+!0W-0&*08$0!

*8!CCP,!M7,!%#!-+7.!M*%)!'&*08<,!10%!*8!#%)0&!$#8%0W%,J!0*%)0&!#''+*80!#&!%)&#:S)!

#%)0&!,#$*7+!10<*7!-+7%'#&1,B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.!%)7%!,:$)!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!$788#%!20!

0,%72+*,)0<!:,*8S!%)0!%##+,!-&#F*<0<!2.!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!>7%)0&J!1.!7&S:108%!*,!

%)7%!%)0!<0,*S8!#'!%)0!,#$*7+!$#1-#808%,!#'!%)0!S710!<#0,!8#%!08$#:&7S0!%)0!

'#&17%*#8!#'!%)0,0!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!78<!%):,!17T0,!*%!1#&0!+*T0+.!%)7%!%)0!-:2+*$!

$&07%0<!*8!%)0!S710!M*++!&0-&#<:$0!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!17T0!-:2+*$!,-7$0,!

%)&07%08*8S!'#&!F:+80&72+0!S&#:-,B!

The!Problem!of!Togetherness!on!the!Left!

L)*,!2&*8S,!10!%#!7!+7&S0&!-&#2+01!M*%)!)#M!%)0!K0'%!)7,!*17S*80<!%)0!

:8'#+<*8S!#'!$)78S0!78<!-&#S&0,,B!!;,!?!%#:$)0<!:-#8!7%!%)0!20S*88*8S!#'!%)*,!

$)7-%0&J!?!20+*0F0!%)0&0!*,!78!#F0&01-)7,*,!#8!,#$*7+*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!*8!K0'%!

-#+*%*$7+!%)*8T*8SJ!7,!2#%)!7!10$)78*,1!'#&!,%&:$%:&7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8!78<!%)0!

*17S*80<!&0,:+%!#'!%)*,!,%&:$%:&7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8B!!!

33h!

O*8871#8![345h\!0W-+*$*%+.!$)7++08S0,!%)*,!%08<08$.!#8!%)0!K0'%J!M&*%*8S!!

I)7%!17.!&0,:+%!*,!,0+'`80S+0$%!#&!78!#F0&0,%*17%*#8!#'!$#++0$%*F*%.J!7,!*'!

+*20&7%*#8!78<!R#.!&0,:+%!'&#1!%)0!10&0!7$%!#'!%#S0%)0&80,,B!!9&*%*$,!#'%08!

&0':,0!M#&T!#8!%)0!,0+'!20$7:,0!*%!20$#10,!*8%0&$)78S072+0!M*%)!7!

80#[+*20&7+\!7&$)*%0$%:&0!#'!$#8%&#+J!78<!20$7:,0!*%!*,J!*8!'7$%J!*117%0&*7+!

+72#&B!!=:%!*'!$7-*%7+*,%!&0$:-0&7%*#8!,*1-+.!$788#%!20!7F#*<0<J!*,!*%!M#&%)!

-7&,*8S!#:%!7!<*''0&08$0!20%M008!X,0+'`$7&0Y!*8!,0&F*$0!%#!$7-*%7+!78<!%)0!T*8<!

#'!X$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'Y!,#!+7:<0<!2.!Z#:$7:+%g![-B563\B!

I)*+0!O*8871#8!&0,0&F0,!)0&!$&*%*V:0!#'!%)0!#F0&01-)7,*,!#8!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!

%#S0%)0&80,,!%#!%)0!<#17*8!#'!K0'%*,%!-#+*%*$7+!%)*8T*8SJ!?!M#:+<!0W%08<!%)*,!':&%)0&J!

7&S:*8S!%)7%J!7%!+07,%!M*%)*8!;10&*$78!$:+%:&0J!%)0&0!*,!<00-!$:+%:&7+!20+*0'!*8!%)0!

,:-0&*#&*%.!#'!%#S0%)0&80,,B!!/:,78!97*8![3453\J!*8!)0&!-#-:+7&!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!

$:+%:&7+!,*S8*'*$78$0!#'!*8%&#F0&,*#8J!$7++,!%)*,!XL)0!EW%&#F0&%!?<07+Y![-B!f\B!!;,!,)0!

<0,$&*20,!*%J!%)0!EW%&#F0&%!?<07+!*,!!

%)0!#18*-&0,08%!20+*0'!%)7%!%)0!*<07+!,0+'!*,!S&0S7&*#:,J!7+-)7J!78<!

$#1'#&%72+0!*8!%)0!,-#%+*S)%B!!L)0!7&$)0%.-7+!0W%&#F0&%!-&0'0&,!7$%*#8!%#!

$#8%01-+7%*#8J!&*,T`%7T*8S!%#!)00<`%7T*8SJ!$0&%7*8%.!%#!<#:2%B!!A0!'7F#&,!

V:*$T!<0$*,*#8,J!0F08!7%!%)0!&*,T!#'!20*8S!M&#8SB!!/)0!M#&T,!M0++!*8!%071,!78<!

,#$*7+*]0,!*8!S&#:-,B!!I0!+*T0!%#!%)*8T!%)7% ! M0!F7+:0!*8<*F*<:7+*%.J!2:%!7++!%##!

#'%08!M0!7<1*&0!#80!')F/!#'!*8<*F*<:7+!k!%)0!T*8<!M)#U,!$#1'#&%72+0!X-:%%*8S!

)*1,0+'!#:%!%)0&0BY![-B!f\!

C.!$&*%*V:0!#'!%)*,!%08<08$.!M*%)*8!%)0!K0'%!<#0,!8#%!&0,%!#8!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

,%&:$%:&7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8,!$788#%!#$$:&!%)&#:S)!,#$*7+!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!

%#S0%)0&80,,B!!?%!*,!+*T0+.!%)7%J!'#&!,#10!-0#-+0!7%!+07,%J!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!

7&0!80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8,!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!C.!-&#2+01!*,!%)7%J!2.!#F0&01-)7,*]*8S!

$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,J!M0!7&0!-#%08%*7++.!#F0&+##T*8S!#%)0&!10$)78*,1,!'#&!

,#$*7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8!78<!+*1*%*8S!)#M!M0!*17S*80!7!1#&0!:%#-*78!,#$*0%.!M)#,0!

&0,#:&$0,J!2#%)!17%0&*7+!78<!*117%0&*7+J!7&0!<*,%&*2:%0<!1#&0!0V:*%72+.B!!C.!M#&&.!

33a!

*,!%)7%!M0!&*,T!7+*087%*8S!-0#-+0!M)#!%)&*F0!20,%!:8<0&!,#$*7+!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!7 ''#&<!

%)01!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!M*%)<&7M!'&#1!%#S0%)0&80,,B!

Imagining!Different!Futures!

! ?!20+*0F0!%)7%!%)0!0W71-+0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$78!)0+-!:,!,00!2#%)!%)0!

+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!7!-&#S&0,,*F0!-#+*%*$,!$08%0&0<!#8!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!7,!M0++!

7,!%)0!%&78,'#&17%*F0!-#%08%*7+!#'!M*%)<&7M7+B!!>0%:&8*8S!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!3dxJ!

#&!&#:S)+.!7!V:7&%0&J!#:%&*S)%!,7*<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!<#!8#%!-&#1#%0!%)&*F*8SB!!L)*,!

-0&$08%7S0!M7,!,+*S)%+.!)*S)0&!'#&!-0#-+0!M)#!*<08%*'*0<!7,!,%&7*S)%![36x\!%)78!'#&!

-0#-+0!M)#!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!8#8`8#&17%*F0!,0W:7+*%.![34x\B!!I*%)*8!7!80#+*20&7+!

-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.J!78<!%)0!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,J!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!+*'0!87&&7%*F0,!%)7%!*%!

-&*F*+0S0,J!*%!M#:+<!20!$)7++08S*8S!%#!*17S*80!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!$#1-#808%!

#'!%)&*F*8SB!!?8!78!*<07+!M#&+<!#&S78*]0<!2.!80#+*20&7+*,1J!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!

M#:+<!)0+-!-0#-+0!$7&0!'#&!%)01,0+F0,!78<!&0-7*&!%)0!-,.$)*$!<717S0!M&#:S)%!2.!

*117%0&*7+!+72#&!,#!%)7%!:+%*17%0+.!%)0.!$#:+<!&0%:&8!%#!+72#&B!!L):,J!M)*+0!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!*8,%&:108%7+!%#!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!78<!

$#8,0V:08%+.!80#+*20&7+*,1J!*%!*,!8#%!%)0!*17S*80<!S#7+!#'!%)*,!,#$*7+!'#&17%*#8B!!

I)08!7,T0<!%#!<0'*80!%)&*F*8SJ!7,!<*,$:,,0<!*8!$)7-%0&!fJ!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!+7&S0+.!

<0,$&*20<!78!7''0$%*F0!,%7%0!#'!)7--*80,,!78<!,7%*,'7 $% *#8!-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!

1078*8S':+!+72#&!78<!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!%.-*$7++.!-&#R0$%0<!*8%#!%)0!':%:&0B!!@#!

-7&%*$*-78%,!,%7%0<!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!*8!78<!#'!*%,0+'J!M7,!%)&*F*8SB!

! A#M0F0&J!*'!7!V:7&%0&!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%!-#-:+7%*#8!&0R0$%0<!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$#:+<!20!7!-7&%!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!%)0!&0,%!#'!1.!-#-:+7%*#8![*B0B!aax!

33i!

#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!%)&00!V:7&%0&,\!M0&0!7%!+07,%!M*++*8S!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!*<07!%)7%!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)&*F*8S!M0&0!$#1-7%*2+0!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&B!!?!71!,7.*8S!

XM*++*8S!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!*<07Y!20$7:,0!X%)&*F*8SY!M7,!8#%!7!M#&<!%)7%!M7,!87%*F0!%#!

%)0!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,!%)7%!?!M7,!72+0!%#!%7-!*8%#B!!?!$0&%7*8+.!)7<!80F0&!

08$#:8%0&0<!*%!7,!7!10120&!#'!<*''0&08%!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,B!!9#8,0V:08%+.!?!

20+*0F0!%)7%J!'#&!178.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!20*8S!0W-#,0<!%#!%)0!$#8$0-%!#F0&!%)0!

$#:&,0!#'!1.!V:0,%*#887*&0!M7,!%)0!'*&,%!%*10!%)0.!M0&0!7,T0<!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0,0!%M#!-&7$%*$0,B!!/#!*%!M#:+<!20!:8&07+*,%*$!%#!0W-0$%!178.!

-7&%*$*-78%,!%#!08%):,*7,%*$7++.!08<#&,0!78!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!%)0*&!-&7$%*$0,![*B0B!%)7%!

S71*8S!)0+-0<!%)01!%#!%)&*F0\!%)7%!M7,!7+*08!%#!%)01B!!!

! ;--&#W*17%0+.!%)&00!V:7&%0&,!#'!%)0!-#-:+7%*#8J!%)#:S)J!M0&0!M*++*8S!%#!

$#8,*<0&!%)7%!%)*,!&0+7%*#8,)*-!0W*,%0<B!!I)7%!?!71!*8%0&0,%0<!*8!0W-+#&*8S!'#&!%)0!

&017*8<0&!#'!%)*,!$)7-%0&!7&0!%)0!'07%:&0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!$78!-#%08%*7++.!+07<!

-+7.0&,!%#!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!%)&*F*8S!78<!)#M!%)7%!$78!)0+-!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,$)#+7&,!

&0%)*8T!%)0!10$)78*,1,!%)&#:S)!M)*$)!,#$*7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8!$78!#$$:&B!!P8!*%,!

,:&'7$0J!*%!M#:+<!20!)7&<!%#!*17S*80!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$#8%&*2:%*8S!%#!%)&*F*8SJ!

0*%)0&!'&#1!7!80#+*20&7+!-0&,-0$%*F0J!,*8$0!*%!*,!8#%!7!'#&1!#'!-&#<:$%*F0!+72#&J!#&!

'&#1!7!1#&0!-&#S&0,,*F0!-0&,-0$%*F0J!,*8$0!%)0!%.-0,!#'!$#11:8*%*0,!7''#&<0<!2.!

%)0!S710!7&0!8#%!0,-0$*7++.!7+*S80<!M*%)!%)0!%.-0,!#'!$#11:8*%*0,!*17S*80<!%#!20!

08$#:&7S*8S!#'!7!1#&0!R:,%!78<!0V:*%72+0!M#&+<B!!A#M0F0&J!?!$#8%08<!%)7%!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!$78!-&#F*<0!F7+:72+0!%##+,!'#&!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!%)&*F*8SB!!D#:!R:,%!)7F0!%#!

T8#M!M)0&0!%#!+##TB!!9&*%*$7+!S71*8S!,$)#+7&,!)7F0!%.-*$7++.!'#&0S&#:8<0<!%)0!,#$*7+!

0+0108%,!#'!S71*8S!7,!%)0!20,%!08S*80,!#'!,#$*7+!%&78,'#&17%*#8!%)&#:S)!S71*8SB!!

336!

A#M0F0&J!?!$#8%08<!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!#%)0&!-#%08%*7+!7F08:0,!'#&!*17S*8*8S!':%:&0!

M#&+<,!#:%,*<0!#'!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,B!!?'!M0!#8+.!+##T!'#&!%&78,'#&17%*F0!

-&7$%*$0,!*8!$#++0$%*F*%.!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!M0!&*,T!1*,,*8S!M)7%!?!

%)*8T!*,!*%,!1#,%!F7+:72+0!$#8%&*2:%*#8!%#!-&#S&0,,*F0!-#+*%*$,!k!*%,!?$#'$()B!!L)*,!

'78%7,.J!1#&0#F0&J!*,!8#%!-&#<:$0<!%)&#:S)!*%,!,#$*7+!10$)78*$,J!M)*$)!7,!M0!)7F0!

,008!&*,T!&0-&#<:$*8S!0W*,%*8S!:80F08!,#$*7+!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!2: % !*8!*%,!87&&7%*F0!78<!

M#&+<B!

@#MJ!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!*8!S710!,%:<*0,!78<!1#&0!2&#7<+.!)7F0!2008!,T0-%*$7+!

#'!7%%&*2:%*8S!%##!1:$)!,*S8*'*$78$0!%#!7!S710U,!87&&7%*F0!78<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,B!!?!

20+*0F0!-7&%!#'!%)*,!,%01,!'&#1!*8,%*%:%*#87+!-&0,,:&0,!%#!0,%72+*,)!S710!,%:<*0,!7,!7!

<*,%*8$%!,:2`'*0+<!*8!10<*7!,%:<*0,B!!L)*,!)7,!+0<!S71*8S!,$)#+7&,!%#!-&*F*+0S0!%)0!

+:<*$!V:7+*%*0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!,*8$0!%)0,0!7&0!%)0!1#,%!#2F*#:,!0+0108%,!%)7%!

,0-7&7%0!F*<0#!S710,!'&#1!#%)0&!10<*7J!,:$)!7,!%0+0F*,*#8!78<!'*+1![9&7M'#&<J!

3453\B!!EF08!M)08!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!<#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)0!87&&7%*F0!$#1-#808%,!#'!

F*<0#!S710,J!%)0&0!*,!,%*++!7!%08<08$.!%#!7,,0&%!%)7%!%)0!+:<*$!0+0108%,!$7&&.!1#&0!

M0*S)%J!78<!%):,!)7F0!1#&0!*1-7$%!#8!78!7:<*08$0B!!!

L7T0J!'#&!0W71-+0J!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7U,![345a\!&0$08%!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!

-#-:+7&!F*<0#!S710!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/&[345d\B!!K*T0!1.,0+'J!%)0.!7&0!<00-+.!

$#8$0&80<!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710,!78<!80#+*20&7+!F7+:0,!78<!

*<0#+#S*0,B!!?8!-7&%*$:+7&J!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7!7&0!$#8$0&80<! M*%)!)#M!

80#+*20&7+!*<0#+#S*0,!$78!20!0120<<0<!*8!S710!<0,*S8!%0$)8*V:0,B!!"&7M*8S!:-#8!

=#S#,%U,![344a\!$#8$0-%!#'!-&#$0<:&7+!&)0%#&*$!78<!2:*+<*8S!#8!#8S#*8S!

$#8F0&,7%*#8,!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S710!87&&7%*F0,!78<!S710-+7.J!

3d4!

({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7!!:,0!%)0!$7,0!,%:<.!#'!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!%)0&0!

$78!20!'&*$%*#8!20%M008!%)0!87&&7%*F0!78<!+:<*$!<*108,*#8,!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!?8!%)0!

$7,0!#'!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/J!%)0!<.,%#-*78!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710!*1-+*$*%+.!

V:0,%*#8!%)0!,%7%:,!V:#!78<!$&*%*V:0!,#$*7+!-&#2+01,!,:$)!7,!*80V:7+*%.J!#--&0,,*#8J!

78<!&7$*,1B!!L)0!+:<*$!0+0108%,J!*8!$#8%&7,%J!&0*8'#&$0!80#+*20&7+!F7+:0,!#'!

*8<*F*<:7+*,1J!$#1-0%*%*F080,,J!$#8,:1-%*#8J!78<!08%&0-&080:&,)*-!7,!7!10%)#<!#'!

$#8,%&:$%*8S!%)0!,0+'!%)&#:S)!%)0*&!01-)7,*,!#8!S&7<:7++.!2:*+<*8S!78<!$:,%#1*]*8S!

7!$)7&7$%0&!%)&#:S)!%)0!%)#:S)%':+!-:&$)7,0!#'!:-S&7<0,!78<!$+0F0&!:,0!#'!+*1*%0<!

&0,#:&$0,B!!!

A#M0F0&J!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7!<#!8#%!$#8$+:<0!%)0*&!7&S:108%!M*%)!%)0,0!

%M#!$+7,)*8S!0+0108%,!27+78$0<!*8!7!,%7%0!#'!%08,*#8B!!?8,%07<J!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!

P+*F7!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!X27+78$0<!-+:&7+*%.Y!78<!*%,!-&0,:10<!X*<0#+#S*$7+!80:%&7+*%.Y!*,!

:8<0&1*80<!2.!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!80#+*20&7+!F7+:0,!M*%)!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/U,!$#&0!

S710-+7.!10$)78*$,![-B!5h\B!!?%!*,!)0&0J!?!20+*0F0J!%)7%!7:<*08$0!,%:<*0,!$78!

-&#<:$%*F0+.!08%0&!%)*,!$#8F0&,7%*#8!78<!-&#F*<0!7<<0<!*8,*S)%!*8%#!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!78<!80#+*20&7+!*<0#+#S*0,B!!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7!

[345a\!<0$+*80!%#!0+72#&7%0!%)0*&!7&S:108%!%)7%!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/U,!-#+*%*$7+!

80:%&7+*%.!*,!:8<0&1*80<!2.!%)0!*<0#+#S*0,!0120<<0<!*8!*%,!S710-+7.!10$)78*$,!

20$7:,0!%)0!$#&0!S710-+7.!10$)78*$,!#'!%)0!S710!#:%M0*S)!*%,!<*,&:-%*F0!<.,%#-*78!

87&&7%*F0B!!?8!%)*,!M7.!%)0.!&0-&#<:$0!%)0!:8'#&%:87%0+.!$#11#8!*<07!*8!S710!

,%:<*0,!%)7%!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!,#10)#M!+0,,!,*S8*'*$78%!

%)78!%)0!S710-+7.!10$)78*$,J!M)*$)!7&0!'*S:&0<!%#!20!%)0!X0,,08$0Y!#'!%)0!F*<0#!

S710![/#<0&178J!345a\!!!@#M!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!$+7*1!%)7%!,:$)!78!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!*,!

3d5!

8#%!-#,,*2+0B!!90&%7*8+.!*8!F*<0#!S710,J!M)*$)!7&0!$#1-+*$7%0<!7,,012+7S0,!#'!

87&&7%*F0!78<!+:<*$!0+0108%,J!,#10!0+0108%,!17.!20!S*F08!S&07%0&!M0*S)%!78<!

*1-#&%78$0!%)78!#%)0&,B!!C.!-#*8%!*,!%)7%!,:$)!7!$+7*1!$788#%!20!%7T08!'#&!S&78%0<!*8!

78!787+.,*,B!!?8!<0$+*8*8S!%#!<*,$:,,!M).!%)0.!%)*8T!%)7%!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!F7+:0,!#'!

M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/!7&0!M0*S)%0<!%#M7&<,!*%,!S710-+7.!10$)78*$,J!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!

P+*F7!&*,T!&0-&#<:$*8S!%)0!7,,:1-%*#8!M*%)*8!S710!,%:<*0,!%)7%!S710-+7.!

10$)78*$,!7&0!1#&0!,*S8*'*$78%!%)78!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!7!F*<0#!S710B!

L)*,!*,!M)0&0!7:<*08$0!,%:<*0,!$78!*8%0&F080!78<!0W-78<!:-#8!%)0!

'#:8<7%*#8,!0,%72+*,)0<!2.!({&0]`K7%#&&0!78<!P+*F7B!!;,!N78*$0!>7<M7.![56ii\!)7,!

7&S:0<J!%0W%,!<#!8#%!S:7&78%00!7!-7&%*$:+7&!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#&!1#<0!#'!&0$0-%*#8B!!

?8,%07<J!%)0.!7&0!-&#<:$0<!M*%)*8!78<!<*,%&*2:%0<!%)&#:S)#:%!1:+%*-+0!,#$*7+!78<!

$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%,B!!I)*+0!%)0!-&#<:$%*#8!#'!7!%0W%!78<!%)0!%0W%!*%,0+'!)7F0!-#M0&':+ !

<0%0&1*8*8S!0''0$%,!:-#8!*%,!&0$0-%*#8J!M0!,)#:+<!20!$7&0':+!%#!,-0$*'.!%)7%!%)*,!*,!

8#%!<0%0&1*87%*#8!2.!M7.!#'!7!S:7&78%00!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!#:%$#10J!2:%!*8,%07<!*,!

1#&0!+*T0!M)7%!/%:7&%!A7++![566h7\!&0'0&,!%#!7,!<0%0&1*87%*#8!*8!%)0!'*&,%!*8,%78$0B!!

L)*,!*,!7!'#&1!#'!<0%0&1*87%*#8!M)0&02.!7!10<*7!%0W%!0,%72+*,)0,!7!-7&%*$:+7&!

)#&*]#8!#'!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!%)7%!*8<*F*<:7+!&07<0&,!M#&T!M*%)*8!M)08!$&07%*8S!%)0*&!

#M8!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8,B!

?8!,)#&%J!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0!+:<*$!78<!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!*8!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!F*<0#!S710!*,!$#1-+0W!78<!:8,%72+0J!,*%:7%0<!7,!*%!*,!7%!%)0!*8%0&,0$%*#8!#'!

%)0!*8%0&0,%,!#'!$:+%:&7+!-&#<:$0&,J!%0W%:7+!'07%:&0,J!78<!7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,B!!

L)0&0'#&0!M0!$788#%!7,,:10!%)7%!%)0!+:<*$!0+0108%,!#'!7!S710!7&0!1#&0!,*S8*'*$78%!

%)78!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!M*%)#:%!0W71*8*8S!)#M!7$%:7+!-0#-+0!-+7.!%)0!F*<0#!

3d3!

S710B!!;,!;<&*0880!/)7M![345f\!&01*8<,!:,J!*8%0&-0++7%*#8!&0V:*&0,!2#%)!7!)7*+*8S!

78<!7!&0,-#8,0!%#!%)7%!)7*+*8SB!!I)*+0!,)0!M7,!&0'0&&*8S!,-0$*'*$7++.!%#!*<08%*%.!

$#8,%&:$%*#8J!?!%)*8T!%)*,!*<07!$78!20!-&#<:$%*F0+.!0W-78<0<!%#!*8$+:<0!178.!T*8<,!

#'!%0W%:7+!08$#:8%0&,!k!%)0&0!*,!%)0!%0W%J!78<!%)08!%)0&0!*,!)#M!-0#-+0!&0,-#8<!%#!%)0!

%0W%J!78<!#80!$788#%!80$0,,7&*+.!20!*8'0&&0<!'&#1!%)0!#%)0&B!!"0$+*8*8S!%#!7$$#:8%!'#&!

%)*,!&:8,!%)0!&*,T!#'!1*,:8<0&,%78<*8S!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!7$%:7+!F*<0#!S710!-+7.0&,B!

>0%:&8*8S!%#!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!%)*8T!*%!M#:+<!20!7!1*,%7T0!%#!7&S:0!%)7%!

S710-+7.!10$)78*$,!7&0!1#&0!*1-#&%78%!%)78!7!S710U,!87&&7%*F0!<0,*S8!'#&!7!+7&S0!

71#:8%!#'!%)01B!!I)08!?!7,T0<!72#:%!-+7.0&,U!%7,%0,!*8!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0*&!

$&*%0&*7!'#&!0F7+:7%*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!!dd!-7&%*$*-78%,![&#:S)+.!)7+'!#'!%)0!,71-+0\!

,%7%0<!%)7%!%)0!%)*8S!%)0.!+##T0<!'#&!%)0!1#,%!M)08!0F7+:7%*8S!7!F*<0#!S710!M7,!%)0!

S710U,!87&&7%*F0B!!L)*,!-&0'0&08$0!M7,!0W-&0,,0<!7+#8S!,0F0&7+!<*108,*#8,J!#'!

$#:&,0B!!/#10!,*1-+.!,%7%0<!%)7%!%)0.!+##T0<!'#&!7!XS##<!,%#&.Y!#&!X-+#%BY!!P%)0&,!

M08%!*8%#!1#&0!<0%7*+B!!Z#&!0W71-+0J!?+080!,%7%0<!%)7%!,)0!-+7.,!X7!+#%!#'!$*8017%*$!#&!

,%#&.!&*$)!S710,B!!?%!)0+-,!10!S0%!+#,%BY!!;8#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%J!L0&0,,7J!,%7%0<!%)7%!,)0!

+##T,!'#&!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!X%)0!,$087&*#J!%)0!,%#&.J!78<!*'!%)0!S710!$78!08%0&%7*8!10!

'#&!7!$#:-+0!#'!)#:&,B!!;!S##<!S710!%#!10!*,!7!%*%+0!%)7%!%&7F0+,!u,*$v!1.!1*8<!%#!

78#%)0&!M#&+<B!!Q710,!%)7%!7&0!$#1-+0%0+.!7M7.!'&#1b&07+*%.!7+M7.,!$7%$)!10BY!!

/#10!-7&%*$*-78%,!108%*#80<!-+#%!*8!$#8R:8$%*#8!M*%)!$)7&7$%0&*]7%*#8,B!!Z#&!

0W71-+0J!@#&178<!M&#%0!%)7%J!!

3dd!

X9)7&7$%0&!78<!,%#&.!7&0!}5!'#&!10J!78<!$)7&7$%0&!1#&0!,#!%)78!,%#&.l!?!$78!

-+7.!%)&#:S)!7!S710!M*%)!,)*%%.!S710-+7.!78<!7!10<*#$&0!,%#&.!*'!%)0!

$)7&7$%0&,!7&0!7M0,#10!08#:S)J!M)0&07,!7!S710!M*%)!S##<!S710-+7.!2:%!8#!

S##<!$)7&7$%0&,!)7,!%#!)7F0!,#10%)*8S!0+,0!&07++.!#:%,%78<*8S![7%1#,-)0&0J!

*8F08%*F0!10$)78*$,J!#&!,#10%)*8S!,*1*+7&\!%#!&0$#1108<!*%!*'!?!71!S#*8S!%#!

-+7.!*%!+#8S!08#:S)!%#!207%!*%BY!

C078M)*+0J!#%)0&!-7&%*$*-78%,!0W-+*$*%+.!-+7$0<!87&&7%*F0!72#F0!S710-+7.!*8!%)0*&!

)*0&7&$).!#'!S71*8S!F7+:0,B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!;&+080!,%7%0<!%)7%!7!F*<0#!S710U,!,%#&.+*80!

M7,!)0&!X#8+.!&07+!$&*%0&*7B!!?'!7!S710!)7,!7!'7,$*87%*8S!,%#&.+*80!2:%!,)#&%.!u,*$v!

S710-+7.J!?!M*++!T00-!S#*8SB!=:%!#'!$#:&,0!%)0!F*$0!F0&,7!*,!%&:0!7,!M0++!`!8#!17%%0&!

)#M!S##<!%)0!S710-+7.J!?!M*++!+#,0!*8%0&0,%!M*%)#:%!7!,%#&.+*80!%)7%!*8%0&0,%,!10BY!

@#M!?!<#!8#%!M78%!%#!$+7*1!%)7%!7!,%7%0<!-&0'0&08$0!'#&!7!S710U,!87&&7%*F0!

1078,!%)7%!%)0!S710U,!87&&7%*F0!78<!*%,!7%%08<78%!*<0#+#S*0,!)7F0!%)0!S&07%0,%!

*1-7$%!#8!78!*8<*F*<:7+!-+7.0&B!!;'%0&!7++J!%0W%,!$78!)7F0!,:2$#8,$*#:,!0''0$%,!#8!

7:<*08$0!10120&,!%)7%!$78!20!R:,%!7,!-&#'#:8<!7,!%)#,0!%)7%!%)0!7:<*08$0!*,!7M7&0!

#'B!!C#&0#F0&J!7,!<*,$:,,0<!*8!$)7-%0&!cJ!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!7!F*<0#!S710!7&0!

*80W%&*$72+.!$#880$%0<!M*%)!7++!#'!%)0!#%)0&!0+0108%,!#'!7!F*<0#!S710J!M)*$)!7&0!*8!

%:&8!0W-0&*08$0<!,*1:+%780#:,+.!2.!%)0!-+7.0&!7+#8S!M*%)!#%)0&!*8'#&17%*#8!

,%&071,!'&#1!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!,$&008B!!L)0,0!F7&*#:,!0+0108%,!$&07%0!78!7,,012+7S0!

%)7%!*,!<*''0&08%!'&#1!%)0!,:1!#'!*%,!-7&%,J!78<!,#!%#!)#+<!:-!#80!0+0108%!7,!'2/!1#,%!

*1-#&%78%!0+0108%!*,!%#!1*,&0-&0,08%!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!

?8,%07<J!?!-&#F*<0!%)0,0!0W71-+0,!%#!V:0,%*#8!%)0!:8,-#T08!7,,:1-%*#8!%)7%!

,%&:$%:&0,!178.!787+.,0,!#'!F*<0#!S710!%0W%,!`!%)7%!%)0!$#&0!S710-+7.!10$)78*$,!#'!

7!F*<0#!S710!:+%*17%0+.!<0%0&1*80!%)0!*<0#+#S.!78<!-#+*%*$7+!-0&,-0$%*F0!#'!7!F*<0#!

S710!%0W%B!!L)0!&0,-#8,0,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!M*%)!%)0*&!01-)7,*,!#8!8#8`+:<*$!

0+0108%,!,:$)!7,!87&&7%*F0!78<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8J!,:SS0,%!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!$0&%7*8!

3df!

,*%:7%*#8,!M)0&0!7!-+7.0&U,!0W-0&*08$0!#'!7!F*<0#!S710!%0W%!17.!20!<#1*87%0<!2.!

%)0!S710U,!,%#&.!#&!$)7&7$%0&,B!!^+%*17%0+.J!%)08J!%)0!1078*8S!#'!7!S710!%0W%!78<!%)0!

0''0$%!*%!)7,!#8!78!7:<*08$0!$788#%!20!0W%&7-#+7%0<!'&#1!%)0!%0W%!*%,0+'B!!?%!1:,%!20!

,*%:7%0<!M*%)*8!%)0!$#8%0W%!#'!&0$0-%*#8J!M)*$)!*,!,0-7&7%0!'&#1!78<!80F0&!

$#1-+0%0+.!S:7&78%00<!2.!%)0!%0W%!*%,0+'B!

;++!#'!%)*,!*,!%#!7&S:0!%)7%J!*8!$0&%7*8!$#8%0W%,J!%)0!87&&7%*F0!<*108,*#8,!#'!7!

F*<0#!S710!7&0!*1-#&%78%!%#!$#8,*<0&J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*'!M0!7&0!%#!:8<0&,%78<!)#M!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!,:--#&%!7!-0&,#8U,!%)&*F*8SB!!L#!&0*%0&7%0J!M)*+0!7!8#%72+0!

-&#-#&%*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!&0R0$%0<!%)0!*<07!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!

0W-0&*08$0,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!7!+7&S0&!-&#-#&%*#8!M0&0!7%!%)0!F0&.!+07,%!&0$0-%*F0!%#!%)0!

*<07B!!C#&0#F0&J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!0W-&0,,0<!-&0'0&08$0,!'#&!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!

#'!7!S710J!*8$+:<*8S!2:%!8#%!+*1*%0<!%#!7!S710U,!-+#%J!$)7&7$%0&,J!78<!M#&+<`2:*+<*8SB!

L)*,!+07<,!10!%#!%)*8T!%)7%J!*8!%)0!$7,0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!78<!#%)0&!CCP,J!*'!M0!

7&0!0W71*8*8S!)#M!F*<0#!S710,!$78!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!M)*$)!

*8$+:<0,!*17S*8*8S!20%%0&!':%:&0,J!M0!$78!-&#<:$%*F0+.!20S*8!#:&!*8F0,%*S7%*#8!2.!

+##T*8S!7%!7!S710U,!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,J!8#%!*8!)#M!%)0!S710!$#8,%&:$%,!$#11:8*%.!

78<!%#S0%)0&80,,J!7,!,:SS0,%0<!2.!<*S*%7+!10<*7!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!L0&&78#F7![3446\!78<!

=70&S![345f\B!!!

L)*,!*,!20$7:,0!#'!78!#'%08`:8<0&0,%*17%0<!':8$%*#8!#'!10<*7!87&&7%*F0,!*8!

$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$78!$#8%0W%,!k!%)0*&!72*+*%.!%#!$#8,%&:$%!78<!,:,%7*8!'78%7,*0,B!!

I)*+0!178.!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!)7F0!<*,1*,,0<!'78%7,.J!-0&)7-,!R:,%*'*72+.J!7,!87~F0!

'+*S)%,!#'!'78$.!#&!M*,)':+!%)*8T*8SJ!?!%)*8T!7!1#&0!-&#<:$%*F0!,%78$0!%#!%7T0!%#M7&<,!

'78%7,.!*,!%)0!#80!#:%+*80<!2.!K*,7!A08<0&,#8![345d\!*8!%)0! '*87 +!$)7-%0&!#'!)0&!2##T!

3dc!

C.9/&$#>&P.#/)J&56//3(4&8%$((4&$#>&86%'63$%&H3.>6='".#B!!A0&0J!A08<0&,#8!7&S:0,!%)7%!

'78%7,.J!*8!*%,!1#&0!#-%*1*,%*$!78<!M)*1,*$7+!$#88#%7%*#8,J!*,!$08%&7+!%#!%)0!$&*%*$7+!

V:0,%*#8!#'!$:+%:&0U,!&#+0!*8!M#&+<`17T*8SB!!?%!*,!M#&%)!V:#%*8S!)0&!&07,#8*8S!'#&!%)*,!

7%!+08S%)G!

! !

L)0&0!*,!7!+*S)%80,,!*8!'+*S)%!78<!M*,)J!78!78%*-&#S&7117%*$!<*,-#,*%*#8!78<!

78!080&S.!M#&%)!)#+<*8S!#8%#!k!$:+%:&0!8#%!#8+.!7,!'#&1!2:%!7!&78S0!#'!

'00+*8S,!%)7%!0W$00<,!%)0!<*,%&:,%!%.-*$7++.!7 ,,*S80<! %#!$&*%*V:0B!!?'!&0+*S*#:,!

'78%7,*0,!#'!<0+*F0&78$0![#&!+*20&7%*#8!%)0#+#S.J!-&#%0,%! &#$T J!,$*08$0!'*$%*#8J!

#&!,0W:7+!,$080`17T*8S\!%0++!:,!78.%)*8SJ!*%!*,!%)7%!'78%7,.!S*F0,!':%:&0,!

'00+*8S!78<!'#&1!*8!%)0!-&0,08%J!17T*8S!*%!-#,,*2+0!%#!*17S*80!7+%0&87%*F0,!

78<!%#!,00!M)7%!*,!7+&07<.!,:,%7*8*8SB!!?%!17T0,!%)#:S)%!72#:%!':%:&0,!1#&0!

#-08!k!+0,,!<&*F08!#&!%0%)0&*8S!#&!+*T0!)0<S*8S!7!20%!%)78!7!&07+`%*10!'#&1!#'!

$&07%*F*%.![-B!536\B!

?8!1.!0W-0&*08$0!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!<*<!8#%!'*8<!%)0!'78%7,*0,!<0,$&*20<!2.!

A08<0&,#8J!%)0!#80,!%)7%!7++#M!:,!%#! 2&*8S!%)0!':%:&0!*8%#!%)0!-&0,08%!78<!,00!M)7%!

*,!7+&07<.!,:,%7*8*8SJ!*8!%)0!S710U,!$##-0&7%*F0J!1:+%*-+7.0&!,0S108%,B!!?8,%07<J!?!

'#:8<!%)01!M)08!?!M*%)<&0M!'&#1!%)0!%#S0%)0&80,,!#'!%)0!S710!78<!08S7S0<!*8!

-&7$%*$0,!1#&0!710872+0!%#!,#+*%:<0G!&07<*8S!*%,!%0W%,J!M7%$)*8S!*%,!$*8017%*$,J!

+*,%08*8S!%#!*%,!1:,*$J!78<!$#8,:1*8S!*%,!:8'#+<*8S!-+#%B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!%#!,7.J!7S7*8J!%)7%!

#%)0&,!<#!8#%!#&!$78!8#%!'*8<!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!%)0!,:,%0878$0!#'!*17S*80<!':%:&0,!

%)&#:S)!%)0!S710U,!,#$*7+!7,-0$%,B!!?%!*,!%#!*8,*,%J!)#M0F0&J!%)7%!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!#8+.!

'#&1!#'!,:,%0878$0!7F7*+72+0!%#!-+7.0&,J!78<!-0&)7-,!8#%!%)0!20,%!-+7$0!*8!%)0!S710!

%#!'*8<!,:,%0878$0!*8!%)0!-&0,08%!#&!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!*17S*8*8S!7!1#&0!0V:*%72+0!78<!

R:,%!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!*8!%)0!':%:&0B!!/:,%0878$0!$78!7+,#!20!'#:8<!*8!,#+*%:<0!78<!

M*%)<&7M7+!'&#1!%#S0%)0&80,,J!78<!7%!+07,%!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!

M*%)<&7M*8S!'&#1!%)0!,#$*7+!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710!7''#&<,!-+7.0&,!7!20%%0&!

3dh!

#--#&%:8*%.!%#!#2,0&F0!78<!&0'+0$%!:-#8!%)0!1#&0!-&#S&0,,*F0!0+0108%,!#'!%)0!S710J!

0+0108%,!%)7%!?!'#:8<!08$#:&7S*8SJ!)07&%08*8SJ!78<!0F08!*8,-*&*8SB!

Diversity!and!Inclusivity!in!the!World!of!Final!Fantasy!XIV!

! /#J!M).!<#!?!$+7*1!%)7%!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!87&&7%*F0!*,!-&#S&0,,*F0J!78<!M).!

<#!?!%)*8T!*%!$78!0872+0!-+7.0&,!%#!20%%0&!*17S*80!7!M#&+<!M*%)!7!1#&0!0V:*%72+0!

<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!&0,#:&$0,J!2#%)!17%0&*7+!78<!,.12#+*$g!!?!'*&,%!M78%!%#!20S*8!M*%)!

)#M!%)0!S710!-#,*%*#8,!%)0!-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&!M*%)*8!%)0!S710U,!+7&S0&!87&&7%*F0B!!L)0!

S710!#-08,!M*%)!7!<&071!,0V:08$0!*8!M)*$)!%)0!-+7.0&U,!7F7%7&J!,-:&&0<!#8!2.!7!

1.,%0&*#:,!F#*$0J!$#8'&#8%,!7!%)&07%08*8S!-0&,#8!M07&*8S!2+7$T!&#20,!78<!7!'+710`

+*T0!17,TB!!P8$0!%)0!7F7%7&!7M7T0,J!%)0!-+7.0&!<*,$#F0&,!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!*8!%)0!1*<,%!#'!

%&7F0+*8S!%#!#80!#'!%)0!S710U,!%)&00!-&*17&.!$*%.`,%7%0,J!Q&*<78*7J!^+U<7)J!#&!K*1,7!

K#1*8,7J!M)*$)!#80!<0%0&1*80<!2.!%)0!10$)78*$7+!$+7,,!$)#,08!2.!%)0!-+7.0&!<:&*8S!

%)0!$)7&7$%0&!$&07%*#8!,0S108%B!!I)*+0!10$)78*$7++.!,*1*+7&J!7,!07$)!$*%.`,%7%0!

':8$%*#8,!7,!7!%:%#&*7+!,0S108%!'#&!%)0!S710!7,!M0++!7,!7!):2!'#&!,*S8*'*$78%!*8`S710!

#&S78*]7%*#8,!78<!*8,%*%:%*#8,J!%)0!$:+%:&0!78<!-#+*%*$,!#'!07$)!$*%.`,%7%0!7&0!

,*S8*'*$78%+.!<*''0&08%!'&#1!#80!78#%)0&B!!Q&*<78*7!*,!7!%)0#$&7$.J!'#:8<0<!#8!%)0!

,.12*#%*$!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0!-0#-+0!+*F*8S!*8!%)0!$*%.!78<!%)0!0+0108%7+!,-*&%,!

#'!%)0!,:&&#:8<*8S!'#&0,%J!^+U<7)!*,!7!,:+%787%0!M)#,0!$:+%:&0!*,!#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!

%&7<0!78<!$#110&$0J!M)*+0!K*1,7!K#1*8,7!*,!7!80M+.`0,%72+*,)0<!%)7+7,,#$&7$.![*%,!

-&*#&!+*'0!M7,!7!)7F08!'#&!-*&7%0,!78<!#:%+7M,\B!!!

! I)7%!*,!*110<*7%0+.!0,%72+*,)0<!*8!%)*,!*8%&#<:$%#&.!,0S108%!78<J!-&*#&!%#!

%)*,J!%)0!$)7&7$%0&!$&07%*#8!,0S108%!M)0&0!%)0,0!$:+%:&7+!78<!-#+*%*$7+!<*''0&08$0,!

3da!

7&0!'*&,%!0W-+7*80<J!*,!%)7%!%)0!M#&+<!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*,!#80!-&01*,0<!#8!

<*''0&08$0B!!"*F0&,*%.!*,!%)0!27,0+*80!#'!%)0!M#&+<J!7!'07% : &0!%)7%!*,!&0*8'#&$0<!

%)017%*$7++.!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!S710B!!L)0!-&*17&.!78%7S#8*,%,!#'!%)0!S710!7&0!%)0!

Q7&+078!E1-*&0J!78!*1-0&*7+!'7,$*,%!&0S*10!%)7%!*,!7%%01-%*8S!%#!$#8V:0&!78<!

)#1#S08*]0!E#&]07B!!Q&*<78*7J!^+U<7)J!78<!K*1,7!K#1*8,7J!*8!78!0''#&%!%#!&0-0+!%)0!

Q7&+078!E1-*&0J!)7F0!R#*80<!%#S0%)0&!*8!78!7++*78$0!$7++0<!%)0!E#&]078!;++*78$0B!!

@#%72+.!%)*,!7++*78$0!<#0,!8#%!<*1*8*,)!07$)!$*%.`,%7%0U,!,#F0&0*S8%.! #&! $:+%:&7+!

,-0$*'*$*%.B!!?8,%07<J!%)0!*8%0&87+!<*F0&,*%.!#'!%)0!E#&]078!;++*78$0!*,!0W-+*$*%+.!'&710<!

7,!*%,!S&07%0,%!,%&08S%)!78<!*,!*8,%&:108%7+!*8!:+%*17%0+.!'&:,%&7%*8S!%)0!*1-0&*7+*,%*$!

0''#&%,!#'!%)0!Q7&+078!E1-*&0B!

! L)0&0!*,!1:$)!*8!%)0!S0#-#+*%*$,!78<!$:+%:&0!#'!E#&]07!%)7%!*,!,:--#&%*F0!#'!7!

-&#S&0,,*F0!-#+*%*$,!k!8710+.!*%,!,%7:8$)!78%*`*1-0&*7+*,1!78<!$)71-*#8*8S!#'!

<*F0&,*%.B!!I)7%!?!-&*17&*+.!%7T0!'&#1!%)*,!M#&+<J!)#M0F0&J!*,!%)0!*<07!%)7%!%)0&0!$78!

20!,%&:$%:&*8S!'#&$0,!*8!,#$*0%.!%)7%!<#!8#%!&0,012+0!)*0&7&$)*0,B!!"*''0&08$0!0W*,%,!

*8!%)0!E#&]078!;++*78$0J!2:%!%)#,0!<*''0&08$0,!0W*,%!*8!7!)#&*]#8%7+J!&7%)0&!%)78!

F0&%*$7+J!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&B!!L)&#:S)!$##-0&7%*#8!78<!$#11:8*$7%*#8!

[,0F0&7+!#'!%)0!S710U,!17*8!V:0,%,!&0F#+F0!7&#:8<!0,%72+*,)*8S!78<!17*8%7*8*8S!

+*80,!#'!$#11:8*$7%*#8!20%M008!%)0!F7&*#:,!)07<,!#'!,%7%0\J!%)0!E#&]078!7++*78$0!*,!

72+0!%#!':8$%*#8!,1##%)+.!<0,-*%0!%)0!+##1*8S!%)&07%!#'!M7&!78<!M*%)#:%!$#++7-,*8S!

*8%#!'7,$*,1B!!Q*F08!%)0!$:&&08%!-#+*%*$7+!7%1#,-)0&0!*8!%)0!^8*%0<!/%7%0,J!M)0&0!M0!

7&0!&#:%*80+.!&01*8<0<!2.!10<*7!*8,%*%:%*#8,!#'!%)0!807&+.`*8,:&1#:8%72+0!$:+%:&7+!

S7-,!20%M008!F7&*#:,!'7$%*#8,![+*20&7+,!78<!$#8,0&F7%*F0J!"01#$&7%!78<!>0-:2+*$78J!

>0<!78<!=+:0\J!*%!*,!)07&%08*8S!%#!20!72+0!%#!0,$7-0!*8%#!7!M#&+<!%)7%!*,!#&S78*]0<!

3di!

<*''0&08%+.J!78<!%):,!)0+-,!-+7.0&,!$#8,%&:$%!7!'00+*8S!'#&!%)0!*17S*80<!-#%08%*7+,!

0120<<0<!M*%)*8!%)0!M#&+<!#'!E#&]07B!!?'J!7,!O0880%)!=:&T0![56hi\!)7,!-&#-#,0<J!

+*%0&7%:&0J!78<!2.!0W%08,*#8!0+0$%&#8*$!10<*7!78<!87&&7%*F0,![=&:110%%J!56ic\J!$78!

':8$%*#8!7,!X0V:*-108%!'#&!+*F*8SY!2.!871*8S!&0$:&&08%!,*%:7%*#8,!78<!-&#F*<*8S!

7:<*08$0,!M*%)!M7.,!#'!80S#%*7%*8S!%)0,0!-7&%*$:+7&!$*&$:1,%78$0,J!?!M#:+<!,:SS0,%!

%)7%!*%!*,!0V:7++.!*1-#&%78%!%#!$#8,*<0&!%)0!X0V:*-108%!'#&!'78%7,*0,Y!%)7%!10<*7!

-&#F*<0B!!Z#&J!7,!;<&*0880!/)7M![345f\!)7,!8#%0<J!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!78<J!2.!0W%08,*#8J!

87&&7%*F0!*,!*1-#&%78%!20$7:,0!*%!X-&#F*<0,!0F*<08$0!#'!M)7%!$#:+<!20!78<!M)#!$78!

20!-#,,*2+0Y![-B!f5\B!!K*T0M*,0J!"7.78!78<!O7%]![5663\!)7F0!7+,#!8#%0<!%)7%!#80!#'!

%)0!-#M0&':+!&*%:7+!':8$%*#8,!#'!%)0!10<*7!*,!%#!8#%!#8+.!&0-#&%!M)7%!*,J!2:%!7+,#!M)7%!

.612'!%#!20B!!L)7%!*,J!%)0!10<*7!$78!7$%!7,!7!$7%7+.,%!'#&!$)78S0!2.!%7--*8S!*8%#!78<!

&0+07,*8S!)#-0,!78<!#%)0&!,:210&S0<!,#$*7+!'#&$0,B!!?8!,)#&%J!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!78<!

87&&7%*F0,J!7,!,*%0,!'#&!%)0!0W0&$*,0!#'!78<!,%&:SS+0!#F0&!-#M0&![9#:+<&.J!3453\J!

*8'#&1!8#%!R:,%!)#M!M0!,00!78<!:8<0&,%78<!%)0!M#&+<!7&#:8<!:,J!2:%!7+,#!%)0!

F7&*#:,!-#%08%*7+,!78<!-#,,*2*+*%*0,!'#&!<*''0&08%!,#$*7+!$#8'*S:&7%*#8,!78<!

&0+7%*#8,)*-,!%)7%!7&0!7F7*+72+0!%#!:,B!!!

! L)0!*1-#&%78$0!#'!%)*,!$788#%!20!:8<0&0,%*17%0<B!!L7T0J!'#&!0W71-+0J!%)0!

80#+*20&7+!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!87%:&7+80,,!#'!0$#8#1*$!-&#$0,,0,B!!;,!L0&&78#F7!

[3446\!)7,!<0%7*+0<J!#80!#'!%)0!M7.,!%)7%!I0,%0&8!-#+*%*$7+!0$#8#1*,%,!#'!%)0!5i

$08%:&.!7%%01-%0<!%#!+*1*%!%)0!,#F0&0*S8!0W0&$*,0!#'!-#M0&!M7,!2.!7,,0&%*8S!%)0!

87%:&7+80,,!#'!0$#8#1*$!-&#$0,,0,J!8710+.!%)0!17&T0%!78<!*%,!:8<0&+.*8S!

10$)78*,1!#'!$#1-0%*%*#8B!!I*%)*8!%)*,!X&0S*10!#'!%&:%)Y![%#!:,0!Z#:$7:+%U,!%0&1\J!

0$#8#1*$!-&#$0,,0,!7&0!'*S:&0<!7,!X+7M,Y!#&!X&:+0,Y![1:$)!+*T0!%)0!+7M,!#'!-).,*$,\!

3d6!

%)7%!7&0!*117808%!%#!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!#&S78*]7%*#8,!78<!%):,!,)#:+<!20!

%&07%0<!7,!20.#8<!%)0!<#17*8!#'!,#F0&0*S8!-#M0&![L0&&78#F7J!3456J!-B!3da`3d6\B!!

I*%)*8!%)*,!'&710M#&TJ!%)0!,%7%0!$78!#8+.!)71-0&!#&!*8%0&'0&0!M*%)!%)0!':8$%*#8!#'!

%)0,0!0$#8#1*$!+7M,B!!L)*,!&0S*10!#'!%&:%)!&0F0&20&7%0,!%#!%)*,!<7.J!+0S*%*1*]*8S!78!

08%*&0!7&&7.!#'!-#+*$*0,!78<!-&#$0<:&0,!%)7%!'*8<!%)0*&!$:&&08%!0W-&0,,*#8!*8!7!

80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.J!,:$)!7,!%)0!<0&0S:+7%*#8!#'!%)0!17&T0%!78<!%)0!

0W%08,*#8!#'!0$#8#1*$!-&#$0,,0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!%#!#%)0&!<#17*8,B!!!

! P80!#'!%)0!M7.,!*8!M)*$)!7!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!7,,0&%,!*%,!

+0S*%*17$.!*,!%)&#:S)!%)0!*<07!%)7%!%)0&0!*,!8#!.6'(">/!%#!%)0!0$#8#1*$!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

%)0!17&T0%!78<!$#1-0%*%*#8J!%)7%!%)0.!7&0!':8<7108%7+!%#!%)0!#&S78*]7%*#8!#'!+*'0B!!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!%)&#:S)#:%!*%,!87&&7%*F0J!&0-&0,08%,!7+%0&87%*F0!1#<0,!#'!

0$#8#1*$!20*8SJ!%):,!-&#F*<*8S!-+7.0&,!M*%)!&0,#:&$0,!%#!*17S*80!7+%0&87%*F0,!%#!

$7-*%7+*,1B!!L#!,00!78!0W71-+0!#'!%)*,J!M0!$78!%:&8!%#!7!,17++!,0&*0,!#'!V:0,%,!+#$7%0<!

*8!%)0!$*%.`,%7%0!#'!Q&*<78*7B!!;,!,%7%0<!72#F0J!Q&*<78*7!*,!:8*V:0!71#8S,%!%)0!#%)0&!

$*%.`,%7%0,!*8!E#&]07!'#&!20*8S!7!%)0#$&7$.B!!L)*,!%)0#$&7$.! *,!'#:8<0<!#8!%)0!

,.12*#%*$!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)0!&0,*<08%,!#'!Q&*<78*7!78<!%)0!0+0108%7+!,-*&*%,!

%)7%!*8)72*%!%)0!,:&&#:8<*8S!'#&0,%,B!!L)&#:S)!V:0,%,!78<!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!M*%)!

$#1-:%0&`$#8%&#++0<!$)7&7$%0&,J!#&!@(9,J!-+7.0&,!$78!+07&8!%)7%!%)0!$*%.`,%7%0!#'!

Q&*<78*7!7$%:7++.!0W*,%,!7%!%)0!10&$.!#'!%)0!'#&0,%!0+0108%7+,J!78<!1:,%!&#:%*80+.!

$#8,:+%!M*%)!%)0!0+0108%7+,!%#!<*,$:,,!)#M!%#!1787S0!Q&*<78*7J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*%,!

-#-:+7%*#8J!$#8,:1-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,J!78<!78.!$*%.!<0F0+#-108%!-&#R0$%,J!*8!#&<0&!%#!

08,:&0!%)7%!%)0!-&0,08$0!78<!7$%*F*%*0,!#'!%)0!$*%.`,%7%0!<#!8#%!$7:,0!:8<:0!)7&1!#8!

*%,!,:&&#:8<*8S!08F*&#8,B!!!

3f4!

! ?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!Q&*<78*7!*,!78!0W71-+0!#'!,%7%0!M)#,0!0$#8#1*$!-#+*$*0,!7&0!

8#%!-&*17&*+.!'&710<!*8!%0&1,!#'!%)0!80#+*20&7+!17&T0%B!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!*%,!&0,*<08%,!

7&0!'&00!%#!7<#-%!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!7&0!,*S8*'*$78%+.!<*''0&08%!'&#1!%)0!#80,!

%.-*$7++.!7''#&<0<!2.!7!$7-*%7+*,%!0$#8#1*$!,%&:$%:&0B!!L)*,!*,!<&717%*]0<!*8!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!V:0,%B!!L)*,!V:0,%!*,!8#%!10$)78*$7++.!#&*S*87+!k!*%!,*1-+.!&0V:*&0,!%)0!

-+7.0&!%#!+#$7%0!78<!%7+T!%#!<*''0&08%!@(9,!+#$7%0<!*8!7!,17++!7&07B!!?%,!-&0,08%7%*#8!*,!

7+,#!,*1-+0J!$#8,*,%*8S!#'!<*7+#S:0!%0W%!%)7%!%)0!-+7.0&!$78!$+*$T!%)&#:S)J!7,!#--#,0<!

%#!#%)0&J!1#&0!$*8017%*$!1#108%,!*8!%)0!S710!%)7%!'07%:&0!,$&*-%0<!$710&7!

1#F0108%,!78<!':++.`F#*$0<!<*7+#S:0B!!A#M0F0&J!,*<0!V:0,%,!+*T0!%)*,!$#8%&*2:%0!%#!

%)0!M#&+<!2:*+<*8S!#'!%)0!S710!2.!*8%&#<:$*8S!-+7.0&,!%#!%)0!<*''0&08%!-0&,-0$%*F0,!

#'!%)0!&0,*<08%,!#'!E#&]07!78<!)#M!%)0,0!-0&,-0$%*F0,!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&B!!

L)0!V:0,%!*8!V:0,%*#8!*8F#+F0,!7!$#8'+*$%!20%M008!7!10&$)78%!'&#1!^+U"7)!78<!78!

78*17+!2&00<0&!#'!Q&*<78*7B!!L)0!10&$)78%!M*,)0,!%#!-:&$)7,0!78*17+!,%#$T!'&#1!

%)0!2&00<0&!2:%!'#&!&07,#8,!)0!$788#%!:8<0&,%78<!%)0!2&00<0&!&0':,0,!%#!,0++!)*,!

,%#$TB!!9#8,0V:08%+.J!%)0!10&$)78%!7,T,!%)0!-+7.0&U,!$)7&7$%0&!%#!S7%)0&!*8'#&17%*#8!

#8!%)0!2&00<0&!,#!%)7%!%)0!10&$)78%!17.!:8<0&,%78<!%)0!2&00<0&U,!800<,!78<!

<0,*&0,!78<!%):,!20%%0&!80S#%*7%0!M*%)!%)0!2&00<0&B! ! =.!,-07T*8S!M*%)!,0F0&7+!#%)0&!

@(9,!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!7&07J!%)0!-+7.0&!+07&8,!%)7%!%)0!2&00<0&!<#0,!8#%!M*,)!% #!,0+ + !% #!

%)0!^+U"7)8!10&$)78%!20$7:,0!)0!$7&0,!'#&!)*,!78*17+,!78<!<#0,!8#%!%&:,%!%)0!

10&$)78%!%#!%&07%!%)01!M*%)!$7&0!78<!&0,-0$%B!!^+%*17%0+.J!%)0!10&$)78%J!'&:,%&7%0<!

2.!%)0!2&00<0&U,!&0':,7+!%#!7<#-%!%)0!%&7<*%*#87+!$#8$0&8,!#'!7!,0++0&!*8!7!$7-*%7+*,%!

17&T0%J!S*F0,!:-!#8!80S#%*7%*#8,!78<!+07F0,!%)0!'7&1B!

3f5!

! L)*,!,17++!87&&7%*F0!7&$!*8!%)0!S710J!?!$#8%08<J!-&#F*<0,!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!

*17S*8*8S!<*''0&08%!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,!%)78!%)0!#80,!%.-*$7++.!#''0&0<!2.!$7-*%7+*,1B!!

?8!7!%.-*$7+!$7-*%7+*,%!0W$)78S0J!%)0!10&$)78%!78<!2&00<0&!M#:+<!20!2:.0&,!78<!

,0++0&,!#'!7!-7&%*$:+7&!$#11#<*%.!*8!7!-7&%*$:+7&!17&T0%B!!L)0!2:.0&!<0,*&0,!%#!,0++!

)*,!$#11#<*%.!'#&!%)0!)*S)0,%!-&*$0!-#,,*2+0J!%)0!,0++0&!<0,*&0,!%#!%)0!-7.!%)0!

$)07-0,%!-&*$0!-#,,*2+0J!78<!,#!%)0!%M#!1:,%!$#1-0%0!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!%#!80S#%*7%0!

%)0!-&*$0!#'!%)0!$#11#<*%.B!!L)0,0!7&0!%)0!,:2R0$%!-#,*%*#8,!%)7%!%)0!10&$)78%!*8!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!7,,:10,!7&0!*8!-+7.!*8!)*,!0W$)78S0!M*%)!%)0!78*17+!2&00<0&B!!L)0!

2&00<0&J!)#M0F0&J!*,!-+7.*8S!78!08%*&0+.!<*''0&08%!S710J!#80!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!

-&01*,0<!:-#8!%)0!17&T0%!+#S*$!#'!$#1-0%*%*#8B!!A0!&0':,0,!%#!&0<:$0!%)0!78*17+,!)0!

2&00<,!%#!7!$#11#<*%.J!%):,!2&*8S*8S!78#%)0&!,0%!#'!0%)*$7+!$#8$0&8,!%#!%)0!1#108%!

#'!0W$)78S0!%)7%!:-,0%,!%)0!,1##%)!#-0&7%*#8!#'!%)0!17&T0%B!!L)0!2&00<0&U,!-#,*%*#8J!

*8!'7$%J!&0,012+0,!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!,.1-7%)0%*$!$##-0&7%*#8!<*,$:,,0<!2.!K7]]7&7%#!

[344f\!78<!L0&&78#F7![3446\J!78<!%):,!1#<0+,!78!7+%0&87%*F0!1078,!#'!#&S78*]*8S!

0$#8#1*$!+*'0!%)78!%)0!1078,!%.-*$7++.!7''#&<0<!2.!80#+*20&7+!17&T0%!$7-*%7+*,1B!!

L)0!2&00<0&U,!-#,*%*#8!*,!8#!+#8S0&!27,0<!#8!%)0!72,%&7$%!$#11#<*%.!F7+:0!#'!)*,!

78*17+,J!2:%!#8!#%)0&!%&:%)`F7+:0,J!70,%)0%*$`F7+:0,J!78<!0W*,%08%*7+`F7+:0,J!,:$)!7,!

)*,!78*17+U,!)07+%)!78<!M0++`20*8SB!!L)*,!*8%&#<:$0,!80M!7''0$%*F0!&0+7%*#8,!*8%#!%)0!

1#108%!#'!0W$)78S0J!,#10%)*8S!%)7%!%)0!^+U"7)!10&$)78%!*,!:8-&0-7&0<!'#&!78<!

:8M*++*8S!%#!7$$#11#<7%0B!!L)0!0W$)78S0J!*8!%:&8J!2&07T,!<#M8!7,!%)0!10&$)78%!

7278<#8,!)*,!-:&,:*%!'#&!%)0!2&00<0&U,!78*17+,B!!L)0!2&00<0&J!7%!+07,%!*8!1.!&07<*8S!

#'!%)*,!V:0,%J!,001,!1#,%+.!&0+*0F0<!2.!%)*,!78<!&0%:&8,!%#!M)7%!*,!%&:+.!F7+:72+0!%#!

)*1!k!17*8%7*8*8S!%)0!M0++`20*8S!#'!)*,!78*17+,B!

3f3!

! @#MJ!7<1*%%0<+.!%)*,!*,!#8+.!#80!,17++!87&&7%*F0!V:0,%!*8!7!S710!%)7%!+*%0&7++.!

)7,!):8<&0<,B!!?%!*,!8#%!0F08!7!-7&%!#'!%)0!17*8!V:0,%+*80!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!78<!,#!

*%!*,!-#,,*2+0!'#&!-+7.0&,!%#!1*,,!%)*,!V:0,%!08%*&0+.J!#&!10&0+.!':+'*++!%)0!10$)78*$7+!

&0V:*&0108%,!#'!%)0!V:0,%!M*%)#:%!08S7S*8S!M*%)!%)0!87&&7%*F0B!!A#M0F0&J!%)*,!V:0,%!

*,!012+017%*$!#'!%)0!2&#7<!-:&-#,0!#'!,*<0!V:0,%,!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!k!M#&+<!

2:*+<*8SB!!/*<0!V:0,%,!+*T0!%)0!#80!?!)7F0!<0,$&*20<!)0+-!%#!<0F0+#-!%)0!-+7.0&U,!

:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!'78%7,.!M#&+<!#'!E#&]07J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!%)0!<*''0&08%!$:+%:&0,J!

-#+*%*$,J!78<!+*F0<!0W-0&*08$0,!#'!*%,!*17S*87&.!*8)72*%78%,B!!;,!,:$)J!%)0,0!,*<0!

V:0,%,!7&0!':8<7108%7++.!-&01*,0<!#8!%)0!1787S0108%!#'!<*''0&08$0B!!L)*,!

*8%0&,0$%,!M*%)!%)0!<#1*878%!%)010!#'!%)0!17*8!,%#&.+*80J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!*8!%)0!

1#108%,!%)7%!08<!%)0!7&$!#'!%)0!$#&0!S710U,!,%#&.+*80B!!L)0!-+7.0&!:+%*17%0+.!

$#8'&#8%,!78<!<0'07%,!%)0!'7,$*,%*$!+07<0&!#'!%)0!Q7&+078!E1-*&0U,!1*+*%7&.J!2&*8S*8S!7!

1#108%7&.![2:%!2.!8#!1078,!<0'*8*%*F0\!)7+%!%#!%)0!E1-*&0U,!0''#&%,!%#!$#8V:0&!%)0!

&0S*#8!78<!:8*'.!*%,!$:+%:&0,J!&0+*S*#8,J!S#F0&8108%,J!78<!0$#8#1*0,B!!L)0!,:$$0,,!#'!

%)0!-+7.0&!*,!0W-+*$*%+.!7%%&*2:%0<!2.!%)0!S710J!%)&#:S)!%)0!%0W%!#'!*1-#&%78%!

,:--#&%*8S!$)7&7$%0&,J!%#!%)0!,%&7%0S*$!7++*7 8$0,! '#&S0<!20%M008!%)0!<*''0&08%!$*%.`

,%7%0,![Z*S:&0!d\B!"*''0&08$0J!*8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!*,!7!$&*%*$7+!&0,#:&$0!*8! % )0!&0,*,%78$0!

7S7*8,%!%#%7+*%7&*78*,1!78<!'7,$*,1J!7!%)010!%)7%!,%&#8S+.!&0,#87%0,!M*%)!

$#8%01-#&7&.!$&*%*$7+!,#$*7+!78<!-#+*%*$7+!%)0#&*0,!#'!,$)#+7&,!,:$)!7,!A7&<%!78<!

@0S&*![3444J!344f\J!L0&&78#F7![3446\J!78<!=70&S![3446J!345f\B!!!

! L):,J!M)08!+##T*8S!'#&!-#%08%*7+!#-08*8S,!*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!7!

80#+*20&7+!&7%*#87+*%.!*8!F*<0#!S710,J!%)0!$7,0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!,:SS0,%,!%)7%!M0!

17.!)7F0!7!20%%0&!$)78$0!#'!'*8<*8S!%)01!*8!%)0!,-7$0,!%)7%!7++#M!'#&!,#+*%:<0!78<!!

3fd!

Z*S:&0!dB!!/$&008,)#%!'&#1!7!<*7+#S:0!,0V:08$0!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!C*8'*+*7J!%)0!

$)7&7$%0&!,-07T*8SJ!*,!%)0!+07<0&!#'!#80!#'!%)0!#&S78*]7%*#8,![XL)0!/$*#8,!#'!%)0!

/0F08%)!"7M8Y\!%)7%!*,!-7&%!#'!%)0!E#&]078!7++*78$0B!!A0&0!,)0!0W%#+,!%)0!F*&%:0,!#'!

<*F0&,*%.B!

M*%)<&7M7+!&7%)0&!%)78!$##-0&7%*#8!78<!%#S0%)0&80,,J!#&!7%!%)0!F0&.!+07,%!7++#M!'#&!

,%&7%0S*$!1#F0108%!20%M008!%)0,0!%M#!,%7%0,B!!?8!1.!0W-0&*08$0!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!?!'0+%!1#&0!&0+*0'!78<!,:,%0878$0J!%)0!)7++17&T,!#'!,0+'`$7&0J!M)08!?!M7,!

7+#80B!!L)*,!*,!:8,:&-&*,*8S!$#8,*<0&*8S!1.!*8%&#F0&%0<!-0&,#87+*%.!78<!$#8$#1*%78%!!

&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!78W*0%.!78<!<0-&0,,*#8B!!A#M0F0&J!?!7+,#!'#:8<!1#&0!%)78!R:,%!

,:,%0878$0!78<!&0+*0'!M)08!?!M7,!7+#80!*8!E#&]07 B! !?!M7,!7+,#!72+0!%#!08$#:8%0&!7!

M#&+<!<*''0&08%!'&#1!1.!$:&&08%!M#&+<J!#80!M)0&0!,%7%0!S#F0&8108%,!012&7$0!78<!

$:+%*F7%0!<*F0&,*%.!78<!<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!#&S78*]*8S!0$#8#1*$!+*'0!#:%,*<0!#'!

$#1-0%*%*#8!78<!$7-*%7+*,1B!!!

3ff!

! ?8!%)0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!M7,!72+0!%#!'*8<!&0,#:&$0,!'#&!

*17S*8*8S!7+%0&87%*F0,!%#!%)0!$:&&08%!,#$*7+!#&<0&!78<!$:+%*F7%0!7!'00+*8S!'#&!M)7%!

%)#,0!7+%0&87%*F0,!$#:+<!20!+*T0B!!L)*,J!?!M#:+<!7&S:0J!$#8%&*2:%0,!%#!78!0W-0&*08$0!#'!

%)&*F*8S!%)7%!*,!8#%!+*1*%0<!2.!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.!78<!$7-*%7+*,1B!!L)*,!0W-0&*08$0!#'!

%)&*F*8S!*,!,%&:$%:&0<!2.!7!'00+*8S!'#&!7!':%:&0!%)7%!*,!20%%0&!%)78!%)0!-&0,08%!8#%!

20$7:,0!7!-0&,#8!)7,!,7%*,'*0<!%)0!87&&#M!&0V:*&0108%,!#'!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.![*B0B!

%)0!0,%72+*,)108%!#'!7!&0-&#<:$%*F0J!1#8#S71#:,!'71*+.!:8*%\!78<!$7-*%7+*,1![*B0B!

%)0!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!M07+%)\B!!L)0!'78%7,.!#''0&0<!2.!!"#$%!!$#'$()&*+,!*,!#80!%)7%!

,:,%7*8,!<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<!78<!%&07%,!%)01!M*%)!<*S8*%.B!!!

I)08!F*0M0<!%)&#:S)!%)0!)0S01#8*$!+08,!#'!%)&*F*8S!0W-&0,,0<!2.!%)0!

17R#&*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!%)08J!*%!*,!<*''*$:+%!%#!$+7*1!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!

$#8%&*2:%0!%#!%)&*F*8SB!!=:%!?!M#:+<!-:%!'#&M7&<!%)7%!%)7%!*,!7!+*1*%0<!:8<0&,%78<*8S!

#'!%)&*F*8SB!!L)0!7+%0&87%*F0!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!?!71!#''0&*8SJ!#80!

,%&:$%:&0<!2.!7!'00+*8S!'#&!7!M7.!#'!#&S78*]*8S!0$#8#1*$!78<!,#$*7+!+*'0!7&#:8<!

<*''0&08$0!78<!<*S8*%.J!<#0,!7++#M!'#&!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!$78!20!

,:,%7*8*8S!78<!%&78,'#&17%*F0B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!7!87~F0!7,,0&%*#8!%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!$78!#F0&%)&#M!)0S01#8.!78<!&*<!:,!#'!-#M0&J!,*8$0!?!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!%)0&0!

7&0!178.!178.!<*,$:&,*F0!78<!10$)78*$7+!'#&$0,!2#%)!*8,*<0!78<!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!

S710!%)7%!M#&T!%#!:8<0&1*80!%)0,0!'00+*8S,!78<!&0$:-0&7%0!%)01!'#&!$7-*%7+B!!?%!*,!

1#&0!7!S08%+0!&01*8<0&!%)7%!$:+%:&7+!,%&:SS+0!*,!8#%!7!]0&#`,:1!S710!*8!M)*$)!7++!

&0,*,%78$0!:+%*17%0+.!$#++7-,0,!27$T!*8%#!78<!*,!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!

<#1*87%*#8B!!

3fc!

Conclusion,!or!Sometimes!It’s!Good!to!be!Left!Alone!!

^+%*17%0+.J!%)*,!$)7-%0&!*,!7!&01*8<0&!%)7%!,%&:$%:&7+!'#&$0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!7&0!

8#%!%#%7+*]*8SJ!8#&!<#!%)0.!S:7&78%00!7!-7&%*$:+7&!0W-0&*08$0!#&!*8%0&-&0%7%*#8!#'!7!

$:+%:&7+!%0W%!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!7,!7!<*S*%7+!CCP!S710!,0%!

M*%)*8!7!'&78$)*,0!%)7%!'&0V:08%+.!M&0,%+0,!M*%)!V:0,%*#8,!#'!1:+%*$:+%:&7+*,1!78<!

,#$*7+!<*''0&08$0![_##&)00,J!3446\J!-&#F*<0,!7!+#%!#'!<*''0&08%!-+7.0&,!7 ! +#%!#'!

<*''0&08%!87&&7%*F0!78<!+:<*$!$#8%08%B!!?%!*,!-0&)7-,!:8,:&-&*,*8SJ!%)08J!%)7%!%)0!S710!

<#0,!8#%!-&#F*<0!7!$#8,*,%08%!78<!$#)0&08%!10,,7S0!72#:%!#:&!&0+7%*#8,)*-!M*%)!

<*''0&08%!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!-#M0&!#&!,%&7%0S*0,!M*%)!)#M!%#!$#-0!M*%)J!+0%!7+#80!

%&78,'#&1J!$#8<*%*#8,!#'!<#1*87%*#8B!!I)7%!*,!,:&-&*,*8SJ!*8!1.!-+7.*8S!#'!%)0!S710J!

*,!%)7%!M)7%!?!M#:+<!$7++!%)0!-&#S&0,,*F0!&0,#:&$0,!#'!%)0!S710J!%)0!$#1-#808%,!%)7%!

$78!)0+-!-+7.0&,!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!,#$*7+!$#8'*S:&7%*#8,!#'!-#M0&!78<!1#&0!

0V:*%72+0!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!M*%)*8!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!%)0!,%7%0!78<!%)0!0$#8#1.J!M0&0!8#%!

'#:8<!2.!-7&%*$*-7%*8S!*8!%)0!,#$*7+!7$%*F*%*0,!#'!%)0!S710B!!?8,%07<J!*%!M7,!2.!

M*%)<&7M*8S!'&#1!#%)0&,!78<!-+7.*8S!%)0!S710!7+#80!%)7%!?!M7,!20,%!72+0!%#!

7--&0$*7%0!%)0!S710U,!'78%7,.!M#&+<B!!!

?8!,)#&%J!%)08J!$78!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-!-0#-+0!%)&*F0g!!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!.0,J!

%)0.!$78J!20$7:,0!%)0.!$78!)0+-!-0#-+0!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!M#&+<,!78<!<0F0+#-!

$:+%:&7+!,%&7%0S*0,!%)7%!$78!17T0!7!<*''0&08$0B!!L)*,!7&S:108%J!)#M0F0&J!*,!-&01*,0<!

#8!7!<*''0&08%!78<!:8'71*+*7&!<0'*8*%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!#80!%)7%!*,!8#%!7''#&<0<!2.!

)0S01#8*$!87&&7%*F0,!%)7%!107,:&0!,:$$0,,!78<!F7+:0!*8!%0&1,!#'!M07+%)!

7$$:1:+7%*#8!78<!&0-&#<:$%*F0!+72#&B!!?!M*++!7<1*%!%)7%!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!:8<0&,%78<*8S!

0W-&0,,0<!2.!%)0!-7&%*$*-78%,!#'!1.!,%:<.B!!;8<!,#!%)0!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)&*F*8S!

3fh!

%)7%!?!71!-:%%*8S!'#&M7&<!*,!8#%!<0,$&*-%*F0!#'!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!%)7%!7+&07<.!0W*,%J!2:%!

*,!1#&0!7!&0,-#8,0!%#!M)7%!?!,00!7,!%)0!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!%)0!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!-:%!

'#&M7&<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,B!!@0F0&%)0+0,,J!*%!*,!S&#:8<0<!*8!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

$#8,:1-%*#8!78<!-+7.!%)7%!<#!0W*,%!*8!%)0!-&0,08%B!!C.!-7&%*$*-78%,!&0-#&%0<!1#F*8S!

20%M008!F7&*#:,!1#<0,!#'!,#$*7+*%.!<:&*8S!%)0*&!-+7.!%*10!78<!'7F#&0<!CCP!S710,!

%)7%!M0&0!<0,*S80<!M*%)!%)*,!'+:*<*%.!*8!1*8<B!!C#&0#F0&J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!7+,#!

0W-&0,,0<!7!-&0'0&08$0!'#&!S710!87&&7%*F0,J!M*%)!,#10!S#*8S!,#!'7&!7,!%#!,7.!%)7%!7!

,%&#8S!87&&7%*F0!$#:+<!#:%M0*S)!78.!+:<*$!$#1-#808%,!#'!7!S710!%)7%!%)0.!'#:8<!

<*,,7%*,'.*8SB!!D0%!M)*+0!%)0.!M0&0!712*F7+08%!72#:%!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!F*<0#!S710,!

$#:+<!)0+-!%)01!%)&*F0J!?!M#:+<!*8,*,%!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!)0+-!:,!%)&*F0!*'!M0!+##T!

20.#8<!%)0!87&&#M!$#8,%&7*8%,!#'!)0S01#8*$!<0'*8*%*#8,!#'!,:$$0,,!78<!'7*+:&0B!!;8<!

,#!1.!,-0$*'*$!*8%0&F08%*#8!*8%#!<*,$:,,*#8,!72#:%!10<*7!78<!%)&*F*8S!*,!%#!,:SS0,%!

%)7%!M)7%!*,!800<0<!7&0!8#%!<*''0&08%!$#8,:1-%*#8!-&7$%*$0,J!-0&!,0J!2:%!<*''0&08%!

$:+%:&7+!:8<0&,%78<*8S,!#'!%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!Z#&!-+7.*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!#''0&,!:,!7!

'78%7,.!M#&+<!M*%)!<*''0&08%!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!78<!1#<0,!#'!20*8S!'&#1!%)#,0!#''0&0<!*8!

%)0!M#&+<,!#'!178.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!78<!%):,!$78!)0+-!:,!<0F0+#-!7!'00+*8S!'#&!

%)#,0!M#&+<,J!7!,08,0!#'!M)7%!*%!M#:+<!'00+!+*T0!%#!+*F0!*8!%)#,0!M#&+<,B!!L)0,0!

'00+*8S,J!7,!K*,7!A08<0&,#8![345d\!7&S:0,J!)0+-!S&#:8<!%)0,0!:%#-*78!*17S*8*8S,!*8!

%)0!-&0,08%!78<!<0F0+#-!,%&#8S!01#%*#87+!7%%7$)108%,!%#!%)0,0!*<07,B!!=.!+##T*8S!

'#&!M)0&0!%)0,0!7%%7$)108%,!7+&07<.!7&0J!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,$)#+7&,!$78!%)08!<0F0+#-!

<*''0&08%!,%&7%0S*0,!7&#:8<!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!)0+-!:,0!%)0!080&S.!#'!%)0,0!

7%%7$)108%,!%#!17T0!7!<*''0&08$0B!!;'%0&!7++J!)#M!$78!M0!17T0!20%%0&!M#&+<,!*'!M0!<#!

8#%!T8#M!)#M!%#!&0$#S8*]0!%)01!*8!%)0!-&0,08%g!!=.!&017*8*8S!1*8<':+!#'!%)0!#-08`

3fa!

08<0<!-#%08%*7+!#'!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!M0!7+,#!&017*8!#-08!%#!

<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<!78<!%#!%)0!<*''0&08% ! #-08*8S,!78<!#--#&%:8*%*0,!

%)7%!%)0,0!M7.,!$&07%0B!!?'!M0!&0$#S8*]0!)#M!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!-+7.*8S!7!F*<0#!S710!#&!

M*%)<&7M*8S!'&#1!-0#-+0!$78!$&07%0!78<!,:,%7*8!<*''0&08$0,!78<!,)*'%!<*,%&*2:%*#8,!

#'!-#M0&!*8!%)0!-&0,08%J!M0!M*++!20!20%%0&!0V:*--0<!%#!<0F0+#-!80M!,%&7%0S*0,!78<!

&0,-#8,0,!%#!%)0!0F0&`,)*'%*8S!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!-#M0&!*8!%)0!': %:&0B!

;S7*8J!%)*,!<#0,!8#%!*S8#&0!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78J!78<!#'%08!

M*++J!20!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!)0S01#8*$!'#&$0,!*8!78!0''#&%!%#!$#8%&#+!78<!1787S0!

&0,*,%78$0B!!?!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!%)0!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!?!71!<0,$&*2*8S!7&0!

&7&0!78<!%)7%!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!M7.!#'!:8<0&,%78<*8S!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!?!71!<0,$&*2*8S!*,!

8#%!-#-:+7&B!!?!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!80#+*20&7+!-#+*$*0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!'&0V:08%+.!0W-+#*%!

%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!78<!%)&*F*8S!<0,$&*20<!%)&#:S)#:%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8J!78<!

%)7%!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'&0V:08%+.!&0,012+0,!%)0!%.-0,!#'!+72#&!-0&'#&10<!*8!78!

*117%0&*7+!0$#8#1.!78<!%):,!$78!20!:,0<!%#!-&0-7&0!-0#-+0!'#&!%)#,0!R#2,J!7,!D00!

[344h\!8#%0<!1#&0!%)78!7!<0$7<0!7S#B!!A#M0F0&J!?!7+,#!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!%)0,0!

#:%$#10,!7&0!8#%!S:7&78%00<J!78<!%)7%!2.!#8+.!-7.*8S!7%%08%*#8!%#!)#M!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!

'#&0$+#,0<!78<!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!,.,%01,!#'!-#M0&!M0!17.!1*,,!#-08*8S,!78<!'*,,:&0,!

%)7%!$78!20!:,0<!%#!17T0!7!<*''0&08$0B!!/%:7&%!A7++![566h2\!0+0S78%+.!,:117&*]0<!

%)0!&*,T,!#'!%)*,!7%%*%:<0!M)08!<*,$:,,*8S!7--&#7$)0,!%#!2+7$T!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!*8!%)0!

10<*7G!

3fi!

9:+%:&7+!)0S01#8.!*,!80F0&!72#:%!-:&0!F*$%#&.!#&!-:&0!<#1*87%*#8![%)7%U,!

8#%!M)7%!%)0!%0&1!1078,\l!*%!*,!80F0&!7!]0&#`,:1!$:+%:&7+!S710l!*%!*,!7+M7.,!

72#:%!,)*'%*8S!%)0!27+78$0!#'!-#M0&!*8!%)0!&0+7%*#8,!#'!$:+%:&0l!*%!*,!7+M7.,!

72#:%!$)78S*8S!%)0!<*,-#,*%*#8,!78<!%)0!$#8'*S:&7%*#8,!#'!$:+%:&7+!-#M0&J!8#%!

S0%%*8S!#:%!#'!*%B!!L)0&0!*,!7!T*8<!#'!r8#%)*8S!0F0&!$)78S0,J!%)0!,.,%01!7+M7.,!

M*8,U!7%%*%:<0J!M)*$)!?!&07<!7,!%)0!$.8*$7+!-&#%0$%*F0!,)0++!%)7%b,#10%*10,!

-&0F08%!%)01!u$:+%:&7+!$&*%*$,v!'&#1!<0F0+#-*8S!,%&7%0S*0,!%)7%!$78!17T0!7!

<*''0&08$0B!!?%!*,!7,!*'J!*8!#&<0&!%#!-&#%0$%!%)01,0+F0,!7S7*8,%!%)0!#$$7,*#87+!

<0'07%J!%)0.!)7F0!%#!-&0%08<!%)0.!$78!,00!&*S)%!%)&#: S)! 0F0&.%)*8S!k!78<!*%U,!

R:,%!%)0!,710!7,!*%!7+M7.,!M7,![-B!fhi\B!

/0<SM*$T![344d\!$7++0<!%)*,!%08<08$.!*8!$:+%:&7+!$&*%*$*,1!-7&78#*<!78<!,:SS0,%0<!

M07T!%)0#&.!78<!&0-7&7%*F0!&07<*8S,!7,!7!M7.!%#!$#&&0$%!%)*,!*127+78$0J!78<!$&*%*$7+!

,#$*7+!,$)#+7&,!,:$)!7,!Q*2,#8`Q&7)71![344h\J!A08<0&,#8![345d\J!78<!O*8871#8!

[345h\!)7F0!0W-78<0<!#8!%)*,!%#!#''0&!7+%0&87%*F0!M7.,!#'!787+.]*8S!,#$*7+!

1#F0108%,J!10<*7!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,J!78<!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!&0,-0$%*F0+.B!!C.!

787+.,*,!#'!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0!-&7$%*$0,!M#&T,!%#!,.8%)0,*]0!78<!7<7-%!%)0,0!

%)0#&*0,!'#&!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!78<!7:<*08$0!,%:<*0,!78<!17-!%)0!

%08,*#8,!78<!#-08*8S,!%)7%!$#8,*<0&*8S!%)0!V:0,%*#8!#'!%)&*F*8S!$78!$&07%0B!! ? % !*,!*8!

%)7%!,-*&*%!%)7%!?!+07F0!1.!7:<*08$0!M*%)!#80!'*87+!780$<#%0!'&#1!1.!%*10!,-08%!*8!

E#&]07B!

! ;,!?!,%7%0<!72#F0J!7++!-+7.0&,!20S*8!%)0*&!%*10!*8!E#&]07!%&7F0+*8S!%#!%)0*&!

$)#,08!,%7&%*8S!$*%.`,%7%0B!!L)*,!*,!20$7:,0!7++!-+7.0&!$)7&7$%0&,!7&0! X 7 <F08%:&0&,JY!7!

$+7,,!#'!$*%*]08!8#%!2#:8<!%#!78.!-7&%*$:+7&!87%*#8!k!*8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!78!*11*S&78%B!!

I)*+0!%)*,!,0&F0,!%)0!':8$%*#87+!-:&-#,0!#'!$&07%*8S!7!$#)0&08%!&07,#8!'#&!M).!*8`

S710!$)7&7$%0&,!1:,%!$#8,%78%+.!-&#F*<0!0W-#,*%*#8!72#:%!%)0!M#&+<U,!<*''0&08%!

$:+%:&0,J!S0#-#+*%*$7+!&0+7%*#8,J!78<!0$#8#1*$!,%&:$%:&0,J!*%!7+,#!,*S87+,!%)0!S710U,!

S080&7+!7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!<*''0&08$0!78<!<*F0&,*%.B!!>7%)0&!%)78!-&0,08%*8S!

*11*S&7%*#8J!<*''0&08$0J!78<!<*F0&,*%.!7,!7!X-&#2+01Y!%#!20!,#+F0<J!%)0!87&&7%*F0!#'!

3f6!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!*8,%07<!'&710,!%)01!7,!#--#&%:8*%*0,!'#&!80M!-#,,*2*+*%*0,!78<J!

:+%*17%0+.J!7!,#:&$0!#'!,%&08S%)B!!L#!%)*,!08<J!07$)!#'!%)0!$*%.`,%7%0,!*8!E#&]07!)7F0!

*8,%*%:%0<!-#+*$*0,!78<!-&#S&71,!%#!,:--#&%!78<!,:,%7*8!*11*S&78%,!%#!%)0*&!$*%*0,J!

,:$)!7,!,0%%*8S!7,*<0!+78<!,-0$*'*$7++.!'#&!*11*S&78%!)#:,*8S!78<!0,%72+*,)*8S!

#&S78*]7%*#8,J!+*T0!%)0!X;<F08%:&0&U,!Q:*+<Y!%#!)0+-!%)01!7$$+*17%0!%#!%)0*&!80M!

)#10B!!L)*,!*,!8#%!M*%)#:%!*%,!%08,*#8B!!L)0!'*&,%!%7,T!S*F08!%#!78.!80M!-+7.0&!

$)7&7$%0&!*,!%#!&0S*,%0&!M*%)!%)0!;<F08%:&0&U,!Q:*+<!2.!,-07T*8S!M*%)!*%,!+#$7+!

&0-&0,08%7%*F0B!!PF0&!%)0!$#:&,0!#'!%)*,!-&#$0,,J!% )#: S)J!.#:&!$)7&7$%0&!08$#:8%0&,!

10120&,!#'!%)0!+#$7+!-#+*$0!'#&$0!M)#!0W-&0,,!*110<*7%0!<*,%&:,%!#'!.#:&!$)7&7$%0&!

<:0!%#!%)0*&!*11*S&78%!,%7%:,B!!L)0!&0-&0,08%7%*F0!#'!%)0!;<F08%:&0&U,!Q:*+<J!

)#M0F0&J!#-08+.!$)7,%*]0,!%)0!-#+*$0!'#&!%&07%*8S!.#:&!$)7&7$%0&!%)7%!M7.!78<!

&01*8<,!%)01!%)7%!%)0!)07<!#'!,%7%0!)7,!#&<0&0<!7++!*11*S&78%,!%#!20!,:--#&%0<!78<!

%&07%0<!M*%)!<*S8*%.B!!?8!%)0!'7$0!#'!$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$78!-#+*%*$,J!M)*$)!)7,!,008!

7!&*,0!*8!87%*#87+*,%!78<!-&#%0$%*#8*,%!&)0%#&*$!78<!78!*8%08,0!,:,-*$*#8!#'!

*11*S&78%,J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!#''0&,!7!S08%+0&!%&07%108%!#'!*11*S&78%,!78<!

*11*S&7%*#8J!#80!*8!M)*$)!%)0!)7&,)!2+#M,!#'!&7$*,1!78<!-&0R:<*$0!7&0!10%!M*%)!

0V:7++.!'#&$0':+!,)71*8S!78<!$08,:&0!2.!%)#,0!*8!-#M0&J!8#%!&0-07%0<!2.!%)0!)07<!#'!

,%7%0B!!?8!,)#&%J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!#''0&,!-+7.0&,!%)0!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!0,$7-0!%)0!

2&:%7+*%.!78<!)7&,)80,,!#'!$#8%01-#&7&.!;10&*$78!7%%*%:<0,!%#M7&<,!*11*S&7%*#8!

78<!<*''0&08$0!78<!<0F0+#-!7!'00+*8S!'#&!7!M#&+<!*8!M)*$)!*11*S&7%*#8!78<!

<*''0&08$0!7&0!8#%!R:,%!$7&0':++.!-#+*$0<!78<!1787S0<J!2:%!7&0!7+,#!08$#:&7S0<J!

,:--#&%0<J!78<!,:,%7*80<!2.!%)0!,%7%0B!!? ,8U %!%)7%!7!8*$0!'78%7,.g!

3c4!

9A;(LE>!i!

9P@9K^/?P@J!P>!IAE>E!"P!IE!QP! Z>PC!AE>Eg!

;,!M0!$#10!%#!%)0!08<!#'!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8J!?!M#:+<!'*&,%!+*T0!%#!&0%:&8!%#!

Z#:$7:+%U,![56ii\!$#8$0-%!#'!X$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'Y!78<!O*8871#8U,![345h\!0+72#&7%*#8!#'!

%)*,!$#8$0-%B!!;,!-&0F*#:,+.!<*,$:,,0<J!Z#:$7:+%!<0&*F0<!)*,!X$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'Y!'&#1!

Q&0$#`>#178!7,$0%*$!-)*+#,#-)*0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!:&S0<!-0#-+0!%#!X7%%08<!%#!

#80,0+'BY!!L)*,!7%%08%*#8!%#!%)0!,0+'J!1078M)*+0J!$#:+<!)7F0!%&78,'#&17%*F0!0''0$%,!8#%!

#8+.!#8!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!-&7$%*%*#80&J!2:%!7+,#!#8!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,B!!;,!Z#:$7:+%!

<*,$:,,0,!*8!8$3/&.?&'2/&</%?J!Q&0$#`>#178!-&7$%*$0,!#'!,0+'`$7&0!$#8,%*%:%0<!7!,#$*7+!

-&7$%*$0!*8!%M#!,*S8*'*$78%!M7.,B!!Z#&!#80J!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,J!M)*$)!01-)7,*]0<!

&0'+0$%*#8J!*8%&#,-0$%*#8J!78<!$7&0':+!$#8%01-+7%*#8!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!&0,%!78<!&080M7+J!

$#:+<!-&0-7&0!-0#-+0!%#!7$%!*8!7!1#&0!0%)*$7+!M7.!M*%)!#%)0&,B!!L)*,!<#0,!8#%!1078!

%)7%!%)0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!0W71*80<!2.!Z#:$7:+%!0+*1*87%0<!,%&:$%:&7+!*127+78$0,!

#'!-#M0&!M*%)*8!Q&0$#`>#178!,#$*0%.B!!L)0.!,*1-+.!7''#&<0<!%)0!#-08*8S!#'!%)0!'*0+<!

#'!-#M0&!%#!S&07%0&!$*&$:+7%*#8B!!?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!%)0!$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'!$&07%0,!,-7$0!'#&!

%)0!0W0&$*,0!#'!X-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.JY!M*%)#:%!80$0,,7&*+.!S:7&78%00*8S!%)7%!%)0,0!

-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.!M*++!010&S0![Z#:$7:+%J!56iiJ!-B!55f\B!

L)0!,0$#8<!M7.!*8!M)*$)!%)0!$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'!*,!7!,#$*7+!-&7$%*$0!*,!*8!)#M!%)0!

-&7$%*$0!M7,!2:*+%!*8%#!%)0!*8'&7,%&:$%:&0!#'!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!+*T0!,$)##+,J!

108%#&*8S!78<!%07$)*8SJ!78<!,-*&*%:7+!,0&F*$0,![O*8871#8J!345hJ!-B!56d\B!!;8!08%*&0!

,#$*7+!*8'&7,%&:$%:&0J!%)08J!,:--#&%0<!%)0!Q&0$#`>#178!-&7$%*$0,!<0,$&*20<!2.!

Z#:$7:+%B!!Z#&!O*8871#8![345h\J!%)*,!*,!%)0!-&*17&.!<*,%*8$%*#8!20%M008!%)0!X$7&0!#'!

%)0!,0+'Y!<0,$&*20<!2.!Z#:$7:+%!78<!%)0!X,0+'`$7&0Y!-&7$%*$0,!-&#1#%0<!2.!

3c5!

$#&-#&7%*#8,!78<!#%)0&!80#+*20&7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!7S08%,B!!L)0!$#8%01-#&7&.!

1*8<':+80,,!1#F0108%J!O*8871#8!7&S:0,J!#$$:&,!*8!7!$#8%0W%!M)0&0!,#$*#0$#8#1*$!

$#8<*%*#8,!7&0!#&S78*]0<!7S7*8,%!7!,#$*7+!*8'&7,%&:$%:&0!% )7 %!,:--#&%,!7!%&:0!X$7&0!#'!

%)0!,0+'Y!*8!Z#:$7:+<*78!,08,0J!7!$7&0!#'!%)0!,0+'!%)7%!-&#1#%0,!X-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.BY!!

?8,%07<J!%)0!$#&-#&7%0!<0-+#.108%!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!*8,%07<!:,0<!*8!,0&F*$0!

#'!%)0!7$$:1:+7%*#8!#'!$7-*%7+!78<!%):,!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!$#8<*%*#8,!#'!

0W-+#*%7%*#8!78<!*80V:7+*%.B!!

O*8871#8J!)#M0F0&J!<#0,!8#%!:&S0!$&*%*$,!%#!%:&8!#:&!7%%08%*#8!7M7.!'&#1!

%)0!,0+'!#&!&0R0$%!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!1*8<':+80,,!7,!)#-0+0,,+.!,:2,:10<!2.!

80#+*20&7+!*8%0&0,%,B!!?8,%07<J!O*8871#8!08$#:&7S0,!:,!%#!:,0!/0<SM*$TU,![344d\!

&0-7&7%*F0!&07<*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%#!,00!%)0!-#%08 % *7+!#-08*8S,!%)7%!,0+'`$7&0!78<!

1*8<':+80,,!$&07%0!78<!%#!$#8,*<0&!)#M!%#!:,0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!%#!$&07%0!<*''0&08%!

':%:&0,B!!O*8871#8!<0,$&*20,!%)*,!R:W%7-#,*%*#8*8S!#'!Z#:$7:+%!78<!/0<SM*$T!7,!7!

1#F0!X'&#1!%)0!-7&78#*<!-&001-%*F0!%)0#&*]*8S!#'!)#M!M0!S#%!)0&0!%#!M)7%!%#!<#!*8!

%)0!1078%*10Y![-B!56f\B!!

L)*,!$#8$0&8!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!78<!,#$*7+!

R:,%*$0!*,!-7&%*$:+7&+.!&0+0F78%!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,J!7,!F*<0#!S710!

,$)#+7&,!)7F0!M&0,%+0<!M*%)!)#M!%#!<*,&:-%!S71*8S!$:+%:&0U,!*8F0,%108%!*8!

80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!*17S*80!1#&0!-&#S&0,,*F0!78<!%&78,'#&17%*F0!%&7R0$%#&*0,B!!Z#&!

*8,%78$0J!*8!)0&!0,,7.!X>7$*,1J!/0W*,1J!78<!Q71*8SU,!9&:0+!P-%*1*,1JY!<*S*%7+!10<*7!

,$)#+7&!K*,7!@7T71:&7![345a\!$&*%*V:0,!S71*8S!$:+%:&0U,!7%%7$)108%!%#!X-&#$0<:&7+!

10&*%#$&7$.JY!7!-7%)M7.!%#!,#$*7+!R:,%*$0!M)0&0!17&S*87+*]0<!S&#:-,!07&8!%)0!&*S)%!

%#!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!S71*8S!$:+%:&0J!M*%)!*%,!7%%08<78%!-+07,:&0,!78<!-#,,*2*+*%*0,J!2.!

3c3!

0W$0++*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710,B!!=.!<#*8S!,#J!%)0,0!17&S*87+*]0<!S710&,!012#<.!%)0!

+*20&7+!F7+:0,!#'!X,0+'`&0+*78$0J!:8'0%%0&0<!$#1-0%*%*#8!*8!:8&0S:+7%0<!,-7$0J!*8!,)#&%J!

7!80#+*20&7+!'78%7,.!#'!%)0!08%&0-&080:&*7+!,0+'U,!-#M0&!*8!-&0$7&*#:,!%*10,Y![-B!

3fa\B!!A#M0F0&J!%)*,!X1#<0+!1*8#&*%.Y!7--&#7$)!%#!,#$*7+!R:,%*$0!*,!7!-##&!-7%)M7.!

%#!,#$*7+!R:,%*$0!,*8$0!'7*+,!%#!7<<&0,,!78<!$)78S0!)#M!%)0!'*0+<!#'!S71*8S!*,!,%7$T0<!

7S7*8,%!-0#-+0!#'!$#+#&J!M#108J!V:00&,J!78<!#%)0&!17&S*87+*]0<!$#11:8*%*0,B!!!

EW%08<*8S!K7:&08!=0&+78%U,![3455\!$&*%*V:0!#'!$#8%01-#&7&.!^/!$:+%:&0!%#!F*<0#!

S710,J!@7T71:&7!7&S:0,!%)7%!%)0!80#+*20&7+!'78%7,.!#'!-&#$0<:&7+!10&*%#$&7$.!

0W01-+*'*0,!7!X%0$)8#$&7%*$!'#&1!#'!$&:0+!#-%*1*,1JY!78!7%%7$)108%!%)7%J!&7%)0&!%)78!

)0+-*8S!#80!7$)*0F0!X%)0!S##<!+*'0JY!*8,%07<!<0,%&#.,!%)0!F0&.!$#8<*%*#8,!#'!X%)0!S##<!

+*'0Y![-B!3fa\B!!@7T71:&7!$#8%08<,!%)7%J!*'!,#$*7+!R:,%*$0!'#&!17&S*87+*]0<!78<!

F:+80&72+0!-0#-+0,!*,!%#!20!7$)*0F0<!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!F*<0#!S710,J!S710&,!1:,%!'*&,%!

+0%!S#!#'!%)*,!'7*%)!*8!10&*%#$&7$.!78<!<*,$#F0&!X)#M!%#!17T0!78#%)0&!M#&+<!M)08!

%)0!#80!.#:U&0!*8!0W$+:<0,!.#:Y![-B!3f6\B!!!!!!!!

L)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!08%0&,!%)0,0!#8S#*8S!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!#8!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!

,0+'`$7&0J!1*8<':+80,,J!78<!,#$*7+!R:,%*$0!2.!17--*8S!78!7+%0&87%*F0!M7.!%#!%)*8T!

72#:%!%)0!F7+:0!#'!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!'#&!S71*8S!7:<*08$0,J!*8!%:&8!<01#8,%&7%*8S!

%)7%!&0$:-0&7%*#8!2.!80#+*20&7+*,1!*,!8#%!%)0!'#&0S#80!$#8$+:,*#8!#'!7!-0&,#8U,!

7%%7$)108%!%#!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!?%!<#0,!%)*,!2.!-#,*8S!78!:8*8%:*%*F0!.0%!

-&#<:$%*F0!V:0,%*#8!k!M)7%!*,!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!%)&*F*8S!78<!S71*8Sg!!?!,7.!

%)7%!%)*,!V:0,%*#8!*,!X:8*8%:*%*F0Y!20$7:,0!%)0,0!%M#!%0&1,J!X%)&*F*8SY!78<!XS71*8SJY!

7&0!7+1#,%!80F0&!-7*&0<!%#S0%)0&J!0*%)0&!*8!,$)#+7&+.!$#8F0&,7%*#8,!#&!*8!%)0!

$#8F0&,7%*#8,!#$$:&&*8S!M*%)*8!<*''0&08%!S71*8S!$#11:8*%*0,B!!;,!?!)7F0![)#-0':++.\!

3cd!

<01#8,%&7%0<J!%)#:S)J!-7*&*8S!%)0,0!%0&1,J!78<!%)0&02.!#-08*8S!,-7$0!'#&!%)0!

-#,,*2*+*%.!#'!%)0*&!$#0W*,%08$0J!$78!)0+-!:,!S7*8!7!20%%0&!:8<0&,%78<*8S!#'!%)0!&#+0!#'!

10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8!*8!0F0&.<7.!+*'0J!,-0$*'*$7++.!*%,!&#+0!*8!)0+-*8S!-0#-+0!$#8,%&:$%!

78<!,:,%7*8!%)0*&!+*'0!M#&+<,!78<!*17S*80!80M!-#,,*2*+*%*0,J!M)*$)!?!$7++!X%)&*F*8SBY!!

;,!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!8#%0<J!'#:8<7%*#87+!%#!%)*,!*,!,:&F*F7+J!#&!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!100%!27,*$!

800<,!78<!$#8%*8:0!':8$%*#8*8S!#8!7!<7.!%#!<7.!27,*,B!

I)08!?!20S78!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8J!?!%)#:S)%!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!M#:+<!

08%):,*7,%*$7++.!012&7$0!%)0!*<07!%)7%!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!$#:+<!)0+-!%)01!%)&*F0J!78<!

*8<00<!7+&07<.!M0&0!)0+-*8S!%)01!%#!%)&*F0J!#8$0!?!*8%&#<:$0<!%)01!%#!%)0!-7*&*8SB!!?!

0F08!*17S*80<!%)7%!1.!&0,07&$)!*8%0&F08%*#8,!$#:+<!)0+-!%)01!,00!%)0*&!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,!7,!1#&0!F7+:72+0!%)78!%)0.!)7<!-&0F*#:,+.!%)#:S)%B!!?8,%07<!#'!,#10%)*8S!

,)710':+J!F*0M*8S!%)0*&!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,!#'!%)&*F*8S!$#:+<!)0+-!

S710&,!7%%7$)!1#&0!F7+:0!%#!%)#,0!-&7$%*$0,B!!!!!!

;,!*,!:,:7++.!%)0!$7,0J!)#M0F0&J!1.!<7%7!-&0,08%0<!7!1#&0!$#1-+0W!-*$%:&0!#'!

%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!S71*8S!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!?8,%07<!#'!08%):,*7,%*$7++.!

012&7$*8S!%)0!7&%*$:+7%*#8!#'!S71*8S!78<!%)&*F*8SJ!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!7%%*%:<0,!

%#M7&<,!%)*,!-7*&*8S!M0&0!<*,%&*2:%0<!7+#8S!7!&78S0!#'!7''0$%,B!!/#10!<*<!

08%):,*7,%*$7++.!08<#&,0!%)0*&!$#880$%*#8J!2:%!R:,%!7,!178.!M0&0!,:,-*$*#:,!#'!

S71*8SU,!72*+*%.!%#!)0+-!%)01!%)&*F0J!M*%)!,#10!S#*8S!,#!'7&!7,!%#!&0R0$%!%)0!

-#,,*2*+*%.!08%*&0+.!#&!*8,*,%!%)7%!S71*8S!$#:+<!-&0F08%!-0#-+0!'&#1!%)&*F*8SB!!

C078M)*+0J!%)#:S)J!%)0!#F0&M)0+1*8S!17R#&*%.!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!$+7*10<!%)7%!

S71*8S!M7,!7!F*%7+!$#1-#808%!#'!%)0*&!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,J!#&!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!1#,%!

S07&0<!%#M7&<,!,:&F*F7+B!!!

3cf!

?8!,)#&%J!%)08J!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!%)#:S)%!%)7%!S71*8S!$#:+<!)0+-!%)01!,:&F*F0J!

2:%!M0&0!1#&0!712*F7+08%!72#:%!*%,!72*+*%.!%#!)0+-!%)01!%)&*F0B!!L)*,!+07<,!%#!M)7%!?!

)7F0!$7++0<!%)0!X-7&7<#W!#'!%)&*F*8SY!k!%)0!20+*0'!%)7%!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!7&0!1#,%!

,:--#&%*F0!#'!7!-0&,#8U,!,:&F*F7+!$78!7+,#!*8)*2 *% !%)0*&!%)&*F*8SB!!Z&#1!%)*,!

-0&,-0$%*F0J!S&#M%)!78<!,:,%0878$0!7&0!8#%!%)0!&0,:+%,!#'!,0+'`$7&0B!!>7%)0&J!

-7&7+.,*,!*,J!7,!-0#-+0!7&0!&0,*S80<!%#!&0+.!:-#8!7!-&7$%*$0!%)0.!'00+!M*++!:+%*17%0+.!

)#+<!%)01!27$TB!!L)*,!#&*08%7%*#8!%#M7&<,!%)0!10<*:1!#'!F*<0#!S710,!78<!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,J!?!7&S:0J!*,!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!2&#7<0&!7%%*%:<0!%#M7&<,!+0*,:&0!78<!+72#&!%)7%!

*,!&0'+0$%*F0!#'!M)7%!I08<.!=&#M8![344h\!)7,!$7++0<!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.B!!

L)*,!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!%7T0,!%)0!08%&0-&080:&*7+!,:2 R0$% *F*% *0,!7 8<!

+#S*$,!#'!'&00!17&T0%!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!M#&T,!%#!0W%08<!%)01!%)&#:S)#:%!%)0!'72&*$!#'!

,#$*7+!+*'0B!!L)*,!&7%*#87+*%.!M#&T,!%#!'&00!%)0! *8<*F*<: 7+J!-&*F7%0!08%0&-&*,0J!78<!%)0!

17&T0%!'&#1!%)0!*8%0&F08%*#8!#'!%)0!,%7%0!78<!*,!7$$#1-+*,)0<!%)&#:S)!7!F7&*0%.!#'!

10%)#<,G!0+*1*87%*8S!':8<*8S!#'!,#$*7+!,0&F*$0!-&#S&71,!+*T0!M0+'7&0J!-&*F7%*]*8S!

-:2+*$!,0&F*$0,J!<0&0S:+7%*8S!'*878$*7+!78<!278T*8S!*8<:,%&*0,J!78<!:8<#*8S!

08F*&#8108%7+!78<!+72#&!&0S:+7%*#8,!["*++#8J!345i\B!!;++!#'!%)*,J!#'!$#:&,0J!*,!*8!

,0&F*$0!%#!%)0!S#7+,!#'!$7-*%7+*,1J!,-0$*'*$7++.!*%,!S#7+!%#!&0-&#<:$0!78<!-&#+*'0&7%0!

$7-*%7+B!!!

P'!-7&%*$:+7&!&0+0F78$0!%#!1.!<*,$:,,*#8!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!)#M0F0&J!*,!%)0!

,:2R0$%*F*%.!%)7%!%)*,!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+ *% .!-&*F*+0S0,G!%)7%!#'!%)0!&7%*#87+J!

08%&0-&080:&*7+!*8<*F*<:7+B!!I*%)*8!%)*,!'&710M#&TJ!-0#-+0!7&0!8#%!#8+.!-&0,:10<!%#!

20!*8<*F*<:7+,!'&00!%#!17T0!$)#*$0,J!2:%!7&0!7+,#!@.3$%%)!.;%"1$'/>!%#!17T0!XS##<Y!

$)#*$0,B!!L)0!$#&#++7&.!#'!%)*,!*,!%)7%!,)#:+<!7!-0&,#8U,!+*'0!20!17&T0<!2.!*8,0$:&*%.!

3cc!

#&!<0-&*F7%*#8J!*%!*,!-&0,:10<!%#!20!7!$#8,0V:08$0!#'!%)0*&!-##&!*8<*F*<:7+!$)#*$0,B!!

?8!#%)0&!M#&<,J!%)0!F:+80&72+0!,:2R0$%!*,!'&710<!7,!78!08%&0-&080:&!M)#!)7,!17<0!

27<!-0&,#87+!*8F0,%108%,!78<!1:,%!8#M!,:''0&!%)0,0!$#8,0V:08$0,B!!?8!%)*,!M7.J!

&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!*,!<*,-+7$0<!'&#1!%)0!-7&%*$:+7&!,#$*7+!*8,%*%:%*#8,!78<!,%&:$%:&0,!%)7%!

$&07%0!78<!&0-&#<:$0!*80V:7+*%.J!,:$)!7,!S08<0&J!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.J!78<!$7-*%7+*,1J!

#8%#!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+![=&#M8J!344h\B!!I*%)*8!%)*,!'&710M#&TJ!*8<*F*<:7+,!7&0!

&0,-#8,*2+0!'#&!%7T*8S!$7&0!#'!%)01,0+F0,J!7!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!'0+%!

7$:%0+.B!!_*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!%)08!20$#10!7&%*$:+7%0<!M*%)!,0+'!$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!7,!

1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!&0-#&%0<!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#!<*,08S7S0!'&#1!<0178<*8S!0F08%,!#&!

,*%:7%*#8,J!+*T0!M7S0!+72#&J!78<!&0-7*&!78<!&080M!%)0*&!)07+%)J!2#%)!108%7++.!78<!

-).,*$7++.J!,#!%)7%!:+%*17%0+.!%)0.!17.!&0%:&8!%#!%)0,0!<0178<,B!!;,!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!

".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!(0:%0&![3446\!78<!D00![344h\!)7F0!7&S:0<J!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!

-7&%*$:+7&+.!*12&*$7%0<!*8!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!#'!7!-#,%`Z#&<*,%!0$#8#1*$!,.,%01!

#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!*117%0&*7+!+72#&![A7&<%!s!@0S&*J!344f\J!7,!%)0.!7&0!2#%)!7!

-&#<:$%!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&!78<!)0+-!-&0-7&0!,:2R0$%,!'#&!*117%0&*7+!+72#&B!

EW%08<*8S!%)*,!+*80!#'!%)#:S)%J!?!7+,#!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)*,!#&*08%7%*#8!%#M7&<,!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!$78!20!$:+%*F7%0<!78<!08$#:&7S0<!2.!%)0!%0W%!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!?8!

1.!787+.,*,!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!?!<01#8,%&7%0<!)#M!%)0!F*<0#!S710!%0W%J!$#1-#,0<!

#'!2#%)!87&&7%*F0!78<!+:<*$!'07%:&0,J!-&#F*<0!-+7.0&,!M*%)!-7&%*$:+7&!%##+,!%#!&0-7*&!

78<!&080M!&0,#:&$0,!%)7%!7&0!F7+:72+0!%#!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!+72#&J!

8710+.!%)0!-+7.0&U,!7%%08%*#8!78<!01#%*#87+!&0,0&F0,B!!A#M0F0&J!%)0!,0+'`$7&0!

-&7$%*$0,!7''#&<0<!2.!%)0,0!%##+,!7&0!,#10%)*8S!#'!7!<#:2+0`0<S0<!,M#&<J!7,!%)0.!7&0!

7+,#!-7*&0<!M*%)!10$)78*$,!%)7%!08$#:&7S0!-+7.0&,!%#!1#8*%#&!78<!S#F0&8!%)0*&!

3ch!

S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!,#!%)0.!17.!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!-+7.!,0,,*#8,!78<!&0%:&8!%#!#%)0&!

-&7$%*$0,!1#&0!F7+:0<!2.!7!,#$*#`0$#8#1*$!,.,%01!,%&:$%:&0<!7&#:8<!$7-*%7+*,1!

78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.B!!L)0,0!10$)78*$,!*8$+:<0<!%*10!1787S0108%!0+0108%,!*8!

%)0!:,0&!*8%0&'7$0!#'!%)0!S710!%#!20%%0&!0872+0!%)0!,0+'`,:&F0*++78$0!#'!%*10!,-08%!*8!

%)0!S710B!!L)0,0!%*10!1787S0108%!'07%:&0,!M#&T!*8!$#8R:8$%*#8!M*%)!%)0!2&#7<0&!

$:+%:&7+!,:,-*$*#8!#'!F*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!%#!$:+%*F7%0!7!-7&%*$:+7&!,%7%0!#'!

1*8<':+80,,!*8!-+7.0&,J!#80!%)7%!$78!$#1-0+!%)01!%#!*8%0&&:-%!%)0*&!S71*8S!,0,,*#8,!

78<!&0%:&8!%#!1#&0!7--&#-&*7%0!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!M#&T!78<!&0+7%*#8,)*-,J!-#%08%*7++.!

&0-&#<:$*8S!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!%)7%!17<0!0,$7-0!,#!7--07+*8S!*8!%)0!'*&,%!-+7$0B!!(:%!

78#%)0&!M7.J!S710,!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!$78J!78<!'&0V:08%+.!<#J!M#&T!%#!&0*8'#&$0!

%)0!*<07!%)7%!%)0!0,$7-0!#''0&0<!2.!%)0!S710!,)#:+<!#8+.!0F0&!20!%01-#&7&.J!78!*<07!

%)7%!*,!':&%)0&!2#+,%0&0<!M)08!M0!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!

$#8,:10<!*8!7!2&#7<0&!$:+%:&7+!$#8%0W%!%)7%!*,!<00-+.!,:,-*$*#:,!#'!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,B!

D0%!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!#8+.!87&&7%*F0!%)7%!M0!$78!%0++!72#:%!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!

20%M008!S71*8SJ!,0+'`$7&0J!78<!%)&*F*8SB!!;,!P&%80&![344h\!&01*8<,!:,J!,%&:$%:&7+!

$#8<*%*#8,!78<!,.,%01,!$78!80F0&!$#1-+0%0+.!S:7&78%00!)#M!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!%)0.!

$:+%*F7%0!M*++!:8'#+<!#F0&!%*10B!!_*<0#!S710!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!8#!<*''0&08%B!!(&7$%*$0,!7&0!

-&#$0,,0,!%)7%!7&0!,*%:7%0<!*8!-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%0W%,!78<!:8'#+<!#F0&!%*10J!%):,!#-08*8S!

:-!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!'#&!$&7$T,!%#!010&S0!*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!<#1*878%!

,#$*7+!78<!0$#8#1*$!,.,%01,!+*T0!$7-*%7+*,1!78<!)0%0&#8#&17%*F*%.B!!;$T8#M+0<S*8S!

%)*,J!)#M!$78!%)0!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!F*<0#!S710!7:<*08$0,!$&07%0!%)0,0!#-08*8S,J!

78<!)#M!*,!%)*,!&0+7%0<!%#!%)&*F*8Sg!!?!M*++!20S*8!M*%)!%)0!,0$#8<!V:0,%*#8!20$7:,0!*%!

3ca!

M*++!-&#F*<0!,#10!80$0,,7&.!$#8%0W%!'#&!1.!78,M0&!%#!%)0!'*&,%B!!;,!7!&01*8<0&J!7!

$&*%*$7+!0+0108%!#'!%)&*F*8SJ!'#&!2#%)!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!1.,0+'J!*,!%)0!72*+*%.!%#!

*17S*80!7!20%%0&!':%:&0B!!=.!*17S*8*8S!20%%0&!':%:&0,J!M0!7&0!72+0!%#!$&07%0!7!'00+*8S!

'#&!%)0,0!':%:&0,!*8!%)0!-&0,08%!78<J!)#-0':++.J!2 0S*8! %#!&07+*]0!%)0,0!':%:&0!

-#%08%*7+,B!!@#MJ!?!)7F0!7&S:0<!%)7%!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!S&07%+.!

*8'#&10<!%)0!':%:&0,!*17S*80<!2.!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!7,!$78!20!,008!*8!%)0*&!<0'*8*%*#8,!

#'!%)&*F*8S!78<!*8!%)0*&!7%%*%:<0,!%#M7&<,!%)0*&!#M8!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!L)*,!M#&&*0,!

10J!7,!*%!<#0,!,#!178.!#%)0&!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!78<!S710&,J!,*8$0!*%!*,!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!7!

$7-*%7+*,%!,%&:$%:&0!*8!M)*$)!78.%)*8S!#:%,*<0!#'!%)0!<#17*8!#'!$7-*%7+*,1![+*T0!,#10!

+0*,:&0!-&7$%*$0,\!*,!,:2,:10<!78<!&0$:-0&7%0<!2.!$7-*%7+J!78<!%):,!20$#10,!

$#1-+*$*%!*8!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!$7-*%7+B!

A#M0F0&J!7,!1.!787+.,*,!#'!1.!%*10!,-08%!*8!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!#8+*80!M#&+<!

#'!E#&]07!<01#8,%&7%0,J!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!#8+.!87&&7%*F0!%)7%!$78!20!%#+<!72#:%!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,B!!":&*8S!1.!-+7.J!-7&%*$:+7&+.!M)08!-+7.*8S!7+#80J!?!<*,$#F0&0<!87&&7%*F0!

0+0108%,J!-+#%,J!78<!&0-&0,08%7%*#8,!%)7%!-&#F*<0<!S+*1-,0,!*8%#!,#$*7+!78<!

0$#8#1*$!,%&:$%:&0,!%)7%!#-0&7%0<!:8<0&!+#S*$,!%)7%!<*''0&0<!,*S8*'*$78%+.!'&#1!

$7-*%7+*,1B!!L)0,0!0+0108%,J!*8!'7$%J!M0&0!$08%&7+!%#!%)0!S710U,!-+#%J!M)*$)!-#,*%*#8,!

-+7.0&,!7,!10120&,!#'!78!#&S78*]7%*#8!M#&T*8S!%#!:8<0&1*80!%)0!*1-0&*7+*,%!

7<F78$0,!#'!7!80*S)2#&*8S!$#:8%&.B!!L)*,!+0<!10!%#!%M#!$#8$+:,*#8,B!!P80!*,!%)7%J!

M)*+0!%)0&0!7&0!$0&%7*8!,%&:$%:&7+!78<!10$)78*$7+!'07%:&0,!#'!%)0!S710!%)7%!M#&T!%#!

&0-&#<:$0!%)0!+0*,:&0`+72#&!$.$+0!%)7%!*,!80$0,,7&.!%#!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!*117%0&*7+!

+72#&J!%)0,0!&0,%!7+#8S,*<0!87&&7%*F0!0+0108%,!%)7%!-&#F*<0!-+7.0&,!M*%)!%##+,!%#!

3ci!

*17S*80!<*''0&08%J!-#%08%*7++.!20%%0&!':%:&0,!78<!<0F0+#-!7!'00+*8S!'#&!%)0,0!':%:&0,!

*8!%)0!-&0,08%B!!!

C.!,0$#8<!$#8$+:,*#8!*,!%)7%!-+7.*8S!7+#80!*8!78!CCP!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!

$78!$&07%0!,-7$0!'#&!$&7$T,!%#!010&S0!*8!%)0!,1##%)!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!80#+*20&7+!

,:2R0$%,!R:,%!7,!M0++!7,J!*'!8#%!20%% 0&! %)78J!-+7.*8S!M*%)!-0#-+0B!!L)*,!$#8%&7,%,!M*%)!

%)0!M#&T!#'!$&*%*$7+!80%M#&T!,$)#+7&,!+*T0!L0&&78#F7![3446\J!".0&`I*%)0'#&<!78<!<0!

(0:%0&![3446\J!78<!=70&S![345f\!M)#!)7F0!,:SS0,%0<!%)7%!%)0!,#$*7+!$7-7$*%*0,!#'!

80%M#&T0<!F*<0#!S710,!)7F0!%)0!1#,%!-#%08%*7+!%#!<*,&:-%!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

80#+*20&7+*,1!%)&#:S)!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,B!!?8!1.!0W-0&*08$0J!78<!?!71!M*++*8S!%#!

M7S0&!*8!%)0!0W-0&*08$0!#'!#%)0&,J!-+7.*8S!7+#80!$&07%0,!%)0!$#8<*%*#8,!'#&!&0'+0$%*#8!

78<!$#8,*<0&7%*#8!%)7%!Z#:$7:+%![56ii\!7&S:0,!7&0!80$0,,7&.!*'!M0!M78%!#:&!,0+'`

$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!%#!20$#10!-7&%!#'!X-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.JY!M)*$)!7&0!:+%*17%0+.!

$#8$0&80<!M*%)!7!1#&0!0%)*$7+!87F*S7%*#8!#'!,#$*7+!-#M0&B!!L)*,!*,!0,-0$*7++.!%&:0!*8!7!

F*<0#!S710!M*%)!2#%)!7!$#1-+0W!87&&7%*F0!78<!,*S8*'*$78%!,#$*7+!0+0108%,J!+*T0!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,J!,*8$0!-+7.*8S!7+#80!#''0&,!-+7.0&,!%)0!20,%!#--#&%:8*%.!%#!0W-0&*08$0!

%)0!87&&7%*F0!#'!%)0!S710!*8!%)0*&!#M8!%*10!M*%)#:%!)7F*8S!%#!M#&&.!72#:%!

7$$#11#<7%*8S!%)0!<*''0&08%!800<,!78<!,$)0<:+0,!#'!#%)0&!-+7.0&,B!!Z#&!*8,%78$0J!

M)08!-+7.*8S!$##-0&7%*F0+.!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0!?!M#:+<!#'%08!,T*-!%)0!$*8017%*$!

*8%&#<:$%*#8,!78<!$#8$+:,*#8,!%)7%!M#:+<!#$$:&!*8!<:8S0#8,!,#!%)7%!#%)0&!-0#-+0!

M#:+<!8#%!)7F0!%#!*<+.!M7*%!7&#:8<!'#&!10B!!I)08!?!&0,:10<!-+7.*8S!2.!1.,0+'J!?!

M#:+<!%)08!M7%$)!%)0!,$080,!?!)7<!1*,,0<!`,*8$0!%)0!S710!7++#M,!.#:!%#!&0F*0M!

,-0$*'*$!,$080,!M)08!&0,%*8S!7%!78!*88B!!

3c6!

Possibilities!and!Potentials!

;8<!,#J!)7F*8S!&0F*0M0<!%)0!17R#&!$#1-#808%,!#'!1.!7&S:108%!78<!%)0!

T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!?!)7F0!$#8,%&:$%0<J!M)0&0!<#!M0!S#!'&#1!)0&0g!!?%!*,!7%!%)*,!-#*8%!

%)7%!?!71!&01*8<0<!#'!78!#2,0&F7%*#8!%)7%!,-7&T0<!/0<SM*$TU,![344d\!*8%0&0,%!*8!

&0-7&7%*F0!&07<*8S!78<!M07T!%)0#&.B!!? 8 !)0&!*8%&#<:$%*#8!%#!%)0,0!$#8$0-%,J!

/0<SM*$T!%0++,!%)0!,%#&.!#'!7!<*,$:,,*#8!,)0!)7<!M*%)!7$%*F*,%!,$)#+7&!9*8<.!(7%%#8!

72#:%!%)0!S080,*,!#'!A?_!78<!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!*%!M7,!08S*800&0<!2.!%)0!;10&*$78!

1*+*%7&.B!!;,!/0<SM*$T!&0$7++,J!)0&!07S0&80,,!%#!<*,$:,,!%)*,!-#%08%*7+!$#8,-*&7$.!M7,!

*8%0&&:-%0<!2.!(7%%#8J!M)#!&01*8<0<!/0<SM*$T!%)7%J!0F08!*'!%)*,!$#8,-*&7$.!M7,!

%&:0J!,:$)!7!<*,$#F0&.!M#:+<!8#%!%0++!%)01!78.%)*8S!%)7%!%)0.!<*<!8#%!7+&07<.!T8#MB!

L)7%!%)0!+*F0,!#'!%)0!-0#-+0!)*%!)7&<0,%!2.!%)0!<*,07,0![S7.!108!78<!;'&*$78!

;10&*$78,\!M0&0!$)07-+.!F7+:0<!2.!%)0!;10&*$78!S#F0&8108%B!!L)7%!%)0!1*+*%7&.!

&#:%*80+.!&0,07&$)0,!M7.,!%#!0''*$*08%+.!T*++!2#%)!$#127%78%,!78<!8#8`$#127%7 8%,B!!

L)7%!-0#-+0!*8!-#M0&!&0S7&<!$7%7,%&#-)*$!08F*&#8108%7+!0F08%,!$7+1+.!78<!'&#1!7!

<*,%78$0B!!!

;,!/0<SM*$T!87&&7%0,J!%)*,!08$#:8%0&!M*%)!(7%%#8!M7,!0872+*8S!'#&!)0&!8#%!

#8+.!20$7:,0!*%!&01*8<0<!)0&!%)7%!T8#M+0<S0!*,!-0&'#&17%*F0J!2:%!20$7:,0!*%!

,:SS0,%0<!78!7+%0&87%*F0!%#!M)7%!/0<SM*$T!$7++,!X%)0!)0&1080:%*$,!#'!,:,-*$*#8JY!

M)*$)!,)0!7&S:0,!)7<!<#1*87%0<!%)0!$&*%*$7+!%)0#&.!#'!)0&!%*10B!!=.!<&7M*8S!

7%%08%*#8!%#!%)0!-0&'#&17%*F0!7,-0$%!#'!T8#M+0<S0J!%)08J!(7%%#8!&01*8<0<!/0<SM*$T!

%)7%!&0$#S8*]*8S!+7&S0!,.,%01,!#'!#--&0,,*#8!78<!<#1*87%*#8!<#0,!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!

$#11*%!7!,$)#+7&!%#!7!-7&%*$:+7&!87&&7%*F0!#:%$#10B!!L)0!<0$*,*#8!%#!+#$7%0!%)0!

)*,%#&*$7++.!'&7:S)%!#&*S*8,!#'!A?_J!'#&!*8,%78$0J!17.!20!:,0':+J!2:%!%)08!7S7*8!*%!17.!

3h4!

8#%!20B!!I)7%!(7%%#8!&01*8<0<!/0<SM*$T!#'!*,!%)7%!%)0!<0$*,*#8!%#!'#$:,!#8!%)*,!

0+0108%!*,!8#%!7!$7%0S#&*$7+!*1-0&7%*F0!#'!$&*%*$7+!%)0#&.B!!?8!,)#&%J!M0!<#!8#%!)7F0!%#!

$#8,%78%+.!&0`<*,$#F0&!%)7%!<#1*87%*#8!78<!#--&0,,*F0!,#$*7+!,.,%01,!0W*,%!*8!#&<0&!

'#&!#:&!$&*%*$7+!&0,07&$)!%#!20!+0S*%*17%0B!!(7*&0<!M*%)!-&7$%*$0!%)0#&.J!M0!$78!7+,#!

7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!%)0,0!,.,%01,!#'!#--&0,,*#8!$78!$&07%0!78<!1#2*+*]0!%)0!-#%08%*7+!

'#&!%&78,'#&17%*F0!-&7$%*$0,!%#!010&S0B!

I0!$78!,00!%)*,!&0'+0$%0<!*8!%)0!87&&7%*F0!7&$!#'!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!A7F*8S!

7&S:0<!%)7%!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,U!-&7$%*$0!#'!:,*8S!F*<0#!S710,!%#!$7&0!'#&!%)0!,0+'!)7,!*%,!

#&*S*8,!M*%)*8!7!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!&7%*#87+*%.J!?!7+,#!<01#8,%&7%0<!%)7%!%)0,0!

-&7$%*$0,!$78!-#%08%*7++.!)0+-!-7&%*$*-78%,!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!':%:&0,!78<!,#$*7+!

$#8'*S:&7%*#8,!#:%,*<0!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!<0F0+#-!7!'00+*8S!'#&!%)0,0!':%:&0,!*8!%)0!

-&0,08%B!!I*%)!%)*,!80M!T8#M+0<S0J!%)#:S)J!M)0&0!$78!M0!S#!'&#1!)0&0g!!?8!1.!

#-*8*#8J!%)*,!T8#M+0<S0!0872+0,!:,!%#!*<08%*'.!78<!$:+%*F7%0!80M!F0$%#&,!'#&!$)78S0!

M)*$)!$78!20!)7&80,,0<!2.!,#$*7+!$&*%*$,!78<!7$%*F*,%,!%#!17T0!<0178<,!'#&!7!1#&0!

R:,%!78<!0V:*%72+0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!-#M0&B!!=:%!M)7%!<#0,!%)*,!+##T!+*T0g!!?!M*++!2&*0'+.!

,T0%$)!,#10!-#,,*2*+*%*0,!*8!%)0!)#-0!#'!-&#F*<*8S!.#:J!%)0!&07<0&J!M*%)!7!1#&0!

$#8$&0%0!*17S0!#'!%)*,B!

Z#&!*8,%78$0J!#80!#'!%)0!-&#2+01,!%)7%!O*8871#8![345h\!*<08%*'*0<!*8!%)0!

$#&-#&7%0!,:2,:1-%*#8!#'!,0+'`$7&0!-&7$%*$0,!M7,!%)0!+7$T!#'!7!,#$*7+!*8'&7,%&:$%:&0!

%#!08,:&0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!+07<!%#!-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.B!!L)0!$7,0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&

*+,!%)7%!?!)7F0!<0,$&*20<!2#%)!<01#8,%&7%0,!%)0!800<!'#&!,:$)!,%&:$%:&0,!M)*+0!7+,#!

-&#F*<*8S!:,!M*%)!80M!*<07,!72#:%!)#M!%#!$&07%0!%)0,0!,%&:$%:&0,B!!L)0&0!*,!7!,+*S)%!

<*,R:8$%:&0!20%M008!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!87&&7%*F0!%)010,J!M)*$)!01-)7,*]0!

3h5!

<*F0&,*%.!78<!7++*78$0,!7$&#,,!<*''0&08$0,J!78<!%)0!,#$*7+!08F*&#8108%,!#'!178.!

CCP>(Q,J!M)*$)!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!2.!)*0&7&$)*0,!#'!-+7.!,%.+0,!78<!%)0!

<*,-7&7S0108%!#'!<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!-+7.*8S!78<J!2.!0W%08,*#8J!<*''0&08%!M7.,!#'!

20*8S!*8!%)0!M#&+<![L7.+#&J!3453\B!!I)*+0!%)*,!$78!178*'0,%!*8!#F0&%!<*,-+7.,!#'!

2*S#%&.![Q&7.J!345f\J!0F08!,:2%+0&!'#&1,!#'!<08*S&7%*#8J!,:$)!7,!1#$T*8S!7!)07+0&!'#&!

8#%!<717S*8S!0801*0,J!$78!)0*S)%08!78W*0%*0,!72#:%!#80U,!-+7$0!M*%)*8!%)0!

$#11:8*%.!#'!%)0!S710J!78<!%):,!$&07%0!-7%%0&8,!#'!*8$+:,*#8!78<!0W$+:,*#8!%)7%!)*%!

10120&,!#'!F:+80&72+0!$#11:8*%*0,!%)0!)7&<0,%B!!!

D0%!*&#8*$7++.J!*%!*,!2.!<#$:108%*8S!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!M07T80,,0,!k!8710+.!

%)0!<*,,#878$0!20%M008!*%,!87&&7%*F0!%)010,!78<!*%,!,#$*7+!10$)78*$,!78<!*%,!

0,$)0M*8S!#'!$7&0':+!$#11:8*%.!#F0&,*S)%!k!%)7%!?!<*,$#F0&0<!%)0!S&07%0,%!-#%08%*7+,!

'#&!1#2*+*%.!78<!-&#S&0,,B!!?%,!87&&7%*F0!%)010,!#'!<*F0&,*%.J!*8$+:,*F*%.J!78<!

$#7+*%*#8`2:*+<*8SJ!'#&!*8,%78$0J!17T0!*%!07,*0&!%#!<0178<!%)7%!%)0!S710!-&#<:$0&,!

7--+.!%)0,0!,710!F7+:0,!%#!*%,!,#$*7+!10$)78*$,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!'07%:&0,!78!

0W%08,*F0!%:%#&*7+!,.,%01!%)7%!-&0-7&0,!-+7.0&,!'#&!%)0!+:<*$!$)7++08S0,!#'!%)0!S710B!!

I).!8#%!7!,*1*+7&!%:%#&*7+!,.,%01!%#!-&0-7&0!-+7.0&,!'#&!%)0!,#$*7+!$)7++08S0,!#'!

<*F0&,*%.!*8!78!CCP>(Qg!!/:$)!7!,.,%01!M#:+<!0872+0!*%,!87&&7%*F0!%)010,!%#!

*8'#&1!)#M!*%,!-+7.0&,!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!#80!78#%)0&!78<J!-0&)7-,J!$:+%*F7%0!7!

$#11:8*%.!M)0&0!-#M0&!*,!80S#%*7%0<!1#&0!0%)*$7++.B!!L)*,!,.,%01J!*8!%:&8J!$#:+<!20!

&0*8'#&$0<!2.!7$%*F0+.!1#8*%#&*8S!*8`S710!*8%0&7$%*#8,!M*%)!-0#-+0!78<!*8%0&F08*8S!

*8!*8,%78$0,!#'!72:,0!78<!<*,$#1'#&%J!&7%)0&!%)78!-7,,*F0+.!&0+.*8S!#8!-+7.0&,!%#!

<#$:108%!78<!&0-#&%!%)*,!72:,0!%)01,0+F0,B!!!

3h3!

P'!$#:&,0J!,:$)!7!,.,%01!M#:+<!-&0,08%!,0F0&7+!$)7++08S0,!%#!S710!<0,*S80&,!

78<!$#11:8*%.!1787S0&,B!!@#%!#8+.!M#:+<!,:$)!7!,.,%01!$7&&.!7!,*S8*'*$78%!

'*878$*7+!78<!+72#&!2:&<08J!2:%!*%!M#:+<!7+,#!<0178<!1#&0!#'!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,U,!

7:<*08$0!2.!&0V:*&*8S!%)01!%#!<0F0+#-!7!-0&)7-,!:8'71*+*7&!,#$*7+!,T*++,0%B!!

A#M0F0&J!S710,!7+&07<.!<#!%)*,B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!)7,!7+&07<.!*8F0,%0<!7!,*S8*'*$78%!

71#:8%!#'!%*10!78<!1#80.!*8%#!<0F0+#-*8S!7!%:%#&*7+!,.,%01!#&S78*]0<!7&#:8<!*%,!

+:<*$!78<!10$)78*$7+!<0178<,J!<0178<,!%)7%!*8!%:&8!7&0!-0&)7-,!:8'71*+*7&!%#!7!

,*S8*'*$78%!8:120&!#'!-+7.0&,B!!;8<!,#!?!M#:+<!-:%!'#&M7&<!%)7%!%)0!27&&*0&,!%#!%)0!

*1-+0108%7%*#8!#'!,:$)!7!,.,%01!7&0!8#%!80$0,,7&*+.!'*878$*7+!#&!10$)78*$7+!*8!

87%:&0!2:%!$:+%:&7+J!,*8$0!%)0.!7&0!0W-&0,,*F0!#'!-7&%*$:+7&!F7+:0,B!!I)*+0!7%!'7$0!

F7+:0!%)0!*<07!#'!<0178<*8S!-+7.0&,!20)7F0!1#&0!&0,-0$%':++.!%#M7&<,!#80!78#%)0&!

17.!,001!+*T0!78!#<*#:,!2:&<08!#8!7!-+7.0&U,!'&00<#1J!%)*,!$#1-+7*8%!*S8#&0,!7++!#'!

%)0!#%)0&!+*1*%7%*#8,!%)7%!S710,!80$0,,7&*+.!-+7$0!#8!7!-+7.0&U,!'&00<#1B!!Q710,!7&0!

,.,%01,!%)7%!-&*F*+0S0!,-0$*'*$!-&7$%*$0,!78<!F7+:0,!72#F0!#%)0&,B!!I)7%!?!71!7,T*8S!

*,!'#&!7!S710!+*T0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,!%#!-&*F*+0S0J!78<!)08$0!-#%08%*7++.!$:+%*F7%0J!

F7+:0,!78<!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!$#:+<!+07<!%#!7!1#&0!0V:*%72+0!<*,%&*2:%*#8!#'!-#M0&!

M*%)*8!*%,!7:<*08$0B!!L)0,0!F7+:0,!7&0!8#%!$#1-+0%0+.!'#&0*S8!%#!!"#$%&!$#'$()&78<!*%,!

7:<*08$0!k!7,!?!78<!#%)0&,![0BSB!_##&)00,J!3446\!)7F0!<01#8,%&7%0<J!1787S*8S!

<*F0&,*%.!*,!$08%&7+!%#!%)0!,0&*0,U!%)017%*$!,%&:$%:&0B!!A08$0!2.!<0178<*8S!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!%#!7++#$7%0!&0,#:&$0,!%#!&0S:+7%0!*%,!,#$*7+!$#11:8*%*0,!78<!-&#%0$%!*%,!

1#,%!F:+80&72+0!-+7.0&,!'&#1!72:,0!78<!<*,$#1'#&%J!?!71!*8!'7$%!7,T*8S!!"#$%&

!$#'$()&*+,!%#!<0+*F0&!#8!%)0!-&#1*,0,!*%,!87&&7%*F0!)7,!17<0B!

3hd!

L)*,!*,!%)0!T*8<!#'!<0178<!%)7%!%)0!T8#M+0<S0!?!)7F0!$:+%*F7%0<!*8!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8!$78!-&#<:$0B!!=.!+##T*8S!7%!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!%)&#:S)!%)0!+08,!#'!

%)&*F*8SJ!M0!$78!20S*8!%#!,00!)#M!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!$78!$&07%0!'00+*8S,!'#&!<*''0&08%!

':%:&0,J!S&#:8<!%)#,0!'00+*8S,!*8!%)0!-&0,08%J!78<!<*&0$%!%)#,0!080&S*0,! % #M 7&<,!

&07+*]*8S!%)#,0!':%:&0,B!!O*8871#8![345h\!7&S:0<!%)7%!#80!#'!%)0!+*1*%7%*#8,!#'!

80#+*20&7+!,0+'`$7&0!M7,!%)0!+7$T!#'!7!,#$*7+!,%&:$%:&0!%#!,:,%7*8!78<!<*&0$%!%)#,0!

-&7$%*$0,!%#M7&<,!M)7%!Z#:$7:+%!)7,!$7++0<!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.B!!?!,)7&0!%)*,!

M#&&.J!.0%!M)*+0!O*8871#8!M7,!$#8$0&80<!M*%)!)#M!0$#8#1*$!78<!-#+*%*$7+!,.,%01,!

78<!,%&:$%:&0,!M0&0!#&S78*]0<!7S7*8,%!,0+'`$7&0!78<!-&7$%*$0,!#'!+*20&%.J!?!M#:+<!

7&S:0!%)7%!%)0&0!7&0!7+%0&87%*F0!-7%),!%)7%!$78!%&78,'#&1!,0+'`$7&0!*8%#!-&7$%*$0,!#'!

+*20&%.B!!L)&#:S)!1.!787+.,*,!#'!%)0!&0+7%*#8,)*-!20%M008!F*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!

78<!%)&*F*8SJ!?!)7F0!7%%01-%0<!%#!$)7&%!,:$)!7!-7%)!2.!,)#M*8S!)#M!F*<0#!S71*8S!

-&7$%*$0,!$78!)0+-!-+7.0&,!$7&0!'#&!%)01,0+F0,B!!L)0,0!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,J!1#&0#F0&J!

$78!+07<!%#!7!T*8<!#'!%)&*F*8S!%)7%!<#0,!8#%!,*1-+.!&0-&#<:$0!%)0!%0&1,!#'!%)&*F*8S!

0,%72+*,)0<!2.!80#+*20&7+*,1J!2:%!$78!0872+0!7:<*08$0,!%#!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!

-#,,*2*+*%*0,!78<!':%:&0,B!!!

L)*,!*,!8#%!-#+*%*$7+!-&7$%*$0!*8!%)0!%&7<*%*#87+!,08,0!#'!0+0$%#&7+!$#8%0,%,!78<!

1780:F0&*8S!'#&!&0,#:&$0!$#8%&#+![A08<0&,#8J!345d\J!2:%!%)*,!<#0,!8#%!1078!%)7%!*%!

$788#%!)7F0!-#+*%*$7+!0''0$%,B!!L#!&0%:&8!%#!78!*<07!*8%&#<:$0<!07&+.!*8!%)*,!

<*,,0&%7%*#8J!%)0!-&7$%*$0,!%)7%!?!)7F0!<0,$&*20<!78<!787+.]0<!*8!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!7&0!

1#&0!-&#-0&+.!$7++0<!D6E'$F.%"'"=$%B!!;,!=0&+78%![344i\!<0,$&*20,!*%J!%)0!D6E'$F.%"'"=$%!

0W*,%,!*8!$+#,0!-&#W*1*%.!%#!-#+*%*$,J!7%!%*10,!0F08!$&#,,*8S!#F0&!*8%#!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!

,-)0&0J!2:%!1#&0!#'%08!%)78!8#%!*,!&0,*,%78%!%#!%)7%!,-)0&0!78<!,%&:$%:&0<!7,!7!&0+*0'!

3hf!

'&#1!%)0!-#+*%*$7+!,-)0&0B!!@0F0&%)0+0,,J!R:W%7-#+*%*$7+!-&7$%*$0,J!+*T0!%)0!*8%*17%0!

-:2+*$!#'!M#108U,!17,,`10<*7%0<!$:+%:&0!787+.]0<!2.!=0&+78%J!$78!)7F0!-#M0&':+!

-#+*%*$7+!0''0$%,!,*8$0!%)0.!)0+-!#&S78*]0!78<!1#2*+*]0!-0#-+0U,!7%%7$)108%,!%#!

-7&%*$:+7&!'78%7,*0,J!*<08%*%*0,J!78<!+*'0!87&&7%*F0,B!!_*<0#!S71*8S!-&7$%*$0,!*8!

-7&%*$:+7&!$78!20!-#M0&':+!,*%0,!'#&!%)0!$&07%*#8!78<!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!'78%7,*0,J!

*<08%*%*0,J!78<!+*'0!87&&7%*F0,!,*8$0!%)0.!&0V:*&0!-+7.0&,!%#!1#&0!':++.!-7&%*$*-7%0!*8!

%)0!:8'#+<*8S!#'!*%,!0F08%,!%)78!#%)0&!10<*7B!!I)*+0!,#10!,$)#+7&,!)7F0J!&*S)%+.J!

7&S:0<!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!'&0V:08%+.!<0,*S80<!*8!,:$)!7!M7.!7,!%#!':&%)0&!

08%&08$)!-+7.0&,!*8!%)0!&).%)1,!78<!+*'0!87&&7%*F0,!#'!80#+*20&7+*,1!78<!*117%0&*7+!

+72#&J!?!M#:+<!7&S:0!%)7%!%)*,!*,!8#%!%)0!#8+.!-#,,*2+0!#:%$#10B!!/#$*7+!-&7$%*$0,!+*T0!

10<*7!$#8,:1-%*#8!:8'#+<!:8-&0<*$%72+.J!$&07%*8S!#-08*8S,!*8!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!

,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!%)7%!$78J!M*%)!08#:S)!'#&$0J!20$#10!%&78,'#&17%*F0B!!

^+%*17%0+.J!%)08J!M)7%!%)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!$#8%&*2:%0,!%#!%)0!'*0+<,!#'!F*<0#!S710!

,%:<*0,!78<!$&*%*$7+!$:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!*,!7!+08,!M)*$)!$78!20!:,0<!%#!*<08%*'.!-#%08%*7+!

S7-,!*8!%)0!&0-&#<:$%*#8!#'!80#+*20&7+!-#+*%*$7+!7''0$%,!%)&#:S)!F*<0#!S710,B!!=.!

7++#M*8S!'#&!%)0!-#,,*2*+*%.!%)7%!F*<0#!S710,!$78!)0+-!-0#-+0!%)&*F0J!M)*$)!?!)7F0!

<#80!2.!,*1-+.!V:0,%*#8*8S!"?!F*<0#!S710,!$78!)0+-!-0#-+0!%)&*F0J!?!)7F0!)#-0':++.!

-&#F*<0<!%)0#&0%*$7+!78<!10%)#<#+#S*$7+!%##+,!%)7%!$78!01-#M0&!,$)#+7&,!%#!

&0$#S8*]0!%)0!1.&*7<!#'!$&07%*F0!78<!:878%*$*-7%0<!M7.,!-0#-+0!7+&07<.!&0,-#8<!%#!

78<!1780:F0&!M*%)*8!%)0!<0178<,!#'!80#+*20&7+!$7-*%7+B!!I)*+0!%)0,0!-&7$%*$0,!7&0!

S&#:8<0<!*8!%)0!-&0,08%J!%)0.!$78!7+,#!20!#&*08%0<!%#M7&<,!%)0!':%:&0J!7!':%:&0!%)7%!

*,!2.!8#!1078,!S:7&78%00<!2.!%)0!,%&:$%:&0,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!'&#1!M)*$)!*%!#&*S*87%0,B!!

L)*,!*,!7!,%78$0!$)7&7$%0&*]0<!2.!78!7$T8#M+0<S0108%!%)7%!-0#-+0!+*F0!:8<0&!

3hc!

F7&.*8S!$#8<*%*#8,!#'!<#1*87%*#8!78<!<0-&*F7%*#8!78<!%)0!)#-0!%)7%!%)0,0!

$*&$:1,%78$0,!$78!20!$)78S0<B!!(0#-+0!$78!*17S*80!<*''0&08%!':%:&0,B!!_*<0#!S710,!

$78!)0+-!-0#-+0!$:+%*F7%0!7!'00+*8S!'#&!%)0,0!':%:&0,J!%):,!S&#:8<*8S!%)0,0!':%:&0,!*8!

%)0!-&0,08%B!!?%!*,!-0&)7-,!8#%!7!+*T0+.!#:%$#10!#'!$#8,:1*8S!F*<0#!S710,J!2:%!*%!*,!7!

-#,,*2*+*%.J!78<!7!-#M0&':+!#80!7%!%)7%B!!L)*,!<*,,0&%7%*#8!7,T,!$&*%*$7+!,$)#+7&,!8#%!%#!

<*,1*,,!%)*,!-#%08%*7+!7,!87*F0J!2:%!%#!&0$#S8*]0!*%!78<!7$T8#M+0<S0!%)7%!S71*8SJ!'#&!

,#10J!*,!80$0,,7&.!'#&!,:&F*F7+B!!;8<!*'!*%!*,!7!80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!'#&!,:&F*F7+J!%)08!*%!

*,!7+,#!7!80$0,,7&.!$#8<*%*#8!'#&!%)&*F*8SB!

3hh!

;((E@"?e!;!

/^>_ED!j^E/L?P@/!

5B A#M!M#:+<!.#:!<0,$&*20!.#:&!S08<0&g!!/0W:7+*%.g!!>7$0g!! ;&0!%)0&0!78.!#%)0&!

%0&1,!#&!$)7&7$%0&*,%*$,!.#:!M#:+<!:,0!%#!<0,$&*20!.#:&,0+'g!!(+07,0!'00+!'&00!

%#!<0,$&*20!.#:&,0+'!*8!78.!M7.!.#:!M*,)B!

3B L0++!10!7!2*%!72#:%!M)0&0!.#:!S&0M!:-B!D#:&!'71*+.g!I)7%!M0&0!.#:&!

-7&08%,U!#$$:-7%*#8g!!E<:$7%*#8g!!!

dB ;&0!.#:!*8!,$)##+g!I)7%U,!%)0!)*S)0,%!+0F0+!#'!'#&17+!0<:$7%*#8!.#:UF0!

$#1-+0%0<g!!?'!.#:!M08%!%#!$#++0S0J!M)7%!M7,!.#:&!17R#&g!!!

fB I)7%!*,!.#:&!#$$:-7%*#8J!*'!M#&T*8Sg!I#&T!)*,%#&.g!

!!!

cB A#M!+#8S!)7F0!.#:!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,g!!!

hB I)7%!*,!%)0!'*&,%!S710!.#:!&010120&!-+7.*8Sg!"*<!.#:!+*T0!*%g!!

aB ?'!.#:!20S78!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!M)*+0!.#:!M0&0!7!$)*+<J!<*<!.#:&!$7&0`S*F0&!

0F0&!+*1*%!)#M!1:$)!!%*10!.#:!M0&0!7++#M0<!%#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,g!!I).!#&!

M).!8#%g!

!!!

iB A7F0!.#:!-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!$#8,*,%08%+.!,*8$0!%)08g!

3ha!

6B ?'!.#:!)7F0!8#%!-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!$#8,*,%08%+.J!M)7%!7&0!,#10!#%)0&!%)*8S,!

%)7%!M0&0!S#*8S!#8!*8!.#:&!+*'0!%)7%!*8%0&&:-%0<!.#:&!F*<0#!S710!-+7.*8Sg!!

54B I).!<#!.#:!$:&&08%+.!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,g!

!!!

55B I)7%!-+7%'#&1,!<#!.#:!-+7.!#8g!!I).!<*<!.#:!$)##,0!%)#,0!-+7%'#&1,g!

!!!

53B I)7%!%.-0,!#'!F*<0#!S710,!<#!.#:!-+7.g!I)7%!7&0!.#:&!%)&00!'7F#&*%0!%*%+0,g!!

5dB I)7%!<#!.#:!+##T!'#&!*8!S710,g!I)7%!7&0!.#:&!$&*%0&*7!'#&!S##<!S710,g!!!

5fB A#M!<#!.#:!'*8<!S710,!.#:!1*S)%!+*T0!%#!-+7.g!!;&0!%)0&0!78.!,-0$*'*$!80M,!

#:%+0%,J!-:2+*$7%*#8,J!#&!M02!,*%0,!%)7%!.#:!:,0g!!?'!,#J!M)7%!7&0!%)0.g!

!!!

5cB 9#:+<!.#:!<0,$&*20!7!%.-*$7+!S71*8S!,0,,*#8!'#&!10g!!

5hB "#!.#:!-&0'0&!%#!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!7+#80!#&!M*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0g!!;&0!%)0&0!

-7&%*$:+7&!!%.-0,!#'!S710,!%)7%!.#:!-&0'0&!%#!-+7.!7+#80g!I*%)!#%)0&!-0#-+0g!

5aB !"#!.#:!+*T0!%#!M7%$)!#%)0&!-0#-+0!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,g!!I).!#&!M).!8#%g!!;&0!

%)0&0!78.!S710,!#&!%.-0,!#'!S710,!%)7%!.#:!-&0'0&!%#!M7%$)!#%)0&!-0#-+0!-+7.!

&7%)0&!%)78!-+7.!.#:&,0+'g!!?'!,#J!M ).g !!!

3hi!

5iB ?'!.#:!<#!M7%$)!#%)0&!-0#-+0!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,J!)#M!<#!.#:!M7%$)!%)01!-+7.g!!

?8!-0&,#8!#&!#8+*80![%)&#:S)!7!M02!,*%0!+*T0!LM*%$)!#&!.#:%:20J!'#&!0W71-+0\g!!

"#!.#:!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!%)0!-+7.0&J!78<!*'!,#J!)#M!<#!.#:!*8%0&7$%!M*%)!%)01!

[%7+TJ!#8+*80!$)7%J!0%$B\g!!!!!!

56B A#M!M#:+<!.#:!<0'*80!7!XS710&gY!"#!.#:!*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&g!I).!#&!M).!

8#%g!!!

34B I)7%!#%)0&!%.-0!#'!10<*7!<#!.#:!S080&7++.!+*T0g!L0+0F*,*#8g!C#F*0,g!=##T,g!

C:,*$g!9#:+<!!.#:!S*F0!10!0W71-+0,!#'!L_!,)#M,J!1#F*0,J!2##T,J!#&!1:,*$!

%)7%!.#:!08R#.g!!!

35B A#M!M#:+<!.#:!<0'*80!X%)&*F*8SgY!A#M!72#:%!X,0+'`$7&0gY!!

33B "#!F*<0#!S710,!)0+-!.#:!%)&*F0!#&!$7&0!'#&!.#:&,0+'g!A#Mg!!

3dB A7F0!.#:!0F0&!:,0<!F*<0#!S710,!7,!7!'#&1!#'!0,$7-0g!9#:+<!.#:!<0,$&*20!'#&!

10!7!%*10!M)08!!.#:!<*<!%)*,g!!I)7%!S710!<*<!.#:!-+7.g!I).!<*<!.#:!$)##,0!

%)7%!S710g!I)7%!M0&0!!.#:!0,$7-*8S!'&#1g!L#g!"*<!*%!)0+-!.#:!0,$7-0g!I).!

#&!M).!8#%g!

3h6!

3fB A7F0!.#:!0F0&!-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!%#!&0+*0F0!,%&0,,g!9#:+<!.#:!<0,$&*20!'#&!

10!7!%*10!M)08!!.#:!<*<!%)*,g!!I)7%!S710!<*<!.#:!-+7.g!I).!<*<!.#:!$)##,0!

%)7%!S710g!I).!M0&0!.#:!,%&0,,0<!7%!%)0!%*10g!"*<!%)0!S710!)0+-!.#:!&0+*0F0!

,%&0,,g!!!

3a4!

;((E@"?e!=!

(;>L?9?(;@L!"E/9>?(L?P@/!

! I)7%!'#++#M,!7&0!2&*0'!87&&7%*F0!<0,$&*-%*#8,!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,!78<!*,!

*8%08<0<!%#!S*F0!%)0!&07<0&!1#&0!$#8%0W%!'#&!*8%0&-&0%*8S!%)0!*8<*F*<:7+!V:#%0,!78<!

2&#7<0&!-7%%0&8,!%)7%!?!787+.]0<!78<!<*,$:,,0<!*8!1.!<*,,0&%7%*#8B!!?8!#&<0&!%#!

-&0,0&F0!%)0!-#,,*2+0!*8%08%!#'!1.!-7&%*$*-78%,J!?!<0'7:+%0<!%#!:,*8S!%)0!%0&1,!%)0.!

:,0<!M)08!<0,$&*2*8S!)#M!%)0.!*<08%*'.!&7%)0&!%)78!,:2,%*%:%*8S!%)01!M*%)!#%)0&J!

1#&0!<*-+#17%*$!%0&1,![0BSB!178.!-7&%*$*-78%,!:,0<!%)0!%0&1!X'017+0Y!*8,%07<!#'!

XM#178Y\B!!!

! ;";!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!97:$7,*78J!'017+0J!78<!)0%0&#,0W:7+B!!=#%)!)0&!

1#%)0&!78<!'7%)0&!&0$0*F0<!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00,J!2:%!,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!8710!%)0*&!

'*0+<,B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!+#78!#''*$0&!'#&!78!7S&*$:+%:&0!$#1-78.!78<!)0&!

1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!278T!%0++0&B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!;<7!M7,!7!':++`%*10!,%:<08%!

M#&T*8S!%#!$#1-+0%0!)0&!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00B!!?8!7<<*%*#8J!,)0!7+,#!)7,!7!-7&%`%*10!

$71-:,!R#2!M#&T*8S!*8!)0&!$#++0S0U,!'*878$*7+!7*<!#''*$0B!!/)0!#8+.!-+7.,!F*<0#!S710,!

#$$7,*#87++.B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!<6F/3&P$3".&M3.(XJ!%)0!8$%%&.?&B6')!

,0&*0,J!78<!C/1.&<6F/32/3.B!

! ;K=E>L!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!S7.J!17+0J!97:$7,*78!#'!

j:020$#*,o(#&%:S:0,0!<0,$08%B!!A*,!'7%)0&!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!

'#&!%)0!-#,%!#''*$0J!M)*+0!)*,!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!'#&!7!

+7&S0!,:-0&17&T0%!$)7*8!'#&!fi!.07&,B!!;+20&%!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!

1787S0108%!78<!M#&T,!7,!78!7,,#$*7%0!<*&0$%#&!'#&!7!$#110&$*7+!2:,*80,,!

3a5!

*8%0++*S08$0!$#1-78.B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)0!)7<!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!

7--&#W*17%0+.!dc!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!$:&&08%+.!*8$+:<0!<'$3&03/7&

T#%"#/J!<'/%%$3"(J!78<!%)0!8"9"%":$'".#!,0&*0,B!

! ;K(AP@/E!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!97:$7,*78J!78<!

;10&*$78B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A*,!'7%)0&!S&7<:7%0<!'&#1!)*S)!

,$)##+!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!0*%)0&!)7<!7!%M#`!#&!'#:&`.07&!<0S&00!'&#1!7!:8*F0&,*%.![)0!

M7,!:8,:&0!M)*$)\B!!A*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7%!7!&0,%7:&78%!78<!)*,!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7%!7!

-&*8%*8S!-&0,,B!!;+-)#8,0J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!

*8!E8S+*,)B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!'*F0!.07&,!#+<J!

7--&#W*17%0+.B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!#-08`M#&+<!>(Q,!78<!

XC0%&#*<F78*7Y!,%.+0!-+7%'#&10&,![XC0%&#*<F78*7Y!*,!7!-#&%178%07:!%7T08!'&#1!%)0!

%M#!1#,%!-#-:+7&!S710,!*8!%)0!S08&0G!P/'3.">!78<!8$('%/9$#"$J&<)@F2.#)&.?&'2/&

Q"12'\B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!P/'3.">&!6(".#J!P.#('/3&L6#'/3&Y&Z%'"@$'/J!

78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!

! ;>KE@E&<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!-78,0W:7+!'017+0!#'!?&*,)!78<!/$#%%*,)!

<0,$08%B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!E7&+.!E<:$7%*#8!78<!M#&T0<!7,!78!

0+0108%7&.!,$)##+!%07$)0&J!7+%)#:S)!,)0!,%7.0<!7%!)#10!'#&!%)0!'*&,%!'#:&%008!.07&,!

#'!;&+080U,!+*'0B!!;&+080U,!'7%)0&!M08%!%#!7!%&7<0!,$)##+!78<!M#&T0<!7,!7!$#1-:%0&!

-&#S&7110&!'#&!N#)8,#8!s!N#)8,#8U,B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!$#1-+0%*8S!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!1:,*$7+!%)07%0&B!!/)0!)7,!-&0F*#:,+.!M#&T0<!7,!7!$7,)*0&!7%!7!

+7&S0!&0%7*+!$)7*8!78<!7!+7&S0!$)7*8!2##T,%#&0B!!I)*+0!)0&!'71*+.!)7,!-+7.0<!F*<0#!

S710,!7++!#'!)0&!+*'0J!,)0!#8+.!20S78!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!*8!%)0!h

!S&7<0!%#!*1-&0,,!

3a3!

7!2#.!,)0!+*T0<B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!$:&&08%+.!*8$+:<0!H.7[@.#&<6#J!<%)&8..F/3&

\J!H"%%$3(&.?&I'/3#"')J!78<!%)0!B3$1.#&-1/&78<!B"9"#"')&,0&*0,B!

! ;/AKED!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!M)*%0o97:$7,*78J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!78<!;10&*$78B!!

/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%!$*%.B!!A0&!-7&08%,!S&7<:7%0<!'&#1!)*S)!,$)##+!78<!#80!

M#&T0<!7,!7!278T0&J!M)*+0!%)0!#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!+*V:#&!,%#&0!1787S0&B!!;,)+0.!)7,!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!9)01*,%&.!78<!C7%)B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!

$)01*$7+!-&#$0,,!#-0&7%#&!7%!7!+7&S0!$#1-78.B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710!

,*8$0!,)0!M7,!d!#&!fJ!7--&#W*17%0+.B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!

,:&F*F7+!78<!,%&7%0S.!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!!$3&83)!,0&*0,J!

%)0!<'$383$?'&,0&*0,J!78<!G6#/(=$F/B!

! =E>DK!*<08%*'*0<!7,!M)*%0J!'017+0J!78<!2*,0W:7+J!2:%!-&*17&*+.!<0,$&*20<!

)0&,0+'!7,!78!*8%&#F0&%0<J!787+.%*$7+!-0&,#8!-&#80!%#!'*%,!#'!78W*0%.B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!

%)0!@0%)0&+78<,J!*8!78!7&07!%)7%!,%&7<<+0<!%)0!+*80!20%M008!&:&7+!78<!,:2:&2B!!/)0!

$:&&08%+.!+*F0,!M*%)!)0&!1#%)0&!78<!2&#%)0&!*8!%)0!@0%)0&+78<,![)0&!'7%)0&!+*F0,!

72#:%!%M08%.!1*+0,!7M7.!'&#1!%)01\B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!,#10!$#++0S0!

0<:$7%*#8!k!)0&!1#%)0&!,%:<*0<!":%$)!K78S:7S0!78<!K*%0&7%:&0!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!

,%:<*0<!;,%&#8#1.!78<!(0<7S#S.B!!@0*%)0&!'*8*,)0<!%)0*&!<0S&00J!%)#:S)J!78<!+0'%!

,$)##+!%#!'#:8<!7!,#'%M7&0!$#8,:+%*8S!'*&1!%)7%!'#$:,0,!#8!,%7%*,%*$,!78<!'7$*+*%7%*#8!

#'!,0&F*$0,B!!=0&.+!)7<!07&80<!)0&!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!R#:&87+*,1!%M#!.07&,!

-&0F*#:,+.!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!'&00+78$0!R#:&87+*,%!,-0$*7+*]*8S!*8!S71*8S!

$:+%:&0B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!'#:&B!!A0&!$:&&08%!'7F#&*%0!

S08&0,!7&0!,%07+%)!S710,J!>(Q,J!,)##%0&,J!78<!$*%.`2:*+<*8S!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!

3ad!

F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!C/1$=)&.?&]$"#J&<.6%&G/$9/3J!%)0!]#"12'(&.?&'2/&T%>&G/F6;%"=&

,0&*0,J!78<!B"(2.#.3/>B!

! =P@@?E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!78<!;10&*$78B!!/)0!S&0M!

:-!*8!7!^8*%0<!/%7%0,!,:2:&2B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!%M#`.07&!2:,*80,,!<0S&00,B!!

A0&!1#%)0&!#M80<!7!$+078*8S!$#1-78.!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7%!7!10<*$7+!,:--+.!

$#1-78.B!!=#88*0J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!(&0`C0<!78<!

/-78*,)B!!/)0!M7,!7+,#!78!01-+#.00!7%!7!108%7+!)07+%)!)#10B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!%M#!.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S710!,0&*0,!*,!8$%%&.?&B6')B!

! =>?LL;@D!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!78<!;10&*$78B!!/)0!

S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A0&!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00B!!/)0!

<0$+*80<!%#!,7.!)#M!1:$)!0<:$7%*#8!)0&!'7%)0&!&0$0*F0<J!#8+.!,%7%*8S!%)7%!)0!M7,!

M#&T*8S!7%!7!C$"#87+<U,!78<!S#*8S!%#!,$)##+!M)08!)0!10%!)0&!1#%)0&B!!L)0.!&78!7!

&0,%7:&78%!78<!7!<78$0!,%:<*#B!!=&*%%78.J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!

,%:<08%J!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!M7,!7+,#!01-+#.0<!

7,!7!&0,%7:&78%!1787S0&B!!/)0!)7,!8#%!-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!*8!%)0!

'#:&%)!S&7<0!78<!<#0,!8#%!)7F0!78.!%7,%0!-&0'0&08$0,B!

! 9;?LK?@!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!,17++!C*<M0,%0&8!

%#M8B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!)0&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!8#%0<!%)7%!

)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!,0+'`01-+#.0<!17,,7S0!%)0&7-*,%!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!M7,!7!,0+'`

01-+#.0<!<&.M7++!'*8*,)0&B!!/)0!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%J!2:%!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.!

)7<!8#%!<0$+7&0<!7!17R#&B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T,!-7&%`%*10!7,!7!=:*+<*8S!78<!EF08%!

C787S0&!7%!)0&!$71-:,!,%:<08%!$08%0&B!!/)0!<#0,!8#%!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,!#'%08J!

3af!

%.-*$7++.!+*1*%*8S!)0&,0+'!%#!1#2*+0!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!S6('&

B$#=/!,0&*0,J!A""&<F.3'(J!78<!%)0!P$3".&]$3'&,0&*0,B!!!

! 9;/ED!*<08%*'*0<!7,!7!S08<0&V:00&J!-78,0W:7+J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78J!T*8T.!-0&,#8!

+*F*8S!M*%)!108%7+!*++80,,B!!L)0.!S&0M!:-!*8!,:2:&278!@0M!A71-,)*&0B!!L)0.!

<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!%)0*&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27 $T S&#:8<!2:%!<*<!,7.!%)7%!%)0*&!

1#%)0&!M7,!78!>@!78<!%)0*&!'7%)0&!M7,!7!,#'%M7&0!08S*800&o1787S0&B!!L)0.!)7F0!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!08F*&#8108%7+!,$*08$0!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M#&T0<!7,!7!

+72#&7%#&.!2*#+#S*,%!78<!$)01*,%B!!L)0.!)7F0!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!%)0*&!

M)#+0!+*'0![3cz!.07&,\B!!L)0.!-+7.!X-&0%%.!1:$)!0F0&.%)*8SY!7,*<0!'&#1!'*S)%*8S!78<!

,-#&%,!S710,B!!L)0*&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!L$%.J!!"#$%&!$#'$()J!78<!M".(2.=7B!

! 9A>?/!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!78<!97:$7,*78B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!

P)*#!78<!M7,!&7*,0<!-&*17&*+.!2.!)*,!1#%)0&!k!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!80F0&!7&#:8<!1:$)B!!

A*,!1#%)0&!M7,!7!)*S)!,$)##+!S&7<:7%0!M)#!M#&T0<!*8!178:7+!78<!<#10,%*$!+72#&!

[7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!)#:,0T00-0&!7%!7!)#,-*%7+\B!!A0!<0$+*80<!%#!

<0,$&*20!)*,!'7%)0&U,!0<:$7%*#8!78<!#$$:-7%*#8B!!9)&*,!)7,!7!=7$)0+ #&U,!<0S&00!*8!

10<*$7+!%0$)8#+#S.!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M#&T0<!7,!%)0!,:-0&F*,#&!#'!7!

1*$&#2*#+#S.!+72!*8!7!)#,-*%7+B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!,*W!

.07&,!#+<B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,!78<!CCP,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!

S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&,0&*0,J!C/$16/&.?&C/1/#>(J!78<!<2$>.N(&.?&P.3>.3B!

! 9?@"D&<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!'017+0J!7,0W:7+!;10&*$78B!!/)0!M7,!2#&8!

*8!;+72717J!2:%!M08%!%#!$#++0S0!*8!L0880,,00!78<!+*F0<!*8!K#,!;8S0+0,!20'#&0!

&0%:&8*8S!%#!%)0!/#:%)!*8!3454B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7<!7!)*S)!,$)##+!0<:$7%*#8!78<!M#&T0<!

7,!7!)7*&<&0,,0&!78<!'7$%#&.!M#&T0&!20'#&0!20$#1*8S!7!$:,%#<*78!7%!7!+#$7+!)*S)!

3ac!

,$)##+B!!9*8<.!)7,!,#10!$#++0S0!0<:$7%*#8J!2:%!<*<!8#%!$#1-+0%0!)0&!<0S&00!<:0!%#!

,0F0&0!<0-&0,,*#8B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!%)0!0W0$:%*F0!7,,*,%78%!%#!7!

$#1-78.!9EPoPM80&B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!d4!

.07&,![X,*8$0!?!M7,!7!T*<Y\B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!N>(Q,![N7-780,0!>(Q,\J!

CCP,J!-:]]+0!S710,J!,)##%0&,J!%*10!1787S0108%!S710,J!7<F08%:&0!S710,J!78<!

,*1:+7%*#8,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!B/('"#)J!78<!A.3%>&

.?&A$3=3$?'B!!!!

! 9KD"E!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!35`.07&`#+<!M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%!178B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!

7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.!M*%)!)*,!1#%)0&J!7!,-0$*7+!0<:$7%*#8!%07$)0&J!78<!)*,!'7%)0&J!7!

-&#'0,,#&!7%!7!+#$7+!:8*F0&,*%.![)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!)*,!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!

27$TS&#:8<,\B!!9+.<0J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!

C#&%:7&.!/$*08$0B!!A0!7+,#!M#&T0<!7%!7!':80&7+!)#10!78<!*,!7!+*$08,0<!$7&-0%!

*8,%7++0&B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!c!#&!hJ!#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!5h!

.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!,)##%0&,!78<!X7&$7<0Y!,%.+0!

1:+%*-+7.0&!S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!8$%%&.?&B6')!,0&*0,J!G.=7/'&

C/$16/J!78<!%)0!<6F/3&<@$(2&M3.(X&,0&*0,B!

! ";_?"!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!17+0!;10&*$78!M)#!*,!6cx!)0%0&#,0W:7+!

78<!cx!S7.![*8!)*,!#M8!M#&<,J!)0!X%)*8T,!,#10!S:.,!7&0!F0&.!)78<,#10J!)08$0!

cxY\B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.B!!A*,!'7%)0&!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!78<!

)*,!1#%)0&!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00![)0!<0$+*80<!%#!108%*#8!%)0*&!'*0+<,!#'!,%:<.\B!!A*,!

'7%)0&!M7,!7!,#'%M7&0!-&#S&7110&!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!M7,!7!,$)##+!$#:8,0+#&B!!"7F*<J!

7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%J!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!

C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!f!#&!c!.07&,!#+<B!!

3ah!

A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!Z(/!S710,J!&#S:0`+*T0!S710,J!78<!7<F08%:&0!

S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!<6F/3&<@$(2&M3.(X&A""&ZJ!02/&M"#>"#1&.?&

+($$=J!0/$@&!.3'3/((&^J!78<!8$%%&.?&B6')J&P.>/3#&A$3?$3/&^B!

! "E==D!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!M)*%0J!78<!-78,0W:7+!M*%)!7,0W:7+!

%08<08$*0,![,)0!,7*<!%)*,!M*%)!7!V:0,%*#8!17&TJ!%)#:S)J!*8<*$7%*8S!:8$0&%7*8%.\B!!/)0!

S&0M!:-!*8!@0M!A71-,)*&0!M*%)!)0&!1#%)0&!78<!'7%)0&B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!*8<*$7%0!)0&!

-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!8#%0<!%)7%!)0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!*8!78!

:801-+#.108%!#''*$0!*8!C7,,7$):,0%%,!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!M7*%&0,,!7%!7!$)7*8!

&0,%7:&78%B!!"022.J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)7<!07&80<!7!=Z;!78<!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!

'&00+78$0!7&%*,%!78<!%07$)0&B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!'#:&!#&!

'*F0!78<!7<1*%,!%#!-+7.*8S!R:,%!72#:%!78.%)*8S!0W$0-%!'#&!,-#&%,!78<!&7$*8S!S710,B!!

A0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!'*S)%*8S!S710,J!Z(/!S710,J!>L/![X&07+!%*10!,%&7%0S.Y\!

S710,J!7<F08%:&0!S710,J!-+7%'#&10&,J!78<!*8<*0!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!

T7$@"J!!"#$%&!$#'$()J&83)('$%&823.#"=%/(J!78<!03$#("('.3B!

! EKE;@P>!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!N0M*,)!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!

@0M!E8S+78<!7&07!#'!%)0!^B/B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!M0&0!$#++0S0!0<:$7%0<![7+%)#:S)!

,)0!<*<!8#%!,-0$*'.!M)7%!%)0*&!'*0+<,!M0&0!#&!M)7%!<0S&00,!%)0.!$#1-+0%0<\!78<!

M#&T0<!7,!':++`%*10!)#,-*%7+!,%7''!M#&T0&,B!!E+078#&!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!

$#1-:%0&!,$*08$0!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!,#'%M7&0!,:--#&%!08S*800&B!!

/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!cB!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!S08&0,!

*8$+:<0!-:]]+0o7<F08%:&0!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&C/1/#>&.?&

_/%>$!,0&*0,![*8!-7&%*$:+7&J!C"#7`(&-N$7/#"#1\J!G2)'2@&L/$9/#J!78<!%)0!B3X&P$3".!

,0&*0,B!

3aa!

! EKCE>!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!

7!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A*,!-7&08%,!<*F#&$0<!M)08!)0!M7,!cB!!A*,!'7%)0&!7%%08<0<!

$#++0S0!2:%!<*<!8#%!$#1-+0%0!)*,!<0S&00!78<!)7,!M#&T0<!7,!7!$#&&0$%*#87+!#''*$0&!78<!

)7,!)7<!F7&*#:,!#%)0&!R#2,!*8!178:'7$%:&*8S!78<!&0%7*+B!!A*,!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!%M#`

.07&!8:&,*8S!<0S&00!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!$#1-+0%*8S!7!'#:&`.07&!<0S&00B!!/)0!

M#&T0<!7,!7!8:&,0B!!E+10&J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!

*8!2*#$)01*,%&.B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!a!#&!iB!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!

F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!,)##%0&,J!78<!,-#&%,!S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!8$%%&.?&B6')!,0&*0,J!%)0!!$%%.6'&,0&*0,J!78<!%)0!!+!-&,0&*0,B!!!

! EC?KD!<0,$&*20<!%)01,0+F0,!7,!S08<0&'+:*<J!;Z;=![X;,,*S80<!Z017+0!7%!

=*&%)Y\J!2*`&#178%*$J!<01*,0W:7+J!M)*%0J!78<!9787<*78B!!L)0.!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!,:2:&2,!

#'!9787<7B!!L)0*&!1#%)0&!)7<!7!$#++0S0!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!*8!%)0!;+])0*10&U,!:8*%!#'!

7!8:&,*8S!)#10B!!L)0*&!'7%)0&!)7<!7!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!'#&!%)0!

S#F0&8108%J!,-0$*'*$7++.!%)0!K*2&7&.!78<!;&$)*F0,!9787<7B!!L)0.!)7F0!,#10!$#++0S0!

0<:$7%*#8J!,%:<.*8S!78*17%*#8J!2:%!+0'%!20'#&0!'*8*,)*8S!%)0*&!<0S&00!<:0!%#!7!R#2!

#''0&B!!L)0.!$:&&08%+.!M#&T!*8!78!78*17%*#8!,%:<*#J!<#*8S!%0+0F*,*#8!M#&T!78<!

#:%,#:&$0<!M#&T!'#&!17R#&!,%:<*#,!+*T0!"*,80.!78<!I7&80&!=&#,B!!L)0.!)7F0!2008!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!5664B!!L)0.!-+7.!>(Q,!1#,%+.!78<!%)0*&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710,!*8$+:<0!<6F/3&P$3".&GHKJ&C/1/#>&.?&'2/&</9/#&<'$3(J!823.#.&03"11/3J!78<!<'$3&

A$3(J&]#"12'(&.?&'2/&T%>&G/F6;%"=B!

! E>@E/L!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!$*,`17+0J!M)*%0!;10&*$78!#'!

E8S+*,)o?&*,)!X0W%&7$%*#8BY!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!C7,,7$):,0%%,!*8!M)7%!)0!<0,$&*20<!7,!7!

X,%72+0!1*<<+0`$+7,,!)#10Y![M)*$)!)0!<0'*80<!7,!8#!<*F#&$0!#&!,0-7&7%*#8!20%M008!

3ai!

)*,!-7&08%,\B!!A*,!'7%)0&!)7,!,#10!$#++0S0!0<:$7%*#8!2:%!<*<!8#%!$#1-+0%0!7!<0S&00!

78<!M#&T0<!*8!7!1787S0&*7+!-#,*%*#8!*8!%)0!$#8,%&:$%*#8!*8<:,%&.B!!A*,!1#%)0&!)7,!

$#1-+0%0<!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!*8!0<:$7%*#8!78<!*,!7!,-0$*7+!0<:$7%*#8!%07$)0&J!

-&*17&*+.!*8!1*<<+0!,$)##+B!!E&80,%!)7,!07&80<!7!()B"B!*8!%)0!'*0+<!#'!1:+%*`

<*,$*-+*87&.!,$*08$0o08S*800&*8SB!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!,08*#&!

V:78%*%7%*F0!787+.,%!'#&!7!-&#1*808%!f45[T\o1:%:7+!':8<!$#1-78.B!!A0!)7,!2008!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7%!+07,%!3c!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!CCP,J!fe!

S710,![7!,%&7%0S.!,:2`S08&0!M)0&0!-+7.0&,!$#8%&#+!78!01-*&0!78<!X0e-+#&0J!0e-78<J!

0e-+#*%J!78<!0e%0&1*87%0Y\J!&0,#:&$0!S7%)0&*8S!S710,J!78<!S710,!M*%)!+7&S0!

:8'#+<*8S!87&&7%*F0,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!<'/%%$3"(J!P"#/=3$?'J!78<!%)0!

-(($(("#`(&83//>!,0&*0,B!

! ZKP>E@9E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!M)*%0!78<!@7%*F0!;10&*$78J!78<!

;10&*$78B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!78!*8<:,%&*7+!,#:%)0&8!%#M8B!!A0&!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!)*S)!

,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M7,!7!,0$&0%7&.!M)*+0!)0&!'7%)0&!$#1-+0%0<!,#10!)*S)!,$)##+J!2:%!

<*<!8#%!07&8!7!<0S&00J!78<!M#&T0<!*8!$#8,%&:$%*#8B!!Z+#&08$0!)0&,0+'!07&80<!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!8:&,*8S!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!':++`%*10!8:&,0B!!

/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!53!.07&,J!2:%!)7,!8#%!2008!-+7.*8S!%)01!

$#8,*,%08%+.B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!)0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!78<!F*<0#!S710,B!

! Z>E""?E!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!A0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!07&80<!'#:&`.07&!<0S&00,J!#80!*8!,#$*7+!

M#&T!78<!%)0!#%)0&!*8!$#1-:%0&!787+.,*,B!!P80!-7&08%!M#&T0<!-7&%`%*10!7,!7!

$#:8,0+#&!'#&!$)*+<&08!78<!7<:+%,!M*%)!,-0$*7+!800<,!M)*+0!%)0!#%)0&!-7&08%!M#&T0<!

':++`%*10!*8!F7&*#:,!%0$)o<7%7!08%&.!R#2,B!!Z&0<<*0!M7,J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!7!':++`%*10!

3a6!

$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!/-#&%,!C787S0108%B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!

'#&!7,!+#8S!7,!)0!$78!&010120&B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0!*,!,-#&%,J!2:%!)0!M*++!

-+7.!8#8`,-#&%,!S710,!*'!%)0.!7&0!*8$&0<*2+.!-#-:+7&![)0!$*%0<!%)0!B/('"#)!,0&*0,!78<!

%)0!8$%%&.?&B6')!,0&*0,!7,!0W71-+0,\B!

! Q;>D!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!A*,-78*$J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!A0!S&0M!:-!

*8!%)0!C*<M0,%0&8!^8*%0<!/%7%0,B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!7%%08<0<!$#++0S0J!2:%!#8+.!#80!

$#1-+0%0<!7!<0S&00B!!L)0.!M#&T0<!'#&!7!,$)##+!<*,%&*$%!7,!7!$##&<*87%#&!78<!

*8%0&-&0%0&J!&0,-0$%*F0+.B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!Q7&.!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!

17R#&*8S!*8!2*#+#S.B!!A0!7+,#!M#&T0<!7,!7!,7+0,!'+##&!M#&T0&!7%!L7&S0%B!!A0!)7,!2008!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!cB!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!7$%*#8J!

7<F08%:&0J!>(Q,J!Z(/,J!,%&7%0S.J!78<!)#&&#&B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!

B/('"#)J!%)0!L$%.!,0&*0,J!78<!%)0!-(($(("#`(&83//>&,0&*0,B!

! QE>L!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!$*,`S08<0&0<!M#178B!!/)0!7+,#!

8#%0<!%)7%!,)0!*,!-7&%*7++.!0%)8*$7++.![8#%!&0+*S*#:,+.\!N0M*,)!78<!7+,#!)7,!=+7$T!

'71*+.!10120&,J!+07F*8S!)0&!'00+*8S!7+*087%0<!'&#1!M)*%0!$:+%:&0B!!Q0&%!S&0M!:-!*8!7!

M#&T*8S!$+7,,!%#M8!*8!7!,#:%)0&8!,%7%0B!!A0&!'7%)0&!)7<!,#10!)*S)0&!0<:$7%*#8!78<!

M#&T0<!7%!7!2+:0!$#++7&!R#2![Q0&%!<0$+*80<!%#!20!1#&0!,-0$*'*$\B!!A0&!1#%)0&!7+,#!)7<!

,#10!)*S)0&!0<:$7%*#8![1#&0!%)78!)0&!'7%)0&\J!78<!M7,!7!,%7.`7%`)#10!1#1B!!Q0&%!

)0&,0+'!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!-:2+*$!-#+*$.J!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!*8!

0<:$7%*#8J!78<!)7,!7+,#!7%%08<0<!,#10!+7M!,$)##+B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!Q0&%!M7,!

M#&T*8S!*8!%)0!-:2+*$!-#+*$.!,0$%#&![*8*%*7++.!8#8`-&#'*%!2:%!&0$08%+.!1#F0<!%#!

S#F0&8108%\!#8!7!&78S0!#'!*,,:0,!&0+7%0<!%#!$)*+<&08!78<!'71*+*0,B!!/)0!)7,!2008!

3i4!

-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!%)0!+7%0`56a4,B!!/)0!-+7.,!7!<*F0&,0!&78S0!#'!F*<0#!S710!

S08&0,J!2:%!)0&!X+*'0%*10!'7F#&*%0!S710Y!*,!P$((&I??/='&^B!

! QP>"P@!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!78<!;10&*$78B!!A0!S&0M!

:-!*8!@0M!D#&T!9*%.B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!)7<!-#,%`S&7<:7%0!0<:$7%*#8,!k!#80!#'!)*,!

-7&08%,!M#&T0<!7,!7!R#:&87+*,%!M)*+0!%)0!#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!+7M.0&B!!Q#&<#8!07&80<!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!0F#+:%*#87&.!2*#+#S.B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)0!M7,!:801-+#.0<J!2:%!

)7,!M#&T0<!-&*17&*+.!7,!7!M&*%0&!78<!0<*%#&B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!

7--&#W*17%0+.!5i!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!'*&,%`-0&,#8!-0&,-0$%*F0!S710,J!

0,-0$*7++.!,)##%0&,J!)#&&#&!S710,J!78<!XM7+T*8S!,*1:+7%#&,JY!7!&0+7%*F0+.!80M!S08&0!

*8!F*<0#!S710,!%)7%!'#$:,0,!#8!08F*&#8108%7+!,%#&.%0++*8S!2.!)7F*8S!-+7.0&,!0W-+#&0!

7!<0,*S80<!,-7$0!78<!:,0!*8'#&17%*#8!'&#1!%)7%!,-7$0!%#!$#8,%&:$%!7!87&&7%*F0B!!L)0!

1#,%!'71#:,!0W71-+0!#'!%)*,!S08&0!*,!K.#/&L.@/B!Q#&<#8U,!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!

<.@$J!<0-C]IGJ!78<!H$'2.%.1"=B!

! QP@Q!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!,%&7*S)%J!;,*78J!9)*80,0!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!

9)*87B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!$#1-+0%0<!:8<0&S&7<:7%0!$#:&,0,!7%!7!-&#'0,,*#87+!

7&$)*%0$%:&0!$#++0S0!78<!M#&T0<!7,!7&$)*%0$%:&0!08S*800&,B!!Q#8S!M7,J!7,!#'!1.!

,:&F0.J!7!':++`%*10!,%:<08%!7%!7!C*<M0,%0&8!;10&*$78!$#++0S0!17R#&*8S!*8!

9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!108%*#8!)#M!+#8S!,)0!)7,!

2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&J!2:%!'&#1!%)0!$#8%0W%!#'!,#10!#'!)0&!78,M0&,!?!$78!

7,,:10!,)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!7!$)*+<B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!7<F08%:&0J!-:]]+0J!78<!0,$7-0!S710,B!

! Q>EL9AE@!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!1*W0<`&7$0![-7&%`E:&#-078!

78$0,%&.J!-7&%`@7%*F0!;10&*$78!78$0,%&.J!,-0$*'*$7++.!%)0!K7T#%7o"7T#%7!%&*20\!

3i5!

M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!

E<:$7%*#8!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!7%%08<0<!$#++0S0J!2:%!<0$+*80<!%#!$#1-+0%0!)*,!<0S&00B!!A0&!

1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!78!?L!$##&<*87%*8S!1787S0&!'#&!7!17R#&!7*&+*80!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!

M#&T0<!7,!7!<&*F0&!'#&!7!+*1#:,*80o%#M8!$7&!$#1-78.B!!Q&0%$)08J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!

M7,!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!

7+,#!M#&T0<!-7&%`%*10!7,!7!,%:<08%!1787S0&!7%!7!$71-:,!$7'{!78<!7!,0&F0&!7%!7!

$#:8%&.!$+:2B!!/)0!0,%*17%0,!%)7%!,)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!5a`56!.07&,B!!

A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!P$3".&]$3'J&B.6;%/&B$(2J!P$3".&H$3')&YJ!78<!02/&

<6"'/&C"?/&.?&_$=7&$#>&8.>)J&0"F'.#&03.6;%/B!!!

! AEKE@E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!$*,`S08<0&0<!M)*%0!M#178J!N0M*,)J!7,0W:7+J!

78<!2*&#178%*$!XM*%)!7!+078!%#M7&<,!M#108BY!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!/#:%)0&8!^8*%0<!

/%7%0,B!!A0&!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!M)*%0!$#++7&!R#2,!

[A0+080!<0$+*80<!%#!20!1#&0!,-0$*'*$\B!!/)0!<*<!8#%!<0,$&*20!)0&!'7%)0&U,!#$$:-7%*#8!

#&!0<:$7%*#8!,*8$0!)0&!-7&08%,!<*F#&$0<!M)08!,)0!M7,!%)&00!78<!A0+080!+*F0<!M*%)!

)0&!1#%)0&B!!A0+080!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!(,.$)#+#S.!78<!K*8S:*,%*$,J!7!

C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!*8!Z#+T+#&0J!78<!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.!M7,!;="![X7++`2:%`<*,,0&%7%*#8Y\!*8!

7!()B"B!*8!9#1-7&7%*F0!K*%0&7%:&0J!7+%)#:S)!,)0!7<1*%%0<!%)7%!,)0!M#:+<!-&#272+.!

8#%!$#1-+0%0!%)7%!<0S&00B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!1787S0&!7%!7!%0$)!

,:--#&%!$#1-78.B!!A0+080!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!d4!

.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0!*,!%)0!>(QB!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!

%)0!K$;3"/%&]#"12'!,0&*0,J!%)0!H.3'$%!,0&*0,J!78<!78.%)*8S!&0+7%0<!%#!%)0!<'$3&A$3(&

'&78$)*,0B!

3i3!

! ?KE@E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!<*,72+0<J!M)*%0J!9787<*78!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!,17++!&:&7+!$#11:8*%.B!!A0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!7%%08<0<!,#10!$#++0S0J!2:%!,)0!

<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!%)0*&!7&07,!#'!,%:<.!#&!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!%)0.!$#1-+0%0<!%)0*&!

<0S&00,B!!A0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!78!0<:$7%*#87+!7,,*,%78%!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!7,!7!

$7&-08%0&B!!?+080J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!#8!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!9)*+<!78<!

D#:%)!,%:<*0,B!!/)0!M7,J!7%!%)0!%*10J!:801-+#.0<!<:0!%#!)0&!<*,72*+*%.!k!,)0!M7,!

2#&8!M*%)!7!$#880$%*F0!%*,,:0!<*,07,0!%)7%!&0,:+%0<!*8!'&0V:08%!<*,+#$7%*#8,!78<!

80&F#:,!,.,%01!'7*+:&0J!71#8S!#%)0&!%)*8S,B!!A#M0F0&J!7'%0&!34!.07&,!,)0!*,!'*87++.!

&0$0*F*8S!10<*$7+!%&07%108%!78<!*,!%7T*8S!<*,%78$0!$#++0S0!$#:&,0,!M)*+0!&0$#F0&*8SB!!

/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!7++!#'!)0&!+*'0J!:,*8S!%)01!7,!7!'#&1!#'!-7*8!

1787S0108%B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!X0F0&.!T*8<!*17S*872+0BY!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&A"'=2/3&^!78<!\!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!

! ?>C;!<0,$&*20<!%)01,0+F0,!*8!$#1-+*$7%0<!M7.,B!!L)0.!<0'*80<!%)0*&!S08<0&!

7,!X-#+*%*$,JY!1078*8S!*%,!0W-&0,,*#8!M7,!<0-08<08%!#8!%)0*&!-#+*%*$7+!F*0M,!*8!7!

-7&%*$:+7&!$#8%0W%B!!L)0.!':&%)0&!<0,$&*20<!%)01,0+F0,!7,!V:00&J!N0M*,)J!78<!M)*%0B!!

?&17!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!(7$*'*$!@#&%)M0,%B!!L)0.!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!%)0*&!-7&08%,U!

0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!,%7%0<!%)7%!%)0*&!1#%)0&!M7,!78!7$$#:8%78%!78<!%)0*&!

<7<!M7,!7!+*2&7&*78B!!?&17!)7,!07&80<!7!()B"B!*8!=*#+#S.!78<!M7,J!7%!%)0!%*10!#'!1.!

,:&F0.J!78!7,,*,%78%!-&#'0,,#&!*8!=*#+#S.B!!L)0.!)7F0!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!X'#&!

7,!+#8S!7,!u%)0.v!$78!&010120&BY!!L)0*&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!B3$1.#&-1/&

,0&*0,J!%)0!8"9"%":$'".#!,0&*0,J!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!!!

! ?/;;9!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!$*,S08<0&0<J!1#,%+.!)0%0&#,0W:7+![*8!%)0!-7,%!)0!

)7,!2008!7%%&7$%0<!%#!%&78,S08<0&!108!78<!M#108!7,!M0++!7,!8#8`

3id!

2*87&.oS08<0&V:00&!-0#-+0!*8!7<<*%*#8!%#!$*,S08<0&0<!M#108\J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78!

178B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!-&*17&*+.!1*<<+0`$+7,,!@0M!N0&,0.!,:2:&2B!!A*,!-7&08%,!2#%)!

)7F0!-#,%`S&7<:7%0!<0S&00,!k!)*,!1#%)0&!)7,!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!*8!K*2&7&.!/$*08$0!

78<!)*,!'7%)0&!)7,!7!()B"B!*8!-)*+#,#-).B!!A*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!+*2&7&*78!20'#&0!

20$#1*8S!7!':++`%*10!,%7.!7%!)#10!1#%)0&!M)*+0!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!7!-&#'0,,#&!7%!7!+#$7+!

,%7%0!:8*F0&,*%.B!!?,77$!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!2:,*80,,!7<1*8*,%&7%*#8!

78<!*,!$:&&08%+.!M#&T*8S!'#&!7!,%7%0!S#F0&8108%!7,!7!,.,%01,!787+.,%!78<!)0+-!<0,T!

%0$)8*$*78B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!56i6!M)08!)*,!'71*+.!-:&$)7,0<!

7!@*8%08<#!E8%0&%7*8108%!/.,%01![@E/\!$#8,#+0B!!A*,!$:&&08%!'7F#&*%0!S710,!7&0!

<2.9/%&]#"12'J!P"12')&Q.X&aJ!78<!<$"#'(&G.N&+,J!2:%!)*,!X7++`%*10Y!'7F#&*%0,!7&0!P/1$&

P$#&+++J!02/&</=3/'&.?&P$#$J!78<!<6F/3&P/'3.">B!

! N;@?9E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!2*#+#S*$7++.!'017+0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!

M)*%0o97:$7,*78J!78<!;10&*$78B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!&:&7+!C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!A0&!

'7%)0&!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!M)*+0!)0&!1#%)0&!)7,!&0$0*F0<!,#10!

,-0$*7+*]0<!F#$7%*#87+!%&7*8*8S!20.#8<!)*S)!,$)##+B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!'#&!%)0!

S#F0&8108%!7,!7!<7*&.!*8,-0$%#&!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!'&00+78$0!$#:&%!

&0-#&%0&B!!N78*$0J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!E8S+*,)!

78<!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!

7--&#W*17%0+.!5h!.07&,B!!/)0!<#0,!8#%!)7F0!78.!-7&%*$:+7&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!

S08&0,J!7+%)#:S)!,)0!S080&7++.!-&0'0&,!1:+%*`-+7.0&J!-7&%.`#&*08%0<!S710,B!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!0/'3"(&!3"/#>(J!H.7[@.#&K.J!78<!<'$3>/N&,$%%/)B!

! NE//?9;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!1#,%+.`)0%0&#,0W:7+J!97:$7,*78!=:+S7&*78!

M#178!M)#!)7,!+*F0<!*8!%)0!^8*%0<!/%7%0,!'#&!%)0!-7,%!5f!.07&,B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!% )0!

3if!

$7-*%#+!#'!=:+S7&*7J!/#'*7B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!07&80<!<0S&00,!'&#1!7!

%0$)8*$7+o-&#'0,,*#87+!)*S)!,$)##+B!!A0&!-7&08%,!M#&T0<!*8!$#8,%&:$%*#8!['7%)0&\!78<!

78!7&$)*%0$%:&0!'*&1![1#%)0&\!20'#&0!,%7&%*8S!%)0*&!#M8!)#:,0)#+<!7--+*78$0!&0-7*&!

2:,*80,,B!!N0,,*$7!)7,!07&80<!7!()B"B!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!

M#&T*8S!7,!7!-&#'0,,#&!7%!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$#++0S0B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!

,*8$0!1*<<+0!,$)##+J!7+%)#:S)!8#%!F0&.!$#8,*,%08%+.B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!

)*<<08!#2R0$%!78<!-:]]+0!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!B"$;%.&+++!78<!

78.!)*<<08!#2R0$%!S710,!#8!)0&!,17&%-)#80!78<!%72+0%B!

! NPD9E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!$*,S08<0&J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!80:&#<*F0&S08%J!

97:$7,*78!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!1*<<+0`$+7,,!,:2:&2B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!

%#!<0,$&*20!)0&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!8#%0<!%)7%!2#%)!M0&0!+7M.0&,B!!

N#.$0!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!;&$)70#+#S.!78<!%)0!;8$*08%!I#&+<!'&#1!78!?F.!

K07S:0!:8*F0&,*%.!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!*8!j:7+*%.!;,,:&78$0!*8!%)0!

F*<0#!S710!*8<:,%&.B!!/)0!0,%*17%0,!,)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!5i!.07&,B!!

A0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!)*<<08!#2R0$%!S710,J!78<!,%#&.`<&*F08!-:]]+0!

S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!]"#1>.@&L/$3'(!,0&*0,J!%)0!L$39/('&P..#&

,0&*0,J!78<!I#"1@$'"(&bB!

! N^@?P>!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!78!;,*78J!2*,0W:7+!17+0!'&#1!N7-78B!!A0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!,17++!$*%.!*8!N7-78!M*%)!)*,!S&78<-7&08%,!M)*+0!)*,!-7&08%,!,%7.0<!M*%)!)*,!%M#!

2&#%)0&,J!M)#!M0&0!&0$0*F*8S!+#8S`%0&1!)#,-*%7+!%&07%108%!'#&!+:8S!$78$0&B!!A*,!

'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!,.,%01,!08S*800&!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!*8!7!27T0&.B!!@0*%)0&!

7%%08<0<!$#++0S0J!2:%!&0$0*F0<!<0S&00,!'&#1!F#$7%*#87+!,$)##+,B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!

N:8*#&!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!*8!%)0!^8*%0<!/%7%0,J!17R#&*8S!*8!

3ic!

9#11:8*$7%*#8B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!56!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710,!*8$+:<0!P.'2/3&^!78<!\!78<!02/&C$('&.?&Z(B!

! O;>ED!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!+#M0&!*8$#10!'71*+.!*8!%)0!C*<M0,%!^B/B!!A0&!-7&08%,!<*F#&$0<!M)08!,)0!M7,!

F0&.!.#:8S!78<!,)0!)7,!8#%!,%7.0<!*8!%#:$)!M*%)!)0&!2*&%)!1#%)0&!#&!)0&!2*&%)!

1#%)0&U,!,*<0!#'!%)0!'71*+.B!!A0&!'7%)0&!78<!,%0-`1#%)0&!2#%)!S&7<:7%0<!'&#1!

$#++0S0J!7+%)#:S)!O7&0.!<0$+*80<!%#!108%*#8!%)0*&!'*0+<,!#'!,%:<.B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!

7,!7!)#,-*%7+!$#1-:%0&!%0$)8*$*78!78<!)0&!,%0-`1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!&0$0-%*#8*,%!7%!7!

+7M!'*&1B!!O7&0.J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!

C787S0108%B!!/)0!7+,#!M7,!M#&T*8S!*8!7!&0%7*+!R#2!7%!7!+#$7+!%)&*'%!,%#&0B!!/)0!)7,!

2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!X#+<!08#:S)!%#!,*%!,%*++!'#&!1#&0!%)78!c!

,0$#8<,BY!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!Z(/,J!78<!,8#M2#7&<*8S!

S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!M".(2.=7J!C/?'&Y&B/$>J!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&

,J&<7)3"@X!

! O;LA>D@!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!)0%0&#,0W:7+!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!,17++!

C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!A0&!'7%)0&!7%%08<0<!7!%0$)8*$7+!$#++0S0![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,%7%0!

M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!)0!$#1-+0%0<!7!<0S&00\!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!07&80<!78!7,,#$*7%0U,!

<0S&00B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!17*+!$7&&*0&!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!,0$&0%7&.B!!

O7%)&.8J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!A:178!

/0&F*$0,B!!/)0!0,%*17%0<!%)7%!,)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!54!

.07&,!#+<J!2:%!#8+.!-+7.,!%)01!#8$0!*8!7!M)*+0B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!

*8$+:<0!<&*F*8S!S710,J!,-#&%,!S710,J!1:,*$!S710,J!78<!'*S)%*8S!S710,!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!

F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!P$3".&]$3'!,0&*0,J!BS&L/3.&^J!78<!02/&B"9"(".#B!

3ih!

! O;L?;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!2*,0W:7+J!M)*%0!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!

'7&1*8S!%#M8!*8!%)0!@#&%)07,%0&8!^B/B!!A0&!'7%)0&!07&80<!7!QE"!%)&#:S)!%)0!1*+*%7&.!

78<!)0&!1#%)0&!7%%08<0<!$#++0S0!2:%!<*<!8#%!$#1-+0%0!7!<0S&00B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!

*8!7!-+7%0!R#2!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!F7&*#:,!#''*$0!R#2,B!!O7%*7!$#1-+0%0<!%)&00!

.07&,!#'!$#++0S0J!17R#&*8S!*8!9#1-:%0&!/$*08$0J!20'#&0!+07F*8S!%#!M#&T!':++`%*10B!!;,!

#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!-08,*#8!2080'*%,!787+.,%B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!%)0!a4,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!7&0!CCP,!78<!7<F08%:&0!S710,B!!

A0&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'!78<!%)0!C/1.(!,0&*0,B!

! O?>O!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!$*,S08<0&0<!;10&*$78!178B!!

A0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$+#,0!M)0&0!)0!S&0M!:-!#&!)*,!-7 &08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!

2:%!<*<!,%7%0!%)7%!)*,!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!*8!%)0!70&#,-7$0!*8<:,%&.!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!M7,!7!

,%7.`7%`)#10!1#1B!!O*&T!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!$#1-:%0&!,#'%M7&0!78<J!

7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!,#'%M7&0!<0F0+#-0&B!!A0!0,%*17%0<!%)7%!)0!)7,!

2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!'#:&!#&!'*F0!.07&,!#+<B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!CCP>(Q,J!,*1:+7%*#8!S710,J!7$%*#8!S710,J!78<!,-#&%,!S710,B!!

A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!K6"%>&A$3(&^J!QLC&bcJ!78<!AAI&^]bcB!!!

! O?qqD!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!^T&7*8*78!'017+0B!!/)0!1#F0<!%#!%)0!

^8*%0<!/%7%0,!M)08!,)0!M7,!d![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,-0$*'.!M)*$)!-7&%!#'!%)0!$#:8%&.\B!!

A0&!-7&08%,!M08%!%#!$#++0S0!78<!17R#&0<!*8!$#1-:%0&!,$*08$0!78<!<08%7+!7,,*,%78$0B!!

/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!M)0%)0&!#&!8#%!)0&!-7&08%,!$#1-+0%0<!78.!<0S&00,!#&!M)7%!

%)0*&!#$$:-7%*#8,!M0&0B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!O*]].!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!

17R#&*8S!*8!=*#+#S.B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T0<!7%!7!+*2&7&.B!!L)0!'*&,%!F*<0#!S710!,)0!

&010120&,!-+7.*8S!M7,!S$E&$#>&B$E'/3J!&0+07,0<!#8!%)0!(+7.,%7%*#8!3!*8!"0$0120&J!

3ia!

3445B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0!*,!%)0!>(QB!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!

%)0!]"#1>.@&L/$3'(&,0&*0,J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*W^J!78<!C/$16/&.?&C/1/#>(B!

! KE/K?E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!2*,0W:7+J!$*,S 08 <0&0<J!M)*%0!(:0&%#!>*$78!

M#178B!!/)0!*,!%)0!,*,%0&!#'!@7<*80B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!@#&%)0&8!Z+#&*<7J!*8!M)7%!,)0!

<0,$&*20,!7,!7!X,-+*%!)#:,0)#+<Y!k!)0&!-7&08%,!<*F#&$0<!M)08!,)0!M7,!7!$)*+<!78<!

2#%)!17&&*0<!#%)0&!-0#-+0B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!7&0!$#++0S0`0<:$7%0<!k!)0&!'7%)0&!

)7,!07&80<!7!NB"B!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!)7,!07&80<!<0S&00,!*8!,-0$*7+!0<:$7%*#8!78<!

'#&0*S8!+78S:7S0!0<:$7%*#8B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M7,!7!+7M.0&!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!)*S)!

,$)##+!/-78*,)!%07$)0&![K0,+*0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!M)7%!)0&! ,% 0-`-7&08%,U!

#$$:-7%*#8,!78<!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<,!M0&0\B!!K0,+*0!)7,!07&80<!7!()B"B!*8!

E8S+*,)!K*%0&7%:&0!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!*8!7!%07$)*8S!-#,%<#$!7%!7!

-&*F7%0!:8*F0&,*%.B!!I)*+0!K0,+*0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!7!,17++!

$)*+<J!,)0!)7,!#8+.!2008!$#8,*,%08%+.!-+7.*8S!%)01!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!7!<0$7<0B!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!S08&0!*,!%)0!>(Q!78<!)0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!%)0!B3$1.#&-1/&,0&*0,J!

%)0!P$((&I??/='!,0&*0,J!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!

! K^LAE>!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!,%&7*S)%J!;,*78J!78<!Z*88*,)B!!A0!<0$+*80<!

%#!<*,$:,,!)*,!$)*+<)##<!#&!'71*+.!27$TS&#:8<B!!A0!)7,!$#1-+0%0<!)*S)!,$)##+!78<J!

7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7%%08<*8S!7!F#$7%*#87+!,$)##+B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!'#&!6!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!CCP,J!N>(Q,J!78<!7$%*#8!

S710,B!

! C;>NP>D!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!;,*78J!9)*80,0J!2*,0W:7+J!78<!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!

:-!*8!7!+7&S0!$*%.!*8!9)*87B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$:,,!)0&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!

27$TS&#:8<!#&!M#&T!)*,%#&.B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!7%!

3ii!

7!C*<M0,%0&8!$#++0S0!17R#&*8S!*8!(,.$)#+#S.!78<!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!

>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!<*<!8#%!&010120&!M)08!,)0!'*&,%!20S78!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,B!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!+*'0!,*1:+7%#&,!78<!7<F08%:&0!S710,B!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!H%$16/&+#=XJ!02/&!6'63/&A$3J!78<!02/&<"@(!,0&*0,B!

! C;>@?E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!97:$7,*78!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A0&!'7%)0&!)7,!7%%08<0<!,#10!$#++0S0!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!)7,!

07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!%7T*8S!-#,%`S&7<:7%0!#8+*80!

$+7,,0,B!!A0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!2:&8!8:&,0!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!'#&!%)0!

S#F0&8108%!<#*8S!&#7<!M#&T!7,!M0++!7,!)7,!7!,*<0!2:,*80,,![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,-0$*'.!

':&%)0&\B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!C7&8*0!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!A07+%)!

s!I0++80,,B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T0<!7%!7!S&#:-!)#10!'#&!S*&+,!M*%)!108%7+!-&#2+01,B!!/)0!

)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!#8`78<`#''!'#&!5d!.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!

*8$+:<0!02/&<"@(!,0&*0,J!%)0!P$3".&H$3')!,0&*0,J!78<!%)0!P.#7/)&M$%%!,0&*0,B!

! C;>L?!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!$*,`S08<0&J!2*,0W:7+J!)0%0&#&#178%*$J!'*&,%!

S080&7%*#8!K7#!;,*78`;10&*$78!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.B!!=#%)!#'!

)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00,B!!L)0.!<*F#&$0<!M)08!,)0!M7,!*8!%)0!'*'%)!

S&7<0!78<!C7&%*!+*F0<!M*%)!)0&!1#%)0&B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!)7<!F7&*#:,!R#2,!#F0&!%)0!

.07&,J!%)0!+#8S0,%!20*8S!7%!7!10<*$7+!$#1-78.!17T*8S!10<*$7+!<0F*$0,B!!":0!%#!)0&!

$#++0S0!'*878$*7+!&0V:*&0108%,J!C7&%*!T8#M,!)0&!1#%)0&!17T0,!|3iJ444!-0&!.07&B!!;,!

#'!1.!,:&F0.J!C7&%*!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!

C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!7+,#!)7<!%M#!-7&%`%*10!R#2,G!#80!*8!)0&!$#++0S0U,!,%:<08%!

$08%0&!%0$)!$&0M!78<!78#%)0&!7,!78!#''*$0!7,,*%78%!*8!)0&!$#++0S0U,!EV:*%.J!"*F0&,*%.J!

78<!?8%0&$:+%:&7+!(&#S&71,!#''*$0B!!L)0!07&+*0,%!S710!,)0!&010120&,!-+7.*8S!*,!!"#$%&

3i6!

!$#'$()&,+++J!&0+07,0<!*8!5666B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!

X2:*+<*8S`M#&+<Y!%.-0!S710,J!78<!F*,:7+!8#F0+,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!

%)0!P$((&I??/='&%&*+#S.J!G.%%/3&8.$('/3&0)=..#J!H%$#/'&8.$('/3J!L/$9)&G$"#J!C"?/&"(&

<'3$#1/J!02/&A$%7"#1&B/$>&,0&*0,J!78<!Z#'"%&B$N#B!!!

! C;>DELL;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!$*,`S08<0&0<J!M)*%0J!2*,0W:7+!'017+0B!!/)0!

S&0M!:-!*8!7!1*<<+0`$+7,,!C*<M0,%0&8!80*S)2#&)##<B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!

<0S&00!*8!E8S+*,)!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!)7,!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!*8!=:,*80,,B!!/)0!<*<!8#%!

<*,$:,,!)0&!-7&08%,U!#$$:-7%*#8,!*8!<0%7*+J!#8+.!,%7%*8S!%)7%!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!

178.!<*''0&08%!R#2,!%)&#:S)#:%!)0&!$)*+<)##<!M)*+0!)0&!'7%)0&!M7,!#:%!#'!M#&TB!!

C7&.0%%7J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!Q+#27+!

=:,*80,,B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!1#,%!#'!)0&!+*'0B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!P$3".&]$3'&,0&*0,J!%)0!<6F/3&<@$(2&M3.(X!,0&*0,J!78<!H$F/3&P$3".J&

02/&02.6($#>&d/$3&B..3B!

! C;LA?K"E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!97:$7,*78!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!

%)0!C*<M0,%0&8!^B/B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!$#++0S0!0<:$7%*#8,![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!

,-0$*'.!':&%)0&\B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!%)0!)07<!#'!7 ! $#:8,0+*8S!2:,*80,,!78<!)0&!

1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!78!#-%)71#+#S*,%U,!7,,*,%78%B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!C7%)*+<0!M7,!7!

':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!=*#+#S.!M*%)!78!01-)7,*,!#8!(&0`C0<B!!/)0!7+,#!

)7<!7!R#2!7,!7!9@;![90&%*'*0<!@:&,0U,!;,,*,%78%\B!!/)0!&0-#&%0<!%)7%!,)0!#8+.!-+7.,!

F*<0#!S710,!M)08!,)0!*,!,*$T!#&!$##-0<!:-!*8!%)0!)#:,0!'#&!178.!<7.,!7%!7!%*10B!!

A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!'78%7,.!S710,J!"*,80.!S710,J!78<!1#F*0`

&0+7%0<!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!L$33)&H.''/3&,0&*0,J!02/&C"''%/&

P/3@$">&,0&*0,J!78<!023"%%9"%%/B!!!!

364!

! C?9A;EK!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!V:00&J!?%7+*78`;10&*$78J!X97%)#+*$`*,)Y!178B!!

A0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!+7&S0!@#&%)07,%0&8!^B/B!$*%.B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!M0&0!$#++0S0`

0<:$7%0<!k!)*,!'7%)0&!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!7!C7,%0&U,!

<0S&00![)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,-0$*'.!%)0*&!7&07,!#'!'#$:,\B!!A*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!-7&%`%*10!7,!

7!,-00$)!-7%)#+#S*,%!78<!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!7!-)#%#S&7-)0&B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!C*$)70+!

M7,!*8!%)0!,0$#8<!.07&!#'!7!()B"B!-&#S&71J!,%:<.*8S!;&%!A*,%#&.B!!A0!M7,!7+,#!

01-+#.0<!7,!7!,%:<08%!%07$)0&!7%!)*,!:8*F0&,*%.!78<!)7,!<#80!'&00+78$0!M#&T!'#&!

1:,0:1,!%)7%!)0!)7,!M#&T0<!'#&!*8!%)0!-7,%B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!

)0!M7,!h!.07&,!#+<B!!A0!08R#.,!-+7.*8S!+#8SJ!*110&,*F0!S710,J!>(Q,J!-+7%'#&10&,J!

78<!*8<*0!S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$J&P$D.3$`(&

P$(7J!<2$>.N&.?&'2/&8.%.((6(J!78<!H3"#=/&.?&H/3("$J&<$#>(&.?&0"@/B!

! C?9AEKKE!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!;,*78J!9)*80,0!'017+0B!!/)0!

S&0M!:-!*8!7!,17++!%#M8!*8!7!9)*80,0!-&#F*8$0!20'#&0!1#F*8S!%#!7!+7&S0&!$*%.!7%!7S0!a!

%#!7%%08<!2#7&<*8S!,$)##+B!!A0&!-7&08%,!$#1-+0%0<!)*S)!,$)##+B!!A0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!

7,!7!)#:,0M*'0!M)*+0!)0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!2:,*80,,178B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!C*$)0++0!

M7,!7!':++`%*10!,%:<08%!7%!7!C*<M0,%0&8!;10&*$78!$#++0S0J!17R#&*8S!*8!C787S0108%!

78<!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!&0-#&%0<!%)7%!,)0!#8+.!-+7.,!F*<0#!

S710,!#$$7,*#87++.B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!7$%*#8!S710,J!7$%*#8`

7<F08%:&0!S710,J!78<!,-#&%,!S710,B!

! @;"?@E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!2*,0W:7+J!I)*%0`A*,-78*$J!78<!;10&*$78B!!

/)0!*,!%)0!,*,%0&!#'!K0,+*0!78<!S&0M!:-!*8!@#&%)0&8!Z+#&*<7!*8!7!,-+*%`)#:,0)#+<![)0&!

-7&08%,!)7<!<*F#&$0<!M)08!,)0!M7,!7!$)*+<!78<!&017&&*0<!#%)0&!-0#-+0\B!!=#%)!#'!

)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!$#++0S0!<0S&00,!k!)0&!'7%)0&!7!NB"B!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!<0S&00,!*8!2#%)!

365!

,-0$*7+!0<:$7%*#8!78<!'#&0*S8!+78S:7S0!0<:$7%*#8B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M7,!7!+7M.0&!78<!)0&!

1#%)0&!M7,!7!/-78*,)!%07$)0&![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!)0&!,%0-`-7&08%,U!

0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<,!78<!#$$:-7%*#8,\B!!@7<*80!)7,!,#10!$#++0S0!0<:$7%*#8!78<!

M7,!-+788*8S!#8!&0%:&8*8S!%#!$#++0S0!,##8J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.B!!/)0!M#&T0<!7,!7!

)#1017T0&!78<!7!,0+'`-:2+*,)0<!7:%)#&B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!

,)0!M7,!7!$)*+<B!!/)0!,7.,!,)0!-+7.,!0F0&.!S08&0J!2:%!)0&!'7F#&*%0!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&

!.3/('J!I%>/3&<=3.%%(&T#%"#/J!78<!B.#`'&<'$39/B!

! @?9PKE!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!;10&*$78!?8<*78!M#178J!,-0$*'*$7++.!

7!"7T#%7!M#178!'&#1!%)0!D78T%#8!/*#:W!87%*#8B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!#8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!

&0,0&F7%*#8B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!&0-#&%!)0&!-7&08% ,U !0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<B!!A0&!'7%)0&!

M#&T0<!7,!%)0!EW0$:%*F0!"*&0$%#&!'#&!%)0*&!&0,0&F7%*#8U,!%&*27+!$#++0S0!78<!)0&!

1#%)0&!M7,!%)0!,$)##+!-,.$)#+#S*,%!78<!"*&0$%#&!#'!/-0$*7+!E<:$7%*#8!'#&!%)0*&!

%&*27++.!&:8!,$)##+B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!@*$#+0!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!

*8!(,.$)#+#S.B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T0<!*8!)0&!$#++0S0U,!P''*$0!#'!/:,%7*872*+*%.B!!/)0!)7,!

-+7.0<!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!7!.#:8S!$)*+<B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!

H.7[@.#&K.J!<6F/3&P$3".&G6#J!78<!02/&A$%7"#1&B/$>B!

! @P>=E>L!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!97:$7,*78J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!=#%)!#'!

)*,!-7&08%,!M0&0!$#++0S0!0<:$7%0<![)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,-0$*'.!':&%)0&\B!!A*,!-7&08%,!

M#&T0<!7,!7!@:&,0!78<!78!?8,:&78$0!;<R:,%#&J!&0,-0$%*F0+.B!!@#&20&%J!7,!#'!1.!

,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!

>)0%#&*$B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!54B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!

S08&0,!*8$+:<0!,-#&%,!S710,J!7<F08%:&0!S710,J!78<!,)##%0&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

363!

S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!P$>>/#&,0&*0,J!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@J!78<!%)0!M.3>/3%$#>(!

,0&*0,B!

! @P>C;@"!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!S7.J!A*,-78*$oK7%*8#J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!A0!

S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.B!!A*,!-7&08%,!<*F#&$0<!M)08!)0!M7,!%)&00!78<!2#%)!

&017&&*0<!+7%0&B!!A*,!'7%)0&!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!7,!7!1787S0&!7%!

%)0!^B/B!(#,%7+!/0&F*$0!78<!)*,!,%0-1#%)0&!07&80<!7!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M7,!7+,#!

01-+#.0<!7%!%)0!^B/B!(#,%7+!/0&F*$0B!!A*,!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00!78<!

M#&T0<!7,!7!$#++0S0!7<1*8*,%&7%#&!78<!)*,!,%0-'7%)0&!07&80<!7!()B"B!78<!M7,!%)0!

0<*%#&!#'!7!:8*F0&,*%.!-&0,,B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!@#&178<!)7,!07&80<!7!()B"B!*8!E8S+*,)!

K*%0&7%:&0!78<!*,!78!*8,%&:$%#&!78<!7$%*8S!7<1*8*,%&7%#&!7%!7!,17++!@7%*F0!:8*F0&,*%.!

*8!%)0!C*<M0,%B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!d4!.07&,B!!A*,!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0!*,!%)0!>(QB!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!B3$1.#&

-1/&,0&*0,J!%)0!H/3(.#$&,0&*0,J!78<!%)0!P$((&I??/='!%&*+#S.B!

! P/9;>!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!,%&7*S)%J!$*,S08<0&0<!178B!!I)*+0!)0!<*<!

8#%!,-0$*'.!)*,!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<J!M0!$78!*8'0&!'&#1!%)0*&!#$$:-7%*#8,!

[,#$*7+!M#&T0&!78<!-&#'0,,#&\!%)7%!%)0.!)7<!7%!+07,%!,#10!)*S)0&!0<:$7%*#8!

0W-0&*08$0B!!P,$7&!)*1,0+'!)7,!07&80<!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00![)0!<*<!8#%!,-0$*'.!)*,!7&07!

#'!'#$:,\!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!)*S)0&!0<!,%7''!10120&B!!A0!)7,!

2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!3c!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!

*8$+:<0!L/$3'2('.#/!78<!K:$7,;&%,!S&7-)*$!7<F08%:&0!S710,!'&#1!%)0!64,![0BSB!02/&

</=3/'&.?&P.#7/)&+(%$#>\B!

! (;L!#8+.!<0,$&*20<!%)01,0+F0,!7,!7!X):178!':++!#'!'+7M,!78<!78W*0%.BY!!L)0.!

7&0!d

!S080&7%*#8!(#+*,)`;10&*$78!78<!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!@#&%)07,%0&8!^8*%0<!/%7%0,B!!

36d!

L)0*&!'7%)0&!)7,!7!)*S)!,$)##+!<0S&00!78<!M#&T0<!-&*17&*+.!*8!7!'7$%#&.B!!L)0*&!

1#%)0&!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!0<:$7%*#8!78<!)7,!M#&T0<!-&0<#1*878%+.!*8!%)0!

*8,:&78$0!*8<:,%&.B!!(7%!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!;&%!A*,%#&.!78<J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!

M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!%)0!&0S*,%&7&!#'!7!'#&`-&#'*%!,$)##+B!!L)0.!)7F0!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!#8!78<!#''!'#&!.07&,B!!L)0*&!'7F#&*%0!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!'*S)%*8S!S710,!78<!>(Q,B!!

L)0*&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!<.6%&8$%";63!,0&*0,J!%)0!B3$1.#&-1/&,0&*0,J!

78<!%)0!]"#1>.@&L/$3'(!,0&*0,B!

! (;LLD!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'+:*<o'0110`-&0,08%*8S![-&0'0&&0<!-&#8#:8,!7&0!

,)0o)0&!78<!%)0.o%)01\J!-78&#178%*$J!I)*%0J!78<!9787<*78B!!L)0.!S&0M!:-!*8!7!

9787<*78!-&#F*8$0B!!=#%)!#'!)0&!-7&08%,!)7F0!7!$#11:8*%.!$#++0S0!+0F0+!0<:$7%*#8B!!

A0&!'7%)0&!M7,!7!10$)78*$!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!XR7$T!#'!7++!%&7<0,BY!!(7%%.!)7,!

07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!;8*17%*#8!s!Q&7-)*$,!78<!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!

M#&T*8S!7,!78!78*17%#&!'#&!7!9787<*78!-&#<:$%*#8!,%:<*#B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!

F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!7--&#W*17%0+.!5663B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!

>(Q,!78<!,*1:+7%#&,J!M)*+0!)0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!L$39/('&P..#!

,0&*0,J!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$&,0&*0,J!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!

! (;^K?@E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!;,*78![A1#8S\J!;10&*$78!'017+0B!!

/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!$*%.!M*%)!)0&!-7&08%,J!M)#!M0&0!&0':S00,!'&#1!K7#,B!!

/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!&0-#&%!)0&!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<!78<!#$$:-7%*#8,B!!;,!#'!

1.!,:&F0.J!(7:+*80!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!/#$*#+#S.!78<!

9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T0<!*8!%)0!&0,*<08%*7+!#''*$0!#'!

)0&!$#++0S0B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!7!$)*+<B!!L)0!#8+.!S710!

36f!

,)0!M7,!X2*S!#8Y!7%!%)0!%*10!#'!1.!,:&F0.!M7,!02/&A$%7"#1&B/$>J!M)*$)!,)0!08R#.0<!

-+7.*8S!M*%)!)0&!2&#%)0&,B!

! >;ZE!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!78<!=&*%*,)B!!A0!S&0M!:-!#8!

%)0!07,%!$#7,%!#'!E8S+78<B!!A*,!'7%)0&!+0'%!,$)##+!7%!7S0!5c!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!07&80<!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!/%7%*,%*$,B!!A*,!'7%)0&!M7,!7!M0+<0&!78<J!+7%0&J!7!)07+%)!78<!

,7'0%.!1787S0&!7%!7!+#$7+!$#1-78.!%)7%!17<0!0+0$%&*$7+!0V:*-108%!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!

M7,!*8*%*7++.!7!$#1-:%0&!-&#S&7110&!2:%!+0'%!)0&!R#2!%#!&7*,0!)0&!$)*+<&08B!!>7'0!)7,!

7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!()*+#,#-).!78<!*,!$:&&08%+.!M#&T*8S!7,!7!%0$)8*$7+!1787S0&!

'#&!7!=&*%*,)!%0+0F*,*#8!2&#7<$7,%0&B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!

fJ!,#!7--&#W*17%0+.!3a!.07&,B!!A0!<0$+*80<!%#!108%*#8!)*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710B!

! >;_E@!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!$*,`S08<0&0<J!2*,0W:7+J!2*&7$*7+![)7+'`2+7$TJ!

)7+'`M)*%0\J!<*,72+0<!M#178B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!-#F0&%.!*8!7!@0M!E8S+78<!,:2:&2B!!/)0!

M7,!&7*,0<!2.!)0&!1#%)0&B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<*,$+#,0!)0&!1#%)0&U,!0<:$7%*#87+!

27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!<*<!&0F07+!%)7%!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!F7&*#:,!R#2,!%)&#:S)#:%!)0&!

$)*+<)##<B!!>7F08U,!1#%)0&!*,!$:&&08%+.!01-+#.0<!*8!L7&S0%B!!>7F08!)7,!07&80<!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!E8S+*,)!K*%0&7%:&0!78<!$#1-+0%0<!$#:&,0M#&T!*8!7!C7,%0&U,!

-&#S&71J!2:%!M7,!'#&$0<!%#!+07F0!)0&!-&#S&71!<:0!%#!7!$)&#8*$!*++80,,B!!/)0!

$:&&08%+.!M#&T,!7,!7!'&00+78$0!%0$)8*$7+!M&*%0&B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!

*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!F*,:7+!8#F0+,J!78<!,:&F*F7+!S710,B!!/)0!)7,!80F0&!<*,$+#,0<!)0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!%#!10J!2:%!?!)7F0!M*%80,,0<!)0&!7F*<+.!$#8,:10!78<!<*,$:,,!

S710,!+*T0!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@J!B.#`'&<'$39/J!78<!%)0!H.7[@.#&,0&*0,B!

! >EE"!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!S7.J!97:$7,*78J!N0M*,)J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!A0!S&0M!

:-!*8!7!,17++!'7&1*8S!%#M8!7<R7$08%!%#!7!$#++0S0B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!)7F0!1:+%*-+0!

36c!

<0S&00,![)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,-0$*'.!':&%)0&\B!!A*,!'7%)0&!M#&T,!7,!7!$#++0S0!-&#'0,,#&!78<!

)*,!1#%)0&!M#&T,!7,!7!)#:,0M*'0!M)*+0!7+,#!F#+:8%00&*8SB!!>00<!)7,!$#1-+0%0<!,#10!

$#++0S0J!17R#&*8S!*8!9#1-:%0&!/$*08$0J!2:%!)7<!%#!<&#-!#:%!<:0!%#!108%7+!)07+%)!

&07,#8,B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7%!7!+#$7+!1#F*0!%)07%0&B!!A0!)7,!2008!

-+7.*8S!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!55!.07&,B!!A0!-+7.,!7!M*<0!F7&*0%.!#'!F*<0#!S710,B!!

A*,!'7F#&*%0,!*8$+:<0!K6"%>&A$3(&^J!02/&A.3%>&I#>(&A"'2&d.6J!!"#$%&!$#'$()&0$='"=(&

-^J!!$%%/#&C.#>.#J!78<!02/&M$''%/&8$'(B!!

! >PQE>!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!;10&*$78!17+0B!!

A0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!$#1-+0%0<!%M#!.07&,!7%!7!

-#,%`)*S)!,$)##+!%0$)8*$7+!$#++0S0B!!A*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!,%7.`7%`)#10!1#1!78<!

)*,!'7%)0&!#M80<!,0F0&7+!2:,*80,,0,J!X*8$+:<*8S!27&%08<*8S!78<!&08%*8S!#:%!

2:*+<*8S,!u,*$vBY!!>#S0&J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!

E8S+*,)!78<!/0$#8<7&.!E<:$7%*#8B!!A0!*,!7+,#!M#&T*8S!7%!7!S&#$0&.!,%#&0B!!A0!

0,%*17%0,!%)7%!)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!5f!.07&,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710!S08&0,!7&0!'78%7,.!78<!7$%*#8!S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!7&0!%)0!

H.7[@.#!,0&*0,J!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$&,0&*0,J!78<!%)0!Z#=2$3'/>&,0&*0,B!

! >P>D!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!,%&7*S)%J!97:$7,*78J!78<!;10&*$78B!!A0!S&0M!

:-!*8!7!,17++!C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!A*,!1#%)0&!7%%08<0<!,#10!$#++0S0!2:%!<0$+*80<!%#!

'*8*,)!7!<0S&00B!!/)0!M#&T0<!7,!7!,%7.`7%`)#10!1#1B!!>#&.!<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!)*,!

'7%)0&U,!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<!2:%!<*<!,% 7 %0!%)7%!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!78!P=QD@J!,#!?!

7,,:10!%)7%!)0!)7,!$#1-+0%0<!7!-#,%`S&7<:7%0!<0S&00B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!>#&.!M7,!7!

':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!9#11:8*$7%*#8,J!C0<*7J!78<!>)0%#&*$B!!A0!)7,!

2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!i!.07&,!#+<B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!

36h!

*8$+:<0!Z(/!S710,J!,%#&.`<&*F08!S710,J!#8+*80!1:+%*-+7.0&!S710,J!78<!,-#&%,!

S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$&,0&*0,J!G.=7/'&C/$16/J!

78<!T9/3N$'=2B!

! /;>;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!,%&7*S)%J!M)*%0J!78<!;10&*$78B!!/)0!S&0M!

:-!*8!7!10<*:1`,*]0<!%#M8!*8!E7,%0&8!?#M7B!!A0&!'7%)0&!)7,!,#10!$#++0S0!0<:$7%*#8J!

2:%!<0$+*80<!%#!'*8*,)!)*,!<0S&00J!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!)7<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00![,)0!<*<!

8#%!,-0$*'.!M)7%!'*0+<\B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!17*+178!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!7,!7!,#$*7+!

M#&T0&B!!/7&7!)7,!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!A*,%#&.!78<!;8$*08%,!u,*$v!/%:<*0,B!!;,!#'!1.!

,:&F0.J!,)0!M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!,08*#&!'*878$*7+!787+ .,% !7%!78!*8,:&78$0!$#1-78.B!!/)0!

0,%*17%0<!,)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!%)0!+7%0!i4,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!

S710!S08&0,!7&0!>(Q,!78<!%:&8`27,0<!,%&7%0S.!S710,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!

*8$+:<0!%)0!B"$;%.!,0&*0,J!8"9"%":$'".#&YJ!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,J!78<!<6F/3&P$3".&GHKB!

! /;^K!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!M)*%0J!;10&*$78!178B!!A0!S&0M!:-!

*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A0!<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!)*,!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!

27$TS&#:8<J!2:%!)0!<*<!,%7%0!%)7%!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!7!%07$)0&!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!M7,!7!

-#+*%*$*78J!7+%)#:S)!,)0!M7,!7!M7*%&0,,!M)*+0!)0!M7,!S&#M*8S!:-B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!

/7:+!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!E8S+*,)B!!A0!7+,#!M#&T0<!7,!7!$71-!

$#:8,0+#&B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!7--&#W*17%0+.!5c!.07&,B!!A*,!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!H.7[@.#&,0&*0,J!!+!-&`bcJ!78<!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&

<7)3"@B!

! L;C;>;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!,%&7*S)%J!97:$7,*78J!;10&*$78!'017+0B!!/)0!

S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!(7$*'*$!@#&%)M0,%!78<!%)0!C*<M0,%B!!/)0!<0$+*80<!%#!<0,$&*20!)0&!

-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!S080&7+!1787S0108%!

36a!

-+7880&!7%!7!+7&S0!$#1-78.J!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!&0S*,%0&0<!8:&,0J!78<!)0&!

,%0-'7%)0&!M#&T0<!'#&!7!+7&S0!'7&1*8S!$#1-78.B!!L717&7J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!7!':++`

%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!=*#+#S.o(&0`C0<B!!/)0!7+,#!M#&T0<!*8!)0&!$#++0S0U,!

7%)+0%*$!#''*$0B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!,)0!M7,!c!.07&,!#+<B!!A0&!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0!*,!%)0!Z(/B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!%)0!C/?'&Y&

B/$>!,0&*0,J!%)0!8$%%&.?&B6')&,0&*0,J!78<!L$%.&eB!

! LE>E//;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!=&7]*+*78!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!/#:%)J!

@#&%)J!78<!@#&%)07,%!=&7]*+B!!A0&!'7%)0&!)7,!07&80<!7!<0S&00!*8!=:,*80,,!

;<1*8*,%&7%*#8!78<!)0&!1#%)0&!)7,!07&80<!7!<0S&00!*8!/-0$*7+!E<:$7%*#8B!!A0&!'7%)0&!

M#&T0<!7,!7!$#110&$*7+!1787S0&!*8!7!+7&S0!$#1-78.!M)*+0!)0&!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!

,%7.`7%`)#10!1#1B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!L0&0,,7!M7,!7!':++`%*10!,%:<08%!7%!78!;10&*$78!

$#++0S0![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,%7%0!)0&!7&07!#'!,%:<.\B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!

'#&!53!.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!M6%%)J!B..@J!78<!%)0!B/9"%&P$)&83)&

,0&*0,B!

! LE>>E@9E!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!7!)0%0&#,0W:7+!17+0!#'!E:&#-078!78<!@7%*F0!

;10&*$78!<0,$08%B!!A0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!%#M8B!!A*,!'7%)0&!07&80<!7!QE"!78<!

)*,!1#%)0&!7%%08<0<!7!F#$7%*#87+!,$)##+!'#&!27T*8S!7'%0&!)*S)!,$)##+B!!A*,!'7%)0&!

M#&T0<!7,!7!-*]]7!<0+*F0&.!178!78<!)*,!1#%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!27T0&!7%!7!+#$7+!S&#$0&.!

,%#&0B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!L0&&08$0!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!/-#&%!

C787S0108%B!!A0!M7,!7+,#!78!;;^!27,T0%27++!$#7$)B!!A0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!,*8$0!)0!M7,!f!#&!cB!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!7&0!,-#&%,!S710,J!Z(/!

S710,J!78<!>(Q,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$J&-&C"#7&'.&'2/&

H$('J!]"#1>.@&L/$3'(J!78<!%)0!QM-&^]&,0&*0,B!!!

36i!

! LP@D!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!)0%0&#,0W:7+J!78<!78!X;10&*$78!1:%Y!u,*$vB!!

A0!S&0M!:-!*8!%)0!@#&%)07,%0&8!^8*%0<!/% 7%0,B!!=#%)!#'!)*,!-7&08%,!)7F0!-#,%`

S&7<:7%0!<0S&00,B!!A*,!1#%)0&!M7,!7!+7M.0&!78<!)*,!'7%)0&!M7,!78!?L!1787S0&B!!L#8.!

)7,!07&80<!7!C7,%0&U,!<0S&00![)0!<*<!8#%!,-0$*'.!)*,!'*0+<\!2:%J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!

:801-+#.0<B!!A0!0,%*17%0<!)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!,*8$0!%)0!<7.,!#'!%)0!

@*8%08<#!hf!$#8,#+0J!M)*$)!<02:%0<!*8!%)0!^8*%0<!/%7%0,!*8!/0-%0120&J!566hB!!A*,!

'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!>(Q,J!,)##%0&,J!78<!,%&7%0S.!S710,B!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!

F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!T9/3N$'=2!78<!-(($(("#`(&83//>&++B!

! _;KE>?E!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!'017+0J!2*&#178%*$!<01*J!(:0&%#!>*$78!78<!

?&*,)J!78<!;10&*$78B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!?#M7![M)*$)!,)0!M7,!@PL!)7--.!72#:%\B!!=#%)!

#'!)0&!-7&08%,!S&7<:7%0<!'&#1!$#++0S0J!7+%)#:S)!,)0!<*<!8#%!,-0$*'.!%)0*&!'*0+<,B!!A0&!

'7%)0&!M#&T0<!7,!7!M#&T0&U,!&*S)%,o$#1-!+7M.0&!M)*+0!)0&!1#%)0&!M7,!7!+*2&7&.!

-7&7-&#'0,,*#87+B!!_7+0&*0!)7,!07&80<!7!=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!L)07%0&!78<!E8S+*,)!78<!

*,J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!M7,!01-+#.0<!7,!7!'&00+78$0!,%7S0!1787S0&!78<!7!+*2&7&.!

-7&7-&#'0,,*#87+B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!d3!.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!

F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!T9/3N$'=2J!<'$3&A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=J!78<!B3$1.#&-1/&^B!

! _EK_;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!M)*%0J!2*,0W:7+!'017+0!#'!/.&*78!78<!/$#%%*,)!

<0,$08%B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!78!7''+:08%!,:2:&2 ! *8!@0M!E8S+78<B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!07&80<!

7!()B"B!*8!/-0$*7+!E<:$7%*#8!78<!*,!8#M!&0%*&0<![,)0!<0$+*80<!%#!,%7%0!)0&!

#$$:-7%*#8\B!!A0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!*8!'*878$0!2:%!*,!8#M!&0%*&0<!7,!M0++![,)0!<0$+*80<!

%#!,%7%0!)*,!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<\B!!_0+F7J!7,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)7<!07&80<!7!

=7$)0+#&U,!<0S&00!*8!/-0$*7+!E<:$7%*#8!78<!M7,!M#&T*8S!7%!7!-&0,$)##+o<7.$7&0!

$08%0&B!!/)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!S710,!'#&!3!.07&,B!!A0&!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!

366!

S08&0,!*8$+:<0!2:*+<*8S!S710,J!,:$)!7,!G.%%/3=.$('/3&0)=..#!#&!P"#/=3$?'J!#&!S710,!

M*%)!*8%0&0,%*8S!,%#&.+*80,J!+*T0!02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@B!!

! I?KK?;C!<0,$&*20<!)*1,0+'!7,!17+0J!,%&7*S)%J!?&*,)J!78<!;10&*$78B!!A0!S&0M!

:-!*8!%)0!@#&%)07,%0&8!^8*%0<!/%7%0,!M*%)!)*,!,*8S+0!1#%)0&![)*,!'7%)0&!+0'%!M)08!)0!

M7,!3\!:8%*+!)0!M7,!5dJ!M)08!)0!M7,!+0S7++.!0178$*-7%0<B!!I*++*71!<0$+*80<!%#!

108%*#8!0*%)0&!#'!)*,!-7&08%,U!0<:$7%*#87+!27$TS&#:8<!#&!#$$:-7%*#8B!!Z#&!)*1,0+'J!

I*++*71!)7,!$#1-+0%0<!,#10!$#++0S0!2:%!<0$+*80<!%#!'*8*,)!)*,!<0S&00!*8!

1787S0108%!,*8$0!)0!,7.,!)0!M7,!<#*8S!M0++!08#:S)!M*%)#:%!*%B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!)0!

M7,!M#&T*8S!7,!7!'&78$)*,0!1787S0&!#'!3!+#$7%*#8,!%)7%!7&0!&78T0<!71#8S!%)0!%#-!

cx!#'!'&78$)*,0!+#$7%*#8,!'#&!)*,!$#1-78.B!!A0!0,%*17%0<!)0!)7,!2008!-+7.*8S!F*<0#!

S710,!,*8$0!56ifB!!A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710!S08&0,!*8$+:<0!-:]]+0!S710,!78<!>(Q,B!!

A*,!'7F#&*%0!F*<0#!S710,!*8$+:<0!0/'3"(J!%)0!!"#$%&!$#'$()!,0&*0,J!%)0!!$%%.6'!,0&*0,J!

78<!02/&C/1/#>&.?&_/%>$&,0&*0,B!!

! q?L;!<0,$&*20<!)0&,0+'!7,!7!1:+%*&7$*7+![2+7$TJ!M)*%0J!@7%*F0!;10&*$78\J!

;10&*$78!'017+0B!!/)0!S&0M!:-!*8!7!C*<M0,%0&8!,:2:&2B!!A0&!1#%)0&!)7,!$#1-+0%0<!

)*S)!,$)##+!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!)7,!07&80<!7!F#$7%*#87+!$#++0S0!<0S&00B!!!A0&!1#%)0&!

M#&T0<!7,!7!&07+!0,%7%0!7S08%!78<!)0&!'7%)0&!M#&T0<!'#&!e0&#W!20'#&0!1#F*8S!%#!7!

<*''0&08%!$#1-78.B!!;,!#'!1.!,:&F0.J!q*%7!M7,!7!':++`%*10!$#++0S0!,%:<08%!17R#&*8S!*8!

(#+*%*$7+!/$*08$0!78<!A:178!/0&F*$0,B!!/)0!,%7%0<!%)7%!,)0!<#0,!8#%!X&07++.!-+7.!F*<0#!

S710,Y!78<!%)7%!,)0!*,!27<!7%!%)01B!!I)08!,)0!<#0,!-+7.!F*<0#!S710,J!%)#:S)J!,)0!

-&0'0&,!X2:*+<*8S!$*%.!#80,Y!+*T0!8/%'"=&,"%%$1/&78<!02/&<"@(!,0&*0,B!!!

! !

! !!

d44!

=?=K?PQ>;(AD!

;7&,0%)J!EB![566a\B!!8);/3'/E'J&H/3(F/='"9/(&.#&/31.>"=&%"'/3$'63/B!!=7+%*1#&0J!C"G!

! N#)8,!A#-T*8,!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

;+7,::%7&*J!(0&%%*B![5666\B!!X?8%&#<:$%*#8G!L)&00!()7,0,!#'!>0$0-%*#8!/%:<*0,BY!!?8!(B!

! ;+7,::%7&*![E<B\J!G/'2"#7"#1&@/>"$&$6>"/#=/(![--B!5`35\B!!K#8<#8G!/7S0B!

;+0W78<0&J!NB![566f\B!!!"#&>/&("f=%/&(.="$%&'2/.3)J&G/%$'"9"(@4&3/>6='".#&$#>&'2/&

& F3.;%/@&.?&3/$(.#B!!K#8<#8G!_0&,#B&

;+%0&J!;B![345a\B!!+33/("('";%/J&02/&3"(/&.?&$>>"='"9/&'/=2#.%.1)&$#>&'2/&;6("#/((&.?&&

& 7//F"#1&6(&2..7/>X!!@0M!D#&TG!(08S:*8!(&0,,B!

;8<0&,#8J!9B!;BJ!/)*2:.7J!;BJ!?)#&*J!@BJ!/M*8SJ!EB!KBJ!=:,)178J!=B!NBJ!/7T71#%#J!;BJ!

b/7+001J!CB![3454\B!!_*#+08%!F*<0#!S710!0''0$%,!#8!7SS&0,,*#8J!01-7%).J!78<!

-&#,#$*7+!20)7F*#&!*8!E7,%0&8!78<!I0,%0&8!$#:8%&*0,B!!H()=2.%.1"=$%&

M6%%/'"#J!b\gJ!5c5k5adB!

;--*7)J!OB!;B![344c\B!!02/&/'2"=(&.?&">/#'"')B!!(&*8$0%#8J!@NG!(&*8$0%#8!^(B!!!

=70&SJ!;B![3446\B!!Q#F0&8108%7+*%.J!80#+*20&7+*,1J!78<!%)0!<*S*%7+!S710B!!()@F%.7h4&&

& bc[5`3\J!55c`53aB!!

=70&SJ!;B![345f\B!!@0#+*20&7+*,1J!&*,TJ!78<!:8$0&%7*8%.!*8!%)0!F*<0#!S710B!!?8!NB>B!"*!!

! K0#!s!^B!C0)78![E<,B\J!8$F"'$%&$'&'2/&;3"#7J&T9/3=.@"#1&'2/&>/('36='"9/&&

& %/1$="/(&.?&#/.%";/3$%"(@![--B!5ih`35f\B!!;88!;&2#&J!C?G!P-08!A:178*%*0,!!

! (&0,,B!

=7+,71#B!;B![5666\B!!Z#&1,!#'!%0$)8#+#S*$7+!012#<*108%G!>07<*8S!%)0!2#<.!*8!!

! $#8%01-#&7&.!$:+%:&0B!!?8!NB!(&*$0!s!CB!/)*+<&*$T![E<,B\J!!/@"#"('&'2/.3)&$#>&

& '2/&;.>)J&-&3/$>/3![--B!3ai`3i6\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

d45!

=7%%0&,2.J!9B![5666\B!!A0&!2#<.o)0&!2#:8<7&*0,B!!?8!NB!(&*$0!s!CB!/)*+<&*$T![E<,B\J!

! !/@"#"('&'2/.3)&$#>&'2/&;.>)J&-&3/$>/3![--B!df5`dci\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0!

=7.1J!@BOB![3444\B!!06#/&"#4&%.1&.#J&<.$F(4&?$#>.@4&$#>&.#%"#/&=.@@6#"')B!!L)#:,78<!

! P7T,J!9;G!/7S0B!

=0$TJ!NB9B!s!I7<0J!CB![344f\B!!K.'&1$@/J&L.N&'2/&1$@/3&1/#/3$'".#&"(&3/(2$F"#1&&

& ;6("#/((&?.3/9/3B!!=#,%#8J!C;G!A7&F7&<!=:,*80,,!/$)##+!(:2+*,)*8S!

=0&+78%J!KB![344i\B!!02/&?/@$%/&=.@F%$"#'J&02/&6#?"#"(2/>&;6("#/((&.?&(/#'"@/#'$%"')&"#!

! -@/3"=$#&=6%'63/![O*8<+0!F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!

=0&+78%J!KB![3455\B!!836/%&.F'"@"(@![O*8<+0!F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!

=)72)7J!AB![344d\B!L)0!%)*&<!,-7$0G!*8%0&F*0M!M*%)!A#1*!=)72)7B!!!?8!NB!>:%)0&'#&<!

! [E<B\J!+>/#'"')J&8.@@6#"')4&=6%'63/4&>"??/3/#=/![-B!34a`335\B!!K#8<#8G!

! K7M&08$0!s!I*,)7&%B!

=*&T0J!KB![5666\B!!=#<*0,!78<!2*#+#S.B!!?8!NB!(&*$0!s!CB!/)*+<&*$T![E<,B\J!!/@"#"('&!

& '2/.3)&$#>&'2/&;.>)J&-&3/$>/3![--B!f3`f6\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

=+0<,%0*8J!=BNB!![56ah\B!!02/&=6%'63/&.?&F3.?/((".#$%"(@J&02/&@">>%/&=%$((&$#>&'2/&&

& >/9/%.F@/#'&.?&2"12/3&/>6=$'".#&"#&-@/3"=$B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!IBIB!@#&%#8!

! s!9#1-78.B!

=#S#,%J!?B![344a\B!!H/3(6$("9/&1$@/(J&02/&/EF3/(("9/&F.N/3&.?&9">/.1$@/(B!!!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!L)0!C?L!(&0,,B!

=#:&<*0:J!(B![56if\B!!B"('"#='".#J&-&(.="$%&=3"'"R6/&.?&'2/&D6>1@/#'&.?&'$('/X!!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!A7&F7&<!^(B!

=#:&<*0:J!(B!78<!I7$V:78%J!KB![5663\B!!-#&"#9"'$'".#&'.&3/?%/E"9/&(.=".%.1)B!!

! 9712&*<S0G!(#+*%.B=&#M8![344c\!

d43!

=&#M8J!IB![344h\B!!;10&*$78!8*S)%17&0G!@0#+*20&7+*,1J!80#$#8,0&F7%*,1J!78<!!

! <0`<01#$&7%*]7%*#8B!!H.%"'"=$%&'2/.3)4&\Y[h\J!h64`a5fB!

=&:110%%J!=B![56ic\B!!E+0$%&*$!+*%0&7%:&0!7,!0V:*-108%!'#&!+*F*8SG!A7:8%0<!)#:,0!!

! '*+1,B!!83"'"=$%&<'6>"/(&"#&P$((&8.@@6#"=$'".#4&^[d\J!3fa`3h5B!

=&.78%J!NB!78<!"7F*0,J!NB![344h\B!!/0+0$%*F0!0W-#,:&0!-&7$%*$0,B!!?8!NB!=&.78%!s!(B!!

! _#&<0&0&![E<,B\J!H()=2.%.1)&.?&/#'/3'$"#@/#'![--B!56`df\B!!@0M!D#&TG!

! >#:%+0<S0!

=:&T0J!OB![56hi\B!!H2"%.(.F2)&.?&%"'/3$3)&?.3@B!!=0&T0+0.J!9;G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!97+*'#&8*7!

! (&0,,B!

=:%+0&J!NB![5664\B!!K/#>/3&'3.6;%/J&!/@"#"(@&$#>&'2/&(6;9/3(".#&.?&">/#'"')B!!@0M!D#&TG!

! >#:%+0<S0B!

=:%+0&J!NB![566d\B!!M.>"/(&'2$'&@$''/3J&T#&'2/&>"(=63("9/&%"@"'(&.?&(/EB!!@0M!D#&TG!!

! >#:%+0<S0B!

=:%+0&J!NB![5666\B!!=#<*0,!%)7%!17%%0&B!!?8!NB!(&*$0!s!CB!/)*+<&*$T![E<,B\J!!/@"#"('&&

& '2/.3)&$#>&'2/&;.>)J&-&3/$>/3![--B!3dc`3fc\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

=:%,$)J!>B![344i\B!!02/&="'":/#&$6>"/#=/J&83.N>(4&F6;%"=(4&$#>&"#>"9">6$%(![O*8<+0!

! F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!

97*8J!/B![3453\B!!56"/'J&02/&F.N/3&.?&"#'3.9/3'(&"#&$&N.3%>&'2$'&=$#`'&('.F&'$%7"#1B!

! @0M!D#&TJ!@DG!=&#7<M7.!=##T,B!

97+0J!QB![345c\B!!-#&"@F.3'$#'&=$9/$'&$;.6'&(/%?W=$3/&?.3&$=$>/@"=(B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

! )%%-,Goo$#8<*%*#87++.7$$0-%0<B$#1o345co4ho3do,0+'$7&0`,##%)*8So!

97++0R7J!QB![3454\B!!"*S*%7+!S710,!78<!0,$7-*,1B!!K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/4&e[f\J!ddc`dcdB!

d4d!

97,,0++J!NBJ!s!N08T*8,J!AB![5666\B!9)0,,!'#&!S*&+,G!Z01*8*,1!78<!$#1-:%0&!S710,B!?8!NB!

! 97,,0++!s!AB!N08T*8,![E<,B\J!!3.@&M$3;"/&'.&P.3'$%&].@;$'![--B!3`fc\B!

9712&*<S0J!

! C;G!C?L!(&0,,B!

9)0,,J!/B![3455\B!!;!dh`3f`dh!$0&02&:1G!(&#<:$%*F*%.J!S08<0&J!78<!F*<0#!S710!!

! 7<F0&%*,*8SB!!83"'"=$%&<'6>"/(&"#&P/>"$&8.@@6#"=$'".#4&^i[d\J!3d4`3c3B!

9)0,,J!/BJ!s!/)7MJ!;B![345c\B!!;!$#8,-*&7$.!#'!'*,)0,J!#&J!)#M!M0!+07&80<!%#!,%#-!!

! M#&&.*8S!72#:%!}S710&S7%0!78<!012&7$0!)0S01#8*$!17,$:+*8*%.B!!S.63#$%&

& .?&M3.$>=$('"#1&$#>&I%/='3.#"=&P/>"$J!c6J!34i`334B!

9#8,7+F#J!CB![344a\B!!82/$'"#1J&K$"#"#1&$>9$#'$1/&"#&9">/.1$@/(B!!9712&*<S0J!C;G!

! L)0!C?L!(&0,,B!

9#:+<&.J!@B![3444\B!!+#(">/&=6%'63/J&G/W"@$1"#"#1&'2/&@/'2.>&.?&=6%'63$%&('6>"/(B!

! K#8<#8G!/7S0B!

9#:+<&.J!@B![3453\B!!P/>"$4&(.="/')4&N.3%>J&<.="$%&'2/.3)&$#>&>"1"'$%&@/>"$&F3$='"=/B!!!

! K#8<#8G!(#+*%.!(&0,,B!

9&7M'#&<J!QB![3453\B!!,">/.&1$@/3(B!!K#8<#8G!>#:%+0<S0B!

9&08,)7MJ!OB![5665\B!!C7--*8S!%)0!17&S*8,G!?8%0&,0$%*#87+*%.J!*<08%*%.!-#+*%*$,J!78<!

! F*#+08$0!7S7*8,%!M#108!#'!$#+#&B!!<'$#?.3>&C$N&G/9"/NJ!Y\XgJ!--B!53f5`5366B!

9,*T,]08%1*)7+.*J!CB![5664\B!!!%.NJ&02/&F()=2.%.1)&.?&.F'"@$%&/EF/3"/#=/B!!@0M!D#&TG!

! A7&-0&!s!>#MB!

<0!97,%0++J!/BJ!s!=&.,#8J!CB![5666\B!>0%##+*8S!-+7.G!".,%#-*7J!<.,-)#&*7J!78<!

! <*''0&08$0B!?8!NB!97,,0++!s!AB!N08T*8,![E<,B\J!!3.@&M$3;"/&'.&P.3'$%&].@;$'&[--B!

! 3d3`3h5\B!!9712&*<S0J!C;G!C?L!(&0,,B!

d4f!

"7.78J!"BJ!s!O7%]J!EB![5663\B!!P/>"$&/9/#'(J&02/&%"9/&;3.$>=$('"#1&.?&2"('.3)B!!!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!A7&F7&<!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

"08]*8J!@BOB![566a\B!!+#'/3F3/'"9/&/'2#.13$F2)J&I'2#.13$F2"=&F3$='"=/(&?.3&'2/&^b

& =/#'63)X!!L)#:,78<!P7T,J!9;G!/7S0B!

"*++#8J!/B![345i\B!!!61"'"9/&%"?/J&02/&R6//3&F.%"'"=(&.?&'2/&F3"(.#&('$'/B!!":&)71J!@9G!

! ":T0!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!!!

"&0MJ!>B![344c\B!!XP8$0!1#&0J!M*%)!*&#8.YG!O7&7#T0!78<!,#$*7+!$+7,,B!!C/"(63/&<'6>"/(4!

! ^Y[f\J!da5`didB!

".0&`I*%)0'#&<J!@B!s!<0!(0:%0&J!QB![3446\B!!K$@/(&.?&/@F"3/J&K%.;$%&=$F"'$%"(@&$#>&&

& 9">/.&1$@/(B!!C*8807-#+*,J!C@G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!C*880,#%7!(&0,,B!

E)&08&0*$)J!=B![3446\B!!M3"12'W(">/>J&L.N&'2/&3/%/#'%/((&F63(6"'&.?&F.("'"9/&'2"#7"#1&

& 2$(&6#>/3@"#/>&-@/3"=$B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!C0%&#-#+*%78!=##T,B&

E++*8S,#8J!KBKB![344h\B!!E12#<*0<!T8#M+0<S0G!I&*%*8S!&0,07&$)0&,U!2#<*0,!*8%#!!

! V:7+*%7%*F0!)07+%)!&0,07&$)B!!56$%"'$'"9/&2/$%'2&3/(/$3=24&bg[3\J!36i`d54B!

E++*8S,#8J!KBKB![345a\B!!I@;.>"@/#'&"#&R6$%"'$'"9/&3/(/$3=2B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!

! >#:%+0<S0B!!

E++*,J!9B![566a\B!!EF#$7%*F0!7:%#0%)8#S&7-).G!I&*%*8S!01#%*#87++.!72#:%!#:&!+*F0,B!!?8!!

! IB!L*0&80.!s!DB!K*8$#+8![E<,B\J!G/F3/(/#'$'".#&$#>&'2/&'/E'J&G/?3$@"#1&'2/&&

& #$33$'"9/&9."=/![--B!55c`5d6\B!!;+278.G!/%7%0!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!@0M!D#&T!(&0,,B!

E++*,J!9B!s!=#$)80&J!;B(B![3444\B!!;:%#0%)8#S&7-).J!-0&,#87+!87&&7%*F0J!&0'+0W*F*%.B!!!

! >0,07&$)0&!7,!,:2R0$%B!!?8!@BOB!"08]*8!s!DB/B!K*8$#+8![E<,B\J!L$#>;..7&.?&&

& R6$%"'$'"9/&3/(/$3=2J!3

!0<B![--B!add`ahi\B!!L)#:,78<!P7T,J!9;G!/7S0B!

d4c!

Z0+,T*J!>B![3444\B!!@#%)*8S!%#!<0$+7&0G!?<08%*%.J!,)710J!78<!%)0!+#M0&!1*<<+0!$+7,,B!

! HPC-4&bbe[5\J!dd`fcB!

Z*80J!QB;B![566d\B!!L08!+*0,!#'!0%)8#S&7-).G!C#&7+!<*+0117,!#'!'*0+<!&0,07&$)B!!!

! S.63#$%&.?&8.#'/@F.3$3)&I'2#.13$F2)4&^^[d\J!3ha`36fB!

Z#:$7:+%J!CB![56ii\B!!02/&=$3/&.?&'2/&(/%?J&02/&2"('.3)&.?&(/E6$%"')&9.%6@/&\B!!!

! @0M!D#&TG!_*8%7S0!=##T,B!

Z#:$7:+%J!CB![344a\B!!</=63"')4&'/33"'.3)4&F.F6%$'".#J&C/='63/(&$'&'2/&8.%%f1/&>/&!3$#=/4&

& baccWbaci&[QB!=:&$)0++J!L&78,B\X!!CB!/0++087&%![E<B\B!!=7,*8S,%#T0G!(7+S&7F0!

! C7$1*++78B!

Z&#8J!NBJ!Z:++0&%#8J!LBJ!C#&*0J!NBJ ! s!(07&$0J!9B![344a7\B!!-&1$@/&.?&.#/`(&.N#J&0.N$3>(&$&

& #/N&1/#>/3/>&F./'"=(&.?&>"1"'$%&(F$=/B!!(&#$00<*8S,!'&#1!-0&%)";9B&

Z&#8J!NBJ!Z:++0&%#8J!LBJ!C#&*0J!NBJ ! s!(07&$0J!9B![344a2\B!!02/&2/1/@.#)&.?&F%$)B!

! (&#$00<*8S,!'&#1!"*S*%7+!Q710,!>0,07&$)!;,,#$*7%*#8!["*Q>;\B!

Q7&8)71J!@BJ!s!I*++*71,J!>B![56i4\B!!(*0&&0!=#:&<*0:!78<!%)0!,#$*#+#S.!#'!$:+%:&0G!;8!

! *8%&#<:$%*#8B!!P/>"$4&86%'63/&j&<.="/')4&^4&346`33dB!

Q00J!NB(B![345f\B!!A2$'&9">/.&1$@/(&2$9/&'.&'/$=2&6(&$;.6'&%/$3#"#1&$#>&%"'/3$=)![3

! 0<B\B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!/%B!C7&%*8U,!(&0,,B!

Q*2,#8`Q&7)71J!NBOBJ!>0,8*$TJ!/B;BJ!s!I#+''J!>B"B![3444\B!!?8%&#<:$%*#8G!9+7,,!*8!-#,%`!

! ,%&:$%:&7+*,%!'&710B!!?8!NBOB!Q*2,#8`Q&7)71J!/B;B!>0,8*$TJ!s!>B"B!I#+''![E<,B\J!

! 8%$((&$#>&"'(&.'2/3(B!!C*8807-#+*,J!C@G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!C*880,#%7!(&0,,B!

Q*2,#8`Q&7)71J!NBOB![344h\B!!-&F.('=$F"'$%"('&F.%"'"=(X!!C*8807-#+*,J!C@G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!

! C*880,#%7!(&0,,B!

d4h!

Q*+&#.J!(B![344f\B!!M/'N//#&=$@F(J&Q$'".#(4&=6%'63/(&$#>&'2/&$%%63/&.?&3$=/B!!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!A7&F7&<!^(B!

Q##<0J!EB![5666\B!!/0W!M*%)!*8'#&178%,!7,!<0F*78%!20)7F*#&B!!B/9"$#'&M/2$9".34&^k4!

! d45`d3fB!

Q&7.J!OBJ!Q72+0&J!OBJ!/)#<)78J!/BJ!s!O:$*$J!CB![344c\B!!A#M!%#!-&#%#%.-0!7!S710!*8!!

! :8<0&!a!<7.,B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

)%%-GooMMMBS717,:%&7B$#1oF*0Mo'07%:&0o5d4ifio)#MH%#H-&#%#%.-0H7HS7

10H*8H:8<0&HaHB-)-!

Q&7.J!OB![345f\B!!G$=/4&1/#>/34&>/9"$#=/&"#&*;.E&C"9/J&02/.3/'"=$%&F/3(F/='"9/(&?3.@&&

& '2/&9"3'6$%&@$31"#(B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!>#:%+0<S0B!

Q&#,]J!EB![5666\B!!(,.$)#787+.,*,!78<!%)0!2#<.B!!?8!NB!(&*$0!s!CB!/)*+<&*$T![E<,B\J!!

! !/@"#"('&'2/.3)&$#>&'2/&;.>)J&-&3/$>/3![--B!3ha`3a5\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

A7+20&,%71J!NB![3455\B!!02/&R6//3&$3'&.?&?$"%63/B!!":&)71J!@9G!":T0!^(B!

A7++J!/B![566h7\B!!L)0!-&#2+01!#'!*<0#+#S.G!C7&W*,1!M*%)#:%!S:7&78%00,B!!?8!"B!

! C#&+0.!s!OB!9)08![E<,B\J!<'6$3'&L$%%J&83"'"=$%&>"$%.16/(&"#&=6%'63$%&('6>"/(!

! [--B!3c`fh\B!!@0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

A7++J!/B![566h2\B!!I)7%!*,!%)*,!r2 +7$TU!*8!2+7$T!-#-:+7&!$:+%:&0g!!?8!"B!C#&+0.!s!OB!

! 9)08![E<,B\J!<'6$3'&L$%%J&83"'"=$%&>"$%.16/(&"#&=6%'63$%&('6>"/(![--B!fhc`fac\B!

! @0M!D#&TG!>#:%+0<S0B!

A7++J!/B![566h$\B!!I)#!800<,!*<08%*%.g!!?8!/B!A7++!s!(B!<:!Q7.![E<,B\J!56/('".#(&.?&

& =6%'63$%&">/#'"')![--B!5`5i\B!!K#8<#8G!/7S0B&

d4a!

A7++J!/B![3444\B!!E8$#<*8So<0$#<*8SB!!?8!(B!C7&&*,!s!L)#&8)71J!/B![E<,B\J!!

! P/>"$&('6>"/(J&-&3/$>/3![3

!0<B\![--B!c5`h5\B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!@0M!D#&T!!

! ^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

A78,#8J!9B![345i\B!!K$@/&'"@/J&Z#>/3('$#>"#1&'/@F.3$%"')&"#&9">/.&1$@/(B!

! =+##1*8S%#8J!?@G!?8<*787!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

A7&<%J!CBJ!s!@0S&*J!;B![3444\B!!I@F"3/B!!9712&*<S0J!C;G!A7&F7&<!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

A7&<%J!CBJ!s!@0S&*J!;B![344f\B!!P6%'"'6>/J&A$3&$#>&>/@.=3$=)&"#&'2/&$1/&.?&I@F"3/X!

! @0M!D#&TJ!@DG!(08S:*8B!

A7&&*,J!;B![345aJ!;-&*+!c\B!;!)*,%#&.!#'!,0+'`$7&0B!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

)%%-GooMMMB,+7%0B$#1o7&%*$+0,o7&%,o$:+%:&02#Wo345ao4fo%)0H)*,%#&.H#'H,0+

'H$7&0B)%1+B!

A7&-0&J!LB![345fJ!C7.!5f\B!!I3$("#1&).63&$6>"/#=/&"(#`'&l?6#`J&02/&?$%(/&=2."=/&;/'N//#&

& >"9/3("')&$#>&I#D.)@/#'B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1&

& )%%-GooMMMB-#+.S#8B$#1o345foco33ocaf5663o%#1#<7$)*`+*'0W)0&#0,`#'`&

& %)0`,%#&1`2+*]]7&<`8*8%08<#B&

A08<0&,#8J!KB![345d\B!!C.9/&$#>&@.#/)J&56//3(4&=%$((4&$#>&=6%'63$%&F3.>6='".#X!!@0M!

! D#&TJ!@DG!@D^!(&0,,B!

A:*]*8S7J!NB![56cc\B!!L.@.&%6>/#(J&-&('6>)&.?&'2/&F%$)W/%/@/#'&"#&=6%'63/B!!=#,%#8J!C;G!

! =07$#8!(&0,,B!

N08T*8,J!>B![5663\B!!H"/33/&M.63>"/6![O*8<+0!F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!

N08T*8,J!AB![344h7\B!!8.#9/31/#=/&=6%'63/J&A2/3/&.%>&$#>&#/N&@/>"$&=.%%">/B!!@0M!!

! D#&TG!@0M!D#&T!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

d4i!

N08T*8,J!AB![344h2\B!!!$#(4&;%.11/3(4&$#>&1$@/3(J&IEF%.3"#1&F$3'"="F$'.3)&=6%'63/X!!

! @0M!D#&TG!@0M!D#&T!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

N#)8,#8J!>B![566d\B!!E<*%#&U,!*8%&#<:$%*#8G!(*0&&0! = #:&<*0:!#8!7&%J!+*%0&7%:&0!78<!!

! $:+%:&0B!!?8!>B!N#)8,#8![E<B\J!02/&?"/%>&.?&=6%'63$%&F3.>6='".#![--B!5`3c\B!

! @0M!D#&TJ!@DG!9#+:12*7!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

N::+J!NB![344c\B!!L$%?WG/$%J&,">/.&1$@/(&;/'N//#&3/$%&36%/(&$#>&?"='".#$%&N.3%>(B!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!L)0!C?L!(&0,,B!!

N::+J!NB![3454\B!!-&=$(6$%&3/9.%6'".#J&G/"#9/#'"#1&9">/.&1$@/(&$#>&'2/"3&F%$)/3(B!!!

! 9712&*<S0J!C;G!L)0!C?L!(&0,,B!

O08<7++J!KB![3443\B!!L$#1"#1&.6'&"#&'2/&9"3'6$%&F6;J&P$(=6%"#"'"/(&$#>&3/%$'".#(2"F(&

& .#%"#/B!!=0&T0+0.J!9;G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!97+*'#&8*7!(&0,,B!

O08<7++J!KB![3446\B!!j:0,%*#8!'#:&G!A#M!<#!*,,:0,!#'!S08<0&!78<!,0W:7+*%.!*8'+:08$0!!

! %)0!,%&:$%:&0,!78<!-&#$0,,0,!#'!V:7+*%7%*F0!*8%0&80%!&0,07&$)g!!?8!;B@B!!

! C7&T)71!s!@BOB!=7.1![E<,B\J!+#'/3#/'&"#R6"3)J&8.#9/3($'".#(&$;.6'&@/'2.>!

! [--B!66`55i\B!!K#8<#8G!/7S0B!!

O0&&J!;BJ!O•$T+*$)J!NBJ!s!=&0&0%#8J!(B![344h\B!!@0M!10<*7!k!80M!-+07,:&0,g!!&

& +#'/3#$'".#$%&S.63#$%&.?&86%'63$%&<'6>"/(4&a[5\J!hd`i3B!

O*8871#8J!KB![345h\B!!;%%08%*#8!:8<0&!&0-7*&G!7,$0%*$*,1!'&#1!,0+'`$7&0!%#!$7&0!#'!!

! %)0!,0+'B!!A.@/#&j&H/3?.3@$#=/J&$&S.63#$%&.?&!/@"#"('&02/.3)4&^g[3`d\J!5if`!

! 56hB!

O:+*$TJ!"B!78<!I*++,#8J!CBJ!0<,B![566c\B!!0$;..J&</E4&">/#'"')&$#>&/3.'"=&(6;D/='"9"')&

& "#&$#'32.F.%.1"=$%&?"/%>N.37X!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!>#:%+0<S0B!

d46!

K7]]7&7%#J!CB![344f\B!!Z&#1!$7-*%7+`+72#:&!%#!$7-*%7+`+*'0![_B!Z#:&8*0&J!;B!_*&%7808J!s! !

! NB!_p)p1pT*J!L&78,B\B!!/F2/@/3$J&02/.3)&j&H.%"'"=(&"#&T31$#":$'".#4&Y[d\J!5ia`!

! 34iB!

K088#8J!=B![345c\B!!;8!*8%0&F*0M!M*%)!;<&*0880!/)7MB!!B"1"'$%&86%'63/&$#>&&

P/>"$&+#"'"$'"9/X!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1&

)%%-Goo<$1*B+7B-,:B0<:o345co4co5do7<&*0880`,)7M`,-07T0&`*8%0&F*0Mo&&

K*'0$#:&,0!;,,#$*7%0,![345f\B!!02/&#/N&?$=/&.?&1$@/3(B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

! )%%-Goo2+#SB%M*%$)B%FoM-$#8%08%o:-+#7<,o345fo4hoL)0@0MZ7$0#'Q710&,B!

! -<'!

K*8<+#'J!LB>BJ!s!L7.+#&J!=B9B![3455\B!!56$%"'$'"9/&=.@@6#"=$'".#&3/(/$3=2&@/'2.>(!

! [d

!0<B\B!K#8<#8G!/7S0B!

K*F*8S,%#80J!/B![344f\B!!L)0!$)7++08S0!#'!$)7 8 S*8S!7:<*08$0,G!P&J!M)7%!*,!%)0!!

! 7:<*08$0!&0,07&$)0&!%#!<#!*8!%)0!7S0!#'!%)0!*8%0&80%g!!I63.F/$#&S.63#$%&.?&

& 8.@@6#"=$'".#4&ba[5\J!ac`ihB!

C7+T#M,T*J!NB!s!>:,,M#&1J!LBCB![345a\B!!?8%&#<:$%*#8J!?<08%*%.J!&0-&0,08%7%*#8J!78<!

! F*<0#!S710!,%:<*0,!20.#8<!%)0!-#+*%*$,!#'!%)0!*17S0B!!?8!NB!C7+T#M,T*!s!LBCB!

! >:,,M#&1![E<,B\J!K$@"#1&3/F3/(/#'$'".#J&G$=/4&1/#>/34&$#>&(/E6$%"')&"#&9">/.&

& 1$@/(![--B!5`5h\B!!=+##1*8S%#8J!?@G!?8<*787!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!&!

C7&T)71J!;B![566i\B!!C"?/&.#%"#/J&G/(/$3=2"#1&3/$%&/EF/3"/#=/(&"#&9"3'6$%&(F$=/B!

! I7+8:%!9&00TJ!9;G!;+%7!C*&7!(&0,,B!

d54!

C7&T)71J!;B![344c\B!!L)0!-#+*%*$,J!0%)*$,J!78<!10%)#<,!#'!&0-&0,08%7%*#8!*8!#8+*80!

! 0%)8#S&7-).B!!?8!@B!"08]*8!s!DB!K*8$#+8![E<,B\J!02/&/;QE&2$#>;..7&.?&&

& R6$%"'$'"9/&3/(/$3=2![d

!0<BJ!--B!a6d`i34\B!!L)#:,78<!P7T,J!9;G!/7S0B!

Cp.&pJ!ZB![344i\B!!-#&"#'3.>6='".#&'.&1$@/&('6>"/(J&K$@/(&"#&=6%'63/B!!K#8<#8G!/7S0B!

[email protected]!KB![5666\B!!Q08<0&J!)72*%:,!78<!%)0!'*0+<G!(*0&&0!=#:&<*0:!78<!%)0!+*1*%,!#'!

! &0'+0W*F*%.B!!02/.3)&86%'63/&<.="/')J!bgJ!6c`55a\B!

C*++*8S%#8J!=B![3446\B!!I**!)7,!80F0&!2008!1#<0&8G!r7$%*F0U!F*<0#!S710,!78<!%)0!!

! r$#8<:$%!#'!$#8<:$%BU!!Q/N&P/>"$&j&<.="/')4&bb[f\J!h35`hf4B!

C*++*8S%#8J!=B![345f\B!!;1:,*8S!#:&,0+F0,!%#!+*'0G!Z*%80,,!$#8,:10&*,1!78<!%)0!2*&%)!!

! #'!2*#`S710,B!!S.63#$%&.?&<F.3'&$#>&<.="$%&+((6/(4&\i[h\J!f65`c4iB!

C##&0J!EB;B![345fJ!C7&B!3i\B!!<'6>)&?"#>(&.#%"#/&1$@/3(&$3/#`'&$#'"(.="$%&;$(/@/#'&

& >N/%%/3(B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!)%%-GooMMMB$80%B$#1o80M,o,%:<.`'*8<,`

#8+*80!`S710&,`7&08%`78%*`,#$*7+`27,0108%H<M0++0&,o!!

C.0&,J!=B![345a\B!!Z&*08<,!M*%)!2080'*%,G!(+7:,*2+0!#-%*1*,1!78<!%)0!-&7$%*$0!#'!!

! %0727SS*8S!*8!F*<0#!S710,B!!K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/J!5`5iB!

@7T71:&7J!KB![345a\B!!;'%0&M#&<G!>7$*,1J!,0W*,1J!78<!S71*8SU,!$&:0+!#-%*1*,1B!!?8!

NB!C7+T#M,T*!78<!LB!>:,,M#&1![E<,B\J!K$@"#1&3/F3/(/#'$'".#J&G$=/4&1/#>/34&

$#>&(/E6$%"')&"#&9">/.&1$@/(![--B!3fc`3c4\B!!=+##1*8S%#8J!?@G!?8<*787!

^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B&

@7&<*J!=B![3454\B!!P)&%"?/&$(&$&#"12'&/%?&F3"/('J&-#&$#'23.F.%.1"=$%&$==.6#'&.?&A.3%>&.?&

& A$3=3$?'B!!;88!;&2#&J!C?G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!C*$)*S78!(&0,,B&

@0M%#8J!EB![566d\B!!C.!20,%!*8'#&178%U,!<&0,,B!!86%'63$%&-#'23.F.%.1)4&i4&5`3dB!

@0M178J!NB![3443\B!!L)0!1.%)!#'!%)0!0&S#<*$!F*<0#S710G!/#10!%)#:S)%,!#8!!

d55!

! -+7.0&`$)7&7$%0&!&0+7%*#8,)*-,!*8!F*<0#S710,B!!K$@/&<'6>"/(4&^[5\B!

! >0%&*0F0<!'&#1!)%%-GooMMMBS710,%:<*0,B#&So4543o80M178B!!

P+7)J!LB![345i\B!!->9/#'63/(&.#&'2/&(">/J&K6">/%"#/(&?.3&GHK&(">/R6/('(B!!>0%&*0F0<!!

! '&#1!)%%-GooMMMB&-S'78B$#1o'07%:&0,o;<F08%:&0,`#8`%)0`/*<0o!

({&0]`K7%#&&0J!€B!78<!P+*F7J!CB![345a\B!!_*<0#!S710,J!<.,%#-*7J!78<!80#+*20&7+*,1G!!

! L)0!$7,0!#'!M".(2.=7J&+#?"#"'/B!!K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/4&5`35B!

P&%80&J!/B=B![344d\B!!Q/N&S/3(/)&>3/$@"#1J&8$F"'$%4&=6%'63/4&$#>&'2/&=%$((&.?&`eiX&!

! ":&)71J!@B9BG!":T0!^(B!

P&%80&J!/B=B![344h\B!!-#'23.F.%.1)&$#>&(.="$%&'2/.3)J&86%'63/4&F.N/34&$#>&'2/&$='"#1&

& (6;D/='X!!":&)71J!@B9BG!":T0!^(B!

P:0++0%%0J!KB![344f\B!!L7T0!&0,-#8,*2*+*%.!'#&!.#:&,0+'G!S6>1/&S6>)!78<!%)0!80#+*20&7+!

! $*%*]08B!!?8!/B!C:&&7.!s!KB!P:0++0%%0![E<,B\J!G/$%"')&0,J&G/@$7"#1&'/%/9"(".#&

& =6%'63/![--B!3d5`3c4\B!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!@0M!D#&T!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

(*T0J!OBKB![56ha\B!!C$#16$1/&"#&3/%$'".#&'.&$&6#"?"/>&'2/.3)&.?&('36='63/&.?&26@$#&&

& ;/2$9".3![3

!0<B\B!!L)0!A7S:0J!@0%)0&+78<,G!C#:%#8B!

(&0,,J!;BKB![5665\B!!A.@/#&N$'=2"#1&'/%/9"(".#J&K/#>/34&=%$((4&$#>&1/#/3$'".#&"#&'2/&

& -@/3"=$#&'/%/9"(".#&/EF/3"/#=/B!!()*+7<0+-)*7J!(;G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!(088,.+F78*7!

! (&0,,B!

>7<M7.J!NB![56ii\B!!>0$0-%*#8!,%:<.G!E%)8#S&7-).!78<!%)0!-&#2+01!#'!<*,-0&,0<!

! 7:<*08$0,!78<!8#17<*$!,:2R0$%,B!!86%'63$%&<'6>"/(4&^[d\G!dc6`dahB!

>7<M7.J!NB!![5665\B!!G/$>"#1&'2/&G.@$#=/X!!9)7-0+!A*++J!@9G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!@#&%)!

! 97&#+*87!(&0,,B!

d53!

>#,0820&SJ!;B![345fJ!P$%B!i\B!!02/&=6%'63/&N$3(&$3/&;$=74&$#>&'2"(&'"@/4&/9/3).#/&=$#&

& N"#B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!)%%-GooMMMBM7,)*8S%#8-#,%B$#1o80M,o7$%`!

! '#:&oM-o345fo54o4io%)0`$:+%:&0`M7&,`7&0`27$T`78<`%)*,`%*10`0F0&.#80`!

! $78`M*8oB!

>:SS*0&#J!LBEB![3444\B!!^,0,!78<!S&7%*'*$7%*#8,!%)0#&.!*8!%)0!35

!$08%:&.B!!P$((&

& 8.@@6#"=$'".#&$#>&<.="/')4&\[5\J!d`daB!

/7+08J!OBJ!s!q*110&178J!EB![344f\B!!G6%/(&.?&F%$)J&K$@/&>/("1#&?6#>$@/#'$%(X&&

& 9712&*<S0J!C;G!C?L!(&0,,B&

/7%#![345i\B!!Z*87+!'78%7,.!e?_!&07$)0,!5f!1*++*#8!7<F08%:&0&,!M#&+<M*<0B!!&

& <"%"=.#/3$B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!)%%-,GooMMMB,*+*$#80&7B$#1o345io4iod5o'*87+`!

! '78%7,.`W*F`&07$)0,`5f`1*++*#8`7<F08%:&0&,`M#&+<M*<0oB!

/0<SM*$TJ!EBOB![344d\B!!0.6=2"#1&?//%"#1J&-??/='4&F/>$1.1)4&F/3?.3@$'"9"')X&&":&)71J!

! @9G!":T0!^(B!

/0+TJ!;BJ!s!Q:,T*8J!EB![345i\B!!L)0!1.%)!#'!%)0!+#80+.!S710&!-+7.*8S!*8!,#+*%:<0!*,!

! <07<B!!A$(2"#1'.#&H.('B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

)%%-,GooMMMBM7,)*8S%#8-#,%B$#1o,-#&%,o%)0`1.%)`#'`%)0`+#80+.`S710&`

-+7.*8S`*8`,#+*%:<0`*,`<07<o345io4do46o4c35h30i`5$24`550i`70c7`!

! 5h0h40fh4c'dH,%#&.B)%1+g:%1H%0&1•B7h7a6fd'36<'!

/08<0&J!OB![344d\B!!/0W!,0++,G!/0WJ!%7,%0J!78<!$+7,,!*8!$#110&$*7+!S7.!78<!+0,2*78!

! 10<*7B!!KC5J&-&S.63#$%&.?&C/(;"$#&$#>&K$)&<'6>"/(J!a[d\J!dd5`dhcB!

/08<0&J!OB![3453\B!!02/&@$7/.9/3J&G/$%"')&'/%/9"(".#&$#>&3/?%/E"9/&$6>"/#=/(B!!@0M!

! D#&TJ!@DG!@D^!(&0,,B!

d5d!

/0880%J!>BJ!s!9#22J!NB![56a3\B!!02/&2">>/#&"#D63"/(&.?&=%$((B!!9712&*<S0J!C;G!9712&*<S0!

! ^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B&&

/)7MJ!;B![3454\B!!I)7%!*,!F*<0#!S710!$:+%:&0gG!9:+%:&7+!,%:<*0,!78<!S710!,%:<*0,B!!

! K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/4&e[f\J!f4d`f3fB&!

/)7MJ!;B![3453\B!!"#!.#:!*<08%*'.!7,!7!S710&gG!Q08<0&J!&7$0J!,0W:7+*%.J!78<!S710&!

! *<08%*%.B!!Q/N&P/>"$&j&<.="/')4&bY[5\J!3i`ffB!

/)7MJ!;B![345f\B!!K$@"#1&$'&'2/&/>1/J&</E6$%"')&$#>&1/#>/3&$'&'2/&@$31"#(&.?&1$@/3&

& =6%'63/X!!C*8807-#+*,J!C@G!^8*F0&,*%.!#'!C*880,#%7!(&0,,B!

/#<0&178J!=B![345a\B!!@#!%*10!%#!<&071G!O*++*8S!%*10J!$7,:7+!S710,J!78<!S08<0&B!!?8!

NB!C7+T#M,T*!78<!LB!>:,,M#&1![E<,B\J!K$@"#1&3/F3/(/#'$'".#J&G$=/4&1/#>/34&

$#>&(/E6$%"')&"#&9">/.&1$@/(![--B!di`ch\B!!=+##1*8S%#8J!?@G!?8<*787!^8*F0&,*%.!

(&0,,B&

/V:7&0`E8*W![345i\B!!!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&)#10-7S0B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

)%%-,Goo'&00%&*7+B'*87+'78%7,.W*FB$#1o87og:%1H,#:&$0•S##S+0s:%1H10<*:1

•$-$:%1H$71-7*S8•0F0&S&008`'%s:%1H%0&1•2&78<`#8+*80s:%1H$#8%08%•4!

L7.+#&J!@B![3455\B!!(+7.!S#27++.J!7$%!+#$7++.G!L)0!,%78<7&<*]7%*#8!#'!-&#!A7+ #!d!

! S71*8SB!!+#'/3#$'".#$%&S.63#$%&.?&K/#>/34&<="/#=/4&$#>&0/=2#.%.1)4&\[5\B!

! >0%&*0F0<!'&#1&

& )%%-GooS08<0&78<,0%B#-08B7$B:To*8<0WB-)-oS08<0&78<,0%o7&%*$+0oF*0Mo5d4!

L7.+#&J!LBKB![344h\B!!H%$)&;/'N//#&N.3%>(J&IEF%.3"#1&.#%"#/&1$@/&=6%'63/![O*8<+0!

! F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!

L7.+#&J!LBKB![3453\B!!G$"("#1&'2/&('$7/(J&IW(F.3'(&$#>&'2/&F3.?/((".#$%":$'".#&.?&

& =.@F6'/3&1$@"#1![O*8<+0&F0&,*#8\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!;17]#8B$#1B!!&

d5f!

L7.+#&J!LBKB![345i\B!!A$'=2&@/&F%$)J&0N"'=2&$#>&'2/&3"(/&.?&1$@/&%"9/&('3/$@"#1B!!!

! (&*8$0%#8J!@NG!(&*8$0%#8!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

L0$)#-0<*7![8B<B\B!!K3"#>"#1B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

! )%%-,GooMMMB%0$)#-0<*7B$#1o<0'*8*%*#8o3ac3aoS&*8<*8S!

L0&&78#F7J!LB![3446\B!!;8#%)0&!+*'0G!L)0!87%:&0!#'!-#+*%*$7+!0$#8#1.!*8!Z#:$7:+%U,!!

! S0807+#S.!#'!2*#-#+*%*$,B!!02/.3)4&86%'63/&j&<.="/')4&^g[h\J!3df`3h3B!

L:&T+0J!/B![3455\B!!-%.#/&'.1/'2/3J&A2)&N/&/EF/='&@.3/&?3.@&'/=2#.%.1)&$#>&%/((&?3.@&

& /$=2&.'2/3X!!@0M!D#&TJ!@DG!=7,*$!=##T,B&

_##&)00,J!QB![3446\B!!L)0!$)7&7$%0&!#'!<*''0&08$0G!(&#$0<:&7+*%.J! &)0%#&*$J!78<!!

! &#+0-+7.*8S!S710,X&&K$@/&<'6>"/(4&a[3\B!!>0%&*0F0<!'&#1!

! )%%-GooS710,%:<*0,B#&So4643o7&%*$+0,oF##&)00,!

I*++*71,J!>BJ!s!P&&#1J!CB![56cf\B!!H3/?$=/&'.&?"%@B!!K#8<#8J!^OG!Z*+1!"&717B!!

I7&TJ!CB![344a\B!!K$@/3&'2/.3)B!!9712&*<S0J!C;G!A7&F7&<!^8*F0&,*%.!(&0,,B!

I*%T#M,T*J!EB![3453\B!!P8!%)0!<*S*%7+!-+7.*8S!'*0+<G!A#M!M0!<#!X,-#&%Y!M*%)!

! 80%M#&T0<!$#1-:%0&!S710,B!K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/4&c[c\J!df6`dafB!

D00J!@B![344h\B!!L)0!+72#:&!#'!':8G!A#M!F*<0#!S710,!2+:&!%)0!2#:8<7&*0,!20%M008!!

! M#&T!78<!-+7.B!!K$@/(&$#>&86%'63/4&b[5\J!hi`a5B!

Gameography!

B"$;%.&+++![3453\B!!I*8<#M,B!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!=+*]]7&<!E8%0&%7*8108%B!!=+*]]7&<!!

! E8%0&%7*8108%B!

02/&I%>/3&<=3.%%(&,J&<7)3"@![3455\B!!(+7.,%7%*#8!dB!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!=0%)0,<7!Q710!

! /%:<*#,B!!=0%)0,<7!/#'%M#&T,B!

d5c!

!"#$%&!$#'$()&*+,&[345d\B!!(+7.,%7%*#8!fB!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!/V:7&0!E8*WB!!/V:7&0!E8*WB!

G"?'&[3455\B!!I*8<#M,B!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!L&*#8!I#&+<,B!!L&*#8!I#&+<,B!

<'$3&A$3(J&02/&T%>&G/F6;%"=![3455\B!!I*8<#M,B!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!=*#M7&0B!!E+0$%&#8*$!!

! ;&%,B!

0.@.>$=2"&C"?/![345f\B!!@*8%08<#!d"/B!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!@*8%08<#!/("B!!@*8%08<#B!

A.3%>&.?&A$3=3$?'![344f\B!!I*8<#M,B!!"0F0+#-0<!2.!=+*]]7&<!E8%0&%7*8108%B!!

! =+*]]7&<!E8%0&%7*8108%B!