Series 3, Number 43 35 NATIONAL CENTER FOR HEALTH STATISTICS
questionnaires (Questions 16 in 2012, 15 in 2014, and 28
in version A and 29 in version B in 2016) were revised after
each wave. In 2012, each service item had four response
categories indicating that the service was “not provided,”
“provided only by residential care community/adult day
services center employees,” “provided only by others
through arrangement,” or “provided by both residential
care community/adult day services center employees and
others through arrangement.” In 2014, respondents were
asked to mark one or more of five categories indicating
that the service was provided by “paid residential care
community/adult day services center employees,”
“arranging for and paying outside vendors,” “arranging for
outside vendors paid by others,” “referral,” or “none of
these apply/not provided.” In 2016, the response options
were revised to four categories indicating that a residential
care community or adult day services center “provides
the service by paid residential care community/adult day
services center employees,” “arranges for the service
to be provided by outside services,” “refers residents/
participants or family to outside service providers,” or
“does not provide, arrange, or refer for this service.”
●
Formatting and wording for staffing questions in the adult
day services center (Questions 23 in 2012, 14 in 2014, and
31–33 in version A and 28–30 in version B in 2016) and
residential care community (Questions 26 in 2012, 17 in
2014, and 29–31 in version A and 30–32 in version B in
2016) questionnaires changed between the three waves.
In 2012, respondents had the option of providing either
the separate numbers of full-time and part-time staff or
the number of full-time equivalent (FTE) staff. In 2014,
the response categories only included number of full-time
staff and number of part-time staff (not FTEs). In both
2012 and 2014, the staffing questions were formatted as
a block to include both employees and contract staff. In
2016, respondents continued to provide the number of
full-time and part-time staff (not FTEs), but the questions
were formatted into two separate blocks for employees
and contract staff. Also in 2016, respondents could skip
the contract staff block if they answered “no” to a stem
question about having any contract or agency staff.
The differences in formatting in 2016 led to some
methodological changes to the staffing data edits in 2016
compared with previous waves. Details about differences
in how the staffing data were edited in 2014 and 2016 are
provided in the “Data Description and Usage (Readme)”
documents for the adult day services center survey (https://
www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nsltcp/NSLTCP_2016_ADSC_
Readme_RDC.pdf) and the residential care community survey
(https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nsltcp/NSLTCP_2016_
RCC_Readme_RDC.pdf).
●
The ADL question about walking or locomotion in the
adult day services center (Questions 32g in 2012, 19f in
2014, and 16f in 2016) and residential care community
(Questions 34g in 2012, 22f in 2014, and 17f in 2016)
questionnaires changed. The 2012 and 2016 waves
Nursing homes—Estimates from the merged 2016 CASPER
nursing home and MARET files were compared with
estimates on skilled nursing facilities from the MedPAC
report (58), the Nursing Home Data Compendium (61), and
the LTCFocus 2015 data (62). Provider-related estimates
using the 2016 merged nursing home file were comparable
with these other data sources.
Survey data
Estimates from the 2016 adult day services center and
residential care community components of NSLTCP were
compared with the 2010 MetLife National Study of Adult Day
Services (53) and findings from the 2010 National Survey of
Residential Care Facilities, respectively. Differences between
2010, 2012, 2014, and 2016 estimates for the number of
residential care communities, beds, and residents were
discussed previously in this appendix. The 2016 estimates
for select provider and user characteristics for both adult
day services centers and residential care communities were
found to be comparable with these other data sources.
Dierences between survey waves
The adult day and residential care components of NSLTCP
have evolved over the three waves of the study, in terms of
new questions, changes in question wording and response
categories, as well as data editing. A comparison of the
questions used in the three waves lists all the new items
added to NSLTCP (https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nsltcp/
NSLTCP_2012-2016_crosswalk.pdf). In addition to new
questions, the question wording and response categories for
several questions were revised in the 2016 wave, as listed
below. Some of these differences may have led to differences
in data editing methods, as well as differences in estimates
between the waves.
●
Response categories for the revenue source question in
the adult day services center questionnaires (Question
11 in 2012, Question 9 in 2014, and Question 10 in
2016) were revised after each wave. The 2012 and 2014
questions included six response categories: Medicaid,
Medicare, other government, out-of-pocket payment
by the participant family, private insurance, and other.
In 2014, a brief definition was added to the Medicaid
response category to specify that this category include
Medicaid managed care programs. In 2016, the number
of response categories increased to eight, with the
“other government” category broken into three separate
categories: Older Americans Act, Veterans Administration,
and other federal, state, or local government. Also, the
Medicaid category definition was revised to include
revenue from a Medicaid state plan, Medicaid waiver,
Medicaid managed care, or California regional center.
●
Response categories for questions on services provided in
the adult day services center questionnaires (Questions
19 in 2012, 12 in 2014, and 30 in version A and 27 in
version B in 2016) and the residential care community